Follow TV Tropes

Following

History JerkWithAHeartOfGold / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Drake from ''DrakeAndJosh'' has his moments, contrasting to the JerkWithAHeartOfJerk sister, Megan.

to:

* Drake Parker from ''DrakeAndJosh'' has his moments, contrasting to the hia JerkWithAHeartOfJerk sister, Megan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Alex P. Keaton from ''FamilyTies'' dreams of reaching the top of the corporate ladder and being rich -- and he often acts pompous about his intelligence. His views also sometimes appear sexist and he often appears to hold a certain contempt for people who lack intelligence and/or wealth. However, he has shown many times that he truly is a lovable and compassionate person -- and his good buddy is [[ExtrovertedNerd Skippy Handelman]].

to:

* Alex P. Keaton from ''FamilyTies'' dreams of reaching the top of the corporate ladder and being rich -- and he often acts pompous about his intelligence. His views also sometimes appear sexist and he often appears to hold a certain contempt for people who lack intelligence and/or wealth. However, he has shown many times that he truly is a lovable and compassionate person -- and his good buddy is [[ExtrovertedNerd [[ExtravertedNerd Skippy Handelman]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ted also meanders into this trope sometimes, though from the other direction: he's often a NiceGuy, but even during the times when he acts like more of a douche than a nice guy, he's ''always'' a caring, loyal friend, and usually snaps out of his JerkAss behavior when he actually ''realizes'' that he's behaving badly.

to:

** Ted also meanders into this trope sometimes, though from the other direction: he's often a NiceGuy, Robin likewise is extremely tactless, insensitive, sarcastic, blunt, emotionally stunted, and prone to ruthlessly mocking everyone around her, but even during the times when he acts like more of a douche than a nice guy, he's ''always'' a caring, loyal friend, cares deeply for her friends and has a secret soft side that she usually snaps out of his JerkAss behavior when he actually ''realizes'' that he's behaving badly.keeps hidden.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* Dr. {{Frasier}} Crane, likewise, is a pompous, self-righteous, overbearing and snobby jackass who nevertheless genuinely loves and cares for his family and friends, is devoted to psychiatry and his patients, and is deep down ruled by an inner need to be liked. His brother [[TheNiles Niles]] is similar — less arrogant and self-righteous than Frasier, but even more snooty and viciously sarcastic, who nevertheless demonstrates genuinely decent redeeming qualities similar to those of his brother, and his love for Daphne frequently brings out his sweet side.

to:

* Dr. {{Frasier}} Crane, likewise, is a pompous, self-righteous, overbearing and snobby jackass who nevertheless genuinely loves and cares for his family and friends, is devoted to psychiatry and his patients, and is deep down ruled by an inner need to be liked. His brother [[TheNiles [[ReplacementFlatCharacter Niles]] is similar — less arrogant and self-righteous than Frasier, but even more snooty and viciously sarcastic, who nevertheless demonstrates genuinely decent redeeming qualities similar to those of his brother, and his love for Daphne frequently brings out his sweet side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Nick in ''[[NewGirl]]'' may qualify. He's incredibly cynical and likes to watch his friends insanity unfold around him but doesn't really do anything Jerkish. He seems to consider Jess one of his closest friends and appears to really like her quirks. Overall it is made quite clear throughout the series that Nick is a really good guy who has simply endured a lot of misfortune and unhappiness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Sister Evangelina in CallTheMidwife. Grumpy, hot tempered and disapproving, she a great midwife and a dirt-poor backstory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Axl on The Middle

Added DiffLines:

* Axl on ''TheMiddle''. Underneath the [[BrattyTeenageDaughter Bratty Teenage Son]] exterior, he's twice helped his sister out in ways she'd never be aware of, despite the many times he's called her a dork and similar things to her face (although once he did call her a "[[{{Determinator}} dork optimist]]" as a compliment. He's also been shown as very willing to help out Brick, his younger brother, with schoolwork.
**In "[[HalloweenEpisode Halloween II]]" persuaded his friends to abandon their original plan to steal candy when they encountered some little kids who'd had their candy stolen, and instead they got the kids their candy back. When a college football recruiter visited, we saw that he could be very polite and charming.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{House}}'': Dr. Gregory House threatens to get into this during his PetTheDog moments, particularly when he was diagnosed with cancer and still insisted on focusing on the patient. As always, it turned out he was just a [[JerkWithAHeartOfJerk Jerk With The Heart Of An Even Bigger Jerk]] than we had assumed -- [[spoiler:he faked having cancer so he could get his hands on the perscription drugs, although to be fair, his team only "found out" he was sick by snooping around behind his back]].

to:

* ''{{House}}'': ''Series/{{House}}'': Dr. Gregory House threatens to get into this during his PetTheDog moments, particularly when he was diagnosed with cancer and still insisted on focusing on the patient. As always, it turned out he was just a [[JerkWithAHeartOfJerk Jerk With The Heart Of An Even Bigger Jerk]] than we had assumed -- [[spoiler:he faked having cancer so he could get his hands on the perscription drugs, although to be fair, his team only "found out" he was sick by snooping around behind his back]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[DrJerk Dr. Owen Harper]] from ''{{Torchwood}}'', gaining his heart of gold mainly during season two. Especially in ''Fragments''.

to:

* [[DrJerk Dr. Owen Harper]] from ''{{Torchwood}}'', ''Series/{{Torchwood}}'', gaining his heart of gold mainly during season two. series 2. Especially in ''Fragments''."Fragments".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Dr. Morris from ''ER'' starts off as a DrJerk, but matures into a JerkWithAHeartofGold by the end of the series.

to:

* Dr. Morris from ''ER'' ''{{ER}}'' starts off as a DrJerk, but matures into a JerkWithAHeartofGold by the end of the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Daryl has never indicated being a racist. In the Season 2 opener he saves T-Dog's life. (As the name T-Dog implies, it could be that the writers are a little racist or at best behind the times.) His brother Merle, on the other hand, is undiluted jerk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StatlerAndWaldorf from TheMuppetShow. [[YourMilageMayVary YMMV]] but they have a couple of moments that show that they aren't total jerks. Like [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ArFSoYHSxs this]] song for example.

to:

* StatlerAndWaldorf from TheMuppetShow. [[YourMilageMayVary YMMV]] but they have a couple of moments that show that they aren't total jerks. Like when they sing [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ArFSoYHSxs this]] song for example.

Added: 215

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheWalkingDead'' has Daryl Dixon, a racist who has no problem saying someone is stupid, but who also shares is stash of medicine and comforts a mother with a missing child.

to:

* ''TheWalkingDead'' has Daryl Dixon, a racist who has no problem saying someone is stupid, but who also shares is his stash of medicine and comforts a mother with a missing child.child.
* StatlerAndWaldorf from TheMuppetShow. [[YourMilageMayVary YMMV]] but they have a couple of moments that show that they aren't total jerks. Like [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ArFSoYHSxs this]] song for example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ralph Kramden, of ''TheHoneymooners''.

to:

* Ralph Kramden, Kramden of ''TheHoneymooners''.

Added: 40

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ralph Kramden, of ''TheHoneymooners''.



* ''TheWalkingDead'' has Daryl Dixon, a racist who has no problem saying someone is stupid, but who also shares is stash of medicine and comforts a mother with a missing child.

to:

* ''TheWalkingDead'' has Daryl Dixon, a racist who has no problem saying someone is stupid, but who also shares is stash of medicine and comforts a mother with a missing child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Ted also meanders into this trope sometimes, though from the other direction: he's often a NiceGuy, but even during the times when he acts like more of a douche than a nice guy, he's ''always'' a caring, loyal friend, and usually snaps out of his JerkAss behavior when he actually ''realizes'' that he's behaving badly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Jayne''': You guys had a riot? On account o' me? My very own riot?

to:

-->'''Jayne''': --->'''Jayne''': You guys had a riot? On account o' me? My very own riot?



