Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheYiddishPolicemensUnion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ultimately subverted with Sitka. Rather than a permanent Jewish homeland, it's a provisional land agreement only meant to last for sixty years. With the lease at its end, the land is set to revert back to American control. What will become of the Jews then, nobody knows.

to:

** Ultimately subverted with Sitka. Rather than a permanent Jewish homeland, it's a provisional land agreement only meant to last for sixty years. years and its administered as a federal district, similar to Puerto Rico. With the lease at near its end, the land is set to revert back to full American control. What will become of the Jews then, nobody knows.control.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ultimately subverted with Sitka. Rather than a permanent Jewish homeland, it's a provisional land agreement only meant to last for sixty years. With the lease at its end, the land is set to revert back to American control and, while the unnamed president believes that the Jews need to reclaim Israel, nobody's sure what will happen next.

to:

* ** Ultimately subverted with Sitka. Rather than a permanent Jewish homeland, it's a provisional land agreement only meant to last for sixty years. With the lease at its end, the land is set to revert back to American control and, while the unnamed president believes that control. What will become of the Jews need to reclaim Israel, nobody's sure what will happen next.then, nobody knows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ultimately subverted with Sitka. Rather than a permanent Jewish homeland, it's a provisional land agreement only meant to last for sixty years. With the lease at its end, the land is set to revert back to American control and, while the unnamed president believes that the Jews need to reclaim Israel, nobody's sure what will happen next.


Added DiffLines:

* ForWantofANail: The early death of Anthony Dimond, the Alaska Territory delegate to congress and the one who blocked the Slattery Report in [=OTL=], is what allowed the establishment of the Sitka refuge in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DysfunctionJunction: By the time the events of the novel, a considerable percentage of the remaining inhabitants of Sitka appear to be alcoholics or drug-addicts, religious fanatics, lunatics, messed-up loners and losers, suicidal death-seekers, the poor and desperate or some combination thereof. Possibly justified, as the novel takes place mere months before Sitka will no longer exist in it's current form and those who could probably made arrangements to be elsewhere long before it happened, which would presumably include most of the sane, well-adjusted people. And those who couldn't, even if they weren't particularly dysfunctional before, certainly have reason to be now.

to:

* DysfunctionJunction: By the time the events of the novel, a considerable percentage of the remaining inhabitants of Sitka appear to be alcoholics or drug-addicts, criminals, religious fanatics, lunatics, messed-up loners and losers, suicidal death-seekers, the poor and desperate or some combination thereof. Possibly justified, as the novel takes place mere months before Sitka will no longer exist in it's its current form and those who could probably made arrangements to be elsewhere long before it happened, which would presumably include most of the sane, well-adjusted people. And those who couldn't, even if they weren't particularly dysfunctional before, certainly have reason to be now.

Added: 262

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguouslyGay: Naomi Landsman is often described and discussed in terms that suggest she is a butch lesbian, but her sexuality is never confirmed one way or another.



* BuryYourGays: [[spoiler:Mendel Shpilman]]

to:

* BuryYourGays: BuryYourGays:
**
[[spoiler:Mendel Shpilman]]Shpilman]]
** [[AmbiguouslyGay Possibly also]] [[spoiler: Naomi Landsman.]]

Added: 117

Changed: 690

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sitka Jews are slangily referred to as "Icebergers" by American Jews, while Sitka Jews call American Jews "Mexicans" because they live South of the border (the ''Canadian'' border, that is).

to:

** Sitka Jews are slangily referred to as called "Icebergers" by American Jews, while referencing the icy climate of Alaska and the "-berg" suffix common in Ashkenazi Jewish names.
**
Sitka Jews call American Jews "Mexicans" because they live South of the border (the ''Canadian'' border, that is).



%%* LegitimateBusinessmensSocialClub

to:

%%* LegitimateBusinessmensSocialClub* LegitimateBusinessmensSocialClub: The Verbover crime syndicate is also a Jewish religious sect with its own buildings and places of worship.



* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: Unusually for an AlternateHistory story the incumbent President of the United States is not named, nor is any description given. The reader is left to make up their own mind which conservative politician or Christian fundamentalist religious figure has risen to the top in this reality, if indeed it is someone we would recognise.

to:

* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: Unusually for an AlternateHistory story story, the incumbent President of the United States is not named, nor is any description given. The reader is left to make up their own mind which conservative politician or Christian fundamentalist religious figure has risen to the top in this reality, if indeed it is someone we would recognise.



