Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Roleplay / VictoriaFalls

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rejoice, for Quests now have a trope page of their own!


''[[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/victoria-falls-a-post-collapse-american-nation-quest-down-with-victoria.53790/ Victoria Falls: A Post-Collapse American Nation Quest]]'' is a [[PlayByPostGames play-by-post]] Quest roleplay created by [=PoptartProdigy=] on Website/SufficientVelocityDotCom, based on William S. Lind's ''Literature/{{Victoria}}''. It began on 11 March 2019.

to:

''[[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/victoria-falls-a-post-collapse-american-nation-quest-down-with-victoria.53790/ Victoria Falls: A Post-Collapse American Nation Quest]]'' is a [[PlayByPostGames play-by-post]] Quest roleplay ForumQuest created by [=PoptartProdigy=] on Website/SufficientVelocityDotCom, based on William S. Lind's ''Literature/{{Victoria}}''. It began on 11 March 2019.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* ReleasedToElsewhere: The official (i.e. the original novel's) description of Rumford's final fate was that he and and his men went on a "crusade" to retake Constantinople from a united Muslim caliphate, after which he eventually returned home and ultimately died peacefully of old age on his farm. In reality, [[spoiler:"Father" Dimitri decided that Rumford's megalomania and warmongering might have been useful when Victoria was still in its expansionist phase, but long-term Russian designs required Victoria to begin a political transition into being a more stable and passive PuppetState, [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness so keeping him around was just going to be more trouble than he was worth]]. In reality, the "crusade" was a ruse to lure Rumford and those of his men who were most ideologically devoted to his cause to an isolated peace, so a Spetsnaz team could ambush and liquidate them all in one fell swoop.]]

to:

* ReleasedToElsewhere: The official (i.e. the original novel's) description of Rumford's final fate was that he and and his men went on a "crusade" to retake Constantinople from a united Muslim caliphate, after which he eventually returned home and ultimately died peacefully of old age on his farm. In reality, [[spoiler:"Father" Dimitri decided that Rumford's megalomania and warmongering might have been useful when Victoria was still in its expansionist phase, but long-term Russian designs required Victoria to begin a political transition into being a more stable and passive PuppetState, [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness so keeping him around was just going to be more trouble than he was worth]]. In reality, the "crusade" was a ruse to lure Rumford and those of his men who were most ideologically devoted to his cause to an isolated peace, place, so a Spetsnaz team could ambush and liquidate them all in one fell swoop.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReleasedToElsewhere: The official (i.e. the original novel's) description of Rumford's final fate was that he and and his men went on a "crusade" to retake Constantinople from a united Muslim caliphate, after which he eventually returned home and ultimately died peacefully of old age on his farm. In reality, [[spoiler:"Father" Dimitri decided that Rumford's megalomania and warmongering might have been useful when Victoria was still in its expansionist phase, but long-term Russian designs required Victoria to begin a political transition into being a more stable and passive PuppetState, [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness so keeping him around was just going to be more trouble than he was worth]]. In reality, the crusade was a ruse to lure Rumford and those of his men who were most ideologically devoted to his cause to an isolated peace, so Spetsnaz team could ambush and liquidate them all in one fell swoop.]]

to:

* ReleasedToElsewhere: The official (i.e. the original novel's) description of Rumford's final fate was that he and and his men went on a "crusade" to retake Constantinople from a united Muslim caliphate, after which he eventually returned home and ultimately died peacefully of old age on his farm. In reality, [[spoiler:"Father" Dimitri decided that Rumford's megalomania and warmongering might have been useful when Victoria was still in its expansionist phase, but long-term Russian designs required Victoria to begin a political transition into being a more stable and passive PuppetState, [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness so keeping him around was just going to be more trouble than he was worth]]. In reality, the crusade "crusade" was a ruse to lure Rumford and those of his men who were most ideologically devoted to his cause to an isolated peace, so a Spetsnaz team could ambush and liquidate them all in one fell swoop.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** New York City never joined Victoria. "Father Dimitri" barely managed to dissuade Rumford and Kraft from launching a very costly invasion against the city.