-->'''Jayne''': (Gives a Buddhist Monk some money) "Buy some shoes."
-->'''Monk''': "the Hero of Canton... He's real!"

to:

-->'''Jayne''': ---->'''Jayne''': (Gives a Buddhist Monk some money) "Buy some shoes."
-->'''Monk''': ---->'''Monk''': "the Hero of Canton... He's real!"



* Professor Kingsfield in THE PAPER CHASE. For instance, in one episode he apparently blows off both Logan's desperate phone call from jail and Hart's attempt to hand in his extra credit work. However, Kingsfield actually intervenes behind the scenes to get Logan released and turns over an entire class period for Hart to present the research he's done.
* [[CriminalMinds David Rossi]] comes off as this on several occasions. A prime example is in the episode ''Penelope'', where he's basically a complete jerk to Penelope Garcia- but only because he wants to catch the guy that shot her. He becomes a bit more subdued in this trope as he gets closer to the team, but he still has his moments.

to:

* Professor Kingsfield in THE PAPER CHASE.''ThePaperChase''. For instance, in one episode he apparently blows off both Logan's desperate phone call from jail and Hart's attempt to hand in his extra credit work. However, Kingsfield actually intervenes behind the scenes to get Logan released and turns over an entire class period for Hart to present the research he's done.
* [[CriminalMinds David Rossi]] comes off as this on several occasions. A prime example is in the episode ''Penelope'', "Penelope", where he's basically a complete jerk to Penelope Garcia- Garcia - but only because he wants to catch the guy that shot her. He becomes a bit more subdued in this trope as he gets closer to the team, but he still has his moments.



-->"You listen to me. While I will admit to a certain cynicism, the fact is that I am a naysayer and hatchet-man in the fight against violence. I pride myself in taking a punch and I'll gladly take another because I choose to live my life in the company of Gandhi and King. My concerns are global. I reject absolutely: revenge, aggression and retaliation. The foundation of such a method... is love. I love you Sheriff Truman."

to:

-->"You listen to me. While I will admit to a certain cynicism, the fact is that I am a naysayer and hatchet-man in the fight against violence. I pride myself in taking a punch and I'll gladly take another because I choose to live my life in the company of Gandhi and King. My concerns are global. I reject absolutely: revenge, aggression and retaliation. The foundation of such a method... is love. I love you you, Sheriff Truman."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheWalkingDead'' has Daryl Dixon, a racist who has no problem saying someone is stupid, but who also shares is stash of medecine and comforts a mother with a missing child.

to:

* ''TheWalkingDead'' has Daryl Dixon, a racist who has no problem saying someone is stupid, but who also shares is stash of medecine medicine and comforts a mother with a missing child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[{{ptitleypuldya7}} 100 Deeds for Eddie [=McDowd=]]]'' has the titular character going from antagonizing Justin while he's a dog to helping him when he's in trouble.

to:

* ''[[{{ptitleypuldya7}} 100 Deeds for Eddie [=McDowd=]]]'' ''Series/OneHundredDeedsForEddieMcdowd'' has the titular character going from antagonizing Justin while he's a dog to helping him when he's in trouble.



----

to:

----

Added: 305

Changed: 479

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Doctor Chase is a lesser example, he is a self-serving jerk and semi-antagonist for the first season but proves his loyalty by season 3. It's also assumed by everyone that he will break Cameron's heart when they begin their friends with benefits relationship, when in fact she's the one who breaks his.

to:

*** ** As often as not it's played straight with House. Case in point: he hires Foreman's ex-con brother over Foreman's wishes and delights in setting the two against each other. This ultimately leads to him "going too far", which leads to the two brothers uniting against him, just as he planned.
**
Doctor Chase is a lesser example, he is a self-serving jerk and semi-antagonist for the first season but proves his loyalty by season 3. It's also assumed by everyone that he will break Cameron's heart when they begin their friends with benefits relationship, when in fact she's the one who breaks his.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** House ''is'' just a JerkWithAHeartOfGold with the "jerk" aspects played up to ludicrously selfish extremes. Doesn't make his heart of gold any less sincere... just covered in more crud.


