Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / SpaceWhaleAesop

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is probably more like "Don't pretend to be something you're not or else you'll get yourself and/or others in a whole heap of trouble", which isn't that Space Whale-y at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***God help him if he ever discovers World of Warcraft.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Don't use TheForce for energy, or it will explode. And eco-terrorists will help it.

Changed: 490

Removed: 814

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stopping thread mode


* The movie ''Teeth'' evokes a old SpaceWhaleAesop: "Don't rape women, or [[spoiler: the [[VaginaDentata teeth in their vaginas]] will bite off your dick."]] Of course, now they've invented an anti-rape device that works almost like that, so, well, don't. At least "Don't rape women" would be a valid message, but in the film only her first victim actually tried to rape her - by the end of the film, her choice of victim just appears to be ''men who vaguely piss her off in some way''. Also, having the aesop "don't rape women" is like having the aesop "don't [[EatsBabies eat babies]]" or "[[KickTheDog puppy-kicking]] isn't a very good sport."
** To be fair, it was FAR from "picking men who vaguely pissed her off". She ''was'' raped/abused. ''Twice'', including by a ''gynecologist''. Her 3rd victim was an accident after she found out [[spoiler: he had tricked her into trusting him, used her for a bet, and talked to his friend about winning the bet ''while he was still inside her'']]. She didn't even mean to do it, her body reacted instinctively. She lured [[spoiler: her brother]] to his demise because [[spoiler: he let her incredibly ill mother cry for help in the hallway for hours, because he ''didn't want to stop having sex and go help her'']]. The last one is clearly a sexual predator, and while it may lead to some [[UnfortunateImplications unfortunate implications]] for her character, it doesn't count as "vaguely pissing her off" either.

to:

* The movie ''Teeth'' evokes a an old SpaceWhaleAesop: "Don't rape women, or [[spoiler: the [[VaginaDentata teeth in their vaginas]] will bite off your dick."]] Of course, now they've invented an anti-rape device that works almost like that, so, well, don't. At least "Don't rape women" would be a valid message, but in the film only her first victim actually tried to rape her - by the end of the film, her choice of victim just appears to be ''men who vaguely piss her off in some way''. Also, having the aesop "don't rape women" is like having the aesop "don't [[EatsBabies eat babies]]" or "[[KickTheDog puppy-kicking]] isn't a very good sport."
** To be fair, it was FAR from "picking men who vaguely pissed her off". She ''was'' raped/abused. ''Twice'', including by a ''gynecologist''. Her 3rd victim was an accident after she found out [[spoiler: he had tricked her into trusting him, used her for a bet, and talked to his friend about winning the bet ''while he was still inside her'']]. She didn't even mean to do it, her body reacted instinctively. She lured [[spoiler: her brother]] to his demise because [[spoiler: he let her incredibly ill mother cry for help in the hallway for hours, because he ''didn't want to stop having sex and go help her'']]. The last one is clearly a sexual predator, and while it may lead to some [[UnfortunateImplications unfortunate implications]] for her character, it doesn't count as "vaguely pissing her off" either.
"]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** If that's the case, I need to read more HarryPotter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correcing an editing error


* [[IronMaiden Bruce Dickinson]] put it best. "And the moral of this story is: This is what not to do if a bird shits on you."

to:

* ** [[IronMaiden Bruce Dickinson]] put it best. "And the moral of this story is: This is what not to do if a bird shits on you."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More on Rime of the Anceint Mariner

Added DiffLines:

*[[IronMaiden Bruce Dickinson]] put it best. "And the moral of this story is: This is what not to do if a bird shits on you."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''{{Snatcher}}'' - Trust other people and be open to them, or a mad Russian scientist responsible for wiping out most of Asia may take advantage of the culture of suspicion around you to trial a new plan to replace people with killer robots indistinguishable from them except for a tendency to get skin cancer and they'll start killing everyone and then the government will want to nuke your island to get rid of them before they spread and ''then'' you'll be sorry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In OzzieAndDrix, the average boy that they live inside of spends ''one'' day eating a bag of chips and watches tv all afternoon. Apparently this is enough to have his otherwise healthy body go into cardiac arrest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "The Lazarus Experiment": Don't try to extend the human lifespan, or you might turn into a cannibalistic giant man-scorpion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** January 2005. Long story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Thanks. Personally, [[ThirdPersonPerson this troper]] viewed the same movie and interpreted it as a pretty straightforward allegory about the AIDS epidemic, thus reaching the much more straightforward - if also more troubling -Aesop of [[UnfortunateImplications "Don't have sex with lesbians/bisexuals, because they are walking death machines."]]

