Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / JulianComstock

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SurvivorGuilt: Instead of being glad the US Navy turned up for a BigDamnHeroes, Julian just thinks the death of all his men killed in his failed attack was AllForNothing, as he could have just waiting a few more days. He drops several hints that [[DeathSeeker he wishes he was killed in that attack]].

to:

* SurvivorGuilt: Instead of being glad the US Navy turned up for a BigDamnHeroes, Julian just thinks the death of all his men killed in his failed attack was AllForNothing, as he could have just waiting waited a few more days. He drops several hints that [[DeathSeeker he wishes he was killed in that attack]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Admiral Fairfield swears that the US Navy will turn up to support Julian's land campaign even if his flagship ''Basilisk'' is the only one left. The ''Basilisk'' is indeed the only ship that turns up because President Deklan has ordered the Navy to abandon Julian's division, so Fairchild gives what support he can under the guise of covering the Navy's withdrawal.

to:

** Admiral Fairfield swears that the US Navy will turn up to support Julian's land campaign even if his flagship ''Basilisk'' is the only one left. The ''Basilisk'' is indeed the only ship that turns up because President Deklan has ordered the Navy to abandon Julian's division, so Fairchild gives what support he can under the guise of covering the Navy's withdrawal. Ironically this is what causes the UriahGambit to fail, as he takes back Adam's dispatches as well and a newspaper publishes them, make Deklan's scheme obvious to all concerned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SurvivorGuilt: Instead of being glad the US Navy turned up for a BigDamnHeroes, Julian just thinks the death of all his men killed in his failed attack was AllForNothing, as he could have just waiting a few more days. He drops several hints that [[DeathSeeker he wishes he was killed in that attack]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LoopholeAbuse:
** Admiral Fairfield swears that the US Navy will turn up to support Julian's land campaign even if his flagship ''Basilisk'' is the only one left. The ''Basilisk'' is indeed the only ship that turns up because President Deklan has ordered the Navy to abandon Julian's division, so Fairchild gives what support he can under the guise of covering the Navy's withdrawal.
** Adam finds his wife and Julian's mother under house arrest. Rather than keep shouting to them from the street, he points out to the sentry that under regulations a superior officer (Adam is a colonel by now) can relieve him while he goes and [[FoodAsBribe gets something to eat]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: The President is not guarded by the Secret Service but a military unit known as the [[UsefulNotes/SaddamHussein Republican Guard]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadGuyOnDisplay: Julian's attempted assassin - and after Julian thinks about it a bit, [[spoiler:his uncle Deklan as well]].
* DefeatMeansFriendship: When trying to flee the draft in a train, Adam fought a man named Lymon Pugh and lost; this loss caused the other runaways to accept him, since it showed that he didn't see himself as "better."

to:

* DeadGuyOnDisplay: Julian's attempted assassin - and after Julian thinks about it a bit, [[spoiler:his uncle Deklan as well]].
well]] gets their heads impaled on the walls of the Presidential Palace. Adam has no sympathy for either of them, but doesn't approve as it makes Julian look as barbaric as President Deklan was.
* DefeatMeansFriendship: When trying to flee the draft in a train, Adam fought a man named Lymon Pugh and lost; this loss caused the other runaways to accept him, since it showed that he didn't see himself as "better."" Lymon then approaches Adam for an apology; after sorting out the misunderstanding that led to the fight, Adam ends up teaching Lymon how to read.



** The Mitteleuropans are referred to as Dutch, which is actually a corruption of ''Duetsche'', because that European empire is run from former Germany. Ironically most of their soldiers and settlers actually are Dutch.

to:

** The Mitteleuropans are referred to as Dutch, which is actually a corruption of ''Duetsche'', because that European empire is run from former Germany. Ironically most of their the soldiers and settlers they send to Labrador actually are Dutch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections: When a war correspondent plagiarizes Adam's writing on Julian's heroics in the war, he goes to his editor to complain. The reporter correspondent denies the charge while the editor tries to intimidate Adam into signing a retraction. Adam agrees but calls in a witness for his signature--who happens to be the President's nephew, Julian Comstock. Cue OhCrap from all concerned and Adam gets his money repaid and a profitable writer's contract on the spot. The editor offers to fire the correspondent as well, but Adam graciously accepts his (expensive handmade) typewriter instead.

to:

* ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections: When a war correspondent plagiarizes Adam's writing on Julian's heroics in the war, he goes to his the editor to complain. The reporter correspondent blandly denies the charge while the editor tries to intimidate Adam into signing a retraction. Adam agrees but calls in a witness for his signature--who happens to be the President's nephew, Julian Comstock. Cue OhCrap from all concerned and Adam gets his money repaid and a profitable writer's contract on the spot. The editor offers to fire the correspondent as well, but Adam graciously accepts his (expensive handmade) typewriter instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GlobalIgnorance
** The Mitteleuropans are referred to as Dutch, which is actually a corruption of ''Duetsche'', because that European empire is run from former Germany. Ironically most of their soldiers and settlers actually are Dutch.
** New York City has a large population of "Egyptians", who are implied to be refugees from all across the Middle East.


