Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / GodIsLoveSongs

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark'' parodied this ruthlessly in the episode, "Christian Rock Hard", where Cartman creates a Christian rock group and achieves massive success replacing the word "baby" in popular songs with the word "Jesus". UnfortunateImplications abound as the songs he picks to adapt get more and more explicit.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark'' parodied this ruthlessly in the episode, "Christian Rock Hard", where Cartman creates a Christian rock group and achieves massive success by just taking already existing love songs and replacing the word words like "baby" in popular songs with the word "Jesus". UnfortunateImplications abound as the songs he picks to adapt get more and more explicit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "You Got the Love" by CandiStaton (popularized by FlorenceAndTheMachine) can be interpreted as such.

to:

* "You Got the Love" by CandiStaton (popularized by FlorenceAndTheMachine) Music/FlorenceAndTheMachine) can be interpreted as such.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Harrison was sued (and lost) due to the musical similarity between his "My Sweet Lord" and The Chiffons' "He's So Fine", and the subject matter is ... not exactly dissonant either; there are at least a couple of verses of "He's So Fine" that could be slipped directly into "My Sweet Lord" and not be glaringly out of place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Also compare and contrast NotChristianRock. GodIsGood is likely to come up in these kinds of songs. If there's no chance of mistaking that the song is about God, you probably have GospelMusic or ChristianRock.

to:

Also compare and contrast NotChristianRock. GodIsGood is likely to come up in these kinds of songs. If there's no chance of mistaking that the song is about God, you probably have GospelMusic or ChristianRock. \n The inverse of this, where love is sung about as though it were a religion, is LoveIsLikeReligion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Literature/TheBible's ''Song of Songs'': Some scholars say that this erotic poetry about a bride and groom on their wedding night is meant to be understood as a metaphor of God's relationship with his people. Of course, other scholars say that the book is simply celebrating erotic love in a marital context. [[TakeAThirdOption Or possibly both.]]

to:

* Literature/TheBible's ''Song of Songs'': ''Literature/SongOfSongs'': Some scholars say that this erotic poetry about a bride and groom on their wedding night is meant to be understood as a metaphor of God's relationship with his people. Of course, other scholars say that the book is simply celebrating erotic love in a marital context. [[TakeAThirdOption Or possibly both.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not quite. While Selah did a version as well, theirs is also a cover. It was first recorded by Norwegian-Irish folk duo Secret Garden, featuring guest vocalist Brian Kennedy. It was never intended to be spiritual, but many people obviously interpret it differently.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->'''Me''': * reads* 'Christ, You Are My Fullness'

to:

->'''Me''': * reads* [=*=]reads[=*=] 'Christ, You Are My Fullness'



->'''Me''': * closes book*

to:

->'''Me''': * closes book*[=*=]closes book[=*=]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Apparently, "I Need You" by [=LeAnn Rimes=] falls into this category. Not surprisingly, it's been included on an album called ''Jesus: Music From And Inspired by the Epic Mini Series''.

to:

* Apparently, "I Need You" by [=LeAnn Rimes=] Music/LeAnnRimes falls into this category. Not surprisingly, it's been included on an album called ''Jesus: Music From And Inspired by the Epic Mini Series''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Although they might actually be romantic lyrics played straight, quite a few lines in songs by KillswitchEngage seem to imply this, what with how closely they mesh with the heavy spiritual ([[NotChristianRock Christian?]]) themes.

to:

* Although they might actually be romantic lyrics played straight, quite a few lines in songs by KillswitchEngage Music/KillswitchEngage seem to imply this, what with how closely they mesh with the heavy spiritual ([[NotChristianRock Christian?]]) themes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya Kyon/Haruhi]] fic ''[[http://www.soulriders.net/brian/fanfic/hotair/ Hot Air]]'' is based off the religious OwlCity song ''Galaxies''. It helps that Haruhi is more or less a GodInHumanForm.

to:

* The [[LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya Kyon/Haruhi]] fic ''[[http://www.soulriders.net/brian/fanfic/hotair/ Hot Air]]'' is based off the religious OwlCity Music/OwlCity song ''Galaxies''. It helps that Haruhi is more or less a GodInHumanForm.



