Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / GameOfThronesS4E10TheChildren

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse of genre savvy and wrong genre savvy


* SacredHospitality: When Jon enters his tent, Mance offers this to him, offering him drink and food. This was a GenreSavvy move on his part as when he catches Jon looking at a butcher's knife, he invokes this to him. Jon, being the son of HonorBeforeReason, whose own brother was murdered in a violation of the same ritual, would never be able to break hospitality to kill Mance. He later cites Mance's commitment to the same as reasons for sparing him to Stannis.

to:

* SacredHospitality: When Jon enters his tent, Mance offers this to him, offering him drink and food. This was a GenreSavvy savvy move on his part as when he catches Jon looking at a butcher's knife, he invokes this to him.reminds him of sacred hospitality in their culture. Jon, being the son of HonorBeforeReason, whose own brother was murdered in a violation of the same ritual, would never be able to break hospitality to kill Mance. He later cites Mance's commitment to the same as reasons for sparing him to Stannis.



* YouWouldntShootMe: Tywin doesn't believe that Tyrion would shoot his own father in the privy. [[WrongGenreSavvy He's wrong.]]

to:

* YouWouldntShootMe: Tywin doesn't believe that Tyrion would shoot his own father in the privy. [[WrongGenreSavvy He's wrong.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the books, Melisandre takes an active role in the battle beyond the wall and Stannis has a third column that gets battered by the giants and their mammoths.

to:

** In the books, Melisandre takes an active role in the battle beyond the wall and Stannis has a third column that gets battered by the giants and their mammoths. The knights here don't chant "Stannis! Stannis! STANNIS!" during the charge.

Added: 693

Changed: 611

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the book, Jaime has to hold Varys at knifepoint to convince him to free Tyrion. With no mention of that incident, it seems more like Varys genuinely wants to save the man whose great potential and competence he recognized some time ago. [[NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished However,]] his helpful act does end up costing him, as he realizes he's likely be found guilty of freeing a condemned man, which allowed him to murder the Hand of the King. As a result he hops on the boat with Tyrion and has to flee King's Landing.

to:

** In the book, Jaime has to hold Varys at knifepoint to convince him to free Tyrion. With no mention of that incident, it seems more like Varys genuinely wants to save the man whose great potential and competence he recognized some time ago. [[NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished However,]] his helpful act does end up costing him, as he realizes he's likely be found guilty of freeing a condemned man, which allowed him to murder the Hand of the King. As a result he hops on the boat with Tyrion and has to flee King's Landing.



* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Jaime Lannister broke a vow to save thousands from the Mad King's atrocities. He now breaks his vows to free an innocent man from prison and a death sentence and defending his beleaguered little brother. His reward; said brother decides to murder their father and a woman, only to hightail it out of there with the Master of Whispers.

to:

* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished:
**
Jaime Lannister broke a vow to save thousands from the Mad King's atrocities. He now breaks his vows to free an innocent man from prison and a death sentence and defending his beleaguered little brother. His reward; said brother decides to murder their father and a woman, only to hightail it out of there with the Master of Whispers.
** Varys helps Tyrion to escape for unstated reasons. This kind act ends up costing him, as he realizes he will likely be prosecuted for freeing a condemned man and abetting a traitor when the motive behind the bells tolling (the murder of the Hand of the King) gets investigated. As a result he hops on the boat with Tyrion and has to flee King's Landing.

Added: 159

Removed: 159

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalModesty: In the book, Shae is only wearing a golden necklace when Tyrion finds her in Tywin's bedchamber. In the show, she's wearing a nightgown.



* AdaptationalModesty: In the book, Shae is only wearing a golden necklace when Tyrion finds her in Tywin's bedchamber. In the show, she's wearing a nightgown.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalVillainy: In the books, Shae tries to apologize and cries while she tells Tyrion that the Queen made her lie in the trial, but she ends up saying the wrong thing and Tyrion kills her. In the series she goes straight to the knife in an attempt to kill Tyrion, without any kind of conversation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamEpisode: Unlike the usual tradition of having the 9th episode as the most shocking one, most of the most surprising and important twist happened in the final episode. Stannis is back, the wildling is defeated, the hound probably die, and the biggest of them all is [[BigBad Tywin Lannister]] is dead...

to:

* WhamEpisode: Unlike the usual tradition of having the 9th episode as the most shocking one, most of the most surprising and important twist happened in the final episode. Stannis is back, the wildling is wildlings are defeated, the hound probably die, dies, and the biggest of them all is [[BigBad Tywin Lannister]] is dead...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Jamie gave Oathkeeper to Brienne because he felt that it would be appropriate for Ned Stark's daughter to be protected by Ned Stark's ReforgedBlade. Its Lannister-styled hilt makes Sandor interpret its intended symbolism the opposite way, and turn on Brienne.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CondescendingCompassion: Throughout his final scene, Tywin appears to be feeling a mixture of pity and disappointment towards his youngest son--both strange and infuriating when you consider that ''he'' is the main reason Tyrion is so flawed to begin with. Best seen when Tyrion admits to being in love with Shae--his father's response is to sigh and say "Oh, Tyrion..." before assuring him that it doesn't ''really'' matter that she's dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the books Varys simply disappears after helping Jaime to get Tyrion out of prison, and it's left unclear where he goes, whether he went to Essos or whether he was just hiding in King's Landing. In the show, likely because they need a reason to keep Conleth Hill on screen - he escapes alongside Tyrion.

to:

** In the books Varys simply disappears after helping Jaime to get Tyrion out of prison, and it's left unclear where he goes, goes; whether he went to Essos or whether he was just hiding in King's Landing. In the show, show - likely because they need needed a reason to keep Conleth Hill on screen - he escapes alongside Tyrion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As in the first episode of the season, Tyrion walks into a room and finds Shae on the bed, saying "My lion".

Added: 308

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WeCanRebuildHim: Qyburn wants to perform questionable experiments on the Mountain to see if he can save his body. It's implied that the process will change him monstrously, but will make him even ''more'' powerful than before.

to:

* WeCanRebuildHim: Qyburn wants to perform questionable experiments on the Mountain to see if he can save his body. It's implied that the process will change him monstrously, but will make him even ''more'' powerful than before.before.
* WhamEpisode: Unlike the usual tradition of having the 9th episode as the most shocking one, most of the most surprising and important twist happened in the final episode. Stannis is back, the wildling is defeated, the hound probably die, and the biggest of them all is [[BigBad Tywin Lannister]] is dead...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In Mance's tent, Mance refers to the wildling pouring their drinks/getting their food as "Toregg", which is the name of Tormund Giantsbane's eldest son in the novels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SecretTestOfCharacter: Stannis gives Jon a fairly small one by asking him what [[HonorBeforeReason Ned Stark]], the man Jon claims to be his father, would have done with Mance to determine if his claim is true.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvenEvilHasStandards: For all his lecherousness and brown-nosing, Pycelle at least has the decency to insist on a less unpleasant death for The Mountain.

to:

* EvenEvilHasStandards: For all his lecherousness and brown-nosing, Pycelle at least has the decency to insist on a less unpleasant death for The Mountain. He vocally makes known his open contempt for Qyburn's career as Mad Scientist who vivisected living men in the name of gaining knowledge. Pycelle may be willing to betray men to their deaths, but as a maester he has still taken vows as a physician, so he is still disgusted with what he sees as Qyburn's perversion of medicine and the search for knowledge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Back in '''King's Landing''', Tyrion, awaiting execution in the Black Cells, receives an unexpected visitor: Jaime, who has killed the guards and swiftly breaks him out to put him on a path toward Varys, his co-conspirator. They've arranged for a ship to take Tyrion away to the Free Cities. After a bittersweet goodbye between the two brothers, Tyrion changes paths and makes for a different destination.

to:

Back in '''King's Landing''', Tyrion, awaiting execution in the Black Cells, receives an unexpected visitor: Jaime, who has killed the guards and swiftly breaks him out to put him on a path toward Varys, his co-conspirator. They've arranged for a ship to take Tyrion away to the Free Cities. After a bittersweet but loving goodbye between the two brothers, Tyrion changes paths and makes for a different destination.



''*Twang*'' Tyrion pulls the trigger and shoots his father in the bowels, just as promised. Tywin is slammed back against the wall, unable to believe that his youngest child has mortally wounded him. Tyrion calmly and slowly recharges the crossbow.

to:

''*Twang*'' Tyrion pulls the trigger and shoots his father in the bowels, just as promised. Tywin is slammed back against the wall, unable to believe that his youngest child has mortally wounded him. Tyrion calmly and slowly recharges the crossbow.



** The {{Patricide}} is incredibly different. When freeing Tyrion, Jaime confesses that Tysha, the prostitute that he claimed to have hired to fake a RescueRomance for Tyrion, was no such thing, but rather exactly what she said she was: a crofter's daughter who really did love him. Tyrion brings this up when he confronts Tywin, and it's Tysha that Tywin refers to as a whore one too many times. This also has the added side effect of completely changing their parting words: in the books, Tyrion, headlong over the DespairEventHorizon, lies to Jaime that he did indeed kill Joffrey, hurting the one person who still loves him simply because he himself is in too much pain to be civil. He regrets it almost immediately, but it's clear the damage is done. ...[[TearJerker Maybe it's just as well they cut this out.]]

to:

** The {{Patricide}} is incredibly different. When freeing Tyrion, Jaime confesses that Tysha, the prostitute that he claimed to have hired to fake a RescueRomance for Tyrion, was no such thing, but rather exactly what she said she was: a crofter's daughter who really did love him. When Lord Tywin found out, he ordered Jaime to lie, deeming the girl nothing but a GoldDigger. Tyrion brings this up when he confronts Tywin, and it's Tysha that Tywin refers to as a whore one too many times. This also has the added side effect of completely changing their the brothers' parting words: in the books, Tyrion, headlong over the DespairEventHorizon, lies to Jaime that he did indeed kill Joffrey, hurting the one person who still loves him simply because he himself is in too much pain to be civil. He regrets it almost immediately, but it's clear the damage is done. ...[[TearJerker Maybe it's just as well they cut this out.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HolyGround: The wights attacking Bran shatter when they enter the wierwood.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Jaime retroactively did this in "Oathkeeper" when he outfitted Brienne with a fine suit of armor and a Valyrian steel sword bearing the mark of the lion. Arya and Sandor distrust her and a fight breaks out because from all appearances, she looks like she's in league with the Lannisters.

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Jaime retroactively did this in "Oathkeeper" when he outfitted Brienne with a fine suit of armor and armor, a Valyrian steel sword bearing the mark of the lion.lion, and had Podrick Payne act as her squire. Arya and Sandor distrust her and a fight breaks out because from all appearances, she looks like she's in league with the Lannisters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Jaime retroactively did this in "Oathkeeper" when he outfitted Brienne with a fine suit of armor and a Valyrian steel sword bearing the mark of the lion. Arya and Sandor distrust her and a fight breaks out because from all appearances, she looks like she's in league with the Lannisters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the books, Mance threatens to use the Horn of Winter, which can bring the Wall down according to a legend. In the show, no such horn is mentioned, and Mance simply threatens to kill all members of the Night's Watch. (The Horn of Joramun is also either a bluff or a TakingYouWithMe, since Mance needs the Wall to stop the White Walkers. Mance, to his credit, fully admits this, justifying it as CrazyEnoughToWork.)

to:

** In the books, Mance shows Jon a large and impressive horn and claims it's the legendary Horn of Joramun, which will cause the wall to collapse when it's blown, and threatens to use it in three days if his people aren't allowed through the Horn of Winter, which can bring wall. Jon is trying to decide whether to try to smash the Wall down according horn when Stannis's attack arrives, not whether to a legend. try to kill Mance. In the show, no such the horn is and the legend are never mentioned, and Mance simply threatens to kill all members of the Night's Watch. (The Horn of Joramun Watch if they don't let him through. [[labelnote:Incidentally]] the entire threat is also either a bluff or a an instance of TakingYouWithMe, since the whole reason Mance needs is leading the wildlings south is that they need the Wall to stop protect them from the White Walkers. Mance, to his credit, Others. Mance fully admits this, justifying this but justifies it as CrazyEnoughToWork.)CrazyEnoughToWork, and Tormund later admits that they knew the horn was a fake anyway.[[/labelnote]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeroicBSOD: Tyrion's response after killing a woman he loved - Shae - and the one man who'd made his life a living hell: his own father. When he returns to Varys to get smuggled out of King's Landing, Tyrion is silent and staring off [[ThousandYardStare into the distance]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Tyrion:''' [[WhamLine I murdered her.]] With, my own hands.

to:

-->'''Tyrion:''' [[WhamLine I murdered her.]] With, [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone With my own hands. hands.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That\'s hardly a \"base breaker,\" which implies controversy. Those changes are universally despised by book-readers.


* BaseBreaker: Book readers were specially angered by the omission of Jaime confessing the truth about Tysha, specially after the show devoting a long time on Tyrion's speech about cousin Orson, who [[CanonForeigner doesn't even exist in the books]].
** And let's not even get started on the reactions [[spoiler:towards the omission of Lady Stoneheart.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BaseBreaker: Book readers were specially angered by the omission of Jaime confessing the truth about Tysha, specially after the show devoting a long time on Tyrion's speech about cousin Orson, who [[CanonForeigner doesn't even exist in the books]].
**And let's not even get started on the reactions [[spoiler:towards the omission of Lady Stoneheart.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not An Example at this point, since Qyburn\'s single We Can Rebuild Him line sort of comes off as trying to get ahold of a research specimen nobody will miss (and even in the books the whole \"survival\" thing hasn\'t been confirmed)


** OutGambitted: Sadly, he couldn't anticipate Qyburn's interference.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Brienne defeats Sandor in both the swordfighting and brawling portion of their duel. In the books, they never fight, and no one defeats Sandor.

to:

** Brienne defeats Sandor in both the swordfighting and brawling portion of their duel. In the books, they never fight, and no one ever defeats Sandor.Sandor (who instead dies of an infection after fighting some mooks).



