Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 9 (click to see context) from:
* ''Film/TwentyOneJumpStreet'' starts with the protagonists arresting a biker for possession of drugs, only for said biker to be let off because the protagonists didn't properly read him the MirandaRights (they only know the first two sentences due to cultural osmosis).
to:
* ''Film/TwentyOneJumpStreet'' starts with the protagonists arresting a biker for possession of drugs, only for said biker to be let off because the protagonists didn't properly read him the MirandaRights (they only know the first two sentences sentence due to cultural osmosis).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 9 (click to see context) from:
to:
* ''Film/TwentyOneJumpStreet'' starts with the protagonists arresting a biker for possession of drugs, only for said biker to be let off because the protagonists didn't properly read him the MirandaRights (they only know the first two sentences due to cultural osmosis).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Now an Index disallowing examples.
Changed line(s) 25 (click to see context) from:
* ''Film/LethalWeapon2''. This is a running concept throughout the movie that the BigBad and TheDragon are diplomats (from [[UsefulNotes/TheApartheidEra apartheid]] [[AcceptableTargets South Africa]]) who can't be arrested or prosecuted over any offence in the United States due to [[DiplomaticImpunity diplomatic immunity]]. In RealLife, most governments would at least expel diplomats who were proven to be heroin smugglers, and probably be prosecuted at home to keep the host country happy (especially as South Africa was a strong US ally). Of course, [[CowboyCop it doesn't turn out well for them in the end.]]
to:
* ''Film/LethalWeapon2''. This is a running concept throughout the movie that the BigBad and TheDragon are diplomats (from [[UsefulNotes/TheApartheidEra apartheid]] [[AcceptableTargets apartheid South Africa]]) who can't be arrested or prosecuted over any offence in the United States due to [[DiplomaticImpunity diplomatic immunity]]. In RealLife, most governments would at least expel diplomats who were proven to be heroin smugglers, and probably be prosecuted at home to keep the host country happy (especially as South Africa was a strong US ally). Of course, [[CowboyCop it doesn't turn out well for them in the end.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 39 (click to see context) from:
* In ''Film/SupermanReturns'', ComicBook/LexLuthor had his conviction from [[Film/{{Superman}} the previous Superman movie]] overturned because Franchise/{{Superman}} didn't show up to testify against him in the appeal. [[HollywoodLaw There is no testimony in appeal hearings]]; only the trial record is reviewed, making this a research flub, as Luthor clearly said he got off because Superman didn't show up to testify at the latest appeal. The reason for this was that Superman had left Earth to follow a false lead regarding the remains of Krypton. The false lead was somehow engineered by Luthor himself exactly for the purpose of getting off on that technicality.
to:
* In ''Film/SupermanReturns'', ComicBook/LexLuthor had his conviction from [[Film/{{Superman}} [[Film/SupermanTheMovie the previous Superman movie]] overturned because Franchise/{{Superman}} didn't show up to testify against him in the appeal. [[HollywoodLaw There is no testimony in appeal hearings]]; only the trial record is reviewed, making this a research flub, as Luthor clearly said he got off because Superman didn't show up to testify at the latest appeal. The reason for this was that Superman had left Earth to follow a false lead regarding the remains of Krypton. The false lead was somehow engineered by Luthor himself exactly for the purpose of getting off on that technicality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* In ''Film/SawV'', Seth Baxter who presumably was under the influence of drugs murders his girlfriend Angelina Acomb during a domestic dispute when she wanted to go to a farewell party of one of her colleagues without him. He flees, but is later captured by the police and sentenced to life in prison. However five years later, he is released from prison due to an unexplained legal technically. However it turns out that Angelina's brother is Mark Hoffman, who is livid Seth served nowhere near the proper punishment for murdering his sister and decides to take matters into his own hands. One night he kidnaps Seth and kills him in a trap designed to look like one from the infamous Jigsaw killer. This gets the attention of John Kramer himself who blackmails Hoffman into becoming a Jigsaw apprentice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* ''Film/AndJusticeForAll'': Cruelly {{inverted}} with Jeff, whom Kirkland is ''unable'' to get off (although he's innocent) because of a technicality.
