Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / EarthThatUsedToBeBetter

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''{{HBeamPiper Space Viking]]'', the main character worries about his home planet's civilization declining, and a historian agrees: "That's what happened to the Terran Federation, by the way. The good men all left to colonize, and the stuffed shirts and yes-men and herd-followers and safety-firsters stayed on Terra and tried to govern the Galaxy."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Halo}}'', we had colonized hundreds of worlds due to Earth becoming way to overpopulated. Now, with about 270,000,000 humans left, we could fit everyone in America.

to:

* In ''{{Halo}}'', we had colonized hundreds of worlds due to Earth becoming way to too overpopulated. Now, with about 270,000,000 humans left, we could fit everyone in America.

Added: 148

Changed: 39

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In JohnScalzi's ''[=~Old Man's War~=]'' series, Earth has become a half-forgotten backwater compared to [[spoiler: and by the sinister machinations of]] the Colonial government. It's centuries behind the technological curve (particularly medically) and under permanent quarantine following a plague that caused mass infertility [[spoiler: and was created by the Colonial government just to justify said quarantine]]. Average quality of life is not really much worse than today, but it could be ''so'' much better.
** Worse, Earth is basically used as a soldier-farm by the Colonial Union.

to:

* In JohnScalzi's ''[=~Old Man's War~=]'' series, Earth has become a half-forgotten [[strike:half-forgotten]] backwater compared to [[spoiler: and [[spoiler:and by the sinister machinations of]] the Colonial government. It's centuries behind the technological curve (particularly medically) and under permanent quarantine following a plague that caused mass infertility [[spoiler: and [[spoiler:and was created by the Colonial government just to justify said quarantine]]. Average quality of life is not really much worse than today, but it could be ''so'' much better.
** Worse, Earth is basically used as a soldier-farm soldier- and colonist-farm by the Colonial Union.
** At least, it's one of the safest human-populated planets and not much threated by AlienInvasion, unlike most of the worlds of
the Colonial Union.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''NightsDawn'' trilogy by PeterFHamilton. Earth suffers from devestating megacyclones (Amarda storms) and so the entire population lives inside giant arcologies.

to:

* ''NightsDawn'' trilogy ''[[{{Literature/ptitleeiku6qu3}} The Night's Dawn Trilogy]]'' by PeterFHamilton. Earth suffers from devestating megacyclones (Amarda storms) and so the entire population lives inside giant arcologies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Mentioned a few times in ''{{Strata}}'' by TerryPratchett, although we never go to Earth. Much of the human population was killed by the Mindquakes, a phenomenon when the population grew too large and dense to the point where the psychic pressure caused people to spontaneously die. The main character Kin Arad grew up on the planet in the aftermath of this--as a child, she saw a small crowd of humans watching robots dance, and this motivated her to grow up to help rebuild the planet and ensure robots never outnumbered humans there. By the time the story is set, Earth is still considered a backwater by the human colony worlds, but its population is back up to three-quarters of a billion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Not really. Almost all humans still live on Earth (or lunar/orbital structures at the very most) - it's just a CrapsackWorld with massive overpopulation, almost all species extinct, regular terrorism and natural disasters and the majority of people surviving on algae.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** According to the novelization, Earth has basically become a giant, polluted slum; the only people who still live there are the people who can't ''afford'' to get offworld.

to:

** According to the novelization, Earth has basically become a giant, polluted slum; the only people who still live there are the people who can't ''afford'' to get offworld. It obviously still has some significance as the birthplace of humanity, judging from the horrified reaction of Call when she realizes that the ''Auriga'' is programmed to return to Earth in the event of an emergency, which would unleash the Xenomorphs on Earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** According to the novelization, Earth has basically become a giant, polluted slum; the only people who still live there are the people who can't ''afford'' to get offworld.

Changed: 492

Removed: 1817

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Earth in the Universal Century may be a more subtle example, as while it doesn't have cyberpunk-esque ruined ecosystems, its been a successful target of {{Colony Drop}}s on at least 4 occasions, with more attempts being barely stopped at the last moment. Furthermore, At least half of the Human population has long since moved into orbital colony structures, and said colonists tend to blame ''all'' of Earth's population for their problems and claim Earth-dwellers to be a bunch of decadent hedonists, Even though its been explicitly shown in some UC shows (such as 08th MS Team) that a lot of Earth still lives fairly primitive lives that look like something more out of a Vietnam War documentary than a Science Fiction setting.

to:

** Earth in the Universal Century may be a more subtle example, as while it doesn't have cyberpunk-esque ruined ecosystems, its been a successful target of {{Colony Drop}}s on at least 4 occasions, with more attempts being barely stopped at the last moment. Furthermore, At least half of the Human population has long since moved into orbital colony structures, and said colonists tend to blame ''all'' of Earth's population for their problems and claim Earth-dwellers to be a bunch of decadent hedonists, Even though its been explicitly shown in some UC shows (such as 08th MS Team) that a lot of Earth still lives fairly primitive lives that look like something more out of a Vietnam War documentary than a Science Fiction setting.hedonists.



