Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / FriedGreenTomatoesAtTheWhistleStopCafe

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Café'' is a 1987 novel by Creator/FannieFlagg. It was adapted into the film ''Film/FriedGreenTomatoes'', which was released in 1991.

''Fried Green Tomatoes'' tells the story of two enduring friendships. The first, set in [[TheEighties the modern day]], is between Evelyn Couch, a dissatisfied, middle-age, menopausal housewife too frightened of death to commit suicide, and Ninny Threadgoode, a boisterous and talkative octogenarian who bolsters Evelyn's spirits with her storytelling. The story she tells is of another pair of women: incorrigible {{Tomboy}} and raconteur Idgie Threadgoode and sweet, stubborn SouthernBelle Ruth Jamison, who together ran a café in [[TheGreatDepression Depression-era]] [[TheDeepSouth Alabama]].

to:

''Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Café'' Cafe'' is a 1987 novel by Creator/FannieFlagg. It was adapted into the film ''Film/FriedGreenTomatoes'', which was released in 1991.

''Fried Green Tomatoes'' 'The novel tells the story of two enduring friendships. The first, set in [[TheEighties the modern day]], is between Evelyn Couch, a dissatisfied, middle-age, menopausal housewife too frightened of death to commit suicide, and Ninny Threadgoode, a boisterous and talkative octogenarian who bolsters Evelyn's spirits with her storytelling. The story she tells is of another pair of women: incorrigible {{Tomboy}} and raconteur Idgie Threadgoode and sweet, stubborn SouthernBelle Ruth Jamison, who together ran a café in [[TheGreatDepression Depression-era]] [[TheDeepSouth Alabama]].





Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He's a Klansman in the movie as well, as Idgie points out because she recognizes his shoes when he's in his robes, and when he says he "doesn't recognize" the Georgian Klansmen that show up in Whistle Stop. Apparently [[EvenEvilHasStandards Whistlestop Klansmen have different standards for how they treat black people than the Georgia ones]]. This would, however, have been subverted by a deleted scene. Idgie mentions offhandedly that she recognizes the "size fourteen clodhoppers" she believes Grady wears. In the deleted scene, Grady reveals the truth--his feet (and thus his shoes) are actually quite small, and thus he couldn't have been who Idgie saw in those robes.

to:

** He's a Klansman in the movie as well, as Idgie points out because she recognizes his shoes when he's in his robes, and when he says he "doesn't recognize" the Georgian Klansmen that show up in Whistle Stop. Apparently [[EvenEvilHasStandards Whistlestop Klansmen have different standards for how they treat black people than the Georgia ones]]. This would, however, have been subverted by a deleted scene.scene which was later inserted into the Extended Cut. Idgie mentions offhandedly that she recognizes the "size fourteen clodhoppers" she believes Grady wears. In the deleted scene, soon after the Georgia Klan comes to town and tortures Big George, Grady reveals the truth--his feet (and thus his shoes) are actually quite small, truth-- he doesn't wear size 14 and thus he couldn't have been who Idgie saw in those robes."doesn't much care for parades, bed sheets, or otherwise."

Added: 205

Changed: 408

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To most younger readers, who are brought up in a world where racial slurs are intolerable, the easy way that the characters in the book use the word "nigger" is very strange and highly offensive. Absolutely justified, though, as that was how people talked to black people in the early parts of the 20th century; even with people like Grady, who likes Big George and his family, but talks down to him when trying to look big in front of out-of-town police officers, or the Threadgoodes who consider Sipsey and Big George part of their family.

to:

** To most younger readers, who are brought up in a world where racial slurs are intolerable, the easy way that the characters in the book use the word "nigger" is very strange and highly offensive. Absolutely justified, though, as that was how people talked to black people in the early parts of the 20th century; even with people like Grady, who likes Big George and his family, but talks down to him when trying to look big in front of out-of-town police officers, or the Threadgoodes who consider Sipsey and Big George part of their family. Interestingly, Ninny continues to use the word "colored" to refer to black people in TheEighties, and no one ever corrects her or remonstrates with her over it.



