Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TheProfiler

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Saga Anderson in ''VideoGame/AlanWakeII'' has a knack for this, with Alex Casey pointing out it's one of her best skills as an FBI agent. While in her [[MemoryPalace Mind Place]], Saga can focus on the image of a person to see how they think, ask them questions, and get answers back. [[spoiler:It's actually a full-on psychic ability, one she got from her father: Odin Anderson.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Three different TrueCrime writers have been caught lying about having FBI profiler training, and having interviewed {{Serial Killer}}s. [[https://thecrimemag.com/meet-the-fake-fbi-profiler/ Paul Harrison]] from the UK and [[https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/13/serial-killer-expert-admits-serial-lies-stephane-bourgoin Stephane Bourgoin]] from France seemingly mostly did it for publicity to sell books, but [[https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/richard-walter-criminal-profiler-fraud.html Richard Walter]] in the US even used his fake credentials to act as an expert witness at trials.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Creator/ThomasHarris is the TropeCodifier of the super-compotent criminal profiler in his Franchise/HannibalLecter series of books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Hannibal Lecter offers his services as a profiler in exchange for a LuxuryPrisonSuite in ''Film/TheSilenceOfTheLambs''. However, Lecter subverts the trope: He is able to offer an extremely accurate profile of Buffalo Bill because he'd met him and knew his personal history, not because of his own insight.

to:

** Hannibal Lecter offers his services as a profiler to Clarice Starling, freshly graduated FBI profiler, in exchange for a LuxuryPrisonSuite in ''Film/TheSilenceOfTheLambs''. However, Lecter subverts the trope: He is able to offer an extremely accurate profile of Buffalo Bill because he'd met him and knew his personal history, not because of his own insight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Later on, we learn another possible reason why she recruited him. His grandfather Captain Jack Zimmerman saved her life during UsefulNotes/WorldWarTwo at the cost of his own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the new canon, Thrawn once faced off against General Yiv the Benevolent, who himself displayed a small measure of this talent, except his passion was architecture rather than art.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one episode, he found himself up against his own former boss, who ''had'' gone off the deep end and started imitating the criminal he was after.

to:

** In one episode, "[[Recap/TheXFilesS03E14Grotesque Grotesque]]", he found finds himself up against his own former boss, mentor, who ''had'' ''has'' gone off the deep end and started imitating the criminal he was he's after.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Vincent D'Onofrio's character in ''Series/LawAndOrderCriminalIntent'' would fit here. From the main ''Series/LawAndOrder'' series, one of the early seasons had the NYPD work up a profile of a suspect who was randomly targeting and shooting African-Americans. The profile seems to net them their killer, but the suspect's attorney uses all the ways his client ''doesn't'' match it, along with the lack of non-circumstantial evidence, to get a Judge to release him. Turns out, the police were right, he ''was'' the killer, and he manages to strike again after his release. Fortunately, his would-be victim guns ''him'' down instead.

to:

* Vincent D'Onofrio's character Robert Goren in ''Series/LawAndOrderCriminalIntent'' would fit here. From the main ''Series/LawAndOrder'' series, one of the early seasons had the NYPD work up a profile of a suspect who was randomly targeting and shooting African-Americans. The profile seems to net them their killer, but the suspect's attorney uses all the ways his client ''doesn't'' match it, along with the lack of non-circumstantial evidence, to get a Judge to release him. Turns out, the police were right, he ''was'' the killer, and he manages to strike again after his release. Fortunately, his would-be victim guns ''him'' down instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/ProdigalSon'': Malcolm Bright (née Whitly) is a gifted criminal psychologist, using his twisted genius to help the NYPD solve crimes and stop killers. Dr. Martin Whitly, also known as the Surgeon, was a serial killer who invited Malcolm to find out why.

to:

* ''Series/ProdigalSon'': Malcolm Bright (née Whitly) is a gifted criminal psychologist, using his twisted genius to help the NYPD solve crimes and stop killers. His father Dr. Martin Whitly, also known as the Surgeon, was a serial killer who invited Malcolm to find out why.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Snow, preternaturally so, in ''Manga/{{Tista}}.

to:

* Snow, preternaturally so, in ''Manga/{{Tista}}.''Manga/{{Tista}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Snow, preternaturally so, in Tista.

to:

* Snow, preternaturally so, in Tista.''Manga/{{Tista}}.



