Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TheSandman2022S01E11ADreamOfAThousandCatsCalliope

Go To

OR

Added: 88

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


In a special animated episode, we follow a kitten journeying to pay audience to a Siamese cat's sermon about the feline's true place in the world, and the odyssey this cat took when she fell asleep and had a peculiar dream one night...

to:

In a special animated episode, AnimatedEpisode, we follow a kitten journeying to pay audience to a Siamese cat's sermon about the feline's true place in the world, and the odyssey this cat took when she fell asleep and had a peculiar dream one night...


Added DiffLines:

* AnimatedEpisode: This episode is animated as it follows a cat's journey in her dream.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MySkullRunnethOver: To punish Richard for hurting Calliope, Dream curses him to have ideas "in abundance". Sure enough he gets them... way too many for his body and brain to keep up with. He's reduced to desperately scribbling them on the walls, even in his own blood.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForcedCreativity: Morpheus' punishment for Richard is to overwhelm his mind with so many ideas that he's left a wreck, scribbling in blood on the walls in a desperate attempt to write them down.

Added: 491

Changed: 216

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshadowing}}: The Three-In-One tell Calliope that Dream has also been imprisoned. Two years later, she sees a newspaper article about people suffering from a sleep disorder waking up, and realizes that means Dream has been freed.

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: {{Foreshadowing}}:
** The first sentence spoken in the episode is Richard telling his audience: "You can't force a character to do something just because it's easier for you as a writer." If he had been willing to accept that the same applies to Muses, he could have avoided a lot of trouble.
**
The Three-In-One tell Calliope that Dream has also been imprisoned. Two years later, she sees a newspaper article about people suffering from a sleep disorder waking up, and realizes that means Dream has been freed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DefiantCaptive: Prophet and Calliope both disagree with their "owners" that they have any right to violate them the way they do.

to:

* DefiantCaptive: The Prophet and Calliope both disagree with their "owners" that they have any right to violate them the way they do.



* CosmicRetcon: This is what happened to the world ruled by cats: The humans' dreams didn't just change things so that humans now held power over cats. It changed things so that humans had ''always'' held power over cats.
* CreatorCameo: Neil Gaiman voices the Skull Bird that greets The Prophet when she enters the Dreaming. Doubles over to RemakeCameo since he uses the ''exact'' same vaguely more airy voice he uses when playing TheNarrator in the Audible Sandman (and also when Narrating his audio books) than he uses in interviews and presumably real life.

to:

* CosmicRetcon: This is what happened to the world ruled by cats: The the humans' dreams didn't just change things so that humans now held power over cats. It changed things so that humans had ''always'' held power over cats.
* CreatorCameo: Neil Gaiman voices the Skull Bird that greets The Prophet when she enters the Dreaming. Doubles over to RemakeCameo since he uses the ''exact'' same vaguely more airy voice he uses when playing TheNarrator in the Audible Sandman (and also when Narrating narrating his audio books) than he uses in interviews and presumably real life.



* DeathOfAChild: Or children in this case - The Prophet was spurred into turning against humans after her previous owner found out that she had given birth to a litter. Paul, the owner, was disappointed to find she had birthed half-breed kittens and, finding no use for them, tied the kittens in a bag and drowned them. This was what caused The Prophet to realize humans were the superior species, not cats.

to:

* DeathOfAChild: Or children in this case - The Prophet was spurred into turning against humans after her previous owner found out that she had given birth to a litter. Paul, the owner, was disappointed Disappointed to find she had birthed half-breed kittens and, and finding no use for them, he tied the kittens in a bag and drowned them. This was what caused The Prophet to realize humans were the superior species, not cats.



* GreyAndGrayMorality: The Prophet is correct that cats are often mistreated by humans but in the cat world it's not as if they were any kinder to humans. Further complicating this is that the humans in the kitten's household, contrasting the Prophet's former owners that only cared about her for her purebreed status, seem affectionate and caring towards her.

to:

* GreyAndGrayMorality: The Prophet is correct that cats are often mistreated by humans humans, but in the cat world it's not as if they were any kinder to humans. Further complicating this is that the humans in the kitten's household, contrasting the Prophet's former owners that only cared about her for her purebreed status, seem affectionate and caring towards her.



* HulkSpeak: Played with; the cats refer to doors and windows as "wall openings" and "clear openings"

to:

* HulkSpeak: Played with; the cats refer to doors and windows as "wall openings" and "clear openings"openings".



