Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / JustTrainWrong

Go To

OR

Added: 1078

Changed: 590

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Grace pulls the emergency brake in the passenger car it should have activated the brakes. Train brakes can be operated operated from any car in an emergency, and don't need the brake throttle [[spoiler: like Gabriel had destroyed]] in the locomotive intact to activate them.

to:

** When Grace pulls the emergency brake in the passenger car it should have activated the brakes. Train brakes can be operated operated from any car in an emergency, and don't need the brake throttle [[spoiler: like Gabriel had destroyed]] in the locomotive intact to activate them.



* ''Film/MurderOnTheOrientExpress2017'':
** The Orient Express is pulled by a heavily modified [[https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/23/241P17_%C3%A0_Dole.JPG SNCF Class 241]] during the whole course of the movie. While the train goes through Turkey and Yugoslavia, the locomotive never changes. In real life, regulations at the time would necessitate that the locomotive be changed at every border crossing.
** The Class 241 was built from 1948 to 1952, [[AnachronismStew but the movie takes place in 1934]].
** When the passengers are boarding the Orient Express in Istanbul, the locomotive looks like a [[https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/eb/Orient-Expre%C3%9F_mit_Lok_Klasse_C.jpg Württemberg C]]. While this is an accurate locomotive that actually pulled the Orient Express, the displayed locomotive number is fantasy. And none of them were sold to the Turkish State Railways.



* The subway train scene in ''Film/{{Predator 2}}'' is set on a train in Los Angeles, or rather, a San Francisco [[UsefulNotes/BayAreaRapidTransit BART]] train being passed off as an LACMTA Red Line train. Now, it's kind of justifiable since at the time the film was made (1990), the Los Angeles Metro Red subway line was under construction at the time, and clearly not yet available for the film, which actually takes place in 1997, by which point, the line was opened for 4 years.

to:

* The subway train scene in ''Film/{{Predator 2}}'' is set on a train in Los Angeles, or rather, a San Francisco [[UsefulNotes/BayAreaRapidTransit BART]] train being passed off as an LACMTA Red Line UsefulNotes/LosAngelesMetroRail train. Now, it's kind of This one is admittedly justifiable since at the time the film was made (1990), the Los Angeles Metro Red subway line was still under construction at the time, and clearly not yet available for the film, which actually takes place in 1997, by which point, point the line was opened had been open for 4 years.



* In ''Film/{{Skyfall}}'', part of Bond's foot pursuit of Raoul Silva takes place on a Jubilee line train of 1996 Stock that is trying to pass itself off as a subsurface District Line train, which used D78 Stock when the film came out.
** Also, due to both Temple and Embankment being cut and cover stations, their District line platforms in the same tunnel rather than separate ones.

to:

* In ''Film/{{Skyfall}}'', part ''Film/{{Skyfall}}'':
** Part
of Bond's foot pursuit of Raoul Silva takes place on a Jubilee line train of 1996 Stock that is trying to pass itself off as a subsurface District Line train, which used D78 Stock when the film came out.
** Also, due to both Temple and Embankment being cut and cover stations, their District line platforms for the Circle and District lines are in the same tunnel rather than separate ones.



*** Also in ''Skyfall'' in the opening sequence in Turkey, while Bond is chasing after the stolen hard drive; Patrice shoots open the coupling of the train. The railcar Bond is on continues to coast after the train ahead. In reality the separation of the brake hoses on the train would cause the trailing cars Bond was on to begin to immediately apply emergency brakes, bringing him to a quick stop.

to:

*** Also in ''Skyfall'' in ** In the opening sequence in Turkey, while Bond is chasing after the stolen hard drive; Patrice shoots open the coupling of the train. The railcar Bond is on continues to coast after the train ahead. In reality the separation of the brake hoses on the train would cause the trailing cars Bond was on to begin to immediately apply emergency brakes, bringing him to a quick stop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/MissionImpossibleDeadReckoningPartOne''

to:

* ''Film/MissionImpossibleDeadReckoningPartOne''''Film/MissionImpossibleDeadReckoning'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added to Video Game section.