** In ''[[MASHTheSeries M*A*S*H]]'''s early years, the main characters Hawkeye and Trapper John were like this-- they're cocky, insubordinate pranksters and hellraisers who irritate others constantly, and two of the best and most caring doctors you could hope for. And most of their pranks [[ChaoticGood were directed toward the mostly unlikeable]] [[JerkAss Frank Burns]] and [[IceQueen Margaret Houlihan]], anyway.

to:

** In ''[[MASHTheSeries M*A*S*H]]'''s early years, the main characters Hawkeye and Trapper John were like this-- they're cocky, insubordinate pranksters and hellraisers who irritate others constantly, and two of the best and most caring doctors you could hope for. And most of their pranks [[ChaoticGood pranks were directed toward the mostly unlikeable]] unlikeable [[JerkAss Frank Burns]] and [[IceQueen Margaret Houlihan]], anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Dr. Cox and his wife Jordan from ''{{Scrubs}}'' are examples. They are both exuberantly acerbic and sarcastic especially to each other, but deep down are caring (albeit emotionally repressed) and loving, although they only express this to each other and their son, Jack -- and, in the case of Cox and very ''very'' occasionally, to J.D.

to:

* Dr. Cox and his wife Jordan from ''{{Scrubs}}'' are examples. They are both exuberantly acerbic and sarcastic especially to each other, but deep down are caring (albeit emotionally repressed) and loving, although they only express this to each other and their son, Jack -- and, in the case of Cox and Cox, very ''very'' occasionally, to J.D.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''TheWalkingDead'' has Daryl Dixon, a racist who has no problem saying someone is stupid, but who also shares is stash of medecine and comforts a mother with a missing child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ultimate in-series example is Eric, ''PowerRangersTimeForce'''s SixthRanger. Having grown up poor, he's [[TheResenter bitterly jealous]] of [[WhitePrince Wes's privileged upbringing]], and much of his motivation after becoming the Quantum Ranger is to finally have as much (if not more) power than [[TheHero Wes]] does, which he gets by becoming the leader of the Silver Guardians, a private security force created by Wes's father. (This is all [[FoeYay amplified]] by how much of a [[NiceGuy genuinely good guy]] Wes is.) Yet one of his best friends is a young girl who's a neighbor of his at the trailer park he lives in, and he also [[MoralityPet keeps birds as pets]]. As the series goes on, he begins to warm up to the Time Force team, even thwarting one of Wes's father's plans that would have inadvertently helped the BigBad. In the finale, he [[spoiler:agrees to become Wes's partner leading the Silver Guardians... at Wes's insistence.]]

to:

** The ultimate in-series example is Eric, ''PowerRangersTimeForce'''s SixthRanger. Having grown up poor, he's [[TheResenter bitterly jealous]] of [[WhitePrince Wes's privileged upbringing]], and much of his motivation after becoming the Quantum Ranger is to finally have as much (if not more) power than [[TheHero Wes]] does, which he gets by becoming the leader of the Silver Guardians, a private security force created by Wes's father. (This is all [[FoeYay amplified]] by how much of a [[NiceGuy genuinely good guy]] Wes is.) Yet one of his best friends is a young girl who's a neighbor of his at the trailer park he lives in, and he also [[MoralityPet keeps birds as pets]]. As the series goes on, he begins to warm up to the Time Force team, even thwarting one of Wes's father's plans that would have inadvertently helped the BigBad. In the finale, he [[spoiler:agrees to become Wes's partner leading [[spoiler:jumps in front of a mook - unmorphed - and takes a shot meant for Wes and his father. He survives and co-leads the Silver Guardians... Guardians with Wes at Wes's insistence.the end.]]

