Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / MemorySorrowAndThorn

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


** some other as well: Josua's "Naidel", Ishgrimnur's "Kvalnir" and Jikiri's "Indreju".

to:

** some other as well: Josua's "Naidel", Ishgrimnur's Isgrimnur's "Kvalnir" and Jikiri's "Indreju".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


* IWillFightNoMoreForever: In the {{Interquel}} ''The Heart of What Was Lost'', Isgrimnur is secretly relieved when the Norns collapse the entrance to Nakkiga, as it means the bloodshed can finally be over. Given a CallBack in the sequel series, when a Sitha recalls Isgrimnur to demostrate that mortals are more than bloodthirsty savages.

to:

* IWillFightNoMoreForever: In the {{Interquel}} ''The Heart of What Was Lost'', Isgrimnur is secretly relieved when the Norns collapse the entrance to Nakkiga, as it means the bloodshed can finally be over. Given a CallBack in the sequel series, when a Sitha recalls Isgrimnur to demostrate demonstrate that mortals are more than bloodthirsty savages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Grammar


** For the Metessans. [[spoiler:Brindalles is killed by the Norns, Seriddan succumbs to his wounds, both their wifes soon die and the only offspring Pasevalles is left a poor orphan after another Baron claims the lands of Metessa as his own - all set-up for Pasevalles becoming TheChessmaster in the Sequel series.]]

to:

** For the Metessans. [[spoiler:Brindalles is killed by the Norns, Seriddan succumbs to his wounds, both their wifes wives soon die and the only offspring Pasevalles is left a poor orphan after another Baron claims the lands of Metessa as his own - all set-up for Pasevalles becoming TheChessmaster in the Sequel series.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


* FantasyCounterpartCulture: Human and non-human lands are clear representatives of various cultures across history, but not necessarilly European.

to:

* FantasyCounterpartCulture: Human and non-human lands are clear representatives of various cultures across history, but not necessarilly necessarily European.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


* FakeUltimateHero: [[spoiler: King John Presbyter. He went into the Hayholt to kill the dragon that was inside, but when he arrived he found that it had already been killed by the previous king, Ealstahn Fiskerne, with the sword Minneyar; Ealstahn had died from his wounds. John takes Minneyar and hacks off one of the dragon's claws, and drags it out of the Hayholt to make it seem as if he had killed it.]]

to:

* FakeUltimateHero: [[spoiler: King John Presbyter. He went into the Hayholt to kill the dragon that was inside, but when he arrived he found that it had already been killed by the previous king, Ealstahn Ealhstan Fiskerne, with the sword Minneyar; Ealstahn Ealhstan had died from his wounds. John takes Minneyar and hacks off one of the dragon's claws, and drags it out of the Hayholt to make it seem as if he had killed it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
now definition-only


* TheWikiRule: A wiki exists https://memorysorrowthorn.fandom.com/wiki/Memory_Sorrow_and_Thorn_Wiki
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheWikiRule: A wiki exists https://memorysorrowthorn.fandom.com/wiki/Memory_Sorrow_and_Thorn_Wiki

Added: 1814

Changed: 303

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheHeavy: Pryrates is the least powerful and personally dangerous of the three main villains (himself, Utuk'ku, and the Storm King), but he gets easily the most face time and has the most personally enmity with the protagonists. He's also the most purely malevolent of the three.

to:

* TheHeavy: While Ineluki, the Storm King, and Utuk'ku, the Queen of the Norns, are the story's main villains, their powers are limited, forcing them to rely on their mortal followers to do most of their dirty work.
** King Elias' collusion with Pryrates and his subsequent [[DealWithTheDevil pact with the Storm King]] precipitate most of the major events that occur in the story. What's more, his gross mismanagement of the kingship effectively ruins the realm that he’s supposed to be governing, allowing various corrupt nobles and monsters to run rampant with impunity. Elias is also responsible for sending out the various armies that hound the heroes during their travels. This essentially makes Ellias the most immediate threat despite his status as an UnwittingPawn, so much so that many characters who're ignorant of the greater machinations at play actually think that ''he'' is the BigBad.
**
Pryrates is responsible for corrupting Elias and continues to serve as the least powerful EvilChancellor well after Elias' descent into madness, routinely encouraging his king's worst habits while also going behind his back, [[spoiler: plotting to turn Elias into a vessel for the Storm King’s spirit.]] Pryrates’ association with the Storm King and personally the powers that it grants him makes him the most dangerous of the three main villains (himself, Utuk'ku, and the Storm King), but human antagonists in terms of raw power. Because of this, he gets easily the most face time and has the most personally leads the charge against the heroes during some of the story’s darkest moments. Naturally, all of this earns Pryrates the [[ItsPersonalWithTheDragon personal enmity with of the protagonists. protagonists]]. He's also the most purely malevolent of the three. villains.
** For the first two books, the heroes are pursued by Ingen Jegger, Utuk’ku’s loyal huntsman. Jegger is a fearsome warrior who leads a pack of bloodhounds and a band of Black Rimmersmen, all of whom are fanatically devoted to the Norns of Stormpike. [[spoiler: Jegger’s final role in the story is to lead the invasion of the Sithi’s home, where he personally kills Amerasu before he himself is killed by Simon.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse


* NotGoodWithPeople: Several characters have issues with awkwardness.
** Just look at Simon our SociallyAwkwardHero.
** There's a lot of ThatCameOutWrong and ChirpingCrickets between Simon and Miriamele, and between Eolair and Maegwin respectively.
** Aditu’s NoSenseOfPersonalSpace and FeeFiFauxPas - which she couldn't care less about - at least are due to her being no mortal.
** Josua maneuvers perfectly within the boundaries of court protocol and along studied guidelines of manner and courtesy but easily loses his bearings on a private level - especially with his girlfriend. Many people think him strange if not half-mad.
** Strangyeard - despite all his wits - is a timid mouse. Tiamak is not much better.
** Geloë doesn't count, because she gives zero fucks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreepyCrows: Especially when they work as spies for the undead revenge-seeking Storm King.


Added DiffLines:

* EnchantedForest: Part of Aldheorte forest is protected by Sithi magic.

Added: 124

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArthurianLegend: Eahlstan Fiskerne, ancestor of [[spoiler: Simon]], is based on the famous FisherKing.

to:

* ArthurianLegend: {{Myth/ArthurianLegend}}: Eahlstan Fiskerne, ancestor of [[spoiler: Simon]], is based on the famous FisherKing.


Added DiffLines:

* DubNameChange: In the german translation of the novels - for whatever reason - Vorzheva’s name has been changed to "Vara".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ealsthan is no ancester of Prester John and his family. He was from Erkynland. Prester John was from Warinsten. No relationship is mentioned.


* ArthurianLegend: Eahlstan Fiskerne, ancestor of Prester John, Elias, Josua, [[spoiler:and Simon]], is based on the famous FisherKing.

to:

* ArthurianLegend: Eahlstan Fiskerne, ancestor of Prester John, Elias, Josua, [[spoiler:and [[spoiler: Simon]], is based on the famous FisherKing.

Added: 1213

Changed: 298

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArthurianLegend: Eahlstan Fiskerne, ancestor of Prester John, Elias, Josua, [[spoiler:and Simon]], is based on the famous FisherKing.



** Plus their grandson Morgan in ''The Last King of Osten Ard''.



** In the SequelSeries, [[spoiler:Simon]] is well-loved by his people, partly thanks to Josua's mentorship.



** For the Metessans. [[spoiler: Brindalles is killed by the Norns, Seriddan succumbs to his wounds, both their wifes soon die and the only offspring Pasevalles is left a poor orphan after another Baron claims the lands of Metessa as his own - all set-up for Pasevalles becoming TheChessmaster in the Sequel series.]]
** The whole sequel series of "The Last King of Osten Ard" in many ways.

to:

** For the Metessans. [[spoiler: Brindalles [[spoiler:Brindalles is killed by the Norns, Seriddan succumbs to his wounds, both their wifes soon die and the only offspring Pasevalles is left a poor orphan after another Baron claims the lands of Metessa as his own - all set-up for Pasevalles becoming TheChessmaster in the Sequel series.]]
** The whole sequel series of "The Last King of Osten Ard" in many ways. This derives more from the realism of the setting than anything else -- Osten Ard is too fleshed-out to allow for permanent happy endings, and [[spoiler:Simon and Miri ruling peacefully for decades]] was perhaps the best we could have hoped for.