* ''Bedlam'' features Fillmore Press, alias Madder Red, a former mass-murdering supervillain who reformed after a stay in a psychiatric institution. He knows ''exactly'' how the criminally insane mind operates, and offers his services to the local police when they're stumped by a string of serial murders. The police, especially detective Ramira Acevedo, have no idea what to make of him -- since Madder Red is believed dead and Press has no actual criminal record, he comes across as a weird guy with bizarrely in-depth knowledge of how crazy killers think. Eventually he's hired on as a paid consultant.

to:

* ''Bedlam'' ''ComicBook/{{Bedlam}}'' features Fillmore Press, alias Madder Red, a former mass-murdering supervillain who reformed after a stay in a psychiatric institution. He knows ''exactly'' how the criminally insane mind operates, and offers his services to the local police when they're stumped by a string of serial murders. The police, especially detective Ramira Acevedo, have no idea what to make of him -- since Madder Red is believed dead and Press has no actual criminal record, he comes across as a weird guy with bizarrely in-depth knowledge of how crazy killers think. Eventually he's hired on as a paid consultant.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->''"The suspect is likely a white male in his late twenties to late thirties, he likely is not a college graduate but feels superior to those with advanced education, and he is likely employed in a bureacratic entity, possibly civil service or quasi-public service from which he feels alienated. He has a problem with authority, and a deep-seated resentment of those he feels have impeded his progress professionally. The minimized sexual activity suggests this is not a primary motive for the killings, in fact the lack of DNA or saliva in the bite-marks of the last-found victim indicate to us possible post-mortem staging. The suspect has trouble with lasting relationships, and is possibly a high-functioning alcoholic, with alcohol being used as a trigger in his crimes. His resentment of the homeless may stem from a personal relationship with someone who was in that cohort, or his victimization of them may simply provide an opportunity for him to assert his superiority and/or intellectual prowess."''

to:

-->''"The suspect is likely a white male in his late twenties to late thirties, he likely is not a college graduate but feels superior to those with advanced education, and he is likely employed in a bureacratic bureaucratic entity, possibly civil service or quasi-public service from which he feels alienated. He has a problem with authority, and a deep-seated resentment of those he feels have impeded his progress professionally. The minimized sexual activity suggests this is not a primary motive for the killings, in fact the lack of DNA or saliva in the bite-marks of the last-found victim indicate to us possible post-mortem postmortem staging. The suspect has trouble with lasting relationships, and is possibly a high-functioning alcoholic, with alcohol being used as a trigger in his crimes. His resentment of the homeless may stem from a personal relationship with someone who was in that cohort, or his victimization of them may simply provide an opportunity for him to assert his superiority and/or intellectual prowess."''



** In the first season, Agent Booth asks Dr. Goodman, an anthropologist, to look over a series of crime scene photographs and photos of their suspect's home to help the FBI figure out where to focus their search for evidence on a short timeline. Goodman is notably hesitant to do this, since his speciality is studying the ''remains'' of people to learn about how they lived, rather than the still-living. That said, rather than trying to identify the suspect based on forensic evidence and hunches, he used the suspect as a starting point to help the FBI figure out how he would have done something, working in reverse of the typical trope.

to:

** In the first season, Agent Booth asks Dr. Goodman, an anthropologist, to look over a series of crime scene photographs and photos of their suspect's home to help the FBI figure out where to focus their search for evidence on a short timeline. Goodman is notably hesitant to do this, since his speciality specialty is studying the ''remains'' of people to learn about how they lived, rather than the still-living. That said, rather than trying to identify the suspect based on forensic evidence and hunches, he used the suspect as a starting point to help the FBI figure out how he would have done something, working in reverse of the typical trope.



