Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TheyWouldCutYouUp

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''TheDailyShow'' spoofs this with a John Oliver story about two politicians who decided to campaign together while running against each other to send a message of civility. The story ends on an homage to ''[[ETTheExtraTerrestrial E.T.]],'' with Jon Stewart playing the part of the evil scientist.

Added: 500

Changed: 535

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the panned sequel, {{Starship Troopers}}:Hero of The Federation, former {{Jerkass}} Lieutenant Pavlov Dill uses these exact words when he finds the finds that the rest of the soldiers (all infected by mind-control Control Bugs) have infected Gen. Shepherd with the Arachnid's plan being to send him back to the Federation so he can infect other Federation Leaders and take over the world. His threats are cut short when another infected soldier slowly walks behind him and slits his throat, making it {{Redemption Equals Death}}:
** Pavlov: "You bastards...you are all under arrest for murder, sedition, for treason against the Federation. Oh! Your going to pay...because we're not going to kill you...oh no...you see, we got special places for things like you...where they cut you up, but they keep you alive when they cut you up...so they can see what makes you tick, and they what makes you sick! And I will be there, oh yeah! I'm going to be there when they see ACK!" (threat cut short by infected soldier cutting his throat).

Added: 350

Changed: 139

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Riley also seemed to think this is what would happen to him if the Initiative gets hold of him again, even though they're presumably known where he is the whole time. Of course, the rel reason they're trying to bring him in is to remove his modifications, which are causing severe mental and physical breakdown, so he's not exactly being rational.



* The Japanese did this to Prisoners of War and Chinese civilians during [[WorldWarTwo World War 2]], and to make it worse, [[HighOctaneNightmareFuel they didn't use any anesthetics on the patients when they were dissected]]
* Vivisection, dissection while awake. It's often used on animals (not that that's any less horrid), but has also been used on humans.

to:

* The Japanese did this to Prisoners of War and Chinese civilians during [[WorldWarTwo World War 2]], and to make it worse, [[HighOctaneNightmareFuel they didn't use any anesthetics on the patients when they were dissected]]
* Vivisection, dissection while awake. It's often used on animals (not that that's any less horrid), but has also been used on humans.
vivisected]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The talking racoon, Woo, of ''SandraAndWoo'' mentions this when he first reveals this gift to Sandra, saying that he's kinda' attached to his vocal cords, and asking her to keep it quiet. The danger is never mentioned again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Vivisection, dissection while awake. It's often used on animals (not that that's any less horrid), but has also been used on humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In a ''LoisAndClark'' episode, Lois travels to an AlternateUniverse where Clark never became Superman due to his adoptive parents dying when he was little. His fiancée keeps berating him using this trope as a warning whenever he covertly uses his powers to save people. This world has also [[CrapsackWorld gone to hell]] after the arrival of Tempus, who gets himself elected President and removes all gun regulations. Cue the chaos. Fortunately, Lois fixes the situation by making Clark a suit identical to her Clark's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The reason that Nancy, heroine of LoisDuncan's AGiftOfMagic, gives for wanting to keep her psychic powers a secret. She's isn't afraid of being dissected, but she is afraid of being dragged off by the government and being turned into a lab rat. [[spoiler: The government already knows about her powers and respects her right to keep them to herself if that's what she wants.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sadly, there is some TruthInTelevision here (there is a long and dark history of [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_experimentation#Human_vivisection human subject research]] and the early days of biological science can best be summed up with "let's see how many needles we can stick in this dog before it stops making noises out of its mouth!") But this trope doesn't exactly show a fair or accurate portrayal of ''modern'' science. Currently, in RealLife, scientists have to follow ''very'' strict ethical testing standards to be able to publish their results. Getting caught violating them can easily end their careers. Of course, these considerations only apply to scientists who ''intend'' their results to be publicly documented (e.g. secret military projects aren't). Crime is only punishable if one is ''caught''. Further theories should be directed to NoDelaysForTheWicked. (Naturally, none of this applies to the [[GovernmentConspiracy various black ops]] organizations that either suspect -- or already know about -- TheMasquerade.)