Added DiffLines:

*According to [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7LNr8QCAzmM this Youtube video]], ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoV'' has the following errors in its railroad layout:
** Loading platforms that are too wide & bridges that are too narrow for trains to pass.
** The occasional railroad crossing cantilever that faces the ''tracks'' instead of the road.
** Railroad crossing posts with gate boxes but no gates.
** Speed signs that say "78/10" regardless of where they're placed.
** Random signal arrangements that are always green no matter what (including ''dual signals for a single track'').
** Signs with nonsensical letters on them ("A", "E", etc.).
** Cars left on a track that are blocking the main line.
** A ''passenger platform in a freight yard.''
** "Crunchy" track radiuses.
** A derailed wellcar left off to the side of a track.
** A "LOOK BOTH WAYS" streetcar warning sign for track that commercial freight trains pass on.
** Railroad crossing cantilevers facing the inside of the crossing rather than the outside.
** Almost no crossing or signal bungalows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LEGO [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E4F09UsPtAY shot a commercial in 2022]] to advertise a collector's set based on the Hogwart's Express from the Harry Potter films. But with ''Olton Hall'' in long term storage at the Warner Brothers Studios in London and her mainline certification expired, LEGO looked for a similarly painted red locomotive and settled on using Keighley & Worth Valley Railway's 41241, an [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LMS_Ivatt_Class_2_2-6-2T LMS Ivatt Class 2]] locomotive. Other than the red color, the engine has no resemblance to the Hall class the LEGO set depicts.

to:

* LEGO [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E4F09UsPtAY shot a commercial in 2022]] to advertise a collector's set based on the Hogwart's Express from the Harry Potter films. But with ''Olton Hall'' in long term storage at the Warner Brothers Studios in London and her mainline certification expired, LEGO looked for a similarly painted red locomotive and settled on using Keighley & Worth Valley Railway's 41241, an [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LMS_Ivatt_Class_2_2-6-2T LMS Ivatt Class 2]] locomotive.locomotive, which, unlike the Hogwarts Express, doesn't even have a tender. Other than the red color, the engine has no resemblance to the Hall class the LEGO set depicts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Easily, the number one mistake is showing a steam locomotive without a tender or bunker and tanks -- which usually means that it doesn't have any fuel or water and therefore can't move -- or having no rods to move it or a mishmash of rods and wheels in all the wrong places. And even if there is a tender, it often looks like one big fuel bunker on wheels with nowhere to put the water. Other common departures from reality might involve a RunawayTrain's safety systems [[FailsafeFailure failing]] without any justifiable reason, or the wrong kind of train or rolling stock for the script. Whenever a train appears, it'll almost always be blasting its horn or whistle (if even that, as sometimes they'll use whistles on diesels and horns on steam engines instead of vice-versa), when in real life trains are only meant to sound their horns and/or whistles at set points along the route such as at level crossings, or if there's something or someone on the track. But, hey, most viewers don't know or care what the proper train would look like, ''or'' the ins-and-outs of railway operations. And more often than not, in media that may involve trains or railroads in general as part of the premise, the engineer is commonly incorrectly referred to as the "conductor". Conductors look after trains and make sure they are safe to ride on or operate. Engineers instead operate the trains themselves and focus on driving them from one place to another. Another thing many pieces of media get wrong about trains are the coupler designs. Many of these trains are depicted with a very cheaply designed coupling system with two links held together by a dinky little bolt with only one large cap on the top which makes the whole coupler system look like it should belong on a tractor and a trailer.

to:

Easily, the number one mistake is showing a steam locomotive without a tender or bunker and tanks -- which usually means that it doesn't have any fuel or water and therefore can't move -- or having no rods to move it or a mishmash of rods and wheels in all the wrong places. And even if there is a tender, it often looks like one big fuel bunker on wheels with nowhere to put the water. Other common departures from reality might involve a RunawayTrain's safety systems [[FailsafeFailure failing]] without any justifiable reason, or the wrong kind of train or rolling stock for the script. Whenever a train appears, it'll almost always be blasting its horn or whistle (if even that, as sometimes they'll use whistles on diesels and horns on steam engines instead of vice-versa), when in real life trains are only meant to sound their horns and/or whistles at set points along the route such as at level crossings, or if there's something or someone on the track. But, hey, most viewers don't know or care what the proper train would look like, ''or'' the ins-and-outs of railway operations. And more often than not, in media that may involve trains or railroads in general as part of the premise, the engineer is commonly incorrectly referred to as the "conductor". Conductors look after trains and make sure they are safe to ride on or operate. Engineers instead operate the trains themselves and focus on driving them from one place to another. Another thing many pieces of media get wrong about trains are the coupler designs. Many of these trains are depicted with a very cheaply designed coupling system with two links held together by a dinky little bolt with only one large cap on the top which makes the whole coupler system look like it should belong on came from a tractor and a trailer.
trailer. It's possible that these couplers are a more simplistic take on the "Link and Pin" couplers from the mid to late 1800s which were the very first couplers used on American railroads, hence why they're used more often than a more accurate "Knuckle Coupler" design which were created in the late 1800s which eventually replaced all link and pin couplers on many modern-day railroads.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Easily, the number one mistake is showing a steam locomotive without a tender or bunker and tanks -- which usually means that it doesn't have any fuel or water and therefore can't move -- or having no rods to move it or a mishmash of rods and wheels in all the wrong places. And even if there is a tender, it often looks like one big fuel bunker on wheels with nowhere to put the water. Other common departures from reality might involve a RunawayTrain's safety systems [[FailsafeFailure failing]] without any justifiable reason, or the wrong kind of train or rolling stock for the script. Whenever a train appears, it'll almost always be blasting its horn or whistle (if even that, as sometimes they'll use whistles on diesels and horns on steam engines instead of vice-versa), when in real life trains are only meant to sound their horns and/or whistles at set points along the route such as at level crossings, or if there's something or someone on the track. But, hey, most viewers don't know or care what the proper train would look like, ''or'' the ins-and-outs of railway operations. And more often than not, in media that may involve trains or railroads in general as part of the premise, the engineer is commonly incorrectly referred to as the "conductor". Conductors look after trains and make sure they are safe to ride on or operate. Engineers instead operate the trains themselves and focus on driving them from one place to another.

to:

Easily, the number one mistake is showing a steam locomotive without a tender or bunker and tanks -- which usually means that it doesn't have any fuel or water and therefore can't move -- or having no rods to move it or a mishmash of rods and wheels in all the wrong places. And even if there is a tender, it often looks like one big fuel bunker on wheels with nowhere to put the water. Other common departures from reality might involve a RunawayTrain's safety systems [[FailsafeFailure failing]] without any justifiable reason, or the wrong kind of train or rolling stock for the script. Whenever a train appears, it'll almost always be blasting its horn or whistle (if even that, as sometimes they'll use whistles on diesels and horns on steam engines instead of vice-versa), when in real life trains are only meant to sound their horns and/or whistles at set points along the route such as at level crossings, or if there's something or someone on the track. But, hey, most viewers don't know or care what the proper train would look like, ''or'' the ins-and-outs of railway operations. And more often than not, in media that may involve trains or railroads in general as part of the premise, the engineer is commonly incorrectly referred to as the "conductor". Conductors look after trains and make sure they are safe to ride on or operate. Engineers instead operate the trains themselves and focus on driving them from one place to another.
another. Another thing many pieces of media get wrong about trains are the coupler designs. Many of these trains are depicted with a very cheaply designed coupling system with two links held together by a dinky little bolt with only one large cap on the top which makes the whole coupler system look like it should belong on a tractor and a trailer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* You can see the same thing in the TV ending of second season of ''Anime/MinamiKe'' where [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWwPKTX36I8 Kana is walking on a ludicrously wide-gauged train track]]. Either that or Kana is about one meter tall. There are also no signal posts for the trains as far as an eye can see.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* There are ''lots'' of ''obvious errors'' in ''Anime/LoveChuunibyoAndOtherDelusions'' like adult characters being shorter than rail gauge[[note]]the distance between rails in a single track[[/note]] which is about one meter in Japan. It's particularly jarring considering how Japanese ''love'' trains.

