Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / OutrankingYourJob

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Mac:''' [''grinning for once''] Sorry, I get to be the boss today. [''walks away'']

to:

-->'''Mac:''' [''grinning for once''] Sorry, I get to be the boss today.this week. [''walks away'']
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A subtle example in ''Film/Ghostbusters1984''. When Walter Peck serves the team his Cease and Desist order, the NYPD officer accompanying him wears the insignia of a captain - normally the commander of an entire precinct. Possibly justified; between Peck's ego and the Ghostbusters' celebrity status, this is the sort of situation that could warrant the personal attention of the NYPD's mid- to upper-level management... though that begs the question why the captain is the ''only'' officer involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/CriminalCase: City of Romance'', the Parisian Police Department's High Commissioner also serves as the team's Profiler and occasionally partners up with the player character to do field investigation when their regular partners are otherwise unavailable. Likewise, his son, the Chief of Police, often does analyses on various clues (something that none of the previous PD Chiefs ever does), and personally helps out a subordinate officer trying to investigate the disappearance of her brother. This is actually lampshaded by one of the suspects, who asks why the Chief of Police is patrolling around the streets like a common beat cop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Seemingly parodied with William de Worde, who transplants this trope into the world of ''journalism'', attempting to be both DaEditor and an IntrepidReporter. Since he more or less invented the industry on Discworld, it's not he, or anyone else, knows any better.

to:

** Seemingly parodied with William de Worde, who transplants this trope into the world of ''journalism'', attempting to be both DaEditor and an IntrepidReporter. Since he more or less invented the industry on Discworld, it's not as if he, or anyone else, knows any better.

Added: 365

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[* Captain Tommy Gregson of ''Series/{{Elementary}}'' is often seen assisting Detective Marcus Bell -- and, by extension, Sherlock Holmes and Joan Watson -- in the investigating of crime scenes, if not doing the investigations himself. He has also had to chase suspects and often interrogates them too.

to:

[* * Captain Tommy Gregson of ''Series/{{Elementary}}'' is often seen assisting Detective Marcus Bell -- and, by extension, Sherlock Holmes and Joan Watson -- in the investigating of crime scenes, if not doing the investigations himself. He has also had to chase suspects and often interrogates them too.


Added DiffLines:

* Played straight and then corrected on ''Series/{{Dragnet}}''. Joe Friday was promoted to lieutenant, but Jack Webb quietly made the character a sergeant again upon learning that lieutenants don't do investigative work[[note]]Webb was a stickler for authenticity and followed LAPD rules and regulations as strictly as he could in all versions of the show[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Franchise/WonderWoman'': In the Golden Age 1st Lt, and later Capt, ComicBook/SteveTrevor generally works alone or with Wondy and is only ever seen commanding a unit when he's rescuing a group of [=POWs=] from captivity.

to:

* ''Franchise/WonderWoman'': ''Franchise/WonderWoman'' [[ComicBook/WonderWoman1942 Vol 1]]: In the Golden Age 1st Lt, and later Capt, Capt and Major, ComicBook/SteveTrevor generally works alone or with Wondy and is only ever seen commanding a unit when he's rescuing a group of [=POWs=] from captivity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Downplayed in ''Literature/RedStormRising'' with General Alekseyev. He's a four-star general and the deputy to CINC-West, the general in charge of the entire war in Europe. But he temporarily steps in to command the 20th Tanks Division (a two-star general's job) when the division commander was killed in an airstrike.

Added: 213

Changed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Continues in ''VideoGame/Xcom2''



* In ''Videogame/Fallout4'', if you join the Minutemen, you are quickly promoted to the rank of General, but treated as a low-ranked mook, constantly told to go rescue kidnapped settlers by yourself.

to:

* In ''Videogame/Fallout4'', if you join the Minutemen, you are quickly promoted to the rank of General, but treated as a low-ranked mook, constantly told to go rescue kidnapped settlers by yourself. Justified because you are given the rank by the [[LastOfHisKind only other active Minuteman in existence]], and you are free to [[NonPlayerCompanion take him with you on you missions.]]
* ''VideoGame/TheElderScrollsIVOblivion'': at high levels, the only [[DemonicSpiders goblins]] you will find are Warlords and Shamans, with easily a Dozen Warlords in many caves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Mac:''' [''grinning for once''] Sorry, I get to be the boss today.[''walks away'']

to:

-->'''Mac:''' [''grinning for once''] Sorry, I get to be the boss today. [''walks away'']