Added DiffLines:

* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: Julian's mother and Adam's wife know full well that Julian's Presidency is not going to last for long and make preparations to escape to France. Once they see the President's mother leaving with all her baggage even Julian's PraetorianGuard, handpicked from the former soldiers he commanded, realise what's happening and proceed to loot the Palace and leave. Adam can't bring himself to condemn them, knowing their job or even life prospects are limited in whatever new regime will come afterwards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AristocratsAreEvil: Deklan Comstock, Mr. Wieland

to:

* AristocratsAreEvil: Deklan Comstock, Mr. WielandWieland is introduced beating his servant because his carriage threw a wheel.



* FutureImperfect: The Dominion is deliberately cultivating this trope in the hopes of both maintaining their power and permanently damning the "Secular Ancients."

to:

* FutureImperfect: The Dominion is deliberately cultivating this trope in the hopes of both maintaining their power and permanently damning the "Secular Ancients."" The Dominion-approved movie ''Eula's Choice'' has the "Secular Police" arresting a man purely for preaching about religion. The idea of man on the Moon is regarded as a fairy tale, and Adam can hardly believe it even when he finds a book on the subject in a Tip. Later he and Julian find the same book in the Dominion archive of banned books.

Added: 614

Changed: 540

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:Subverted; Deacon Hollingshead's daughter, who has had relations with women, was thought to have died when the Army of the Californias attacked the house she was in. Julian, however, had her secretly moved to Montreal.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Subverted; Deacon Hollingshead's daughter, who has had relations with women, was thought to have died when the Army of the Californias attacked the house she was in. Julian, however, had her secretly moved to Montreal.Montreal beforehand.]]



* ChurchMilitant: Deacon Hollingshead

to:

* ChurchMilitant: Deacon HollingsheadHollingshead. His objections to President Julian Conqueror's attempt to curb Dominion power [[ItsPersonal quickly turn into a grudge match between them.]]



* MonumentalDamage: An otherwise intact (Secular-era) cathedral in Montreal gets destroyed during a ''Mitteleuropan'' artillery strike while in New York, a remnant of the Statue of Liberty is preserved as an exhibit.

to:

* MonumentalDamage: An otherwise intact (Secular-era) cathedral in Montreal gets destroyed during a ''Mitteleuropan'' artillery strike while in strike. In New York, a remnant of the Statue of Liberty is preserved as an exhibit.



* ScienceIsBad: Biological evolution is a "discredited creed," and arguing in favor of it is heresy.

to:

* ScienceIsBad: Biological evolution is a "discredited creed," creed", and arguing in favor of it is heresy.



* ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections: When a war correspondent plagiarizes Adam's writing on Julian's heroics in the war, he goes to his editor to complain. The reporter correspondent denies the charge while the editor tries to intimidate Adam into signing a retraction. Adam agrees but calls in a witness for his signature--who happens to be the President's nephew, Julian Comstock. Cue OhCrap from all concerned and Adam gets his money repaid and a profitable writer's contract on the spot. The editor offers to fire the correspondent as well, but Adam graciously accepts his (expensive handmade) typewriter instead.



** ''Eula's Choice''; Adam sometimes points out the film's historical inaccuracies. Later on, Julian makes his own movie about Charles Darwin.
** In addition, after Julian loots the Dominion's collection of banned media he and Adam watch a surviving thirty-minute segment of the 1959 CozyCatastrophe movie ''Film/OnTheBeach''. They find it somewhat confusing.

to:

** ''Eula's Choice''; Adam sometimes points out the film's historical inaccuracies. Choice'', a blatant propaganda piece of Dominion-approved history. Later on, Julian makes his own movie about Charles Darwin.
Darwin, which is hardly any better when it comes to historical accuracy or anti-religious propaganda.
** In addition, after Julian loots the Dominion's collection of banned media he and Adam watch a surviving thirty-minute segment of the 1959 CozyCatastrophe movie ''Film/OnTheBeach''. They find it somewhat confusing.



* WhyDidItHaveToBeSnakes: Literal for Adam and Julian.

to:

* WhyDidItHaveToBeSnakes: Literal for Adam and Julian. Adam's father was a preacher for a snake-handling religious sect, so he at least knows how to handle them, and which ones are venomous. Julian doesn't and finds them terrifying.