to:

Sadly, there is some TruthInTelevision here (there is a long and dark history of [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_experimentation#Human_vivisection human subject research]] and the early days of biological science can best be summed up with "let's see how many needles we can stick in this dog before it stops making noises out of its mouth!") But this trope doesn't exactly show a fair or accurate portrayal of ''modern'' science. Currently, in RealLife, scientists have to follow ''very'' strict ethical testing standards to be able to publish their results. Getting caught violating them can easily end their careers. Of course, these considerations only apply to scientists who ''intend'' their results to be publicly documented (e.g. secret military projects aren't). [[NotCheatingUnlessYouGetCaught Crime is only punishable if one is ''caught''.caught]]. Further theories should be directed to NoDelaysForTheWicked. (Naturally, none of this applies to the [[GovernmentConspiracy various black ops]] organizations that either suspect -- or already know about -- TheMasquerade.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In a less extreme example, the main character of ''KyleXY'' keeps his abilities a secret because he wants to live a normal life, rather than spending all his days being tested by scientists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Toyed with in ''HarvestMoon DS.'' Local MadScientist Daryl has been chasing the strange creature Mukumuku for ''years'' in an attempt to figure out how it works, and given the long and fantastic family history of genetic experimentation he brags of, it seems ItRunsInTheFamily. So when chance favors him, and he happens upon an injured [[OurMermaidsAreDifferent mermaid girl?]] He takes her home to his basement, and... [[MoralityPet diligently cares for her until she recovers.]] And if you befriend said mermaid, she ''openly chastises you'' for daring to think Daryl would experiment on her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Original comment for farscape was incorrect


** Ironically, when the crew actually does arrive on Earth, they're all treated as honored dignitaries and celebrities. Although it's somewhat implied that this is because Crichton knew how to manage the situation, not that humans were actually better than the previous episode had given them credit for being.

to:

** Ironically, when the crew actually does arrive on Earth, they're all treated as honored dignitaries and celebrities. Although it's somewhat implied that this is because Moya arrived at Earth several weeks before Crichton knew how to manage the situation, not did (Note that Crichton's father and several other humans were already aboard when Crichton steps out) so the aliens actually better than the previous episode had given them credit for being.managed to do fine by themselves.

Changed: 132

Removed: 131

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This is one of the reasons the sheriff gives for bringing the recently discovered "bat boy" to the local vet:
-->"I didn't know where else to take him...Can't go to jail, he's underage.\\
Folks up at the Med School, bet they'd carve him up or bake him. \\
I'd send the FBI a page, but I don't think we're at that stage."

to:

* This In ''BatBoyTheMusical'', this is one of the reasons the sheriff gives for bringing the recently discovered "bat boy" to the local vet:
-->"I didn't know where else to take him...Can't go to jail, he's underage.\\
Folks up at the Med School, bet they'd carve him up or bake him. \\
I'd send the FBI a page, but I don't think we're at that stage."
vet, rather than somewhere else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:{{Theater}}]]
* This is one of the reasons the sheriff gives for bringing the recently discovered "bat boy" to the local vet:
-->"I didn't know where else to take him...Can't go to jail, he's underage.\\
Folks up at the Med School, bet they'd carve him up or bake him. \\
I'd send the FBI a page, but I don't think we're at that stage."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
they weren't actually Rangers yet, they'd just got the gem abilities


** The irony of course being that they're suffering from WrongGenreSavvy. Several teams of Power Rangers operate openly, and it's unlikely that Lightspeed would allow the goverment to experiment on other power rangers given the generally brotherhood like nature of the Rangers.
Camacan MOD

Changed: 158

Removed: 125

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Move extra quote to the quotes page.


