Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Flashman

Go To

OR

Added: 919

Changed: 450

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainDowngrade: General Elphinstone gets one, funnily enough. While he was every bit as incompetent as portrayed by Flashman, his decision to basically hand himself over to Akbar Khan during the retreat is portrayed as merely being an act of colossal stupidity. In reality, Elphinstone [[DirtyCoward was fully aware of how much of a disaster the retreat was and was consciously abandoning his men in the hope he would be treated well by the Afghans]].

to:

* HistoricalVillainDowngrade: General Elphinstone HistoricalVillainDowngrade:
** ''Flashman and the Redskins'' accurately portrays George Armstrong Custer as a moron who got his entire command massacred through [[AttackAttackAttack suicidal overconfidence]], but his atrocities against Native Americans prior to this (including shooting mothers, children, and elders at Washita River and sexually abusing female captives, with men under his command having the saying "Indian women rape easy") are barely acknowledged except at the beginning when someone tries to bring them up to defend the Native Americans and
gets one, funnily enough. While he was every bit as incompetent as portrayed shouted down by Flashman, his decision to basically hand himself over to Akbar Khan during the retreat is portrayed as merely being an act of colossal stupidity. In reality, Elphinstone [[DirtyCoward was fully aware of how much of a disaster the retreat was and was consciously abandoning his men Flashman's AuthorTract.
** ''Flashman
in the hope he would be treated well by Great Game'' doesn't shy away from showing the Afghans]].extent of British reprisals against suspected rebels after the 1857 mutiny, with [[EvenEvilHasStandards even Flashman]] balking at some of the worst excesses; however, the widespread sexual violence committed against Indian women by British troops goes largely unmentioned.



* NobleSavage: Averted like all hell and mocked. Flashy finds them no better (but in many senses no worse) than the Europeans or the Americans, though he does admire individuals like the Yawner, [[spoiler: who would later become famous as Geronimo]], and Mangas Colorado. And [[NubileSavage Sonsee-array,]] [[TheCasanova of course.]]

to:

* NobleSavage: Averted like all hell and mocked. Flashy finds them no better (but in many senses no worse) than the Europeans or the Americans, though he does admire individuals like the Yawner, [[spoiler: who (who would later become famous as Geronimo]], Geronimo), and Mangas Colorado. And [[NubileSavage Sonsee-array,]] [[TheCasanova of course.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** An Apache brave in ''Flashman and the Redskins'' tries to ride down a baby with his horse after killing its mother; fortunately Flashman manages to shoot him before he can.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Indian rebels in ''Flashman and the Great Game'' view themselves as heroic freedom fighters battling against British oppression. All the British characters view them as bloodthirsty thugs massacring innocent white families out of a largely irrational hatred for the British. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality Since the British are the viewpoint side they are portrayed as right.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters: Discussed in ''Flashman and the Redskins''. The first chapter has Flashman get into an argument with a British intellectual who sees the Native Americans who fought against the United States as being brave patriots fighting against the brutal invasion of their land by white Americans, whereas Flashman knows from personal experience that they were just as brutal and just as likely to commit atrocities as their white enemies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleanup/renamed, cutting misuse and ZCEs.


* BloodBrothers: Ilderim Khan, a Pathan horseman, becomes this with Harry. Harry genuinely likes and admires the young man (after all, as he says, it takes a true coward to recognize courage), and is stunned to realize that [[spoiler:Ilderim was killed by rebels as a prisoner-of-war in the Sepoy Mutiny.]]
** Flashman also becomes a blood brother to Yakub Beg in ''Flashman at the Charge''.

Added: 1606

Changed: 261

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BetterManhandleTheMurderWeapon: Flashman in "Flashman on the March'', in which he [[spoiler:gets found standing over Emperor Tewodros/Theodore's body holding the gun with which he had just shot himself (he had picked it up to read the inscription on the gun butt). Fortunately this was what he had been ordered to do but was unwilling to go through with, so his superiors think he did the right thing and have it hushed up to protect his reputation.]]



** {{Subverted}} in "Flashman and the Tiger": [[spoiler:Flashman's about to pull one by killing Colonel Moran, only to realize he's being arrested for the murder of Ronald Adair]].

to:

** {{Subverted}} in "Flashman and the Tiger": [[spoiler:Flashman's about to pull one by killing Colonel Moran, only to realize he's being about to be arrested for the murder of Ronald Adair]].



* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: [[spoiler:John Sebastian Moran]] goes on one in ''Flashman and the Tiger'' against those who sold him into slavery, with victims including [[spoiler:John Charity Spring. Flashman]] is also targeted indirectly, which sets up the events of the story.

to:

* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: RoaringRampageOfRevenge:
** After the scalp-hunters (the same gang Creator/CormacMcCarthy portrayed in ''Literature/BloodMeridian'') have spent about a chapter of ''Flashman and the Redskins'' raping and slaughtering the Mimbreno, they decide to get their revenge and raid the gang's camp in the middle of the night, butcher everyone who fights back and kidnap all the survivors who don't manage to get away in time before having them FlayedAlive, with Flashman only being spared because he [[PetTheDog decided not to rape any of the captives]] when given the chance.
** ''Flashman on the March" depicts the RealLife retaliatory expedition undertaken by the British against Emperor Tewodros of Abyssinia for taking British subjects hostage, which Flashman manages to get roped into. [[spoiler:He ends up being thought to have killed Tewodros himself due to a case of BetterManhandleTheMurderWeapon (it was actually a suicide).]]
**
[[spoiler:John Sebastian Moran]] goes on one in ''Flashman and the Tiger'' against those who sold him into slavery, with victims including [[spoiler:John Charity Spring. Flashman]] is also targeted indirectly, which sets up the events of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** An example stemming from DatedHistory: both ''Great Game'' and the previous book, ''Flashman at the Charge'', depict the Russian Empire as plotting to annexe British India. This was believed to be the case at the time the books were written, but modern-day historians believe that, while some invasion plans were drawn up, none of them were ever implemented and no serious invasion attempts were ever made. In contrast to this, ''Flashman at the Charge'' has the Russian plan to attack India via Afghanistan, in reality never put into effect, actually being carried out and only being failing thanks to Flashman and Yakub Beg, whereas ''Flashman in the Great Game'' has the Russians, specifically Nikolay Ignatyev, orchestrating the 1857 rebellion to undermine the British, which there is no evidence actually happened.

to:

** An example stemming from DatedHistory: both ''Great Game'' and the previous book, ''Flashman at the Charge'', depict the Russian Empire as plotting to annexe British India. This was believed to be the case at the time the books were written, but modern-day historians believe that, while some invasion plans were drawn up, none of them were ever implemented and no serious invasion attempts were ever made. In contrast to this, ''Flashman at the Charge'' has the Russian plan to attack India via Afghanistan, in reality never put into effect, actually being carried out and only being failing thanks to Flashman and Yakub Beg, whereas ''Flashman in the Great Game'' has the Russians, specifically Nikolay Ignatyev, orchestrating the 1857 rebellion to undermine the British, which there is no evidence actually happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The ''Flashman'' novels by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser are a {{Picaresque}} series of adventures, starring Harry Flashman. They are presented as the memoirs of an infamous Victorian war hero who describes his adventures as a bully, rapist, lecher, backstabber, and [[DirtyCoward coward]]. The author had a fondness for RefugeInAudacity and strove to make his stories -- narrated by the eponymous rogue from the perspective of his comfortable retired life -- as deliciously offensive as possible.

to:

The ''Flashman'' novels by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser are a {{Picaresque}} series of adventures, starring Harry Flashman. They are presented as the memoirs of an infamous a famous Victorian war hero (with fourteen lines in ''Who's Who'') who describes his adventures as a bully, rapist, lecher, backstabber, [[TheBully bully]], [[SerialRapist rapist]], [[HandsomeLech lecher]], [[OpportunisticBastard backstabber]] and [[DirtyCoward coward]]. The author had a fondness for RefugeInAudacity BlackComedy and strove to make his stories -- narrated by the eponymous rogue from the perspective of his comfortable retired life -- as [[CrossesTheLineTwice deliciously offensive as possible.possible]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The character Flashman is taken from the Victorian novel ''Literature/TomBrownsSchooldays'', where he is presented without any redeeming qualities. He has ''almost'' no redeeming qualities in Fraser's books either, except for crystal-clear powers of observation and real affection for his wife Elspeth and his grandchildren and great-grandchildren. In fact, these last two are the only categories of people in the world he's prepared to risk his own life for. Like his latter-day literary child Literature/CiaphasCain, there is the occasional indication that Flashy doth protest too much and is braver than he thinks he is -- but unlike Cain, even if this is the case, cowardice is only one aspect of the bullying, self-centered, and misogynistic Flashy's awfulness. Of course, given the many military catastrophes and disasters of the nineteenth-century British Empire, frequently in the situations Flashy finds himself in "being a coward" also counts as "being the OnlySaneMan" (certainly, a certain George Armstrong Custer should have retreated when Flashman advised it).

