Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / FreedomFromChoice

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking a work cut for lacking tropability


* ''WebVideo/NotJustBikes'': Jason mentions, with deep annoyance, how certain parts of North America seem to be full of people who are furious at the idea of being given a choice to walk, bike or take public transit rather than have to drive in traffic arguing that their freedom is being taken away by being offered infrastructure that gives them more choices (without removing cars from the equation).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlayedForDrama in ''WebAnimation/StarterSquad'', where various Pokémon under [[spoiler:the [[GeneralRipper Caterpie leader]]]] only accept their rule so that they won't have to make their own decisions in life. This also helps [[spoiler:Squirtle]] recognize that another Pokémon claiming to act on the gods' behalf is doing the exact same thing, pushing responsibility for the lives he'd taken up until that point to a higher power under the justification of following orders.

to:

* PlayedForDrama in ''WebAnimation/StarterSquad'', where various Pokémon under [[spoiler:the [[GeneralRipper Caterpie leader]]]] only accept their tyrannical rule so that they won't have to make their own decisions in life. This also helps [[spoiler:Squirtle]] recognize that another Pokémon claiming to act on the gods' behalf is doing the exact same thing, pushing responsibility for the lives he'd taken up until that point to a higher power under the justification of following orders.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PlayedForDrama in ''WebAnimation/StarterSquad'', where various Pokémon under [[spoiler:the [[GeneralRipper Caterpie leader]]]] only accept their rule so that they won't have to make their own decisions in life. This also helps [[spoiler:Squirtle]] recognize that another Pokémon claiming to act on the gods' behalf is doing the exact same thing, pushing responsibility for the lives he'd taken up until that point to a higher power under the justification of following orders.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Perhaps not surprisingly, this was a part of the [[ThoseWackyNazis Nazis']] ideology. They replaced freedom of choice with the ''Führerprinzip'' (leader principle), i.e. obedience to higher authority, with the Fuhrer's word being above all law (this was partly an outgrowth of Germany unifying with Prussia at its center, with Prussia's strong military culture seeping into the rest of the country, especially through education). It was thus felt that if people were obeying orders, nothing they did could be wrong. Therefore when Nazi war criminals [[JustFollowingOrders used this defense at Nuremberg]] it was not entirely self-serving or cognitive dissonance-they ''really believed that.''
* According to Wikipedia's article on "Freedom of Choice", a social experiment determined that there's kind of a "sweet spot" when it comes to freedom and the ability to make choices. While in general, the ability to make choices (and to make choices that lead to more choices) is considered a good thing, having an abundance of choice requires both a thorough understanding of the choices and potential consequences and the ability to cope with consequences. As the number of pairwise comparisons the brain has to make increases quadratically with each additional option available (with only three options the brain has to make three comparisons, a fourth ups it to six, a fifth requires ten, and so on), people who lack either of those may find themselves happier within ''this'' trope, where decisions are made ''for'' them as [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overchoice overchoice]] seeps in. There is an experiment involved a supermarket issuing coupons for jam. The same supermarket, the same price, the same days of the week; the only difference was the number of different flavors of jam for sale on the shelf - one week had 3 flavors, another week had 24. Total sales of jam were significantly lower the week there were 24 flavors on the shelf because trying to determine the best choice out of 24 options was much more mentally tiresome for shoppers than picking the best out of 3 options, and those shoppers just ended up not buying any jam at all.
* Some of the supporters of [[StayInTheKitchen traditional gender roles and expectations]] (in particular, certain religious leaders), say that women are "oppressed" because they are (supposedly) overwhelmed with all the choices they have, or are unsatisfied with life because they picked options other than what's (supposedly) [[AppealToNature "natural."]]

to:

* Perhaps not surprisingly, this was a part of the [[ThoseWackyNazis Nazis']] ideology. They replaced freedom of choice with the ''Führerprinzip'' (leader principle), i.e. obedience to higher authority, with the Fuhrer's word being above all law (this was partly an outgrowth of Germany unifying with Prussia at its center, with Prussia's strong military culture seeping into the rest of the country, especially through education). It was thus felt that if people were obeying orders, nothing they did could be wrong. Therefore when Nazi war criminals [[JustFollowingOrders used this defense at Nuremberg]] it was not entirely self-serving or cognitive dissonance-they dissonance -- they ''really believed that.''
* According to Wikipedia's article on "Freedom of Choice", a social experiment determined that there's kind of a "sweet spot" when it comes to freedom and the ability to make choices. While in general, the ability to make choices (and to make choices that lead to more choices) is considered a good thing, having an abundance of choice requires both a thorough understanding of the choices and potential consequences and the ability to cope with consequences. As the number of pairwise comparisons the brain has to make increases quadratically with each additional option available (with only three options the brain has to make three comparisons, a fourth ups it to six, a fifth requires ten, and so on), people who lack either of those may find themselves happier within ''this'' trope, where decisions are made ''for'' them as [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overchoice overchoice]] seeps in. There is an experiment involved a supermarket issuing coupons for jam. The same supermarket, the same price, the same days of the week; the only difference was the number of different flavors of jam for sale on the shelf - -- one week had 3 flavors, another week had 24. Total sales of jam were significantly lower the week there were 24 flavors on the shelf because trying to determine the best choice out of 24 options was much more mentally tiresome for shoppers than picking the best out of 3 options, and those shoppers just ended up not buying any jam at all.
* Some of the supporters of [[StayInTheKitchen traditional gender roles and expectations]] (in particular, certain religious leaders), say that women are "oppressed" because they are (supposedly) overwhelmed with all the choices they have, or are unsatisfied with life because they picked options other than what's (supposedly) [[AppealToNature "natural."]] "[[AppealToNature natural]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* “[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/14090706/1/Different-manor Different manor]]” makes this the main reason Harry submits to Daphne Greengrass, as he's become tired and frustrated at the stress of his responsibilities as the "Boy-Who-Lived" and finds that he prefers submitting to Daphne and letting her make the important decisions.

Added: 434

Removed: 434

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
sorted folder by alphabetical order


[[folder:Web Video]]
* ''WebVideo/NotJustBikes'': Jason mentions, with deep annoyance, how certain parts of North America seem to be full of people who are furious at the idea of being given a choice to walk, bike or take public transit rather than have to drive in traffic arguing that their freedom is being taken away by being offered infrastructure that gives them more choices (without removing cars from the equation).
[[/folder]]



[[folder:Web Video]]
* ''WebVideo/NotJustBikes'': Jason mentions, with deep annoyance, how certain parts of North America seem to be full of people who are furious at the idea of being given a choice to walk, bike or take public transit rather than have to drive in traffic arguing that their freedom is being taken away by being offered infrastructure that gives them more choices (without removing cars from the equation).
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''ComicBook/EightBillionGenies'', some people suffer from "wishlock", where they are unable to make a wish because thinking about making a wish causes paralysis from the other wishes they ''don't'' make.

Changed: 147

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Compare and Contrast with DesperatelyNeedsOrders where the character not wanting to make decisions is not out of preference but rather cause they're straight up ''unable to''.

to:

Compare and Contrast with DesperatelyNeedsOrders TheDitherer where the character not wanting to make decisions is not out of preference but rather cause they're straight up ''unable to''.
to''. If this is more isolated to a certain situation(s) rather than being a general aspect them, you have DesperatelyNeedsOrders.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


Compare and Contrast with DesperatelyNeedsOrders where the character not wanting to make decisions is not out of preference but rather cause they're straight up ''unable to''.

Added: 206

Removed: 204

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/TheBooksOfEmber'' have a bit of this, although it's shown that the lot-drawing doesn't actually matter (it's touted as a sort of sacred infallible system, but people can swap their drawings).



* ''Literature/TheCityOfEmber'' has a bit of this, although it's shown that the lot-drawing doesn't actually matter (it's touted as a sort of sacred infallible system, but people can swap their drawings).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A common way for Authoritarian rulers and Totalitarian dictators to justify their rule regardless of whether the general populace would like it or not.

to:

* A common way for Authoritarian authoritarian rulers and Totalitarian totalitarian dictators to justify their rule regardless of whether the general populace would like it or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One study compared the artistic merit of three groups: the control group wasn't given any directions, the second group was told "be creative," and the third group was told something like "for example, tear or fold the stickers to make a collage." The instruction to "be creative" with no constraints was no more effective than the control group, while the group that had an actual guideline to work with/against wound up being significantly more creative. Similarly, it's harder to face a blank page with absolute freedom than to write for a prompt (hence the popularity of prompts and fic exchanges) -- the constraints turn out to be liberating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/{{Warframe}}'''s climactic story quest, "The New War", [[spoiler:the Sentients [[TheBadGuyWins overrun the Origin System]] and install Ballas as the ruler of the empire-slash-cult of Narmer, enforced through [[MindControlDevice mind-controlling Narmer Veils]]. At the beginning of his VillainousBreakdown, as he [[ControlFreak rages over the existence of the few people still able to oppose him]] despite now ruling a system-spanning empite, Ballas furiously claims that the people of the system "''wanted'' to kneel" as they sought the comfort of being told what to think.]]

