Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / AmericanHorrorStoryRoanoke

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FaceHeelTurn: In "Chapter 9", [[spoiler: a dying Lee makes the same deal with Scáthach that the Butcher once did, performing blood sacrifices in her name in exchange for her own life being saved.]]

to:

* FaceHeelTurn: In "Chapter 9", 9," [[spoiler: a dying Lee makes the same deal with Scáthach that the Butcher once did, performing blood sacrifices in her name in exchange for her own life being saved.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalAttractiveness: In-universe, ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' does this with all the ghosts. On the ShowWithinAShow, they look just like ordinary people. But as we see later on, they actually all look more like walking corpses.

Added: 342

Changed: 47

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OddballInTheSeries: By far the most unusual season because it's presented as a paranormal documentary in the first half then as a reality television show in the second, has no opening sequence just a title card and Evan Peters isn't introduced until episode 5. It's also currently the shortest season at ten episodes.

to:

* OddballInTheSeries: By far the most unusual season because it's presented as a paranormal documentary in the first half then as a reality television show in the second, has no opening sequence just a title card and series mainstay Evan Peters isn't introduced until episode 5. It's also currently the shortest season at ten episodes.



* StockUnsolvedMysteries: The season involves the disappearance of the Roanoke Colony. The rather mundane cause for the disappearance was that the colonists simply decided to move far inland to survive the winter. Of course, they were all sacrificed afterwards by their possessed leader and became ghosts, but that's not why they disappeared.



* WholePlotReference: This season's storyline of city folk running afoul of a community of backwards and particularly violent historical ghosts in the middle of nowhere is similar to the 1964 film ''Film/TwoThousandManiacs''.

to:

* WholePlotReference: This season's ''My Roanoke Nightmare'''s storyline of city folk running afoul of a community of backwards and particularly violent historical ghosts in the middle of nowhere is similar to the 1964 film ''Film/TwoThousandManiacs''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Though of course, this is only how the in-universe show portrayed it; we don't know what he might have actually faced back when he was alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OddballInTheSeries: By far the most unusual season because it's presented as a paranormal documentary in the first half then as a reality television show in the second, has no opening sequence just a title card and Evan Peters isn't introduced until episode 5.

to:

* OddballInTheSeries: By far the most unusual season because it's presented as a paranormal documentary in the first half then as a reality television show in the second, has no opening sequence just a title card and Evan Peters isn't introduced until episode 5. It's also currently the shortest season at ten episodes.

Added: 477

Removed: 478

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
indentation


* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: By some variation, the house is destroyed, therefore nobody will allow to go back to it and be harmed, plus Lee performing a HeroicSacrifice to be the carer for Priscilla and become the next Butcher as a RedemptionEqualsDeath for having nearly ruined Flora's life. On the downside, Shelby, Matt, and the entire "real life"/"reenactment" cast and crew of ''Roanoke'' are dead and the spirits of the Colony are still to return every Blood Moon]].



** BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: By some variation, the house is destroyed, therefore nobody will allow to go back to it and be harmed, plus Lee performing a HeroicSacrifice to be the carer for Priscilla and become the next Butcher as a RedemptionEqualsDeath for having nearly ruined Flora's life. On the downside, Shelby, Matt, and the entire "real life"/"reenactment" cast and crew of ''Roanoke'' are dead and the spirits of the Colony are still to return every Blood Moon]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: By some variation, the house is destroyed, therefore nobody will allow to go back to it and be harmed, plus Lee performing a HeroicSacrifice to be the carer for Priscilla and become the next Butcher as a RedemptionEqualsDeath for having nearly ruined Flora's life. On the downside, Shelby, Matt, and the entire "real life"/"reenactment" cast and crew of ''Roanoke'' are dead and the spirits of the Colony are still to return every Blood Moon]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, the more the series progressed, the more teasers became relevant. The odd swamp thing romance for example was based off of [[spoiler:Matt getting seduced by Scathach]]. The paranormal monster (the hair ghost in the tub) was a reference to the supernatural monsters, the creepy rednecks coming towards the house referenced both the Polks and the Roanoke colonists, probably more.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Or did they? [[spoiler: the text before Spirit Chasers states the episode was approved to air by "the survivors", though it's unclear who the survivors ARE, beyond Flora who was not actually on the show.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They do. They're the ones who keep shooting arrows at people and kill the [[spoiler:policemen and one of the Spirit Chasers]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Never getting to see your daughter because you lost custody, having to essentially kidnap her in order to spend time with her - and then ''losing her'' in the woods, only finding her hoodie.
* Lee's first daughter, Emily, was kidnapped from her car when she went into the store for five minutes. Judging by the fact that she communicates with Cricket, she was also murdered.