->''"I can't let ANYONE else find out [about my powers]. Not even my parents. I know the chemical plant wants to find me, and turn me into some experiment!"''
-->--'''[[TheSecretWorldOfAlexMack Alex Mack]]''' gets to the nitty gritty of this trope in the OpeningNarration of her show.

to:

->''"I can't let ANYONE else find out [about my powers]. Not even my parents. I know the chemical plant wants to find me, and turn me into some experiment!"''
-->--'''[[TheSecretWorldOfAlexMack Alex Mack]]''' gets to the nitty gritty of this trope in the OpeningNarration of her show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The {{Planetary}}/[[JusticeLeagueOfAmerica JLA]] crossover oneshot is set in an alternate reality where the Planetary organization controls the advancement of science and technology the world over. By the time of the story, they've ''already'' cut up [[TheFlash Barry Allen]] and Ray Palmer (the Atom) in order to create super-fast couriers and shrinking technology for Fantastic Voyage-style medical procedures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What Wolfram & Hart want to do with Connor in ''{{Angel}}''.

to:

* What Wolfram & Hart want to do with Connor in ''{{Angel}}''. Given that the main thing that separates him from the many people with superpowers in the world is that he's a focus of prophecy (presumably ones that will be defunct if they kill him) it seems a bit of a waste.

Added: 328

Changed: 84

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Especially since Henry van Staten does it to him in 'Dalek' in an earlier season.
** And then Torchwood get their hands on him. [[spoiler:And promptly avert things; the squad with trained guns ''lower'' them and applaud, and while he's captive he's told he'd be kept comfortable, and is in no way actually restricted. The Doctor proceeds to ... act civilised (aside from breaking a window to make a point).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The Japanese did this to Prisoners of War and Chinese civilians during [[WorldWarTwo World War 2]], and to make it worse, [[HighOctaneNightmareFuel they didn't use any anesthetics on the patients when they were dissected]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
typo


* Asimov also wrote an SF version of the Golden Goose story (''Pâté de Foie Gras'') which subverted this. Even though it's just a goose, the government scientists were extremely careful not to harm it, and were terrified when it developed a fever.

to:

* Asimov also wrote an SF version of the Golden Goose story (''Pâté (''Pâté de Foie Gras'') which subverted this. Even though it's just a goose, the government scientists were extremely careful not to harm it, and were terrified when it developed a fever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If [[GovernmentConspiracy the authorities]] got [[CapturedSuperBeing their hands on them]], they'd [[PoundsAreDoggyPrison stick them in a concrete box]] and [[PlayingWithSyringes perform all sorts of cruel experiments]] to find out what makes them and/or their special powers tick, either [[WhatMeasureIsANonHuman destroying their quality of life, or killing them outright]]. Scientists will usually be portrayed as [[ForScience too obsessed to care]] for anyone or anything who might be used to further our knowledge of the universe or make a cool new weapon, caring only about the fame or payment they'll receive from their higher-ups. Only one bad scientist is quite enough to spoil your day, but in [[DarkerAndEdgier settings that use this trope]] the ''majority'' of encountered research workers are likely to be like this.

to:

If [[GovernmentConspiracy the authorities]] got [[CapturedSuperBeing their hands on them]], them, they'd [[PoundsAreDoggyPrison stick them in a concrete box]] and [[PlayingWithSyringes perform all sorts of cruel experiments]] to find out what makes them and/or their special powers tick, either [[WhatMeasureIsANonHuman destroying their quality of life, or killing them outright]]. outright]] in hopes of getting [[CapturedSuperEntity all sorts of goodies.]] Scientists will usually be portrayed as [[ForScience too obsessed to care]] for anyone or anything who might be used to further our knowledge of the universe or make a cool new weapon, caring only about the fame or payment they'll receive from their higher-ups. Only one bad scientist is quite enough to spoil your day, but in [[DarkerAndEdgier settings that use this trope]] the ''majority'' of encountered research workers are likely to be like this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If [[GovernmentConspiracy the authorities]] got their hands on them, they'd [[PoundsAreDoggyPrison stick them in a concrete box]] and [[PlayingWithSyringes perform all sorts of cruel experiments]] to find out what makes them and/or their special powers tick, either [[WhatMeasureIsANonHuman destroying their quality of life, or killing them outright]]. Scientists will usually be portrayed as [[ForScience too obsessed to care]] for anyone or anything who might be used to further our knowledge of the universe or make a cool new weapon, caring only about the fame or payment they'll receive from their higher-ups. Only one bad scientist is quite enough to spoil your day, but in [[DarkerAndEdgier settings that use this trope]] the ''majority'' of encountered research workers are likely to be like this.

