Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* EmptyShell: Cathy loves no one and has no desires, hobbies, personal likes or dislikes of her own, besides her willingness to manipulate and hurt anyone in her way for personal gain. When she runs away from home, her parents note that her room has no personal possessions in it, and looks like no one has lived there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 61 (click to see context) from:
* ParentalFavoritism: Cyrus prefers Adam over Charles - even though Charles loved his father while Adam did not. Adam [[spoiler:prefers Aron]]. Deconstructed by the second half of the novel. [[spoiler:Adam's favoritism of Aron makes him contribute to Aron's inability to face reality, including lying to him about his mother his entire life. It ultimately leads to Aron's death]].
to:
* ParentalFavoritism: Cyrus prefers Adam over Charles - even though Charles loved his father while Adam did not. Adam [[spoiler:prefers Aron]]. Deconstructed by the second half of the novel. [[spoiler:Adam's favoritism idealization of Aron makes leads him contribute to not recognize Aron's inability to face reality, including lying to moral sensitivity is preventing him about from being able to properly develop mentally. Thus, Aron is unable to handle the truth of his mother being Cathy and that Adam had lied to him, leading him to his entire life. It ultimately leads to Aron's death]].death in World War I]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 30 (click to see context) from:
** Implied to be the case with Aron. It's suggested that his image as the good son comes from years of studying his father and imitating him.
to:
** Implied to be the case with Aron. It's suggested that his image as the good son comes from years of studying his father and imitating him.him rather than being genuine. Considering how Aron appears to care very little about how his actions to find shelter would effect those around him (ex. him breaking off his relationship with Abra to go into religion [[spoiler:and going to fight in World War I]]), it might have some truth.
Changed line(s) 39,40 (click to see context) from:
* CutHimselfShaving: Cathy walks out on Adam Trask and leaves him the parting gift of a bullet in the shoulder. When the sheriff questions him, he says that the gun went off while he was cleaning it. Since Adam is a cavalry officer and a really bad liar, this doesn't really fly.
* DevilInPlainSight: Cathy in her early years, as many people are able to see or at least feel uneasy about the person she actually is.
* DevilInPlainSight: Cathy in her early years, as many people are able to see or at least feel uneasy about the person she actually is.
to:
* CutHimselfShaving: Cathy walks out on Adam Trask and leaves him the parting gift of a bullet in the shoulder. When the sheriff questions him, he says that the gun went off while he was cleaning it. Since Adam is a cavalry officer and a really bad liar, this doesn't really fly.
neither the deputy sheriff nor the sheriff are convinced.
* DevilInPlainSight: Cathy in her earlyyears, as many years. Nearly everyone perceptive of people are able to see or at least feel uneasy tell something's off about her even before she shoots her husband in the person she actually is.shoulder and abandons her sons.
* DevilInPlainSight: Cathy in her early
* {{DramaticIrony}}: Adam laments about Cal's lack of ambition compared to Aron who graduated early and is going to Stanford, even though the audience knows that Cal convinced Aron to graduate early, and Aron is only pursuing higher education as a way to escape reality. Not to mention that Cal is anything but lazy, as Lee points out to Adam when he hears the words.
Changed line(s) 43 (click to see context) from:
* EvilTwin: Deconstructed. Cal views himself as the bad twin and is convinced he'll never be anything else. In spite of this he still tries to change this perception of himself, and it's revealed that he's only this way because he's desperate for anyone to love him. It also shows the negative effect ParentalFavouritism has by propping one twin up as good and the other as bad.
to:
* EvilTwin: Deconstructed. Cal views himself as the bad twin and is convinced he'll never be anything else. In spite of this he still tries to change this perception of himself, and it's revealed that he's only this way because he's desperate for anyone to love him.him (which eventually happens by the end). It also shows the negative effect ParentalFavouritism has by propping one twin up as good and the other as bad.
Changed line(s) 49 (click to see context) from:
* GoMadFromTheRevelation: Aron runs off to enlist in the Army to get away from everyone.
to:
* GoMadFromTheRevelation: [[spoiler: Aron runs off to enlist in the Army to get away from everyone.everyone]].
* LoveMakesYouDumb: Adam with Cathy at first. The narrator remarks how Adam could not have realized Cathy's true nature is because he was seeing her in an ideal person rather than the actual Cathy.
Changed line(s) 64 (click to see context) from:
* SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan: Adam and Charles (who are actually described as having a relationship more similar to that of a sister and a brother), Aron and Cal.
to:
* SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan: Adam and Charles (who are actually described as having a relationship more similar to that of a sister and a brother), along with Aron and Cal.
Changed line(s) 66 (click to see context) from:
* SiblingTriangle: [[spoiler:Cathy marries Adam, but sleeps with his brother Charles]]. Later, [[spoiler: Aron's girlfriend Abra transfers her affections to Cal due to Aron's rejection of her and her own realizations of Aron not wanting to face reality]].
to:
* SiblingTriangle: [[spoiler:Cathy marries Adam, but sleeps with his brother Charles]]. Later, [[spoiler: Aron's girlfriend Abra transfers her affections to Cal due to Aron's rejection of her and her own realizations of Aron not wanting to face reality]].about Aron's character and how she and Cal are NotSoDifferent]].