to:

* There are ''lots'' of ''obvious errors'' in ''Anime/LoveChuunibyoAndOtherDelusions'' ''Anime/LoveChunibyoAndOtherDelusions'' like adult characters being shorter than rail gauge[[note]]the distance between rails in a single track[[/note]] which is about one meter in Japan. It's particularly jarring considering how Japanese ''love'' trains.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* There are ''lots'' of ''obvious errors'' in ''Anime/LoveChuunibyoAndOtherDelusions'' like adult characters being shorter than rail gauge[[note]]the distance between rails in a single track[[/note]] which is about one meter in Japan. It's particularly jarring considering how Japanese ''love'' trains.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Australian films set in the 1930s which require a steam train (such as ''{{Film/Sirens}}'' and ''Film/RabbitProofFence'') will use stock footage from the 1974 film ''A Steam Train Passes''. However, the locomotive featured in ''A Steam Train Passes'' wasn't built until the 1940s.

to:

* Australian films set in the 1930s which require a steam train (such as ''{{Film/Sirens}}'' ''{{Film/Sirens|1994}}'' and ''Film/RabbitProofFence'') will use stock footage from the 1974 film ''A Steam Train Passes''. However, the locomotive featured in ''A Steam Train Passes'' wasn't built until the 1940s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A common error in many cartoons is for steam engines to be operated by only the driver (engineer in American terms), with the fireman being mysteriously absent. Slightly TruthInTelevision: smaller tank engines used for shunting or short lines were able to be operated by one person most of the time, but not large mainline tender engines.

to:

* A common error in many cartoons is for steam engines to be operated by only the driver (engineer in American terms), with the fireman being mysteriously absent. This could be due to the fact that many modern diesel and electric trains don't require a fireman and only the engineer. Slightly TruthInTelevision: smaller tank engines used for shunting or short lines were able to be operated by one person most of the time, but not large mainline tender engines.

Added: 785

Changed: 783

Removed: 225

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''WesternAnimation/ThePolarExpress'': Things like the rolling stock bending around a mountain peak or a 100% decline, the length of the train keeps varying from five to about a dozen coaches etc etc. And let's not start on the scene with the train crossing the frozen body of water and slithering across the ice like a snake while being steered by changing the rotation of the drivers on the locomotive.[[note]]The usage of alternating forward and reverse to control the train's sliding is actually ''more'' plausible than the most glaring issue to rail enthusiasts: that being that the violent, sudden manner in which the engineer repeatedly switched from forward to reverse and back again should have torn the running gear to pieces.[[/note]] That said, it was explicitly stated to be a "[[AWizardDidIt magic]] train."

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/ThePolarExpress'': ''WesternAnimation/ThePolarExpress'':
**
Things like the rolling stock bending around a mountain peak or a 100% decline, the length of the train keeps varying from five to about a dozen coaches etc etc. And let's not start on the scene with the train crossing the frozen body of water and slithering across the ice like a snake while being steered by changing the rotation of the drivers on the locomotive.[[note]]The usage of alternating forward and reverse to control the train's sliding is actually ''more'' plausible than the most glaring issue to rail enthusiasts: that being that the violent, sudden manner in which the engineer repeatedly switched from forward to reverse and back again should have torn the running gear to pieces.[[/note]] That said, it was explicitly stated to be a "[[AWizardDidIt magic]] train."



