Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ThatThingIsNotMyChild

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''TheMarvelousLandOfOz'', Tip, a boy who's "small and rather delicate in appearance," creates a huge pumpkin-headed scarecrow man named "Jack Pumpkinhead" to frighten a witch, who uses magic to bring it to life. This leads to Tip being very uncomfortable with the creature calling him "Father", although he does consider Jack a good friend. At the end [[spoiler: it turns out that Tip is a girl, Princess Ozma, who's been under a spell since she was younger to protect her identity. After being changed back into Ozma, she's thrilled that Jack Pumpkinhead can no longer refer to her as "father".]]

to:

* In ''TheMarvelousLandOfOz'', ''Literature/TheMarvelousLandOfOz'', Tip, a boy who's "small and rather delicate in appearance," creates a huge pumpkin-headed scarecrow man named "Jack Pumpkinhead" to frighten a witch, who uses magic to bring it to life. This leads to Tip being very uncomfortable with the creature calling him "Father", although he does consider Jack a good friend. At the end [[spoiler: it turns out that Tip is a girl, Princess Ozma, who's been under a spell since she was younger to protect her identity. After being changed back into Ozma, she's thrilled that Jack Pumpkinhead can no longer refer to her as "father".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Horrifically averted with ''DeadSpace2'', where a woman calls lovely to her [[BodyHorror necromorph]] baby . . . only to get her entrails splattered against the wall when it goes kaboom.

to:

* Horrifically averted with ''DeadSpace2'', where a woman calls lovely lovingly to her [[BodyHorror necromorph]] baby . . . only to get her entrails splattered against the wall when it goes kaboom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Gargoyles}}'', Xanatos created a clone of Goliath, who reacted in disgust, calling him a "thing" and an "abomination". Elisa immediately pointed out that "[[SdrawkcabName Thailog]]" could be considered his son, and Goliath reluctantly agrees they should help free him from Sevarius. Unfortunately, Thailog had already learned [[XanatosGambit a few tricks]] from his [[TheChessmaster other]] [[CompleteMonster daddies]]...

to:

* In ''{{Gargoyles}}'', Xanatos created a clone of Goliath, who reacted in disgust, calling him a "thing" and an "abomination". Elisa immediately pointed out that "[[SdrawkcabName Thailog]]" could be considered his son, and Goliath reluctantly agrees they should help free him from Sevarius. Unfortunately, Thailog had already learned [[XanatosGambit a few tricks]] from his [[TheChessmaster other]] [[CompleteMonster [[MorallyAmbiguousDoctorate daddies]]...
** Which actually makes this an [[InvertedTrope inversion]]--it really only takes Goliath about a minute or two to accept Thailog as a son, but Thailog refuses to accept Goliath as a ''parent,'' [[GoodIsWeak claiming he's too weak]] for him to admire. He rejects Xanatos and Sevarius too, but that's more because his own ambitions oppose theirs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:247:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/525px-Demonic_fetus_4868.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:247:Sorry [[{{Berserk}} Guts]] but that thing is your child]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:274:Sorry [[{{Berserk}} Guts]] but that thing is your child]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:274:Sorry [[caption-width-right:247:Sorry [[{{Berserk}} Guts]] but that thing is your child]]
child]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:247:Sorry [[{{Berserk}} Guts]] but that thing is your child]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:247:Sorry [[caption-width-right:274:Sorry [[{{Berserk}} Guts]] but that thing is your child]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:247:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/525px-Demonic_fetus_4868.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:247:Sorry [[{{Berserk}} Guts]] but that thing is your child]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Okay, same episode, but the un-intentional copy-cat said it better.


* In an episode of ''StarTrekTheNextGeneration'', the crew were kidnapped and their DNA used to make clones. They ended up killing the clones, and were accused by the former kidnappers of genocide (and certain RealLife groups of showing an abortion on TV).
** In another episode of TNG, Ryker murders the not-yet-awake clone of himself produced by the colony that reproduced by cloning (their initial population was too small to provide adequate genetic diversity). Ryker cites some "diminished my uniqueness" excuse. The tranporter-accident clone fares better, having been stranded on a planet for years and thus diverged from the "original" Ryker.

to:

* In an episode of ''StarTrekTheNextGeneration'', Riker kills the crew were kidnapped and their DNA used to make clones. They ended up killing the clones, and were accused by the former kidnappers of genocide (and certain RealLife groups of showing an abortion on TV).
** In another episode of TNG, Ryker murders the not-yet-awake
still-in-development clone of himself produced by the colony that reproduced by cloning (their initial population was too small to provide adequate genetic diversity). Ryker Riker cites some "diminished my uniqueness" excuse. The excuse, (and the fact this was done without his permission). Later, a tranporter-accident clone fares better, having been stranded on a planet for years and thus diverged from being recognized as much as Riker as the "original" Ryker.
one on Enterprise. The two act... [[SubvertedTrope like brothers.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This is Kitana's reaction towards Mileena's insistence of 'being a family' in her Story Mode chapter in {{Mortal Kombat 9}}.

to:

* This is Kitana's reaction towards her 'sister' Mileena's insistence of 'being a family' in her Story Mode chapter in {{Mortal Kombat 9}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* This is Kitana's reaction towards Mileena's insistence of 'being a family' in her Story Mode chapter in {{Mortal Kombat 9}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted in the VorkosiganSaga. In ''Brothers in Arms'', Miles discovers that a Komarran terrorist cell has cloned him as part of a Byzantine plot. Miles immediately declares the clone his brother, informs him of the automatically determined DeadGuyJunior name Vor tradition gives him, and goes out of his way to protect and support him. His mother and father do the same, when they meet him.

to:

* Averted in the VorkosiganSaga. In ''Brothers in Arms'', Miles discovers that a Komarran terrorist cell has cloned him as part of a Byzantine plot. Miles immediately declares the clone his brother, informs him of the automatically determined automatically-determined DeadGuyJunior name Vor tradition gives him, and goes out of his way to protect and support him. His mother and father do the same, when they meet him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted in the VorkosiganSaga. In ''Brothers in Arms'', Miles discovers that a Komarran terrorist cell has cloned him as part of a Byzantine plot. Miles immediately declares the clone his brother, gives him his appropriate DeadGuyJunior name, and goes out of his way to protect and support him. His mother and father do the same, when they meet him.

to:

* Averted in the VorkosiganSaga. In ''Brothers in Arms'', Miles discovers that a Komarran terrorist cell has cloned him as part of a Byzantine plot. Miles immediately declares the clone his brother, gives informs him his appropriate of the automatically determined DeadGuyJunior name, name Vor tradition gives him, and goes out of his way to protect and support him. His mother and father do the same, when they meet him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This seems to be much how Guts reacts in ''{{Berserk}}'', after[[spoiler:his unborn child is defiled when Casca is raped by Femto.]] Unlike most examples on the list, it actually ''is'' his child, but merely corrupted by events outside of his control.

to:

* This seems to be much how Guts reacts in ''{{Berserk}}'', after[[spoiler:his unborn after [[spoiler:Casca miscarries and gives birth to a hideously deformed child is defiled when Casca is after the events of the Eclipse where she was raped by Femto.]] Femto]]. Unlike most examples on the list, it actually ''is'' his child, but merely corrupted by events outside of his control.




to:

* This may have been the motive for the Cobblepot family from ''{{Batman Returns}}'' to throw baby Oswald over a bridge in its wicker bassinet.



[[AC:TabletopGames]]

to:

[[AC:TabletopGames]][[AC:Tabletop Games]]



[[AC:{{Videogames}}]]

to:

[[AC:{{Videogames}}]][[AC:{{Video Games}}]]



[[AC:{{WesternAnimation}}]]

to:

[[AC:{{WesternAnimation}}]][[AC:{{Western Animation}}]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Played brutally, horribly straight in ''{{Duumvirate}}''. Luke ''agrees'' with this sentiment when [[spoiler:killing his parents]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It\'s way too common a phrase to give any one instance the \"Trope Namer\" status.


* Trope Namer: "Father, you show me Regan's identical twin: same face, same voice, same smell, same everything down to the way she dots her i’s, and still I'd know in a second that it wasn't really her! I'd know it! I'd know it in my gut and I'm telling you I know ''[[TheExorcist that thing upstairs is not my daughter!]]''"

to:

* Trope Namer: *TheExorcist : "Father, you show me Regan's identical twin: same face, same voice, same smell, same everything down to the way she dots her i’s, and still I'd know in a second that it wasn't really her! I'd know it! I'd know it in my gut and I'm telling you I know ''[[TheExorcist that ''that thing upstairs is not my daughter!]]''"
daughter!''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Trope Namer: "Father, you show me Regan's identical twin: same face, same voice, same smell, same everything down to the way she dots her i’s, and still I'd know in a second that it wasn't really her! I'd know it! I'd know it in my gut and I'm telling you I know ''that thing upstairs is not my daughter!''"