Changed line(s) 69 (click to see context) from:
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictor of sorts, though Aron's status as one is a bit dubious since Aron takes his idealization to an extreme to wanting to find shelter from reality.
to:
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictor of sorts, though more so for Tom as Aron's status actions later in the novel can be viewed as one is a bit dubious since Aron takes his idealization to an extreme to wanting to find shelter from reality.selfishness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* LostInTranslation: Discussed. Lee while discussing the story of Cain and Abel with Adam and Samuel comments that different translations of the Bible change the tone of God's words to Cain involving overcoming sin. With some other scholars researching in the text's original Hebrew, Lee comes to the conclusion the more accurate word concerning how God tells Cain to face sin is ''timshel'', or that God gives human beings the choice to dictate their lives.
Changed line(s) 59 (click to see context) from:
* ParentalSubstitute: To a downplayed extent Lee is this toward Caleb due to his father preferring his brother Aron. He's the one who gives him advice throughout the novel and can see the better points of his character that Adam fails to recognize.
to:
* ParentalSubstitute: To a downplayed extent extent, Lee is this toward Caleb due to his father preferring his brother Aron. He's the one who gives him advice throughout the novel and can see the better points of his character that Adam fails to recognize.
Changed line(s) 68 (click to see context) from:
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictor of sorts, though Aron's status as one is debatable considering how much of his actions are driven by his desire to find shelter from reality.
to:
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictor of sorts, though Aron's status as one is debatable considering how much of a bit dubious since Aron takes his actions are driven by his desire idealization to an extreme to wanting to find shelter from reality.
Changed line(s) 79 (click to see context) from:
** How different? Well, it turns out that Lee and his Tong leaders have been studying ancient Hebrew in order to analyse a single word in Literature/TheBible.
to:
** How different? Well, it turns out that Lee and his Tong leaders have been studying ancient Hebrew in order to analyse a single word in Literature/TheBible.Literature/TheBible that changes the meaning of the statement it is in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 58 (click to see context) from:
* ParentalFavoritism: Cyrus prefers Adam over Charles - even though Charles loved his father while Adam did not. Adam [[spoiler:prefers Aron]].
to:
* ParentalFavoritism: Cyrus prefers Adam over Charles - even though Charles loved his father while Adam did not. Adam [[spoiler:prefers Aron]]. Deconstructed by the second half of the novel. [[spoiler:Adam's favoritism of Aron makes him contribute to Aron's inability to face reality, including lying to him about his mother his entire life. It ultimately leads to Aron's death]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 40 (click to see context) from:
* DevilInPlainSight: Cathy in her early years.
to:
* DevilInPlainSight: Cathy in her early years.years, as many people are able to see or at least feel uneasy about the person she actually is.
* ParentalSubstitute: To a downplayed extent Lee is this toward Caleb due to his father preferring his brother Aron. He's the one who gives him advice throughout the novel and can see the better points of his character that Adam fails to recognize.
Changed line(s) 64 (click to see context) from:
* SiblingTriangle: [[spoiler:Cathy marries Adam, but sleeps with his brother Charles]]. Later, [[spoiler: Aron's girlfriend Abra transfers her affections to Cal]].
to:
* SiblingTriangle: [[spoiler:Cathy marries Adam, but sleeps with his brother Charles]]. Later, [[spoiler: Aron's girlfriend Abra transfers her affections to Cal]].Cal due to Aron's rejection of her and her own realizations of Aron not wanting to face reality]].
Changed line(s) 67 (click to see context) from:
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictor of sorts.
to:
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictor of sorts.sorts, though Aron's status as one is debatable considering how much of his actions are driven by his desire to find shelter from reality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 54 (click to see context) from:
* MeaningfulName: Naming the boys Caleb and Aaron was after the Bible characters. In a counterpoint to the Cain and Abel sequence, it was Caleb and not Aaron who lived to reach the Promised Land, but because Caleb was one who hadn't sinned.
to:
* MeaningfulName: Naming the boys Caleb and Aaron was after the Bible characters. In a counterpoint to the Cain and Abel sequence, it was Caleb and not Aaron who lived to reach the Promised Land, but because Caleb was one who hadn't sinned.Land.
Added DiffLines:
** The original names suggested by Samuel for the twins were Caleb and Joshua, both whom were the only male Israelites of their generation permitted to enter Canaan. However, Adam didn't like the name Joshua due to the biblical Joshua being a warrior, so he changed it to Aaron instead. Samuel mentally notes how [[spoiler:Aaron never made it to Canaan unlike Caleb]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correcting minor errors.
Changed line(s) 41 (click to see context) from:
* DirectLineToTheAuthor[=/=]AutobiographicalRole: John Steinbeck himself as a young boy shows up in the novel as a minor character. Steinbeck is implied to have heard about and/or seen the events in the novel as he was growing up and simply wrote about them as an adult. The Hamiltons are indeed loosely based on author Steinbeck's own relatives but their lives are supposedly rather heavily fictionaluzed.
to:
* DirectLineToTheAuthor[=/=]AutobiographicalRole: John Steinbeck himself as a young boy shows up in the novel as a minor character. Steinbeck is implied to have heard about and/or seen the events in the novel as he was growing up and simply wrote about them as an adult. The Hamiltons are indeed loosely based on author Steinbeck's own relatives but their lives are supposedly rather heavily fictionaluzed.fictionalized.