** In the books, Brienne's quest is a great deal longer and she never gets anywhere close to finding Sansa or Arya. Here, she gets put in the right direction fairly quickly. This is likely an intentional choice on the writers' part, since several parts of Brienne's journey turn out to be fruitless and don't serve to advance the plot much further, so it would be a waste of screentime to show them.

to:

** In the books, Brienne's quest is a great deal longer and she never gets anywhere close to finding Sansa or Arya. Here, she gets put in the right direction fairly quickly. This is likely an intentional choice on the writers' part, since several parts in the book large portions of Brienne's her journey turn out to be fruitless and don't serve to advance the plot much further, so much. Showing all of it just for the sake of some extra character development for her and Pod would be a waste of screentime to show them. screentime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GoodVersusGood: The fight between Brienne and Sandor is this. Brienne is an honorable woman who wants to protect the Stark girls and fulfill her vow to Catelyn. Sandor, despite his flaws, also wants to protect Arya and has very good reasons not to trust Brienne. This makes the communication breakdown between them - and their ensuing violent fight - all the more tragic since both fighters are otherwise decent people.

Changed: 119

Removed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Example Indentation. Also, Littlefinger might be a sociopathic wild card, but he IS competent, give him that much. (-:


* FromBadToWorse: Tywin is dead, meaning the real political power behind the Iron Throne is in utter disarray, more than likely to be filled by [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen Cersei]].
** Even worse, the only other competent small council members are both on a ship to Essos.

to:

* FromBadToWorse: Tywin is dead, meaning the real political power behind the Iron Throne is in utter disarray, more than likely to be filled by [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen Cersei]].
**
Cersei]]. Even worse, the only other competent small council members are both on a ship to Essos.Essos or playing at politics in the Vale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

** Even worse, the only other competent small council members are both on a ship to Essos.

Changed: 761

Removed: 1449

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That\'s very much open to interpretation.


** The circumstances of Tyrion's killing spree in the Tower of the Hand are completely altered from the books, to say the least.
*** As has been mentioned elsewhere, the televised version of Shae is a whore through and through, OnlyInItForTheMoney and having no real feelings for her employer (though she does fake it well enough). When Tyrion stumbles upon her in his father's bed, she essentially tries to seduce him, calling him "my giant of Lannister" / "my lion"--what she had once said (pseudo)lovingly but also humiliated him with at the trial. She also doesn't attack him, making the TV encounter an unintended example of AdaptationalHeroism: in the books, Tyrion is simply fed up with her betrayal and strangles her without (physical) provocation.
*** The {{Patricide}} is also incredibly different. When freeing Tyrion, Jaime confesses that Tysha, the prostitute that he claimed to have hired to fake a RescueRomance for Tyrion, was no such thing, but rather exactly what she said she was: a crofter's daughter who really did love him. Tyrion brings this up when he confronts Tywin, and it's Tysha that Tywin refers to as a whore one too many times. This also has the added side effect of completely changing their parting words: in the books, Tyrion, headlong over the DespairEventHorizon, lies to Jaime that he did indeed kill Joffrey, hurting the one person who still loves him simply because he himself is in too much pain to be civil. He regrets it almost immediately, but it's clear the damage is done. ...[[TearJerker Maybe it's just as well they cut this out.]]

to:

** The circumstances of Tyrion's killing spree in the Tower of the Hand are completely altered from the books, to say the least.
*** As has been mentioned elsewhere, the televised version of Shae is a whore through and through, OnlyInItForTheMoney and having no real feelings for her employer (though she does fake it well enough). When Tyrion stumbles upon her in his father's bed, she essentially tries to seduce him, calling him "my giant of Lannister" / "my lion"--what she had once said (pseudo)lovingly but also humiliated him with at the trial. She also doesn't attack him, making the TV encounter an unintended example of AdaptationalHeroism: in the books, Tyrion is simply fed up with her betrayal and strangles her without (physical) provocation.
***
** The {{Patricide}} is also incredibly different. When freeing Tyrion, Jaime confesses that Tysha, the prostitute that he claimed to have hired to fake a RescueRomance for Tyrion, was no such thing, but rather exactly what she said she was: a crofter's daughter who really did love him. Tyrion brings this up when he confronts Tywin, and it's Tysha that Tywin refers to as a whore one too many times. This also has the added side effect of completely changing their parting words: in the books, Tyrion, headlong over the DespairEventHorizon, lies to Jaime that he did indeed kill Joffrey, hurting the one person who still loves him simply because he himself is in too much pain to be civil. He regrets it almost immediately, but it's clear the damage is done. ...[[TearJerker Maybe it's just as well they cut this out.]]

Top