Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / WhatIf2

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
These alt texts were NOT included in the book, hence why they were excluded


** '''Chapter 37: Laser Umbrella''' explores using laser beams as an umbrella. Since it would require an extremely powerful laser, as well as surgically precise aiming, it's a cool idea[[note]]'''Megan:''' It isn't.[[/note]] that won't end up working very well.

to:

** '''Chapter 37: Laser Umbrella''' explores using laser beams as an umbrella. Since it would require an extremely powerful laser, as well as surgically precise aiming, it's a cool idea[[note]]'''Megan:''' It isn't.[[/note]] idea that won't end up working very well.



'''Cueball:''' ''(sitting at the controls of his giant roof-mounted laser)'' Dunno.[[labelnote:AltText]]List of possible causes. Smoking in bed. Dryer lint. Induced currents. Sunspots. Neap tides. COX-2 inhibition. [=eBay=]. A reverse fire extinguisher. One of the ghosts from Pac-Man got loose and got into your house and knocked over a candle. Could be anything.[[/labelnote]]

to:

'''Cueball:''' ''(sitting at the controls of his giant roof-mounted laser)'' Dunno.[[labelnote:AltText]]List of possible causes. Smoking in bed. Dryer lint. Induced currents. Sunspots. Neap tides. COX-2 inhibition. [=eBay=]. A reverse fire extinguisher. One of the ghosts from Pac-Man got loose and got into your house and knocked over a candle. Could be anything.[[/labelnote]]
Dunno.



---> '''Megan:''' No, it doesn't.[[labelnote:AltText]]Why would that sound reasonable. Why would you say that.[[/labelnote]]

to:

---> '''Megan:''' No, it doesn't.[[labelnote:AltText]]Why would that sound reasonable. Why would you say that.[[/labelnote]]



---> '''Megan:''' It isn't.[[labelnote:AltText]]What's wrong with you?[[/labelnote]]

to:

---> '''Megan:''' It isn't.[[labelnote:AltText]]What's wrong with you?[[/labelnote]]



---> '''Megan:''' Fine.[[labelnote:AltText]]But we shouldn't be.[[/labelnote]]

to:

---> '''Megan:''' Fine.[[labelnote:AltText]]But we shouldn't be.[[/labelnote]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Cueball:''' ''(sitting at the controls of his giant roof-mounted laser)'' Dunno.

to:

'''Cueball:''' ''(sitting at the controls of his giant roof-mounted laser)'' Dunno.
Dunno.[[labelnote:AltText]]List of possible causes. Smoking in bed. Dryer lint. Induced currents. Sunspots. Neap tides. COX-2 inhibition. [=eBay=]. A reverse fire extinguisher. One of the ghosts from Pac-Man got loose and got into your house and knocked over a candle. Could be anything.[[/labelnote]]



---> '''Megan:''' No, it doesn't. ('''AltText:''' Why would that sound reasonable. Why would you say that.)

to:

---> '''Megan:''' No, it doesn't. ('''AltText:''' Why [[labelnote:AltText]]Why would that sound reasonable. Why would you say that.)[[/labelnote]]



---> '''Megan:''' It isn't. ('''AltText:''' What's wrong with you?)

to:

---> '''Megan:''' It isn't. ('''AltText:''' What's [[labelnote:AltText]]What's wrong with you?)you?[[/labelnote]]



---> '''Megan:''' Fine. ('''AltText:''' But we shouldn't be.)

to:

---> '''Megan:''' Fine. ('''AltText:''' But [[labelnote:AltText]]But we shouldn't be.)[[/labelnote]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---> '''Megan:''' No, it doesn't.

to:

---> '''Megan:''' No, it doesn't. ('''AltText:''' Why would that sound reasonable. Why would you say that.)



---> '''Megan:''' It isn't.

to:

---> '''Megan:''' It isn't. ('''AltText:''' What's wrong with you?)