Changed line(s) 44 (click to see context) from:
* {{Fauxreigner}}: When Lee first appears in the book, he sepaks in stereotypical YouNoTakeCandle fashion, but when a character comments he can't possibly talk like that all the time, he drops the act and speaks normally for the rest of the book.
to:
* {{Fauxreigner}}: When Lee first appears in the book, he sepaks speaks in stereotypical YouNoTakeCandle fashion, but when a character comments he can't possibly talk like that all the time, he drops the act and speaks normally for the rest of the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 9,10 (click to see context) from:
The book was adapted into a 1955 film, directed by Creator/EliaKazan and starring Creator/JamesDean in his breakout role as Cal. The film notably is a very loose adaptation, only covering the last part of the story with Aron and Cal as teenagers; this was approved by John Steinbeck. For tropes exclusive to the film, go [[Film/EastOfEden here]].
to:
The book was adapted into a [[Film/EastOfEden 1955 film, film]], directed by Creator/EliaKazan and starring Creator/JamesDean in his breakout role as Cal. The film notably is a very loose adaptation, only covering the last part of the story with Aron and Cal as teenagers; this was approved by John Steinbeck. For tropes exclusive to the film, go [[Film/EastOfEden here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 9,10 (click to see context) from:
The book was adapted to a 1955 film by Elia Kazan, starring James Dean in his breakout role. The film notably is a very loose adaptation, only covering the last part of the story with Aron and Cal as teenagers. This was approved by John Steinbeck. For tropes exclusive to the film, go [[Film/EastOfEden here]].
to:
The book was adapted to into a 1955 film film, directed by Elia Kazan, Creator/EliaKazan and starring James Dean Creator/JamesDean in his breakout role. role as Cal. The film notably is a very loose adaptation, only covering the last part of the story with Aron and Cal as teenagers. This teenagers; this was approved by John Steinbeck. For tropes exclusive to the film, go [[Film/EastOfEden here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Took out some stuff that was specific to the movie
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
* AllGirlsWantBadBoys: Subverted. Abra is initially put off by Cal's bad traits. It's not until she gets to know him that she takes an interest. She also loses interest in Aron once he starts showing that he's not as good as he seems.
to:
* AllGirlsWantBadBoys: Subverted. Abra is initially put off by Cal's bad traits. It's not until she gets to know him that she takes an interest. She also loses interest in Aron once he starts showing that he's not as good as he seems.
Changed line(s) 22 (click to see context) from:
* AmbiguouslyGay: In the book, Abra seems to suspect that Aron is gay, and his disinterest in Abra does develop along with his intense admiration of the pastor, Mr. Rolf.
to:
* AmbiguouslyGay: In the book, Abra seems to suspect that Aron is gay, and his disinterest in Abra does develop along with his intense admiration of the pastor, Mr. Rolf.
Changed line(s) 26 (click to see context) from:
* BatmanGambit: Cathy has a gift for seeing people's weaknesses and the sociopathy needed to manipulate them. It's a repeated theme through the book that she'll mention an idea, it will spread and become other people's beliefs, but no one will remember it originated from her. (Ex:'s The ministed who committed suicide had trouble in Boston, they should jar their own fruits at the whorehouse, etc.)
to:
* BatmanGambit: Cathy has a gift for seeing people's weaknesses and the sociopathy needed to manipulate them. It's a repeated theme through the book that she'll mention an idea, it will spread and become other people's beliefs, but no one will remember it originated from her. (Ex:'s The ministed minister who committed suicide had trouble in Boston, they should jar their own fruits at the whorehouse, etc.)
Deleted line(s) 34 (click to see context) :
* CallingTheOldManOut: Abra does this to Adam [[spoiler: after he had a stroke]] for his treatment of Cal.
Changed line(s) 37 (click to see context) from:
* TheClan: two for the price of one!
to:
* TheClan: two Two for the price of one!
Changed line(s) 47 (click to see context) from:
* ForTheEvulz: Apparently why Charles sleeps with Cathy on her and Adam's wedding night (even though he had been suspicious about her and warned Adam). When she tells Charles she gave Adam her painkiller-spiked tea accidentally-on-purpose, he merely laughs and says "That poor bastard."
to:
* ForTheEvulz: Apparently why Charles sleeps with Cathy on her and Adam's wedding night (even though he had been suspicious about her and warned Adam). When she tells Charles she gave Adam her painkiller-spiked tea accidentally-on-purpose, he merely laughs and says says, "That poor bastard."
Changed line(s) 50,51 (click to see context) from:
* GoMadFromTheRevelation: Aron. In the movie, [[spoiler:he smashes his head through the window of the train, laughing maniacally at Adam as it pulls away.]]
* GoodTwin: Deconstructed as well, though not the extent of EvilTwin. Aron is only considered good because he's "just like his father" and, while he shows kindness at various points, it's hinted that [[BeneathTheMask his image is all an act to win his father's approval]] (and outright confirmed in a deleted scene from the film).
* GoodTwin: Deconstructed as well, though not the extent of EvilTwin. Aron is only considered good because he's "just like his father" and, while he shows kindness at various points, it's hinted that [[BeneathTheMask his image is all an act to win his father's approval]] (and outright confirmed in a deleted scene from the film).
to:
* GoMadFromTheRevelation: Aron. In the movie, [[spoiler:he smashes his head through the window of the train, laughing maniacally at Adam as it pulls away.]]