* [[RunawayBride Runaway Groom]]: [[spoiler:Mendel Shpilman.]]

to:

* [[RunawayBride Runaway Groom]]: RunawayBride: [[spoiler:Mendel Shpilman.Shpilman is a male example.]]



* YiddishAsASecondLanguage: [[InvertedTrope Inverted]] into Yiddish as a Primary Language. In a true flip of the trope, they use "American" phrases and [[ClusterFBomb curses]]. There's a handy Yiddish glossary in the novel, particularly helpful with the Sitka slang.

to:

* YiddishAsASecondLanguage: [[InvertedTrope Inverted]] into Although the characters are all supposed to be speaking Yiddish, there are a number of Yiddish and Hebrew words that are used as a Primary Language. In a true flip of slang that appear untranslated, such as "sholem" for "gun." Ironically, the trope, they text sometimes states that Sitka residents use "American" phrases and [[ClusterFBomb curses]]. There's a handy Yiddish glossary in the novel, particularly helpful with the Sitka slang.(i.e. English language) curse words.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustBeforeTheEnd: Not in the apocalyptic sense typical for the setting (being a non-lethal and highly localized variant), but in an emotional sense for (almost) every Jewish character. The upcoming Reversion means the end of the Jewish district and most (if not almost all) residents will not be able to stay in the US once the territory is under their control, but neither do they have any emigration alternatives. Thus, many Jews don't know what exactly they are supposed to do and what will happen in a few months at all, and the book portrays the resulting feeling of all-pervasive uncertainty, emotional collapse and resignation very effectively. The best example is the police force itself, which is disintegrating rapidly as the events of the novel take place, so that, for instance, a report by the forensic pathologist is left uncompleted because said pathologist leaves the District, open cases are "blackflagged", i.e. closed without resolution, by police chiefs and no one besides Landsman actually cares about solving the mystery of Shpilman's murder (not even Berko, who's in it out of loyalty to Landsman rather than an actual interest in solving the case).

to:

* JustBeforeTheEnd: Not in the apocalyptic sense typical for the setting (being a non-lethal and highly localized variant), but in an emotional sense for (almost) every Jewish character. The upcoming Reversion means the end of the Jewish district and most (if not almost all) residents will not be able to stay in the US once the territory is under their control, but neither do they have any emigration alternatives. Thus, many Jews don't know what exactly they are supposed to do and what will happen in a few months at all, and the book portrays the resulting feeling of all-pervasive uncertainty, emotional collapse and resignation very effectively. The best example is Within the police force itself, which is disintegrating rapidly as the events of the novel take place, so that, for instance, a report by the forensic pathologist is force, reports are left uncompleted because said pathologist leaves the District, open incomplete, cases are "blackflagged", i.e. closed without resolution, by police chiefs dropped, and no one besides Landsman actually cares about solving the mystery of Shpilman's murder (not even Berko, who's in it out of loyalty to Landsman rather than an actual interest in solving the case).murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WorkingWithTheEx:

to:

* WorkingWithTheEx: DaChief that Landsman reports to is his ex-wife.

Added: 541

Changed: 719

Removed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VitriolicBestBuds: Landsman and Berko Shemets share plenty of snark but are clearly each other's best friend beyond being cousins. Played with regarding Berko and Willie Dick, who are described in terms of being mortal enemies who hate each other so much that they weirdly seem closer than most ''actual'' best friends.

to:

* VitriolicBestBuds: VitriolicBestBuds:
**
Landsman and Berko Shemets share plenty of snark but are clearly each other's best friend beyond being cousins. Played with regarding Berko and Willie Dick, who are described in terms of being mortal enemies who hate each other so much that they weirdly seem closer than most ''actual'' best friends. friends.
** Seen when Willie Dick, Berko Shemets and Meyer Landsman are in the same room together. There's a lot of antagonism due to personal and historical reasons, but it's obvious their work as policemen gives them a stronger bond than anyone.



