Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / WeWillNotHaveAppendixesInTheFuture

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Some people are born with smaller wisdom teeth, or no wisdom teeth at all. The percentage that these people make out of the population also seems to be growing over time. Conversely, there are also people with a second set of wisdom teeth, as well as people with jaws large enough to actually fit all of their adult teeth.

to:

* Some people are born with smaller wisdom teeth, or no wisdom teeth at all. The percentage that these people make out of the population also seems to be growing over time. Conversely, there are also people with a second set of wisdom teeth, as well as people with jaws large enough to actually fit all of their adult teeth. \n It is also worth pointing out that while the appendix is no longer biological necessary, wisdom teeth are no longer necessary for primarily cultural reasons. Due to modern dentistry and tooth-care (like toothpaste and toothbrushes), most people don't lose their adult teeth (or can have those they lose replaced with a fake tooth). Wisdom teeth come in later in life as back-ups for lost adult teeth, but since we generally don't need them, we don't have the space to spare in our mouths and they end up just hurting and pushing our existing teeth out of alignment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In Mikhail Akhmanov and Christopher Gilmore's ''Captain French, or the Quest for Paradise'', the titular protagonist has 2000 years (subjective time) or 20,000 years (objective time) over his new wife, who is only in her 50s (but looks 20 thanks to the omnipresent cure for aging). The first thing he does after taking her onboard his ship is to have her examined by the ship's AutoDoc. The doc revealed something horrible to French - she still has an appendix. Angry at the carelessness of her home planet's religious fanatics, he has the AutoDoc remove the "offending organ" despite the fact that it there was ''nothing wrong with it''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn - it's still considered vestigial, but not necessarily useless. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. It's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs, but it does seem to serve at least a non-vital purpose. This is what we would expected from evolution; if you have something useless hanging around, it can be repurposed.

to:

A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial or even [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appendicitis outright self-destructive]] organ, but ScienceMarchesOn - it's still considered vestigial, but not necessarily useless. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. It's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs, but it does seem to serve at least a non-vital purpose. This is what we would expected from evolution; if you have something useless hanging around, it can be repurposed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
correcting a word choice for readability.


A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn - it's still considered vestigial, but not necessarily useless. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. It's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs, but it does seem to serve at least a non-vital purpose. This remains as expected by evolution; if you have something useless hanging around, it can be repurposed.

to:

A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn - it's still considered vestigial, but not necessarily useless. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. It's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs, but it does seem to serve at least a non-vital purpose. This remains as is what we would expected by from evolution; if you have something useless hanging around, it can be repurposed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Evolutionary note: the appendix remains vestigial; it\'s just been evolutionary repurposed


A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. It's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs, but it does seem to serve at least a non-vital purpose.

to:

A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn.ScienceMarchesOn - it's still considered vestigial, but not necessarily useless. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. It's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs, but it does seem to serve at least a non-vital purpose.
purpose. This remains as expected by evolution; if you have something useless hanging around, it can be repurposed.
Camacan MOD

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->"Hello, I am a useless pinky toe. Someday, you will be born without me."

to:

->"Hello, ->''"Hello, I am a useless pinky toe. Someday, you will be born without me.""''

Changed: 3

Removed: 139

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is actually a plot point in Asimov's ''EndOfEternity'', when two of the main characters, both time travelers, who were born three million years apart notice that the only difference between them is the lack of wisdom teeth and the lack of appendix in the one from the later time. They (perhaps hastily) draw the conclusion that [[KnightsTemplar Eternity]] was trying to prevent human evolution.

to:

** This is actually a plot point in Asimov's ''EndOfEternity'', ''TheEndOfEternity'', when two of the main characters, both time travelers, who were born three million years apart notice that the only difference between them is the lack of wisdom teeth and the lack of appendix in the one from the later time. They (perhaps hastily) draw the conclusion that [[KnightsTemplar Eternity]] was trying to prevent human evolution.