* There is a new area of Psychology called Investigative Psychology lead by David Canter (A famed profiler himself) that intents to find a way to use Offender Profiling outside the more horrific types of crimes and even in non-forensic fields. It's far from being as exact as other fields in Psychology, and that's saying something, but it has had some success using Geographical Profiling (normally only used with serial offenders) in nonrelated areas such as Marketing. So it was recently upgraded from "[[ItWillNeverCatchOn Most likely to end up being nothing but a footnote in some textbook]]." to "Ambitious new field."

to:

* There is a new area of Psychology called Investigative Psychology lead by David Canter (A famed profiler himself) that intents to find a way to use Offender Profiling outside the more horrific types of crimes and even in non-forensic fields. It's far from being as exact as other fields in Psychology, and that's saying something, but it has had some success using Geographical Profiling (normally only used with serial offenders) in nonrelated unrelated areas such as Marketing. So it was recently upgraded from "[[ItWillNeverCatchOn Most likely to end up being nothing but a footnote in some textbook]]." to "Ambitious new field."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Not to be confused with the alternate meaning of {{Profiling}}, drawing prejudiced conclusions about someone based on their ethnicity or race.

to:

Not to be confused with the alternate meaning of {{Profiling}}, drawing prejudiced conclusions about someone based on their ethnicity or race. At least, [[BigotWithABadge we hope not]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The [[UrExample earliest known criminal profile]] was for (who else?) UsefulNotes/JackTheRipper, written by police surgeon [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Bond_(British_physician) Thomas Bond]] in 1888. Bond's report analyzes forensic evidence from the crime scenes and speculates about the killer's personality and background. 100 years later, the UsefulNotes/{{FBI}} published their own psychological profile of the Ripper murders as a thought experiment to commemorate the occasion; it can be read [[https://vault.fbi.gov/Jack%20the%20Ripper here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


Not to be confused with the alternate meaning of {{Profiling}}, drawing prejudiced conclusions about someone based on their ethnicity or race.

Added: 310

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The entire main cast of ''Series/CriminalMinds'', except for JJ, who is the media liaison, and Garcia, who is the technical analyst (read: computer person), though JJ becomes one in the 7th season and Garcia in the 6th inherited some of her media work. Some of their leaps of logic are still quite far-fetched though, especially in later seasons and ''especially'' when they accurately profile unique or bizarre psychoses. They also go on arrests and conduct interrogations, which real life profilers ''do not do''. Profiles is more or less used to rule out suspects as well as find them, although they can advise detectives and prosecutors how to conduct interrogations. They ''can'', however, testify in court, although they were originally barred from doing so.

to:

* The entire main cast premise of ''Series/CriminalMinds'', with its main cast except for JJ, who is the media liaison, and Garcia, who is the technical analyst (read: computer person), though JJ becomes one in the 7th season and Garcia in the 6th inherited some of her media work. Some of their leaps of logic are still quite far-fetched though, especially in later seasons and ''especially'' when they accurately profile unique or bizarre psychoses. They also go on arrests and conduct interrogations, which real life profilers ''do not do''. Profiles is more or less used to rule out suspects as well as find them, although they can advise detectives and prosecutors how to conduct interrogations. They ''can'', however, testify in court, although they were originally barred from doing so.