* WithFriendsLikeThese: Seen when Willie Dick, Berko Shemets and Meyer Landsman are in the same room together. There's a lot of antagonism due to personal and historical reasons, but it's obvious their work as policemen gives them a stronger bond than anyone.
%%* WorkingWithTheEx

to:

* WithFriendsLikeThese: Seen when Willie Dick, Berko Shemets and Meyer Landsman are in the same room together. There's a lot of antagonism due to personal and historical reasons, but it's obvious their work as policemen gives them a stronger bond than anyone.
%%* WorkingWithTheEx
WorkingWithTheEx:



%%* YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters

to:

%%* YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters* YouHaveGotToBeKiddingMe: Berko gives Landsman an incredulous look when he realises that his apathetic partner hasn't made even the slightest effort to line up another job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FatBastard: Rabbi Shpilman is a huge criminal in both senses of the term.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ZeppelinsFromAnotherWorld: No actual Zeppelins appear, but early in the novel Landsman finds "a windup zeppelin" amongst other junk in a basement, in keeping with the AlternateHistory setting.

to:

* ZeppelinsFromAnotherWorld: No actual Zeppelins appear, but early in the novel Landsman finds "a windup zeppelin" amongst other junk in a basement, in keeping with the AlternateHistory setting.
setting. It should be noted that such toys really did exist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one scene, Berko's son watches an unnamed Yiddish-dubbed cartoon that's clearly meant to be ''DragonTales''.

to:

** In one scene, Berko's son watches an unnamed Yiddish-dubbed cartoon that's clearly meant to be ''DragonTales''.''WesternAnimation/DragonTales''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved to YMMV subpage as it's a subjective, Just For Fun wick


* XMeetsY: Imagine ''VideoGame/TheShivah'' crossed with ''Film/{{Fargo}}''. With a hint of ''Literature/{{Fatherland}}'' dropped in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BrokenMasquerade

to:

* %%* BrokenMasquerade



* ChessMotifs

to:

* %%* ChessMotifs



* EnterStageWindow

to:

* %%* EnterStageWindow



* FilmNoir

to:

* %%* FilmNoir



* GladToBeAliveSex
* GodwinsLawOfTimeTravel: A rare [[InvertedTrope inversion]]. In this world's alternate timeline, Hitler got his ass kicked even ''harder'' that he did in our world. Among other changes, Germany was nuked in 1946 and the Holocaust killed only a third as many Jews as it did in RealLife. The book explores how these events (coupled with the collapse of Israel) complicate the lives of surviving Jews.

to:

* %%* GladToBeAliveSex
* GodwinsLawOfTimeTravel: A rare [[InvertedTrope inversion]]. In this world's alternate timeline, Hitler got his ass a ss kicked even ''harder'' that he did in our world. Among other changes, Germany was nuked in 1946 and the Holocaust killed only a third as many Jews as it did in RealLife. The book explores how these events (coupled with the collapse of Israel) complicate the lives of surviving Jews.



* LegitimateBusinessmensSocialClub

to:

* %%* LegitimateBusinessmensSocialClub



* MysteriousInformant

to:

* %%* MysteriousInformant



* TitleDrop

to:

* %%* TitleDrop



* WorkingWithTheEx

to:

* %%* WorkingWithTheEx



* YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters

to:

* %%* YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** OrsonWelles [[DifferentWorldDifferentMovies made his film]] of ''Literature/HeartOfDarkness''.

to:

** OrsonWelles Creator/OrsonWelles [[DifferentWorldDifferentMovies made his film]] of ''Literature/HeartOfDarkness''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Soviet Union appears to have collapsed at some point during the 1970s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed per TRS.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed per TRS.


* TheNapoleon: Willie Dick, the 4'7" tall Tlingit cop, [[BadassBiker rides a 2/3 scale motorcycle]] and is generally described in terms that qualify him as a {{Badass}} of tall-tale proportions. Berko even {{Lampshades}} this, calling Dick "the emperor of the French."

to:

* TheNapoleon: Willie Dick, the 4'7" tall Tlingit cop, [[BadassBiker rides a 2/3 scale motorcycle]] and is generally described in terms that qualify him as a {{Badass}} badass of tall-tale proportions. Berko even {{Lampshades}} this, calling Dick "the emperor of the French."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KilledToUpholdTheMasquerade [[spoiler: Naomi Landsman]]

to:

* KilledToUpholdTheMasquerade KilledToUpholdTheMasquerade: [[spoiler: Naomi Landsman]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Germany was nuked in 1946 and Israel was destroyed after only 6 months during the first round of the ArabIsraeliWar.

to:

** Germany was nuked in 1946 and Israel was destroyed after only 6 months during the first round of the ArabIsraeliWar.Arab-Israeli War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* DisappearedDad: Meyer Landsman's dad.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Reconstruction}}: Reconstructs traditional FilmNoir and HardboiledDetective stories by giving it a fresh setting -- an AlternateHistory version of America where a thriving Yiddish culture exists on the Alaskan frontier.