----
<<|TimeTravelTropes|>>
<<|SpeculativeFictionTropes|>>
<<|WeWillNotUseAnIndexInTheFuture|>>
<<|YouFailBiologyForever|>>
<<|HollywoodEvolution|>>

to:

----
<<|TimeTravelTropes|>>
<<|SpeculativeFictionTropes|>>
<<|WeWillNotUseAnIndexInTheFuture|>>
<<|YouFailBiologyForever|>>
<<|HollywoodEvolution|>>
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the DoctorWho VirginNewAdventures (a series of SpinOff novels during the series' long hiatus), the companions Chris Cwej and Roz Forrester have no appendices. They're from the 30th Century.

to:

* In the DoctorWho VirginNewAdventures (a series of SpinOff novels during the series' long hiatus), ''Series/DoctorWho'' [[VirginNewAdventures New Adventures]] spin-off novels, the companions Chris Cwej and Roz Forrester have no appendices. They're from the 30th Century.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's a children's show. The thought of amputating something as little as a toe would probably never get past network executives
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That sounds more like changes in cultural mores than in human physiology.


* Played with in ArthurCClarke's ''3001'', a woman who is [[RipVanWinkle Frank Poole's]] romantic interest is utterly disgusted when they finally become intimate [[CircumcisionAngst because he does not have a foreskin]]. That far in the future evidently no one is circumcised.

to:

* Played with in ArthurCClarke's ''3001'', a woman who is [[RipVanWinkle Frank Poole's]] romantic interest is utterly disgusted when they finally become intimate [[CircumcisionAngst because he does not have a foreskin]]. That far in the future evidently no one is circumcised.

Changed: 99

Removed: 371

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* H.G. Wells designed the Martians in ''War of the Worlds'' by turning this trope UpToEleven: he started from a humanoid body plan, then stripped off ''everything'' -- limbs, digestive tracts, sexual reproduction -- that he thought mechanization and/or medical technology could potentially make obsolete. All that he left them was a giant head, a few tendrils for pushing buttons, and the ability to breathe.

to:

* H.G. Wells designed the Martians in ''War of the Worlds'' by turning this trope UpToEleven: he started from a humanoid body plan, then stripped off ''everything'' -- limbs, digestive tracts, sexual reproduction -- that he thought mechanization and/or medical technology could potentially make obsolete. All that he left them was a giant head, a few tendrils for pushing buttons, and the ability to breathe. Instead of eating, they drain captured aliens and humans of blood and inject it into their bodies.



* This reasoning was the inspiration for the appearance of the Martians in WarOfTheWorlds. Their technology is so advanced that they no longer need anything other than their brains, mouths, and tentacles to operate said technology. Even their digestive systems have been replaced by machines that drain captured aliens and humans of blood and inject it into their bodies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Played with in ArthurCClarke's ''3001'', a woman who is [[RipVanWinkle Frank Poole's]] romantic interest is utterly disgusted when they finally become intimate [[CircumcisionAngst because he does not have a foreskin]]. That far in the future evidently no one is circumcised.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In GURPS TranshumanSpace No Appendix is an advantage that the Alpha genetic upgrade and Zisudra parahuman have, both templates are intended to be an "ideal" human.

to:

* In GURPS TranshumanSpace ''{{GURPS}}: TranshumanSpace'' No Appendix is an advantage that the Alpha genetic upgrade and Zisudra parahuman have, both templates are intended to be an "ideal" human.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* This reasoning was the inspiration for the appearance of the Martians in WarOfTheWorlds. Their technology is so advanced that they no longer need anything other than their brains, mouths, and tentacles to operate said technology. Even their digestive systems have been replaced by machines that drain captured aliens and humans of blood and inject it into their bodies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. Nonetheless, it's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs but it does seem to serve a purpose, if not a vital one.

to:

A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. Nonetheless, it's It's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs organs, but it does seem to serve at least a purpose, if not a vital one.
non-vital purpose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

***For those who never seen this episode, right after Homer says this, the camera points at the kids, who instead of being drawn in the Simpsons style, are drawn "horrifically" normal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Incidentally, shouldn't the plural of appendix be appendices?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the DoctorWho VirginNewAdventures (a series of SpinOff novels during the series' long hiatus), the companions Chris Cwej and Roz Forrester have no appendices. They're from the 30th Century.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The interesting thing about this trope in Asimov's works is that he is a biochemist; where, exactly, this trope pops up is purely a property of ScienceMarchesOn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added hyphen to Legion of Super-Heroes