Deleted line(s) 23 (click to see context) :
* ''Film/AndJusticeForAll'': Cruelly {{inverted}} with Jeff, whom Kirkland is ''unable'' to get off (although he's innocent) because of a technicality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
%%%
%%
%% This page has been alphabetized. Please add new examples in the correct order. Thanks!
%%
%%%
Times where a criminal gets OffOnATechnicality in LiveActionFilms.
----
* {{Inverted}} in ''Film/TheATeam''. [[spoiler:The team successfully clears their name of the crime they were originally convicted of and send a gang of crooked CIA agents and PrivateMilitaryContractors to prison... and are promptly re-arrested on the technicality that "it's still illegal to break out of jail." Captain Sosa tells her superior to his face, [[PrecisionFStrike "This is chickenshit, sir."]]]]
* ''Film/ActsOfVengeance2017'': It's mentioned Valera got an accused child murderer off due to a technicality. [[spoiler:The man went on to kill Strode's daughter too, resulting in him later murdering Valera's wife and daughter for revenge.]]
* At the end of ''Film/AntMan1'', the police "lose" some of the paperwork connected to Scott's latest arrest, tainting the case against him and making him once again a free man.
* In the movie ''Film/CarlitosWay'', five years after drug dealer Carlito Brigante is sent to prison for murder, his lawyer gets him out because of prosecutorial misconduct and illegal wiretaps that led to the evidence being tainted. The judge that ordered Carlito's release made it quite clear this was the only reason he released him and deeply regrets having to do this (especially since it was the same judge who presided over his trial and sentenced Brigante to prison the first time anyway. In fact, he'd been forced to since the appeals court reversed his ruling).
* ''Film/CruelAndUnusual'': Edgar is outraged when some of the other condemned suggest that, just because she died first, Maylon wasn't condemned for his murder while he was for killing her.
* Scorpio in ''Film/DirtyHarry'', who got off due to Harry Callahan illegally obtaining the evidence that would have convicted him and using the JackBauerInterrogationTechnique to make him talk concerning where the girl Scorpio kidnapped was, since the DA said he "couldn't condone police torture." This would only invalidate the confession of that case (even without Scorpio's confession, there's more than enough hard evidence for a conviction), but certainly not Scorpio's ''attempted murder'' of Callahan, assault with a deadly weapon, possession of an illegal automatic weapon, and kidnapping him, which is enough for a life sentence by itself.
** In the sequel, ''Film/MagnumForce'', the film opens with a known racketeer, his attorney, driver, and bodyguard being executed by a traffic cop after the former gets off on a technicality for the killing of a labor reformer and his family.
** Two films later, in ''Film/SuddenImpact'', Harry's first scene is in a courtroom where a judge throws out a case on an arrest Harry made, saying that he didn't have valid grounds for the search that got him the evidence justifying the arrest. Of course, a while later the released suspect tries to murder Harry and is killed in self-defense, delivering karmic justice.
* The Sally Field movie ''Film/EyeForAnEye'' has this as its premise, as a woman who loses her daughter to a rapist tries to get him behind bars, but seeks her own kind of justice on him after he gets off on a technicality. The tagline of the movie is "What do you do when justice fails?" In RealLife, at the very least, the killer's constant making faces at Field would earn him a bunch of "contempt of court" charges.
* ''Film/FreeStateOfJones'': The Mississippi Supreme Court engineered this to save the state's miscegenation law from a constitutional challenge, overturning Davis Knight's conviction on technical grounds.
* ''Film/ISpitOnYourGrave'': The third film has Oscar tell Jennifer his daughter's rapist was released because the physical evidence against him went missing.
* In ''Film/TheInnocent1994'', the autistic child Gregory helps identify the mass murderers Tinsley and Bates, but they're released shortly after their arrest after Gregory is deemed to be an unreliable witness.
* In ''Film/JohnDoeVigilante'', John Doe's targets are all unrepentant criminals who have escaped justice or been let off on a technicality.
