Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheVoyageOfMaelDuin

Go To

OR

Added: 548

Changed: 341

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WalkOnWater: The hermit from Tory relates that he took up his life of penitence because one day, on a pleasure cruise in his boat, he was blown into the open sea and encountered the spirit of a saintly monk "sitting upon the wave". The monk chastised him for his sins and enjoined him to spend the rest of his life as a hermit on a small rock in the sea.

to:

* WalkOnWater: WalkOnWater:
** Exploring island no. 5, the voyagers see hints that the island is a meeting place of giants, and leave in fright. Looking back, they see a crowd of demonic giants "rushing along the sea to the island".
**
The hermit from Tory relates that he took up his life of penitence because one day, on a pleasure cruise in his boat, he was blown into the open sea and encountered the spirit of a saintly monk "sitting upon the wave". The monk chastised him for his sins and enjoined him to spend the rest of his life as a hermit on a small rock in the sea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The P. W. Joyce translation describes the voyagers being feasted by the island queen and her daughters before going "to sleep on soft couches till the morning". The original text makes clear that Máel Dúin and his companions sleep with the queen and her daughters respectively, and continue to do so during their entire stay on the island. The same detail is omitted in Jacobs' child-friendly version. Both Joyce and Jacobs also omit that right upon their arrival on the island, the daughters of the queen prepare a bath for the voyagers.

to:

** The P. W. Joyce translation describes the voyagers being feasted by the island queen and her daughters before going "to sleep on soft couches till the morning". The original text makes clear that Máel Dúin and his companions sleep with the queen and her daughters respectively, and continue to do so during their entire stay on the island. The same detail is omitted in Jacobs' child-friendly version. Both Joyce and Jacobs also omit that right upon their arrival on the island, the daughters of the queen prepare a bath for the voyagers.voyagers, presumably because it is slightly too sexual.

Added: 898

Changed: 354

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Bowdlerize}}: The translation by P. W. Joyce and the retelling by Creator/JosephJacobs omit that Máel Dúin is the product of a rape. This loses the finer points of the original, namely, that Ailill was no better than the pirates that killed him, and that Máel Dúin's perceived duty to avenge his father to restore the family honor is rather questionable to begin with.

to:

* {{Bowdlerize}}: {{Bowdlerize}}:
**
The translation by P. W. Joyce and the retelling by Creator/JosephJacobs omit that Máel Dúin is the product of a rape. This loses the finer points of the original, namely, that Ailill was no better than the pirates that killed him, and that Máel Dúin's perceived duty to avenge his father to restore the family honor is rather questionable to begin with.with.
** The P. W. Joyce translation describes the voyagers being feasted by the island queen and her daughters before going "to sleep on soft couches till the morning". The original text makes clear that Máel Dúin and his companions sleep with the queen and her daughters respectively, and continue to do so during their entire stay on the island. The same detail is omitted in Jacobs' child-friendly version. Both Joyce and Jacobs also omit that right upon their arrival on the island, the daughters of the queen prepare a bath for the voyagers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheresNoPlaceLikeHome: The voyagers discover an island ruled by a queen who invites them into her palace and straightaway takes Máel Dúin as her lover and sets up his seventeen companions with her own seventeen daughters. She also reveals that on her island there is no old age, and that they will live an eternal life of pleasure in her palace as long as they stay on the island. After spending three months on the queen's island, Máel Dúin's companions want to return to Ireland. At first Máel Dúin objects on the grounds that their life in Ireland could not possibly be better than their life here; only when his companions announce that they will leave with or without him, Máel Dúin chooses to go with them, rather than to part with them and stay on the island alone.

to:

* TheresNoPlaceLikeHome: The voyagers discover an island ruled by a queen who invites them into her palace and straightaway takes Máel Dúin as her lover and sets up his seventeen companions with her own seventeen daughters. She also reveals that on her island there is no old age, and that they will live an eternal life of pleasure in her palace as long as they stay on the island. After spending three months on the queen's island, Máel Dúin's companions want to return to Ireland. At first Máel Dúin objects on the grounds that their life in Ireland could not possibly be better than their life here; only when his companions announce that they will leave with or without him, Máel Dúin chooses to go with them, rather than to part with them. The queen does not want them to leave and stay on prevents their departure with magic, until after nine months they outwit the island alone.queen and succeed in leaving the island.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheresNoPlaceLikeHome: The voyagers discover an island ruled by a queen who invites them into her palace and straightaway takes Máel Dúin as her lover and sets up his seventeen companions with her own seventeen daughters. She also reveals that on her island there is no old age, and that they will live an eternal life of pleasure in her palace as long as they stay on the island. After spending three months on the queen's island, Máel Dúin's companions want to return to Ireland. At first Máel Dúin objects on the grounds that their life in Ireland could not possibly be better than their life here; only when his companions announce that they will leave with or without him, Máel Dúin chooses to go with them, rather than to part with them and stay on the island alone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TalkingAnimal: Island no. 18 is discovered by the voyagers when they hear voices and the chanting of psalms, and follow the sound until they see a rock-like island full of talking birds. A little later they land on another small island where an immortal hermit lives with a swarm of birds which, he explains, are the souls of his relatives and descendants who have died back in Ireland. This suggests that all the talking birds are actually human souls awaiting the Last Judgement.

Top