* IWillFightNoMoreForever: In the {{Interquel}} ''The Heart of What Was Lost'', Isgrimnur is secretly relieved when the Norns collapse the entrance to Nakkiga, as it means the bloodshed can finally be over. Given a CallBack in the sequel series, when a Sitha recalls Isgrimnur to demostrate that mortals are more than bloodthirsty savages.



* KilledOffScreen: Happens to several characters like [[spoiler: Deornoth, Gwythinn, Isorn, Brindalles …]]

to:

* KilledOffScreen: Happens to several characters like including [[spoiler: Deornoth, Gwythinn, Isorn, Brindalles …]]and Brindalles.]]



** In the SequelSeries, the titular Witchwood Crown, and the Armor of Ruyan Ve.



* MagicalNativeAmerican: Binabik, sort of. More like a Magical Inuit, but the basic idea of the trope still applies. Tiamak is a variation in that what makes him distinctive is that he's gained a "modern" education but is still presumed to be a savage because of his race.

to:

* MagicalNativeAmerican: Binabik, sort of. More like a Magical Inuit, but the basic idea of the trope still applies. Tiamak is a variation in that what makes him distinctive is that he's gained a "modern" education but is still presumed to be a savage because of his race.


Added DiffLines:

* NoHistoricalFiguresWereHarmed: Josua may be an {{Expy}} of the Anglo-Saxon king Alfred the Great. Both are younger siblings who reluctantly took the throne, and spent large parts of their early reigns hounded out of their own capitals by sudden, treacherous invasions. Williams even gives Josua the famous (apocryphal) story of Alfred being so worried about the state of his kingdom that he lets some cakes burn in the oven, and is chastised by a peasant woman who doesn't recognize him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Character Alignment and its related tropes are Flame Bait, and are not allowed to be linked anywhere except on work pages as examples where they are cannonical


** Members are [[ReasonableAuthorityFigure Reasonable Authority Figures]] that should abide to the LawfulGood - if they don't, you'll easily have someone like Pryrates on your hands.

to:

** Members are [[ReasonableAuthorityFigure Reasonable Authority Figures]] that should abide to the LawfulGood - do good- if they don't, you'll easily have someone like Pryrates on your hands.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


## ''The Navigator's Children'', which has been [[https://www.tadwilliams.com/2021/11/book-news-forthcoming/ split into two volumes]] like the final installment of the first trilogy: ''Into the Narrowdark'' (slated to release July 2022) and ''The Navigator's Children'' (release date still TBA)

to:

## ''The Navigator's Children'', which has been [[https://www.tadwilliams.com/2021/11/book-news-forthcoming/ split into two volumes]] like the final installment of the first trilogy: ''Into the Narrowdark'' (slated to release (released July 2022) and ''The Navigator's Children'' (release date still TBA)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CombatByChampion: Prester John vs. Sir Camaris in the story's lore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* TheyCallHimSword: Count Streawe's KnifeNut goon becomes known as "Avi Stetto" (lit. "I have a knife") because of his fondness for threatening people with them.

to:

* TheyCallHimSword: Count Streawe's KnifeNut knife-using goon becomes known as "Avi Stetto" (lit. "I have a knife") because of his fondness for threatening people with them.

Changed: 56

Removed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


There is also a [[LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters rather spectacularly large]] number of secondary characters and plot lines, which are responsible for the size of the books. On the SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism, the story falls somewhere in the middle: AnyoneCanDie, characters get KilledOffForReal with depressing regularity, and the main characters seem to be the [[TheWoobie focus]] of all the suffering that the author can imagine throwing at them. Yet what [[EarnYourHappyEnding slim hope there is of victory]] may owe more to ThePowerOfLove than strength of arms.

to:

There is also a [[LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters rather spectacularly large]] large number of secondary characters and plot lines, which are responsible for the size of the books. On the SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism, the story falls somewhere in the middle: AnyoneCanDie, characters get KilledOffForReal with depressing regularity, and the main characters seem to be the [[TheWoobie focus]] of all the suffering that the author can imagine throwing at them. Yet what [[EarnYourHappyEnding slim hope there is of victory]] may owe more to ThePowerOfLove than strength of arms.