* ''BladeRunner'': Overcrowded and rainy
** Undercrowded-- recall J.F. Sebastian's noting "No housing shortage around here; plenty of room for everybody," and that he lives alone in the Bradbury building. And a number of interior scenes clearly have daylights outside at the eyeball-scorching level of sunlight one usually expects from Los Angeles. (Presumably rain came in every now and then as a chain of small winter storms blew in-- not uncommon weather for Los Angeles in November.) There may well be some big screwed-up-biosphere reason artificial animals are so popular, but there isn't any real clear sign of it on-camera.
*** WordOfGod is that [[GlobalWarming the constant rain clouds are due to the oceans evaporating.]]
** Same as in the book really, though there it is more explicitly explained to be the result of a radioactive disaster (possibly war) of some kind. Most of the biosphere is dead or dying, and big dust storms are known to sweep through pretty much anywhere. There's still a significant earthbound population (though most who could afford to have already left the planet), but there's tons of empty apartments in even the most densely populated buildings. Owning an actual living animal of any kind is a pretty big status symbol (people carry around a Blue Book for animal values) so artificial animals are popular as a cheaper and covert way to APPEAR to be able to afford a real one.

to:

* ''BladeRunner'': Overcrowded Undercrowded and rainy
** Undercrowded-- recall J.F. Sebastian's noting "No housing shortage around here; plenty of room for everybody," and that he lives alone in
rainy. The book goes into more detail on the Bradbury building. And a number of interior scenes clearly have daylights outside at the eyeball-scorching level of sunlight one usually expects from Los Angeles. (Presumably rain came in every now and then as a chain of small winter storms blew in-- not uncommon weather for Los Angeles in November.) There may well be some big screwed-up-biosphere reason artificial damaged biosphere; real animals are so popular, but there isn't any real clear sign of it on-camera.
*** WordOfGod is
rare enough that [[GlobalWarming the constant rain clouds are due to the oceans evaporating.]]
** Same as in the book really, though there it is more explicitly explained to be the result of a radioactive disaster (possibly war) of some kind. Most of the biosphere is dead or dying, and big dust storms are known to sweep through pretty much anywhere. There's still a significant earthbound population (though most who could afford to have already left the planet), but there's tons of empty apartments in even the most densely populated buildings. Owning an actual living animal of any kind
owning one is a pretty big status symbol (people carry around a Blue Book for animal values) so artificial animals are popular as a cheaper and covert way to APPEAR to be able to afford a real one.symbol.



** That said, the environment itself is doing quite fine. Most of Europe is mentioned to be covered in forests, land overtaken as a result of population and industry shifts.



** It's basicly a grimdark version of [[StarWars Coruscant]]. It also has defences that would make any would-be invader shit themselves.
*** And there is no doubt about a million other defenses around and on the planet, that the Imperium has simply ''lost.'' They do that.
** Unless one had the luck to see him/herself on the [[TheGovernment Adeptus Terra]] payroll. Emperor's servants live relatively decently.

to:

** It's basicly a grimdark version of [[StarWars Coruscant]]. It also has defences that would make any would-be invader shit themselves.
*** And there is no doubt about a million other defenses around and on the planet, that the Imperium has simply ''lost.'' They do that.
** Unless one had the luck to see him/herself on the [[TheGovernment Adeptus Terra]] payroll. Emperor's servants live relatively decently.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In some of IsaacAsimov's stories, Earth becomes a world of overcowded, domed cites, where [[PlanetOfHats everyone has]] agoraphobia and [[FantasticRacism hates those darn job - stealing robots.]] In some other Asimov stories Earth is radioactive, but not so much that people can't live here; it's just very very very unpleasant. Other people moved to the stars. (After [[ScienceMarchesOn Science Marched On]] and it was discovered that it wouldn't be possible to live on a planet with much radiation, Asimov said that if he could go back and fix the stories he would but it was so much a part of the setting he couldn't.)

to:

* In some of IsaacAsimov's stories, Earth becomes a world of overcowded, overcrowded, domed cites, where [[PlanetOfHats everyone has]] agoraphobia and [[FantasticRacism hates those darn job - stealing job-stealing robots.]] In some other Asimov stories Earth is radioactive, but not so much that people can't live here; it's just very very very unpleasant. Other people moved to the stars. (After [[ScienceMarchesOn Science Marched On]] and it was discovered that it wouldn't be possible to live on a planet with much radiation, Asimov said that if he could go back and fix the stories he would but it was so much a part of the setting he couldn't.)