* The LegionOfSuperheroes would have us believe that in 1,000 years humans will grow an ''extra heart''. Forgot the fact that an extra pump in our chest would cause more problems than it would solve.

to:

* The LegionOfSuperheroes {{Legion Of Super-Heroes}} would have us believe that in 1,000 years humans will grow an ''extra heart''. Forgot the fact that an extra pump in our chest would cause more problems than it would solve.

Added: 219

Changed: 970

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
the plural of \'appendix\' is always \'appendices\', anatomically or literarily.


[[FridgeLogic Never mind]] that it takes millions of years for significant evolution like that to occur and the fact animals like whales and snakes (specifically snakes like boas, pythons, and slender blind snakes) have had vestigial leg bones for so long that it's unlikely that humans would shrug off their own vestigial organs anytime within [[HollywoodEvolution a hundred thousand years]]. Especially since [[YouFailBiologyForever evolution is a result of natural selection]], and there isn't much evolutionary pressure against having an appendix. Of course, this trope can easily be justified through [[GeneticEngineeringIsTheNewNuke genetic modification]].

Or that if something is truly vestigial, there is no advantage in getting rid of it so evolution will be ''particularly'' slow in getting rid of vestigial organs if it gets rid of them at all. Whenever a feature becomes useless to an animal it tends to slowly disappear since genetic mutations that leads to its degeneration are not weeded out by natural selection. In short, evolution does not just create, it is also responsible for maintaining features that would otherwise be lost over time. To take the example of vestigial hip bones in a whale, even if said bones do not bother the whale, any whale born with degenerate leg bones would not be weeded out and so on... There is of course the issue of the resources, minor as they presumably are, that the animal uses to grow these useless bones; evolution therefore favors getting rid of them entirely, but the pressure is not very strong.

to:

[[FridgeLogic Never mind]] that it takes millions of years for significant evolution like that to occur and the fact animals like whales and snakes (specifically snakes like boas, pythons, and slender blind snakes) have had vestigial leg bones for so long that it's unlikely that humans would shrug off their own vestigial organs anytime within [[HollywoodEvolution a hundred thousand years]]. Especially since

[[YouFailBiologyForever evolution Evolution is a result of natural selection]], and there isn't much evolutionary pressure against having an appendix. Of course, this trope can easily be justified through [[GeneticEngineeringIsTheNewNuke genetic modification]].

Or that if
If something is truly vestigial, there is no little advantage in getting rid of it so evolution will be ''particularly'' slow in getting rid of vestigial organs organs, if it gets rid of them at all. Whenever a feature becomes useless to an animal it tends does tend to slowly disappear since genetic mutations that leads lead to its degeneration are not weeded out by natural selection. In short, evolution does not just create, it is also responsible for maintaining features that would otherwise be lost over time. To take the example of vestigial hip bones in a whale, even if said bones do not bother the whale, any whale born with degenerate leg bones would not be weeded out and so on... There is of course also the issue of the resources, minor as they presumably are, that the animal uses to grow these useless bones; evolution features; there is therefore favors getting rid of them entirely, some benefit to losing these vestiges, but there's not much in it.

Of course, this trope can easily be justified through [[GeneticEngineeringIsTheNewNuke genetic modification]] -
the pressure is not very strong.
appendix didn't ''naturally'' evolve away, humans simply altered their own genome to weed out the junk.



Do not confuse with {{We Will Not Use An Index in the Future}}, although that would probably illustrate the error of [[GrammarNazi misspelling]] "[[HypocriticalHumor appendices]]." Also see WeWillHavePerfectHealthInTheFuture.

to:

Do not confuse with {{We Will Not Use An Index in the Future}}, although that would probably illustrate the error of [[GrammarNazi misspelling]] "[[HypocriticalHumor appendices]]." Future}}. Also see WeWillHavePerfectHealthInTheFuture.
WeWillHavePerfectHealthInTheFuture and EvolutionaryLevels.