Added DiffLines:

** Raymond "Red" Reddington, who assists Keen in her investigations, does do a lot of profiling and exhibits a lot of the characteristics of this character. Which would make sense because Red is a [[CardCarryingVillain criminal mastermind]] offering his services to help Keen and the FBI catch other criminals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In one of Fazil Iskander's stories, an old woman was found murdered in an Abkhazian village. The local AmateurSleuth heard that she was found lying the way she fell down, the skirt exposing her legs. For him, that was enough to narrow the number of suspects considerably and instantly; a properly raised villager might have been mad enough to murder a lady, but he would have never left her lying without rearranging her clothing properly. Therefore, it must be either an outsider or a spoiled Abkhazian. It was some city hooligan visiting his relatives; turns out the lady caught him having an affair with her granddaughter.

Changed: 34

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Paul Britton, one of Britain's leading forensic psychologist who (according to his books anyway) effectively kickstarted and setup the forensic psychology field in Britain and worked on several high profile cases such as Fred and Rosemary West and the Jamie Bulger murder. That said, he got it badly wrong with the investigation into the murder of Rachel Nickell, abetting the police in their attempt to incriminate and entrap a likely suspect who was convicted but later turned out to be innocent (and, to make it worse, the actual killer turned out to have ''also been the perpetrator'' of a series of rapes that Britton helped investigate).

to:

* Paul Britton, one of Britain's leading forensic psychologist who (according to his books anyway) effectively kickstarted and setup the forensic psychology field in Britain and worked on several high profile cases such as Fred and Rosemary West and the Jamie Bulger murder. That said, he got it badly wrong with the investigation into the murder of Rachel Nickell, abetting the police in their attempt to incriminate and entrap a likely suspect who was convicted but later turned out to be innocent (and, to innocent. To make it worse, the actual killer turned out to have ''also been the perpetrator'' of a double murder ''and'' a series of rapes that Britton helped investigate).investigate.

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Paul Britton, one of Britain's leading forensic psychologist who (according to his books anyway) effectively kickstarted and setup the forensic psychology field in Britain and worked on several high profile cases such as Fred and Rosemary West and the Jamie Bulger murder. That said, he got it badly wrong with the investigation into the murder of Rachel Nickell, abetting the police in their attempt to incriminate and entrap a likely suspect who was convicted but later turned out to be innocent (and, to make it worse, the actual killer turned out to have also been the perpetrator of ''another'' murder that Britton helped investigate).

to:

* Paul Britton, one of Britain's leading forensic psychologist who (according to his books anyway) effectively kickstarted and setup the forensic psychology field in Britain and worked on several high profile cases such as Fred and Rosemary West and the Jamie Bulger murder. That said, he got it badly wrong with the investigation into the murder of Rachel Nickell, abetting the police in their attempt to incriminate and entrap a likely suspect who was convicted but later turned out to be innocent (and, to make it worse, the actual killer turned out to have also ''also been the perpetrator perpetrator'' of ''another'' murder a series of rapes that Britton helped investigate).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[PropheticName John Edward Douglas]], founder of the FBI's Criminal Profiling Program and inspiration for several of the trope examples listed above, has written several professional and true-crime books about profiling and his personal experiences with its use (one of which, ''Series/Mindhunter'', was itself adapted for TV). His near-fatal bout of viral encephalitis, while pursuing the Green River Killer case, surely contributed to this trope's assumption that a profiler's work is both emotionally and physically exhausting. If there is a profiler in fiction, chances are he is one of the inspirations for it.

to:

* [[PropheticName John Edward Douglas]], founder of the FBI's Criminal Profiling Program and inspiration for several of the trope examples listed above, has written several professional and true-crime books about profiling and his personal experiences with its use (one of which, ''Series/Mindhunter'', ''Series/{{Mindhunter}}'', was itself adapted for TV). His near-fatal bout of viral encephalitis, while pursuing the Green River Killer case, surely contributed to this trope's assumption that a profiler's work is both emotionally and physically exhausting. If there is a profiler in fiction, chances are he is one of the inspirations for it.