to:

* ** Never getting to see your daughter because you lost custody, having to essentially kidnap her in order to spend time with her - and then ''losing her'' in the woods, only finding her hoodie.
* ** Lee's first daughter, Emily, was kidnapped from her car when she went into the store for five minutes. Judging by the fact that she communicates with Cricket, she was also murdered.

Added: 375

Changed: 196

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultFear: Never getting to see your daughter because you lost custody, having to essentially kidnap her in order to spend time with her - and then ''losing her'' in the woods, only finding her hoodie.

to:

* AdultFear: AdultFear:
*
Never getting to see your daughter because you lost custody, having to essentially kidnap her in order to spend time with her - and then ''losing her'' in the woods, only finding her hoodie.hoodie.
* Lee's first daughter, Emily, was kidnapped from her car when she went into the store for five minutes. Judging by the fact that she communicates with Cricket, she was also murdered.



* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler:Every last one of the Lots.]]

to:

* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler:Every last one of the Lots.Polks.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Unlike previous seasons of ''AHS'', ''very'' little information about ''Roanoke'' was revealed prior to airing. A total of twenty-six promotional videos were released in the weeks leading up, but according to Murphy, only one of them is indicative of the real seasonal theme. The subtitle itself, ''Roanoke'', wasn't confirmed by FX until the day after its premiere.

to:

Unlike previous seasons of ''AHS'', ''very'' little information about ''Roanoke'' was revealed prior to airing. A total of twenty-six promotional videos were released in the weeks leading up, but according to Murphy, only one of them is was indicative of the real seasonal theme. The subtitle itself, ''Roanoke'', wasn't confirmed by FX until the day after its premiere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Some aspects of ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' are later revealed to be fabrications or inaccuracies. The rain of teeth never happened, though the TV show convinced the Polks that it was real. Also, the reenactment Mama Polk says that her kin made a deal with the Butcher over 200 years ago, but the real Mama Polk says it was exactly 150 years ago.
* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler:Cain, Jether, Mama, and Ishmael Polk.]]

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Some aspects of ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' are later revealed to be fabrications or inaccuracies. The rain of teeth never happened, though the TV show convinced the Polks that it was real. Also, the The reenactment Mama Polk says that her kin made a deal with the Butcher over 200 years ago, but the real Mama Polk says it was exactly 150 years ago.
ago. The three hunters who killed each other in 1952 never appear or are mentioned outside of the reenactments, so it's not clear whether they actually existed.
* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler:Cain, Jether, Mama, and Ishmael Polk.[[spoiler:Every last one of the Lots.]]



** Taissa Farmiga is confirmed to reappear, after not having been on the show since ''Coven''.

to:

** Taissa Farmiga is confirmed to reappear, reappears after not having been on the show since ''Coven''.



* DemotedToExtra: Creator/MattBomer and Music/LadyGaga are no longer in the main cast and just play recurring characters.

to:

* DemotedToExtra: Creator/MattBomer Denis O'Hare, Wes Bentley, Cheyenne Jackson, Lady Gaga, and Music/LadyGaga are no longer especially Evan Peters have much less screentime than in the last season. Frances Conroy, Finn Wittrock, and Taissa Farmiga go from main cast and just play or important recurring characters.roles to TheCameo. Matt Bomer is reduced to TheVoice, and is not even credited.



** ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' serves as the framing device for "Chapter 1"-"Chapter 5." It features talking head interviews and dramatized reenactments.
** "Chapter 6"-"Chapter 9" involve the show's sequel, ''Return to Roanoke: Three Days in Hell'', a hidden camera reality show with the interviewees and their reenactors living in the house.

to:

** ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' serves as the framing device for takes up "Chapter 1"-"Chapter 1" through "Chapter 5." It features talking head interviews and dramatized reenactments.
** "Chapter 6"-"Chapter 6" through "Chapter 9" involve the show's sequel, ''Return to Roanoke: Three Days in Hell'', a hidden camera reality show with the interviewees and their reenactors living in the house.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


of this season. While it concludes in Episode 5, Episodes 6 through 9 is about the making of the sequel series ''Return to Roanoke''. Episode 10 features a couple of other shows, including a paranormal investigation series called ''Spirit Chasers''.

Added: 1048

Changed: 304

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShowWithinAShow: ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' serves as the framing device of this season. While it concludes in Episode 5, Episodes 6 through 9 is about the making of the sequel series ''Return to Roanoke''. Episode 10 features a couple of other shows, including a paranormal investigation series called ''Spirit Chasers''.

to:

* ShowWithinAShow: ShowWithinAShow:
**
''My Roanoke Nightmare'' serves as the framing device for "Chapter 1"-"Chapter 5." It features talking head interviews and dramatized reenactments.
** "Chapter 6"-"Chapter 9" involve the show's sequel, ''Return to Roanoke: Three Days in Hell'', a hidden camera reality show with the interviewees and their reenactors living in the house.
** "Chapter 10" goes all out, featuring footage from a [=PaleyFest=] panel, episodes of ''Crack'd'' (a true crime documentary series) and ''Spirit Chasers'' (a paranormal investigation show), two [=YouTube=] videos, a [[Series/AmericanHorrorStoryAsylum Lana Winters]] special, and brief news broadcasts. The final scene of the episode, [[spoiler:where Lee talks to Flora then burns down the farmhouse]], is the only time this season actually averts this trope.
of this season. While it concludes in Episode 5, Episodes 6 through 9 is about the making of the sequel series ''Return to Roanoke''. Episode 10 features a couple of other shows, including a paranormal investigation series called ''Spirit Chasers''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The police car containing Flora drives off before the colonists arrive.


* BolivianArmyEnding: The season ends with [[spoiler:the colonists approaching the burning house while the police are still there likely with the intention of killing everyone including Flora (making Lee's decision to stay in the House so her daughter could leave a SenselessSacrifice)]].

to:

* BolivianArmyEnding: The season ends with [[spoiler:the colonists approaching the burning house while the police are still there likely with the intention of killing everyone including Flora (making Lee's decision to stay in the House so her daughter could leave a SenselessSacrifice)]].everyone]].

Added: 502

Changed: 131

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DecoyProtagonist: The story starts off being about Matt and Shelby, with Lee as a supporting character. [[spoiler: In the end, Lee is the FinalGirl, and the person with the most CharacterDevelopment throughout the series.]]



* ShowWithinAShow: ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' serves as the framing device of this season. While it concludes in Episode 5, Episode 6 onwards is about the making of the sequel series ''Return to Roanoke''.

to:

* ShowWithinAShow: ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' serves as the framing device of this season. While it concludes in Episode 5, Episode Episodes 6 onwards through 9 is about the making of the sequel series ''Return to Roanoke''.Roanoke''. Episode 10 features a couple of other shows, including a paranormal investigation series called ''Spirit Chasers''.


Added DiffLines:

* TooDumbToLive: Lee feels this way about the cast of ''Spirit Chasers'', for going to investigate the House (during the Blood Moon no less) even after everything else that's happened there. She outright tells them that they all deserve to die for it. [[spoiler: And they do.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BolivianArmyEnding: The season ends with [[spoiler:the colonists approaching the burning house while the police are still there likely with the intention of killing everyone including Flora (making Lee's decision to stay in the House so her daughter could leave a SenselessSacrifice)]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* FiveBadBand: The ghosts fit this surprisingly well.
** BigBad: Tomasyn White/The Butcher
** TheDragon: Ambrose White
** EvilGenius[=/=]TheDarkChick: Scáthach doubles as both
** TheBrute: Pig Man