* NeverGotToSayGoodbye: In the novel, Idgie and Stump were out collecting leaves and pinecones for Ruth's sick-room when she died.

to:

* TheMunchausen: Idgie loves invoking this [[{{Troll}} for fun]], inventing tall tales and making the details progressively more outlandish until only the most gullible of listeners wouldn't twig to the fact that she's making it all up.
* NeverGotToSayGoodbye: In the novel, Idgie and Stump were out collecting leaves and pinecones for Ruth's sick-room when she died. Also, [[spoiler: Evelyn was attending a weight-loss spa when Ninny died.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KevorkaMan: Artis Peavey is not particularly attractive, and he's usually down-and-out, spends his money on gambling and flashy clothes, and relies on women to support him. Fortunately for him, the ladies love him and will fight each other to be the one to take care of him.

to:

* KevorkaMan: KavorkaMan: Artis Peavey is not particularly attractive, and he's usually down-and-out, spends his money on gambling and flashy clothes, and relies on women to support him. Fortunately for him, the ladies love him and will fight each other to be the one to take care of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KevorkaMan: Artis Peavey is not particularly attractive, and he's usually down-and-out, spends his money on gambling and flashy clothes, and relies on women to support him. Fortunately for him, the ladies love him and will fight each other to be the one to take care of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CainAndAbel: Arguably deconstructed with Big George's twin boys Jasper and Artis. Jasper is born light-complected like his mother, while Artis is dark like his father. Throughout his life, Jasper is encouraged to mingle with only lighter-complected black people and to be deferential to white people. Jasper grows up hard-working, successful, and highly respectable, while Artis comes to resent his brother's advantage, leading him down a path of fast living, gambling, and crime. As children, Artis's resentment drives him to attack his brother with a penknife, while as adults, Jasper loves his brother but finds himself avoiding Artis due to Artis's unsavory lifestyle. The book none-too-subtly hints that the difference in the brothers' lives are due to the disparity in the way they were raised and the way their complexions are perceived by white society.

to:

* CainAndAbel: Arguably In the novel, deconstructed with Big George's twin boys Jasper and Artis. Jasper is born light-complected like his mother, while Artis is dark like his father. Throughout his life, Jasper is encouraged to mingle with only lighter-complected black people and to be deferential to white people. Jasper grows up hard-working, successful, and highly respectable, while Artis comes to resent his brother's advantage, leading him down a path of fast living, gambling, and crime. As children, Artis's resentment drives him Their relationship to attack his brother each other is likewise strained; however, when the novel revisits them as old men, Artis is light-hearted and dies with a penknife, smile on his face, while as adults, Jasper loves comes to realize his brother but finds himself avoiding Artis due to Artis's unsavory lifestyle. The book none-too-subtly hints that the difference in the brothers' lives are due to the disparity in the way they were raised and the way their complexions are perceived by white society.years of faithful service as a railroad porter has gained him very little; now even his own grandchildren look down on him for having been "deferential."



* StrawFeminist: Various purposefully comical stereotypes show up in Evelyn's time, and after getting caught up in the story, Evelyn herself becomes an aggressive female-empowerment activist for a while before calming down.

to:

* StrawFeminist: Various purposefully comical stereotypes show up in Evelyn's time, and after getting caught up in the story, Evelyn herself becomes an aggressive female-empowerment activist (under the nom de guerre "Tawanda") for a while before calming down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PoorCommunicationKills: Due to some ambiguous pronouns, Evelyn is devastated and furious when a nurse seems to callously tell her that Mrs. Threadgoode has died. She's also a little bit ''too'' happy when the nurse clarifies that it was Mrs. Threadgoode's ''roommate'' who died.

to:

* PoorCommunicationKills: Due to some ambiguous pronouns, Evelyn is devastated and furious when a nurse seems to callously tell her that Mrs. Threadgoode has died. She's also a little bit ''too'' happy when the a different nurse clarifies that it was Mrs. Threadgoode's ''roommate'' who died.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PoorCommunicationKills: Due to some ambiguous pronouns, Evelyn is devastated and furious when a nurse seems to callously tell her that Mrs. Threadgoode has died. She's also a little bit ''too'' happy when the nurse clarifies that it was Mrs. Threadgoode's ''roommate'' who died.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScaryBlackMan: Big George invokes this when he and Idgie help Ruth leave Frank. All he has to do to scare Frank out of interfering is stand there, be big, and core an apple.

to:

* ScaryBlackMan: Big George invokes this when he and Idgie help Ruth leave Frank. All he has to do to scare Frank out of interfering is stand there, be big, and core an apple. This comes back to bite him when [[spoiler:he's accused of Bennett's murder and the fact that George "threatened" him is introduced as evidence]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PsychoKnifeNut: At age 10, Artis stabs his brother Jasper and can't stop when he finds out how good it feels (thankfully it's only a pen knife and Jasper survives). Many years later, [[spoiler:when his brother Willie Boy is murdered, Artis [[{{Revenge}} tracks down the killer]] and cuts his heart out]].

to:

* PsychoKnifeNut: At age 10, Artis stabs his brother Jasper and can't stop when he finds out how good it feels (thankfully it's only a pen knife and Jasper survives). He also relieves his nerves in another scene by stabbing [[spoiler:Frank Bennett's corpse]]. Many years later, [[spoiler:when his brother Willie Boy is murdered, Artis [[{{Revenge}} tracks down the killer]] and cuts his heart out]].