---> '''Megan:''' Fine.

to:

---> '''Megan:''' Fine. ('''AltText:''' But we shouldn't be.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Chapter 37: Laser Umbrella''' explores using laser beams as an umbrella. Since it would require an extremely powerful laser, as well as surgically precise aiming, it's a cool idea that won't end up working very well.

to:

** '''Chapter 37: Laser Umbrella''' explores using laser beams as an umbrella. Since it would require an extremely powerful laser, as well as surgically precise aiming, it's a cool idea idea[[note]]'''Megan:''' It isn't.[[/note]] that won't end up working very well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "If I were to jump into a container of liquid nitrogen (or dispose of a body in that way), how deep would it have to be for me/them to shatter into frozen pieces at the bottom?"

to:

** "If I were to jump into a container of liquid nitrogen (or [[DisposingOfABody dispose of a body body]] in that way), how deep would it have to be for me/them to shatter into frozen pieces at the bottom?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Chapter 2: Helicopter Ride''' explores what happens to a helicopter if you decide to latch onto the blades. Since, normally, you'd fall off about halfway through the first turn from centrifugal force alone, Randall introduces the ACME Hand Anchors, labeled as "Incredibly dangerous" and "The FAA ''hates'' it!", to keep Cueball attached.

to:

** '''Chapter 2: Helicopter Ride''' explores what happens to a helicopter if you decide to latch onto the blades. Since, normally, you'd fall off about halfway through the first turn from centrifugal force alone, Randall introduces the [[AcmeProducts ACME Hand Anchors, Anchors]], labeled as "Incredibly dangerous" and "The FAA ''hates'' it!", to keep Cueball attached.attached. It doesn't help though, since your body won't be attatched to your arms for much longer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImplausibleDeniability: [[https://what-if.xkcd.com/119/ Laser Umbrella]] ends with Cueball setting a neighbor's house on fire.

to:

* ImplausibleDeniability: [[https://what-if.xkcd.com/119/ '''Chapter 37: Laser Umbrella]] Umbrella''' ends with Cueball setting a neighbor's house on fire.



* WaxingLyrical: In "[[https://what-if.xkcd.com/83/ Star Sand]]", one image compares the Sun to stars that are "heavier, bluer, bigger, younger, [[Music/DaftPunk harder, better, faster, stronger]]".

to:

* WaxingLyrical: In "[[https://what-if.xkcd.com/83/ '''Chapter 16: Star Sand]]", Sand''', one image compares the Sun to stars that are "heavier, bluer, bigger, younger, [[Music/DaftPunk harder, better, faster, stronger]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add two tropes listed on the blog's page for articles also found in the book


* ImplausibleDeniability: [[https://what-if.xkcd.com/119/ Laser Umbrella]] ends with Cueball setting a neighbor's house on fire.
-->'''Neighbor:''' Why is my house on fire ''again''?\\
'''Cueball:''' ''(sitting at the controls of his giant roof-mounted laser)'' Dunno.



'''Scientist 2:''' OK. You'll need to come along since we need two people to turn the keys to access it.

to:

'''Scientist 2:''' OK. You'll need to come along since we need two people to turn the keys to access it.it.

* WaxingLyrical: In "[[https://what-if.xkcd.com/83/ Star Sand]]", one image compares the Sun to stars that are "heavier, bluer, bigger, younger, [[Music/DaftPunk harder, better, faster, stronger]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''[[ApocalypseHow/ClassX2 Chapter 20: Elemental Worlds]]''' explores what happens if Mercury, Ceres, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto are made of Mercury, Cerium, Uranium, Neptunium, and Plutonium, respectively. While Mercury Mercury and Cerium Ceres are, generally, perfectly fine for our Solar System, the other three have more catastrophic implications, especially for Neptunium Neptune, which would glow so hot that the planet ''vaporizes itself''. Things get worse using unstable isotopes - if our Uranium Uranus were made of [[superscript:235]]U instead of [[superscript:238]]U, the resulting radiation would cause a nuclear reaction so strong that Earth would be stripped to nothing but a blob of magma in only 3 hours.

to:

** '''[[ApocalypseHow/ClassX2 Chapter 20: Elemental Worlds]]''' explores what happens if Mercury, Ceres, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto are made of Mercury, Cerium, Uranium, Neptunium, and Plutonium, respectively. While Mercury Mercury and Cerium Ceres are, generally, perfectly fine for our Solar System, System (brighter than they currently are, but not enough to really affect us on Earth), the other three have more catastrophic implications, especially for Neptunium Neptune, which would glow so hot that the planet ''vaporizes itself''. Things get worse using unstable isotopes - if our Uranium Uranus were made of [[superscript:235]]U instead of [[superscript:238]]U, the resulting radiation would cause a nuclear reaction so strong that the plasma wave would strip Earth would be stripped to nothing but a blob of magma in only 3 hours.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As a side note, all of the text found in images is stylized in all caps, SORT OF LIKE THIS. For the sake of clarity, they've been changed to proper capitalization, where applicable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Chapter 35: No-Rules NASCAR''' imagines a scenario where NASCAR strips all of its rules, leading to a race where the goal is to simply get a human around the track 200 times as fast as possible. The answer is around an hour, at a G-limit of 10. If the human doesn't need to survive, it can be done even faster by making a particle accelerator, finishing all 200 laps in only 2 seconds.