* Some spiritual songs by OwlCity are mistaken for romantic songs, especially "Galaxies" and "Meteor Shower".

to:

* Some spiritual songs by OwlCity Music/OwlCity are mistaken for romantic songs, especially "Galaxies" and "Meteor Shower".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In an [[InvertedTrope inversion]] of the trope, Justin Briner [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-9X6ZFzO3w sang]] the traditional hymn ''"Be Thou My Vision"'' in character as Eridan from ''Webcomic/{{Homestuck}}'', to Eridan's moirail[[labelnote:*]]A troll who keeps another's violent tendencies in check; something like a MoralityChain or even LivingEmotionalCrutch[[/labelnote]] Feferi. Surprisingly few words are changed, and the central theme that "you make me a better person" is fully intact.

to:

* In an [[InvertedTrope inversion]] {{inver|tedTrope}}sion of the trope, Justin Briner [[http://www.[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-9X6ZFzO3w sang]] the traditional hymn ''"Be Thou My Vision"'' in character as Eridan from ''Webcomic/{{Homestuck}}'', to Eridan's moirail[[labelnote:*]]A troll who keeps another's violent tendencies in check; something like a MoralityChain or even LivingEmotionalCrutch[[/labelnote]] Feferi. Surprisingly few words are changed, and the central theme that "you make me a better person" is fully intact.



* Literature/TheBible's ''Song of Songs'': Some scholars say that this erotic poetry about a bride and groom on their wedding night is meant to be understood as a metaphor God's relationship with his people. Of course, other scholars say that the book is simply celebrating erotic love in a marital context. [[TakeAThirdOption Or possibly both]].
* Actually a lot of music from the HighMedieval period is a version of this. At various periods and cultures, straightforward songs about romantic love were being frowned on by MoralGuardians of the day, so a lot of lovesongs have at least a veneer of being addressed to the Virgin Mary, [[GettingCrapPastTheRadar an acceptable way for the writers to be writing about loving a woman.]]

to:

* Literature/TheBible's ''Song of Songs'': Some scholars say that this erotic poetry about a bride and groom on their wedding night is meant to be understood as a metaphor of God's relationship with his people. Of course, other scholars say that the book is simply celebrating erotic love in a marital context. [[TakeAThirdOption Or possibly both]].
both.]]
* Actually a lot of music from the HighMedieval period is a version of this. At various periods and cultures, straightforward songs about romantic love were being frowned on by MoralGuardians of the day, so a lot of lovesongs have at least a veneer of being addressed to the Virgin Mary, [[GettingCrapPastTheRadar an acceptable way for the writers to be writing about loving a woman.]]woman]].



* WordOfGod (ha!) has it that Pete Townshend's "Let My Love Open the Door" is sung from the point of view of God to humanity, making this an [[InvertedTrope inversion]].

to:

* WordOfGod (ha!) has it that Pete Townshend's "Let My Love Open the Door" is sung from the point of view of God to humanity, making this an [[InvertedTrope inversion]].{{inver|tedTrope}}sion.



He says, come here, baby, and kiss me like you mean it.

to:

He says, come says: Come here, baby, and kiss me like you mean it.



* Music/AmyGrant has been popular both in the Christian music and mainstream music scene since the 1980s, and has recorded both GodIsLoveSongs and SillyLoveSongs of the more romantic variety - as well as even a few "I love my child" songs. As such, it's not surprising for many to confuse just who the love songs were written for.

to:

* Music/AmyGrant has been popular both in the Christian music and mainstream music scene since the 1980s, and has recorded both GodIsLoveSongs God-Is-Love Songs and SillyLoveSongs of the more romantic variety - as well as even a few "I love my child" songs. As such, it's not surprising for many to confuse just who the love songs were written for.