* ParentalAbandonment: Implied with Prophet, who says she can't remember her mother, and vows to do better with her own kittens. That said being as she is a purebreed cat [[HumansAreBastards it's likely she was taken from her mother as a kitten to be sold.]]

to:

* ParentalAbandonment: Implied with Prophet, who says she can't remember her mother, and vows to do better with her own kittens. That said being said, as she is a purebreed cat cat, [[HumansAreBastards it's likely she was taken from her mother as a kitten to be sold.]]



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman: Prophet is shocked that her humans would murder her babies, and though the woman expresses some empathy, the man acts callous about it.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman: The Prophet is shocked that her humans would murder her babies, and though the woman expresses some empathy, the man acts callous about it.



Richard Madoc is an author and professor who has one successful novel under his belt, but has struggled to write anything since. He seeks the advice of fellow writer Erasmus Fry, who while researching a book in Greece came across something that would help him write again. Well not something, but some''one''.

to:

Richard Madoc is an author and professor who has one successful novel under his belt, but has struggled to write anything since. He seeks the advice of fellow writer Erasmus Fry, who while researching a book in Greece came across something that would help him write again. Well Well, not something, but some''one''.



* AndIMustScream: Dream punishes Richard for his crimes against Calliope by overwhelming him with inspiration, the ideas for stories coming at him faster than he can get him out, leaving him to write them in paragraphs on the walls in his own blood. After he frees Calliope, the opposite occurs when his head is so empty of ideas, he can't even remember anyone's name.

to:

* AndIMustScream: Dream punishes Richard for his crimes against Calliope by overwhelming him with inspiration, the ideas for stories coming at him faster than he can get him them out, leaving him to write them in paragraphs on the walls in his own blood. After he frees Calliope, the opposite occurs when his head is so empty of ideas, he can't even remember anyone's name.



* BrokenPedestal: Averted; Nora, the medical student fan from the first scene, is the one who Richard sends to free Calliope. She's disturbed by his words, but thinks he's perhaps suffering a psychotic episode. Instead of learning the truth, however, when she goes to his house she finds nothing there, since all Richard had needed to do was say that he freed Calliope, which he did as he rambled. Although she is told to free a captive woman and finds a locked room containing just a book ''about'' a captive woman and thus she does seem to think he's delusional.

to:

* BrokenPedestal: Averted; Downplayed; Nora, the medical student fan from the first scene, is the one who Richard sends to free Calliope. She's disturbed by his words, but thinks he's perhaps suffering a psychotic episode. Instead of learning the truth, however, when she goes to his house she finds nothing there, since all Richard had needed to do was say that he freed Calliope, which he did as he rambled. Although she is Being told to free a captive woman and finds finding a locked room containing just a book ''about'' a captive woman and thus she does seem to think merely results in the understanding he's delusional.delusional instead of a captor and rapist.



* DeathByIrony: Erasmus Fry collected bezoars which are said to have healing properties and in particular are supposed to help those who have been poisoned...he later killed himself via poisoning.

to:

* DeathByIrony: Erasmus Fry collected bezoars which are said to have healing properties and in particular are supposed to help those who have been poisoned...he poisoned. He later killed himself via poisoning.poisoning (or by trying to prove the efficacy of one of his bezoars).



** Richard telling Fry he isn't sure he can go through with enslaving Calliope. This causes her face to subtlety flicker with intrigue, clearly wondering if maybe this new captor will be more open to reason then her previous one. The rest of the episode shows that no, he's just as bad and she'll have to contact Dream if she wants to get out.

to:

** Richard telling Fry he isn't sure he can go through with enslaving Calliope. This causes her face to subtlety subtly flicker with intrigue, clearly wondering if maybe this new captor will be more open to reason then her previous one. The rest of the episode shows that no, he's just as bad and she'll have to contact Dream if she wants to get out.



* JerkassGods: Zigzagged; when Calliope summons The Three-In-One and begs for their help, they tell her that because she was lawfully bound, they can't interfere. When she protests that there must be ''someone'' who can help her, The Crone mentions The Endless, but snarks that they're "having a difficult time of late", referencing both the Prodigal abandoning his responsibilities and Dream's imprisonment. However, they quickly move into straight-up {{Jerkass}} territory when The Crone recounts the history of Orpheus, reminding Calliope that her son was murdered. On the other hand they do drop some hints that later lead her to being able to call Dream for help.

to:

* JerkassGods: Zigzagged; when Calliope summons The Three-In-One and begs for their help, they tell her that because she was lawfully bound, they can't interfere. When she protests that there must be ''someone'' who can help her, The Crone mentions The Endless, but snarks that they're "having a difficult time of late", referencing both the Prodigal abandoning his responsibilities and Dream's imprisonment. However, they quickly move into straight-up {{Jerkass}} territory when The Crone recounts the history of Orpheus, reminding Calliope that her son was murdered. On the other hand hand, they do drop some hints that later lead her to being able to call Dream for help.