* In the ''Red Dwarf'' novels Earth has had all its mineral resources stripped from it, is afflicted by comically high levels of pollution, and is home only to "a few hundred thousand people too poor, too scared or too stupid to leave" -- the rest of humanity is spread throughout the Solar System. Lister still loves Earth and considers it home, even though it's a dump.

to:

* In the ''Red Dwarf'' ''RedDwarf'' novels Earth has had all its mineral resources stripped from it, is afflicted by comically high levels of pollution, and is home only to "a few hundred thousand people too poor, too scared or too stupid to leave" -- the rest of humanity is spread throughout the Solar System. Lister still loves Earth and considers it home, even though it's a dump.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''MassEffect'': Very overcrowded with all attendant issues, though things are getting better. Growing up in the slums is one of Shepard's optional backgrounds. The codex states that with colonization of other worlds and thus lessening of the population, Earth "is entering a new golden age."

to:

* ''MassEffect'': Very overcrowded with all attendant issues, though things are getting better. Growing up in the slums is one of Shepard's optional backgrounds. The codex states that with colonization According to the Codex, the colonizations of other worlds has lead to a wealth of resources being sent back to Earth, and thus lessening of the population, Earth "is entering a new golden age." current technology has resulted in the elimination of most genetic diseases and pollution. There's also some environmental problems, but those have been getting better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sometimes goes hand in hand with GaiasLament. Occasionally prone to starting TheWarOfEarthlyAggession out of jealousy.

to:

Sometimes goes hand in hand with GaiasLament. Occasionally prone to starting TheWarOfEarthlyAggession TheWarOfEarthlyAggression out of jealousy.jealousy or selfishness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sometimes goes hand in hand with GaiasLament.

to:

Sometimes goes hand in hand with GaiasLament. Occasionally prone to starting TheWarOfEarthlyAggession out of jealousy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** WordOfGod is that [[GlobalWarming the constant rain clouds are due to the ocean evaporating.]]

to:

*** WordOfGod is that [[GlobalWarming the constant rain clouds are due to the ocean oceans evaporating.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** WordOfGod is that [[GlobalWarming the constant rain clouds are due to the ocean evaporating.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Same as in the book really, though there it is more explicitly explained to be the result of a radioactive disaster (possibly war) of some kind. Most of the biosphere is dead or dying, and big dust storms are known to sweep through pretty much anywhere. There's still a significant earthbound population (though most who could afford to have already left the planet), but there's tons of empty apartments in even the most densely populated buildings. Owning an actual living animal of any kind is a pretty big status symbol (people carry around a Blue Book for animal values) so artificial animals are popular as a cheaper and covert way to APPEAR to be able to afford a real one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Undercrowded-- recall J.F. Sebastian's noting "No housing shortage around here; plenty of room for everybody," and that he lives alone in the Bradbury building. And a number of interior scenes clearly have daylights outside at the eyeball-scorching level of sunlight one usually expects from Los Angeles. (Presumably rain came in every now and then as a chain of small winter storms blew in-- not uncommon weather for Los Angeles in November.) There may well be some big screwed-up-biosphere reason artificial animals are so popular, but there isn't any real clear sign of it on-camera.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In John Scalzi's [[OldMansWar Old Man's War]] series, Earth has become a half-forgotten backwater compared to [[spoiler: and by the sinister machinations of]] the Colonial government. It's centuries behind the technological curve (particularly medically) and under permanent quarantine following a plague that caused mass infertility [[spoiler: and was created by the Colonial government just to justify said quarantine]]. Average quality of life is not really much worse than today, but it could be ''so'' much better.

to:

* In John Scalzi's [[OldMansWar Old JohnScalzi's ''[=~Old Man's War]] War~=]'' series, Earth has become a half-forgotten backwater compared to [[spoiler: and by the sinister machinations of]] the Colonial government. It's centuries behind the technological curve (particularly medically) and under permanent quarantine following a plague that caused mass infertility [[spoiler: and was created by the Colonial government just to justify said quarantine]]. Average quality of life is not really much worse than today, but it could be ''so'' much better.