* "Love Song For A Savior" by Jars Of Clay, [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]].

to:

* "Love Song For A Savior" by Jars Of Clay, [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]].{{s|arcasmMode}}urprisingly.



* Jamie Grace's [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysrIY84Ubmc "Hold Me"]] sounds more like a typical {{Silly Love Song|s}} (and could easily work as one with no lyrical revision whatsoever), but is intended to be about the singer's relationship to God and is often played on Christian stations.

to:

* Jamie Grace's [[http://www.[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysrIY84Ubmc "Hold Me"]] sounds more like a typical {{Silly Love Song|s}} (and could easily work as one with no lyrical revision whatsoever), but is intended to be about the singer's relationship to God and is often played on Christian stations.



* Originally, "When You Look Me In The Eyes" by the JonasBrothers was released on Nick Jonas' solo album, a few years before the brothers formed their band together, and it (along with all the other tracks on said album) was intended to be a Christian rock song.

to:

* Originally, "When You Look Me In The Eyes" by the JonasBrothers Music/TheJonasBrothers was released on Nick Jonas' solo album, a few years before the brothers formed their band together, and it (along with all the other tracks on said album) was intended to be a Christian rock song.



* OlderThanYouThink, given some of the imagery in Creator/JohnDonne's Holy Sonnets, particularly #14 ("Batter my heart, three-person'd God;"):

to:

* OlderThanYouThink, OlderThanTheyThink, given some of the imagery in Creator/JohnDonne's Holy Sonnets, particularly #14 ("Batter my heart, three-person'd God;"):



for your love is more delightful than wine.:\\

to:

for your love is more delightful than wine.:\\\\



* [[http://www.alittleleaven.com/ Chris Rosebrough]], of [[http://piratechristianradio.com/ Pirate Christian Radio fame]] [[TakeThat bashes this trope for all its worth]]. Other than the typical TGWTG-esque critique of such horrible music, he goes into [[BerserkButton an unstoppable rage]] when said songs end up failing to correctly represent his version of the Christian faith. Case in point, [[http://www.alittleleaven.com/2008/07/you-call-this-w.html his commentary on this entry]]

to:

* [[http://www.alittleleaven.com/ Chris Rosebrough]], of [[http://piratechristianradio.com/ Pirate Christian Radio fame]] [[TakeThat bashes this trope for all its worth]]. Other than the typical TGWTG-esque critique of such horrible music, he goes into [[BerserkButton an unstoppable rage]] when said songs end up failing to correctly represent his version of the Christian faith. Case in point, [[http://www.alittleleaven.com/2008/07/you-call-this-w.html his commentary on this entry]]entry]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* "You Got the Love" by CandiStaton (popularized by FlorenceAndTheMachine) can be interpreted as such.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=npgdw5Zb7TY This]] parody of Rebecca Black's infamous song, "Friday" converts it into a song about going to Church on ''"Sunday"''. Some people believe it to be better than the original. This is not high praise.

to:

* [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=npgdw5Zb7TY This]] parody of Rebecca Black's infamous song, "Friday" converts it into a song about going to Church on ''"Sunday"''. Some people believe it to be better than the original. [[DamnedByFaintPraise This is not high praise.]]

Changed: 455

Removed: 479

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Song titles go in quotes, not italics. Artist names go in neither.


-->''Jesus is my boyfriend!\\

to:

-->''Jesus -->Jesus is my boyfriend!\\



...but obviously not in that way.''

to:

...but obviously not in that way.''