to:

If [[GovernmentConspiracy the authorities]] got [[CapturedSuperBeing their hands on them, them]], they'd [[PoundsAreDoggyPrison stick them in a concrete box]] and [[PlayingWithSyringes perform all sorts of cruel experiments]] to find out what makes them and/or their special powers tick, either [[WhatMeasureIsANonHuman destroying their quality of life, or killing them outright]]. Scientists will usually be portrayed as [[ForScience too obsessed to care]] for anyone or anything who might be used to further our knowledge of the universe or make a cool new weapon, caring only about the fame or payment they'll receive from their higher-ups. Only one bad scientist is quite enough to spoil your day, but in [[DarkerAndEdgier settings that use this trope]] the ''majority'' of encountered research workers are likely to be like this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted: When [[ReasonableAuthorityFigure Special Agent Axel Hughes finds out that Joey is the KidWithTheRemoteControl for ''{{Heroman}}'', Joey asks him what's going to happen to him. "The U.S. Government is going to lock you away and do experiments on you for the rest of your life." Upon the look of horror on Joey's face, Axel laughs and tells him, that ''no''; a friendly alliance is more beneficial for everyone. "You really thought we were going to do that?"

to:

* Averted: When [[ReasonableAuthorityFigure Special Agent Axel Hughes Hughes]] finds out that Joey is the KidWithTheRemoteControl for ''{{Heroman}}'', Joey asks him what's going to happen to him. "The U.S. Government is going to lock you away and do experiments on you for the rest of your life." Upon the look of horror on Joey's face, Axel laughs and tells him, that ''no''; a friendly alliance is more beneficial for everyone. "You really thought we were going to do that?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Averted: When [[ReasonableAuthorityFigure Special Agent Axel Hughes finds out that Joey is the KidWithTheRemoteControl for ''{{Heroman}}'', Joey asks him what's going to happen to him. "The U.S. Government is going to lock you away and do experiments on you for the rest of your life." Upon the look of horror on Joey's face, Axel laughs and tells him, that ''no''; a friendly alliance is more beneficial for everyone. "You really thought we were going to do that?"

Added: 290

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Subverted in ''SingularitySky'' when an ignorant citizen if a backwater world asks a SufficientlyAdvancedAlien for a goose that lays golden eggs. No-one thinks about how it works until they start suffering radiation sickness... transmutation in real life is a nuclear process, after all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: Real Life]]
* Nazis would do this to minorities among other things, that's why Mengele is known as Angel of death...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''PushingDaisies,'' this is why Ned doesn't want anybody to know that he can bring people BackFromTheDead -- see the page quote. Given Ned's neurotic personality, it's not really surprising that he would think this.

to:

* In ''PushingDaisies,'' this is why Ned doesn't want anybody to know that he can bring people BackFromTheDead -- see the page quote.BackFromTheDead. Given Ned's neurotic personality, it's not really surprising that he would think this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Possibly fated to become a DiscreditedTrope, at least in the literal pass-me-the-scalpel sense, as sonography, MRIs, and other imaging techniques have made hands-on vivisection unnecessary for the internal examination of research subjects, given sufficient funding and resources. Depending on who exactly might be after you and why, however, you may still want to be very careful not to get discovered and/or captured just the same.

to:

Possibly fated to become a DiscreditedTrope, at least in the literal pass-me-the-scalpel sense, as sonography, MRIs, [=MRIs=], and other imaging techniques have made hands-on vivisection unnecessary for the internal examination of research subjects, given sufficient funding and resources. Depending on who exactly might be after you and why, however, you may still want to be very careful not to get discovered and/or captured just the same.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In XCom series it's the standard procedure when dealing with captive aliens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The irony of course being that they're suffering from WrongGenreSavvy. Several teams of Power Rangers operate openly, and it's unlikely that Lightspeed would allow the goverment to experiment on other power rangers given the generally brotherhood like nature of the Rangers.

Top