to:

** Thanks. Personally, [[ThirdPersonPerson this troper]] viewed the same movie and interpreted it as a pretty straightforward allegory about the AIDS epidemic, thus reaching the much more straightforward - if also more troubling -Aesop - Aesop of [[UnfortunateImplications "Don't have sex with lesbians/bisexuals, because they are walking death machines."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Thanks. Personally, [[ThirdPersonPerson this troper]] viewed the same movie and interpreted it as a pretty straightforward allegory about the AIDS epidemic, thus reaching the much more straightforward - if also more troubling -Aesop of [[UnfortunateImplications "Don't have sex with lesbians/bisexuals, because they are walking death machines."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The children turned into donkeys were all lazy and chose to play rather than go to school. So another lesson could be that you should get a good education or else all you'll be able to do is hard labor. FridgeBrilliance

to:

** The children turned into donkeys were all lazy and chose to play rather than go to school. So another lesson could be that you should get a good education or else all you'll be able to do is hard labor. FridgeBrillianceFridgeBrilliance!
** So, in other words: "If you play now, you'll have to work later. If you work now, you'll get to play later." Aesops like this drive kids absolutely nuts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Of course, the bus doesn't stop it for all that long.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Thumb-sucking summons up a scissor-wielding tailor who snips of the offending digits; fussy eating habits result in death by starvation; and going out in a rainstorm to play leads to being hurled away to your doom by a sudden gust of wind. There is also a girl who ends up as a pile of ashes after playing with matches despite admonitions from her parents and her two pet cats. The there are stories about a tomboy girl who became a real boy. And many similar.

to:

** Thumb-sucking summons up a scissor-wielding tailor who snips of the offending digits; fussy eating habits result in death by starvation; and going out in a rainstorm to play leads to being hurled away to your doom by a sudden gust of wind. There is also a girl who ends up as a pile of ashes after playing with matches despite admonitions from her parents and her two pet cats. The Then there are stories about a tomboy girl who became a real boy. And many similar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In an episode of ''AdventureTime'' Finn learns that if you break a promise you'll get to hold slumber parties, fight zombies, awake gumball guardians and ''reverse death itself!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Or the SpaceWhaleAesop can be interpreted more generally, in which case the Space Whale vanishes: "An Objectivist society, if left to its own devices, will self-destruct as individuals seek power over others at any cost." In this interpretation, splicing didn't kill Rapture by itself. A breakdown of Objectivist ideals didn't kill Rapture by itself either, because the extensive use of splicers was a problem before Ryan stopped sticking to his guns. ''People'' killed Rapture, with splicing just being a convenient short-cut to the end on account of [[WithGreatPowerComesGreatInsanity providing great power at the cost of your sanity]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A more typical example: In "It Hits the Fan," "Don't abuse swear words or an EldritchAbomination will awaken!"
** And in-universe in "Flashbacks," "Don't leave the bus by yourself or a scary monster will eat you!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[SoBadItsGood ever-so-wonderful]] film ''{{Gamera}} vs Zigra'' gives us the message "Don't pollute the earth's oceans, or else a giant Nazi space fish will mind-control the Earth." Fortunately, we have a giant turtle on our side that'll fight for us... SoYeah...

to:

* The [[SoBadItsGood ever-so-wonderful]] film ''{{Gamera}} vs Zigra'' gives us the message "Don't pollute the earth's oceans, or else a giant Nazi space fish will mind-control the Earth." Fortunately, we have a giant turtle on our side that'll fight for us... SoYeah...

Removed: 1467

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removing natter


** The second film's Teevee is a hell of a {{BrokenAesop}}, what with him being the only one in either film to ''earn'' his way into winning, rather than just pure karma luck (Charlie) or pure brute force (Veruca). The {{HandWave}} was that he looked at a few of the [=UPCs=], and ''doing the math'' figured out which bar to buy, winning on the first actual purchase. Sure, he was a little shit, but most kids are, while few if any are that kind of ''impossibly brilliant''.
** Even in the first film, Teevee is the only one to approach the Factory with scientific curiosity, and he is the only person to verbalize its potential and volunteer to be the first human to be tested on it. His most egregious sin is his intelligence and spirit of scientific endeavor (being not much more reckless than a handful of self-experimenting Nobel laureates), which apparently wasn't at all stunted by his television watching.
*** Um. He zapped himself with a ''prototype'' device that he had just witnessed firsthand shrink a large object to about 5% its original size and which had (to his knowledge) only been tested on non-living matter. To get to this device, he backhanded two people out of his way. Plus, he had witnessed the earlier fates of the three children who overstepped their bounds. And that was before Wonka had a chance to mention that sometimes only half of the signals make it to the TV. Scientific endeavor and intelligence are this kid's most egregious sins?