** They got the NS logo (the horse and the NS) but ''not'' the distinctive striping on the front of the locomotive. For a railfan, the easy assumption was that it was Russian mobsters in Newark (or some other Rust Belt city).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/HowIMetYourMother'' spent a fair bit of time on Long Island trains in its ninth season, and the interiors were usually accurate. However, the stock footage used for views out the windows used an image of a suburban train from Melbourne, Australia in one episode, as elucidated [[https://danielbowen.com/2013/09/29/himym-comeng-train/ here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's possible this is a locomotive on loan to a company that operates in Pennsylvania (something railroads sometimes do), but that's highly unlikely to occur on just any random train.

to:

** It's possible this is a locomotive on loan to a company that operates in Pennsylvania (something railroads sometimes do), but that's highly unlikely to occur on just any random train. In this case, it's because while the film was set in Pennsylvania, [[CaliforniaDoubling it was shot in Illinois]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheStoryOfCaseyJr'':
** The eponymous Casey Jr. is shown without his rods connected to his cylinders, which no steam train can move without.
** Later, Casey jumps over a broken bridge with the entire circus train behind him, and lands without issue. He may be a cartoon, but normally trains that fall off bridges just plummet to their doom thanks to gravity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Feel free to correct me later on issues of context.


* Read any given English language article on UsefulNotes/HighSpeedRail and look for the mistakes. It's fun! Classics include mixing up average and top speeds ("UsefulNotes/{{China}} runs trains at 300 km/h whereas hours only average 50 mph"), calling it "the" or "a" high speed rail, as if the rail itself was somehow high speed (no it's not, "high speed rail" is shorthand for "rail vehicles and technology that allow operation at high speed" the physical line is called [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a "high speed ''line''"]]), getting usual ticket costs wrong, weird notions on what a "profitable" rail line means and of course lots and lots of misconceptions on how trains work. No, high speed rail will not simply use the existing single-track infrastructure, no there will be no level crossings with trains passing at 200 mph, no high-speed rail does not use Diesel ([[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InterCity_125 except when it does)]], no high-speed rail does not usually share track with freight. Some of this can be excused by HSR simply not existing in most of the Anglosphere.

to:

* Read any given English language article on UsefulNotes/HighSpeedRail and look for the mistakes. It's fun! Classics include mixing up average and top speeds ("UsefulNotes/{{China}} runs trains at 300 km/h whereas hours only average 50 mph"), calling it "the" or "a" high speed rail, as if the rail itself was somehow high speed (no it's not, "high speed rail" is shorthand for "rail vehicles and technology that allow operation at high speed" the physical line is called [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a "high speed ''line''"]]), getting usual ticket costs wrong, weird notions on what a "profitable" rail line means and of course lots and lots of misconceptions on how trains work. No, high speed rail will not simply use the existing single-track infrastructure, no infrastructure. No, there will be no level crossings with trains passing at 200 mph, no mph. No, high-speed rail does not use Diesel ([[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InterCity_125 except when it does)]], no does)]]. And no, high-speed rail does not usually share track with freight.freight services (mostly because timing the high-speed trains to avoid deadly collisions with the slower but heavier freight trains would give traffic control personnel a nightmare). Some of this can be excused by HSR simply not existing in most of the Anglosphere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Read any given English language article on UsefulNotes/HighSpeedRail and look for the mistakes. It's fun! Classics include mixing up average and top speeds ("UsefulNotes/{{China}} runs trains at 300 km/h whereas hours only average 50 mph"), calling it "the" or "a" high speed rail, as if the rail itself was somehow high speed (no it's not, "high speed rail" is shorthand for "rail vehicles and technology that allow operation at high speed" the physical line is called [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a "high speed ''line''"]]), getting usual ticket costs wrong, weird notions on what a "profitable" rail line means and of course lots and lots of misconceptions on how trains work. No, high speed rail will not simply use the existing single-track infrastructure, no there will be no level crossings with trains passing at 200 mph, no high-speed rail does not use Diesel, no high-speed rail does not usually share track with freight. Some of this can be excused by HSR simply not existing in most of the Anglosphere.

to:

* Read any given English language article on UsefulNotes/HighSpeedRail and look for the mistakes. It's fun! Classics include mixing up average and top speeds ("UsefulNotes/{{China}} runs trains at 300 km/h whereas hours only average 50 mph"), calling it "the" or "a" high speed rail, as if the rail itself was somehow high speed (no it's not, "high speed rail" is shorthand for "rail vehicles and technology that allow operation at high speed" the physical line is called [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a "high speed ''line''"]]), getting usual ticket costs wrong, weird notions on what a "profitable" rail line means and of course lots and lots of misconceptions on how trains work. No, high speed rail will not simply use the existing single-track infrastructure, no there will be no level crossings with trains passing at 200 mph, no high-speed rail does not use Diesel, Diesel ([[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InterCity_125 except when it does)]], no high-speed rail does not usually share track with freight. Some of this can be excused by HSR simply not existing in most of the Anglosphere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The franshise's 2021 reboot, ''WesternAnimation/ThomasAndFriendsAllEnginesGo'', takes this trope all the way up to 11 and beyond, with the engines and vehicles being far cartoonier than just colors and faces (the engines flat out use their wheels or buffers as limbs at times), and at times can seem like they are made of rubber rather than metal. The size discrepancies between the engines are also worsened.

to:

** The franshise's 2021 reboot, ''WesternAnimation/ThomasAndFriendsAllEnginesGo'', takes this trope all the way up to 11 and beyond, with the engines and vehicles being far cartoonier than just colors and faces (the engines flat out use their wheels or buffers as limbs at times), and at times can seem like they are made of rubber rather than metal. The size discrepancies between the engines are also worsened. There's a good reason the page image is (currently) a screencap from the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/TheSwarm'', the driver falls against the brake, shoving it forward, causing the train to speed up and crash. Pushing the brake forward applies it, and applying the brakes is how you ''stop'' the train.

to:

* In ''Film/TheSwarm'', ''Film/TheSwarm1978'', the driver falls against the brake, shoving it forward, causing the train to speed up and crash. Pushing the brake forward applies it, and applying the brakes is how you ''stop'' the train.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Easily, the number one mistake is showing a steam locomotive without a tender or bunker and tanks -- which usually means that it doesn't have any fuel or water and therefore can't move -- or having no rods to move it or a mishmash of rods and wheels in all the wrong places. And even if there is a tender, it often looks like one big fuel bunker on wheels with nowhere to put the water. Other common departures from reality might involve a RunawayTrain's safety systems [[FailsafeFailure failing]] without any justifiable reason, or the wrong kind of train or rolling stock for the script. Whenever a train appears, it'll almost always be blasting its horn or whistle (if even that, as sometimes they'll use whistles on diesels and horns on steam engines instead of vice-versa), when in real life trains are only meant to sound their horns and/or whistles at set points along the route such as at level crossings, or if there's something or someone on the track. But, hey, most viewers don't know or care what the proper train would look like, ''or'' the ins-and-outs of railway operations. And more often than not, in media may involve trains as part of the premise, the engineer is commonly incorrectly referred to as the "conductor". Conductors look after trains and make sure they are safe to ride on or operate. Engineers instead operate the trains themselves and focus on driving them from one place to another.

to:

Easily, the number one mistake is showing a steam locomotive without a tender or bunker and tanks -- which usually means that it doesn't have any fuel or water and therefore can't move -- or having no rods to move it or a mishmash of rods and wheels in all the wrong places. And even if there is a tender, it often looks like one big fuel bunker on wheels with nowhere to put the water. Other common departures from reality might involve a RunawayTrain's safety systems [[FailsafeFailure failing]] without any justifiable reason, or the wrong kind of train or rolling stock for the script. Whenever a train appears, it'll almost always be blasting its horn or whistle (if even that, as sometimes they'll use whistles on diesels and horns on steam engines instead of vice-versa), when in real life trains are only meant to sound their horns and/or whistles at set points along the route such as at level crossings, or if there's something or someone on the track. But, hey, most viewers don't know or care what the proper train would look like, ''or'' the ins-and-outs of railway operations. And more often than not, in media that may involve trains or railroads in general as part of the premise, the engineer is commonly incorrectly referred to as the "conductor". Conductors look after trains and make sure they are safe to ride on or operate. Engineers instead operate the trains themselves and focus on driving them from one place to another.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Easily, the number one mistake is showing a steam locomotive without a tender or bunker and tanks -- which usually means that it doesn't have any fuel or water and therefore can't move -- or having no rods to move it or a mishmash of rods and wheels in all the wrong places. And even if there is a tender, it often looks like one big fuel bunker on wheels with nowhere to put the water. Other common departures from reality might involve a RunawayTrain's safety systems [[FailsafeFailure failing]] without any justifiable reason, or the wrong kind of train or rolling stock for the script. Whenever a train appears, it'll almost always be blasting its horn or whistle (if even that, as sometimes they'll use whistles on diesels and horns on steam engines instead of vice-versa), when in real life trains are only meant to sound their horns and/or whistles at set points along the route such as at level crossings, or if there's something or someone on the track. But, hey, most viewers don't know or care what the proper train would look like, ''or'' the ins-and-outs of railway operations.