* GoodTwin: Deconstructed as well, though not the extent of EvilTwin.Aron is only considered good because he's "just like his father" and, while he shows kindness at various points, it's hinted that [[BeneathTheMask his image is all an act runs off to win his father's approval]] (and outright confirmed enlist in a deleted scene the Army to get away from the film).everyone.
* GoodTwin: Deconstructed as well, though not the extent of EvilTwin.
Changed line(s) 80 (click to see context) from:
* TroubledButCute: Cal is an antisocial loner who believes himself to be the EvilTwin in comparison to his well-behaved brother Aron. Despite his oddness and mean-spirited attitude on occasion, all he wants is love from his father. This is reflected in Abra's attitude towards him; she at first finds him creepy, but then gets to spend time with him and sees he's NotSoDifferent. Also, being played by James Dean helps a lot.
to:
* TroubledButCute: Cal is an antisocial loner who believes himself to be the EvilTwin in comparison to his well-behaved brother Aron. Despite his oddness and mean-spirited attitude on occasion, all he wants is love from his father. This is reflected in Abra's attitude towards him; she at first finds him creepy, but then gets to spend time with him and sees he's NotSoDifferent. Also, being played by James Dean helps a lot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Abra is dairk-haired in the novel. Moving Spared by the Adaptation entry to film page.
Deleted line(s) 52 (click to see context) :
* HeroesWantRedheads: Abra is a redhead and has romantic attachments with both brothers.
Deleted line(s) 73 (click to see context) :
* SparedByTheAdaptation: [[spoiler: Aron is definitely killed in World War I in the book, and that is what causes Adam's stroke. The film shows the stroke happening as he enlists, and his fate is left ambiguous. Kate likewise commits suicide in the book but her fate is never said in the film. To a lesser extent, Adam is definitely dying by the end of the novel, but appears to be recovering from his stroke by the end of the film]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed duplicate entry
Deleted line(s) 17 (click to see context) :
* AsianSpeekeeEngrish: {{Subverted}} and {{deconstructed}}. Lee seems to be this, but is actually faking it to go along with white people's expectations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
[[quoteright:285:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ts_8270.jpeg]]
to:
Changed line(s) 6,7 (click to see context) from:
A 1952 novel by Creator/JohnSteinbeck, ''East of Eden'' was brought to the screen in 1955 by director Creator/EliaKazan with a cast headed by Creator/JamesDean (in the only one of his films to be released before his death).
to:
A 1952 novel by Creator/JohnSteinbeck, ''East of Eden'' was brought to considered the screen author's most ambitious work. The Hamilton family in 1955 by director Creator/EliaKazan with a cast headed by Creator/JamesDean (in the only one novel is based off that of Steinbeck's maternal grandfather. He considered it his films to be released before his death).
MagnumOpus.
Changed line(s) 10,11 (click to see context) from:
The Elia Kazan film notably is a very loose adaptation, only covering the last part of the story with Aron and Cal as teenagers. This was approved by John Steinbeck
to:
The book was adapted to a 1955 film by Elia Kazan Kazan, starring James Dean in his breakout role. The film notably is a very loose adaptation, only covering the last part of the story with Aron and Cal as teenagers. This was approved by John Steinbeck
Steinbeck. For tropes exclusive to the film, go [[Film/EastOfEden here]].
Deleted line(s) 18,19 (click to see context) :
* AdaptationDistillation: Director Elia Kazan decided to completely cut out the first two thirds of the book and just make the movie about the final third, which focuses on Adam's two sons as teenagers.
* AdaptationalHeroism: With the first two thirds of the novel cut out, Kate is far more sympathetic. In the novel, she's a murderess and arsonist as well as a ManipulativeBitch - who became the madam of the brothel by poisoning the original one. The film makes her seem more subtly tragic, even dropping hints that she regrets leaving her sons.
* AdaptationalHeroism: With the first two thirds of the novel cut out, Kate is far more sympathetic. In the novel, she's a murderess and arsonist as well as a ManipulativeBitch - who became the madam of the brothel by poisoning the original one. The film makes her seem more subtly tragic, even dropping hints that she regrets leaving her sons.
Changed line(s) 25 (click to see context) from:
* AlwaysIdenticalTwins: Subverted, at least in the film. Aron and Cal look alike but they're not identical. Aron is taller and has lighter hair.
to:
* AlwaysIdenticalTwins: Subverted, at least in the film. Aron and Cal look alike but they're not identical. Aron is taller and has lighter hair.
Changed line(s) 34 (click to see context) from:
** Implied to be the case with Aron in the film. A DeletedScene shows that his image as the good son comes from years of studying his father and imitating him.
to:
** Implied to be the case with Aron in the film. A DeletedScene shows Aron. It's suggested that his image as the good son comes from years of studying his father and imitating him.
Deleted line(s) 54 (click to see context) :
* GettingCrapPastTheRadar: Kate's place in the film is shown only as a saloon, with no mention of sex or depravity. But as the other characters talk about "what she is" and [[spoiler: Aron's ultimate horror at discovering it]] leaves no doubt that she's the madam of a brothel.