* "Not Alone" by ''All That Remains'' is implicitly one of these, despite being expressed with traditional heavy rock/metal themes.
--> ''I'm not alone''
--> ''With the touch of your hand''
--> ''I am whole again''

to:

* "Not Alone" by ''All All That Remains'' Remains is implicitly one of these, despite being expressed with traditional heavy rock/metal themes.
--> ''I'm -->I'm not alone''
--> ''With
alone
-->With
the touch of your hand''
--> ''I
hand
-->I
am whole again''again



* Several of Lifehouse's songs could be read that way, especially ''Everything'' and ''Storm''.
** In fact, in an interview Lifehouse member Jason Wade once said that he was surprised that so many people took their first big hit ''Hanging by a Moment'' as a love song, because to him it was a very spiritual song.

to:

* Several of Lifehouse's songs could be read that way, especially ''Everything'' "Everything" and ''Storm''.
**
"Storm". In fact, in an interview Lifehouse member Jason Wade once said that he was surprised that so many people took their first big hit ''Hanging "Hanging by a Moment'' Moment" as a love song, because to him it was a very spiritual song.



* "The King Of Carrot Flowers, Part Two" by Neutral Milk Hotel opens with the singer proclaiming "I love you Jesus Christ, Jesus Christ, I love you". Considering it's from an album which frequently alludes to Anne Frank and Reincarnation (as well as mountains covered in semen and lesbian prostitutes) it's either a very overt - and incongruous - example of this trope or an amusingly subtle subversion.
** At least one Christian rock band has covered it straight however, seemingly without catching the double meaning of the phrase Jesus Christ.

to:

* "The King Of Carrot Flowers, Part Two" by Neutral Milk Hotel opens with the singer proclaiming "I love you Jesus Christ, Jesus Christ, I love you". Considering it's from an album which frequently alludes to Anne Frank and Reincarnation (as well as mountains covered in semen and lesbian prostitutes) it's either a very overt - and incongruous - example of this trope or an amusingly subtle subversion.
**
subversion. At least one Christian rock band has covered it straight however, seemingly without catching the double meaning of the phrase Jesus Christ.



* Some spiritual songs by OwlCity are mistaken for romantic songs, especially ''Galaxies'' and ''Meteor Shower''.

to:

* Some spiritual songs by OwlCity are mistaken for romantic songs, especially ''Galaxies'' "Galaxies" and ''Meteor Shower''."Meteor Shower".



* Music/BobMarley: ''Hallelujah Time'' (From ''Music/{{Burnin}}''), ''So Jah Say'' (From ''Music/NattyDread''), ''Positive Vibration'' (From ''Rastaman Vibration''), ''Forever Loving Jah'' (From ''Music/{{Uprising}}'')
* Music/PeterTosh: ''Igziabeher (Let Jah Be Praised)'' from ''Music/LegalizeIt''.

to:

* Music/BobMarley: ''Hallelujah Time'' (From "Hallelujah Time" (from ''Music/{{Burnin}}''), ''So "So Jah Say'' (From Say" (from ''Music/NattyDread''), ''Positive Vibration'' (From "Positive Vibration" (from ''Rastaman Vibration''), ''Forever "Forever Loving Jah'' (From Jah" (from ''Music/{{Uprising}}'')
* Music/PeterTosh: ''Igziabeher "Igziabeher (Let Jah Be Praised)'' Praised)" from ''Music/LegalizeIt''.



* "You Raise Me Up", popularized by Josh Groban, is actually a cover. The original song by christian group Selah even has a third verse that makes the spiritual elements much more explicit.

to:

* "You Raise Me Up", popularized by Josh Groban, is actually a cover. The original song by christian Christian group Selah even has a third verse that makes the spiritual elements much more explicit.



* Being a Christian rock band ''Music/{{Skillet}}'' has a few, such as "Salvation".

to:

* Being a Christian rock band ''Music/{{Skillet}}'' Music/{{Skillet}} has a few, such as "Salvation".