* ''Film/AndJusticeForAll'': Cruelly {{inverted}} with Jeff, whom Kirkland is ''unable'' to get off (although he's innocent) because of a technicality.
* In the third film of the ''Jack Slater'' film series, the ShowWithinAShow of ''Film/LastActionHero'', Slater's nemesis the Ripper was only given ten years in prison rather than the death penalty because an illegal search by Slater rendered the murder weapon inadmissible in court.
* ''Film/LethalWeapon2''. This is a running concept throughout the movie that the BigBad and TheDragon are diplomats (from [[UsefulNotes/TheApartheidEra apartheid]] [[AcceptableTargets South Africa]]) who can't be arrested or prosecuted over any offence in the United States due to [[DiplomaticImpunity diplomatic immunity]]. In RealLife, most governments would at least expel diplomats who were proven to be heroin smugglers, and probably be prosecuted at home to keep the host country happy (especially as South Africa was a strong US ally). Of course, [[CowboyCop it doesn't turn out well for them in the end.]]
* Played for laughs in ''Film/LiarLiar'' [[spoiler:until the end, where Fletcher gets a MyGodWhatHaveIDone moment]].
* In ''Film/AMurderOfCrows'', the man responsible for the death of the SerialKiller's family got off on a technicality, and triggered his StartOfDarkness.
* ''Franchise/ANightmareOnElmStreet'':
** Child-killer Freddy Krueger was let off because, as expanded on in ''Film/FreddysDeadTheFinalNightmare'', a drunken judge failed to sign the search warrant in the right place, so the parents of Elm Street banded together and burned him alive. A case of HollywoodLaw, as [[http://www.worldfamouscomics.com/law/back20021126.shtml these]] [[http://www.worldfamouscomics.com/law/back20030121.shtml articles]] from the column "The Law Is a Ass" detail why that particular arrest was, in fact, valid and wouldn't have been tossed out.
** The circumstances of Freddy's arrest are expanded on in a few books (including the ''Film/FreddyVsJason'' novelization). Some CowboyCop suspicious of Freddy actually broke into the Krueger house and utterly trashed the place looking for him, stumbling across Freddy's hidden "[[RoomFullOfCrazy trophy room]]" (where he kept scrapbooks containing newspaper clippings and such); afterward he rushed to the power plant, found Freddy there and brought him in.
** ''Comicbook/FreddyVsJasonVsAsh'' has a time displaced FBI agent (long story) try to prevent Freddy from ever becoming a dream demon by correctly signing the search warrant himself. [[FridgeLogic Whether an FBI agent who probably wasn't even born yet has the authority to do so is another question]].
** The first episode of ''Series/FreddysNightmares'' stated that Freddy got off simply because the arresting officer failed to read Freddy his Miranda rights (which is also [[HollywoodLaw not legitimate]], since it only means any statements he made couldn't be used, but other evidence could be).
* In the thriller ''Film/SomeoneToWatchOverMe'', the villain is released after being arrested for murder because no one read him his rights, even though he was never interrogated and no statements made by him were used as evidence against him. Especially {{facepalm}}-worthy, since the movie actually (apparently unwittingly) provided a legitimate reason for why he might be released: he isn't represented by counsel during a lineup, even though he requests it, tainting the resulting identification (which is the prosecution's whole case).
* In ''Film/TheStarChamber'', having to free obviously guilty murderers on technicalities inspires Judge Stephen Hardin to join a secret court which "tries", convicts and sentences them to death, with a hitman carrying it out. Two specific examples from early in the movie:
** The film opens with a pair of undercover cops chasing a suspect who pops his gun into the trash when he gets home. The cops are unable to legally search the trash because they don't have a warrant, so they attempt a bit of LoopholeAbuse and search the garbage truck when they pick up the trash. In court, it comes out that the trash was still in the truck's hopper when it was searched, so it was still the suspect's trash. Judge Hardin reluctantly dismisses the case.
