Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / HatfieldsAndMcCoys

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GunsAkimbo: Sally McCoy, briefly.

to:

* GunsAkimbo: Sally McCoy, [=McCoy=], briefly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GunsAkimbo: Sally McCoy, briefly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The raid to seize Randall [=McCoy=] not only fails to capture Randall but results in [[spoiler: in the deaths of two of Randall's remaining children]]

to:

** The raid to seize Randall [=McCoy=] not only fails to capture Randall but results in [[spoiler: in the deaths of two of Randall's remaining children]]



* HeroicBastard: Contton Top.

to:

* HeroicBastard: Contton Cotton Top.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AssholeVictim: Practically no one in either family mourns the passing of Devil Anse's Uncle Jim Vance. Devil Anse is not surprised that his Uncle died in a violent shootout. Prior to Vance dying he was so out of control that Devil Anse figured that eventually he would've had to [[ShootTheDangerousMinion kill Vance himself]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbominationAccusationAttack: Harmon [=McCoy=] accuses Hatfield family member Jim Vance of "[[GoshDangItToHeck fornicating with his hound dog]]" (as Harmon's wife later described it) after Vance took exception to Harmon's Union uniform.
-->'''Vance:''' Didn't even pay for your drink. What kind of damn man are you? \\
'''Harmon:''' The kind who you want to come after, you'll find ready Jim Vance! Unlike your kinfolk here, I'm not afeared of no man, on account of he uses his dog for a whore!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Cottontop" Mounts is portrayed as being definitely guilty of the murder of Alifair McCoy, whereas in reality it's believed she was killed by either Johnse or Cap (witness accounts being rather confused on who shot who). His confession is thought to have been fabricated in the hope that he would get more lenient treatment if he pleaded guilty.

to:

** "Cottontop" Mounts is portrayed as being definitely guilty of the murder of Alifair McCoy, [=McCoy=], whereas in reality it's believed she was killed by either Johnse or Cap (witness accounts being rather confused on who shot who). His confession is thought to have been fabricated in the hope that he would get more lenient treatment if he pleaded guilty.

Added: 1685

Changed: 1335

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Though his hands certainly weren't clean in the historical feud, Perry Cline was not a swindling AmoralAttorney, he had known the Hatfields all of his life, and was even related to them by marriage. He and his brother had been orphaned in 1861 (when Perry was 12) and left in the care of their parents' slaves Mose and Charity. Devil Anse took advantage of the situation to seize the Cline family's land along Grapevine Creek via shady lawsuits, intimidation, and squatting. During the Civil War, the pro-Confederate Logan Wildcats—led by Devil Anse Hatfield and Jim Vance—attacked several local pro-Union families including the Clines, with several people being murdered. Among the victims were Perry's brother-in-law Asa Harmon [=McCoy=][[note]] Randall's brother, who was married to Perry's older sister[[/note]] and Mose, the former slave who was Perry's foster father. After the war, Cline was again cheated on a land deal with the Hatfields, this time by Jim Vance, while Devil Anse brought a new lawsuit aimed at taking the Cline homestead via a forged land survey. Perry got his law license specifically because the Hatfields kept trying to steal his property. Cline would later go on to establish a school for black children in Pikeville, and reportedly took care of his foster mother and former slave Charity in her old age.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
**
Though his hands certainly weren't clean in the historical feud, Perry Cline was not a swindling AmoralAttorney, he had known the Hatfields all of his life, and was even related to them by marriage. He and his brother had been orphaned in 1861 (when Perry was 12) and left in the care of their parents' slaves Mose and Charity. Devil Anse took advantage of the situation to seize the Cline family's land along Grapevine Creek via shady lawsuits, intimidation, and squatting. During the Civil War, the pro-Confederate Logan Wildcats—led by Devil Anse Hatfield and Jim Vance—attacked several local pro-Union families including the Clines, with several people being murdered. Among the victims were Perry's brother-in-law Asa Harmon [=McCoy=][[note]] Randall's brother, who was married to Perry's older sister[[/note]] and Mose, the former slave who was Perry's foster father. After the war, Cline was again cheated on a land deal with the Hatfields, this time by Jim Vance, while Devil Anse brought a new lawsuit aimed at taking the Cline homestead via a forged land survey. Perry got his law license specifically because the Hatfields kept trying to steal his property. Cline would later go on to establish a school for black children in Pikeville, and reportedly took care of his foster mother and former slave Charity in her old age.
** "Cottontop" Mounts is portrayed as being definitely guilty of the murder of Alifair McCoy, whereas in reality it's believed she was killed by either Johnse or Cap (witness accounts being rather confused on who shot who). His confession is thought to have been fabricated in the hope that he would get more lenient treatment if he pleaded guilty.