to:

** New York City never joined Victoria. "Father Dimitri" barely managed to dissuade Rumford and Kraft from launching what would have, even by the best case scenarios, been a very ''very'' costly invasion against the city.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''[[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/victoria-falls-a-post-collapse-american-nation-quest-down-with-victoria.53790/ Victoria Falls: A Post-Collapse American Nation Quest]]'' is a [[PlayByPostGames play-by-post]] Quest roleplay created by [=PoptartProdigy=] on Sandbox/SufficientVelocityDotCom, based on William S. Lind's ''Literature/{{Victoria}}''. It began on 11 March 2019.

to:

''[[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/victoria-falls-a-post-collapse-american-nation-quest-down-with-victoria.53790/ Victoria Falls: A Post-Collapse American Nation Quest]]'' is a [[PlayByPostGames play-by-post]] Quest roleplay created by [=PoptartProdigy=] on Sandbox/SufficientVelocityDotCom, Website/SufficientVelocityDotCom, based on William S. Lind's ''Literature/{{Victoria}}''. It began on 11 March 2019.

Added: 920

Changed: 147

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BasedOnAGreatBigLie: The Quest's backstory depicts many of the events of the novel as being largely fictional, altered by the Victorian government to enhance its image as the heroic nation conquering the "Cultural Marxists" within the United States.
** New York City never joined Victoria. "Father Dimitri" barely managed to dissuade Rumford and Kraft from launching a potentially costly invasion against the city.

to:

* BasedOnAGreatBigLie: The Quest's backstory depicts many of the events of the original ''Victoria'' novel as being largely fictional, altered being the officially sanctioned and heavily propagandized history by the Victorian government about the SecondAmericanCivilWar, meant to enhance its image as the heroic nation conquering the "Cultural Marxists" within the United States.
** New York City never joined Victoria. "Father Dimitri" barely managed to dissuade Rumford and Kraft from launching a potentially very costly invasion against the city.



** The "privateers of the Aztec Empire" that the Northern Confederation fought in the Gulf of Mexico were actually just random pirates, and the campaign against wasn't quite as successful as the book depicted.

to:

** The "privateers of the Aztec Empire" that the Northern Confederation fought in the Gulf of Mexico were actually just random pirates, and the campaign against them wasn't quite as successful as the book depicted.



* FinalSolution: General Blackwell's AfterActionReport to Victoria's high command following the war with the Commonwealth outlines his belief that the Commonwealth ''cannot'' be subjugated the way other Victorian conquests have - the "Machine State" has no central leaders, with each citizen instead being a component in the Commonwealth. He instead recommends exterminating everyone above a certain age to permanently destroy the ideals of the Commonwealth.

to:

* FinalSolution: General Blackwell's AfterActionReport to Victoria's high command following the war with the Commonwealth outlines his belief that the Commonwealth ''cannot'' be subjugated the way other Victorian conquests have - -- the "Machine State" has no central leaders, with each citizen instead being a component in the Commonwealth. He instead recommends exterminating everyone above a certain age to permanently destroy the ideals of the Commonwealth.


Added DiffLines:

* ReleasedToElsewhere: The official (i.e. the original novel's) description of Rumford's final fate was that he and and his men went on a "crusade" to retake Constantinople from a united Muslim caliphate, after which he eventually returned home and ultimately died peacefully of old age on his farm. In reality, [[spoiler:"Father" Dimitri decided that Rumford's megalomania and warmongering might have been useful when Victoria was still in its expansionist phase, but long-term Russian designs required Victoria to begin a political transition into being a more stable and passive PuppetState, [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness so keeping him around was just going to be more trouble than he was worth]]. In reality, the crusade was a ruse to lure Rumford and those of his men who were most ideologically devoted to his cause to an isolated peace, so Spetsnaz team could ambush and liquidate them all in one fell swoop.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PragmaticVillainy: Tsar Alexander IV runs on this, which is why he is so dangerous. He advocates for ecology because he wants to rule a world that isn't dying, and [[spoiler:has Kraft and Rumford assassinated once they prove to be more trouble than worth.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unionist Party: Victorian Sympathisers that won't admit to being Victorian Sympathisers. [[spoiler:After a campaign lambasting their policies and leadership, they have ceased to be a force in politics, ''for now''.]]