* DramatisPersonae: Made necessary by the LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters.

to:

* %%* DramatisPersonae: Made necessary by the LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters.LoadsAnd LoadsOf Characters.



* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters



* TwoLinesNoWaiting: Along with LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters comes Loads And Loads Of Subplots.

to:

* TwoLinesNoWaiting: Along with LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters numerous characters comes Loads And Loads Of Subplots.

Added: 53

Removed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBad: Ineluki and Utuk'ku, both in their own way.



* BigBad: Ineluki and Utuk'ku, both in their own way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigBad: Ineluki and Utuk'ku, both in their own way.
* BigGood: In essence Prince Josua as the accepted leader of the forces opposing the BigBad.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's a lot of ThatCameOutWrong and ChirpingCrickets between Simon and Miriamele, and between Eolair and Maegwyn respectively.

to:

** There's a lot of ThatCameOutWrong and ChirpingCrickets between Simon and Miriamele, and between Eolair and Maegwyn Maegwin respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EverybodyIsSingle: Despite the medieval setting, hardly anybody is married. It's easier to count those who ''are'' (Isgrimnur, Leobardis, Isorn, Seriddan, Brindalles, Lluth, [[spoiler: Josua and Vorzheva later]]) than those who are not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheGoodKing: Prince Josua had he taken the job - only that it would have killed him with worry and self-doubt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RedShirt: Ostrael, the young pikeman at Naglimund.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DivideAndConquer: '''Discussed''' The war between Elias and Josua serving as a distraction and hindrance to the mortals, so they have no time finding out about the KansasCityShuffle going on with the Three Swords.


Added DiffLines:

* WeNeedADistraction: So Camaris and the Sithi can enter the Hayholt unnoticed by Elias and his allies.

Added: 237

Changed: 64

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** DwindlingParty: In the Storm King War the members die away quickly [[spoiler: as Ookekuk, Doctor Morgenes, Jarnauga and Dinivan are murdered. Xorastra is already dead, Padreic is missing presumed dead and Pryrates was expelled for obvious reasons.]]

to:

** DwindlingParty: In the Storm King War the members die away quickly [[spoiler: as Ookekuk, Doctor Morgenes, Jarnauga and Dinivan are murdered. Xorastra is already dead, Padreic is missing presumed dead and Pryrates was expelled for obvious reasons.]]



** Members are [[ReasonableAuthorityFigure Reasonable Authority Figures]] that should abide to the LawfulGood - if they don't, you'll easily have someone like Pryrates on your hands.



** OhNoNotAgain: In "The Last King of Osten Ard" [[spoiler: Strangyeard died, Lady Faiera and Prince Josua have been missing for years, leaving only Binabik and Tiamak alive and active.]]

to:

** OhNoNotAgain: In "The Last King of Osten Ard" [[spoiler: Strangyeard died, Lady Faiera and Prince Josua have been missing for years, and the open positions have not been filled, thus leaving only Binabik and Tiamak alive and active.]]]]
** There's no [[JustTheFirstCitizen master or leader]].

Added: 949

Changed: 156

Removed: 477

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CovertGroup: The League of the Scroll is not per se a [[SecretSocieties secret society]] but they're quite happy with little publicity - understandable as they're mission is to gain knowledge that will protect the realms of men and hence they are a nuisance to any forces opposing them.
** Thus in the Storm King War they're quickly a DwindlingParty, [[spoiler: as Ookekuk, Doctor Morgenes, Jarnauga and Dinivan are murdered and Xorastra is already dead.]]
** This in turn leads to the FieldPromotion of Binabik, Father Strangyeard and Tiamak to the ranks of members - because at this point there is no active member of the League left alive. [[spoiler: Cadrach and Pryrates do not count. No one knows who Cadrach really is - or where - and Pryrates was expelled.]]

to:

* CovertGroup: The League of the Scroll is not per se a [[SecretSocieties secret society]] but they're quite happy with little publicity - understandable as they're mission is to gain knowledge that will protect the realms of men and hence they are a nuisance to any forces opposing them.
** Thus in the Storm King War they're quickly a DwindlingParty, [[spoiler: as Ookekuk, Doctor Morgenes, Jarnauga and Dinivan are murdered and Xorastra is already dead.]]
** This in turn leads to the FieldPromotion of Binabik, Father Strangyeard and Tiamak to the ranks of members - because at this point there is no active member of the League left alive. [[spoiler: Cadrach and Pryrates do not count. No one knows who Cadrach really is - or where - and Pryrates was expelled.]]
them. See TheOrder below.



