Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheLadyOrTheTiger

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MiscarriageOfJustice: The king's trial system does not even pretend to protect the innocent and condemn the guilty. In this particular defendant's case, everyone knows he did what he was accused of, but the king doesn't mind because either outcome will work for him.

Added: 438

Changed: 518

Removed: 62

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeldGaze: When the lover enters the arena, he and princess lock eyes. Such is their bond that he knows immediately that she can save him, and she knows he's asking which door to open. She even knew ahead of time that he would ask, which makes the decision to send him to the tiger -- if that is her decision -- particularly cruel.

to:

* HaveAGayOldTime: As a product of the 1880s, this story uses 'gay' to mean "happy" as well as 'hilarious' with its older meaning of "boisterously merry."
* HeldGaze: When the lover enters the arena, he and princess lock eyes. Such is their bond that he knows sees immediately that she can could save him, and she knows he's sees him asking her which door to open. She even knew ahead of time that he would ask, which makes the decision to send him to the tiger -- if that is her decision -- particularly cruel.



* TitleDrop: The last line of the story.
-->Which came out of the opened door - the lady, or the tiger?



* TitleDrop: The last line of the story.
-->Which came out of the opened door - the lady, or the tiger?

to:

* TitleDrop: The last line of TrialByOrdeal: A terrible and simple one -- if the story.
-->Which came out of the opened
door - the lady, or the tiger?you open has a tiger behind it, you're guilty (and dead).

Added: 239

Changed: 241

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UndesirablePrize: In cases where the man on trial is already married or betrothed, being found innocent isn't necessarily a good thing. After all, he will then be married on the spot, and neither he nor the lady can refuse. In the case of the central 'defendant' of this story, we don't know whether he had any interest in the woman in question, though there's enough evidence to make the princess suspicious... [[GreenEyedMonster and jealous]].

to:

* UndesirablePrize: In cases where Opening the man on trial is already married or betrothed, being found innocent isn't necessarily a good thing. After all, he will then be married on the spot, and neither he nor door to the lady can refuse. means getting married to her... whether you like it or not. In the case of the central 'defendant' of this story, we don't know whether he had any interest in the woman in question, though but there's enough evidence to make the princess suspicious... [[GreenEyedMonster and jealous]].


Added DiffLines:

* UnwantedSpouse: The potential result of an 'acquittal' -- the King doesn't care whether the defendant loves someone else or already has a wife. If you don't get eaten by the tiger, you get married to the lady, and that's just how it is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheUnreveal: The story doesn't tell us just what the princess has sent her lover to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllCrimesAreEqual: Zigzagged. The story is clear that only a crime which is significant enough to interest the king gets tried in the arena, so lesser matters presumably get settled elsewhere. However, anyone who ''does'' wind up in the arena has a 50% chance of meeting a horrible death, no matter what he allegedly did.

Added: 214

Changed: 106

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MortonsFork: No matter what the princess chooses, she'll lose her man. The only question is whether she'd rather lose him to the teeth of a tiger or the arms of another woman.

to:

* MortonsFork: No matter what the princess chooses, she'll lose her man. The only question is whether she'd rather lose him to the teeth claws of a tiger or the arms of another woman.



* PantheraAwesome: Not that it's particularly awesome for the poor schmuck who opens the wrong door, but the story plays up the strength and savagery of the tiger and makes sure that we know that the lover has no chance of escape if the princess points him to the fatal door.

to:

* PantheraAwesome: Not that it's particularly awesome for the any poor schmuck who opens meets the wrong door, tiger, but the story plays up the strength and savagery of the tiger beast and makes sure that we know it clear that the lover has no chance of escape is ''doomed'' if the princess points sends him to the fatal wrong door.