The novels are extremely well-researched, and Flashman encounters pretty much anyone who was famous during the Victorian times, as well as living through most of the great political movements and scandals of the era.

to:

The character Flashman is taken from the Victorian novel ''Literature/TomBrownsSchooldays'', where he is presented without any redeeming qualities. He has ''almost'' no redeeming qualities in Fraser's books either, except for crystal-clear powers of observation and real affection for his wife Elspeth and his grandchildren and great-grandchildren. In fact, these last two are the only categories of people in the world he's prepared to risk his own life for. Like his latter-day literary child Literature/CiaphasCain, there is the occasional indication that Flashy doth protest too much and is braver than he thinks he is -- but unlike Cain, even if this is the case, cowardice is only one aspect of the [[UnsympatheticComedyProtagonist bullying, self-centered, and misogynistic Flashy's awfulness. awfulness]]. Of course, given the many military catastrophes and disasters cock-ups of the nineteenth-century British Empire, frequently in the situations Flashy finds himself in "being a coward" also counts as "being the OnlySaneMan" (certainly, a certain George Armstrong Custer should have retreated when Flashman advised it).

The novels are extremely well-researched, and Flashman [[BeenThereShapedHistory encounters pretty much anyone who was famous during the Victorian times, as well as living through most of the great political movements and scandals of the era.era]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: InUniverse, ''Flashman and the Angel of the Lord'' gives two different views of John Brown. Crixus of the Underground Railroad views him as a straightforward hero, whereas Flashman views him as an insane KnightTemplar. Interestingly, Fraser himself seems to take a third view of Brown as a WellIntentionedExtremist who was neither straightforwardly heroic nor totally delusional.

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: InUniverse, ''Flashman and the Angel of the Lord'' gives two different views of John Brown. Crixus of the Underground Railroad views him as a straightforward hero, whereas Flashman views him as an insane KnightTemplar.KnightTemplar and mass murderer. Interestingly, Fraser himself seems to take a third view of Brown as a WellIntentionedExtremist who was neither straightforwardly heroic nor totally delusional.



* ArtisticLicenseHistory: While Fraser is known for his careful research, he does occasionally slip. He portrays the Underground Railroad as much more organized and far-reaching than it was, and also invents a pre-1865 precursor of the UsefulNotes/KuKluxKlan.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: While Fraser is known for his careful research, he does occasionally slip. He portrays the Underground Railroad as much more organized and far-reaching than it was, and also invents a pre-1865 precursor of the UsefulNotes/KuKluxKlan. He also depicts the Indian Mutiny as having been orchestrated by the Russian Empire.

Added: 2044

Changed: 488

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiHero: Flashman is an UnscrupulousHero who cares only about himself and what he can get out of a situation.

to:

* AntiHero: Flashman is an UnscrupulousHero (at best) who cares only about himself and what he can get out of a situation.



* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Thomas Henry Kavanaugh is portrayed in ''Flashman in the Great Game'' as an incompetent bungler who got lost during his famous escape from Lucknow due to his own stubbornness and only made it to his destination because of Flashman's help. Lampshaded by Fraser, who suggests in the ending notes that Flashman [[UnreliableNarrator deliberately exaggerated]] Kavanaugh's negative qualities out of jealousy that his role in the escape didn't get as much recognition as Kavanaugh's.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
**
Thomas Henry Kavanaugh is portrayed in ''Flashman in the Great Game'' as an incompetent bungler who got lost during his famous escape from Lucknow due to his own stubbornness and only made it to his destination because of Flashman's help. Lampshaded by Fraser, who suggests in the ending notes that Flashman [[UnreliableNarrator deliberately exaggerated]] Kavanaugh's negative qualities out of jealousy that his role in the escape didn't get as much recognition as Kavanaugh's.
** Also lampshaded in the same book in the case of Lakshmibai, the Rani of Jhansi and a prominent leader of the 1857 mutiny. One of the book's footnotes admits that the claim she refused to protect British civilians in Jhansi from being murdered, although depicted as true in the book, has not been proven one way or the other in RealLife, and that she may have simply not been able to prevent the massacre due to the number of people involved. Fraser also admits that there is no evidence she murdered any of the envoys sent to request help by the Jhansi garrison as she is depicted doing in the book (although even InUniverse this particular claim is treated with scepticism, with Flashman not believing Ilderim when he tells him about it).
** An example stemming from DatedHistory: both ''Great Game'' and the previous book, ''Flashman at the Charge'', depict the Russian Empire as plotting to annexe British India. This was believed to be the case at the time the books were written, but modern-day historians believe that, while some invasion plans were drawn up, none of them were ever implemented and no serious invasion attempts were ever made. In contrast to this, ''Flashman at the Charge'' has the Russian plan to attack India via Afghanistan, in reality never put into effect, actually being carried out and only being failing thanks to Flashman and Yakub Beg, whereas ''Flashman in the Great Game'' has the Russians, specifically Nikolay Ignatyev, orchestrating the 1857 rebellion to undermine the British, which there is no evidence actually happened.

Added: 702

Changed: 886

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheDitz: Flashman's wife, Elspeth. As far as he knows. She does show reserves of amazing fortitude, though: in Madagascar, fleeing from mad Queen Ravonalova, a searching guard steps on her finger and breaks it--and she doesn't even cry out. In ''Flashman and the Redskins'' Harry comments on his wife's 'cold courage'.

to:

** Flashman's father-in-law Morrison is even more of an inveterate coward than Flashman, who at least makes an effort to look brave whereas Morrison starts screaming and crying at the slightest sign of danger. In ''Flash for Freedom'' he volunteers as a special constable to keep order during Chartist unrest, only to dither for as long as possible when the time comes to leave (not helped by Flashman rubbing in the possibility of violence or death as much as possible) before returning after only a few minutes pretending to have injured himself. In another book, the news that the government is investigating the conditions in mills such as his sees him cowering under his bedclothes for several days hiding from an imaginary mob of angry workers.
* TheDitz: Flashman's wife, Elspeth. As far as he knows. She does show reserves of amazing fortitude, though: in Madagascar, fleeing from mad Queen Ravonalova, Ranavalona, a searching guard steps on her finger and breaks it--and she doesn't even cry out. In ''Flashman and the Redskins'' Harry comments on his wife's 'cold courage'.


Added DiffLines:

* HoistByHisOwnPetard: As Flashman lampshades several times, by convincing the entire country that he's a brave patriot and war hero rather than an inveterate coward, he has also made himself Britain's go-to man for missions involving torture and agonizing death and ensured that he will be expected to throw himself into the fray whenever a war breaks out somewhere in the Empire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BoldInflation: Queen Victoria emphasizes every fifth word or so with italics. ''Very'' much [[JustifiedTrope justified by real life]], as evinced by Victoria's diaries.

to:

* BoldInflation: Queen Victoria emphasizes every fifth word or so with italics. ''Very'' much [[JustifiedTrope justified by real life]], as evinced evidenced by Victoria's diaries.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: InUniverse, Flashman is remembered as a great war hero and a paragon of British values when in reality he was an inveterate coward and lecher who conned his way into his reputation and whose "heroic acts" were mostly the result of luck making him look more heroic than he actually was (ironically, most of his few genuine acts of heroism, such as preventing a Russian invasion of India, are the ones [[TheGreatestStoryNeverTold no-one ever found out about]] during his lifetime).


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Thomas Henry Kavanaugh is portrayed in ''Flashman in the Great Game'' as an incompetent bungler who got lost during his famous escape from Lucknow due to his own stubbornness and only made it to his destination because of Flashman's help. Lampshaded by Fraser, who suggests in the ending notes that Flashman [[UnreliableNarrator deliberately exaggerated]] Kavanaugh's negative qualities out of jealousy that his role in the escape didn't get as much recognition as Kavanaugh's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Not to be confused with ''Series/ChoushinseiFlashman''. Or the robot master from ''VideoGame/MegaMan2''.

to:

Not to be confused with ''Series/ChoushinseiFlashman''. Or ''Series/ChoushinseiFlashman'', or the robot master from ''VideoGame/MegaMan2''.

Top