* SignificantWardrobeShift: Calliope spends most of the episode in a grey silk slip, with her hair hanging freely. After she's freed, she's wearing a ''peplos'' (an Ancient greek gown) and her hair is braided.

to:

* SignificantWardrobeShift: Calliope spends most of the episode in a grey silk slip, with her hair hanging freely. After she's freed, she's wearing a ''peplos'' (an Ancient ancient greek gown) and her hair is braided.



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman: Both Eramus Fry and Richard Madoc try to use this is a justification for their horrific treatment of Calliope. It just makes them even more loathsome and unsympathetic, that they don't even recognize Calliope as a person. Highlighted when Richard insists that Calliope was "made" to inspire humanity, completely ignoring her objection that she and her sisters were born like any other being, and the fact that forcefully stealing the inspiration from her renders calling it a "gift" moot. When Richard confronts Calliope after being threatened by Dream, he's floored when she tells him that Dream is her former husband and the father of her son, pathetically saying that he didn't know she had children.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman: Both Eramus Fry and Richard Madoc try to use this is as a justification for their horrific treatment of Calliope. It just makes them even more loathsome and unsympathetic, that they don't even recognize Calliope as a person. Highlighted when Richard insists that Calliope was "made" to inspire humanity, completely ignoring her objection that she and her sisters were born like any other being, and the fact that forcefully stealing the inspiration from her renders calling it a "gift" moot. When Richard confronts Calliope after being threatened by Dream, he's floored when she tells him that Dream is her former husband and the father of her son, pathetically saying that he didn't know she had children.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fingore}}: When Richard gets so many ideas that he has to write to them down, he resorts to cutting his hands and writing on the wall in his own blood.

to:

* {{Fingore}}: When Dream gives Richard gets so many more ideas that than he has can manage to write to them down, down on paper, he resorts to cutting his hands and writing on the wall in his own blood.

Added: 376

Changed: 417

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagicallyBindingContract: Fry's binding ritual forces Calliope to serve him (and later Richard), though she isn't actually compelled to share her gifts and only does that under duress. Still, it's referred to as a contract and can't be broken, even by Dream. He gets around this by giving Richard no choice but to break it himself, tormenting him with boundless inspiration.



** Richard has this reaction when he walks into his house and sees Dream sitting in his chair. Particularly when he realizes Dream isn't just a normal intruder.

to:

** Richard has this reaction when he walks into his house and sees Dream sitting in his chair. Particularly when he realizes He's more annoyed than scared, at first, assuming Dream isn't just a normal intruder.to be some random intruder, but he quickly changes his tune when Dream starts speaking and everything about him ''exudes'' barely-contained rage.



* TranquilFury: This episode shows, more than any of the rest of the season, why it is ''not'' a good idea to go after someone Dream cares about; he's clearly enraged by what's happened to Calliope, and devises a particularly nasty punishment for Richard because of it.

to:

* TranquilFury: This episode shows, more than any of the rest of the season, why it is ''not'' a good idea to go after someone Dream cares about; he's clearly enraged by what's happened to Calliope, and devises a particularly nasty punishment for Richard because of it. Even though he doesn't know who this man is, Richard is immediately cowed by Dream's demeanor.



* YouHaveNoIdeaWhoYoureDealingWith: Invoked by Richard when he finds Morpheus waiting in his house. Averted by Morpheus who knows exactly who and what Richard Madoc is and exactly how to deal with him.

to:

* YouHaveNoIdeaWhoYoureDealingWith: Invoked by Richard says "Do you have any idea who I am?" when he finds Morpheus waiting in his house. Averted by Morpheus who responds that he knows exactly who and what Richard Madoc is and exactly how to deal with him.him, which puts Richard in his place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Putting a link of the example in the example.


-->'''Dream:''' [[ArmorPiercingResponse ...Because he]] ''[[ArmorPiercingResponse hurt you.]]''

to:

-->'''Dream:''' [[ArmorPiercingResponse ...-->'''Dream:''' ...Because he]] ''[[ArmorPiercingResponse hurt he ''hurt you.]]''''

Added: 241

Removed: 247

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
You Already Changed The Past is a completely different trope, in which it's impossible to alter the past because the past already includes all attempts to alter it


* {{Retconjuration}}: How dream-changing reality works, according to its king. Without really involving time-travel, a thousand or so individuals dreaming the same thing at the same time can change the past so that the dream was always true.