* ShowDontTell: The story relies very heavily on telling, since it's entirely told by the third person narrator, and adds to the ambiguity regarding certain characters' actions and motives, while ultimately letting readers come to their own conclusions as to what the princess decided.

to:

* ShowDontTell: The story relies very heavily on telling, since it's entirely told by the third person narrator, and adds to the ambiguity regarding certain characters' actions and motives, while ultimately letting readers come to their own conclusions conclusion as to what the princess decided.decided.
* TakeAThirdOption: Defied -- the princess's only choices are to watch her lover die or watch him marry someone else. Given that Stockton's point was to make the ''reader'' confront the choice, this is deliberate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeldGaze: When the lover enters the arena, he and princess lock eyes. Such is their bond that he knows she can save him, and she knows he's asking which door to open. She even knows ahead of time that he will ask, which makes the decision to send him to the tiger -- if that is her decision -- particularly cruel.

to:

* HeldGaze: When the lover enters the arena, he and princess lock eyes. Such is their bond that he knows immediately that she can save him, and she knows he's asking which door to open. She even knows knew ahead of time that he will would ask, which makes the decision to send him to the tiger -- if that is her decision -- particularly cruel.



* LamarckWasRight: The king is "semi-barbarian" by exposure to AncientGrome, and his daughter consequently has a mix of 'civilized' and 'barbaric' in her nature.

to:

* LamarckWasRight: The king is "semi-barbarian" by exposure to AncientGrome, and his daughter consequently has a mix an unstable blend of 'civilized' and 'barbaric' in her nature.



* PantheraAwesome: Not that it's particularly awesome for the poor schmuck who gets torn to pieces by the tiger, but the story plays up the strength and savagery of the tiger and makes sure that we know that opening the wrong door means certain death.

to:

* PantheraAwesome: Not that it's particularly awesome for the poor schmuck who gets torn to pieces by opens the tiger, wrong door, but the story plays up the strength and savagery of the tiger and makes sure that we know that opening the wrong door means certain death.lover has no chance of escape if the princess points him to the fatal door.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AwesomeButImpractical: Pretty much everything the king does, but particularly his trial system, which requires finding a suitable woman for every defendant, having an entire wedding procession on standby for a Not Guilty verdict, plus having a team to wrangle a fierce and hungry tiger in the event of a Guilty verdict.


Added DiffLines:

* HeldGaze: When the lover enters the arena, he and princess lock eyes. Such is their bond that he knows she can save him, and she knows he's asking which door to open. She even knows ahead of time that he will ask, which makes the decision to send him to the tiger -- if that is her decision -- particularly cruel.


Added DiffLines:

* LamarckWasRight: The king is "semi-barbarian" by exposure to AncientGrome, and his daughter consequently has a mix of 'civilized' and 'barbaric' in her nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheDeterminator: We're not told the specifics of how the princess learned the secret of the doors, but we do know no one else had ever managed it before.

Added: 205

Changed: 83

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In an ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to try particularly significant criminals. The accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence. No one watching knows which door leads to which, so the defendant's fate is entirely up to chance, and the trials make for thrilling public entertainment as well.

During one such trial, the defendant is a commoner who had the audacity to love the king's only daughter. She has bribed the guards and learned which door leads to the lady and which to the tiger. As the man enters the arena, the princess has an opportunity to guide him to life or death, but which does she choose? The story leaves the answer up to the reader.

to:

In an ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to try particularly significant criminals. The accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a hungry tiger which promptly kills will kill him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who will immediately becomes become his wife as a reward for his innocence. No one watching knows which door leads to which, so the defendant's fate is entirely up to chance, and the trials make for thrilling public entertainment as well.

During one such trial, the defendant is a commoner man who had the audacity to love court the king's only favorite daughter. She has bribed the guards and learned which door leads to the lady and which to the tiger. As the man enters the arena, the princess has an opportunity to guide him to life or death, but which does she choose? The story leaves the answer up to the reader.



* DaddysGirl: The king loves his daughter more than anything else, at least in part because she's most like him in temperament. (Not enough to stop him from throwing her boyfriend to a tiger, mind you...)



* IfICantHaveYou: If the princess guides the man to the tiger, she sends him to a horrible death rather than see him marry another.

to:

* IfICantHaveYou: If the princess guides the man to the tiger, she sends him to a horrible death rather than see him marry with another.