to:

** Unionist Party: Victorian Sympathisers that won't admit to being Victorian Sympathisers. [[spoiler:After a campaign lambasting their policies and leadership, and their assassination attempts at the other politicians being foiled, they have ceased to be a force in politics, ''for now''.]]



* GreaterScopeVillain: Although the Victorians are the main enemy, the Tsar's Imperialist ambitions loom large over the setting.

to:

* GreaterScopeVillain: Although the Victorians are the main enemy, the Tsar's Imperialist ambitions loom large over the setting. The Tsar is more competent than the Victorians and made them his puppets.

Added: 555

Changed: 36

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LaResistance: One exists within Victoria itself and was a possible starting position at the beginning of the quest, though the pervasiveness of the CMC keeps them fragmented and hard to contact. One of their members is Maria Mercedes, the former First Lady.

to:

* LaResistance: One exists within Victoria itself and was a possible starting position at the beginning of the quest, though the pervasiveness of the CMC keeps them fragmented and hard to contact. One of their members is Maria Mercedes, the former First Lady. An Omake describes their struggles.


Added DiffLines:

** While the air force of Victoria is superior due to being their top priority, they are still beatable because they use horrible tactics like ''sticking in close formation'', which backfire the moment missiles that don't need direct hits are shot at their positions. Also, their neglect of navy allows the Commonwealth to dominate naval warfare, taking over lakes and ports, and drawing out the precious Victorian planes.


Added DiffLines:

* WrittenByTheWinners: John Rumford had altered history in his favor regarding the rise of Victoria, resulting in the original book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MissionCreep: The Commonwealth falls into this as they get high on victory fever and Victoria walks out on peace negotiations. To get them back to the table, Chicago launches Operation Foil, an invasion of Victorian territory to seize the Welland Canal. Facing minimal resistance, they then capture Buffalo and declare a plebiscite on whether the residents want to remain a part of Victoria. They are massively overextended, winter is coming, and public will at home is running out. [[spoiler:Luckily, the referendum is a resounding no and Victoria, humiliated, signs a punitive peace treaty without complaint. The Commonwealth is able to withdraw before the lake freezes over and evacuates any civilians who wanted to leave with them.]]

to:

* MissionCreep: The Commonwealth falls into this as they get high on victory fever and Victoria walks out on peace negotiations. To get them back to the table, Chicago launches Operation Foil, an invasion of Victorian territory to seize the Welland Canal. Facing minimal resistance, they then capture Buffalo and declare a plebiscite on whether but Blackwell won't take the residents want to remain a part of Victoria.bait. They are massively overextended, winter is coming, and public will at home is running out. [[spoiler:Luckily, [[spoiler:They succeed in drawing him out by declaring a plebiscite on whether the residents want to remain a part of Victoria. Luckily, the referendum is a resounding no votes to remain and Victoria, humiliated, signs a punitive peace treaty without complaint. The Commonwealth is able to withdraw before the lake freezes over and evacuates any civilians who wanted to leave with them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MissionCreep: The Commonwealth falls into this as they get high on victory fever and Victoria walks out on peace negotiations. To get them back to the table, Chicago launches Operation Foil, an invasion of Victorian territory to seize the Welland Canal. Facing minimal resistance, they then capture Buffalo and declare a plebiscite on whether the residents want independence from Victoria. They are massively overextended, winter is coming, and public will at home is running out. [[spoiler:Luckily, the referendum is a resounding no and Victoria, humiliated, signs a punitive peace treaty without complaint. The Commonwealth is able to withdraw before the lake freezes over and evacuates any civilians who wanted to leave with them.]]

