History Recap / PennyAndAggieDinnerForSix

* FoeYay: In-universe example, with Sara shipping Penny and Aggie, this time even convincing Katy-Ann of her theory.

--> "This has to be a case of mistaken identity..."\\
'''-- Penny'''

At five and a half months' running time the third-longest ''PennyAndAggie'' arc, [[Recap/PennyAndAggieDinnerForSix Dinner for Six]] brings the title characters' rivalry back into focus, changes the dynamic between Aggie and Marshall, and resolves the plot thread of Nick's and Charisma's relationship, all set within a framework of farce.

Following "Dinner for Six" in the archives is a five-page preview of ''Burgerzone'', an unfinished teen fantasy/horror graphic novel unrelated to ''PennyAndAggie''.

Meanwhile, a janitor finds Nick still passed out and has him taken into the corridor where, as a crowd gathers, Marshall arrives with Aggie. As Nick revives, with some temporary short-term memory loss but otherwise okay, Marshall uses his first-aid training to care for him until the paramedics arrive. Nick gives Annie a sly wink when Marshall tells him his name until Aggie desperately interjects "His mother calls him "Mar." At this point Charisma comes by, and Marshall tries to explain that the evening's off. Charisma loses her temper and yells at him, "You were put on this Earth to slow me down!" As Marshall barely stops himself from saying "I hate you," the paramedics walk past them, carrying Nick on a stretcher, and as their eyes meet, she realizes her mistake too late.

Some days later, Nick stops by Charisma's home and, meeting Marshall outside, tells him gratefully that no matter what, he'll always be welcome in his home. Inside, Nick asks Charisma to look him in the eye and tell him she ''wouldn't'' be happier if both their children didn't exist. She can't. Realizing that it's over between them, Nick accepts a goodbye hug from Charisma as she tells him one last time she loves him. "I love you too," he says. "But I love my daughter more."

Meanwhile, a janitor finds Nick still passed out and has him taken into the corridor where, as a crowd gathers, Marshall arrives with Aggie. As Nick revives, with some temporary short-term memory loss but otherwise okay, Marshall uses his first-aid training to care for him until the paramedics arrive. Nick gives Annie a sly wink when Marshall tells him his name until Aggie desperately interjects "His '''''Mother''''' calls him '''''Mar'''''". At this point Charisma comes by, and Marshall tries to explain that the evening's off. Charisma loses her temper and yells at him, "You were put on this Earth to slow me down!" As Marshall barely stops himself from saying "I hate you," the paramedics walk past them, carrying Nick on a stretcher, and as their eyes meet, she realizes her mistake too late.

* ShoutOut: Karen's [[GoodAngelBadAngel Good Angel]] resembles the title character of ''UglyGirl''.

Meanwhile, a janitor finds Nick still passed out and has him taken into the corridor where, as a crowd gathers, Marshall arrives with Aggie. As Nick revives, with some temporary short-term memory loss but otherwise okay, Marshall uses his first-aid training to care for him until the paramedics arrive. (Nick and Marshall now realize who each other is.) At this point Charisma comes by, and Marshall tries to explain that the evening's off. Charisma loses her temper and yells at him, "You were put on this Earth to slow me down!" As Marshall barely stops himself from saying "I hate you," the paramedics walk past them, carrying Nick on a stretcher, and as their eyes meet, she realizes her mistake too late.

As they wait for Nick, Charisma asks Penny whether "her" father used to be apathetic, joyless and inactive, but has now become full of life. Penny reflects that her father, Rob, has in fact been a couch potato for years (the reason for this is revealed in a subsequent arc), and then recalls his having openly gawked at younger women earlier that day. Now convinced Rob ''is'' having an affair with Charisma, Penny hugs her in gratitude for supposedly bringing back the lively, fun dad she once knew, and by doing so, giving her parents another shot at happiness. This confuses Charisma, who knows Nick is a widower. At this point Karen turns up and, thinking Penny's "working the mom" to get at Marshall, trades insults with her, thus further frustrating Charisma.