Added: 128

Changed: 209

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While it is not employed in Part 3 of ''The Gods Themselves'', the eugenics-conscious moon government ''wants'' to use genetic engineering to get rid of various vestigial organs including wisdom teeth.

to:

** While it is not employed in Part 3 of ''The Gods Themselves'', the eugenics-conscious moon government ''wants'' to use genetic engineering to get rid of various vestigial organs including wisdom teeth.they consider unnecessary, like molars (the artificial food of the Moon requires little chewing).




to:

* ''[[PhilipJoseFarmer The Wind Whales of Ishmael]]'' features a race of four toed future people.
* The Hive Series by {{T J Bass}} features a race of Nebish - four feet tall, four toes, pink blood due to lack of hemoglobin...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This trope was facetiously employed in ''PhilOfTheFuture'' when Phil ran into a problem: he would have to be seen barefoot to stamp tomatoes in a farm on a class trip, but in his time, no one has pinky toes. To quote Phil's mother "They won't lose their pinky toes for another 70 years." Ironically, pinky toes are actually used for balance.

to:

* This trope was facetiously employed in ''PhilOfTheFuture'' when Phil ran into a problem: he would have to be seen barefoot to stamp tomatoes in a farm on a class trip, but in his time, no one has pinky toes. To quote Phil's mother [[SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale "They won't lose their pinky toes for another 70 years." "]] Ironically, pinky toes are actually used for balance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[FridgeLogic Couldn't he just say that he lost them in an accident, or something?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[FridgeLogic Never mind]] that it takes millions of years for significant evolution like that to occur and the fact animals like whales and snakes have had vestigial leg bones for so long that it's unlikely that humans would shrug off their own vestigial organs anytime within [[HollywoodEvolution a hundred thousand years]]. Especially since [[YouFailBiologyForever evolution is a result of natural selection]], and there isn't much evolutionary pressure against having an appendix. Of course, this trope can easily be justified through [[GeneticEngineeringIsTheNewNuke genetic modification]].

to:

[[FridgeLogic Never mind]] that it takes millions of years for significant evolution like that to occur and the fact animals like whales and snakes (specifically snakes like boas, pythons, and slender blind snakes) have had vestigial leg bones for so long that it's unlikely that humans would shrug off their own vestigial organs anytime within [[HollywoodEvolution a hundred thousand years]]. Especially since [[YouFailBiologyForever evolution is a result of natural selection]], and there isn't much evolutionary pressure against having an appendix. Of course, this trope can easily be justified through [[GeneticEngineeringIsTheNewNuke genetic modification]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Parodied in ''DrKatzProfessionalTherapist'': when Ben is due to have his wisdom teeth removes, Laura mentions she never had them, which her dentist attributed to her being "more evolved". They end up getting into an argument over the veracity of the statement.

to:

* Parodied in ''DrKatzProfessionalTherapist'': when Ben is due to have his wisdom teeth removes, removed, Laura mentions she never had them, which her dentist attributed to her being "more evolved". They end up getting into an argument over the veracity of the statement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:RealLife]]

to:

[[AC:RealLife]][[AC:TruthInTelevision?]]

Changed: 1398

Removed: 1416

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More cleanup


Not to mention that future medical technology might become so powerful and universal as to eliminate disease-based natural selection pressure on humans.

Or that if something is truly vestigial, there is no advantage in getting rid of it so evolution will be ''particularly'' slow in getting rid of vestigial organs if it gets rid of them at all. Whenever a feature becomes useless to an animal it tends to slowly disappear since genetic mutations that leads to its degeneration are not weeded out by natural selection. In short, evolution does not just create, it is also responsible for maintaining features that would otherwise be lost over time. To take the example of vestigial hip bones in a whale, even if said bones do not bother the whale, any whale born with degenerate leg bones would not be weeded out and so on and so on... As a rule, this tends to happen fairly quickly so if you still have a so-called 'vestigial' organ it probably isn't that vestigial. The law of numbers does a bit to counter this: even a mildly ''advantageous'' mutation is far more likely to die out than to spread to the general population: an allele that confers a 2% fitness advantage still has a 96% chance of disappearing after a few generations. "Quickly" is still on the timescale of ''evolution'' and to give a hint as to the timetable of evolution, humans still carry reminders of our pre-mammalian ancestors, such as a tiny vestigial third eyelid that is only found in its active form on reptiles and some birds. Mammals split from reptiles over a hundred million years ago.

