Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / GeorgesMarvellousMedicine

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Broken Aesop is YMMV.


* BrokenAesop: George's decision to not use anything from the medicine cupboard seems like a message to children about not playing around with harmful substances. All well and good except for the fact that many of the things he actually ''did'' use realistically would have killed Grandma anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''George's Marvellous Medicine'' is a 1981 children's book by Creator/RoaldDahl. George is a young boy left alone with his nasty grandmother who constantly tortures him. Responsible for giving her medicine, he decides to mix one of his own in hopes it will get her to stop annoying him, using ingredients such as paint and animal pills, having no idea what the result will be.

to:

''George's Marvellous Medicine'' is a 1981 children's book by Creator/RoaldDahl. George is a young boy farmboy left alone with his nasty grandmother who constantly tortures him. Responsible for giving her medicine, he decides to mix one of his own in hopes it will get her to stop annoying him, using ingredients such as paint and animal pills, having no idea what the result will be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SquareCubeLaw: Square cube what? Though Grandma is depicted as unnaturally thin in her giant form, which could have compensated for the otherwise increased mass, the chicken the same batch of medicine is used on retains its relative girth as it grows, yet is still agile enough to run around with Grandma on its back.

to:

* SquareCubeLaw: Square cube what? Though Grandma is depicted as unnaturally thin in her giant form, which could have compensated for the otherwise increased mass, the chicken animals the same batch of medicine is used on retains its retain their relative girth as it grows, they grow, yet is are still agile enough for an enlarged pony to run around with Grandma on its back.



* WomenAreWiser: Not that George's father is stupid but he does have a tendency to get very worked up and excited, so that it takes George at least three tries before he can point out that he can't remember everything he put into his medicine. His wife tells him to calm down and listen to his son, and is less optimistic about the chances of being able to replicate the medicine.

to:

* WomenAreWiser: Not that George's father is stupid but he does have a tendency to get very worked up and excited, so that it takes George at least three tries before he can point out that he can't remember everything he put into his medicine. His wife tells him to calm down and listen to his son, and is less optimistic about the chances of being able to replicate the medicine.medicine, pointing out that even if they remember the ingredients correctly they can't guarantee the amount of each ingredient necessary for the final recipe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Grandma is a darker example. Although everything she says to George usually ends with him being [[{{Jerkass}} lazy, stupid, childish or selfish]], the lead-in usually runs on InsaneTrollLogic. She apparently thinks that children should get smaller rather than larger, that insect-riddled cabbage is a delicacy, and hints that she might be a witch [[{{Troll}} just to spook her grandson]]. She goes further during and after her transformation.


Added DiffLines:

* TransformationExhilaration: The titular medicine seems to have made Grandma a true believer in the merits of greater height, despite starting the story believing that growing up (children both maturing and becoming physically larger) are childish habits. It probably helped that the medicine also cured all her bodily ailments into the bargain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SquareCubeLaw: Square cube what? Though Grandma is depicted as unnaturally thin in her giant form, which could have compensated for the otherwise increased mass, the pony the same batch of medicine is used on retains its relative girth as it grows, yet is still agile enough to run around with Grandma on its back.

to:

* SquareCubeLaw: Square cube what? Though Grandma is depicted as unnaturally thin in her giant form, which could have compensated for the otherwise increased mass, the pony chicken the same batch of medicine is used on retains its relative girth as it grows, yet is still agile enough to run around with Grandma on its back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Cloudcuckoolander}}: Mr Kranky is described as a kind father to George who, due to his excitable nature, is nonetheless not always an easy person to live with. The giant chicken in the middle of the yard being certainly not a small thing, and the subsequent possibilities surrounding the medicine and giant animals, has him spending most of the remainder of the book in a state of near-mania.

to:

* {{Cloudcuckoolander}}: Mr Kranky is described as a kind father to George who, due to his excitable nature, nature at even the smallest of things, is nonetheless not always an easy person to live with. The giant chicken in the middle of the yard [[{{Understatement}} being certainly not a small thing, thing]], and the subsequent possibilities surrounding the medicine and giant animals, has him spending most of the remainder of the book in a state of near-mania.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Cloudcuckoolander: Mr Kranky is described as a kind father to George who, due to his excitable nature, is nonetheless not always an easy person to live with. The giant chicken in the middle of the yard being certainly not a small thing, and the subsequent possibilities surrounding the medicine and giant animals, has him spending most of the remainder of the book in a state of near-mania.

to:

* Cloudcuckoolander: {{Cloudcuckoolander}}: Mr Kranky is described as a kind father to George who, due to his excitable nature, is nonetheless not always an easy person to live with. The giant chicken in the middle of the yard being certainly not a small thing, and the subsequent possibilities surrounding the medicine and giant animals, has him spending most of the remainder of the book in a state of near-mania.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Cloudcuckoolander: Mr Kranky is described as a kind father to George who, due to his excitable nature, is nonetheless not always an easy person to live with. The giant chicken in the middle of the yard being certainly not a small thing, and the subsequent possibilities surrounding the medicine and giant animals, has him spending most of the remainder of the book in a state of near-mania.

Added: 4

Changed: 204

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing end-of-story spoilers brought up in this query: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/query.php?parent_id=115065&type=att#comment-341269


And far from poisoning her, it instead makes her grow incredibly tall. When his parents return to the farm and see that it has similar effects on the animals, his dad tries to get George to reproduce the formula. However, he cannot get it ''exactly'' right (to the misfortune of the chickens they test it on). The fourth and final batch turns out to be a ''shrinking'' medicine... which Grandma mistakes for tea and drinks a whole teacup full of. She then proceeds to shrink till she is invisible to the naked eye.

to:

And far from poisoning her, it instead makes her grow incredibly tall. When his parents return to the farm and see that it has similar effects on the animals, his dad tries to get George to reproduce the formula. However, he cannot get it ''exactly'' right (to the misfortune of the chickens they test it on). The fourth and final batch turns out to be a ''shrinking'' medicine... which Grandma mistakes for tea and drinks a whole teacup full of. She then proceeds to shrink till she is invisible to the naked eye.\n

----


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added the rhyme

Added DiffLines:

--->Fiery broth and witch's brew\\
Foamy froth and riches blue\\
Fume and spume and spoondrift spray\\
Fizzle swizzle shout hooray\\
Watch it sloshing, swashing sploshing\\
Hear it hissing, squishing, spissing\\
Grandma better start to pray.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''George's Marvellous Medicine'' is a 1981 children's book by Creator/RoaldDahl. George is a young boy left alone with his horrible grandmother. Responsible for giving her medicine, he decides to mix his own one using ingredients such as paint and animal pills, having no idea what the result will be.

to:

''George's Marvellous Medicine'' is a 1981 children's book by Creator/RoaldDahl. George is a young boy left alone with his horrible grandmother. nasty grandmother who constantly tortures him. Responsible for giving her medicine, he decides to mix one of his own one in hopes it will get her to stop annoying him, using ingredients such as paint and animal pills, having no idea what the result will be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryoneHasStandards: George hates his grandmother and thinks she's a terrible person, but even ''he'' doesn't want her to be killed. Thus, he and his mother warn her not to drink from the cup he's holding because it's a variant of the Marvelous medicine that shrinks the person who swallows it and one dose turned a hen into a chick-size.

to:

* EveryoneHasStandards: George hates his grandmother and thinks she's a terrible person, but even ''he'' doesn't want her to be killed.killed[[note]]though the "medicine" he makes for her would result in exactly that if this were RealLife[[/note]]. Thus, he and his mother warn her not to drink from the cup he's holding because it's a variant of the Marvelous medicine that shrinks the person who swallows it and one dose turned a hen into a chick-size.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: It's very obvious that Dahl deliberately gave the eponymous "medicine" fantastical effects for the sake of writing a funny story. Nevertheless, modern editions include [[DoNotTryThisAtHome a warning]] that doing the same thing in RealLife would be LethallyStupid, lest there be at least one child [[ChildrenAreInnocent who would try to make the "medicine" themselves, thinking it would actually make people grow taller]].

