Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekVoyagerS3E24WorstCaseScenario

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SaveGameLimits: In order for Paris to play from the start, Torres has to "reset" the ''Insurrection Alpha'' program. Apparently the holoprograms in the 24th century don't have a way for multiple players of scenario to save different states[[note]]although it is possible this is because the program is unfinished and not open to editing by normal users.[[/note]].

to:

* SaveGameLimits: In order for Paris to play from the start, Torres has to "reset" the ''Insurrection Alpha'' program. Apparently the holoprograms in the 24th century don't have a way for multiple players of scenario to save different states[[note]]although it is possible this is Possibly because the program is unfinished and not open unfinished, Torres has to editing by normal users.[[/note]].reset it so that Paris can play from the start.

Added: 345

Changed: 341

Removed: 562

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbortedArc: This episode lampshades how the cultural conflict between the Maquis and Starfleet personnel that was established in the show's first few episodes was quickly abandoned and has been virtually ignored for the better part of three seasons. The premise of the episode allows the writers to temporarily revive it in a holodeck setting.



* ReasonableAuthorityFigure:
** When everyone thinks the program is a mere holo-novel, Janeway and Chakotay are good sports about it. They want to know who wrote it out of mere curiosity. Janeway also sees the value in the crew creating their own fiction as a stress reliever, especially since they're cut off from all the newest forms of media back in the Alpha Quadrant.
** In the holo-novel, Chakotay is portrayed as fairly reasonable--giving junior officers the chance to join his team. At one point, he even offers holo-Janeway food and supplies rather than destroy her shuttle on sight.

to:

* ReasonableAuthorityFigure:
**
ReasonableAuthorityFigure: When everyone thinks the program is a mere holo-novel, Janeway and Chakotay are good sports about it. They want to know who wrote it out of mere curiosity. Janeway also sees the value in the crew creating their own fiction as a stress reliever, especially since they're cut off from all the newest forms of media back in the Alpha Quadrant.
** In the holo-novel, Chakotay is portrayed as fairly reasonable--giving junior officers the chance to join his team. At one point, he even offers holo-Janeway food and supplies rather than destroy her shuttle on sight.
Quadrant.

Added: 758

Changed: 156

Removed: 235

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiVillain: Holo-Chakotay. Yes, he's the bad guy for committing mutiny, but he's committed to executing a non-violent mutiny, is willing to recruit anyone who is willing to join him, and offers extra provisions to those who will get left off the ship. His mission statement for returning home is also pretty reasonable: take every opportunity to get home faster without worrying about scientific discovery along the way.



* EvenEvilHasStandards: Holo-Chakotay. Yes, he's the bad guy for committing mutiny, but he doesn't kill anyone unless it's necessary. He even tells Holo-Janeway and Holo-Paris that they can keep their shuttle and some extra provisions.



* LeaningOnTheFourthWall: Tuvoks reasons for abandoning the simulation boil down to "the show's writers [[AbortedArc dropped the Maquis plot]] without really doing anything with it".

to:

* LeaningOnTheFourthWall: LeaningOnTheFourthWall:
**
Tuvoks reasons for abandoning the simulation boil down to "the show's writers [[AbortedArc dropped the Maquis plot]] without really doing anything with it".it".
** Chakotay says that the mutineers' new mission will not waste time by investigating every random anomaly the ship passes, reflecting a common criticism of the show's concept.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not really what this trope is about


* AbortedArc (InUniverse): Tuvok wrote the program under concerns of the Starfleet/Maquis crew conflict and in the case of a possible mutiny. Over time he found the blended crew working better than expected [[WeAreStrugglingTogether due to circumstance]] and [[FireForgedFriends shared experience]] and left the program unfinished. This carries an enormous amount of RealitySubtext, as the Voyager premise was designed to foster contention between the crew members, only for the network and upper management to shoot down story suggestions based on that... except this one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeelFaceRevolvingDoor: Invoked by Tom as a way to test the progam's limits. He begins the program assuring Holo-Chakotay that he'll side with the mutineers, but once it actually begins, tries to save Tuvok. Then when Holo-Chakotay makes his offer to the captured crew, Tom steps forward to join him. He later notes to B'Elanna that this sequence of events made Holo-Chakotay so suspicious of him that he would only allow Tom to do minor maintenence work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** B'Elanna rejects the idea that she might have a steamy romance with Tom as completely unrealistic.

to:

** B'Elanna rejects the idea that she might have a steamy romance with Tom as completely unrealistic. They'll officially begin a relationship just four episodes later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Several clues cue hardcore fans that the teaser is taking place earlier in Voyager's continuity. In the opening scene, B'Elanna is wearing a Starfleet ensign's pip, and Chakotay is speaking openly of how "the Maquis" aren't getting along with Tuvok and Janeway, along with stating they're still seventy years from the Alpha Quadrant. Janeway's hairstyle is different, Jonas can be heard on the comm even though he was killed back in Season 2 (albeit clearly not being voiced by Raphael Sbarge), and Kes is back to her old hairstyle. The wham moment is Seska's appearance after her death in "Basics, Part II".

to:

** Several clues cue hardcore fans that the teaser is taking place earlier in Voyager's continuity. In the opening scene, B'Elanna is wearing a Starfleet ensign's pip, and Chakotay is speaking openly of how "the Maquis" aren't getting along with Tuvok and Janeway, along with stating they're still seventy years from the Alpha Quadrant. Janeway's hairstyle is different, Quadrant (he also never once calls her by name, only 'Ensign'). Janeway and Kes are wearing their original hairstyles, and Jonas can be heard is called on the comm even though he was killed back in Season 2 (albeit clearly not being voiced by Raphael Sbarge), and Kes is back to her old hairstyle. Sbarge). The wham moment is Seska's appearance after her death in "Basics, Part II".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Several clues cue hardcore fans that the teaser is taking place earlier in Voyager's continuity. Janeway's hairstyle is different, Jonas can be heard on the comm even though he was killed back in Season 2 (albeit clearly not being voiced by Raphael Sbarge), Kes is back to her old hairstyle, and B'Elanna is wearing a Starfleet ensign's pip. The wham moment is Seska's appearance after her death in "Basics, Part II".

to:

** Several clues cue hardcore fans that the teaser is taking place earlier in Voyager's continuity. In the opening scene, B'Elanna is wearing a Starfleet ensign's pip, and Chakotay is speaking openly of how "the Maquis" aren't getting along with Tuvok and Janeway, along with stating they're still seventy years from the Alpha Quadrant. Janeway's hairstyle is different, Jonas can be heard on the comm even though he was killed back in Season 2 (albeit clearly not being voiced by Raphael Sbarge), and Kes is back to her old hairstyle, and B'Elanna is wearing a Starfleet ensign's pip. hairstyle. The wham moment is Seska's appearance after her death in "Basics, Part II".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There are a few hints about the episode opening with a FakeActionPrologue (e.g. Torres being referred to as an ensign and never by name, Jonas still being alive, Tuvok saying Chakotay is still new to being first officer), Janeway's hair in the power bun that preceded "Future's End", etc.

to:

** There are a few hints about the episode opening with a FakeActionPrologue (e.g. Torres being referred to as an ensign and never by name, Jonas still being alive, Tuvok saying Chakotay is still new to being first officer), officer, Janeway's hair in the power bun that preceded "Future's End", etc.).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Several clues cue hardcore fans that the teaser is taking place earlier in Voyager's continuity. Janeway's hairstyle is different, Jonas can be heard on the comm even though he was killed back in Season 2 (albeit clearly not being voiced by Raphael Sbarge), and B'Elanna is wearing a Starfleet ensign's pip. The wham moment is Seska's appearance after her death in "Basics, Part II".

to:

** Several clues cue hardcore fans that the teaser is taking place earlier in Voyager's continuity. Janeway's hairstyle is different, Jonas can be heard on the comm even though he was killed back in Season 2 (albeit clearly not being voiced by Raphael Sbarge), Kes is back to her old hairstyle, and B'Elanna is wearing a Starfleet ensign's pip. The wham moment is Seska's appearance after her death in "Basics, Part II".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbortedArc: Tuvok wrote the program under concerns of the Starfleet/Maquis crew conflict and in the case of a possible mutiny. Over time he found the blended crew working better than expected [[WeAreStrugglingTogether due to circumstance]] and [[FireForgedFriends shared experience]] and left the program unfinished. This carries an enormous amount of RealitySubtext, as the Voyager premise was designed to foster contention between the crew members, only for the network and upper management to shoot down story suggestions based on that... except this one.

to:

* AbortedArc: AbortedArc (InUniverse): Tuvok wrote the program under concerns of the Starfleet/Maquis crew conflict and in the case of a possible mutiny. Over time he found the blended crew working better than expected [[WeAreStrugglingTogether due to circumstance]] and [[FireForgedFriends shared experience]] and left the program unfinished. This carries an enormous amount of RealitySubtext, as the Voyager premise was designed to foster contention between the crew members, only for the network and upper management to shoot down story suggestions based on that... except this one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