Changed: 1070

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''[[Series/DesertPunk Desert Punk]]'' is set in the "Great Kanto Desert", which is a wasteland with some remnants of old cities. At present, the Kanto region of Japan is not only a plain (i.e. somewhere fertile), but it's also a very industrialized and populated area, being the place where Tokyo is located. It's indicated that due to a combination of nuclear and/or biological weapons and a RobotWar, humans almost drove themselves to extinction. Also, it could be just CreatorProvincialism, but there's no indication of what if anything is left of the rest of the world.




to:

* In the VorkosiganSaga, most of the series is set on several planets that became human space colonies and Earth is sort of like a giant Switzerland/United Nations. When Miles visits Earth, his description of what he considers classic London archetecture is all modern or near future, implying that the famous landmarks in the city were either replaced of destroyed. There's also a description of the "Island of Los Angeles", implying that California eventually sank into the Pacific Ocean.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Earth in {{Fallen Dragon}} is heading this way. As a result of poverty, economic stagnation and industrial stagnation, most the planet is covered in {{Dying Town}}s. Colonisation and {{Casual Space Travel}} is creeping to a halt due to mounting costs and the {{Megacorp}}s inhabiting Earth are plundering their own distant colonies before returning to Earth to hole up.

to:

* The Earth in {{Fallen Dragon}} is heading this way. As a result of poverty, economic stagnation and industrial stagnation, most the planet is covered in {{Dying Town}}s. Colonisation and {{Casual Space Travel}} CasualInterstellarTravel is creeping to a halt due to mounting costs and the {{Megacorp}}s inhabiting Earth are plundering their own distant colonies before returning to Earth to hole up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Earth in the Universal Century may be a more subtle example, as while it doesn't have cyberpunk-esque ruined ecosystems, its been a successful target of ColonyDrops on at least 4 occasions, with more attempts being barely stopped at the last moment. Furthermore, At least half of the Human population has long since moved into orbital colony structures, and said colonists tend to blame ''all'' of Earth's population for their problems and claim Earth-dwellers to be a bunch of decadent hedonists, Even though its been explicitly shown in some UC shows (such as 08th MS Team) that a lot of Earth still lives fairly primitive lives that look like something more out of a Vietnam War documentary than a Science Fiction setting.

to:

** Earth in the Universal Century may be a more subtle example, as while it doesn't have cyberpunk-esque ruined ecosystems, its been a successful target of ColonyDrops {{Colony Drop}}s on at least 4 occasions, with more attempts being barely stopped at the last moment. Furthermore, At least half of the Human population has long since moved into orbital colony structures, and said colonists tend to blame ''all'' of Earth's population for their problems and claim Earth-dwellers to be a bunch of decadent hedonists, Even though its been explicitly shown in some UC shows (such as 08th MS Team) that a lot of Earth still lives fairly primitive lives that look like something more out of a Vietnam War documentary than a Science Fiction setting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''NightsDawn'' trilogy by PeterFHamilton. Earth suffers from devestating megacyclones (Amarda storms) and so the entire population lives inside giant arcologies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That said, the environment itself is doing quite fine. Most of Europe is mentioned to be covered in forests, land overtaken as a result of population and industry shifts.

Added: 289

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''MassEffect'': Very overcrowded with all attendant issues, though things are getting better. Growing up in the slums is one of Shepard's optional backgrounds. The codex states that with colonization of other worlds and thus lessening of the population, Earth "is entering a new golden age."

to:

* ''MassEffect'': Very overcrowded with all attendant issues, though things are getting better. Growing up in the slums is one of Shepard's optional backgrounds. The codex states that with colonization of other worlds and thus lessening of the population, Earth "is entering a new golden age.""
** Like in the modern day, it depends considerably on where you live, though the rich and poor countries have shifted around for a bit. India is now one of the richest and most pleasant regions on the planet, while Texas is a Third World country, and New York is a slum-ridden megalopolis.

Added: 536

Changed: 607

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
used to be better= present time, which it clearly at one point got worse than


* Living on the Earth of ColonyWars is little more than a status symbol, as the entire planet is a sickly brown color. The eponymous war happens because the government on Earth and the upper-class it represents expect the colonies to exist solely for the purpose of funneling resources back to them, until the colonies rise up against the abuse and declare independence. In the first game's best ending, most of the people of Earth simply leaves to make new lives for themselves on the colonies. [[ItGotWorse This ending is not canon.]]