* AbsurdlySharpBlade: The Discourager of Hesitancy's scimitar can split a hair, as he helpfully demonstrates when the prince seems to be getting cold feet at his wedding.
* AffablyEvil: The Discourager -- the servant whose job is to "ensure" prompt compliance with the king's orders -- is soft-spoken, gracious, and polite at all times.

to:

* AbsurdlySharpBlade: The Discourager of Hesitancy's Discourager's scimitar can split a hair, as he helpfully demonstrates when the prince seems to be getting cold feet at his wedding.
* AffablyEvil: The Discourager of Hesitancy -- the servant whose job is to "ensure" prompt compliance with the king's orders -- is soft-spoken, gracious, and polite at all times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoEnding: The story ends just as the man opens the door. The readers are left to decide for themselves what was behind it.

to:

* NoEnding: The story ends just as the man opens the door. [[AmbiguousEnding The readers are left to decide for themselves what was behind it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* SinisterScimitar: The Discourager's WeaponOfChoice.

to:

* SinisterScimitar: The Discourager's WeaponOfChoice.weapon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UptownGirl: The man has dared to love far above his station. The rather LemonyNarrator tells us that this sort of cross-status relationship is common now, but at the time it was basically the UrExample and no one quite knew what to make of it.

Added: 285

Changed: 26

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbsurdlySharpBlade: The Discourager's scimitar can split a hair, as he helpfully demonstrates when the prince seems to be getting cold feet at his wedding.
* AffablyEvil: The Discourager of Hesitancy -- the servant whose job is to "ensure" prompt compliance with the king's orders -- is soft-spoken, gracious, and polite at all times.

to:

* AbsurdlySharpBlade: The Discourager's Discourager of Hesitancy's scimitar can split a hair, as he helpfully demonstrates when the prince seems to be getting cold feet at his wedding.
* AffablyEvil: The Discourager of Hesitancy -- the servant whose job is to "ensure" prompt compliance with the king's orders -- is soft-spoken, gracious, and polite at all times.


Added DiffLines:

* ArousedByTheirVoice: The prince doesn't hesitate to say his vows to his unseen bride after feeling the softness of her hand and hearing the sweetness of her voice.


Added DiffLines:

* OffWithHisHead: The threat the Discourager poses to those who seem reluctant to do whatever the King tells them to do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AffablyEvil: The king is described as "bland and genial" when things are going smoothly, and "whenever there was a little hitch, and some of his orbs got out of their orbits, he was blander and more genial still, for nothing pleased him so much as to make the crooked straight and crush down uneven places."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LuckBasedMission: The trials. They're fair and impartial in the sense that the outcome isn't predetermined and everyone has a 50% chance at acquittal, but they're utterly ''unfair'' in terms of punishing wrongdoing or rewarding virtue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheBadGuyWins: As the story points out from very early on, the cruel and selfish king gets his way no matter what happens: either he gets to see the guy whose only crime was dating his daughter without his permission torn apart, or married off to someone else, and thus no longer something he has to care about.

Added: 407

Changed: 230

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EverythingButTheGirl: If the lover opens the correct door, he will be acquitted, freed, and married off in great joy to a woman just as lovely as the princess (and one that he might already take an interest in) but he won't get the princess. The twist is that this can only happen if the princess decides to let it happen -- and she could send him to his death instead and spare herself that humiliation.



* ParentalMarriageVeto: Not that it's ever claimed the princess planned to marry her lover, but her father's reaction when he discovers their relationship is... unsubtle.

to:

* ParentalMarriageVeto: Not that it's ever claimed Whether or not the princess planned to lover thought he could actually marry the princess, her lover, but her father's reaction when father promptly ensures that he discovers their relationship is... unsubtle.never will, either because he's been married off to someone else or because he's been eaten by a tiger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ParentalMarriageVeto: Not that it's ever claimed the princess planned to marry her lover, but her father's reaction when he discovers their relationship is... unsubtle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbsurdlySharpBlade: The Discourager's scimitar can split a hair, as he helpfully demonstrates when the prince seems to be getting cold feet at his wedding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n->''Think of it, fair reader, not as if the decision of the question depended upon yourself, but upon that hot-blooded, semi-barbaric princess, her soul at a white heat beneath the combined fires of despair and jealousy. She had lost him, but who should have him?''

