Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / AliBabaAndTheFortyThieves

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: The robbers cut Kasim's body into four parts.

to:

* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: The More like quarter the man he used to be, as the robbers cut Kasim's body into four parts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking Dismembering The Body.

Added DiffLines:

* DismemberingTheBody: When Ali Baba went looking for his brother, Cassim, he went to the Forty Thieves' hideout where he last told of his brother of their wealth. He discovered his body quartered at the entrance, where he returned him home in pieces. He tried to keep his death a secret, recruiting his brother's slave, Morgiana, in helping him hide the body.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
My bad. I thought for certain that letter was supposed to be in lowercase. That was really stupid of me.


* HypercompetentSidekick: Ali Baba's slave girl Morgiana singlehandedly thwarts all the thieves' attempts on his life before he even realizes he's in danger.

to:

* HypercompetentSidekick: HyperCompetentSidekick: Ali Baba's slave girl Morgiana singlehandedly thwarts all the thieves' attempts on his life before he even realizes he's in danger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FamilyUnfriendlyDeath: In order to infiltrate Ali-Baba's house the chief bandit poses as an oil merchant and hides his men in large oil jars. (One of the jars actually does contain oil, to keep up the ruse). When Morgiana discovers the hiding bandits, she dispatches them all with boiling oil.

to:

* FamilyUnfriendlyDeath: In order to infiltrate Ali-Baba's Ali Baba's house the chief bandit poses as an oil merchant and hides his men in large oil jars. (One of the jars actually does contain oil, to keep up the ruse). When Morgiana discovers the hiding bandits, she dispatches them all with boiling oil.



* HyperCompetentSidekick: Ali Baba's slave girl Morgiana singlehandedly thwarts all the thieves' attempts on his life before he even realizes he's in danger.

to:

* HyperCompetentSidekick: HypercompetentSidekick: Ali Baba's slave girl Morgiana singlehandedly thwarts all the thieves' attempts on his life before he even realizes he's in danger.



* SparedByTheAdaptation: In the original tale Kasim is killed by the titular thieves after they discover him in their cave. The thieves themselves are all dead by the end of the tale. Kid-friendly adaptations typically spare Kasim by having him simply imprisoned by the thieves (and later rescued by Ali Baba), while the thieves end up in jail rather than dead.

to:

* SparedByTheAdaptation: In the original tale tale, Kasim is killed by the titular thieves after they discover him in their cave. The thieves themselves are all dead by the end of the tale. Kid-friendly adaptations typically spare Kasim by having him simply imprisoned by the thieves (and later rescued by Ali Baba), while the thieves end up in jail rather than dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AreWeThereYet: When the robbers are hiding in oil jars, on the order of their chief, they hear Morgiana approach, thinking she is the robber chief, and one of them asks "is it time?". She replies in a deep voice "Not now, soon." All the robbers do this in turn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Contralto Of Danger has been disambiguated


* InnocentSoprano: In the Soviet musical adaptation, Ali Baba's wife, TheIngenue Zainab, has a very high voice, in contrast to the ContraltoOfDanger of Kasim's savvier and less scrupulous wife Fatima.

to:

* InnocentSoprano: In the Soviet musical adaptation, Ali Baba's wife, TheIngenue Zainab, has a very high voice, in contrast to the ContraltoOfDanger contralto of Kasim's savvier and less scrupulous wife Fatima.

Added: 155

Removed: 714

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetization.


* GoodIsDumb: Ali Baba is so incredibly dutiful and virtuous that he completely misses several attempts on his life until Morgiana has already foiled them.



* GoodIsDumb: Ali Baba is so incredibly dutiful and virtuous that he completely misses several attempts on his life until Morgiana has already foiled them.



* SiblingYinYang: Kasim is greedy and impetuous; Ali Baba is prudent and patient. Kasim's vices lead to his downfall; Ali Baba's virtues keep his family prosperous (though he still would have been toast without Morgiana).
* SisterhoodEliminatesCreep: In some versions, Ali Baba's wife Zainab and Qasim's widow Fatima take Morgiana's role. Zainab gets the robber chief Hassan drunk and Fatima kills him. Technically, there are thirty-eight more robbers, but they are such idiots that Fatima disposes of them within seconds, and only Hassan is really dangerous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


"Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves" is a story from the ''Literature/ArabianNights'' originally written by Syrian Maronite writer Hanna Diyab.

to:

"Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves" is a story from the ''Literature/ArabianNights'' originally written composed by Syrian Maronite writer Hanna Diyab.



Although the story is best-known as part of the ''Arabian Nights'', and is one of the best-known stories from the ''Arabian Nights'', it was originally written by Syrian Maronite writer Hanna Diyab in the early 18th century. Diyab had recounted the story to Antoine Galland, the French translator, at Galland's request, who went on to include the story in the ''Thousand and One Nights'' without crediting him. This theft was exposed when Diyab's autobiography was found in 1993 and greatly expanded our understanding of some of the most popular tales from the collection such as "Literature/{{Aladdin}}" (which Diyab is also the original author of).

to:

Although the story is best-known as part one of the ''Arabian Nights'' and is probably the best-known one along with "Literature/{{Aladdin}}", they were not part of the earliest ancient Arabic versions. Since there are no Arabic sources for them predating the 1704 French translation ''The Thousand and One Nights'', and is one of the best-known stories from the ''Arabian Nights'', it was they were both most likely originally written composed by Syrian Maronite writer Hanna Diyab in the early 18th century. Diyab had recounted the story these stories and a number of other ones upon request to Antoine Galland, the French translator, at Galland's request, translator of the 1704 edition, who went on to include the story them in the ''Thousand and One Nights'' his translation without crediting him. Diyab. This theft was exposed when Diyab's autobiography was found in 1993 1993, and finally translated and published in full in 2015, and greatly expanded our understanding of some of the most popular tales from the collection such as "Literature/{{Aladdin}}" (which Diyab is also the original author of).
collection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: The robbers cut Kasim's body into four parts

to:

* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: The robbers cut Kasim's body into four partsparts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Some interpretations say" violates Examples Are Not Arguable. "is basically this" makes a Zero Context Example.