to:

* MissionCreep: The Commonwealth falls into this as they get high on victory fever and Victoria walks out on peace negotiations. To get them back to the table, Chicago launches Operation Foil, an invasion of Victorian territory to seize the Welland Canal. Facing minimal resistance, they then capture Buffalo and declare a plebiscite on whether the residents want independence from to remain a part of Victoria. They are massively overextended, winter is coming, and public will at home is running out. [[spoiler:Luckily, the referendum is a resounding no and Victoria, humiliated, signs a punitive peace treaty without complaint. The Commonwealth is able to withdraw before the lake freezes over and evacuates any civilians who wanted to leave with them.]]

Added: 574

Changed: 280

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeThat: The backstory is a very blatant one against the former United States President Creator/DonaldTrump, as it is established that he was the one who had the United States default on its sovereign debt, and in a manner that indicates he did it mostly to spite his political opponents.

to:

* TakeThat: TakeThat:
**
The backstory is a very blatant one against the former United States President Creator/DonaldTrump, as it is established that he was the one who had the United States default on its sovereign debt, and in a manner that indicates he did it mostly to spite his political opponents.opponents.
** The war between the Commonwealth and Victoria, even if it was decided by rolls, is a protracted TakeThat against everything Victoria represents. Long story short, Victory is totally annihilated fighting a third generation army, and loses equipment it has no chance of replacing on its own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--'''Sara M. Johnson'''

to:

-->--'''Sara -->-- '''Sara M. Johnson'''

Added: 572

Changed: 172

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MakeItLookLikeAnAccident: [[spoiler:With Victoria properly consolidated, "Father" Dimitri concludes that William Kraft [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness is no longer of any use to Russia's efforts]] and has also proven far too unstable to be allowed to control Victoria without oversight. He arranges for Kraft to be poisoned, and Kraft's personal doctor, equipped to the finest standards of Retroculture, is [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] unable to find anything suspicious about his employer's death, and so it is deemed that Kraft died from natural causes in his sleep.]]



* RussiaTakesOverTheWorld: Russia is the world's premier superpower, ruling much of the world either directly through military conquest, or through puppets and proxies.

to:

* RussiaTakesOverTheWorld: Russia is the world's premier superpower, ruling much of the world either directly through military conquest, or through puppets and proxies. But their golden imperial age is beginning to signs of waning with a resurgent European Union and a reunited China slowly, but surely starting to challenge their hegemony.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LiteraryAgentHypothesis: {{Invoked}}. The premise of the story is that John Rumford was an UnreliableNarrator who flitered his account of the events surrounding the rise of Victoria through a combination of his own megalomania and SelfServingMemory and as well as a bunch of straight up lies and propaganda to make both himself and the state of Victoria look better.

to:

* LiteraryAgentHypothesis: {{Invoked}}. The premise of the story is that John Rumford was an UnreliableNarrator who flitered filtered his account of the events surrounding the rise of Victoria through a combination of his own megalomania and SelfServingMemory and as well as a bunch of straight up lies lies, propaganda, and propaganda WishFulfillment to make both himself and the state of Victoria look better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LiteraryAgentHypothesis: {{Invoked}}. The premise of the story is that John Rumford was an UnreliableNarrator who flitered his account of the events surrounding the rise of Victoria through a combination of his own megalomania and SelfServingMemory and as well as a bunch of straight up lies and propaganda to make both himself and the state of Victoria look better.

Added: 403

Changed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: The Victorian government's attempts to force their population into subsistence farming results in massive dieoffs from starvation, as most people are not equipped to grow their own food.

to:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome:
**
The Victorian government's attempts to force their population into subsistence farming results in massive dieoffs from starvation, as most people are not equipped to grow their own food.