** A pair of men are picked up for raping and murdering a child when one of the cops claims to smell marijuana in their van and they find the victim's shoe. The technicality this time is that the search was illegal because there was no marijuana present in the van to justify the search. The reasoning behind this one is what drives Hardin to join the secret court. [[spoiler:The men are later revealed to be innocent as someone stole their van, let someone else use it to commit the rape/murder, and returned it without their knowledge.]]
* In ''Film/StarTrekIntoDarkness'', Kirk and Spock are called out by Admiral Pike for violating the PrimeDirective, having corrupted a pre-warp culture in the most dramatic way possible by letting them all see the ''Enterprise'' while rescuing Spock after his mission to prevent a volcano from wiping said culture out. Spock points out that ''[[InvokedTrope technically]]'', their plan was not in violation of the Directive, as the ''Enterprise'' would have stayed out of sight had Sulu's shuttle not gotten fouled by the volcanic gas. Naturally, his use of the trope [[LampshadeHanging gets called out]] by the enraged Admiral.
* In ''Film/SupermanReturns'', ComicBook/LexLuthor had his conviction from [[Film/{{Superman}} the previous Superman movie]] overturned because Franchise/{{Superman}} didn't show up to testify against him in the appeal. [[HollywoodLaw There is no testimony in appeal hearings]]; only the trial record is reviewed, making this a research flub, as Luthor clearly said he got off because Superman didn't show up to testify at the latest appeal. The reason for this was that Superman had left Earth to follow a false lead regarding the remains of Krypton. The false lead was somehow engineered by Luthor himself exactly for the purpose of getting off on that technicality.
* ''Film/TheresSomethingAboutMary'': Mary's architect friend, [[spoiler:who was actually a pizza delivery boy]], claimed Pat was a murderer who stayed in prison for five years until a technicality got him off. [[spoiler:The claim was false]].
* ''Film/WindRiver'': The coroner's report on Natalie's body acknowledges that she was raped, but he legally has to list the cause of death as the extreme cold rather than as a homicide (even though it was only through the actions of her rapist that she was in a position to die of cold to begin with). This infuriates FBIAgent Jane Banner, as she knows her boss won't let her stay on the case unless it's declared a murder. She resolves the problem by simply not reporting in for as long as possible.
----
%%
%% This page has been alphabetized. Please add new examples in the correct order. Thanks!
%%
%%%
Times where a criminal gets OffOnATechnicality in LiveActionFilms.
----
* {{Inverted}} in ''Film/TheATeam''. [[spoiler:The team successfully clears their name of the crime they were originally convicted of and send a gang of crooked CIA agents and PrivateMilitaryContractors to prison... and are promptly re-arrested on the technicality that "it's still illegal to break out of jail." Captain Sosa tells her superior to his face, [[PrecisionFStrike "This is chickenshit, sir."]]]]
* ''Film/ActsOfVengeance2017'': It's mentioned Valera got an accused child murderer off due to a technicality. [[spoiler:The man went on to kill Strode's daughter too, resulting in him later murdering Valera's wife and daughter for revenge.]]
* At the end of ''Film/AntMan1'', the police "lose" some of the paperwork connected to Scott's latest arrest, tainting the case against him and making him once again a free man.
* In the movie ''Film/CarlitosWay'', five years after drug dealer Carlito Brigante is sent to prison for murder, his lawyer gets him out because of prosecutorial misconduct and illegal wiretaps that led to the evidence being tainted. The judge that ordered Carlito's release made it quite clear this was the only reason he released him and deeply regrets having to do this (especially since it was the same judge who presided over his trial and sentenced Brigante to prison the first time anyway. In fact, he'd been forced to since the appeals court reversed his ruling).
* ''Film/CruelAndUnusual'': Edgar is outraged when some of the other condemned suggest that, just because she died first, Maylon wasn't condemned for his murder while he was for killing her.