to:

Not to mention that future medical technology might become so powerful and universal as to eliminate disease-based natural selection pressure on humans.

Or that if something is truly vestigial, there is no advantage in getting rid of it so evolution will be ''particularly'' slow in getting rid of vestigial organs if it gets rid of them at all. Whenever a feature becomes useless to an animal it tends to slowly disappear since genetic mutations that leads to its degeneration are not weeded out by natural selection. In short, evolution does not just create, it is also responsible for maintaining features that would otherwise be lost over time. To take the example of vestigial hip bones in a whale, even if said bones do not bother the whale, any whale born with degenerate leg bones would not be weeded out and so on and so on... As a rule, this tends to happen fairly quickly so if you still have a so-called 'vestigial' organ it probably isn't There is of course the issue of the resources, minor as they presumably are, that vestigial. The law of numbers does a bit to counter this: even a mildly ''advantageous'' mutation is far more likely to die out than to spread to the general population: an allele that confers a 2% fitness advantage still has a 96% chance animal uses to grow these useless bones; evolution therefore favors getting rid of disappearing after a few generations. "Quickly" is still on them entirely, but the timescale of ''evolution'' and to give a hint as to the timetable of evolution, humans still carry reminders of our pre-mammalian ancestors, such as a tiny vestigial third eyelid that pressure is only found in its active form on reptiles and some birds. Mammals split from reptiles over a hundred million years ago.
not very strong.



* Some people are born with smaller wisdom teeth, or no wisdom teeth at all. The percentage that these people make out of the population also seems to be growing over time. Conversely, there are also people with a second set of wisdom teeth, as well as people with jaws large enough to actually fit all of their adult teeth.
* The vestigal hip bones in whales, embedded in flesh and disconnected from the skeleton is a good example of, "Since they don't hinder the organism, then there is no evolutionary pressure for removal." So the bones are still there, totally neutral as far as the animal is concerned. There is of course the issue of the resources, minor as they presumably are, that the animal uses to grow these useless bones; evolution therefore favors getting rid of them entirely, but the pressure is not very strong.

to:

* Some people are born with smaller wisdom teeth, or no wisdom teeth at all. The percentage that these people make out of the population also seems to be growing over time. Conversely, there are also people with a second set of wisdom teeth, as well as people with jaws large enough to actually fit all of their adult teeth.
* The vestigal hip bones in whales, embedded in flesh and disconnected from the skeleton is a good example of, "Since they don't hinder the organism, then there is no evolutionary pressure for removal." So the bones are still there, totally neutral as far as the animal is concerned. There is of course the issue of the resources, minor as they presumably are, that the animal uses to grow these useless bones; evolution therefore favors getting rid of them entirely, but the pressure is not very strong.
teeth.

Added: 945

Changed: 2618

Removed: 4300

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter... noooo...


[[FridgeLogic Never mind]] that it takes millions of years for significant evolution like that to occur and the fact animals like whales and snakes have had vestigial leg bones for so long that it's unlikely that humans would shrug off their own vestigial organs anytime within [[HollywoodEvolution a hundred thousand years]]. Especially since [[YouFailBiologyForever evolution is a result of natural selection]], and humanity likely won't face a mass extinction of people with appendixes anytime soon. Of course, this trope can easily be justified through [[GeneticEngineeringIsTheNewNuke genetic modification]].

to:

[[FridgeLogic Never mind]] that it takes millions of years for significant evolution like that to occur and the fact animals like whales and snakes have had vestigial leg bones for so long that it's unlikely that humans would shrug off their own vestigial organs anytime within [[HollywoodEvolution a hundred thousand years]]. Especially since [[YouFailBiologyForever evolution is a result of natural selection]], and humanity likely won't face a mass extinction of people with appendixes anytime soon.there isn't much evolutionary pressure against having an appendix. Of course, this trope can easily be justified through [[GeneticEngineeringIsTheNewNuke genetic modification]].