Added DiffLines:

** It's made abundantly clear that a polity like Victoria would easily collapse on itself if its traits were applied in reality. The only reason Victoria is still functioning is because Russia keeps propping it up.

Added: 423

Changed: 240

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalVillainy: [[spoiler:"Father Dimitri", portrayed in Lind's novel as the "unofficial liaison" of Tsar Alexander IV, is now an Okhrana agent who was tasked with forcing the collapse of the United States by assisting Rumford and Kraft in the Civil War.]]

to:

* AdaptationalVillainy: AdaptationalVillainy:
**
[[spoiler:"Father Dimitri", portrayed in Lind's novel as the "unofficial liaison" of Tsar Alexander IV, is now an Okhrana agent who was tasked with forcing the collapse of the United States by assisting Rumford and Kraft in the Civil War.]]]]
** Victoria itself - since they are no longer the protagonist of the story, we get to see exactly how much of a hellhole it is and how horrible the people living in the nation are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadassBoast: "To the shores of Maine", which effectively declares that the Commonwealth ''will'' destroy Victoria, however long it takes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalWimp: Bictoria understandably nowhere near the InvincibleVillain [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality or, well, hero]] the novel portrays it as. Most of their victories are solely due to Russian backing and blatant opportunism.

to:

* AdaptationalWimp: Bictoria Victoria is understandably nowhere near the InvincibleVillain or, well, [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality or, well, hero]] the novel portrays it as. Most of their victories are solely due to Russian backing and blatant opportunism.



** Victoria cracking cold fusion and building a dam across the Bay of Fundy is merely a network of refurbished nuclear power plants and an absurdly ambitious tidal power station, respectively, both of which are run by Russian corporations.
** Rumford was sent abroad to retake Constantinople from a united Muslim caliphate, eventually dying of old age on campaign. However, the crusade was a ruse [[spoiler:by Tsar Alexander to get him and his inner circle in one place to wipe them out with a Spetsnaz team]].

to:

** Victoria cracking cold fusion and building a dam across the Bay of Fundy is merely a network of refurbished nuclear power plants and an absurdly ambitious tidal power station, station respectively, both of which are run by Russian corporations.
** Rumford was sent abroad to retake Constantinople from a united Muslim caliphate, eventually returning home and dying of old age on campaign. his farm. However, the crusade was a ruse [[spoiler:by Tsar Alexander to get him and his inner circle in one place to and wipe them out with a Spetsnaz team]].



* DividedStatesOfAmerica: Decades of brutalization and decay has made organization difficult beyond the city-state level, but some polities are powerful enough to control major parts of or multiple states. Major factions include:

to:

* DividedStatesOfAmerica: Decades of brutalization and decay has made organization difficult beyond the city-state level, but some polities are powerful enough to control major multiple former states and/or large parts of or multiple states.them. Major factions include:



* FinalSolution: In General Blackwell's AfterActionReport to Victoria's high command following the war with the Commonwealth, he outlines his belief that the Commonwealth ''cannot'' be subjugated the way other Victorian conquests have - the "Machine State" has no central leaders, with each citizen instead being a component in the Commonwealth. He instead recommends completely annihilating everyone above a certain age to permanently destroy the ideals of the Commonwealth.

to:

* FinalSolution: In General Blackwell's AfterActionReport to Victoria's high command following the war with the Commonwealth, he Commonwealth outlines his belief that the Commonwealth ''cannot'' be subjugated the way other Victorian conquests have - the "Machine State" has no central leaders, with each citizen instead being a component in the Commonwealth. He instead recommends completely annihilating exterminating everyone above a certain age to permanently destroy the ideals of the Commonwealth.