* YouAlreadyChangedThePast: How dream-changing reality works, according to its king. Without really involving time-travel, a thousand or so individuals dreaming the same thing at the same time can change the past so that the dream was always true.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DefiantCaptive: Prophet and Calliope both disagree with their "owners" that they have any right to violate them the way they do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HumansAreNotTheDominantSpecies: Both stories are about the subject of humans dominating another species that they may have no business dominating: cats and gods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BlueAndOrangeMorality: While saddened by the cold-hearted murder of her kittens, Prophet doesn't so much take issue with the fact that at least one of her humans is evil, as with the fact that humans in fact have the power to murder kittens by virtue of being the dominant species. She seeks not to punish them, but to make it so cats are the dominant species.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PragmaticAdaptation: Several scenes that were in other locations in the comic, including the book launch and the interview where Madoc learns about Fry's death, take place in Madoc's house to reduce the number of locations required.

to:

* PragmaticAdaptation: Several scenes In the comic, the progress of Richard's career after he writes his second novel is shown in a montage of many brief scenes, most only a panel or two long. In the TV version, these are condensed into fewer, longer scenes, and several events that were in other locations in the comic, including the book launch and the interview where Madoc learns about Fry's death, take place in Madoc's house to reduce the number of locations required.required. Madoc is also in the same house all the way through, unlike in the comic where he moves to a larger and more impressive house after his career takes off.

Added: 943

Changed: 23

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalPersonalityChange: Richard in the TV version is in a sense 'nicer' than his comic book counterpart, expressing hesitation about enslaving Calliope, making several fumbling attempts to coax her to help him before he becomes desperate enough to resort to force, and afterwards repeatedly trying to persuade her that there are upsides to her situation. In contrast, the comic book version of Richard goes for the forceful option immediately and is brutally, even sometimes cheerfully, straightforward in his interactions with her. This doesn't alter the fact that TV Richard's actions are just as cruel in effect, and arguably in places crueller, since he's not only keeping Calliope captive and exploiting her but also trying to make her complicit in his attempts to reassure himself that he's not really that kind of person (unlike Comic Richard, who's accepted the choices he's made and doesn't care what Calliope thinks of him).



** The character who delivers Madoc the bezoar in the beginning of the story, and helps him when he's gone mad towards the end, is a male doctor in the comic book. Here, it's a female medical student who does those things.

to:

** The character who delivers Madoc the bezoar in the beginning of the story, and helps him when he's gone mad towards the end, is a male doctor named Felix in the comic book. Here, it's a female medical student named Nora who does those things.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KubrickStare: During Dream's first conversation with Calliope, he lowers his gaze while asking her to let him help, but when she asks what he plans to do to Richard, he looks up, instantly converting his contrite expression into a menacing Kubrick stare.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BewareTheNiceOnes: The Kitten's owners coo over how cute their Kitten is when it's dreaming, not knowing it's dreaming of hunting and eating humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObliviousGuiltSlinging: Richard looks bothered after being told that Erasmus committed suicide after being unable to get his favorite book republished. After handing over Calliope, Erasmus had asked Richard to arrange this as a favor should he be successful. It's clear that Richard had forgotten all about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman: Both Eramus Fry and Richard Madoc try to use this is a justification for their horrific treatment of Calliope. It just makes them even more loathsome and unsympathetic, that they don't even recognize Calliope as a person. Highlighted when Richard insists that Calliope was "made" to inspire humanity, completely ignoring her objection that she and her sisters were born like any other being, and the fact that forcefully stealing the inspiration from her renders calling it a "gift" moot.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman: Both Eramus Fry and Richard Madoc try to use this is a justification for their horrific treatment of Calliope. It just makes them even more loathsome and unsympathetic, that they don't even recognize Calliope as a person. Highlighted when Richard insists that Calliope was "made" to inspire humanity, completely ignoring her objection that she and her sisters were born like any other being, and the fact that forcefully stealing the inspiration from her renders calling it a "gift" moot. When Richard confronts Calliope after being threatened by Dream, he's floored when she tells him that Dream is her former husband and the father of her son, pathetically saying that he didn't know she had children.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per TRS, this is now Trivia and renamed to Production Lead Time


* AnimationLeadTime: All those {{Remake Cameo}}es listed below? Probably recorded at the same time as Audible's Sandman Volume 2 was made. Note that Creator/ArthurDarvill, the Star of the Live Action Segment, played William Shakespeare during Volume 1 years earlier so he wasn’t busy like the rest of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KickTheDog: The Prophet's male owner drowned her kittens because they were half-breeds with a random stray cat, which is what makes her want to restore a world where cats are on top.

to:

* KickTheDog: The Prophet's male owner drowned her kittens because they were half-breeds with a random stray cat, as opposed to dropping them off at a shelter, which is what makes her want to restore a world where cats are on top.

Top