Or that if something is truly vestigial, there is no advantage in getting rid of it so evolution will be ''particularly'' slow in getting rid of vestigial organs if it gets rid of them at all.

A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. To be fair, though, it's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs.

[[http://science.discovery.com/top-ten/2008/organs/organs.html Here is a list of 10 human vestigial organs.]]

Do not confuse with {{We Will Not Use An Index in the Future}}, although that would probably illustrate the error of [[GrammarNazi misspelling]] "[[HypocriticalHumor appendices]]". Also see WeWillHavePerfectHealthInTheFuture.

to:

Or that if something is truly vestigial, there is no advantage in getting rid of it so evolution will be ''particularly'' slow in getting rid of vestigial organs if it gets rid of them at all.

all. Whenever a feature becomes useless to an animal it tends to slowly disappear since genetic mutations that leads to its degeneration are not weeded out by natural selection. In short, evolution does not just create, it is also responsible for maintaining features that would otherwise be lost over time. To take the example of vestigial hip bones in a whale, even if said bones do not bother the whale, any whale born with degenerate leg bones would not be weeded out and so on and so on... As a rule, this tends to happen fairly quickly so if you still have a so-called 'vestigial' organ it probably isn't that vestigial. The law of numbers does a bit to counter this: even a mildly ''advantageous'' mutation is far more likely to die out than to spread to the general population: an allele that confers a 2% fitness advantage still has a 96% chance of disappearing after a few generations. "Quickly" is still on the timescale of ''evolution'' and to give a hint as to the timetable of evolution, humans still carry reminders of our pre-mammalian ancestors, such as a tiny vestigial third eyelid that is only found in its active form on reptiles and some birds. Mammals split from reptiles over a hundred million years ago.

A note on the appendix itself: The appendix has historically been thought a useless, vestigial organ, but ScienceMarchesOn. In the last few years scientists have begun to suspect that it is actually important to the body, as a reservoir of the "good bacteria" species that populate the colon and are necessary for digestion. When the colon's population is thrown out of whack by infection, diarrhea, or the like, the bacteria "hiding" in the appendix can recolonize it and return the necessary balance. There are also suggestions that this reservoir is used in training the immune system of babies and young children. To be fair, though, Nonetheless, it's still a lot easier to live without one than it is to live without any of your other organs.

[[http://science.discovery.com/top-ten/2008/organs/organs.html Here is
organs but it does seem to serve a list of 10 human vestigial organs.]]

purpose, if not a vital one.

Do not confuse with {{We Will Not Use An Index in the Future}}, although that would probably illustrate the error of [[GrammarNazi misspelling]] "[[HypocriticalHumor appendices]]". appendices]]." Also see WeWillHavePerfectHealthInTheFuture.



** Well, it doesn't seem to slow [[DoctorWho the Doctor]] down.
*** To be fair, the Doctor's got a [[http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/3a/Bicardial.jpg binary vascular system]], which is probably normal for Time Lords. A second heart in a vascular system like ours would be a bad idea.
*** If you want to get technical, since a heart is just a pump for blood, all mammals and birds have two hearts as a result of their [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vascular_system#Nonhuman double circulatory system]], the hearts just happen to be right next to each other.
** Or the [[{{Warhammer40000}} Adeptus Astartes]].

to:

** Well, it doesn't seem to slow [[DoctorWho the Doctor]] down.
*** To be fair, the Doctor's got a [[http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/3a/Bicardial.jpg binary vascular system]], which is probably normal for Time Lords. A second heart in a vascular system like ours would be a bad idea.
*** If you want to get technical, since a heart is just a pump for blood, all mammals and birds have two hearts as a result of their [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vascular_system#Nonhuman double circulatory system]], the hearts just happen to be right next to each other.
** Or the [[{{Warhammer40000}} Adeptus Astartes]].