* Scorpio in ''Film/DirtyHarry'', who got off due to Harry Callahan illegally obtaining the evidence that would have convicted him and using the JackBauerInterrogationTechnique to make him talk concerning where the girl Scorpio kidnapped was, since the DA said he "couldn't condone police torture." This would only invalidate the confession of that case (even without Scorpio's confession, there's more than enough hard evidence for a conviction), but certainly not Scorpio's ''attempted murder'' of Callahan, assault with a deadly weapon, possession of an illegal automatic weapon, and kidnapping him, which is enough for a life sentence by itself.
** In the sequel, ''Film/MagnumForce'', the film opens with a known racketeer, his attorney, driver, and bodyguard being executed by a traffic cop after the former gets off on a technicality for the killing of a labor reformer and his family.
** Two films later, in ''Film/SuddenImpact'', Harry's first scene is in a courtroom where a judge throws out a case on an arrest Harry made, saying that he didn't have valid grounds for the search that got him the evidence justifying the arrest. Of course, a while later the released suspect tries to murder Harry and is killed in self-defense, delivering karmic justice.
* The Sally Field movie ''Film/EyeForAnEye'' has this as its premise, as a woman who loses her daughter to a rapist tries to get him behind bars, but seeks her own kind of justice on him after he gets off on a technicality. The tagline of the movie is "What do you do when justice fails?" In RealLife, at the very least, the killer's constant making faces at Field would earn him a bunch of "contempt of court" charges.
* ''Film/FreeStateOfJones'': The Mississippi Supreme Court engineered this to save the state's miscegenation law from a constitutional challenge, overturning Davis Knight's conviction on technical grounds.
* ''Film/ISpitOnYourGrave'': The third film has Oscar tell Jennifer his daughter's rapist was released because the physical evidence against him went missing.
* In ''Film/TheInnocent1994'', the autistic child Gregory helps identify the mass murderers Tinsley and Bates, but they're released shortly after their arrest after Gregory is deemed to be an unreliable witness.
* In ''Film/JohnDoeVigilante'', John Doe's targets are all unrepentant criminals who have escaped justice or been let off on a technicality.
* ''Film/AndJusticeForAll'': Cruelly {{inverted}} with Jeff, whom Kirkland is ''unable'' to get off (although he's innocent) because of a technicality.
* In the third film of the ''Jack Slater'' film series, the ShowWithinAShow of ''Film/LastActionHero'', Slater's nemesis the Ripper was only given ten years in prison rather than the death penalty because an illegal search by Slater rendered the murder weapon inadmissible in court.
* ''Film/LethalWeapon2''. This is a running concept throughout the movie that the BigBad and TheDragon are diplomats (from [[UsefulNotes/TheApartheidEra apartheid]] [[AcceptableTargets South Africa]]) who can't be arrested or prosecuted over any offence in the United States due to [[DiplomaticImpunity diplomatic immunity]]. In RealLife, most governments would at least expel diplomats who were proven to be heroin smugglers, and probably be prosecuted at home to keep the host country happy (especially as South Africa was a strong US ally). Of course, [[CowboyCop it doesn't turn out well for them in the end.]]
* Played for laughs in ''Film/LiarLiar'' [[spoiler:until the end, where Fletcher gets a MyGodWhatHaveIDone moment]].
* In ''Film/AMurderOfCrows'', the man responsible for the death of the SerialKiller's family got off on a technicality, and triggered his StartOfDarkness.
* ''Franchise/ANightmareOnElmStreet'':
** Child-killer Freddy Krueger was let off because, as expanded on in ''Film/FreddysDeadTheFinalNightmare'', a drunken judge failed to sign the search warrant in the right place, so the parents of Elm Street banded together and burned him alive. A case of HollywoodLaw, as [[http://www.worldfamouscomics.com/law/back20021126.shtml these]] [[http://www.worldfamouscomics.com/law/back20030121.shtml articles]] from the column "The Law Is a Ass" detail why that particular arrest was, in fact, valid and wouldn't have been tossed out.
** The circumstances of Freddy's arrest are expanded on in a few books (including the ''Film/FreddyVsJason'' novelization). Some CowboyCop suspicious of Freddy actually broke into the Krueger house and utterly trashed the place looking for him, stumbling across Freddy's hidden "[[RoomFullOfCrazy trophy room]]" (where he kept scrapbooks containing newspaper clippings and such); afterward he rushed to the power plant, found Freddy there and brought him in.