Added: 768

Changed: 515

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ButtMonkey: Julian Threadgoode is the Butt Monkey of the Threadgoode family. Even the baby of the family, Idgie, takes advantage of his gullible nature and lack of smarts while they're growing up. [[spoiler: In spite of this, Julian and Idgie end up as companions in their old age.]]

to:

* ButtMonkey: Julian Threadgoode is the Butt Monkey of the Threadgoode family. Even the baby of the family, Idgie, takes advantage of his gullible nature and lack of smarts while they're growing up. [[spoiler: In [[spoiler:In spite of this, Julian and Idgie end up as companions in their old age.]]



* JustLikeRobinHood: Railroad Bill is a local outlaw who breaks into government railroad cars to steal supplies, which he throws off the train to down-and-out people suffering during the Depression. While there's quite a price on Railroad Bill's head, no one is too eager to see him caught, as his stealing saves lives. [[spoiler: Later on, adult Stump reveals that Railroad Bill was really Idgie in AshFace working in secret with the town sheriff.]]

to:

* JustLikeRobinHood: Railroad Bill is a local outlaw who breaks into government railroad cars to steal supplies, which he throws off the train to down-and-out people suffering during the Depression. While there's quite a price on Railroad Bill's head, no one is too eager to see him caught, as his stealing saves lives. [[spoiler: Later [[spoiler:Later on, adult Stump reveals that Railroad Bill was really Idgie in AshFace working in secret with the town sheriff.]]



** In the film, Idgie is played by Mary Stuart Masterson, who at 5'4" is significantly shorter than many of the full-grown men she stands up to. (Subverted in the novel, where Idgie's described as tall and lanky.)

to:

** In the film, Idgie is played by Mary Stuart Masterson, who at 5'4" is significantly shorter than many of the full-grown men she stands up to. (Subverted (Averted in the novel, where Idgie's described as tall and lanky.)



* PsychoKnifeNut: At age 10, Artis stabs his brother Jasper and can't stop when he finds out how good it feels (thankfully it's only a pen knife and Jasper survives). Many years later, [[spoiler:when his brother Willie Boy is murdered, Artis [[{{Revenge}} tracks down the killer]] and cuts his heart out]].



* RelatedInTheAdaptation: An odd but minor example: In the novel, the woman Ed and Evelyn visit in the nursing home is Ed's unnamed mother. In the film, they go to visit Ed's aunt Vesta Adcock. This is an interesting (if random) switcheroo, since in the novel, Vesta Adcock is a long-time resident of Whistle Stop whom Mrs. Threadgoode has known for many years, while in the film, they're only fellow nursing home residents and there's no evidence that they knew each other previously.

to:

* RelatedInTheAdaptation: RelatedInTheAdaptation:
**
An odd but minor example: In the novel, the woman Ed and Evelyn visit in the nursing home is Ed's unnamed mother. In the film, they go to visit Ed's aunt Vesta Adcock. This is an interesting (if random) switcheroo, since in the novel, Vesta Adcock is a long-time resident of Whistle Stop whom Mrs. Threadgoode has known for many years, while in the film, they're only fellow nursing home residents and there's no evidence that they knew each other previously.



* RightForTheWrongReasons: The prosecutor thinks that Idgie and Big George killed Frank Bennett [[spoiler:but Judge Smoote dismisses the case anyways. Unbeknownst to him, the real killer is Big George's mother Sipsey.]]

to:

* RightForTheWrongReasons: The prosecutor thinks that Idgie and Big George killed Frank Bennett [[spoiler:but Judge Smoote dismisses the case anyways.anyways, because it can't be proven and he hated Bennett. Unbeknownst to him, the real killer is Big George's mother Sipsey.]]

Added: 450

Changed: 79

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustLikeRobinHood: Railroad Bill is a local outlaw who breaks into government railroad cars to steal supplies, which he throws off the train to down-and-out people suffering during the Depression. While there's quite a price on Railroad Bill's head, no one is too eager to see him caught, as his stealing saves lives. [[spoiler: Later on, adult Stump reveals that Railroad Bill was really Idgie in AshFace working in secret with the town sheriff.]]