Added: 390

Changed: 280

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Captain Tommy Gregson of ''Series/{{Elementary}}'' is often seen assisting Detective Marcus Bell -- and, by extension, Sherlock Holmes and Joan Watson -- in the investigating of crime scenes, if not doing the investigations himself. He has also had to chase suspects and often interrogates them too.

to:

* ** Subverted in one episode of ''Series/{{CSINY}}'' when Lindsay asks Det. Taylor to help her out with the mountain of evidence she needs to process.
-->'''Mac:''' [''grinning for once''] Sorry, I get to be the boss today.[''walks away'']
[*
Captain Tommy Gregson of ''Series/{{Elementary}}'' is often seen assisting Detective Marcus Bell -- and, by extension, Sherlock Holmes and Joan Watson -- in the investigating of crime scenes, if not doing the investigations himself. He has also had to chase suspects and often interrogates them too.

Added: 985

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/RunningWithTheDevil'', the Cook is a veteran drug smuggler who has risen through the ranks of a drug cartel and now is in charge of a major smuggling route from Colombia to Canada. However, someone is stealing from the cartel so his bosses order him to personally audit the entire smuggling chain and find the thief. This means that he has to go back in the field and supervise every exchange in the complex smuggling operation and personally protect the shipment when it is targeted by rival criminals. It is the type of work he has not done in years and it is way about his pay grade but his boss takes the theft personally and even assigns his personal hitman to assist the Cook.
** On the law enforcement side there is the DEA Agent In Charge who should be supervising the investigation from her office rather than personally interviewing a junkie. However, a bad batch of drugs sold by the Man killed her sister so she takes a very personal interest in the case.



* ''Literature/TheWonderfulWizardOfOz'': Frank L. Baum seemed to like playing this trope for laughs. It may be that in [[{{Cloudcuckooland}} Oz]], this is the normal state of formal militaries.

to:

* ''Literature/TheWonderfulWizardOfOz'': Frank L. Baum seemed to like playing this trope for laughs. It may be that in [[{{Cloudcuckooland}} Oz]], this is the normal state of formal militaries.militarizes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the following expansion, ''Legion'', the player character was made leader of an entire faction based on their class, such as Warriors leading Odyn's Valajar armies or Paladins leading the Order of the Silver Hand. Again, there was some examples of assigning missions to followers, the vast majority of the player's efforts were... going out and personally killing things.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Played straight with Samantha Traynor, your communications specialist. Due to the presence of the ArtificialIntelligence EDI on-board the ''Normandy'', her job amounts to an extremely over-qualified secretary. Justified, as [[FantasticRacism anti-AI sentiment]] meant EDI was pretending to be nothing more than a VI during the ''Normandy'''s retrofitting to avoid getting shut down, and if that were true, Traynor would definitely be needed.

to:

** Played straight with Samantha Traynor, your communications specialist. Due to the presence of the ArtificialIntelligence EDI on-board the ''Normandy'', her job amounts to an extremely over-qualified secretary. Justified, as [[FantasticRacism anti-AI sentiment]] meant EDI was pretending to be nothing more than a VI during the ''Normandy'''s retrofitting to avoid getting shut down, and if that were true, Traynor would definitely be needed. Also her job quickly grows into being in charge of cryptography and signal tracking for the Normandy and much of the fleet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Lampshaded in ''Literature/RainbowSix''. When Rainbow is initially formed, Ding and Clark assume they will be granted the respective ranks of captain and colonel, and are surprised to be addressed as Major Chavez and ''General'' Clark. Note that the entire Rainbow unit, including support staff, consists of less than 50 people. And all the enlisted personnel under them were various flavors of Sergeant (Which is justified by the fact that they were all recruited from various special forces units, which requires several years experience and the promotions that go with them before being considered for entry).

to:

* Lampshaded in ''Literature/RainbowSix''. When Rainbow is initially formed, Ding and Clark assume they will be granted the respective ranks of captain captain[[note]]which Ding notes is senior enough to receive proper respect while junior enough to go out in the field and see action[[/note]] and colonel, and are surprised to be addressed as Major Chavez and ''General'' Clark. Note that the entire Rainbow unit, including support staff, consists of less than 50 people. And all the enlisted personnel under them were various flavors of Sergeant (Which is justified by the fact that they were all recruited from various special forces units, which requires several years experience and the promotions that go with them before being considered for entry).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When he's not just giving exposition to ComicBook/{{Batman}}, Commissioner Gordon is often depicted as personally leading investigations and hunting down criminals as if he were a beat cop. His wife lampshades this on at least one occasion, noting the police commissioner isn't even supposed to wear cuffs. Ironically, the [[Series/{{Batman}} Adam West show's]] mild-mannered, [[PoliceAreUseless utterly ineffectual]] politico is probably the most ''realistic'' version of Gordon on-air. However, Gordon does have a logical in-universe reason: Gotham PD is so incredibly corrupt that anything important enough for Batman is probably also something any corrupt cop would be working to cover up.