* This trope was facetiously employed in ''PhilOfTheFuture'' when Phil ran into a problem: he would have to be seen barefoot to stamp tomatoes in a farm on a class trip, but in his time, no one has pinky toes.
** And how. Quote Phil's mother "They won't lose their pinky toes for another 70 years."
** [[FridgeLogic Couldn't he just have said it was a birth defect or something?]]
*** It kinda seems like a BrokenAesop about being normal when you think about it.
** Ironically, pinky toes are actually used for balance, if TheOtherWiki is correct.
** [[FridgeLogic Also, who stares at people's feet that closely?]]
*** [[FetishFuel Who, indeed?]]

to:

* This trope was facetiously employed in ''PhilOfTheFuture'' when Phil ran into a problem: he would have to be seen barefoot to stamp tomatoes in a farm on a class trip, but in his time, no one has pinky toes.
** And how. Quote
toes. To quote Phil's mother "They won't lose their pinky toes for another 70 years."
** [[FridgeLogic Couldn't he just have said it was a birth defect or something?]]
*** It kinda seems like a BrokenAesop about being normal when you think about it.
**
" Ironically, pinky toes are actually used for balance, if TheOtherWiki is correct.
** [[FridgeLogic Also, who stares at people's feet that closely?]]
*** [[FetishFuel Who, indeed?]]
balance.



[[AC:TableTopGames]]
* In GURPS TranshumanSpace No Appendix is an advantage that the Alpha genetic upgrade and Zisudra parahuman have, both templates are intended to be an "ideal" human.

[[AC:WesternAnimation]]
* Parodied in ''DrKatzProfessionalTherapist'': when Ben is due to have his wisdom teeth removes, Laura mentions she never had them, which her dentist attributed to her being "more evolved". They end up getting into an argument over the veracity of the statement.
* Also parodied in ''TheSimpsons'', where a news report says that scientists predict people will evolve an additional finger in the future. Characters on the show, of course, have only three fingers and a thumb on each hand.
** In the episode Lady Bouvier's Lover, Homer is worried that Abe marrying Marge's mother would make him and Marge brother and sister, and as a result turn the kids into "...horrible freaks with pink skin, no overbites, and five fingers on each hand!"



* Some people are born with smaller wisdom teeth, or no wisdom teeth at all. The percentage that these people make out of the population also seems to be growing over time.
** There are also people with a second set of wisdom teeth.
** And people with jaws large enough to actually fit all of their adult teeth.
* The vestigal hip bones in whales, embedded in flesh and disconnected from the skeleton are a good example of, 'Since they don't hinder the organism, then there is no evolutionary pressure for removal''. So the bones are still there, totally neutral as far as the animal is concerned.
** There is of course the issue of the resources, minor as they presumably are, that the animal uses to grow these useless bones; evolution therefore favors getting rid of them entirely, but the pressure is not very strong.
** Whenever a feature becomes useless to an animal it tends to slowly disappear since genetic mutations that leads to its degeneration are not weeded out by natural selection. In short, evolution does not just create, it is also responsible for maintaining features that would otherwise be lost over time. Even if said bones do not bother the whale, any whale born with degenerate leg bones would not be weeded out and so on and so on... As a rule, this tends to happen fairly quickly so if you still have a so-called 'vestigial' organ it probably isn't that vestigial.
** The law of numbers does a bit to counter this: even a mildly ''advantageous'' mutation is far more likely to die out than to spread to the general population: an allele that confers a 2% fitness advantage still has a 96% chance of disappearing after a few generations. "Quickly" is still on the timescale of ''evolution''.
** To give a hint as to the timetable of evolution, humans still carry reminders of our pre-mammalian ancestors, such as a tiny vestigial third eyelid that is only found in its active form on reptiles and some birds. Mammals split from reptiles over a hundred million years ago.
* Most "vestigial" organs and parts are really "spandrels" in evolutionary theory parlance. Parts which once served one purpose, but now serve another (or which may still be useful for the original thing, but became multi-functional). Like the human tailbone was once part of a tail, but is now used to anchor some butt muscles. Not useless, but not used for the "original" purpose. Evolution tends to often result in life "recycling" parts which are already present.