Added: 414

Changed: 345

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In an ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to try particularly significant criminals. The accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence. Not even the king knows in advance which door leads to which, so this method is considered fair and impartial.

to:

In an ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to try particularly significant criminals. The accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence. Not even the king No one watching knows in advance which door leads to which, so this method the defendant's fate is considered fair entirely up to chance, and impartial.
the trials make for thrilling public entertainment as well.



* AncientGrome: Subverted. The central kingdom and the Roman Empire are contemporaries, and the king has raised himself to ''semi-''barbarian by adopting some Roman customs, but he's twisted them to fit his own fancy.

to:

* AncientGrome: Subverted. The central kingdom and the Roman Empire are contemporaries, and the king has raised himself to ''semi-''barbarian by adopting some Roman customs, ideas, but he's twisted them to fit his own fancy.



* LoveTriangle: The chosen lady for this trial also has her eye on the defendant -- and the princess ''thinks'' he might return her interest. As much as she wants to save her lover from the tiger, sending him to the lady would be just as painful.

to:

* LoveTriangle: The chosen lady for this trial also has her eye on the defendant -- and or at least, [[ImaginaryLoveTriangle the princess ''thinks'' he thinks she does]] -- and she also thinks her lover might return her interest. As much as she wants to save her lover him from the tiger, sending him to the lady would be just as painful.



* PantheraAwesome: Not that it's particularly awesome for the poor schmuck who gets torn to pieces by the tiger, but the story still plays on the strength and majesty of the tiger when it's used to kill criminals.

to:

* PantheraAwesome: Not that it's particularly awesome for the poor schmuck who gets torn to pieces by the tiger, but the story still plays on up the strength and majesty savagery of the tiger when it's used and makes sure that we know that opening the wrong door means certain death.
* ThePowerOfHate: The princess ''hates'' the lady who will get her lover if he opens her door. She despises the woman so deeply and intensely that it might give her the strength
to kill criminals. send him to the other door.
* ThePowerOfLove: The princess genuinely loves the man. She can't bear to send him to the tiger. But that same strength of love makes her equally unable to bear the idea of seeing him marry someone else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


During one such trial, the defendant is a man who had the audacity to love the king's only daughter. She has bribed the guards and learned which door leads to the lady and which to the tiger. As the man enters the arena, the princess has an opportunity to guide him to life or death, but which does she choose? The story leaves the answer up to the reader.

to:

During one such trial, the defendant is a man commoner who had the audacity to love the king's only daughter. She has bribed the guards and learned which door leads to the lady and which to the tiger. As the man enters the arena, the princess has an opportunity to guide him to life or death, but which does she choose? The story leaves the answer up to the reader.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In an ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to try particularly significant criminals. The accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence. No one knows in advance which door leads to which, so this method is considered fair and impartial, and the trials always draw a large crowd.

to:

In an ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to try particularly significant criminals. The accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence. No one Not even the king knows in advance which door leads to which, so this method is considered fair and impartial, and the trials always draw a large crowd.
impartial.

Added: 214

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

----


Added DiffLines:

* PantheraAwesome: Not that it's particularly awesome for the poor schmuck who gets torn to pieces by the tiger, but the story still plays on the strength and majesty of the tiger when it's used to kill criminals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In an ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to judge particularly significant crimes. The accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a fierce tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence.

to:

In an ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to judge try particularly significant crimes.criminals. The accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a fierce tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence.
innocence. No one knows in advance which door leads to which, so this method is considered fair and impartial, and the trials always draw a large crowd.



* ForcedToWatch: Subverted. The princess is not under any external pressure to attend the trial: the narrative even tells us that a less-barbarian woman wouldn't even be there. However, if she wants to control the outcome, she has no choice but to attend -- and that will mean witnessing the agonizing result of her decision.

to:

* ForcedToWatch: Subverted. The princess is not under any external pressure to attend the trial: the narrative even tells us that a less-barbarian woman wouldn't even be have been there. However, if she wants to control the outcome, she has no choice but to attend -- and that will mean witnessing the agonizing result of her decision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForcedToWatch: Subverted. The princess is not under any external pressure to attend: the narrative even tells us that a less-barbarian woman wouldn't even be there. However, if she wants to control the outcome, she has no choice but to attend -- and seeing her lover go to the lady ''or'' the tiger will be agonizing for her.