to:

** '''Chapter 35: [[NoRulesRacing No-Rules NASCAR''' NASCAR]]''' imagines a scenario where NASCAR strips all of its rules, leading to a race where the goal is to simply get a human around the track 200 times as fast as possible. The answer is around an hour, at a G-limit of 10. If the human doesn't need to survive, it can be done even faster by making a particle accelerator, finishing all 200 laps in only 2 seconds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A handful of subtle callbacks to '''How To''', another one of Randall's books:

to:

** A handful of subtle callbacks to '''How To''', ''How To'', another one of Randall's books:

Added: 592

Changed: 81

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** A handful of subtle callbacks to '''How To''', another one of Randall's books:
*** '''Chapter 4: Ironic Vaporization''' talks about how vaporizing a cubic metre of iron will annoy "the neighbors who live downwind from you", referencing '''Chapter 2: How to Throw a Pool Party''', where using a giant humidifier to collect water from the atmosphere could have the same effect.
*** '''Chapter 38: Eat a Cloud''' features a nutritional label for a cloud, referencing the nutritional label for lava found in '''Chapter 9: How to Build a Lava Moat'''.
*** A footnote in '''Chapter 50: Japan Runs an Errand''' makes a direct mention of '''Chapter 2: How to Throw a Pool Party'''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As a side note, all of the text found in images is stylized in all caps, SORT OF LIKE THIS. For the sake of clarity, they've been changed to proper capitalization, where applicible.

to:

As a side note, all of the text found in images is stylized in all caps, SORT OF LIKE THIS. For the sake of clarity, they've been changed to proper capitalization, where applicible.
applicable.



--> A solidified lava lamp is just about the most boring thing in the world. But the scenario made me wonder: If making a lamp out of molten lava wouldn't be very exciting, then what about a volacno made of lamps? This is probably the most useless calculation I've ever done,* but... [[TitleDrop what if]] Mount Saint Helens erupted again today, but instead of tephra,† it spewed compact fluorescent bulbs?

to:

--> A solidified lava lamp is just about the most boring thing in the world. But the scenario made me wonder: If making a lamp out of molten lava wouldn't be very exciting, then what about a volacno volcano made of lamps? This is probably the most useless calculation I've ever done,* but... [[TitleDrop what if]] Mount Saint Helens erupted again today, but instead of tephra,† it spewed compact fluorescent bulbs?



** '''Chapter 6: Pidgeon Chair''' shows that it is possible to use pidgeons to lift yourself to the top of a skyscraper, but it's extremely risky and your life will be in the hands of anyone with a bag of seeds.

to:

** '''Chapter 6: Pidgeon Chair''' shows that it is possible to use pidgeons pigeons to lift yourself to the top of a skyscraper, but it's extremely risky and your life will be in the hands of anyone with a bag of seeds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Chapter 35: No-Rules NASCAR''' imagines a scenario where NASCAR strips all of its rules, leading to a race where the goal is to simply get a human around the track 200 times as fast as possible. The answer is around an hour, at a G-limit of 10. If the human doesn't need to survive, it can be done even faster by making a particle accelerator, finishing 30 laps in a mere 2.7 milliseconds.

to:

** '''Chapter 35: No-Rules NASCAR''' imagines a scenario where NASCAR strips all of its rules, leading to a race where the goal is to simply get a human around the track 200 times as fast as possible. The answer is around an hour, at a G-limit of 10. If the human doesn't need to survive, it can be done even faster by making a particle accelerator, finishing 30 all 200 laps in a mere 2.7 milliseconds.only 2 seconds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** "Tephra" is labeled in a footnote as "whatever that stuff is that comes out of a volcano."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Billy the Clown is running out of cash, so in order to raise money, he devises his newest trick: He will inflate, by mouth, a standard-size party balloon until the material (some form on indestructible rubber) is just one atom thick. How large would the inflated party balloon be?"