Added: 501

Changed: 233

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ButWhatAboutTheAstronauts: averted - a [[AbusivePrecursors "Secular Ancestors"]] book on space travel shows that although the Chinese landed people on the Moon in the 21st century, no permanent off-world bases were established before the oil ran out. Adam briefly muses on what life would be like on the moon; he imagines without air, water or food it would be pretty harsh.
* CensorshipBureau: Only Dominion-approved books may be read legally.

to:

* ButWhatAboutTheAstronauts: averted - a [[AbusivePrecursors "Secular Ancestors"]] book on space travel shows that although the Chinese landed people on the Moon in the 21st century, no permanent off-world bases were established before the oil ran out. Adam briefly muses on what life would be like on the moon; he imagines without air, water or food moon, assuming from the bulky spacesuits that it would must be pretty harsh.
rather cold.
* CensorshipBureau: Only Dominion-approved books may be read legally. After he becomes President, Julian sends troops to seize the Dominion archive of forbidden books and gladly delves into them.



* EnforcedTechnologyLevels: Society is kept at a sustainable 19th-century level of technology and the theocracy preaches against the Years of Vice and Profligacy. Of course, this also helps sustain their power, as a more advanced level of technology would require a more literate population; currently most of the workforce are kept in IndenturedServitude that's slavery in all but name.

to:

* EnforcedTechnologyLevels: Society is kept at a sustainable 19th-century level of technology in the PostPeakOil world, and the theocracy preaches against the Years of Vice and Profligacy. Of course, this also helps sustain their power, as a more advanced level of technology would require a more literate population; currently most of the workforce are kept in IndenturedServitude that's slavery in all but name.


Added DiffLines:

* ReluctantRuler: Deconstructed with Julian, who regards being made President after his uncle is deposed as a FateWorseThanDeath. As a result he puts little effort into the pragmatic political maneuvering needed to survive in the position--picking a fight with the powerful Dominion church, ignoring the Senate, giving arbitrary orders to the military without thinking of the consequences, and [[WhileRomeBurns losing himself in his personal interests in Theatre and Philosophy the worse things get]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FirstPersonPeripheralNarrator: Adam Hazzard tells the story of Jullian Comstock as the first person narrator.

to:

* FirstPersonPeripheralNarrator: Adam Hazzard tells the story of Jullian Julian Comstock as the first person narrator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FeudalFuture: Because people during the End needed to eat, they willingly became serfs. Unfortunately, the system of serfdom became entrenched, persisting into the relative prosperity of post-Peak Oil society. In addition, the return of an industrial working class in the cities is beginning to put said serfdom to the test.

to:

* FeudalFuture: Because people during the End needed to eat, they willingly (at least according to Dominion-approved history) became serfs. Unfortunately, the system of serfdom became entrenched, persisting into the relative prosperity of post-Peak Oil society. In addition, the return of an industrial working class in the cities is beginning to put said serfdom to the test.

Added: 57

Changed: 391

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilUncle: Deklan Comstock.

to:

* EnforcedTechnologyLevels: Society is kept at a sustainable 19th-century level of technology and the theocracy preaches against the Years of Vice and Profligacy. Of course, this also helps sustain their power, as a more advanced level of technology would require a more literate population; currently most of the workforce are kept in IndenturedServitude that's slavery in all but name.
* EvilUncle: Deklan Comstock.Comstock, who's also a PresidentEvil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BilingualBackfire: Calyxa is from Montreal and has a habit of [[HidingBehindTheLanguageBarrier delivering insults in French]]. This backfires when she does this to the powerful Dominion official Deacon Hollingshead, who replies in French that he's not an idiot and will have her arrested if she tries it again.


Added DiffLines:

* ClosestThingWeGot: Adam is shocked to find the miscreant Private Langers impersonating a Dominion Officer to give solace to the dying. He tells the doctor about the imposter only to get told he already knows. Turns out when Julian was given command of the campaign he dismissed all their Dominion Officers [[DidNotThinkThisThrough so now there's no-one to do the job of giving last rites]]. Adam has to admit that he's actually good at it (though he later gets in trouble for RobbingTheDead).


Added DiffLines:

* RuleOfDrama: Parodied when Julian writes a play on the work of Charles Darwin, but realises it's rather uninteresting. So Adam consults a famous author who says it just needs a few additions to spice it up. Like a LoveTriangle, and songs, and a fight with pirates, and a [[MisplacedWildlife lion]], and a ClimbingClimax DuelToTheDeath on the [[TheMountainsOfIllinois Alps of Oxford]]...none of which happened to the real Darwin. Regardless, all these elements are added to the play and it's a roaring success.