* Living on the Earth of ColonyWars is little more than a status symbol, as the entire planet is a sickly brown color. The eponymous war happens because the government on Earth and the upper-class it represents expect the colonies to exist solely for the purpose of funneling resources back to them, until the colonies rise up against the abuse and declare independence. In the first game's best ending, most of the people of Earth simply leaves to make new lives for themselves on the colonies. [[ItGotWorse This ending is not canon.]]

to:

* Living on ''MassEffect'': Very overcrowded with all attendant issues, though things are getting better. Growing up in the Earth slums is one of ColonyWars is little more than a status symbol, as the entire planet is a sickly brown color. Shepard's optional backgrounds. The eponymous war happens because the government on Earth codex states that with colonization of other worlds and the upper-class it represents expect the colonies to exist solely for the purpose of funneling resources back to them, until the colonies rise up against the abuse and declare independence. In the first game's best ending, most thus lessening of the people of population, Earth simply leaves to make "is entering a new lives for themselves on the colonies. [[ItGotWorse This ending is not canon.]]golden age."

Added: 536

Removed: 610

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The codex doesn't give us enough information to say whether or not it solidly "used to be better." We're told environmental damage is being repaired and the start of what will likely be a golden age has been caused by the influx of resources from colonization, and that the benefits simply haven't spread to the entire planet yet. It's even touched upon by Thane, who mentions that, unlike his own world, Earth discovered space travel before resource deprivation and pollution became a real problem.


* ''MassEffect'': Very overcrowded with all attendant issues, though things are getting better. Growing up in the slums is one of Shepard's optional backgrounds.
** The codex stated that with colonization of other worlds and thus lessening of the population, Earth "is entering a new golden age."
*** You still never get to go there. In the first game the closest you get is the moon, and in the second, you're not welcome outside the Terminus systems. Given how much Shepard has pissed off the Reapers, though, good money is on a climatic battle scene around the InsignificantLittleBluePlanet in the third game.


Added DiffLines:

* Living on the Earth of ColonyWars is little more than a status symbol, as the entire planet is a sickly brown color. The eponymous war happens because the government on Earth and the upper-class it represents expect the colonies to exist solely for the purpose of funneling resources back to them, until the colonies rise up against the abuse and declare independence. In the first game's best ending, most of the people of Earth simply leaves to make new lives for themselves on the colonies. [[ItGotWorse This ending is not canon.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Aria}}'': [[TokenLoli Ai]] has never seen a blue sky and Akari comments that you can no longer swim in the oceans or dig in the earth. Also, the oceans rose so Venice is gone. Luckily, terraforming Mars went extremely well and they built a new Venice. on it.

to:

* ''{{Aria}}'': [[TokenLoli Ai]] has never seen a blue sky and Akari comments that you can no longer swim in the oceans or dig in the earth. Also, the oceans rose so Venice is gone. Luckily, terraforming Mars went extremely well and they built a new Venice. on On it.




to:

* The more charitable interpretation of YokohamaKaidashiKikou, where there weren't any real cataclysm, and most of the Earth's populations simply left for a greener pastures, leaving their less adventurous brethren back home. Definitely of the "still pleasant" variety.




to:

* CliffordSimak's ''City''. By the end of the series the most human population left for idyllic transhuman life on Jupiter, the few remaining "websters" living in the isolated communities decide to either leave Earth to or go to cryogenic sleep, and the Earth is left for the post-human sentient ants and dogs (who also eventually leave).




to:

** Unless one had the luck to see him/herself on the [[TheGovernment Adeptus Terra]] payroll. Emperor's servants live relatively decently.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** You still never get to go there. In the first game the closest you get is the moon, and in the second, you're not welcome outside the Terminus systems. Given how much Shepard has pissed off the Reapers, though, good money is on a climatic battle scene around the InsignificantLittleBluePlanet in the third game.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''TheHistoryOfTheGalaxy'', Earth i an overpopulated world at the beginning of the timeline but thr population steadily leaves during the war. Hundreds of years later, Earth is once again a lush world, nature having taken back most of what used to be civilization.

to:

* In ''TheHistoryOfTheGalaxy'', Earth i is an overpopulated world at the beginning of the timeline but thr the population steadily leaves during the war. Hundreds of years later, Earth is once again a lush world, nature having taken back most of what used to be civilization.

Added: 268

Changed: 595

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In MikhailAkhmanov's ''Earth's Shadow'', Earth has long ago been mostly abandoned due to the discovery of interstellar portal technology. Entire cities have been moved to other planets, leaving a planet full of giant holes in the ground. Only the poorest countries couldn't afford to move. The remaining powers in the world are the Central-European Republic of Ukraine and a state in South America, populated mostly by the escaped Russian population of Ukraine. During the final days of the exodus, the warring factions activate a jamming device, blocking portal travel to and from the planet.
* In ''TheHistoryOfTheGalaxy'', Earth i an overpopulated world at the beginning of the timeline but thr population steadily leaves during the war. Hundreds of years later, Earth is once again a lush world, nature having taken back most of what used to be civilization.

Top