Changed line(s) 73 (click to see context) from:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." Others fall somewhere between Tom and Will. [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
to:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism:
** Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." Others fall somewhere between Tom and Will. [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
** Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." Others fall somewhere between Tom and Will. [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 20 (click to see context) from:
* AisianSpeekeeEngrish: {{Subverted}} and {{deconstructed}}. Lee seems to be this, but is actually faking it to go along with white people's expectations.
to:
* AisianSpeekeeEngrish: AsianSpeekeeEngrish: {{Subverted}} and {{deconstructed}}. Lee seems to be this, but is actually faking it to go along with white people's expectations.
Changed line(s) 29 (click to see context) from:
* AwesomenessByAnaylsis: Charles, Cal, Abra, and especially Cathy are gifted at this, reading and manipulating the people around them to frightening effect.
to:
* AwesomenessByAnaylsis: AwesomenessByAnalysis: Charles, Cal, Abra, and especially Cathy are gifted at this, reading and manipulating the people around them to frightening effect.
Changed line(s) 31 (click to see context) from:
* BeserkerTears: Discussed—one of Cal's favorite hobbies is to tease and taunt his twin brother Aron. But he always makes sure not to take it too far, for if Aron starts crying, he becomes violent and dangerous to deal with.
to:
* BeserkerTears: BerserkerTears: Discussed—one of Cal's favorite hobbies is to tease and taunt his twin brother Aron. But he always makes sure not to take it too far, for if Aron starts crying, he becomes violent and dangerous to deal with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 8,9 (click to see context) from:
The novel concerns two families, the Trasks and the Hamiltons, who live in Salinas Valley, California. The Hamiltons, headed by patriarch Samuel Hamilton and wife Liza, initially settle into the valley with their nine kids. When the kids set out to seek their fortunes, the land is settled by the wealthy Adam Trask. The Trask family grows, adding a wife, Cathy, a DevilInPlainSight, and sons Cal and Aron. Just after the birth of the two sons, Cathy vanishes from their lives. Years later, the now-grown boys meet a girl named Abra, whose presence drives a wedge between the two.
to:
The novel concerns two families, the Trasks and the Hamiltons, who live in the Salinas Valley, California. The Hamiltons, headed by patriarch Samuel Hamilton and wife Liza, initially settle into the valley with their nine kids. When the kids set out to seek their fortunes, the land is settled by the wealthy Adam Trask. The Trask family grows, adding a wife, Cathy, a DevilInPlainSight, and sons Cal and Aron. Just after the birth of the two sons, Cathy vanishes from their lives. Years later, the now-grown boys meet a girl named Abra, whose presence drives a wedge between the two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AisianSpeekeeEngrish: {{Subverted}} and {{deconstructed}}. Lee seems to be this, but is actually faking it to go along with white people's expectations.
* AlliterativeTitle
* AllLoveIsUnrequited: The story revolves around this trope, but with love in the general sense: father/son and brother/brother in addition to romance.
* AwesomenessByAnaylsis: Charles, Cal, Abra, and especially Cathy are gifted at this, reading and manipulating the people around them to frightening effect.
* BatmanGambit: Cathy has a gift for seeing people's weaknesses and the sociopathy needed to manipulate them. It's a repeated theme through the book that she'll mention an idea, it will spread and become other people's beliefs, but no one will remember it originated from her. (Ex:'s The ministed who committed suicide had trouble in Boston, they should jar their own fruits at the whorehouse, etc.)
* BeserkerTears: Discussed—one of Cal's favorite hobbies is to tease and taunt his twin brother Aron. But he always makes sure not to take it too far, for if Aron starts crying, he becomes violent and dangerous to deal with.
* BatmanGambit: Cathy has a gift for seeing people's weaknesses and the sociopathy needed to manipulate them. It's a repeated theme through the book that she'll mention an idea, it will spread and become other people's beliefs, but no one will remember it originated from her. (Ex:'s The ministed who committed suicide had trouble in Boston, they should jar their own fruits at the whorehouse, etc.)
* BeserkerTears: Discussed—one of Cal's favorite hobbies is to tease and taunt his twin brother Aron. But he always makes sure not to take it too far, for if Aron starts crying, he becomes violent and dangerous to deal with.
* BondageIsBad: Kate, who works at a whorehouse, starts using chains and whips and razors on her "customers." This is coming from the same lady who killed both of her parents, shot her husband, and left her twin babies after telling her husband that he should throw them in a well.
* ChineseLaborer: Lee, a Chinese cook and valet (also a stereotype at one time in California), has a horrible backstory about how his mother disguised herself as a man so she could live and work alongside his father on the railroad, hiding her pregnancy when it came about, until the day she gave birth. Her husband wasn't nearby to help her, and when the other workers realized there was a woman in their midst they basically gang-raped her to death.
* CreatorCameo: Given that the story is partly about his family, Steinbeck himself appears a few times in the book, mainly in one intercalary chapter explaining one of his Uncles. But it's most notable that he has a scene where Adam Trask shows up to his mother's house to speak with his Grandma, and they meet as John Steinbeck and his sister stand behind their mother.
* CruelAndUnusualDeath: A character's mother get gangraped so brutally that she survives only long enough for someone to, quote, "claw (her son) from the mangled meat of his mother."
* CutHimselfShaving: Cathy walks out on Adam Trask and leaves him the parting gift of a bullet in the shoulder. When the sheriff questions him, he says that the gun went off while he was cleaning it. Since Adam is a cavalry officer and a really bad liar, this doesn't really fly.