Added DiffLines:

* ScreamingBirth: Played for laughs when screaming breaks out as Calyxa is giving birth. Adam races upstairs to find the doctor and midwife cowering in fear at the horrible creature peering through the window. Even though he's high on opium given to calm him down, Adam just shoos away the giraffe (which is allowed to wander the grounds of the Presidential Palace) and closes the window.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In addition, after Julian loots the Dominion's collection of banned media he and Adam watch a surviving thirty-minute segment of the 1959 CozyCatastrophe movie ''Film.OnTheBeach''. They find it somewhat confusing.

to:

** In addition, after Julian loots the Dominion's collection of banned media he and Adam watch a surviving thirty-minute segment of the 1959 CozyCatastrophe movie ''Film.OnTheBeach''.''Film/OnTheBeach''. They find it somewhat confusing.

Added: 216

Changed: 425

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShowWithinAShow: ''Eula's Choice''; Adam sometimes points out the film's historical inaccuracies. [[spoiler:Later on, Julian makes his own movie about Charles Darwin.]]
** In addition, after Julian loots the Dominion's collection of banned media he and Adam watch a surviving thirty-minute segment of the 1959 CozyCatastrophe movie ''On The Beach''. They find it somewhat confusing.

to:

* ShowWithinAShow: ShowWithinAShow:
**
''Eula's Choice''; Adam sometimes points out the film's historical inaccuracies. [[spoiler:Later Later on, Julian makes his own movie about Charles Darwin.]]
Darwin.
** In addition, after Julian loots the Dominion's collection of banned media he and Adam watch a surviving thirty-minute segment of the 1959 CozyCatastrophe movie ''On The Beach''.''Film.OnTheBeach''. They find it somewhat confusing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{BFG}}: The US Army's "Trench Sweeper", and the Mitteleuropans' "Chinese Cannons."

to:

* {{BFG}}: The US Army's "Trench Sweeper", Sweeper" (a handheld light machine gun), and the Mitteleuropans' "Chinese Cannons."Cannon" (a long-range artillery piece that can be [[IKEAWeaponry broken down for transportation]]).

Added: 320

Removed: 320

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per this ATT, reverting this to that pending formal name change.


* ClimateChange: Washington DC is a swamp, it doesn't snow in central Canada until November, and the US and Mitteleuropa are fighting a war over Labrador, Nunavut and the now-open Northwest Passage. In passing it's mentioned the Mitteleuropan army is mostly composed of displaced Dutch whose homeland is now under water.


Added DiffLines:

* GlobalWarming: Washington DC is a swamp, it doesn't snow in central Canada until November, and the US and Mitteleuropa are fighting a war over Labrador, Nunavut and the now-open Northwest Passage. In passing it's mentioned the Mitteleuropan army is mostly composed of displaced Dutch whose homeland is now under water.

Changed: 47

Removed: 461

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[DeadGuyOnDisplay Dead Guys On Display]] Julian's attempted assassin - and after Julian thinks about it a bit, [[spoiler:his uncle Deklan as well]].

to:

* [[DeadGuyOnDisplay Dead Guys On Display]] DeadGuyOnDisplay: Julian's attempted assassin - and after Julian thinks about it a bit, [[spoiler:his uncle Deklan as well]].



* UsefulNotes/TheEuropeanUnion: From the information and propaganda mentioned, it's implied that ''Mitteleuropa'' could likely be a German-controlled EU remnant. It's also mentioned in passing that England is a nominal member of the alliance, [[UsefulNotes/WithEuropeButNotOfIt though it would rather stay out of it]].



* [[GratuitousForeignLanguage Gratuitous Dutch]]: Adam grabs a short letter off of a dead Mitteleuropan soldier; it is in untranslated Dutch.

to:

* [[GratuitousForeignLanguage Gratuitous Dutch]]: GratuitousForeignLanguage: Adam grabs a short letter off of a dead Mitteleuropan soldier; it is in untranslated Dutch.



* [[spoiler:ZeroPercentApprovalRating: Because of this, the Army of the Laurentians deposes Deklan Comstock and installs Julian as President.]]

Added: 320

Removed: 320

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed per TRS


* ClimateChange: Washington DC is a swamp, it doesn't snow in central Canada until November, and the US and Mitteleuropa are fighting a war over Labrador, Nunavut and the now-open Northwest Passage. In passing it's mentioned the Mitteleuropan army is mostly composed of displaced Dutch whose homeland is now under water.