Added: 356

Changed: 102

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie: [[spoiler:Lee's ex-husband Mason, Dr. Cunningham, and Cricket are killed before the events of the season. Sidney's PA Diana and Edward Mott's actor Rory become the first (named) victims in the present, followed by producer Sidney himself and the Butcher's actress Agnes getting the axe in "Chapter 7". In the same episode, the most shocking death at this point in the season is main character Matt (the main male character whose survival in the first half of the season was a ForegoneConclusion) getting abruptly and brutally offed. The following episode, Shelby (who was in the same boat as Matt) kills herself out of grief over Matt's death, and Dominic is killed by the Pig Man. By the end of episode 9, Lee is the only one still alive.]]

to:

* AnyoneCanDie: [[spoiler:Lee's ex-husband Mason, Dr. Cunningham, and Cricket are killed before the events of the season. Sidney's PA Diana and Edward Mott's actor Rory become the first (named) victims in the present, followed by producer Sidney himself and the Butcher's actress Agnes getting the axe in "Chapter 7". In the same episode, the most shocking death at this point in the season is main character Matt (the main male character whose survival in the first half of the season was a ForegoneConclusion) getting abruptly and brutally offed. The following episode, Shelby (who was in the same boat as Matt) kills herself out of grief over Matt's death, and Dominic is killed by the Pig Man. By the end of episode 9, Lee is the only one still alive.alive, and she dies at the end of the final episode (along with the whole paranormal investigative crew).]]



** EvilGenius/ TheDarkChick: Scáthach doubles as both

to:

** EvilGenius/ TheDarkChick: EvilGenius[=/=]TheDarkChick: Scáthach doubles as both


Added DiffLines:

** "Chapter 10" jumps between various formats, with one of them being footage from the paranormal investigative show "Spirit Chasers" who were exploring the house [[spoiler: and were all killed by the ghosts.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TrashTheSet: In the final episode, [[spoiler: Lee blows up the house, ensuring no one else will ever live there and fall victim to the ghosts.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** EvilGenius/TheDarkChick: Scáthach doubles as both

to:

** EvilGenius/TheDarkChick: EvilGenius/ TheDarkChick: Scáthach doubles as both
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FiveBadBand: The ghosts fit this surprisingly well.
**BigBad: Tomasyn White/The Butcher
**TheDragon: Ambrose White
**EvilGenius/TheDarkChick: Scáthach doubles as both
**TheBrute: Pig Man
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie: [[spoiler:Lee's ex-husband Mason, Dr. Cunningham, and Cricket are killed before the events of the season. Sidney's PA Diana and Edward Mott's actor Rory become the first (named) victims in the present, followed by producer Sidney himself and the Butcher's actress Agnes getting the axe in "Chapter 7". In the same episode, the most shocking death at this point in the season is main character Matt (the main male character whose survival in the first half of the season was a ForegoneConclusion) getting abruptly and brutally offed. The following episode, Shelby (who was in the same boat as Matt) kills herself out of grief over Matt's death, and Dominic is killed by the Pig Man.]]

to:

* AnyoneCanDie: [[spoiler:Lee's ex-husband Mason, Dr. Cunningham, and Cricket are killed before the events of the season. Sidney's PA Diana and Edward Mott's actor Rory become the first (named) victims in the present, followed by producer Sidney himself and the Butcher's actress Agnes getting the axe in "Chapter 7". In the same episode, the most shocking death at this point in the season is main character Matt (the main male character whose survival in the first half of the season was a ForegoneConclusion) getting abruptly and brutally offed. The following episode, Shelby (who was in the same boat as Matt) kills herself out of grief over Matt's death, and Dominic is killed by the Pig Man. By the end of episode 9, Lee is the only one still alive.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TitleOnlyOpening: In contrast with the previous seasons, there's no opening sequence only title cards ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' and ''Return to Roanoke''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler: The last of the Polks is killed by the Butcher, after his mother's death means her family's not protected anymore.]]

to:

* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler: The last of the Polks is killed by the Butcher, after his mother's death means her family's not protected anymore.[[spoiler:Cain, Jether, Mama, and Ishmael Polk.]]



