Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / LeSilenceDeLaMer

Go To

OR

Added: 102

Changed: 273

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalHeroism: There's nothing indicating that Werner believes in Nazi ideals in the 2004 film adaptation, and he saves Jeanne from a rape attempt in it.

to:

* AdaptationalHeroism: There's nothing indicating that Werner believes in Nazi ideals in the 2004 film adaptation, and he saves Jeanne the girl from a rape attempt in it.



* AttemptedRape: In the 2004 TV film adaptation, Jeanne is attacked by her cousin Pascal in her home when she refuses his advances. Her screams alert Werner, who just got out of his car, and his presence alone is enough to make Pascal go away.

to:

* AttemptedRape: In the 2004 TV film adaptation, film, the girl (named Jeanne in this adaptation) is attacked by her cousin Pascal in her home when she refuses his advances. Her screams alert Werner, who just got out of his car, and his presence alone is enough to make Pascal go away.



* LaResistance: Naturally, as the author was a member of the French resistance when he wrote the book.

to:

* LaResistance: Naturally, as KissingCousins: Jeanne's cousin Pascal is attracted to her in the author was a member of 2004 TV film. She doesn't reciprocate the French resistance when feelings, and he wrote the book.tries to sexually assault her, only to be stopped by Werner's timely arrival.


Added DiffLines:

* LaResistance: Naturally, as the author was a member of the French resistance when he wrote the book.

Added: 161

Changed: 106

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalHeroism: There's nothing indicating that Werner believes in Nazi ideals in the 2004 film adaptation, and he saves Jeanne from a rape attempt in it.



* AttemptedRape: In the 2004 TV film Jeanne is attacked by her cousin Pascal in her home when she refuses his advances, but her screams alert Werner.

to:

* AttemptedRape: In the 2004 TV film adaptation, Jeanne is attacked by her cousin Pascal in her home when she refuses his advances, but her advances. Her screams alert Werner.Werner, who just got out of his car, and his presence alone is enough to make Pascal go away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AttemptedRape: In the 2004 TV film Pascal attacks Jeanne in her home when she refuses his advances, but her screams alert Werner.

to:

* AttemptedRape: In the 2004 TV film Jeanne is attacked by her cousin Pascal attacks Jeanne in her home when she refuses his advances, but her screams alert Werner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut released in 1949 and starring Howard Vernon, Nicole Stéphane and Jean-Marie Robain, the other is a 2004 TV film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru.In the 2004 adaptation, the niece becomes a granddaughter called Jeanne Larosière and the uncle a grandfather called André Larosière.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut released in 1949 and starring Howard Vernon, Nicole Stéphane and Jean-Marie Robain, the other is a 2004 TV film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru. In the 2004 adaptation, the niece becomes a granddaughter called Jeanne Larosière and the uncle a grandfather called André Larosière.



* ElegantClassicalMusician: the niece and Werner

to:

* ElegantClassicalMusician: Werner. And also Jeanne, in the niece and Werner2004 TV adaptation.



* RevengeByProxy: In the 2004 adaptation[[DisproportionateRetribution 99 French hostages are shot]] in retaliation for a Resistance attack that kills two German officers.

to:

* RevengeByProxy: In the 2004 adaptation[[DisproportionateRetribution TV adaptation [[DisproportionateRetribution 99 French hostages are shot]] in retaliation for a Resistance attack that kills two German officers.

Changed: 364

Removed: 72

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Several mistakes to due confusing the book with the 1949 film or the 2004 TV adaptation, or the 1949 film with the 2004 film.


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut released in 1949 and starring Howard Vernon, Nicole Stéphane and Jean-Marie Robain, the other is a 2004 TV film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut released in 1949 and starring Howard Vernon, Nicole Stéphane and Jean-Marie Robain, the other is a 2004 TV film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru.In the 2004 adaptation, the niece becomes a granddaughter called Jeanne Larosière and the uncle a grandfather called André Larosière.



* AnachronismStew: Part of Werner's HeelRealization comes on a visit to Paris in September 1941, when he reads a memo from March 1941 about operations at Treblinka. Treblinka was not brought into service as an extermination camp until 1942.
* AttemptedRape: Pascal attacks Jeanne in her home when she refuses his advances, but her screams alert Werner.

to:

* AnachronismStew: Part In the 1949 film, part of Werner's HeelRealization comes on a visit to Paris in September 1941, when he reads a memo from March 1941 about operations at Treblinka. Treblinka was not brought into service as an extermination camp until 1942.
* AttemptedRape: In the 2004 TV film Pascal attacks Jeanne in her home when she refuses his advances, but her screams alert Werner.