Added: 287

Changed: 1066

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AlternateHistory: The point of divergence occurred in 1940, when Alaskan Delegate Anthony Diamond died in a car crash, thus allowing the US Congress to implement the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slattery_Report Slattery Report]] which opened Alaska to Jewish immigration. 4 million of the 6 million Jews who would have been killed in the Holocaust fled to Alaska, creating a vibrant and sprawling community centered around Sitka. Also, Germany was nuked in 1946 and Israel was destroyed after only 6 months during the first round of the ArabIsraeliWar. Other minor examples include the fact that OrsonWelles [[DifferentWorldDifferentMovies made his film]] of ''Literature/HeartOfDarkness''.
** Another major difference is a lengthy war between America and Cuba during the sixties.

to:

* AlternateHistory: The point of divergence occurred in 1940, when AlternateHistory:
**
Alaskan Delegate Anthony Diamond died in a car crash, thus allowing the US Congress to implement the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slattery_Report Slattery Report]] which opened Alaska to Jewish immigration. 4 million of the 6 million Jews who would have been killed in the Holocaust fled to Alaska, creating a vibrant and sprawling community centered around Sitka. Also,
**
Germany was nuked in 1946 and Israel was destroyed after only 6 months during the first round of the ArabIsraeliWar. Other minor examples include the fact that ArabIsraeliWar.
**
OrsonWelles [[DifferentWorldDifferentMovies made his film]] of ''Literature/HeartOfDarkness''.
** Another major difference is There was a lengthy war between America and Cuba during the sixties.

Added: 588

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MinorCrimeRevealsMajorPlot: Murder is about the uppermost possible limit of a "minor" crime, but compared to [[spoiler:blowing up the al-Aqsa mosque, aka the current third-holiest site in Islam on the site of the former Jewish Temple in Jerusalem, as the first step of a plot to overthrow alternate-history Palestine]], it's not so bad after all. [[spoiler:It turns out it wasn't even the perpetrators of the plot who actually shot him, either; it was the victim (who was publicly thought to be a candidate for this generation's Messiah) trying to duck out of it via assisted suicide.]]



* TheNapoleon: Willie Dick, the 4'7" tall Tlinglit cop, [[BadassBiker rides a 2/3 scale motorcycle]] and is generally described in terms that qualify him as a {{Badass}} of tall-tale proportions. Berko even {{Lampshades}} this, calling Dick "the emperor of the French."

to:

* TheNapoleon: Willie Dick, the 4'7" tall Tlinglit Tlingit cop, [[BadassBiker rides a 2/3 scale motorcycle]] and is generally described in terms that qualify him as a {{Badass}} of tall-tale proportions. Berko even {{Lampshades}} this, calling Dick "the emperor of the French."

Added: 364

Changed: 161

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StylisticSuck: Alter Litvak's written messages are light on punctuation and feature the occasional grammatical error, because they're hastily jotted down while in conversation.

to:

* StylisticSuck: StylisticSuck:
**
Alter Litvak's written messages are light on punctuation and feature the occasional grammatical error, because they're hastily jotted down while in conversation.conversation.
** Journalist Dennis Brennan's spoken dialogue verges on overly florid PurpleProse in places, because he's an American journalist who's learned to speak Yiddish without learning to speak it very well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: Unusually for an AlternateHistory story the incumbent President of the United States is not named, nor is any description given. The reader is left to make up their own mind which conservative politician or Christian fundamentalist religious figure has risen to the top in this reality.

to:

* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: Unusually for an AlternateHistory story the incumbent President of the United States is not named, nor is any description given. The reader is left to make up their own mind which conservative politician or Christian fundamentalist religious figure has risen to the top in this reality.reality, if indeed it is someone we would recognise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ParentalAbandonment: A lot of Landsman's issues with guilt, religion, cynicism and even chess can be traced back to the suicide of his father, a chess prodigy and Holocaust survivor. Since Landsman's father took his life the day after Landsman wrote him a letter begging him not to force Landsman to play chess, a game which Landsman hated but which was one of the few ways his father tried to connect with him, Landsman blamed himself as a child with numerous psychological issues resulting. [[spoiler: Ironically, as an adult Landsman would later find that letter unopened in his father's possessions, meaning he actually had nothing to do with it.]]