to:

Easily, the number one mistake is showing a steam locomotive without a tender or bunker and tanks -- which usually means that it doesn't have any fuel or water and therefore can't move -- or having no rods to move it or a mishmash of rods and wheels in all the wrong places. And even if there is a tender, it often looks like one big fuel bunker on wheels with nowhere to put the water. Other common departures from reality might involve a RunawayTrain's safety systems [[FailsafeFailure failing]] without any justifiable reason, or the wrong kind of train or rolling stock for the script. Whenever a train appears, it'll almost always be blasting its horn or whistle (if even that, as sometimes they'll use whistles on diesels and horns on steam engines instead of vice-versa), when in real life trains are only meant to sound their horns and/or whistles at set points along the route such as at level crossings, or if there's something or someone on the track. But, hey, most viewers don't know or care what the proper train would look like, ''or'' the ins-and-outs of railway operations.
operations. And more often than not, in media may involve trains as part of the premise, the engineer is commonly incorrectly referred to as the "conductor". Conductors look after trains and make sure they are safe to ride on or operate. Engineers instead operate the trains themselves and focus on driving them from one place to another.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Cases of anachronistic locomotives and rolling stock [[AcceptableBreaksFromReality are more forgivable]], for most of the same reasons given in sister tropes involving [[ArtisticLicenseShips ships]], [[JustPlaneWrong aircraft]] or [[TanksButNoTanks armoured vehicles.]] Sometimes there are simply no serviceable examples still in existence, or the surviving examples are stabled at preserved railway lines far from their original area of operation and are too expensive to transport, leaving the production team to choose between this trope and CaliforniaDoubling. Even when you manage to make locomotive and rolling stock match the period and the location, they're often in a livery from an earlier or later period of their service lifespan, and the owners may well be reluctant to have them repainted for filming, especially considering the expense involved. They figure that only weird railroad nerds will notice anway.

to:

Cases of anachronistic locomotives and rolling stock [[AcceptableBreaksFromReality are more forgivable]], for most of the same reasons given in sister tropes involving [[ArtisticLicenseShips ships]], [[JustPlaneWrong aircraft]] or [[TanksButNoTanks armoured vehicles.]] Sometimes there are simply no serviceable examples still in existence, or the surviving examples are stabled at preserved railway lines far from their original area of operation and are too expensive to transport, leaving the production team to choose between this trope and CaliforniaDoubling. Even when you manage to make locomotive and rolling stock match the period and the location, they're often in a livery from an earlier or later period of their service lifespan, and the owners may well be reluctant to have them repainted for filming, especially considering the expense involved. They figure that only weird railroad nerds will notice anway.
anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Olwin takes on coal by '''opening her cab roof''' which allows the coal to fall in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/{{Blood}}'' has a mission in its first episode set in a train, and as it was a game in the 90s when 3D levels were still a novelty, it's unsurprisingly rather off. Most notably, it's incredibly wide, there are no doors on the cars, there are walkways stretching all over the place, including the cab, there's no water by the tender, and the only controls inside the cab (which has no windows) is a handful of switches [[NoOSHACompliance that cause the train to derail]] (at which point the developers were pretty clearly taking the piss).