* ContemptCrossfire: Werner the German officer quartered in the French home is an OfficerAndAGentleman, truly believing in the ideals of the Nazi party and how eliminating the weak will make the world a better place (for their part, his unwilling hosts maintain absolute silence towards him). Then after he meets his brother (now a CardCarryingVillain delighting in the pain and misery he causes) and learns about the death camps, he finally realizes the brutish, destructive thuggery that the Nazis stand for, and volunteers for the Eastern front.

to:

* ContemptCrossfire: Werner the German officer quartered in the French home is an OfficerAndAGentleman, truly believing in the ideals of the Nazi party and how eliminating the weak will make the world a better place (for their part, his unwilling hosts maintain absolute silence towards him). Then after he meets his brother best friend (now a CardCarryingVillain delighting in the pain and misery he causes) and learns about the death camps, he finally realizes the brutish, destructive thuggery that the Nazis stand for, and volunteers for the Eastern front.



* ElegantClassicalMusician: Jeanne and Werner
* ExternalCombustion

to:

* ElegantClassicalMusician: Jeanne the niece and Werner
* ExternalCombustionExternalCombustion: In the 2004 film, the French resistance puts a time bomb under Werner's car.



* JustFollowingOrders: Werner is no doubt thinking about this at the end, when, right before leaving, he cracks open an Anatole France book and sees the quote "It is beautiful for a soldier to disobey orders which are criminal."

to:

* JustFollowingOrders: In the 1949 film Werner is no doubt thinking about this at the end, when, right before leaving, he cracks open an Anatole France book and sees the quote "It is beautiful for a soldier to disobey orders which are criminal."



* PlaceWorseThanDeath: When Werner reveals that he has requested a transfer to the Eastern Front, he remarks to his hosts that he is "Off to Hell".

to:

* PlaceWorseThanDeath: When Werner reveals that he has requested a transfer to the Eastern Front, he remarks to his hosts in the book and the 1949 film that he is "Off to Hell".



* PragmaticAdaptation: The 1949 film omits the AttemptedRape plot point.



* RevengeByProxy: [[DisproportionateRetribution 99 French hostages are shot]] in retaliation for a Resistance attack that kills two German officers.

to:

* RevengeByProxy: [[DisproportionateRetribution In the 2004 adaptation[[DisproportionateRetribution 99 French hostages are shot]] in retaliation for a Resistance attack that kills two German officers.



* TranquilFury: The humiliated anger of the uncle and niece is palpable, but never finds expression, except maybe in a few [[DeathGlare Death Glares]]. In the 2004 film, Werner's reaction when he prevents a [[AttemptedRape rape of Jeanne by Pascal]] also qualifies.

to:

* TranquilFury: The humiliated anger of the uncle and niece is palpable, but never finds expression, except maybe in a few [[DeathGlare Death Glares]]. In Glares]] in the 2004 film. In this same film, Werner's reaction when he prevents a [[AttemptedRape rape of Jeanne by Pascal]] also qualifies.

Added: 4

Changed: 26

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TranquilFury: The humiliated anger of the uncle and niece is palpable, but never finds expression, except maybe in a few [[DeathGlare Death Glares]]. In the 2004 film, Werner's reaction when he prevents Pascal's AttemptedRape of Jeanne also qualifies.
* WorthyOpponent: How Werner views France. The uncle comes to feel the same way about Werner.

to:

* TranquilFury: The humiliated anger of the uncle and niece is palpable, but never finds expression, except maybe in a few [[DeathGlare Death Glares]]. In the 2004 film, Werner's reaction when he prevents Pascal's AttemptedRape a [[AttemptedRape rape of Jeanne by Pascal]] also qualifies.
* WorthyOpponent: How Werner views France. The uncle comes to feel the same way about Werner.Werner.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949 starring Howard Vernon, Nicole Stéphane and Jean-Marie Robain, the other is a 2004 TV film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut released in 1949 and starring Howard Vernon, Nicole Stéphane and Jean-Marie Robain, the other is a 2004 TV film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949, the other is a 2004 TV film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949, 1949 starring Howard Vernon, Nicole Stéphane and Jean-Marie Robain, the other is a 2004 TV film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949, the other is a 2004 TV film.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949, the other is a 2004 TV film.film starring Julie Delarme, Thomas Jouannet and Creator/MichelGalabru.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949, the other is a 2004 TV film - and several stage plays.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into several stage plays as well as two French-language films - -- one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949, the other is a 2004 TV film - and several stage plays.film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Part of Werner's HeelRealization comes on a visit to Paris in September 1941, when he reads a memo from March 1941 about operations at Treblinka. Treblinka was not brought into service as an extermination camp until 1942.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: AnachronismStew: Part of Werner's HeelRealization comes on a visit to Paris in September 1941, when he reads a memo from March 1941 about operations at Treblinka. Treblinka was not brought into service as an extermination camp until 1942.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ContemptCrossfire: Werner the German officer quartered in the French home is an OfficerAndAGentleman, truly believing in the ideals of the Nazi party and how eliminating the weak will make the world a better place (for their part, his unwilling hosts maintain absolute silence towards him). Then after he meets his brother (now a CardCarryingVillain delighting in the pain and misery he causes) and learns about the death camps, he finally realizes the brutish, destructive thuggery that the Nazis stand for, and volunteers for the Eastern front.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:256:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/SilenceDeLaMer_7672.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:256: Thomas Jouannet and Julie Delarme in the 2004 [[FilmOfTheBook TV film adaptation]].]]

French novella ("The Silence of the Sea") written in 1942 by Jean Bruller and published secretly under his pseudonym, "Vercors". Which is just as well, as it quickly became a symbol of [[LaResistance mental resistance]] against the German occupation.

to:

[[quoteright:256:http://static.[[quoteright:250:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/SilenceDeLaMer_7672.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:256: Thomas Jouannet and Julie Delarme in
org/pmwiki/pub/images/9782253003106_001_t.jpeg]]

''Le Silence de la Mer'' (''The Silence of
the 2004 [[FilmOfTheBook TV film adaptation]].]]

Sea'') is a French novella ("The Silence of the Sea") written in 1942 by Jean Bruller and published secretly under his pseudonym, "Vercors". Which is just as well, as it quickly became a symbol of [[LaResistance mental resistance]] against the German occupation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:256: Thomas Jouannet and Julie Delarme in the 2004 [[FilmOfTheBook film adaptation]].]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:256: Thomas Jouannet and Julie Delarme in the 2004 [[FilmOfTheBook TV film adaptation]].]]



A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949 - and several stage plays.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them is Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949 1949, the other is a 2004 TV film - and several stage plays.
plays.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WorthyOpponent: How Werner views France.

to:

* WorthyOpponent: How Werner views France. The uncle comes to feel the same way about Werner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PayEvilUntoEvil: Werner has Pascal arrested by the [[SecretPolice Gestapo]] after the latter [[AttemptedRape assaults]] Jeanne.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BreakTheBeliever: Werner truly believed the Reich would bring about a better breed of humanity, until he realizes what kind of brutal thugs they truly are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949 - and several stage plays.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of WorldWarII.UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949 - and several stage plays.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them Jean-Pierre Melville's feature-length debut in 1949 - and several stage plays.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them Jean-Pierre Melville's Creator/JeanPierreMelville's feature-length debut in 1949 - and several stage plays.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them Jean-Pierre Melville's feature-length debut - and several stage plays.

to:

A 1946 English TV adaptation was one of the first programmes broadcast by the BBC after the end of WorldWarII. The book has also been adapted into two French-language films - one of them Jean-Pierre Melville's feature-length debut in 1949 - and several stage plays.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


French novella written in 1942 by Jean Bruller and published secretly under his pseudonym, "Vercors". Which is just as well, as it quickly became a symbol of [[LaResistance mental resistance]] against the German occupation.

to:

French novella ("The Silence of the Sea") written in 1942 by Jean Bruller and published secretly under his pseudonym, "Vercors". Which is just as well, as it quickly became a symbol of [[LaResistance mental resistance]] against the German occupation.

Added: 986

Changed: 445

Removed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----



* [[spoiler: AlasPoorVillain]]

to:

* [[spoiler: AlasPoorVillain]]AlasPoorVillain
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Part of Werner's HeelRealization comes on a visit to Paris in September 1941, when he reads a memo from March 1941 about operations at Treblinka. Treblinka was not brought into service as an extermination camp until 1942.