to:

* ParentalAbandonment: A lot of Landsman's issues with guilt, religion, cynicism and even chess can be traced back to the suicide of his father, a chess prodigy and Holocaust survivor. Since Landsman's father took his life the day after Landsman wrote him a letter begging him not to force Landsman to play chess, a game which Landsman hated but which was one of the few ways his father tried to connect with him, Landsman blamed himself as a child with numerous psychological issues resulting. [[spoiler: Ironically, as an adult Landsman would later find that letter unopened in his father's possessions, meaning he his father never actually read it and Landsman actually had nothing to do with it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DysfunctionJunction: By the time the events of the novel, a considerable percentage of the remaining inhabitants of Sitka appear to be alcoholics or drug-addicts, religious fanatics, lunatics, messed-up loners and losers, suicidal death-seekers, the poor and desperate or some combination thereof. Possibly justified, as the novel takes place mere months before Sitka will no longer exist in it's current form and those who could made arrangements to be elsewhere long before it happened, which would presumably include most of the sane, well-adjusted people.

to:

* DysfunctionJunction: By the time the events of the novel, a considerable percentage of the remaining inhabitants of Sitka appear to be alcoholics or drug-addicts, religious fanatics, lunatics, messed-up loners and losers, suicidal death-seekers, the poor and desperate or some combination thereof. Possibly justified, as the novel takes place mere months before Sitka will no longer exist in it's current form and those who could probably made arrangements to be elsewhere long before it happened, which would presumably include most of the sane, well-adjusted people. And those who couldn't, even if they weren't particularly dysfunctional before, certainly have reason to be now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DysfunctionJunction: By the time the events of the novel, a considerable percentage of the remaining inhabitants of Sitka appear to be alcoholics or drug-addicts, religious fanatics, lunatics, messed-up loners and losers, suicidal death-seekers, the poor and desperate or some combination thereof. Possibly justified, as the novel takes place mere months before Sitka will no longer exist in it's current form and those who could made arrangements to be elsewhere long before it happened, which would presumably include most of the sane, well-adjusted people who were in touch with reality.

to:

* DysfunctionJunction: By the time the events of the novel, a considerable percentage of the remaining inhabitants of Sitka appear to be alcoholics or drug-addicts, religious fanatics, lunatics, messed-up loners and losers, suicidal death-seekers, the poor and desperate or some combination thereof. Possibly justified, as the novel takes place mere months before Sitka will no longer exist in it's current form and those who could made arrangements to be elsewhere long before it happened, which would presumably include most of the sane, well-adjusted people who were in touch with reality.people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DysfunctionJunction: By the time the events of the novel, a considerable percentage of the remaining inhabitants of Sitka appear to be alcoholics or drug-addicts, religious fanatics, lunatics, messed-up loners and losers, suicidal death-seekers, the poor and desperate or some combination thereof. Possibly justified, as the novel takes place mere months before Sitka will no longer exist in it's current form and those who could made arrangements to be elsewhere long before it happened, which would presumably include most of the sane, well-adjusted people who were in touch with reality.


Added DiffLines:

* ParentalAbandonment: A lot of Landsman's issues with guilt, religion, cynicism and even chess can be traced back to the suicide of his father, a chess prodigy and Holocaust survivor. Since Landsman's father took his life the day after Landsman wrote him a letter begging him not to force Landsman to play chess, a game which Landsman hated but which was one of the few ways his father tried to connect with him, Landsman blamed himself as a child with numerous psychological issues resulting. [[spoiler: Ironically, as an adult Landsman would later find that letter unopened in his father's possessions, meaning he actually had nothing to do with it.]]

Added: 410

Changed: 79

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoodleIncident: A lot of the details of the AlternateHistory the novel is set in are alluded to, but not actually described.

to:

* NoodleIncident: A lot of the details of the AlternateHistory the novel is set in are alluded to, but not actually described. Some of the little tidbits that can be pieced together from hints that appear:
** The Soviet Union collapsed after a successful Nazi invasion, leading (eventually) to a Third Russian Republic.
** A major war was fought between the United States and Cuba, and appears to have been this world's equivalent to UsefulNotes/TheVietnamWar.
** Creator/MarilynMonroe married President Kennedy (presumably [[UsefulNotes/JohnFKennedy John]], although it's never actually stated) and became First Lady.

Top