* HillbillyHorrors: The Polk family are ''deeply'' inbred, live in squalor, exhibit racism, and flee from the sheriff's department despite not having committed any crimes (other than severe child neglect) as far as the audience knows. We later find out that they [[spoiler:offer up sacrifices to the Butcher in exchange for being left alone.]]

to:

* HillbillyHorrors: The Polk family are ''deeply'' inbred, live in squalor, exhibit racism, sell and flee from the sheriff's department despite not having committed any crimes (other than severe child neglect) as far as the audience knows. We later find out that they use drugs, engage in cannibalism, and [[spoiler:offer up sacrifices to the Butcher in exchange for being left alone.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler: The last of the Polks is killed by the Butcher, after his mother's death means her family's not protected anymore.]]


Added DiffLines:

* FaceHeelTurn: In "Chapter 9", [[spoiler: a dying Lee makes the same deal with Scáthach that the Butcher once did, performing blood sacrifices in her name in exchange for her own life being saved.]]


Added DiffLines:

** "Chapter 9" also features footage from some fan bloggers of ''My Roanoke Nightmare'' who were exploring the area around the house [[spoiler: and ended up killed by Lee and the ghosts.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TheManBehindTheMan: The Butcher is the most visible supernatural threat, but is actually in service to the witch Scáthach.


Added DiffLines:

* SoleSurvivor: [[spoiler: A bump in Episode 6 promises that there'll only be one from everyone involved in ''Return to Roanoke''. Episode 9 reveals it to be Lee.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShownTheirWork: Some viewers have commented on and even mocked the "quasi-Scottish" accents of the English Butcher and her clan, not realizing that this accent is, in fact, a fairly historically accurate English accent. Specifically, it's a reconstruction of a London-ish English accent from the 15th-16th century. You'll hear a similar accent in "Film/TheWitch" and by googling "Shakespeare: Original Pronunciation". Now whether this was intentional on the part of the show or just a coincidence brought on by poor imitations of modern accents is still up for debate.

to:

* ShownTheirWork: Some viewers have commented on and even mocked the "quasi-Scottish" accents of the English Butcher and her clan, not realizing that this accent is, in fact, a fairly historically accurate English accent. Specifically, it's a reconstruction of a London-ish English accent from the 15th-16th century. You'll hear a similar accent in "Film/TheWitch" ''Film/TheWitch'' and by googling "Shakespeare: Original Pronunciation". Now whether this was intentional on the part of the show or just a coincidence brought on by poor imitations of modern accents is still up for debate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The sixth season, presented as a faux paranormal documentary series "My Roanoke Nightmare" about an interracial couple (Shelby and Matt Miller) who buy a home out in the woods in Dare, North Carolina. Unfortunately, everything that can go wrong starts to go wrong for the couple: the house turns out to be a former nursing home owned by a pair of murderous sisters who butchered their clients. Matt's drug addicted ex-cop sister Lee kidnaps her kid, who promptly goes missing on the property, while the land is the same land as the legendary lost colony of Roanoke. And the colonists, led by the maniacal matriarch the Butcher, don't take kindly to tresspassers, unless it is to use them for their annual ritual blood sacrifice to the Harvest Moon.... Which is almost upon them.

to:

The sixth season, presented as a faux paranormal documentary series "My Roanoke Nightmare" about an interracial couple (Shelby and Matt Miller) who buy a home out in the woods in Dare, North Carolina. Unfortunately, everything that can go wrong starts to go wrong for the couple: the house turns out to be a former nursing home owned by a pair of murderous sisters who butchered their clients. Matt's drug addicted ex-cop sister Lee kidnaps her kid, who promptly goes missing on the property, while the land is the same land as the legendary lost colony of Roanoke. And the colonists, led by the maniacal matriarch the Butcher, don't take kindly to tresspassers, unless it is to use them for their annual ritual blood sacrifice to the Harvest Moon....Moon... Which is almost upon them.

Top