History NightmareFuel / CreepyPasta

3rd Nov '17 10:21:00 AM CJCroen1393
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''[[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/The_Disappearance_of_Ashley,_Kansas The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas]]'' is the curious tale of [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin the day the town of Ashley, Kansas, disappeared]]. The town is small and isolated, and doesn't even have its own police station. One night, all roads leading into Ashley end up becoming roads to nowhere, endlessly circling and never reaching Ashley. But that's not the scary part. [[spoiler:A woman calls the police frantically, saying "Last night they came back." The police officer on the other end tries to calm her and find out what's happening. She says she is hiding in the closet and mentions that her son died the previous year after being hit by a car. She tells the police officer that her son has returned to the world of the living, but he CameBackWrong, and he along with the rest of Ashley's dead are now looking for their loved ones. ''This is not a good thing.'' Whatever these things are, they burn every house they enter and kill the occupants [[NothingIsScarier in a way that is not identified]]. At the end of the phone call, the woman's son enters her house and kills her, laughing, "I found you, Mommy." When the police go to check on Ashley the following morning, they find nothing there, except [[{{Hellgate}} a smouldering fissure in the Earth.]]]]

to:

* ''[[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/The_Disappearance_of_Ashley,_Kansas The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas]]'' is the curious tale of [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin the day the town of Ashley, Kansas, disappeared]]. The town is small and isolated, and doesn't even have its own police station. One night, all roads leading into Ashley end up becoming roads to nowhere, endlessly circling and never reaching Ashley. But that's not the scary part. [[spoiler:A woman calls the police frantically, saying "Last night they came back." The police officer on the other end tries to calm her and find out what's happening. She says she is hiding in the closet and mentions that her son died the previous year after being hit by a car. She tells the police officer that her son has returned to the world of the living, but he CameBackWrong, and he along with the rest of Ashley's dead are now looking for their loved ones. ''This is not a good thing.'' Whatever these things are, they burn every house they enter and kill the occupants [[NothingIsScarier in a way that is not identified]]. At the end of the phone call, the woman's son enters her house and kills her, laughing, "I found you, Mommy." When the police go to check on Ashley the following morning, they find nothing there, except [[{{Hellgate}} a smouldering fissure in the Earth.]]]]]]]]
* [[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/My_Dead_Girlfriend_Keeps_Messaging_Me_on_Facebook "My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook"]]. It starts off as a TearJerker, with the titular girlfriend Emily dying in a car accident and her boyfriend, Nathan (the narrator) still getting messages from her on Facebook, messages that make him suspect that he's being harassed by someone who hacked her account and is mocking him over her death. Then things get...weird. The messages end up eerily alluding to Emily's death, with her saying things like "I'm cold" or "fre'ezing" (the crash happened in cold weather) or "let me walk" (a reference to an older conversation they had, but also alluding to the fact that her body was [[HalfTheManHeUsedToBe bisected]] in the crash). Nathan slowly freaks out over it...and then, he gets one last message...it's a [[ParanoiaFuel a photo of the exterior of his house and his computer in the window]]. And accompanying it, is this message...
-->'''Emily:''' FREEZING
9th Sep '17 9:56:49 PM zandercan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/The_Pill The Pill]] is probably the best CosmicHorrorStory on the wiki.
26th Aug '17 10:46:00 AM CantNotLookAtThisSite
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [[https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/3iex1h/im_a_search_and_rescue_officer_for_the_us_forest/ The Search And Rescue Series]] on reddit's nosleep. Told by a Search and Rescue officer revealing the aspects of his work he doesn't normally talk about, the series details such lovely subject matter as a woman climbing up a tree and vanishing without ever coming back down, an unknown creature pulling a WoundedGazelleGambit and imperfectly imitating a little girl's cry to lure in park rangers, a developmentally disabled boy, a missing boy's body recovered in perfect condition save for bizarre holes in the internal organs, and random staircases strewn throughout the woods that appear to be mini EldritchLocations in their own right. Sweet dreams, and don't go up the stairs.

to:

* [[https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/3iex1h/im_a_search_and_rescue_officer_for_the_us_forest/ The Search And Rescue Series]] on reddit's nosleep. Told by a Search and Rescue officer revealing the aspects of his work he doesn't normally talk about, the series details such lovely subject matter as a woman climbing up a tree and vanishing without ever coming back down, an unknown creature pulling a WoundedGazelleGambit and imperfectly imitating a little girl's cry to lure in park rangers, a developmentally disabled boy, a missing boy's body recovered in perfect condition save for bizarre holes in the internal organs, and random staircases strewn throughout the woods that appear to be mini EldritchLocations in their own right. Sweet dreams, and don't go up the stairs.stairs.
* ''[[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/The_Strangers The Strangers]]'' is a cautionary tale about a man whose curiosity gets the better of him one day while people-watching on the New York subway. He sees a man who looks normal in every way, but there's something odd about the man that the narrator just can't put his finger on. He ends up following the man and finds that he rides the subway all the way to the end, every day. He asks the middle aged man, called "The Stranger", what he's doing, and the Stranger simply replies "You won't be able to go back." At the next stop, a bunch of weird looking creatures board the train, and the narrator is absolutely terrified. [[spoiler:Turns out that the Stranger is a visitor from an alternate universe, who got trapped in our world, after becoming curious about another strange-looking person. The narrator has become the next in a long line of "Strangers", desperately trying to find their way home. The narrator finds himself slowly going insane as he travels up and down the line every day. The story itself is an ApocalypticLog written by the narrator, who leaves it on the train in the hope that it will some day make it back to our universe's New York. Apparently, it did...]]
* ''[[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/The_Disappearance_of_Ashley,_Kansas The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas]]'' is the curious tale of [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin the day the town of Ashley, Kansas, disappeared]]. The town is small and isolated, and doesn't even have its own police station. One night, all roads leading into Ashley end up becoming roads to nowhere, endlessly circling and never reaching Ashley. But that's not the scary part. [[spoiler:A woman calls the police frantically, saying "Last night they came back." The police officer on the other end tries to calm her and find out what's happening. She says she is hiding in the closet and mentions that her son died the previous year after being hit by a car. She tells the police officer that her son has returned to the world of the living, but he CameBackWrong, and he along with the rest of Ashley's dead are now looking for their loved ones. ''This is not a good thing.'' Whatever these things are, they burn every house they enter and kill the occupants [[NothingIsScarier in a way that is not identified]]. At the end of the phone call, the woman's son enters her house and kills her, laughing, "I found you, Mommy." When the police go to check on Ashley the following morning, they find nothing there, except [[{{Hellgate}} a smouldering fissure in the Earth.]]]]
26th Aug '17 8:08:36 AM CantNotLookAtThisSite
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** The author admits beneath the story that they wrote it when they were ''[[CreepyChild twelve years old]]''. Talk about a vivid imagination...
9th Aug '17 1:50:37 PM Ubu_Noir
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''[[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Anasi%27s_Goatman_Story Anasi's Goatman Story]]'': [[SirSwearsaLot Swearing]] aside, the story is about a group of teens who are terrorized by a skinwalker.

to:

* ''[[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Anasi%27s_Goatman_Story Anasi's com/wiki/Anansi%27s_Goatman_Story Anansi's Goatman Story]]'': [[SirSwearsaLot Swearing]] aside, the story is about a group of teens who are terrorized by a skinwalker.
8th Aug '17 8:21:14 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''[[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Unbranded_Laptop Unbranded Laptop]]'' is pure nightmare fuel in every sentence, with InfantImmortality ending with a little girl's first cut on her right cheek. What's worse is the final sentence, where the person watching the laptop will likely experience the same [[PsychicAssistedSuicide fate]].

to:

* ''[[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Unbranded_Laptop Unbranded Laptop]]'' is pure nightmare fuel in every sentence, with InfantImmortality ending with a little girl's first cut on her right cheek. What's worse is the final sentence, where the person watching the laptop will likely experience the same [[PsychicAssistedSuicide fate]].
31st Jul '17 9:28:10 AM TheCuza
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler:The narrator might not have any idea, but it should be fairly obvious to the reader: One man isn't much of a meal for a huge sea monster, but he sure makes good bait.]]
13th Jul '17 5:22:12 PM 3LionCubs
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* "World's Best School Psychologist" is another case of AdultFear gone mad. On March 23, 1993, a young student in junior high paid a visit to a psychologist, Dr. Tanner. He unloaded his emotional baggage concerning his parents, who were incredibly strict, harsh, and unloving toward him. Dr. Tanner requested that the boy return to his office at 4 PM without telling anyone. He promised that after a month, his situation would get better, since he was the [[TitleDrop world's best school psychologist.]] [[spoiler: At that meeting, Tanner drugs the boy and he wakes up in bedroom handcuffed to the bed, with a TV and NES set up nearby. Tanner explains that the boy will be staying at this house for a month, but he'll be allowed to play video games, eat, and watch TV. During school hours, he watched news reports about his disappearance and his parents desperately searching for him, showing emotion toward him for the first time in his life. At the end of the month, the charred, decapitated skeleton of a young teenager is found in a garbage bag under an overpass, which nearly sends the boy's parents over the DespairEventHorizon. That's when Tanner makes the boy promise not to tell anyone about what happened here. He then wakes up in a park and returns home to his parents, who are overjoyed to have their son back. The boy's life is happier, but one question remains: just who did Dr. Tanner throw over that overpass?]]