* KissingCousins: Ruth and Idgie in the novel (though they're related by marriage, not by blood, and it's never established to what degree they're cousins).

to:

* KissingCousins: Ruth and Idgie in the novel (though they're related by marriage, not by blood, and it's never established to what degree they're cousins). In the film, Ruth is the daughter of an old family friend of the Threadgoodes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DarkFeminineLightFeminine: Inverted. Both Idgie and Ruth are said to be attractive, but while Idgie is blonde and suntanned, she acts more like the Dark Feminine, with her sharp temper, wild ways, and dark secrets. Meanwhile, Ruth, a dark-eyed brunette in the film, is all sweetness, light, and honesty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ButtMonkey: Julian Threadgoode is the Butt Monkey of the Threadgoode family. Even the baby of the family, Idgie, takes advantage of his gullible nature and lack of smarts while they're growing up. [[spoiler: In spite of this, Julian and Idgie end up as companions in their old age.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HideYourLesbians: Between Idgie and Ruth. See also AmbiguouslyGay. Averted in the novel, where they are explicitly a couple.

to:

* HideYourLesbians: Between Idgie and Ruth. See also AmbiguouslyGay. Averted in the novel, where they are explicitly a couple. The town's newsletter even openly acknowledges their coparenting of Stump and regards Idgie and Ruth as a married couple in all but name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CainAndAbel: Arguably deconstructed with Big George's twin boys Jasper and Artis. Jasper is born light-complected like his mother, while Artis is dark like his father. Throughout his life, Jasper is encouraged to mingle with only lighter-complected black people and to be deferential to white people. Jasper grows up hard-working, successful, and highly respectable, while Artis comes to resent his brother's advantage, leading him down a path of fast living, gambling, and crime. The book none-too-subtly hints that the difference in the brothers' lives are due to the disparity in the way they were raised and the way their complexions are perceived by white society.

to:

* CainAndAbel: Arguably deconstructed with Big George's twin boys Jasper and Artis. Jasper is born light-complected like his mother, while Artis is dark like his father. Throughout his life, Jasper is encouraged to mingle with only lighter-complected black people and to be deferential to white people. Jasper grows up hard-working, successful, and highly respectable, while Artis comes to resent his brother's advantage, leading him down a path of fast living, gambling, and crime. As children, Artis's resentment drives him to attack his brother with a penknife, while as adults, Jasper loves his brother but finds himself avoiding Artis due to Artis's unsavory lifestyle. The book none-too-subtly hints that the difference in the brothers' lives are due to the disparity in the way they were raised and the way their complexions are perceived by white society.

Added: 1732

Changed: 569

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CainAndAbel: Arguably deconstructed with Big George's twin boys Jasper and Artis. Jasper is born light-complected like his mother, while Artis is dark like his father. Throughout his life, Jasper is encouraged to mingle with only lighter-complected black people and to be deferential to white people. Jasper grows up hard-working, successful, and highly respectable, while Artis comes to resent his brother's advantage, leading him down a path of fast living, gambling, and crime. The book none-too-subtly hints that the difference in the brothers' lives are due to the disparity in the way they were raised and the way their complexions are perceived by white society.



* PassFail: Examined. One of the novel's subplots involves Big George's granddaughter Clarissa, who is light-complected enough to shop in white department stores. Unaware that his niece is trying to pass, her dark-complected elderly uncle Artis hugs her in public (in Birmingham, Alabama, in the 1950s) while she refuses to acknowledge that they're related. Artis is violently ejected from the store, while Clarissa burns with shame over what she's done to him, but is unable to intervene, knowing she'll be even ''more'' violently ejected if the white employees realize they've been deceived.

to:

* PassFail: Examined. One of Examined at length in the novel's subplots involves novel.
**
Big George's granddaughter Clarissa, who light-skinned wife has twin sons: Jasper, who's as light as she is, and Artis, who's dark like his father. Throughout his life, Jasper is encouraged by his parents to associate with other light-skinned black people, gradually earning Artis's resentment as he realizes his twin's skin color opens doors that are closed to him. His parents realize the animosity between their sons but feel powerless to change things, knowing that this is the best way to give at least one of their sons an advantage in a segregated society.
** Jasper's daughter Clarissa
is light-complected enough to shop in white department stores. Unaware that his niece is trying to pass, her dark-complected elderly uncle Artis hugs her in public (in Birmingham, Alabama, in the 1950s) while she refuses to acknowledge that they're related. Artis is violently ejected from the store, while Clarissa burns with shame over what she's done to him, but is unable to intervene, knowing she'll be even ''more'' violently ejected if the white employees realize they've been deceived.

Top