* CruelAndUnusualDeath: A character's mother get gangraped so brutally that she survives only long enough for someone to, quote, "claw (her son) from the mangled meat of his mother."
* CutHimselfShaving: Cathy walks out on Adam Trask and leaves him the parting gift of a bullet in the shoulder. When the sheriff questions him, he says that the gun went off while he was cleaning it. Since Adam is a cavalry officer and a really bad liar, this doesn't really fly.
* {{Fauxreigner}}: When Lee first appears in the book, he sepaks in stereotypical YouNoTakeCandle fashion, but when a character comments he can't possibly talk like that all the time, he drops the act and speaks normally for the rest of the book.
* FilleFatale: Cathy tricks boys into tying her up and fooling around with her at the age of '''10''', only to practice her ability to manipulate people. And this is only the first in a long life of shocking deeds…
* FilleFatale: Cathy tricks boys into tying her up and fooling around with her at the age of '''10''', only to practice her ability to manipulate people. And this is only the first in a long life of shocking deeds…
* JacobAndEsau: The story relies heavily on the Cain/Abel, Jacob/Esau motif throughout its entirety. There are two sets of brothers: Adam and Charles and then Aron and Cal (sons of Adam and a crazy maniacal whore named Cathy). Adam and Aron = Jacob/Abel, Charles and Cal = Esau/Cain. Adam and Aron are good boys who take after their dads. Charles and Cal are more...unstable and tend to flirt with evil, taking after their mothers.
* LiteraryAllusionTitle: From Genesis 4:16.
* MajoredInWesternHypocrisy: Subverted and dissected. Lee is a graduate of UC Berkeley and a California native speaking fluent English, although he plays the role of an AsianSpeekeeEngrish much of the time. However, he is firm in belief that he is ultimately an American, not a Chinese, having found himself to be even more of stranger in China than in United States.
* LiteraryAllusionTitle: From Genesis 4:16.
* MajoredInWesternHypocrisy: Subverted and dissected. Lee is a graduate of UC Berkeley and a California native speaking fluent English, although he plays the role of an AsianSpeekeeEngrish much of the time. However, he is firm in belief that he is ultimately an American, not a Chinese, having found himself to be even more of stranger in China than in United States.
* MissKitty: Cathy kills her mentor, who is one of these, and then takes over her brothel and becomes a completely vicious version of this trope.
Changed line(s) 50 (click to see context) from:
* RomanAClef: the Hamilton sections are based heavily on Steinbeck's maternal family history.
to:
* PlayingBothSides: Caleb takes part with his businessman friend Will in war profiteering, buying beans for two cents a pound over fair market value, establishing a monopoly, then selling those beans for more than ten cents a pound over market value several weeks later in the heat of UsefulNotes/WorldWarOne.
* RomanAClef:the The Hamilton sections are based heavily on Steinbeck's maternal family history.
* RomanAClef:
Changed line(s) 60,61 (click to see context) from:
* SurprisinglyGoodEnglish: Lee.
* ThemeInitials
* ThemeInitials
to:
* StrangerInAFamiliarLand: Deconstructed. Seeing Lee's struggles in trying to fit in, Sam Hamilton suggests perhaps he might go " back" to China. Lee reminds him that he was born in Grass Valley, CA, grew up in California, and went to University of California, and he DID try going to China, only to find that he fit in less there than he did in the States because things changed so much since his father's time.
* SurprisinglyGoodEnglish:Lee.
Lee speaks perfect Engrish when he's first hired, but that soon is revealed to be a ruse; Lee speaks perfectly good English, but he found it ran so counter to people's preconceptions that the only way he could be accepted in American society was to conform to the stereotype.
*ThemeInitialsThemeInitials: This is a Cain and Abel story where the brothers are named Caleb and Aaron, with their father and uncle respectively named Adam and Charles. Also, Adam's wife is named Cathy.
* ThemeTwinNaming: The story book depicts the relationship with two brothers (not twins) named Charles and [[AdamAndOrEve Adam]]. When Adam's twin sons are born, he considers actually naming them Cain and Abel, but a neighbor tells him [[WhatDidYouExpectWhenYouNamedIt that would be asking for trouble]]. He goes with [[ThemeInitials Caleb (Cal) and Aaron (Aron)]] instead. Of course, the relationship repeats anyway.
* TheTriadsAndTheTongs: The YellowPeril variant is referenced, and averted when Lee tells Adam and Samuel about going for help to his "family association".
-->'''Samuel:''' "I have heard of them."\\
'''Lee:''' "You mean Chinee hatchet man fightee Tong war over slave girl? It's a little different from that, really."
** How different? Well, it turns out that Lee and his Tong leaders have been studying ancient Hebrew in order to analyse a single word in Literature/TheBible.
* TroubledButCute: Cal is an antisocial loner who believes himself to be the EvilTwin in comparison to his well-behaved brother Aron. Despite his oddness and mean-spirited attitude on occasion, all he wants is love from his father. This is reflected in Abra's attitude towards him; she at first finds him creepy, but then gets to spend time with him and sees he's NotSoDifferent. Also, being played by James Dean helps a lot.
* SurprisinglyGoodEnglish:
*
* ThemeTwinNaming: The story book depicts the relationship with two brothers (not twins) named Charles and [[AdamAndOrEve Adam]]. When Adam's twin sons are born, he considers actually naming them Cain and Abel, but a neighbor tells him [[WhatDidYouExpectWhenYouNamedIt that would be asking for trouble]]. He goes with [[ThemeInitials Caleb (Cal) and Aaron (Aron)]] instead. Of course, the relationship repeats anyway.