* GlobalWarming: Washington DC is a swamp, it doesn't snow in central Canada until November, and the US and Mitteleuropa are fighting a war over Labrador, Nunavut and the now-open Northwest Passage. In passing it's mentioned the Mitteleuropan army is mostly composed of displaced Dutch whose homeland is now under water.

Added: 460

Changed: 40

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AfterTheEnd: The "End" being when the oil ran out. By the time the story starts, society had long since recovered.

to:

* AfterTheEnd: The "End" being when the oil ran out. By the time the story starts, society had long since recovered.has stabilized at a pre-ACW level.
* ApocalypseHow: Class 1, bordering on Class 2-a combination of resource depletion and climate change resulted in the collapse of industrial civilization.



* DaysOfFuturePast: The social mores of the 19th century were actively restored. Society and technology in general are a mix of this and UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, or rather "imperfect" recreations of them. Justified in part, due to a good deal of modern technology becoming useless with the End of Oil. Not to mention the whole thing being a deliberate effort create an "idealized" version of Americana.

to:

* DaysOfFuturePast: The social mores of the 19th century were actively restored. Society and technology in general are a mix of this and UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, or rather "imperfect" recreations of them. Justified in part, due to a good deal of modern technology becoming useless with the End of Oil. Not to mention the whole thing being a deliberate effort to create an "idealized" version of Americana.


Added DiffLines:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: With the regression in technology has come a regression of social values. Feminism, LGBT rights, and religious freedom have all ceased to exist.


Added DiffLines:

* PresidentForLife: In the future, Presidents rule for life and choose their successors, just like the Emperors of the Roman Empire.

Changed: 276

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Expy}}: Julian Comstock himself is a futuristic version of [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_(emperor) Julian the Apostate]], who himself was known for his attempt to reduce the power of Christianity in an effort to restore to past secular glory in his short reign.

to:

* {{Expy}}: Julian Comstock himself is a futuristic version of [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_(emperor) Julian the Apostate]], who himself was known for his attempt to reduce the power of Christianity in an effort to restore to past secular glory in his short reign. Furthermore, his early life as an orphan due to the death of his father by his relative (Deklan playing the role of Constantius II, who murdered Julian's father), his rise to leadership due to his military aptitude, and his scholarly background with disdain for Christianity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Expy}}: Julian Comstock himself is a futuristic version of [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_(emperor) Julian the Apostate]], who himself was known for his attempt to reduce the power of Christianity in an effort to restore to past secular glory in his short reign.

Added: 747

Changed: 1060

Removed: 322

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* [[spoiler:BuryYourGays: Subverted; Deacon Hollingshead's daughter, who has had relations with women, was thought to have died when the Army of the Californias attacked the house she was in. Julian, however, had her secretly moved to Montreal.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:BuryYourGays: Subverted; BuryYourGays:
** [[spoiler:Subverted;
Deacon Hollingshead's daughter, who has had relations with women, was thought to have died when the Army of the Californias attacked the house she was in. Julian, however, had her secretly moved to Montreal.]]



* DaysOfFuturePast: The social mores of the 19th century were actively restored.
** Society and technology in general are a mix of this and UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, or rather "imperfect" recreations of them. Justified in part, due to a good deal of modern technology becoming useless with the End of Oil. Not to mention the whole thing being a deliberate effort create an "idealized" version of Americana.

to:

* DaysOfFuturePast: The social mores of the 19th century were actively restored.
**
restored. Society and technology in general are a mix of this and UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, or rather "imperfect" recreations of them. Justified in part, due to a good deal of modern technology becoming useless with the End of Oil. Not to mention the whole thing being a deliberate effort create an "idealized" version of Americana.



* NostalgiaFilter: Averted by the Dominion, who portrays the civilization of the "Secular Ancestors" as a corrupt Babylon filled with such evils as pornography and the separation of church and state. In addition, since it's been a century since the "False Tribulation" no one has any first-hand memories of "the Oil Florescence".

to:

* NostalgiaFilter: NostalgiaFilter:
**
Averted by the Dominion, who portrays the civilization of the "Secular Ancestors" as a corrupt Babylon filled with such evils as pornography and the separation of church and state. In addition, since it's been a century since the "False Tribulation" no one has any first-hand memories of "the Oil Florescence".



* RagnarokProofing: Averted; scavenged electronics don't work anymore, scavenged books have brittle pages, and most late 20th-early 21st century movies do not survive -- the few that ''do'' survive have serious damage.

to:

* RagnarokProofing: RagnarokProofing:
**
Averted; scavenged electronics don't work anymore, scavenged books have brittle pages, and most late 20th-early 21st century movies do not survive -- the few that ''do'' survive have serious damage.

Top