to:

* "World's Best School Psychologist" is another case of AdultFear gone mad. On March 23, 1993, a young student in junior high paid a visit to a psychologist, Dr. Tanner. He unloaded his emotional baggage concerning his parents, who were incredibly strict, harsh, and unloving toward him. Dr. Tanner requested that the boy return to his office at 4 PM without telling anyone. He promised that after a month, his situation would get better, since he was the [[TitleDrop world's best school psychologist.]] [[spoiler: At that meeting, Tanner drugs the boy and he wakes up in bedroom handcuffed to the bed, with a TV and NES set up nearby. Tanner explains that the boy will be staying at this house for a month, but he'll be allowed to play video games, eat, and watch TV. During school hours, he watched news reports about his disappearance and his parents desperately searching for him, showing emotion toward him for the first time in his life. At the end of the month, the charred, decapitated skeleton of a young teenager is found in a garbage bag under an overpass, which nearly sends the boy's parents over the DespairEventHorizon. That's when Tanner makes the boy promise not to tell anyone about what happened here. He then wakes up in a park and returns home to his parents, who are overjoyed to have their son back. The boy's life is happier, but one question remains: just who did Dr. Tanner throw over that overpass?]]overpass?]]
* [[https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/3iex1h/im_a_search_and_rescue_officer_for_the_us_forest/ The Search And Rescue Series]] on reddit's nosleep. Told by a Search and Rescue officer revealing the aspects of his work he doesn't normally talk about, the series details such lovely subject matter as a woman climbing up a tree and vanishing without ever coming back down, an unknown creature pulling a WoundedGazelleGambit and imperfectly imitating a little girl's cry to lure in park rangers, a developmentally disabled boy, a missing boy's body recovered in perfect condition save for bizarre holes in the internal organs, and random staircases strewn throughout the woods that appear to be mini EldritchLocations in their own right. Sweet dreams, and don't go up the stairs.
5th Jul '17 12:08:08 PM CJCroen1393
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* [[http://geosheas-lost-episodes.wikia.com/wiki/South_Park_Lost_Episode This]] ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark'' one becomes a mix of this and TearJerker when you [[FridgeHorror realize]] that [[spoiler:the woman committing suicide in the audio is most likely supposed to be Mary Kay Bergman...a former voice actress for most of the show's female characters who ''actually'' committed suicide in real life]].
22nd Jun '17 6:35:40 PM CJCroen1393
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Another lost episode one that's commonly overlooked would be [[http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Half-Baked_Sun_Cakes "Half-Baked Sun Cakes"]], one for ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic''. Though slightly more TearJerker than NightmareFuel, there's still an unnerving aspect to it. The story consists of the protagonist watching a "new" episode of the show he had never seen before and in it Twilight is preparing for a visit from Princess Celestia. Sounds innocent enough, but there's something very off about the episode--Twilight is the ''only'' character in it. She carries around a doll of Spike and talks to it like it's the real Spike and everyone else is completely absent. Despite this Twilight talks to blank walls and thin air as though they're her friends and indeed the episode plays out like they're ''supposed'' to be there, but aren't. At the end, Twilight sings a song with some truly odd lyrics considering the nature of the show ("Ave Maria!", "Birther of the son (sun?)", etc.). It then ends with Twilight's usual (at the time) friendship letter, which predictably the Spike doll never writes a word of because it's a doll. And then? Well...
-->Then, the creepiest goddamn thing happened: She stopped, and her face had this look of complete heartbreak. It was like when Pinkie Pie thought her friends didn’t want to come to her party. It was like your face the first time you finished “My Little Dashie.” She sat down, [[DespairEventHorizon a look of despair and ultimate sadness on her eyes, now watering]]. Sad stock music played in the background. [[LastOfHisKind The camera puled back, showing her sitting in empty Sugar Cube Corner, then fades to outside, still pulling back to show all of empty Ponyville, into the clouds.]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 426. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=NightmareFuel.CreepyPasta