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: It's very obvious that Dahl deliberately gave the eponymous "medicine" fantastical effects for the sake of writing a funny story. Nevertheless, modern editions include [[DoNotTryThisAtHome a warning]] that doing making the same thing in RealLife would be LethallyStupid, lest there be at least one child [[ChildrenAreInnocent who would try to make the "medicine" themselves, thinking it would actually make people grow taller]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntThinkThisThrough: As George was just grabbing whatever he could find to make the medicine, when he tries to recreate it he forgets various minor details, such as lipsticks, and his mother also observes that the recipe needs the same ''amount'' of each ingredient rather than just needing the same ingredients. As a result George forgets a few minor ingredients and will never be able to guarantee the right quantity of even the ones he did remember, resulting in three failed attempts to recreate the recipe.

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: As George was just grabbing whatever he could find to make the medicine, when he his father tries to help him recreate it the recipe George ends up forgetting some minor details; for example, when looking at what he used from his parents' room he forgets various minor details, such as lipsticks, and that he added a couple of his mother's lipsticks to the recipe. George's mother also observes that the recipe needs the same ''amount'' of each ingredient rather than just needing the same ingredients. As a ingredients, with the result that George forgets a few minor ingredients and will never be able to guarantee the right quantity of even the ones he did remember, resulting to say nothing of the question of whether the order in which he added everything had any impact on the recipe. As a result, he creates three failed attempts to recreate different versions of the recipe.original medicine that fail to achieve the desired results.

Added: 128

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LethallyStupid: George. It's only thanks to ArtisticLicenseMedicine that the "medicine" he makes for Grandma doesn't kill her.



* SchmuckBait: Grandma sees a cup of what looks like tea in George's hands the day after she becomes a giant. She demands it immediately. George and his mother protest, but George's father tells her it's good tea. Grandma takes the cup and chugs it before learning she's just taken a massive overdose of George's Marvelous Medicine 4.

to:

* SchmuckBait: Grandma sees a cup of what looks like tea in George's hands the day after she becomes a giant. She demands it immediately. George and his mother protest, but George's father tells her it's good tea. Grandma takes the cup and chugs it before learning she's just taken a massive overdose of George's Marvelous Medicine 4.#4.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: It's very obvious that Dahl deliberately gave the eponymous medicine fantastical effects for the sake of writing a funny story. Nevertheless, modern editions include [[DoNotTryThisAtHome a warning]] that doing the same thing in RealLife would be LethallyStupid, lest there be at least one child [[ChildrenAreInnocent who would try to make the "medicine" themselves, thinking it would actually make people grow taller]].

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: It's very obvious that Dahl deliberately gave the eponymous medicine "medicine" fantastical effects for the sake of writing a funny story. Nevertheless, modern editions include [[DoNotTryThisAtHome a warning]] that doing the same thing in RealLife would be LethallyStupid, lest there be at least one child [[ChildrenAreInnocent who would try to make the "medicine" themselves, thinking it would actually make people grow taller]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: It's very obvious that Dahl deliberately gave the eponymous medicine fantastical effects for the sake of writing a funny story. Nevertheless, modern editions include a warning that doing the same thing in RealLife would be LethallyStupid, lest there be at least one child [[ChildrenAreInnocent who would try to make the "medicine" themselves, thinking it would actually make people grow taller]].

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: It's very obvious that Dahl deliberately gave the eponymous medicine fantastical effects for the sake of writing a funny story. Nevertheless, modern editions include [[DoNotTryThisAtHome a warning warning]] that doing the same thing in RealLife would be LethallyStupid, lest there be at least one child [[ChildrenAreInnocent who would try to make the "medicine" themselves, thinking it would actually make people grow taller]].

Top