B'elanna Torres discovers a holodeck program on ''Voyager'' simulating a Maquis rebellion where Commander Chakotay calls for a mutiny after Janeway leaves the ship on an away mission. This program soon becomes popular as the crew try it out for themselves, either taking the side of the mutineers or Janeway loyalists trying to retake ''Voyager'' from the Maquis.

to:

B'elanna B'Elanna Torres discovers a holodeck program on ''Voyager'' simulating a Maquis rebellion where Commander Chakotay calls for a mutiny after Janeway leaves the ship on an away mission. This program soon becomes popular as the crew try it out for themselves, either taking the side of the mutineers or Janeway loyalists trying to retake ''Voyager'' from the Maquis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadlyDoctor: Holo-EMH "treats" Tom's phaser burn by injecting him with nitric acid, NoSell{{s}} his attempt to attack him when he's choking Tuvok and then tosses both of them out of the Sick Bay with one arm.

to:

* DeadlyDoctor: Holo-EMH "treats" Tom's phaser burn by injecting him with nitric acid, NoSell{{s}} {{No Sell}}s his attempt to attack him when he's choking Tuvok and then tosses both of them out of the Sick Bay with one arm.

Added: 560

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!This episode provides examples of

to:

!!This episode provides examples of
of:

* AbortedArc: Tuvok wrote the program under concerns of the Starfleet/Maquis crew conflict and in the case of a possible mutiny. Over time he found the blended crew working better than expected [[WeAreStrugglingTogether due to circumstance]] and [[FireForgedFriends shared experience]] and left the program unfinished. This carries an enormous amount of RealitySubtext, as the Voyager premise was designed to foster contention between the crew members, only for the network and upper management to shoot down story suggestions based on that... except this one.

Added: 485

Changed: 353

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NewRulesAsThePlotDemands: The original holonovel was built as a functional training tool and wouldn't allow the player to cheat through modifying holodeck settings, but Seska writes a new scenario where it actively manipulates the rules to ensure their eventual death. Tom and Tuvok are [[TheComputerIsACheatingBastard stuck in a situation actively working against them]], and their only hope is Janeway as a DeusExMachina rewriting the program in real time to give them a fair shot.



* OffTheRails

to:

* OffTheRailsOffTheRails: The primary development in the second half of the episode, where any semblance of a story or training purposes are thrown out the window in an EverythingTryingToKillYou mode.



* SelfFulfillingProphecy: Invoked; when the Maquis and Starfleet crewmembers end up [[EnemyMine working well together]], Tuvok realizes his program could itself [[MuseAbuse create tensions between the two groups]] and deletes it. Or so he thinks. Tuvok's expectations are subverted when they find it and enjoy it.

to:

* SelfFulfillingProphecy: Invoked; when the Maquis and Starfleet crewmembers end up [[EnemyMine [[FireForgedFriends working well together]], Tuvok realizes his program could itself [[MuseAbuse create tensions between the two groups]] and deletes it. Or so he thinks. Tuvok's expectations are subverted when [[ActuallyPrettyFunny they find it and enjoy it.it]].



* TechnicianVsPerformer: Ultimately why Tuvok and Paris are urged to work on the program together. Tuvok's precision and faithfulness to accuracy has resulted in a realistic scenario without strawmen or melodramatic pomp... but it's also bogged down in strict adherence to reality, necessitating Tom's more entertainment-focused moderation. (In theory, since we never get to see the outcome of their effort.)

to:

* TechnicianVsPerformer: Ultimately why Tuvok and Paris are urged to work on the program together. Tuvok's precision and faithfulness to accuracy has resulted in a realistic scenario without strawmen or melodramatic pomp... but it's also bogged down in strict adherence to reality, necessitating Tom's reality and can't really deviate with surprise developments. This necessitates Tom creating a more entertainment-focused moderation.moderation, as there wasn't any option for a true FaceHeelTurn. (In theory, since we never get to see the outcome of their effort.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNotSecret: Word quickly spreads of ''Insurrection Alpha'' despite (or because) of its subversive nature. Which makes it puzzling that no-one knows who wrote it.

to:

* TheNotSecret: Word quickly spreads of ''Insurrection Alpha'' despite (or because) of its subversive nature. Which makes it puzzling that no-one no one knows who wrote it.



* SmoochOfVictory: Holo-Seska and Holo-Chakotay snog after killing Holo-Janeway. No-one is impressed.

to:

* SmoochOfVictory: Holo-Seska and Holo-Chakotay snog after killing Holo-Janeway. No-one No one is impressed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NewEraSpeech: Holo-Chakotay gives one after seizing Voyager.

to:

* NewEraSpeech: Holo-Chakotay gives one after seizing Voyager.''Voyager''.

Top