to:

* When he's not just giving exposition to ComicBook/{{Batman}}, Commissioner Gordon is often depicted as personally leading investigations and hunting down criminals as if he were a beat cop. His wife lampshades this on at least one occasion, noting the police commissioner isn't even supposed to wear cuffs. Ironically, the [[Series/{{Batman}} [[Series/Batman1966 Adam West show's]] mild-mannered, [[PoliceAreUseless utterly ineffectual]] politico is probably the most ''realistic'' version of Gordon on-air. However, Gordon does have a logical in-universe reason: Gotham PD is so incredibly corrupt that anything important enough for Batman is probably also something any corrupt cop would be working to cover up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** During the planning for Emperor Gregor's wedding, Lt. Ivan Xav Vorpatril is assigned to help the upper-class women planning the thing, which is strictly-speaking below his pay grade. This includes his own mother, the Emperor's social protocol manager. He describes the situation in the following picturesque metaphor;

to:

** During the planning for Emperor Gregor's wedding, Lt. Captain Ivan Xav Vorpatril is assigned to help the upper-class women planning the thing, which is strictly-speaking below his pay grade. This includes his own mother, the Emperor's social protocol manager. He describes the situation in the following picturesque metaphor;
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When he's not just giving exposition to ComicBook/{{Batman}}, Commissioner Gordon is often depicted as personally leading investigations and hunting down criminals as if he were a beat cop. His wife lampshades this on at least one occasion, noting the police commissioner isn't even supposed to wear cuffs. Ironically, the [[Series/{{Batman}} Adam West show's]] mild-mannered, [[PoliceAreUseless utterly ineffectual]] politico is probably the most ''realistic'' version of Gordon on-air.

to:

* When he's not just giving exposition to ComicBook/{{Batman}}, Commissioner Gordon is often depicted as personally leading investigations and hunting down criminals as if he were a beat cop. His wife lampshades this on at least one occasion, noting the police commissioner isn't even supposed to wear cuffs. Ironically, the [[Series/{{Batman}} Adam West show's]] mild-mannered, [[PoliceAreUseless utterly ineffectual]] politico is probably the most ''realistic'' version of Gordon on-air. However, Gordon does have a logical in-universe reason: Gotham PD is so incredibly corrupt that anything important enough for Batman is probably also something any corrupt cop would be working to cover up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Videogame/Fallout4'', if you join the Minutemen, you are quickly promoted to the rank of General, but treated as a low-ranked mook, constantly told to go rescue kidnapped settlers by yourself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Link fix.


** Almost played straight in the third game as reportedly some members of the Bioware team wanted the council to award Shepard the rank of "Supreme Commander" and yet would still have Shepard commanding only the Normandy and leading his three man team. However the title was deemed a bit too [[Narm hokey]] and the promotion was never carried out.

to:

** Almost played straight in the third game as reportedly some members of the Bioware team wanted the council to award Shepard the rank of "Supreme Commander" and yet would still have Shepard commanding only the Normandy and leading his three man team. However the title was deemed a bit too [[Narm [[{{Narm}} hokey]] and the promotion was never carried out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Franchise/WonderWoman'': In the Golden Age 1st Lt, and later Capt, ComicBook/SteveTrevor generally works alone or with Wondy and is only ever seen commanding a unit when he's rescuing a group of [=POWs=] from captivity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Pulling this. Shepard commands the Normandy as a Spectre, and the military doctrine and responsibilities involved are different (the ship is primarily a vehicle used for intel work rather than a warship).