to:

* Trope Namer: "Father, you show me Regan's identical twin: same face, same voice, same smell, same everything down to the way she dots her i’s, and still I'd know in a second that it wasn't really her! I'd know it! I'd know it in my gut and I'm telling you I know ''that ''[[TheExorcist that thing upstairs is not my daughter!''"
daughter!]]''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Trope Namer: "Father, you show me Regan's identical twin: same face, same voice, same smell, same everything down to the way she dots her i’s, and still I'd know in a second that it wasn't really her! I'd know it! I'd know it in my gut and I'm telling you I know ''that thing upstairs is not my daughter!''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted ''hard'' in a ''WeirdScience'' story. The children on a new colony are systematically taken from their mothers at birth, and the mothers aren't allowed to see them. The women's leader eventually forces the head doctor to admit why this is happening: The children are malformed and mutated, and the medical staff was trying to protect the mothers from the horror and trauma. The women basically storm the nursery, and accept the children with open arms. The leader turns to the head doctor, and with a mix of pity and contempt says to him "Did you truly believe we could not love our [[GrotesqueCute own children]]?"

to:

* Averted ''hard'' in a ''WeirdScience'' story. The children on a new colony are systematically taken from their mothers at birth, and the mothers aren't allowed to see them. The women's leader eventually forces the head doctor to admit why this is happening: The children are malformed and mutated, and the medical staff was trying to protect the mothers from the horror and trauma. The women basically storm the nursery, and accept the children with open arms. The leader turns to the head doctor, and with a mix of pity and contempt says to him "Did you truly believe we could not love our [[GrotesqueCute [[UglyCute own children]]?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted ''hard'' in a ''WeirdScience'' story. The children on a new colony are systematically taken from their mothers at birth, and the mothers aren't allowed to see them. The women's leader eventually forces the head doctor to admit why this is happening: The children are malformed and mutated, and the medical staff was trying to protect the mothers from the horror and trauma. The women basically storm the nursery, and accept the children with open arms. The leader turns to the head doctor, and with a mix of pity and contempt says to him "Did you truly believe we could not love our [[GrotequeCute own children]]?"

to:

* Averted ''hard'' in a ''WeirdScience'' story. The children on a new colony are systematically taken from their mothers at birth, and the mothers aren't allowed to see them. The women's leader eventually forces the head doctor to admit why this is happening: The children are malformed and mutated, and the medical staff was trying to protect the mothers from the horror and trauma. The women basically storm the nursery, and accept the children with open arms. The leader turns to the head doctor, and with a mix of pity and contempt says to him "Did you truly believe we could not love our [[GrotequeCute [[GrotesqueCute own children]]?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Averted ''hard'' in a ''WeirdScience'' story. The children on a new colony are systematically taken from their mothers at birth, and the mothers aren't allowed to see them. The women's leader eventually forces the head doctor to admit why this is happening: The children are malformed and mutated, and the medical staff was trying to protect the mothers from the horror and trauma. The women basically storm the nursery, and accept the children with open arms. The leader turns to the head doctor, and with a mix of pity and contempt says to him "Did you truly believe we could not love our [[GrotequeCute own children]]?"

Changed: 445

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added examples



to:

* In a particularly [[{{Tearjerker}} heartbreaking]] example, ''FruitsBasket'' features [[StepfordSmiler Momiji]]'s mother reacting this way (using the almost exact quote) upon discovering that her child [[InvoluntaryShapeshifting turns into a rabbit when she holds him]] because he's under the zodiac curse. Momiji's father had [[spoiler:her memory of her son cleared]] to aid her failing health brought on by the emotional stress of all this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Horrifically averted with ''DeadSpace 2'', where a woman calls lovely to her [[BodyHorror necromorph]] baby . . . only to get her entrails splattered against the wall when it goes kaboom.

to:

* Horrifically averted with ''DeadSpace 2'', ''DeadSpace2'', where a woman calls lovely to her [[BodyHorror necromorph]] baby . . . only to get her entrails splattered against the wall when it goes kaboom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''TheMarvelousLandOfOz'', Tip, a boy who's "small and rather delicate in appearance," creates a huge pumpkin-headed scarecrow man and uses magic to bring him to life. This leads to him being very uncomfortable with the creature calling him "Father". At the end [[spoiler: it turns out that Tip is a girl, Princess Ozma, who's been under a spell since she was younger to protect her identity. After being changed back into Ozma, she's thrilled that Jack Pumpkinhead can no longer refer to her as "father".]]

to:

* In ''TheMarvelousLandOfOz'', Tip, a boy who's "small and rather delicate in appearance," creates a huge pumpkin-headed scarecrow man and named "Jack Pumpkinhead" to frighten a witch, who uses magic to bring him it to life. This leads to him Tip being very uncomfortable with the creature calling him "Father"."Father", although he does consider Jack a good friend. At the end [[spoiler: it turns out that Tip is a girl, Princess Ozma, who's been under a spell since she was younger to protect her identity. After being changed back into Ozma, she's thrilled that Jack Pumpkinhead can no longer refer to her as "father".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''TheMarvelousLandOfOz'', Tip, a boy who's "small and rather delicate in appearance," creates a huge pumpkin-headed scarecrow man and uses magic to bring him to life. This leads to him being very uncomfortable with the creature calling him "Father". At the end [[spoiler: it turns out that Tip is a girl, Princess Ozma, who's been under a spell since she was younger to protect her identity. After being changed back into Ozma, she's thrilled that Jack Pumpkinhead can no longer refer to her as "father".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted in the VorkosiganSaga (''Brothers in Arms''), Miles discovers that a Komarran terrorist cell had him cloned for a substitution plot, but Miles very emphatically views Mark as his brother. Mark is surprised.

to:

* Averted in the VorkosiganSaga (''Brothers VorkosiganSaga. In ''Brothers in Arms''), Arms'', Miles discovers that a Komarran terrorist cell had him has cloned for him as part of a substitution plot, but Byzantine plot. Miles very emphatically views Mark as immediately declares the clone his brother. Mark is surprised.
brother, gives him his appropriate DeadGuyJunior name, and goes out of his way to protect and support him. His mother and father do the same, when they meet him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Gargoyles}}'', Xanatos created a clone of Goliath, who reacted in disgust, calling him a "thing" and an "abomination". Elisa immediately pointed out that "[[SdrawkcabName Thailog]]" could be considered his son, and Goliath reluctantly agrees they should help free him from Sevarius. Unfortunately, Thailog had already learned [[XanatosGambit a few tricks]] from his [[TheChessmaster other]] [[CompleteMonster daddies]]...

to:

* In ''{{Gargoyles}}'', Xanatos created a clone of Goliath, who reacted in disgust, calling him a "thing" and an "abomination". Elisa immediately pointed out that "[[SdrawkcabName Thailog]]" could be considered his son, and Goliath reluctantly agrees they should help free him from Sevarius. Unfortunately, Thailog had already learned [[XanatosGambit a few tricks]] from his [[TheChessmaster other]] [[CompleteMonster daddies]]...daddies]]...

[[AC:{{Theater}}]]
* Done in the stage adaptation of ''{{Wicked}}''. Elphaba's father undisguisedly loathes her with a passion and dotes on her younger sister Nessa merely because Elphaba is green. The moment she's born he screams [[ThisIsSparta "TAKE! IT! AWAY!"]] at the nurse before angrily storming off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Horrifically averted with ''DeadSpace 2'', where a woman calls lovely to her [[BodyHorror necromorph]] baby . . . only to get her entrails splattered against the wall when it goes kaboom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Gargoyles}}'', Xanatos created a clone of Goliath, who reacted in disgust, calling him a "thing" and an "abomination". Elisa immediately pointed out that "[[SdrawkcabName Thailog]]" could be considered his son, but while he agreed the damage had already been done and the clone turned against him.

to:

* In ''{{Gargoyles}}'', Xanatos created a clone of Goliath, who reacted in disgust, calling him a "thing" and an "abomination". Elisa immediately pointed out that "[[SdrawkcabName Thailog]]" could be considered his son, but while he agreed the damage and Goliath reluctantly agrees they should help free him from Sevarius. Unfortunately, Thailog had already been done and the clone turned against him.learned [[XanatosGambit a few tricks]] from his [[TheChessmaster other]] [[CompleteMonster daddies]]...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted in the VorkorsiganSaga (''Brothers in Arms''), Miles discovers that a Komarran terrorist cell had him cloned for a substitution plot, but Miles very emphatically views Mark as his brother. Mark is surprised.

to:

* Averted in the VorkorsiganSaga VorkosiganSaga (''Brothers in Arms''), Miles discovers that a Komarran terrorist cell had him cloned for a substitution plot, but Miles very emphatically views Mark as his brother. Mark is surprised.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--''YoungJustice'', "Schooled"

to:

-->--''YoungJustice'', -->--''Series/YoungJustice'', "Schooled"

Top