Changed: 437

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[PropheticName John Edward Douglas]], founder of the FBI's Criminal Profiling Program and inspiration for several of the trope examples listed above, has written several professional and true-crime books about profiling and his personal experiences with its use. His near-fatal bout of viral encephalitis, while pursuing the Green River Killer case, surely contributed to this trope's assumption that a profiler's work is both emotionally and physically exhausting. If there is a profiler in fiction, chances are he is one of the inspirations for it.

to:

* [[PropheticName John Edward Douglas]], founder of the FBI's Criminal Profiling Program and inspiration for several of the trope examples listed above, has written several professional and true-crime books about profiling and his personal experiences with its use.use (one of which, ''Series/Mindhunter'', was itself adapted for TV). His near-fatal bout of viral encephalitis, while pursuing the Green River Killer case, surely contributed to this trope's assumption that a profiler's work is both emotionally and physically exhausting. If there is a profiler in fiction, chances are he is one of the inspirations for it.



* Paul Britton, one of Britain's leading forensic psychologist who (according to his books anyway) effectively kickstarted and setup the forensic psychology field in Britain and worked on several high profile cases such as Fred and Rosemary West and the Jamie Bulger Case.

to:

* Paul Britton, one of Britain's leading forensic psychologist who (according to his books anyway) effectively kickstarted and setup the forensic psychology field in Britain and worked on several high profile cases such as Fred and Rosemary West and the Jamie Bulger Case.murder. That said, he got it badly wrong with the investigation into the murder of Rachel Nickell, abetting the police in their attempt to incriminate and entrap a likely suspect who was convicted but later turned out to be innocent (and, to make it worse, the actual killer turned out to have also been the perpetrator of ''another'' murder that Britton helped investigate).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Millennium}}'': Lance Henriksen stars as ex-FBI agent turned FBI consultant Frank Black, who would frequently share his thoughts on elusive killers with his old colleagues. The first season was ambiguous whether Frank's insights [[MaybeMagicMaybeMundane were just a keen sense of intuition or were actually supernatural in origin]]. Later seasons make these visions unambiguously psychic, however.

to:

* ''Series/{{Millennium}}'': ''Series/Millennium1996'': Lance Henriksen stars as ex-FBI agent turned FBI consultant Frank Black, who would frequently share his thoughts on elusive killers with his old colleagues. The first season was ambiguous whether Frank's insights [[MaybeMagicMaybeMundane were just a keen sense of intuition or were actually supernatural in origin]]. Later seasons make these visions unambiguously psychic, however.

Changed: 254

Removed: 241

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/ProdigalSon'':
** Malcolm Bright (née Whitly) is a gifted criminal psychologist, using his twisted genius to help the NYPD solve crimes and stop killers. Dr. Martin Whitly, also known as the Surgeon, was a serial killer who invited Malcolm to find out why.

to:

* ''Series/ProdigalSon'':
**
''Series/ProdigalSon'': Malcolm Bright (née Whitly) is a gifted criminal psychologist, using his twisted genius to help the NYPD solve crimes and stop killers. Dr. Martin Whitly, also known as the Surgeon, was a serial killer who invited Malcolm to find out why.



* ''{{Series/Frasier}}'''s mother [[PosthumousCharacter Hester]], whom he followed into psychiatry, occasionally did forensic psychology consultations for the Seattle Police Department, which is where she met Martin.
* In the ''Elementary'' episode "The Deductionist", a profiler being brought in to revisit a serial killer leads to Sherlock spending much of the episode articulating a distaste for a "snake oil" science, "super geniuses" relative to screwed-up people he claims they'll have you believe are themselves geniuses... but this turns out to be motivated by a personal history where she got into his head and, following an actual romantic relationship, wrote an extremely unflattering article about an anonymous "deductionist" on a fast track to substance abuse and other dooms he worries she'll be proven right about. In the case at hand, her skill is portrayed as legitimate, but [[spoiler:the book she wrote about him ruined his family with what he insists were false allegations concerning ''his father'']].

to:

* ''{{Series/Frasier}}'''s ''Series/{{Frasier}}'''s mother [[PosthumousCharacter Hester]], whom he followed into psychiatry, occasionally did forensic psychology consultations for the Seattle Police Department, which is where she met Martin.
* In the ''Elementary'' ''Series/{{Elementary}}'' episode "The Deductionist", a profiler being brought in to revisit a serial killer leads to Sherlock spending much of the episode articulating a distaste for a "snake oil" science, "super geniuses" relative to screwed-up people he claims they'll have you believe are themselves geniuses... but this turns out to be motivated by a personal history where she got into his head and, following an actual romantic relationship, wrote an extremely unflattering article about an anonymous "deductionist" on a fast track to substance abuse and other dooms he worries she'll be proven right about. In the case at hand, her skill is portrayed as legitimate, but [[spoiler:the book she wrote about him ruined his family with what he insists were false allegations concerning ''his father'']].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Pacific Bay arc of ''VideoGame/CriminalCase'', psychological evidences are handled by criminal psychologist Dr. Russell Crane, who would sometimes assist the coroner, Roxie, and the forensics expert, Yann, in some of their analysis if psychological aspects of the killer is involved. He is also responsible of giving reports on certain killers' mental health to the Judge to help him assign sentences.

to:

* In the Pacific Bay arc of ''VideoGame/CriminalCase'', ''VideoGame/CriminalCasePacificBay'', psychological evidences are handled by criminal psychologist Dr. Russell Crane, who would sometimes assist the coroner, Roxie, and the forensics expert, Yann, in some of their analysis if psychological aspects of the killer is involved. He is also responsible of giving reports on certain killers' mental health to the Judge to help him assign sentences.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* D.A.V.E. from ''WesternAnimation/TheBatman'' is an AI supposedly designed to do this, apparently created by combining the brainwaves of Batman’s entire rogues gallery. When told about break-ins at a chemical plant and a pillow factory on the same night, it immediately figures out that the Joker is going to bombard Gotham with chemically-laced feathers to “tickle” everyone to death. When it inevitably turns rogue, it uses the same skills to uncover Batman’s secret identity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''TabletopGame/{{Shadowrun}}'' has a Positive Quality called "Profiler", which represents a character who is an expert on using [[EverythingIsOnline the Matrix]] to collate psychological, professional and relationship-based profiles on targets. Profilers gain bonuses to social skill rolls when interacting with anyone they've profiled, but gain penalties to social skill caps when forced into deep interactions with people they don't know or have failed to profile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Comicbooks]]

to:

[[folder:Comicbooks]][[folder:Comic Books]]



[[folder:Videogames]]

to:

[[folder:Videogames]][[folder:Video Games]]



[[folder:Webcomics]]

to:

[[folder:Webcomics]][[folder:Web Comics]]



[[folder:Web Originals]]

to:

[[folder:Web Originals]]Original]]

Added: 483

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[folder:Fan Works]]
* Hikigaya Hachiman in ''Fanfic/MyHeroSchoolAdventureIsAllWrongAsExpected'' is able to form a surprisingly accurate picture of All for One after having examined his handiwork only once. He notes that the exact combination of Quirks present in the U.S.J. Nomu had to have been devised by an absolute sociopath and that the Shock Absorption Quirk in particular had to have been added primarily for the vicious irony of having All Might effectively beat ''himself'' to death.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Dr. James G. Kent, the police psychiatrist in ''Film/TheSniper'', may represent one of the earliest examples on film. The film was one of the first to focus on the psychology of a serial killer as a major plot point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A rather ridiculously accurate profiling is done on ''Series/{{Angel}}'', which not only describes the killer, but Angel himself.

to:

* A rather ridiculously accurate profiling is done on ''Series/{{Angel}}'', which not only describes the killer, but Angel himself.himself (mind you, he's a vampire that Angel sired).

Top