* AdoptAServant: Some interpretations say that Morgiana was basically this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdoptAServant: Some interpretations say that Morgiana was basically this.

Added: 361

Removed: 362

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixed alphabetization error


* SparedByTheAdaptation: In the original tale Kasim is killed by the titular thieves after they discover him in their cave. The thieves themselves are all dead by the end of the tale. Kid-friendly adaptations typically spare Kasim by having him simply imprisoned by the thieves (and later rescued by Ali Baba), while the thieves end up in jail rather than dead.



* SparedByTheAdaptation: In the original tale Kasim is killed by the titular thieves after they discover him in their cave. The thieves themselves are all dead by the end of the tale. Kid-friendly adaptations typically spare Kasim by having him simply imprisoned by the thieves (and later rescued by Ali Baba), while the thieves end up in jail rather than dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SparedByTheAdaptation: In the original tale Kasim is killed by the titular thieves after they discover him in their cave. The thieves themselves are all dead by the end of the tale. Kid-friendly adaptations typically spare Kasim by having him simply imprisoned by the thieves (and later rescued by Ali Baba), while the thieves end up in jail rather than dead.

Added: 109

Changed: 124

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Although the story is best-known as part of the ''Arabian Nights'', and is one of the best-known stories from the ''Arabian Nights'', it was originally written by Syrian Maronite writer Hanna Diyab in the early 18th century. Diyab had recounted the story to Antoine Galland, the French translator, at Galland's request and went on to include them in the ''Thousand and One Nights'' without crediting him. This theft was exposed when Diyab's autobiography was found in 1993 and greatly expanded our understanding of some of the most popular tales from the collection such as Literature/{{Aladdin}} (which Diyab is also the original author of).

to:

Although the story is best-known as part of the ''Arabian Nights'', and is one of the best-known stories from the ''Arabian Nights'', it was originally written by Syrian Maronite writer Hanna Diyab in the early 18th century. Diyab had recounted the story to Antoine Galland, the French translator, at Galland's request and request, who went on to include them the story in the ''Thousand and One Nights'' without crediting him. This theft was exposed when Diyab's autobiography was found in 1993 and greatly expanded our understanding of some of the most popular tales from the collection such as Literature/{{Aladdin}} "Literature/{{Aladdin}}" (which Diyab is also the original author of).



* RichSiblingPoorSibling: Ali Baba and Kassim are sons of a merchant but while Kassim grew up to be a greedy merchant with a wealthy wife, Ali Baba is a woodcutter and marries a poor wife. However, when Ali Baba struck luck of finding a thieves' hideout and took some of the wealth, Kassim demand the location of the hideout. This ended up getting him killed when the thieves found him in their hideout.

to:

* RichSiblingPoorSibling: Ali Baba and Kassim are sons of a merchant but while Kassim grew up to be a greedy merchant with a wealthy wife, Ali Baba is a woodcutter and marries a poor wife. However, when Ali Baba struck luck of finding a thieves' hideout and took some of the wealth, Kassim demand demands the location of the hideout. This ended up getting him killed when the thieves found him in their hideout.



* SpellMyNameWithAnS: Depending on the version of the story, Ali Baba's brother is either spelled "Kasim", "Cassim", or "Kasym".

to:

* SpellMyNameWithAnS: SpellMyNameWithAnS:
**
Depending on the version of the story, Ali Baba's brother is either spelled "Kasim", "Cassim", or "Kasym".



* StupidEvil: The Forty Thieves are obsessed with finding Ali Baba to silence him, and just don't know when to quit. They spend a fortune to find the place (as the tailor gets smart and charges a larger fee each time) two of them are killed by the leader for messing up, and when they finally ''do'' find his house, ''all'' of them but the leader are killed in the attempt. But the leader ''still'' doesn't give up, and his final attempt gets ''him'' killed. Relocating and setting up shop elsewhere may have been the smart thing, but they clearly lacked smarts.

to:

* StupidEvil: The Forty Thieves are obsessed with finding Ali Baba to silence him, and just don't know when to quit. They spend a fortune to find the place (as the tailor gets smart and charges a larger fee each time) time), two of them are killed by the leader for messing up, and when they finally ''do'' find his house, ''all'' of them but the leader are killed in the attempt. But the leader ''still'' doesn't give up, and his final attempt gets ''him'' killed. Relocating and setting up shop elsewhere may have been the smart thing, but they clearly lacked smarts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RichSiblingPoorSibling: Ali Baba and Kassim are sons of a merchant but while Kassim grew up to be a greedy merchant with a wealthy wife, Ali Baba is a woodcutter and marries a poor wife. However, when Ali Baba struck luck of finding a thieves' hideout and took some of the wealth, Kassim demand the location of the hideout. This ended up getting him killed when the thieves found him in their hideout.

Top