* ''VideoGame/MassEffect1'' has you playing Shepard, a Lieutenant Commander in the Alliance Navy. Early in the game Shepard assumes command of an advanced reconnaissance frigate, but he/she also leads every away mission, typically leaving Navigator Pressly in command. In any modern real-life navy, the captain's place is on the ship, and he/she would have specialized teams to handle away missions, such as Marines or [=SEALs=]. You also only bring two crew members with you on your missions. It's unlikely a 3-man team would even have an officer in charge; they would typically be led by a junior NCO. Further complicating things is the fact that Shepard is both an Alliance officer and a Spectre, the latter putting him/her outside of the Alliance command structure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[Series/McMillanAndWife Stewart McMillan]]'' is the Police Commissioner of San Francisco, who solves murders with the help of only one sergeant and his civilian wife.

to:

* ''[[Series/McMillanAndWife On ''Series/McMillanAndWife'', Stewart McMillan]]'' McMillan is the Police Commissioner of San Francisco, who solves murders with the help of only one sergeant and his civilian wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''[[Series/McMillanAndWife Stewart McMillan]]'' is the Police Commissioner of San Francisco, who solves murders with the help of only one sergeant and his civilian wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Almost played straight in the third game as reportedly some members of the Bioware team wanted the council to award Shepard the rank of "Supreme Commander" and yet would still have Shepard commanding only the Normandy and leading his three man team. However the title was deemed a bit too [[Narm hokey]] and the promotion was never carried out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* More or less the rule in human spaceflight. The small size of crews (the largest crew on a spacecraft has been eight on two shuttle flights, and at one point 13 for a few days on the International Space Station) and the need for experienced personnel means that commanders (who are almost always military officers, and senior ones at that) are in charge of only a handful of people, sometimes just one. On Apollo-Soyuz in 1975 this led to a situation where a General (Tom Stafford, who was a Brigadier General in the USAF at the time, he retired as a Lieutenant General) was only commanding 2 other men. Apollo 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17 were commanded by Navy Captains and Colonels, one rank below that of that of the flag officers (Rear Admiral Lower Half through Admiral for Navy and Brigadier General through General for Air Force).

to:

* More or less the rule in human spaceflight. The small size of crews (the largest crew on a spacecraft has been eight on two shuttle flights, and at one point 13 for a few days on the International Space Station) and the need for experienced personnel means that commanders (who are almost always military officers, and senior ones at that) are in charge of only a handful of people, sometimes just one. On Apollo-Soyuz in 1975 this led to a situation where a General (Tom Stafford, who was a Brigadier General in the USAF at the time, he retired as a Lieutenant General) was only commanding 2 other men.men, while on the Soviet side, Alexey Leonov (a Colonel at the time) commanded just a single subordinate, Valery Kubasov, his flight engineer, who wasn't even in the military. Apollo 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17 were commanded by Navy Captains and Colonels, one rank below that of that of the flag officers (Rear Admiral Lower Half through Admiral for Navy and Brigadier General through General for Air Force).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Averted with Pash Cracken, who voluntarily accepts a demotion to join Rogue Squadron in ''Wedge's Gamble'', then resumes his former rank and is PutOnABus in ''The Bacta War''.

to:

*** Averted with Pash Cracken, who voluntarily accepts a demotion to join Rogue Squadron in ''Wedge's Gamble'', then resumes his former rank and is PutOnABus in ''The Bacta War''.War'' when the rest of the squadron resigns; Pash can't stay because with his father, he knows his presence would ensure nobody believed the Rogues had truly gone renegade.



** Also largely averted in the Wraith Squadron books. Wedge is still a Commander, making him if anything under-ranked for someone who is in overall command whenever the Wraiths and Rogues are working together. The rest of the Wraiths are either Flight Officers or Lieutenants, with one eventually promoted to Captain.

to:

** Also largely averted in the Wraith Squadron books. Wedge is still a Commander, making him if anything under-ranked for someone who is in overall command whenever the Wraiths and Rogues are working together. The rest of the Wraiths are either Flight Officers or Lieutenants, with one eventually promoted to Captain.Captain when Wedge transfers back to the Rogues and chooses him to lead the Wraiths in the field in his absence.

Added: 1024

Changed: 781

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''Literature/XWingSeries'' eventually sees Wedge Antilles promoted to General, while many of his subordinates are also promoted... resulting in a unit in which half the pilots outrank the ''commanders'' of other squadrons. Somewhat justified in that Rogue Squadron is an elite unit. Averted with Pash Cracken, who voluntarily accepts a demotion to join Rogue Squadron.
** This is actually deconstructed, as once this happens...Rogue Squadron tends to pretty much break up, with them going to command other squadrons, and only reforming in special instances, or leaving Rogue Squadron proper to the next generation.

to:

* The ''Literature/XWingSeries'' eventually sees ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'':
** ''Literature/XWingSeries'': ZigZagged.
***
Wedge Antilles promoted to General, while many Antilles, the commander of both Rogue and Wraith Squadrons for most of the series, spends most of it DecliningPromotion so he can keep flying (he's ranked commander, which in ''Franchise/StarWars'''s rank system is apparently higher than captain but below general). In ''Isard's Revenge'' Admiral Ackbar finally guilts him into accepting his long-delayed general's pips on grounds that his subordinates are also promoted... resulting following his example. This results in a unit in which half the pilots outrank the ''commanders'' of other squadrons. Somewhat justified {{justified}} in that Rogue Squadron is an elite unit. Averted with Pash Cracken, who voluntarily accepts a demotion to join Rogue Squadron.
** This is actually deconstructed, as
unit, and also {{deconstructed}} in that once this happens...these promotion cycles happen, Rogue Squadron tends to pretty much break up, with them going to command other squadrons, and only reforming in special instances, or leaving Rogue Squadron proper to the next generation.generation.
*** Averted with Pash Cracken, who voluntarily accepts a demotion to join Rogue Squadron in ''Wedge's Gamble'', then resumes his former rank and is PutOnABus in ''The Bacta War''.



** Generally averted when these characters appear in the ''Literature/NewJediOrder'' series, though many have apparently not been promoted in the interim. Wedge, as a General, is seen commanding task forces and the defense of entire systems, with Tycho frequently as his second in command. Wes and Hobbie are squadron commanders, as is Gavin Darklighter, now a Colonel and in command of Rogue Squadron itself.

to:

** Generally averted when these characters appear in the ''Literature/NewJediOrder'' series, though many have apparently not been promoted in the interim. Wedge, as a General, is seen commanding task forces and the defense of entire systems, with Tycho frequently as his second in command. Wes and Hobbie are squadron commanders, as is Gavin Darklighter, now a Colonel and in command of Rogue Squadron itself. Corran Horn, meanwhile, left the military entirely to join the Jedi Order (his commission is reactivated in ''Edge of Victory II: Ruin'').
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Stargate}}'' has Colonel O'Neil leading a specialized team of a Lieutenant Colonel, a number of Lieutenants, and a civilian scientist. And an alien who was roughly equivalent to a 4-star general before defecting. Justified both because this is an elite unit and because many of the team members have highly advanced qualifications.

to:

* ''Film/{{Stargate}}'' has Colonel O'Neil leading a specialized team of a Lieutenant Colonel, a number of Lieutenants, and a civilian scientist. And an alien who was roughly equivalent to a 4-star general before defecting. Justified both because Of course this is an elite unit and because many justified as United States Air Force is accustomed to sending small teams of the team members have highly advanced qualifications.experienced officers (aka flight crews) on long missions away from a base.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Similarly, Brigadier General Theodore Roosevelt Jr. (yes, President UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt's son) insisted on going with the troops landing on Utah Beach, feeling that in the chaos that was going to ensue, ''someone'' had to be on the scene who could take control and make the necessary strategic decisions. [[BadassGrandpa At 56 years of age]], and [[{{Determinator}} while suffering from arthritis and heart trouble]], he led his troops on the beach using his cane to signal with. He ended up dying of a heart attack the following month.

to:

* Similarly, Brigadier General Theodore Roosevelt Jr. (yes, President UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt's son) insisted on going with the troops landing on Utah Beach, feeling that in the chaos that was going to ensue, ''someone'' had to be on the scene who could take control and make the necessary strategic decisions. [[BadassGrandpa [[OldSoldier At 56 years of age]], and [[{{Determinator}} while suffering from arthritis and heart trouble]], he led his troops on the beach using his cane to signal with. He ended up dying of a heart attack the following month.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** During the planning for Emperor Gregor's wedding, Lt. Ivan Xav Vorpatril is assigned to help the upper-class women planning the thing. This includes his own mother, the Emperor's social protocol manager. He describes the situation in the following picturesque metaphor;

to:

** During the planning for Emperor Gregor's wedding, Lt. Ivan Xav Vorpatril is assigned to help the upper-class women planning the thing.thing, which is strictly-speaking below his pay grade. This includes his own mother, the Emperor's social protocol manager. He describes the situation in the following picturesque metaphor;



* The various ''VideoGame/{{Wolfenstein}}'' games have Captain BJ Blazkowicz as the player character. He commands no one. Justified, in that BJ works for the OSS.

to:

* The various ''VideoGame/{{Wolfenstein}}'' games have Captain BJ Blazkowicz as the player character. He commands no one. Justified, in that BJ works for the OSS.OSS; see Real Life below.

Top