Added: 25

Changed: 209

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[ParksAndRecreation Ron Swanson]]. Also Tom to a lesser extent.

to:

* [[ParksAndRecreation Ron Swanson]]. Also Tom Swanson from ''ParksAndRecreation'' is a gruff, bitter misanthropist who hates his ex-wives, liberals, and the government, but when it comes down to it he's always there to help his coworkers and dispense sage wisdom.
**Tom
to a lesser extent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* Sam in ''{{iCarly}}''. A lazy, gluttonous bully she is saved by her [[MoralityPet genuine feelings of friendship for Carly]] and (very rare) moments of decency towards Freddie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Dr. {{Frasier}} Crane, likewise, is a pompous, self-righteous and snobby jackass who nevertheless genuinely loves and cares for his family and friends, is devoted to psychiatry and his patients, and is deep down ruled by an inner need to be liked. His brother [[TheNiles Niles]] is similar — less arrogant and self-righteous than Frasier, but even more snooty and sarcastic, who nevertheless demonstrates genuinely decent redeeming qualities, especially his determinedly concealed adoration of his older brother, and his love for Daphne, which frequently brings out his good side.

to:

* Dr. {{Frasier}} Crane, likewise, is a pompous, self-righteous self-righteous, overbearing and snobby jackass who nevertheless genuinely loves and cares for his family and friends, is devoted to psychiatry and his patients, and is deep down ruled by an inner need to be liked. His brother [[TheNiles Niles]] is similar — less arrogant and self-righteous than Frasier, but even more snooty and viciously sarcastic, who nevertheless demonstrates genuinely decent redeeming qualities, especially his determinedly concealed adoration qualities similar to those of his older brother, and his love for Daphne, which Daphne frequently brings out his good sweet side.



** Daphne is kind of a double subversion as a BitchInSheepsClothing [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold With A Heart Of Gold]]. She's sweet, polite, and cheerful on the outside; manipulative, bitchy, hot-tempered, and slightly unbalanced on the inside; and deeply loyal and caring on the ''very'' inside.
** Even Roz is a bit of this as well. She's a swaggering, loud, snarky, ball-breaking office slut; but shows that deep down she does feel vulnerable about her life and relationships, is a romantic at heart, and is very, ''very'' protective towards her best friend Frasier. Yeah, this show had a big thing for taking comedy-fodder stereotypes and giving them depth and complexity.

to:

** Daphne is kind of a double subversion as a BitchInSheepsClothing [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold With A Heart Of Gold]]. She's sweet, polite, and cheerful on the outside; manipulative, bitchy, hypocritical, hot-tempered, and slightly unbalanced on the inside; and deeply loyal and caring on the ''very'' inside.
** Even Roz is a bit of this as well. She's a swaggering, loud, snarky, flippant, ball-breaking office slut; VillageBicycle; but shows that deep down she does feel vulnerable about her life and relationships, is a romantic at heart, and is very, ''very'' protective towards her best friend Frasier. Yeah, this show had a big thing for taking comedy-fodder stereotypes and giving them depth and complexity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He spends his share of a very large robbery the crew pulled on an entire CRATE of apples, which he shares with the entire crew.
*** I wouldn't necessarily count that. He seems, at least in this troper's interpretation, to have done it because he was feeling guilty about trying to collect on Simon and River.

to:

** He spends his share of a very large robbery the crew pulled on an entire CRATE of apples, which he shares with the entire crew.
*** I wouldn't necessarily count that. He seems, at least in this troper's interpretation, to have done it
crew, because he was feeling guilty about trying to collect his actions in the previous episode.
** The only person
on Simon and River.the crew he shows little affection at all toward is River. Why? Because he perceives her as a threat ''to everyone else''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace


* In ''Series/TinMan'' Cain starts as this, but the other three wear him down until he remembers what a good guy he really is, and that (pardon the {{Wicked}} reference), good deeds don't necessarily go unpunished. Oddly enough, it's a HeroicSacrifice into a frozen lake that did the best job of thawing him out.

to:

* In ''Series/TinMan'' Cain starts as this, but the other three wear him down until he remembers what a good guy he really is, and that (pardon the {{Wicked}} ''Theatre/{{Wicked}}'' reference), good deeds don't necessarily go unpunished. Oddly enough, it's a HeroicSacrifice into a frozen lake that did the best job of thawing him out.

Top