Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / BookOfJonah

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is the one with the whale]].[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]

to:

The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is the one with the whale]].whale.[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is [[TheOneWith The One With The Whale]].[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]

to:

The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is [[TheOneWith The One With The Whale]].the one with the whale]].[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Then again, ancient cultures like the Hebrews categorized animals based on their habitat rather than their evolutionary line.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PetTheDog: Compared to the wrathful God associated with most of the Old Testament, God here is incredibly benevolent to Nineveh despite their evil, even defying AMillionIsAStatistic by saying he cares for everyone in the city.

to:

* PetTheDog: Compared to the wrathful God associated with most of the Old Testament, God here is incredibly benevolent to Nineveh despite their evil, even defying AMillionIsAStatistic by saying he cares for everyone in the city.city, up to and including the cows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
'No Ending' amending

Added DiffLines:

** Ostensibly Jonah did finally learn his lesson. Who else would have written such a frank and unflattering portrayal of Jonah, other than Jonah himself?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* EatenAlive: Pretty much. Jonah winds up swallowed by the Great Fish when he's thrown overboard. However, this was more a form of rescue via DivineIntervention than with the fish getting a meal, and it vomits him back onto dry land three days later.

to:

* EatenAlive: Pretty much. Jonah winds up swallowed by the Great Fish when he's thrown overboard. However, this was more a form of rescue via DivineIntervention than with the fish getting a meal, and it vomits him back onto dry land three days later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EatenAlive: Pretty much. Jonah winds up swallowed by the Great Fish when he's thrown overboard. However, this has more to do with a DeusExMachina rescue than with the fish getting a meal, and it vomits him back onto dry land three days later.

to:

* EatenAlive: Pretty much. Jonah winds up swallowed by the Great Fish when he's thrown overboard. However, this has was more to do with a DeusExMachina form of rescue via DivineIntervention than with the fish getting a meal, and it vomits him back onto dry land three days later.



* GettingEatenIsHarmless: Jonah comes out not much the worse for wear after spending three days inside the fish's stomach. Of course, [[DeusExMachina divine intervention]] is a factor.

to:

* GettingEatenIsHarmless: Jonah comes out not much the worse for wear after spending three days inside the fish's stomach. Of course, [[DeusExMachina divine intervention]] {{divine intervention}} is a factor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatTheHellHero / TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: One delivered by God has got to hurt. Specifically, God chews out Jonah for caring more about his shade plant than all the people of Nineveh, which God specially points out includes those who don't know right from left and much cattle. Essentially, thousands of innocent children and animals.

to:

* WhatTheHellHero / TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: WhatTheHellHero: One delivered by God has got to hurt. Specifically, God chews out Jonah for caring more about his shade plant than all the people of Nineveh, which God specially points out includes those who don't know right from left and much cattle. Essentially, thousands of innocent children and animals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jonah's three days in the whale were ultimately for a good purpose, since he was saved from death as well as allowed to continue living and preaching the message of God, but was nevertheless painful, unpleasant, and someone no one in their right mind would want to go through. Sound familiar?

to:

** Jonah's three days in the whale were ultimately for a good purpose, since he was saved from death as well as allowed to continue living and preaching the message of God, but was nevertheless painful, unpleasant, and someone something no one in their right mind would want to go through. Sound familiar?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/1102016064_univ_lsr_xl.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:What a lovely day for a swim!]]

Added: 260

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

-----
!!Structure of the book:
* Jonah's call, his attempt to flee, and his sacrifice (Jonah chapter 1)
* Jonah's song in the belly of the great fish (Jonah chapter 2)
* Jonah preaches to Nineveh (Jonah chapter 3)
* Jonah is taught a lesson by God (Jonah chapter 4)

-----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Every single person in the city of Nineveh starts repenting when they hear Jonah's message, and the king decrees that everyone should fast and wear sackcloth-- [[UpToEleven even the animals]].

to:

** Every single person in the city of Nineveh [[HeelFaceTown Nineveh]] starts repenting when they hear Jonah's message, and the king decrees that everyone should fast and wear sackcloth-- [[UpToEleven even the animals]].

Added: 175

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EgocentricallyReligious: {{Deconstructed}}. The {{Aesop}} of the story is that Jonah is wrong to be more concerned with God's favor to him personally than with the repentance of the tens of thousands of people in Nineveh.

to:

* EgocentricallyReligious: {{Deconstructed}}. The {{Aesop}} of the story is that Jonah is wrong to be more concerned with God's favor to him personally about God providing for his personal comfort than with about the repentance fate of the tens of thousands of people in Nineveh.