to:

** "Billy the Clown is running out of cash, so in order to raise money, he devises his newest trick: He will inflate, by mouth, a standard-size party balloon until the material (some form on of indestructible rubber) is just one atom thick. How large would the inflated party balloon be?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Chapter 60: Dog Overload''' states that under the conditions underlined in the ApocalypseHow section of this page, the dog sphere will expand faster than light itself in only 197 years.

to:

** '''Chapter 60: Dog Overload''' states that under the conditions underlined outlined in the ApocalypseHow section of this page, the dog sphere will expand faster than light itself in only 197 years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Short Answers #2''' has a question asking how fast you have to go to break every bone in your body on a trampoline, as well as how fast you have to go to go through the mesh. The answer is indeterminate, since there are very tiny bones, mainly in your hands and feet. As for going through the mesh, it's not possible.
** '''Chapter 19: Slow Dinosaur Extinction''' explores the Chicxulub meteor impact, the impact believed to have killed off the dinosaurs, if the meteor hit the earth at only 3 mph (4.83 km/h). The result isn't mass extinction, but since many meteors are essentially giant balls of gravel, the impact leads to the meteor spreading outwards like a puddle via soil liquefaction, spreading faster than the speed of sound.

to:

** '''Short Answers #2''' has a question asking how fast you have to go to break every bone in your body on a trampoline, as well as how fast you have to go to go through the holes in the mesh. The answer is indeterminate, since there are very tiny bones, mainly in your hands and feet. As for going through the mesh, it's not possible.
** '''Chapter 19: Slow Dinosaur Extinction''' explores the Chicxulub meteor impact, the impact believed to have killed off the dinosaurs, if the meteor hit the earth Earth at only 3 mph (4.83 km/h). The result isn't mass extinction, but since many meteors are essentially giant balls of gravel, the impact leads to the meteor spreading outwards like a puddle via soil liquefaction, spreading faster than the speed of sound.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BulletCatch: The premise of '''Chapter 12: Catch!''' Randall explains that this trope might be possible, provided you shoot the bullet upwards so that the bullet stops mid-air, and have a friend catch it there by flying with a hot-air balloon or something.


Added DiffLines:

* DeadpanSnarker: Randall's personality in general. It shows up very occasionally, more often in '''Short Answers''' segments.
--> Decorating Tip: The air in your house should be in gas form


Added DiffLines:

* RhetoricalQuestionBlunder: Randall does this to himself in '''Chapter 53: Saliva Pool''':
--> But it would all be worth it, because at the end of it all, you'd have an Olympic-size swimming pool full of saliva. And isn't that, deep down, all any of us really want?*
---> [[FootnoteFever * No. It is not.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->[[FootnoteFever * Okay, there's no ''way'' that's true.]]

to:

--->[[FootnoteFever * Okay, there's no ''way'' no]] ''[[FootnoteFever way]]'' [[FootnoteFever that's true.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AttentionDeficitOohShiny: In '''Chapter 40: Lava Lamp''', Randall discusses why a lava lamp with real lava can be both a lame idea and a terrible idea. Near the end, he veers off into calculations about a volcano made out of lamps -- lamp lava, if you will.
--> A solidified lava lamp is just about the most boring thing in the world. But the scenario made me wonder: If making a lamp out of molten lava wouldn't be very exciting, then what about a volacno made of lamps? This is probably the most useless calculation I've ever done,* but... [[TitleDrop what if]] Mount Saint Helens erupted again today, but instead of tephra,† it spewed compact fluorescent bulbs?
--->[[FootnoteFever * Okay, there's no ''way'' that's true.]]
--->[[FootnoteFever † The technical term for "whatever that stuff is that comes out of a volcano."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BluntNo: At the end of '''Chapter 42: Blood Alcohol''', Megan can be seen with a gallon of blood, trying to suggest that they do it with blood.

to:

* BluntNo: At the end of '''Chapter 42: Blood Alcohol''', Megan can be seen with a gallon of blood, trying to suggest that they do it the Gallon Challenge with blood.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

---> And yet I bet someone would ''still'' try to go over it in a barrel.

Top