* TheTriadsAndTheTongs: The YellowPeril variant is referenced, and averted when Lee tells Adam and Samuel about going for help to his "family association".
-->'''Samuel:''' "I have heard of them."\\
'''Lee:''' "You mean Chinee hatchet man fightee Tong war over slave girl? It's a little different from that, really."
** How different? Well, it turns out that Lee and his Tong leaders have been studying ancient Hebrew in order to analyse a single word in Literature/TheBible.
* TroubledButCute: Cal is an antisocial loner who believes himself to be the EvilTwin in comparison to his well-behaved brother Aron. Despite his oddness and mean-spirited attitude on occasion, all he wants is love from his father. This is reflected in Abra's attitude towards him; she at first finds him creepy, but then gets to spend time with him and sees he's NotSoDifferent. Also, being played by James Dean helps a lot.
Added DiffLines:
* VillainsOutShopping: Cathy goes to church to see her son be an altar boy, and reads ''Alice in Wonderland''.
* WalkingTheEarth: Adam walks the earth for several years after leaving the Army-he doesn't have much want or need to return home.
* WhatIsThisThingYouCallLove: Cathy spends most of her life thinking of herself as superior to everyone else because she's so much smarter and prettier. After meeting Caleb, she realizes that none of that matters because everyone else around her can do ''something'' that she can't do. She never quite figures out what that thing is, but she still senses that nothing else is worth taking pride in without this one undefinable ability. [[AlasPoorVillain She ends up killing herself because even though she can't figure out what it is she can't do, she still understands that it's the only thing that makes life worth living.]]
* WalkingTheEarth: Adam walks the earth for several years after leaving the Army-he doesn't have much want or need to return home.
* WhatIsThisThingYouCallLove: Cathy spends most of her life thinking of herself as superior to everyone else because she's so much smarter and prettier. After meeting Caleb, she realizes that none of that matters because everyone else around her can do ''something'' that she can't do. She never quite figures out what that thing is, but she still senses that nothing else is worth taking pride in without this one undefinable ability. [[AlasPoorVillain She ends up killing herself because even though she can't figure out what it is she can't do, she still understands that it's the only thing that makes life worth living.]]
Added DiffLines:
* YouNoTakeCandle: Lee speaks "Chinee" until a white man observes how very odd it is that no one Chinese ever speaks good English, whereupon he reveals it's intentional, for those who expect it. He was in fact born in the United States and has lived his entire life there. He only reveals his true fluency and personality to people he trusts. He switches to standard English with his employer while the employer is suffering HeroicBSOD.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 36 (click to see context) from:
* ElectiveBrokenEnglish: Lee pretends to speak English in stereotypical AsianSpeekeeEngrish fashion.
to:
* ElectiveBrokenEnglish: ElectiveBrokenLanguage: Lee pretends to speak English in stereotypical AsianSpeekeeEngrish fashion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ElectiveBrokenEnglish: Lee pretends to speak English in stereotypical AsianSpeekeeEngrish fashion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 6,7 (click to see context) from:
A 1952 novel by Creator/JohnSteinbeck, ''East of Eden'' was brought to the screen in 1955 by director Creator/EliaKazan with a cast headed by Creator/JamesDean.
to:
A 1952 novel by Creator/JohnSteinbeck, ''East of Eden'' was brought to the screen in 1955 by director Creator/EliaKazan with a cast headed by Creator/JamesDean.
Creator/JamesDean (in the only one of his films to be released before his death).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 6,7 (click to see context) from:
A 1952 novel by Creator/JohnSteinbeck, ''East of Eden'' was brought to the screen in 1955 by director Creator/EliaKazan with a cast headed by JamesDean.
to:
A 1952 novel by Creator/JohnSteinbeck, ''East of Eden'' was brought to the screen in 1955 by director Creator/EliaKazan with a cast headed by JamesDean.
Creator/JamesDean.
The Elia Kazan film notably is a very loose adaptation, only covering the last part of the story with Aron and Cal as teenagers. This was approved by John Steinbeck
* AdaptationalHeroism: With the first two thirds of the novel cut out, Kate is far more sympathetic. In the novel, she's a murderess and arsonist as well as a ManipulativeBitch - who became the madam of the brothel by poisoning the original one. The film makes her seem more subtly tragic, even dropping hints that she regrets leaving her sons.
* AllGirlsWantBadBoys: Subverted. Abra is initially put off by Cal's bad traits. It's not until she gets to know him that she takes an interest. She also loses interest in Aron once he starts showing that he's not as good as he seems.
* AlwaysIdenticalTwins: Subverted, at least in the film. Aron and Cal look alike but they're not identical. Aron is taller and has lighter hair.
* AlwaysIdenticalTwins: Subverted, at least in the film. Aron and Cal look alike but they're not identical. Aron is taller and has lighter hair.
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
* BitchInSheepsClothing: Cathy until she inherits Faye's brothel and no longer has to hide her real personality.
to:
* BitchInSheepsClothing: BitchInSheepsClothing:
** Cathy until she inherits Faye's brothel and no longer has to hide her realpersonality.personality.
** Implied to be the case with Aron in the film. A DeletedScene shows that his image as the good son comes from years of studying his father and imitating him.