to:

* ForcedToWatch: Subverted. The princess is not under any external pressure to attend: attend the trial: the narrative even tells us that a less-barbarian woman wouldn't even be there. there. However, if she wants to control the outcome, she has no choice but to attend -- and seeing her lover go to the lady ''or'' the tiger that will be mean witnessing the agonizing for her.result of her decision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForcedToWatch: Subverted. The princess is not under any external pressure to attend: the narrative even tells us that a less-barbarian woman wouldn't even be there. However, if she wants to control the outcome, she has no choice but to attend -- and seeing her lover go to the lady ''or'' the tiger will be agonizing for her.


Added DiffLines:

* PublicExecution: The outcome of the trial, if the accused is found 'guilty'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In an ancient and semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to judge and sentence particularly significant criminals. The defendant is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own fate by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a fierce tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence.

During one such trial, the defendant is a man who had the audacity to love the king's only daughter. She has bribed the guards and learned which door leads to the lady and which to the tiger. As the man enters the arena, the princess has an opportunity to guide him to life or death, but which does she pick? The story leaves the answer up to the reader.

to:

In an ancient and ancient, semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to judge and sentence particularly significant criminals. crimes. The defendant accused is brought into the king's arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose his own fate verdict by opening one of them: behind one door lurks a fierce tiger which promptly kills him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other is a desirable woman who immediately becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence.

During one such trial, the defendant is a man who had the audacity to love the king's only daughter. She has bribed the guards and learned which door leads to the lady and which to the tiger. As the man enters the arena, the princess has an opportunity to guide him to life or death, but which does she pick? choose? The story leaves the answer up to the reader.



* MortonsFork: No matter what the princess chooses, she'll lose the man. The only question is whether she'd rather lose him to the teeth of a tiger or the arms of another woman.

to:

* MortonsFork: No matter what the princess chooses, she'll lose the her man. The only question is whether she'd rather lose him to the teeth of a tiger or the arms of another woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In an ancient and semi-barbaric kingdom, particularly significant trials take place according to a system the king devised on his own whim. The defendant is taken to the king's arena and made to face two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose a door and open it: one of them contains a fierce tiger which immediately kills the prisoner as punishment for his guilt, but the other conceals a desirable woman whom the prisoner immediately marries as a reward for his innocence.

to:

In an ancient and semi-barbaric kingdom, the king has established a unique method to judge and sentence particularly significant trials take place according to a system the king devised on his own whim. criminals. The defendant is taken to brought into the king's arena and made to face arena, facing two identical, soundproofed doors. He then must choose a door and open it: his own fate by opening one of them contains them: behind one door lurks a fierce tiger which immediately promptly kills the prisoner him as punishment for his guilt, but behind the other conceals is a desirable woman whom the prisoner who immediately marries becomes his wife as a reward for his innocence.



* LoveTriangle: The chosen lady for this trial also has her eyes on the defendant -- and the princess ''thinks'' he might return her interest. As much as she wants to save her lover from the tiger, sending him to the lady would be just as painful.

to:

* LoveTriangle: The chosen lady for this trial also has her eyes eye on the defendant -- and the princess ''thinks'' he might return her interest. As much as she wants to save her lover from the tiger, sending him to the lady would be just as painful.



* TitleDrop: The last line of the door references the question.

to:

* TitleDrop: The last line of the door references the question.story.



* XanatosGambit: The king knows that the young man is guilty of loving his daughter, as does everyone else, but either outcome of the trial will work in his favor. If the man picks the tiger, he'll be killed, but if he picks the lady, he'll be married on the spot. Either way, he'll no longer be able to pursue the princess.

to:

* XanatosGambit: The king knows that the young man is guilty of loving his daughter, as does everyone else, but either outcome of the trial will work in his favor. If the man picks the tiger, he'll be killed, but if he picks the lady, he'll be married on the spot.married. Either way, he'll no longer be able to pursue the princess.

Top