Added DiffLines:

* ThwartedEscape: Jonah, RefusingTheCall, books passage as far as possible in the opposite direction from Nineveh. Turns out, it's not that easy to escape from TheOmnipotent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HappilyEverBefore: Nineveh may have repented now, but eventually the city becomes wicked again, as God declares in the Book of Isaiah that now he ''will'' destroy it. (The prophetic book of Nahum also spells doom for Nineveh.) Plus, Assyria became the conqueror of the northern kingdom of Israel.

to:

* HappilyEverBefore: Nineveh may have repented now, but eventually the city becomes wicked again, as God declares in the Book of Isaiah that now he ''will'' destroy it. (The prophetic [[Literature/BookOfNahum book of Nahum Nahum]] also spells doom for Nineveh.) Plus, Assyria became the conqueror of the northern kingdom of Israel.

Added: 496

Changed: 298

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeelFaithTurn: Jonah's prayer in Chapter 2 is a widely cited example of repentance, notably used in the [[UsefulNotes/{{Judaism}} Jewish liturgy]] for [[UsefulNotes/JewishHolidays Yom Kippur]]. However, in-story Jonah had a few more lessons to learn about compassion for others even after he repented for himself.

to:

* HeelFaithTurn: HeelFaithTurn:
**
Jonah's prayer in Chapter 2 is a widely cited example of repentance, notably used in the [[UsefulNotes/{{Judaism}} Jewish liturgy]] for [[UsefulNotes/JewishHolidays Yom Kippur]]. However, in-story Jonah had a few more lessons to learn about compassion for others even after he repented for himself.himself.
** Every single person in the city of Nineveh starts repenting when they hear Jonah's message, and the king decrees that everyone should fast and wear sackcloth-- [[UpToEleven even the animals]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeusExMachina: Our hero just got himself thrown overboard? How fortunate that there happens to be a giant fish right there to rescue him!


Added DiffLines:

* EatenAlive: Pretty much. Jonah winds up swallowed by the Great Fish when he's thrown overboard. However, this has more to do with a DeusExMachina rescue than with the fish getting a meal, and it vomits him back onto dry land three days later.


Added DiffLines:

* GodIsGood: Far from being eager to smite evildoers, the Almighty gives Jonah a second chance when he definitely didn't deserve it, then spares the entire city of Nineveh when they repent. He even takes the time to teach Jonah AnAesop about mercy and compassion.


Added DiffLines:

* HeelFaithTurn: Jonah's prayer in Chapter 2 is a widely cited example of repentance, notably used in the [[UsefulNotes/{{Judaism}} Jewish liturgy]] for [[UsefulNotes/JewishHolidays Yom Kippur]]. However, in-story Jonah had a few more lessons to learn about compassion for others even after he repented for himself.


Added DiffLines:

* PrayerIsALastResort: Inside the fish, Jonah prays in repentance, noting that it took him going to the bottom of the ocean before he realized he needed to change his ways. God gives him a second chance anyway.


Added DiffLines:

* SeaMonster: This would be a more accurate translation of the Hebrew ''dag gadol'', literally "great fish," which can mean any type of giant sea creature in general. It ''could'' mean "whale," [[CommonKnowledge but not exclusively]].

Added: 154

Changed: 61

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GettingEatenIsHarmless: Jonah comes out not much the worse for wear after spending three days inside the fish's stomach.

to:

* GettingEatenIsHarmless: Jonah comes out not much the worse for wear after spending three days inside the fish's stomach. Of course, [[DeusExMachina divine intervention]] is a factor.
** Subverted in, off all places, [[https://www.chick.com/reading/tracts/0289/0289_01.asp a Chick Tract.]] Jonah is covered in acid burns when he gets out.

Added: 211

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GettingEatenIsHarmless: Jonah comes out not much the worse for wear after spending three days inside the fish's stomach.



* SwallowedWhole: Yep, you remember the part where Jonah meets the Great Fish.

to:

* SwallowedWhole: Yep, you remember the part where Jonah meets the Great Fish.Fish...
* TooSpicyForYogSothoth: After three days, the Great Fish pukes Jonah out onto dry land.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SwallowedWhole: Yep, you remember the part where Jonah meets the Great Fish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Expanded the comparison between Jonah's 3 days in the whale and Christ's 3 days in the grave.

Added DiffLines:

** Jonah's three days in the whale were ultimately for a good purpose, since he was saved from death as well as allowed to continue living and preaching the message of God, but was nevertheless painful, unpleasant, and someone no one in their right mind would want to go through. Sound familiar?

Added: 540

Removed: 606

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BellyOfTheWhale: TropeNamer, although here it's an UnbuiltTrope (see below).



* CantRefuseTheCallAnymore: "In the belly of a whale" is often used to refer to a period in a story where the protagonist is caught in a situation with no hope. However, in the story of Jonah the whale is actually ''not'' a punishment but God's way of saving Jonah from drowning. It also represented him giving Jonah a second chance by taking him back to land. Note, though, that the Bible itself compares being in the whale as a trial, when Christ compares the three days in the whale with his upcoming three days dead before resurrection.