Added: 532

Changed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FamilialFoe: While Frank Phillips belongs to neither of the FeudingFamilies, he hates Hatfields more than some of the [=McCoy=]s (who become his employers) do. A grandnephew of Devil Anse shoots Frank in the leg while he is serving an eviction notice, and Frank kills that man and his brother in self-defense. Anse then tells Frank to get out of town or risk retaliation. He sticks around and is happy to take BountyHunter jobs to try to kill or arrest Anse’s sons, brothers, nephews, cousins, and uncle, succeeding in many cases.



* GoneHorriblyRight: Frank Philips is the right man to send after the Hatfields but his brutal methods escalate the conflict. Randall [=McCoy=] is appalled by what Philips is doing.

to:

* GoneHorriblyRight: Frank Philips is the right man to send after the Hatfields after they keep killing their earlier assailants but his brutal methods escalate the conflict. Randall [=McCoy=] is appalled by what Philips is doing.



* TheGunslinger: "Bad" Frank Philips

to:

* TheGunslinger: "Bad" Frank PhilipsPhilips is a quick-drawing BountyHunter turned semi-lawman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousSituation: whether [[spoiler: Nancy]]. was a mole from the start or just after her brother died.

to:

* AmbiguousSituation: whether Whether [[spoiler: Nancy]]. Nancy]] was a mole from the start or just after her brother died.

Changed: 22

Removed: 216

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Useful notes aren't tropes.


* UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar: The series starts at the end of the war. Much of the early tension between Hatfield and Mccoy is a result of Devil Anse Hatfield deserting when he realizes the Confederacy has lost.



* AntiHero/ AntiVillain: The Hatfields and Mccoys can be seen as either. Neither side is particularly more justified or vilified than the other, and both are sympathetic.

to:

* AntiHero/ AntiVillain: The Hatfields and Mccoys [=McCoys=] can be seen as either. Neither side is particularly more justified or vilified than the other, and both are sympathetic.



** Ellison Hatfield -who advises his brother that killing anyone will escalate the situation- and Jeff McCoy also stay out of the feud.

to:

** Ellison Hatfield -who advises his brother that killing anyone will escalate the situation- and Jeff McCoy [=McCoy=] also stay out of the feud.



** Devil Anse has it especially bad when he kills the three McCoy brothers when the law might have hanged at least two of them anyway, which would have kept the feud from escalating due to his vigilante justice.

to:

** Devil Anse has it especially bad when he kills the three McCoy [=McCoy=] brothers when the law might have hanged at least two of them anyway, which would have kept the feud from escalating due to his vigilante justice.



* SmallRoleBigImpact: Floyd Hatfield, Bill Wallace, Sam and Paris McCoy and the Levenger brothers: none appear that much but they all do a lot to escalate the feud, directly or indirectly.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: Floyd Hatfield, Bill Wallace, Sam and Paris McCoy [=McCoy=] and the Levenger brothers: none appear that much but they all do a lot to escalate the feud, directly or indirectly.



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Floyd Hatfield seems to disappear after the pig stealing trial, as does Sam McCoy after [[spoiler: Paris is shot in front of him when they try to kill Anse]].

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Floyd Hatfield seems to disappear after the pig stealing trial, as does Sam McCoy [=McCoy=] after [[spoiler: Paris is shot in front of him when they try to kill Anse]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OhCrap: [[spoiler:Ellison "Cottontop" Mounts]] is confident that his friends will free him before he is hung. He finally has this reaction as he is being led to the scaffold when he realises that nobody is coming to his rescue.

Added: 130

Changed: 126

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PetTheDog: a minor one but Perry does make a genuinely good, albeit brief, argument to spare Cottontop’s life while acting as his lawyer.

to:

* PetTheDog: a PetTheDog:
** A
minor one one, but Perry does make a genuinely good, albeit brief, argument to spare Cottontop’s life while acting as his lawyer.

Top