to:

* ''VideoGame/{{Blood}}'' ''VideoGame/Blood1997'' has a mission in its first episode set in a train, and as it was a game in the 90s when 3D levels were still a novelty, it's unsurprisingly rather off. Most notably, it's incredibly wide, there are no doors on the cars, there are walkways stretching all over the place, including the cab, there's no water by the tender, and the only controls inside the cab (which has no windows) is are a handful of switches [[NoOSHACompliance that cause the train to derail]] (at which point the developers were pretty clearly taking the piss).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When a steam engine appears [[RailroadTracksOfDoom to ram the protagonists down]], it will sometimes have a diesel horn blaring rather than a whistle. Or, if it's a diesel barreling down on them, it will blast a steam whistle.

to:

* When a steam engine appears [[RailroadTracksOfDoom to ram the protagonists down]], it will sometimes have a diesel horn blaring rather than a whistle. Or, if it's a diesel barreling down on them, it will blast a steam whistle. Somehow these are both TruthInTelevision as certain trains such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHW1Q8WmxPo SP 4449]] and [[https://www.youtube.com/shorts/r3WnqIIgUm0 NH FL9s]] wear air horns and air whistles respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Considering the [[RealityIsOutToLunch daily]] [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs routine]] of Nichijou this should go hardly noticed by anyone.

Added: 280

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Some cartoons depict the interiors of passenger cars more akin to subway cars, including seating, stanchions[[note]]the vertical poles that stick from the floor and ceiling of the train wagon, often used for commuters who have no available seating[[/note]], and automatic doors.



* The ending of the ''WesternAnimation/FraidyCat'' episode "Meaner Than the Junkyard Cat" has Fraidy watching a trainyard with fast diesel trains passing by him. Despite being diesels, the trains have steam whistle sounds, and steam chugging.

to:

* The ending of the ''WesternAnimation/FraidyCat'' episode "Meaner Than the a Junkyard Cat" has Fraidy watching a trainyard with fast diesel trains passing by him. Despite being diesels, the trains have steam whistle sounds, and steam chugging.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/MissionImpossibleDeadReckoningPartOne''
** The Orient Express in the film's finale is a mix of Continental European rolling stock pulled by a British style engine with design elements taken from various British Railways standard classes.
** Gabriel [[spoiler: causes a runaway train by attacking the locomotive crew, breaking open the throttle, and destroying the brake handle. He ties one of the bodies of the crew to the whistle cord, causing the train to whistle as the body swings around. Without a fireman tending to the fire; the locomotive would have eventually begun to lose steam pressure and slow down with the throttle wide open and the frequent whistles. The risk of water to dropping below the crown sheet causing a boiler explosion without a fireman to operate the water injector is also possible.]]
** When the train [[spoiler: falls off the bridge, the train cars hang on to each other through the chains linking them briefly before each one snaps and pulls the next one off the bridge. The horizontal forces on the chains would have likely caused them to snap much faster instead of dangling in the air long enough for Ethan and Grace to climb out of them.]]
** When Grace pulls the emergency brake in the passenger car it should have activated the brakes. Train brakes can be operated operated from any car in an emergency, and don't need the brake throttle [[spoiler: like Gabriel had destroyed]] in the locomotive intact to activate them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WesternAnimation/{{Garfield}}'s movie has a scene where Garfield infiltrates a dispatcher's room and switches trains willy nilly sending them all on collision courses with one another. This would be impossible as the system would not allow the controller to switch points in front of an approaching train, and the signal system is interlocked to prohibit any movement that might cause a collision.

to:

* WesternAnimation/{{Garfield}}'s Film/{{Garfield}}'s movie has a scene where Garfield infiltrates a dispatcher's room and switches trains willy nilly sending them all on collision courses with one another. This would be impossible as the system would not allow the controller to switch points in front of an approaching train, and the signal system is interlocked to prohibit any movement that might cause a collision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''WesternAnimation/TurningRed'', streetcars are incorrectly portrayed with steering wheels despite being correctly portrayed to run on rails.

Top