[[AC:TableTopGames]]
* In GURPS TranshumanSpace No Appendix is an advantage that the Alpha genetic upgrade and Zisudra parahuman have, both templates are intended to be an "ideal" human.

[[AC:WesternAnimation]]
* Parodied in ''DrKatzProfessionalTherapist'': when Ben is due to have his wisdom teeth removes, Laura mentions she never had them, which her dentist attributed to her being "more evolved". They end up getting into an argument over the veracity of the statement.
* Also parodied in ''TheSimpsons'', where a news report says that scientists predict people will evolve an additional finger in the future. Characters on the show, of course, have only three fingers and a thumb on each hand.
** In the episode Lady Bouvier's Lover, Homer is worried that Abe marrying Marge's mother would make him and Marge brother and sister, and as a result turn the kids into "...horrible freaks with pink skin, no overbites, and five fingers on each hand!"

to:

* Some people are born with smaller wisdom teeth, or no wisdom teeth at all. The percentage that these people make out of the population also seems to be growing over time.
** There
time. Conversely, there are also people with a second set of wisdom teeth.
** And
teeth, as well as people with jaws large enough to actually fit all of their adult teeth.
* The vestigal hip bones in whales, embedded in flesh and disconnected from the skeleton are is a good example of, 'Since "Since they don't hinder the organism, then there is no evolutionary pressure for removal''. removal." So the bones are still there, totally neutral as far as the animal is concerned.
**
concerned. There is of course the issue of the resources, minor as they presumably are, that the animal uses to grow these useless bones; evolution therefore favors getting rid of them entirely, but the pressure is not very strong.
** Whenever a feature becomes useless to an animal it tends to slowly disappear since genetic mutations that leads to its degeneration are not weeded out by natural selection. In short, evolution does not just create, it is also responsible for maintaining features that would otherwise be lost over time. Even if said bones do not bother the whale, any whale born with degenerate leg bones would not be weeded out and so on and so on... As a rule, this tends to happen fairly quickly so if you still have a so-called 'vestigial' organ it probably isn't that vestigial.
** The law of numbers does a bit to counter this: even a mildly ''advantageous'' mutation is far more likely to die out than to spread to the general population: an allele that confers a 2% fitness advantage still has a 96% chance of disappearing after a few generations. "Quickly" is still on the timescale of ''evolution''.
** To give a hint as to the timetable of evolution, humans still carry reminders of our pre-mammalian ancestors, such as a tiny vestigial third eyelid that is only found in its active form on reptiles and some birds. Mammals split from reptiles over a hundred million years ago.
* Most "vestigial" organs and parts are really "spandrels" in evolutionary theory parlance. Parts which once served one purpose, but now serve another (or which may still be useful for the original thing, but became multi-functional). Like the human tailbone was once part of a tail, but is now used to anchor some butt muscles. Not useless, but not used for the "original" purpose. Evolution tends to often result in life "recycling" parts which are already present.

[[AC:TableTopGames]]
* In GURPS TranshumanSpace No Appendix is an advantage that the Alpha genetic upgrade and Zisudra parahuman have, both templates are intended to be an "ideal" human.

[[AC:WesternAnimation]]
* Parodied in ''DrKatzProfessionalTherapist'': when Ben is due to have his wisdom teeth removes, Laura mentions she never had them, which her dentist attributed to her being "more evolved". They end up getting into an argument over the veracity of the statement.
* Also parodied in ''TheSimpsons'', where a news report says that scientists predict people will evolve an additional finger in the future. Characters on the show, of course, have only three fingers and a thumb on each hand.
** In the episode Lady Bouvier's Lover, Homer is worried that Abe marrying Marge's mother would make him and Marge brother and sister, and as a result turn the kids into "...horrible freaks with pink skin, no overbites, and five fingers on each hand!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It kinda seems like a BrokenAesop about being normal when you think about it.

Top