-->When shadows fall\\

to:

-->When --->When shadows fall\\






** Not really. His style of writing is not that uncommon among Christian mystics. He's just one of the more famous ones.



-->'''Homer''' (hearing Debbie Boone's "You Light Up My Life"): I bet the guy she was singing that about was real happy.\\

to:

-->'''Homer''' (hearing -->'''Homer:''' ''(hearing Debbie Boone's "You Light Up My Life"): Life")'' I bet the guy she was singing that about was real happy.\\



--> '''Cartman:''' "''I wanna get down on my knees and start pleasing Jesus; I wanna feel his salvation all over my face!''"

to:

--> '''Cartman:''' "''I "I wanna get down on my knees and start pleasing Jesus; I wanna feel his salvation all over my face!''"face!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Also compare and contrast NotChristianRock. GodIsGood is likely to come up in these kinds of songs.

to:

Also compare and contrast NotChristianRock. GodIsGood is likely to come up in these kinds of songs. If there's no chance of mistaking that the song is about God, you probably have GospelMusic or ChristianRock.

Added: 585

Changed: 317

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Music/DanielAmos' "I Love You #19" (from ''Music/HorrendousDisc'') is a meta version. It's as much a ''song about love'' as it is a ''love song'', pondering how hard it can be to convince your romantic interest that your feelings are sincere--and then it draws a comparison to how hard it is to convince others that Jesus loves them.

to:

* Music/DanielAmos' Music/DanielAmos:
**
"I Love You #19" (from ''Music/HorrendousDisc'') is a meta version. It's as much a ''song about love'' as it is a ''love song'', pondering how hard it can be to convince your romantic interest that your feelings are sincere--and then it draws a comparison to how hard it is to convince others that Jesus loves them.them.
** "When Worlds Collide" (from ''Music/VoxHumana'') is a straighter example. It's a love song from God to humanity.
-->When shadows fall\\
When lovers mourn\\
And you fight your darkest tendencies\\
I promise to hold you close to me when\\
Worlds collide\\
I'm on your side
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->But I really think it's sexy when he kicks Satans ass!

to:

-->But I really think it's sexy when he kicks Satans Satan's ass!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Music/DanielAmos' "I Love You #19" (from ''Music/HorrendousDisc'') is a meta version. It's as much a ''song about love'' as it is a ''love song'', pondering how hard it can be to convince your romantic interest that your feelings are sincere--and then it draws a comparison to how hard it is to convince others that Jesus loves them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The "Let My Love Open The Door"/"Still" inversion is parodied by "You, You, You" from ABitOfFryAndLaurie, with Stephen as God and Hugh as a (female) backup singer.

to:

* The "Let My Love Open The Door"/"Still" inversion is parodied by "You, You, You" from ABitOfFryAndLaurie, ''Series/ABitOfFryAndLaurie'', with Stephen as God and Hugh as a (female) backup singer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The movie ''Film/SisterAct'' inverts this by taking 1960s love songs and turning them into hymns. Oddly, because of the tamer (relatively) lyrics of such songs at the time, as well as that it's the brides of Christ singing them, it actually works better than modern Christian rock.

to:

* The movie ''Film/SisterAct'' inverts this by taking 1960s love songs and turning them into hymns. For instance, a version of Mary Wells' "My Guy" that changes the TitleDrop to "My God", but keeps the rest of the lyrics identical to the original. Oddly, because of the tamer (relatively) lyrics of such songs at the time, as well as that it's the brides of Christ singing them, it actually works better than modern Christian rock.

Changed: 91

Removed: 81

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* Many songs by NotChristianRock band Music/{{Flyleaf}}, including "All Around Me", "Sorrow", and "Missing", are not explicitly about religion, but can easily be interpreted that way.
** Made more explicit by the very Christian DavidCrowderBand covering the former.

to:

* Many songs by NotChristianRock Music/NotChristianRock band Music/{{Flyleaf}}, including "All Around Me", "Sorrow", and "Missing", are not explicitly about religion, but can easily be interpreted that way.
**
way. Made more explicit by the very Christian DavidCrowderBand Music/DavidCrowderBand covering the former.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