to:

* In ''VideoGame/{{Warframe}}'''s climactic story quest, "The New War", [[spoiler:the Sentients [[TheBadGuyWins overrun the Origin System]] and install Ballas as the ruler of the empire-slash-cult of Narmer, enforced through [[MindControlDevice mind-controlling Narmer Veils]]. At the beginning of his VillainousBreakdown, as he [[ControlFreak rages over the existence of the few people still able to oppose him]] despite now ruling a system-spanning empite, empire, Ballas furiously claims that the people of the system "''wanted'' to kneel" as they sought the comfort of being told what to think.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Web Video]]
* ''WebVideo/NotJustBikes'': Jason mentions, with deep annoyance, how certain parts of North America seem to be full of people who are furious at the idea of being given a choice to walk, bike or take public transit rather than have to drive in traffic arguing that their freedom is being taken away by being offered infrastructure that gives them more choices (without removing cars from the equation).
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/{{Warframe}}'''s climactic story quest, "The New War", [[spoiler:the Sentients [[TheBadGuyWins overrun the Origin System]] and install Ballas as the ruler of the empire-slash-cult of Narmer, enforced through [[MindControlDevice mind-controlling Narmer Veils]]. At the beginning of his VillainousBreakdown, as he [[ControlFreak rages over the existence of the few people still able to oppose him]] despite now ruling a system-spanning empite, Ballas furiously claims that the people of the system "''wanted'' to kneel" as they sought the comfort of being told what to think.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''LightNovel/BeingAbleToEditSkillsInAnotherWorldIGainedOpWaifus'' has a slave harem that's perfectly happy to have their "husband" make all the decisions. When they were free agents, their lives were crap. With him in charge, they're happy and basically live in luxury.

to:

* ''LightNovel/BeingAbleToEditSkillsInAnotherWorldIGainedOpWaifus'' ''Literature/BeingAbleToEditSkillsInAnotherWorldIGainedOpWaifus'' has a slave harem that's perfectly happy to have their "husband" make all the decisions. When they were free agents, their lives were crap. With him in charge, they're happy and basically live in luxury.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ComicBook/JudgeDredd'': One storyline has a pro-democracy group want to end the reign of the judges. Dredd is just about the only member of Justice Department to want it to go ahead, citing the massive riots that would occur if repressed. The movement goes ahead, instructions on how to vote from home are broadcast, the vote is carried out... and the ApatheticCitizens of Mega-City One don't disappoint, voting to keep the judges by a landslide, Judge Dredd citing the trope as the reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/TheHeraldsOfValdemar'', 13-year-old Talia is offered her 'choice' in an ArrangedMarriage -- a younger man's first wife or an older man's underwife. One of her own father's underwives tells her that the second option is nice because she'll never have to make a decision.

to:

* In ''Literature/TheHeraldsOfValdemar'', the ''Literature/HeraldsOfValdemar'' book ''Arrows of the Queen'', 13-year-old Talia is offered her 'choice' in an ArrangedMarriage -- a younger man's first wife or an older man's underwife. One of her own father's underwives tells her that the second option is nice because she'll never have to make a decision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/TheHeraldsOfValdemar'', 13-year-old Talia is offered her 'choice' in an ArrangedMarriage -- a younger man's first wife or an older man's underwife. One of her own father's underwives tells her that the second option is nice because she'll never have to make a decision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


While freedom from choice is morally neutral, a character who takes the desire for freedom from choice too far might [[JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope become destructive]] as he goes off the deep end pondering ([[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans and justifying]]) TheEvilsOfFreeWill. The AssimilationPlot is related, as the characters touting it sometimes presents it as the ultimate escape from having to choose.

to:

While freedom from choice is morally neutral, a character who takes the desire for freedom from choice too far might [[JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope become destructive]] as he goes off the deep end pondering ([[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans and justifying]]) TheEvilsOfFreeWill. The AssimilationPlot is related, as the characters touting it sometimes presents it as the ultimate escape from having to choose. When one character makes a choice for another in one particular incident only, it's MakingTheChoiceForYou.

Top