* ElectiveMute

to:

* ElectiveMuteDuringTheWar: The interplay between a German officer and his two unwilling hosts in a small house in occupied France.
* ElectiveMute: The uncle and niece refuse to say a single word to the German officer who has been quartered in their home.



* [[spoiler: [[FinalFirstHug Final First Words]]]]: ''"Adieu."''

to:

* [[spoiler: [[FinalFirstHug Final First Words]]]]: ''"Adieu."''Words]]: "Adieu", says the niece to Werner as he's leaving.



* HeelRealisation: Happens during [[spoiler: Werner's time in Paris]].

to:

* HeelRealisation: Happens during [[spoiler: Werner's time in Paris]].Paris.
* HitlerCam: The 1949 film uses this several times, including some instances shot from the POV of the uncle sitting in a chair, but also a couple of shots from the inside of the fireplace as Werner stands over the fire.
* JustFollowingOrders: Werner is no doubt thinking about this at the end, when, right before leaving, he cracks open an Anatole France book and sees the quote "It is beautiful for a soldier to disobey orders which are criminal."



* NoNameGiven: In the original novel, the two principal characters are known only as "the uncle" and "the niece".

to:

* NoNameGiven: In the original novel, the two principal characters are known only as "the uncle" and "the niece". In the 1949 film, Werner is the only character who has a name.



* PlaceWorseThanDeath: When Werner reveals that he has [[spoiler: requested a transfer to the Eastern Front, he remarks to his hosts that he is "Off to Hell"]].

to:

* PlaceWorseThanDeath: When Werner reveals that he has [[spoiler: requested a transfer to the Eastern Front, he remarks to his hosts that he is "Off to Hell"]].Hell".



* PragmaticAdaptation: The 1949 film omits the AttemptedRape plot point.



* [[spoiler: ReassignedToAntarctica]]

to:

* [[spoiler: ReassignedToAntarctica]]ReassignedToAntarctica: Although he does it to himself, volunteering to leave his cushy, pleasant duty station in occupied France and instead fight on the Eastern Front.



* TheThingThatWouldNotLeave: A rare use of this for drama, as Werner doesn't have to leave.



* WorldWarII
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The story centres on an elderly man and his young niece, who are forced to share their home with a German officer named Werner, and though they are unable to hinder him directly, they resolve to show resistance by never saying a word to him. The uncomfortable arrangement is complicated by the fact that Werner is a [[FriendlyEnemy polite Francophile]] who genuinely desires amity with his unwilling hosts and between their two warring nations.

to:

The story centres on an elderly man and his young niece, who are forced to share their home with a German officer named Werner, Werner Von Ebrannac, and though they are unable to hinder him directly, they resolve to show resistance by never saying a word to him. The uncomfortable arrangement is complicated by the fact that Werner is a [[FriendlyEnemy polite Francophile]] who genuinely desires amity with his unwilling hosts and between their two warring nations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: [[FinalFirstHug Final First Words]]: ''"Adieu."''

to:

* [[spoiler: [[FinalFirstHug Final First Words]]: Words]]]]: ''"Adieu."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[spoiler: [[FinalFirstHug Final First Words]]: ''"Adieu."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** BreakTheCutie
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[spoiler: AlasPoorVillain]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TranquilFury: The anger and humiliation of the uncle and niece is palpable, but never finds expression, except maybe in a few [[DeathGlare DeathGlares]]. In the 2004 film, Werner's reaction when he prevents Pascal's AttemptedRape of Jeanne also qualifies.

to:

* TranquilFury: The humiliated anger and humiliation of the uncle and niece is palpable, but never finds expression, except maybe in a few [[DeathGlare DeathGlares]].Death Glares]]. In the 2004 film, Werner's reaction when he prevents Pascal's AttemptedRape of Jeanne also qualifies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TranquilFury: The anger and humiliation of the uncle and niece is palpable, but never finds expression, except maybe in a few DeathGlares. In the 2004 film, Werner's reaction when he prevents Pascal's AttemptedRape of Jeanne also qualifies.

to:

* TranquilFury: The anger and humiliation of the uncle and niece is palpable, but never finds expression, except maybe in a few DeathGlares.[[DeathGlare DeathGlares]]. In the 2004 film, Werner's reaction when he prevents Pascal's AttemptedRape of Jeanne also qualifies.

Top