Changed: 194

Removed: 1351

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removing natter


** Also gives some serious FridgeLogic. [[spoiler:The plants were mad at us for ruining the environment but not for ''eating them''?]]
*** This is not necessarily FridgeLogic. [[spoiler: Animals eating plants is part of the cycle of life. Pollution is not. If plants are able to secrete a neurotoxin, they probably are aware of that better than humans.]]
**** Ummm, [[spoiler: since when is pollution NOT a part of the cycle of life? Decomposers have been around a LOT longer than humans have, and the planet generates plenty of waste on its own and usually cleans up after itself as well. Even the truly nastier forms of pollution like open air degredation and landfills tend to fade away after a century or two. The main difference is in HOW humanity pollutes, and even then it rarely does so in ways vastly different from some of what happens in the "cycle of life."]]
**** Not to mention that far more pollutants go into the air from methane from animal flatulence than from automobiles each year. For the good of the earth, kill all flatulent animals! So the plants won't be mad at us!
***** Or, you know, stop keeping the flatulent animals' numbers unnaturally high, unnaturally sedentary, and fed an unnatural diet, which increases the amount there to fart and increases the volume of gas passed. SoYeah, still our fault.
*** Someone (I think it was {{Moviebob}}), pointed out that it's easy get the BrokenAesop of "Nature is out to kill you, so [[TheDogShotFirst kill it first]]".

to:

** Also gives some serious FridgeLogic. [[spoiler:The plants were mad at us for ruining the environment but not for ''eating them''?]]
*** This is not necessarily FridgeLogic. [[spoiler: Animals eating plants is part of the cycle of life. Pollution is not. If plants are able to secrete a neurotoxin, they probably are aware of that better than humans.]]
**** Ummm, [[spoiler: since when is pollution NOT a part of the cycle of life? Decomposers have been around a LOT longer than humans have, and the planet generates plenty of waste on its own and usually cleans up after itself as well. Even the truly nastier forms of pollution like open air degredation and landfills tend to fade away after a century or two. The main difference is in HOW humanity pollutes, and even then it rarely does so in ways vastly different from some of what happens in the "cycle of life."]]
**** Not to mention that far more pollutants go into the air from methane from animal flatulence than from automobiles each year. For the good of the earth, kill all flatulent animals! So the plants won't be mad at us!
***** Or, you know, stop keeping the flatulent animals' numbers unnaturally high, unnaturally sedentary, and fed an unnatural diet, which increases the amount there to fart and increases the volume of gas passed. SoYeah, still our fault.
***
Someone (I think it was {{Moviebob}}), pointed out that it's easy get the BrokenAesop of "Nature is out to kill you, so [[TheDogShotFirst kill it first]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TalesOfVesperia'' does pretty much the same thing as FinalFantasyVII.

to:

* ''TalesOfVesperia'' does pretty much the same thing as FinalFantasyVII.
FinalFantasyVII
* ''TalesOfSymphonia'': Don't be wasteful, or the world will need to be split in half to save the giant tree that supplies the world with life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* DinnerForSchmucks has the moral of either a)If you make fun of people you will have your house burned down, or b)If you stand up for them you and your girlfriend will lose your jobs, and a taxidermist will hide under your bed as you have sex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** Or, you know, stop keeping the flatulent animals' numbers unnaturally high, unnaturally sedentary, and fed an unnatural diet, which increases the amount there to fart and increases the volume of gas passed. SoYeah, still our fault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And how exactly does Meg look anything like Peter (unlike Chris)? Apparently if she has a slight makeover, she becomes a hot blonde.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Not to mention that far more pollutants go into the air from methane from animal flatulence than from automobiles each year. For the good of the earth, kill all flatulent animals! So the plants won't be mad at us!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Remember, always be kind to your pets." If you're not, they'll turn into fireballs and cover the village in flaming goop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[AmazonsAttack Hey, they did pretty good when they attacked America!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*In an episode of ''Justice League Unlimited'', Wonder Woman tells fellow party-goers that if they don't start acting against global warming, then her Amazonian relatives will use military force to get something done about it. Riiiiight.

Top