* KingInTheMountain: According to folklore, president Barack Obama was poisoned by Donald Trump and now sleeps in the depths of Lake Erie, to awake when the United States is restored.
* LaResistance: One exists within Victoria itself and was a possible starting position at the beginning of the quest, though the pervasiveness of the CMC keeps them fragmented and hard to contact. One of their members is Maria Mercedes, the former first lady.

to:

* KingInTheMountain: According to folklore, president Barack Obama was poisoned by Donald Trump and now sleeps in the depths of Lake Erie, to awake when the United States is restored.
* LaResistance: One exists within Victoria itself and was a possible starting position at the beginning of the quest, though the pervasiveness of the CMC keeps them fragmented and hard to contact. One of their members is Maria Mercedes, the former first lady.First Lady.



* PatronSaint: The Church of the Shepherd, a folk religion among the Victorian resistance, tells stories of the Shepherds: former presidents, martyrs, and resistance figures, that embody and teach different aspects of faith, life, and guerilla warfare techniques.

to:

* PatronSaint: The Church of the Shepherd, a folk religion among the Victorian resistance, tells stories of the Shepherds: former presidents, martyrs, and resistance figures, that embody figures embodying and teach teaching different aspects of faith, life, and guerilla warfare techniques.



* StepfordSmiler: The Blue Mountain Farmers were raised in an environment where showing negative emotion, especially around their "Papas," made them liable to be "[[DeadlyEuphemism weeded]]."

to:

* StepfordSmiler: The Blue Mountain Farmers were raised in an environment where showing negative emotion, especially around their "Papas," "Papas", made them liable to be "[[DeadlyEuphemism weeded]]."



* UnitedEurope: Downplayed. While the European Union forms credible opposition to Russia, Great Britain, France, Italy and Greece suffered civil wars and Poland bled itself white holding back the Russian advance. Only German and the Nordics are said to have been continuously stable.

to:

* UnitedEurope: Downplayed. While the European Union forms credible opposition to Russia, its member states - Great Britain, France, Italy and Greece - have all suffered civil wars and wars. Poland meanwhile bled itself white holding back the Russian advance. Only German Germany and the Nordics Nordic states are said to have been continuously stable.



* WeHardlyKnewYe: Illinois governor Audrey Jameson, one of the foregone options for leader during faction creation, is assassinated on the first turn. Her death forms the impetus of founding a counter-intelligence office and uncovers a [[spoiler:unionist conspiracy]].

to:

* WeHardlyKnewYe: Illinois governor Audrey Jameson, one of the foregone options for leader during faction creation, is assassinated on the first turn. Her death forms the impetus of founding a counter-intelligence office and uncovers a [[spoiler:unionist [[spoiler:Unionist Party conspiracy]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalWimp: Bictoria understandably nowhere near the InvincibleVillain [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality or, well, hero]] the novel portrays it as. Most of their victories are solely due to Russian backing and blatant opportunism.

Added: 672

Changed: 422

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Word About The World" updates speak of geopolitical developments and crises outside of the Commonwealth's sphere of influence, particularly in the Caribbean and East Asia.



* WeAREStrugglingTogether: Cascadia's Rainbow Uprising in 2062 fractured after the [[TokenEvilTeammate Victoria-aligned White Army]] indulges in killing Japanese civilians in Kitimat. Their Revivalist and Native allies turned on them to stop the atrocity, triggering other groups to settle their own scores.

to:

* UnitedEurope: Downplayed. While the European Union forms credible opposition to Russia, Great Britain, France, Italy and Greece suffered civil wars and Poland bled itself white holding back the Russian advance. Only German and the Nordics are said to have been continuously stable.
* WeAREStrugglingTogether: The Commonwealth has to deal with opposition parties in their own parliament as seriously as external enemies, lest the ruling coalition lose elections and get their policies rolled back.
**
Cascadia's Rainbow Uprising in 2062 fractured after the [[TokenEvilTeammate Victoria-aligned White Army]] indulges in killing Japanese civilians in Kitimat. Their Revivalist and Native allies turned on them to stop the atrocity, triggering other groups to settle their own scores.

Top