* TheOrder: The League of the Scroll - see CovertGroup above.

to:

* TheOrder: The League of the Scroll - see CovertGroup above.founded by Ealsthan Fiskerne about two hundred years ago, the group's goal is to accumulate wisdom which will help protect Osten Ard and its people.
** ArbitraryHeadcountLimit: Never more than seven members.
** DwindlingParty: In the Storm King War the members die away quickly [[spoiler: as Ookekuk, Doctor Morgenes, Jarnauga and Dinivan are murdered. Xorastra is already dead, Padreic is missing presumed dead and Pryrates was expelled for obvious reasons.]]
** FactionMotto: "Podos orbiem, quil meminit" (shortened to "POQM") translating to "He who remembers can make the world anew" in Nabbanai.
** FieldPromotion: For Binabik, Father Strangyeard and Tiamak to the ranks of members - because at this point there is no active member of the League left alive. [[spoiler: Padreic and Pryrates not counting.]]
** MembershipToken: The golden necklace with a scroll and quill pendant and the letters POQM on the back.
** OhNoNotAgain: In "The Last King of Osten Ard" [[spoiler: Strangyeard died, Lady Faiera and Prince Josua have been missing for years, leaving only Binabik and Tiamak alive and active.]]

Added: 667

Changed: 515

Removed: 204

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ConfessInConfidence: Father Strangyeard accepts confession from Camaris when it is thought that his knowledge might give them something of aid against the Storm King, yet he refuses to disclose it out of shame. What is revealed therein is devastating to the priest, but proves useless to the heroes' plans; it is not fully revealed until the denouement when it turns out that Camaris also told Josua.
* ConvenientDecoyCat: A grey cat that lives in the Hayholt saves Simon when he's trapped in a cellar by Pryrates, by offering itself as a distraction. The cat makes several appearances later in the story.



* ConfessInConfidence: Father Strangyeard accepts confession from Camaris when it is thought that his knowledge might give them something of aid against the Storm King, yet he refuses to disclose it out of shame. What is revealed therein is devastating to the priest, but proves useless to the heroes' plans; it is not fully revealed until the denouement when it turns out that Camaris also told Josua.
* ConvenientDecoyCat: A grey cat that lives in the Hayholt saves Simon when he's trapped in a cellar by Pryrates, by offering itself as a distraction. The cat makes several appearances later in the story.

to:

* ConfessInConfidence: ** This in turn leads to the FieldPromotion of Binabik, Father Strangyeard accepts confession from Camaris when it is thought that his knowledge might give them something of aid against the Storm King, yet he refuses to disclose it out of shame. What is revealed therein is devastating and Tiamak to the priest, but proves useless to ranks of members - because at this point there is no active member of the heroes' plans; it is League left alive. [[spoiler: Cadrach and Pryrates do not fully revealed until the denouement when it turns out that Camaris also told Josua.
* ConvenientDecoyCat: A grey cat that lives in the Hayholt saves Simon when he's trapped in a cellar by Pryrates, by offering itself as a distraction. The cat makes several appearances later in the story.
count. No one knows who Cadrach really is - or where - and Pryrates was expelled.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TheOrder: The League of the Scroll - see CovertGroup above.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CovertGroup: The League of the Scroll is not per se a [[SecretSocieties secret society]] but they're quite happy with little publicity - understandable as they're mission is to gain knowledge that will protect the realms of men and hence they are a nuisance to any forces opposing them.
** Thus in the Storm King War they're quickly a DwindlingParty, [[spoiler: as Ookekuk, Doctor Morgenes, Jarnauga and Dinivan are murdered and Xorastra is already dead.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MacGuffin:
** The three swords, obviously.
** The horn Tituno/Cellian once owned by Ineluki and Hakatri, now by Camaris.
** Sithi Mirrors and the white arrow Simon receives from Jiriki.
** The golden necklaces and pendants (parchment and quill) of the seven members of the League of the Scroll - and the FakinMacGuffin i.e. the copy in silver and lesser detail Jarnulf owns for reasons yet unknown.

Top