These are songs that, at first hearing, seem to be ordinary love songs, but are actually allegories about the singer's relationship with God, often by artists who are trying to gain or keep a mainstream secular audience and feel that talking about God will put people off and exclude them[[note]]although if you want to be cynical, you can get the best of both worlds by writing an ordinary love song and ''telling people'' it's secretly about God[[/note]]. Can sometimes lead to UnfortunateImplications when a praise song sounds dirty to people who aren't familiar with the context.

to:

These are songs that, at first hearing, seem to be ordinary love songs, but are actually allegories about the singer's relationship with God, God. This is often done by artists who are trying to gain or keep a mainstream secular audience and feel that talking about God will put people off and exclude them[[note]]although if them[[note]]if you want to be cynical, you can get the best of both worlds by writing an ordinary love song and ''telling people'' it's secretly about God[[/note]]. Can It can sometimes lead to UnfortunateImplications problems when a praise song sounds dirty to people who aren't familiar with the context.



Also compare and contrast NotChristianRock.

to:

Also compare and contrast NotChristianRock.
NotChristianRock. GodIsGood is likely to come up in these kinds of songs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* 'Music/RelientK'''s "Must Have Done Something Right" is supposed to be this.

to:

* 'Music/RelientK'''s ''Music/RelientK'''s "Must Have Done Something Right" is supposed to be this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Arguably ''Relient K'''s "Must Have Done Something Right" is supposed to be this.

to:

* Arguably ''Relient K'''s 'Music/RelientK'''s "Must Have Done Something Right" is supposed to be this.this.



* Being a Christian rock band ''Music/{{Skilket}}'' has a few, such as "Salvation".

to:

* Being a Christian rock band ''Music/{{Skilket}}'' ''Music/{{Skillet}}'' has a few, such as "Salvation".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Music/{{Plumb}}'s "In My Arms" is from the [=POV=] of God. Many people [[AlternativeCharacterInterpretation view]] [[MisaimedFandom it]] as being about a mother and her baby though.
* Being a Christian rock band ''Music/{{Skilket}}'' has a few, such as "Salvation".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace


* Many songs by NotChristianRock band {{Flyleaf}}, including "All Around Me", "Sorrow", and "Missing", are not explicity about religion, but can easily be interpreted that way.

to:

* Many songs by NotChristianRock band {{Flyleaf}}, Music/{{Flyleaf}}, including "All Around Me", "Sorrow", and "Missing", are not explicity explicitly about religion, but can easily be interpreted that way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Borderline, as the original version is somewhat less ambiguous. It's the [[CoveredUp more well known]] MandyMoore version that causes the confusion.

to:

** Borderline, as the original version is somewhat less ambiguous. It's the [[CoveredUp more well known]] MandyMoore Music/MandyMoore version that causes the confusion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[TheMelancholyOfHaruhiSuzumiya Kyon/Haruhi]] fic ''[[http://www.soulriders.net/brian/fanfic/hotair/ Hot Air]]'' is based off the religious OwlCity song ''Galaxies''. It helps that Haruhi is more or less a GodInHumanForm.

to:

* The [[TheMelancholyOfHaruhiSuzumiya [[LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya Kyon/Haruhi]] fic ''[[http://www.soulriders.net/brian/fanfic/hotair/ Hot Air]]'' is based off the religious OwlCity song ''Galaxies''. It helps that Haruhi is more or less a GodInHumanForm.

Added: 152

Changed: 150

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> "Immaculate conception really makes my day/ but the dudes got lats that make me feel gay/ Turn the other cheek is really showing class/ But I really think it's sexy when he kicks Satans ass"

to:

--> "Immaculate -->Immaculate conception really makes my day/ but day
-->but
the dudes got lats that make me feel gay/ Turn gay.
-->Turn
the other cheek is really showing class/ But class
-->But
I really think it's sexy when he kicks Satans ass"ass!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Music/BobDylan's entire ''Music/SlowTrainComing'' album.

Top