* BrokenPedestal: [[spoiler: Aron had always imagined his mother as a saint or a wholesome woman in some way. Discovering that she's actually the madam of a brothel devastates him]].
** Cathy until she inherits Faye's brothel and no longer has to hide her real
** Implied to be the case with Aron in the film. A DeletedScene shows that his image as the good son comes from years of studying his father and imitating him.
* BrokenPedestal: [[spoiler: Aron had always imagined his mother as a saint or a wholesome woman in some way. Discovering that she's actually the madam of a brothel devastates him]].
* EvilTwin: Deconstructed. Cal views himself as the bad twin and is convinced he'll never be anything else. In spite of this he still tries to change this perception of himself, and it's revealed that he's only this way because he's desperate for anyone to love him. It also shows the negative effect ParentalFavouritism has by propping one twin up as good and the other as bad.
* GettingCrapPastTheRadar: Kate's place in the film is shown only as a saloon, with no mention of sex or depravity. But as the other characters talk about "what she is" and [[spoiler: Aron's ultimate horror at discovering it]] leaves no doubt that she's the madam of a brothel.
* GoodTwin: Deconstructed as well, though not the extent of EvilTwin. Aron is only considered good because he's "just like his father" and, while he shows kindness at various points, it's hinted that [[BeneathTheMask his image is all an act to win his father's approval]] (and outright confirmed in a deleted scene from the film).
* HeroesWantRedheads: Abra is a redhead and has romantic attachments with both brothers.
* HeroesWantRedheads: Abra is a redhead and has romantic attachments with both brothers.
Changed line(s) 39 (click to see context) from:
* SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan: Adam and Charles (who are actually described as having a relatonship more similar to that of a sister and a brother), Aron and Cal.
to:
* SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan: Adam and Charles (who are actually described as having a relatonship relationship more similar to that of a sister and a brother), Aron and Cal.
Added DiffLines:
* SparedByTheAdaptation: [[spoiler: Aron is definitely killed in World War I in the book, and that is what causes Adam's stroke. The film shows the stroke happening as he enlists, and his fate is left ambiguous. Kate likewise commits suicide in the book but her fate is never said in the film. To a lesser extent, Adam is definitely dying by the end of the novel, but appears to be recovering from his stroke by the end of the film]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The narrator of the book explicitly identifies himself as being the John Steinbeck mentioned.
Changed line(s) 27 (click to see context) from:
* DirectLineToTheAuthor[=/=]AutobiographicalRole: John Steinbeck himself as a young boy shows up in the novel as a minor character, or at least a young boy named John Steinbeck who is the grandson of Samuel Hamilton, son of Ernest and Olive (nee Hamilton) Steinbeck (names of author's actual grandfather and parents), does. Steinbeck is implied to have heard about and/or seen the events in the novel as he was growing up and simply wrote about them as an adult. The Hamiltons are indeed loosely based on author Steinbeck's own relatives but their lives are supposedly rather heavily fictionaluzed.
to:
* DirectLineToTheAuthor[=/=]AutobiographicalRole: John Steinbeck himself as a young boy shows up in the novel as a minor character, or at least a young boy named John Steinbeck who is the grandson of Samuel Hamilton, son of Ernest and Olive (nee Hamilton) Steinbeck (names of author's actual grandfather and parents), does.character. Steinbeck is implied to have heard about and/or seen the events in the novel as he was growing up and simply wrote about them as an adult. The Hamiltons are indeed loosely based on author Steinbeck's own relatives but their lives are supposedly rather heavily fictionaluzed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cathy is a psychopath, but a fully human one.
Deleted line(s) 38 (click to see context) :
* Satan: Cathy, complete with hoof-like feet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 43 (click to see context) from:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." Others fall between Tom and Will. [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
to:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." Others fall somewhere between Tom and Will. [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 43 (click to see context) from:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
to:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." Others fall between Tom and Will. [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 44 (click to see context) from:
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictors of sorts.
to:
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictors DoomedMoralVictor of sorts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 43 (click to see context) from:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]][[spoiler:inverted in that the ultimate protagonists of the story are the cynical but realistic survivors like Cal, notwithstanding Steinbeck's own preferences.]]
to:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]][[spoiler:inverted in that the ultimate protagonists of the story are the cynical but realistic survivors like Cal, notwithstanding Steinbeck's own preferences.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 43 (click to see context) from:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
to:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]]][[spoiler:inverted in that the ultimate protagonists of the story are the cynical but realistic survivors like Cal, notwithstanding Steinbeck's own preferences.]]
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictors of sorts.
** The Cal and Aron mirror Will and Tom to an extent. Will and Cal work well together, being both practical and business-minded. Both Aron and Tom wind up as DoomedMoralVictors of sorts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 43 (click to see context) from:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist, even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
to:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist, WideEyedIdealist with "ideas coming out of his ears," even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 43 (click to see context) from:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist, even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves Uncle Tom he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]
to:
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: Members of the Hamilton clan. Sam is a WideEyedIdealist, while Liza is a cynic. Of their children, Tom is another WideEyedIdealist, even more so than his father, while Will is a cynic who "never had any ideas" and thus "the only one in the family who made any money." [[AuthorTract John loves his Uncle Tom but he doesn't seem to like Uncle Will much.]]