* UnbuiltTrope: "In the belly of a whale" is often used to refer to a period in a story where the protagonist is caught in a situation with no hope. However, in the story of Jonah the whale is actually ''not'' a punishment but God's way of saving Jonah from drowning. It also represented him giving Jonah a second chance by taking him back to land. Note, though, that the Bible itself compares being in the whale as a trial, when Christ compares the three days in the whale with his upcoming three days dead before resurrection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HappilyEverBefore: Nineveh may have repented now, but eventually the city becomes wicked again, as God declares in the Book of Isaiah that now he ''will'' destroy it. Plus, Assyria became the conqueror of the northern kingdom of Israel.

to:

* HappilyEverBefore: Nineveh may have repented now, but eventually the city becomes wicked again, as God declares in the Book of Isaiah that now he ''will'' destroy it. (The prophetic book of Nahum also spells doom for Nineveh.) Plus, Assyria became the conqueror of the northern kingdom of Israel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SelfDefeatingProphecy: Jonah's prophecy that Nineveh will be destroyed frightens the Ninevites into repenting, and since they repent, God has mercy and decides not to destroy them. Significantly, Jonah reveals that he was GenreSavvy enough to know that this was God's plan all along, and he ran away because he didn't want the Ninevites to be spared. God calls him out for not wanting mercy for his enemies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Literature/BooksOfKings In the reign of Jeroboam II]], the Lord speaks to his prophet Jonah ben Ammitai, telling him to go to the capital of the Assyrian Empire, Nineveh. The city's wickedness will be punished with destruction if they persist, but God wants Jonah to give them a warning so they have a chance to repent. However, Jonah doesn't want to go to Ninevah, as they had a reputation for being extremely cruel, and instead flees his mission on a voyage to Tarshish in Gaul (Spain!)

to:

[[Literature/BooksOfKings In the reign of Jeroboam II]], the Lord speaks to his prophet Jonah ben Ammitai, telling him to go to the capital of the Assyrian Empire, Nineveh. The city's wickedness will be punished with destruction if they persist, but God wants Jonah to give them a warning so they have a chance to repent. However, Jonah doesn't want to go to Ninevah, Nineveh, as they had a reputation for being extremely cruel, and instead flees his mission on a voyage to Tarshish in Gaul (Spain!)



* WhatTheHellHero / TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: One delivered by God has got to hurt. Specifically, God chews out Jonah for caring more about his shade plant than all the people of Ninevah, which God specially points out includes those who don't know right from left and much cattle. Essentially, thousands of innocent children and animals.

to:

* WhatTheHellHero / TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: One delivered by God has got to hurt. Specifically, God chews out Jonah for caring more about his shade plant than all the people of Ninevah, Nineveh, which God specially points out includes those who don't know right from left and much cattle. Essentially, thousands of innocent children and animals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse. It\'s Genre Savvy, not just \"savvy\".


* EitherOrProphecy: Sort of. The people of Nineveh are GenreSavvy enough to hear "God will smite you for your evil" as "Repent or be destroyed". The prophet himself didn't catch it, and complains.

to:

* EitherOrProphecy: Sort of. The people of Nineveh are GenreSavvy clever enough to hear "God will smite you for your evil" as "Repent or be destroyed". The prophet himself didn't catch it, and complains.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is {{The One With}} The Whale.[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]

to:

The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is {{The [[TheOneWith The One With}} With The Whale.Whale]].[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is [[TheOneWith The One With]] The Whale.[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]

to:

The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is [[TheOneWith The {{The One With]] With}} The Whale.[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is TheOneWith The Whale.[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]

to:

The Book of Jonah comes from [[Literature/TheBible the Old Testament]] and is grouped with the Minor Prophets. This is TheOneWith [[TheOneWith The One With]] The Whale.[[note]]Which in the original Hebrew is just called "great fish", using a generic word for "fish" that can refer to anything from a shark to a salmon.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SkewedPriorities: Called out by God in the closing words. Notably, Jonah is so angry about the plant's death that ''HE'' wants to die. Yet he cared nothing about letting thousands of Ninevites die.

to:

* SkewedPriorities: Called out by God in the closing words. Notably, Jonah is so angry about the plant's death that ''HE'' wants to die. Yet he cared nothing about letting thousands of Ninevites die. See YankTheDogsChain though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Literature/BooksOfKings In the reign of Jeroboam II]], the Lord speaks to his prophet Jonah ben Ammitai, telling him to go to the capital of the Assyrian Empire, Nineveh. The city's wickedness will be punished with destruction if they persist, but God wants Jonah to give them a warning so they have a chance to repent. However, Jonah doesn't want the Ninevites to be forgiven, and instead flees his mission on a voyage to Tarshish in Gaul (Spain!)

to:

[[Literature/BooksOfKings In the reign of Jeroboam II]], the Lord speaks to his prophet Jonah ben Ammitai, telling him to go to the capital of the Assyrian Empire, Nineveh. The city's wickedness will be punished with destruction if they persist, but God wants Jonah to give them a warning so they have a chance to repent. However, Jonah doesn't want the Ninevites to be forgiven, go to Ninevah, as they had a reputation for being extremely cruel, and instead flees his mission on a voyage to Tarshish in Gaul (Spain!)

Top