** ''Comicbook/FreddyVsJasonVsAsh'' has a time displaced FBI agent (long story) try to prevent Freddy from ever becoming a dream demon by correctly signing the search warrant himself. [[FridgeLogic Whether an FBI agent who probably wasn't even born yet has the authority to do so is another question]].
** The first episode of ''Series/FreddysNightmares'' stated that Freddy got off simply because the arresting officer failed to read Freddy his Miranda rights (which is also [[HollywoodLaw not legitimate]], since it only means any statements he made couldn't be used, but other evidence could be).
* In the thriller ''Film/SomeoneToWatchOverMe'', the villain is released after being arrested for murder because no one read him his rights, even though he was never interrogated and no statements made by him were used as evidence against him. Especially {{facepalm}}-worthy, since the movie actually (apparently unwittingly) provided a legitimate reason for why he might be released: he isn't represented by counsel during a lineup, even though he requests it, tainting the resulting identification (which is the prosecution's whole case).
* In ''Film/TheStarChamber'', having to free obviously guilty murderers on technicalities inspires Judge Stephen Hardin to join a secret court which "tries", convicts and sentences them to death, with a hitman carrying it out. Two specific examples from early in the movie:
** The film opens with a pair of undercover cops chasing a suspect who pops his gun into the trash when he gets home. The cops are unable to legally search the trash because they don't have a warrant, so they attempt a bit of LoopholeAbuse and search the garbage truck when they pick up the trash. In court, it comes out that the trash was still in the truck's hopper when it was searched, so it was still the suspect's trash. Judge Hardin reluctantly dismisses the case.
** A pair of men are picked up for raping and murdering a child when one of the cops claims to smell marijuana in their van and they find the victim's shoe. The technicality this time is that the search was illegal because there was no marijuana present in the van to justify the search. The reasoning behind this one is what drives Hardin to join the secret court. [[spoiler:The men are later revealed to be innocent as someone stole their van, let someone else use it to commit the rape/murder, and returned it without their knowledge.]]
* In ''Film/StarTrekIntoDarkness'', Kirk and Spock are called out by Admiral Pike for violating the PrimeDirective, having corrupted a pre-warp culture in the most dramatic way possible by letting them all see the ''Enterprise'' while rescuing Spock after his mission to prevent a volcano from wiping said culture out. Spock points out that ''[[InvokedTrope technically]]'', their plan was not in violation of the Directive, as the ''Enterprise'' would have stayed out of sight had Sulu's shuttle not gotten fouled by the volcanic gas. Naturally, his use of the trope [[LampshadeHanging gets called out]] by the enraged Admiral.
* In ''Film/SupermanReturns'', ComicBook/LexLuthor had his conviction from [[Film/{{Superman}} the previous Superman movie]] overturned because Franchise/{{Superman}} didn't show up to testify against him in the appeal. [[HollywoodLaw There is no testimony in appeal hearings]]; only the trial record is reviewed, making this a research flub, as Luthor clearly said he got off because Superman didn't show up to testify at the latest appeal. The reason for this was that Superman had left Earth to follow a false lead regarding the remains of Krypton. The false lead was somehow engineered by Luthor himself exactly for the purpose of getting off on that technicality.
* ''Film/TheresSomethingAboutMary'': Mary's architect friend, [[spoiler:who was actually a pizza delivery boy]], claimed Pat was a murderer who stayed in prison for five years until a technicality got him off. [[spoiler:The claim was false]].
* ''Film/WindRiver'': The coroner's report on Natalie's body acknowledges that she was raped, but he legally has to list the cause of death as the extreme cold rather than as a homicide (even though it was only through the actions of her rapist that she was in a position to die of cold to begin with). This infuriates FBIAgent Jane Banner, as she knows her boss won't let her stay on the case unless it's declared a murder. She resolves the problem by simply not reporting in for as long as possible.
----
