Follow TV Tropes

Following

History JerkWithAHeartOfGold / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Camacan MOD

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Urkel has been renamed Extroverted Nerd.


* Alex P. Keaton from ''FamilyTies'' dreams of reaching the top of the corporate ladder and being rich -- and he often acts pompous about his intelligence. His views also sometimes appear sexist and he often appears to hold a certain contempt for people who lack intelligence and/or wealth. However, he has shown many times that he truly is a lovable and compassionate person -- and his good buddy is [[TheUrkel Skippy Handelman]].

to:

* Alex P. Keaton from ''FamilyTies'' dreams of reaching the top of the corporate ladder and being rich -- and he often acts pompous about his intelligence. His views also sometimes appear sexist and he often appears to hold a certain contempt for people who lack intelligence and/or wealth. However, he has shown many times that he truly is a lovable and compassionate person -- and his good buddy is [[TheUrkel [[ExtrovertedNerd Skippy Handelman]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Stefan from ''TopChef'' season 5. A very heavy competitor, he comes off as an overconfident ass (which he is, honestly). However, he does have friendships with the other contestants (outside of competition of course) and he tried to comfort Carla when she started to cry during the final judges session.

to:

* Stefan from ''TopChef'' ''Series/TopChef'' season 5. A very heavy competitor, he comes off as an overconfident ass (which he is, honestly). However, he does have friendships with the other contestants (outside of competition of course) and he tried to comfort Carla when she started to cry during the final judges session.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [Series/[{{Firefly}} Jayne Cobb]] is on the borderline, and definitely leaning toward "Jerk" but shows some nicer moments, such as sending a chunk of his pay to his mom to help take care of his ailing brother, and wearing a truly hideous hat because his mother made it for him.

to:

* [Series/[{{Firefly}} [[Series/{{Firefly}} Jayne Cobb]] is on the borderline, and definitely leaning toward "Jerk" but shows some nicer moments, such as sending a chunk of his pay to his mom to help take care of his ailing brother, and wearing a truly hideous hat because his mother made it for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Dr. {{Frasier}} Crane, likewise, is a pompous, self-righteous and snobby jackass who nevertheless genuinely loves and cares for his family and friends, is devoted to psychiatry and his patients, and is deep down ruled by an inner need to be liked. His brother [[TheNiles Niles]] is similar, in that he's even ''more'' of a pompous, arrogant jerk who nevertheless demonstrates genuinely decent redeeming qualities, especially his determinedly concealed adoration of his older brother, and his love for Daphne, which always brings out his good side (part of the reason people complain that ''Frasier'' was less funny after Niles and Daphne got together was because it made Niles a whole lot nicer, i.e., more boring).

to:

* Dr. {{Frasier}} Crane, likewise, is a pompous, self-righteous and snobby jackass who nevertheless genuinely loves and cares for his family and friends, is devoted to psychiatry and his patients, and is deep down ruled by an inner need to be liked. His brother [[TheNiles Niles]] is similar, in that he's even ''more'' of a pompous, similar — less arrogant jerk and self-righteous than Frasier, but even more snooty and sarcastic, who nevertheless demonstrates genuinely decent redeeming qualities, especially his determinedly concealed adoration of his older brother, and his love for Daphne, which always frequently brings out his good side (part of the reason people complain that ''Frasier'' was less funny after Niles and Daphne got together was because it made Niles a whole lot nicer, i.e., more boring).side.



** Even Roz is a bit of this as well. She's a swaggering, loud, snarky, ball-breaking office slut; but shows that deep down she does feel insecure and vulnerable about her life and relationships, is a romantic at heart, and is very, ''very'' protective towards her best friend Frasier. Yeah, this show had a big thing for taking comedy-fodder stereotypes and giving them depth and complexity.

to:

** Even Roz is a bit of this as well. She's a swaggering, loud, snarky, ball-breaking office slut; but shows that deep down she does feel insecure and vulnerable about her life and relationships, is a romantic at heart, and is very, ''very'' protective towards her best friend Frasier. Yeah, this show had a big thing for taking comedy-fodder stereotypes and giving them depth and complexity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[ParksAndRecreation Ron Swanson]]. Also Tom to a lesser extent.

Added: 494

Changed: 877

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As much as [[TedBaxter Bulk and Skull]] from MightyMorphinPowerRangers are jerks and bullies, they do have a soft spot, showcasing genuine care for a disgusting pig, trying to save a runaway stroller, and when stuck in a dreamscape, they dream of being heroes. They also ''[[BeyondTheImpossible saved the rangers lives]]'' durring one episode where the MonsterOfTheWeek gave them LaserGuidedAmnesia. Maybe not full gold, but some lower value precious metal, made shinier as the show went on.

to:

*** Dillon seems to invoke this trope as a defense mechanism more so than actually ''being'' it (he's probably closer to GoodIsNotNice). In the third episode, "Rain", when the three core Rangers are trying to get him to join the team for good, he says, "I'm not that kind of person", "that kind of person" being the noble heroes he imagines Scott, Flynn and Summer as, even though most of his actions that have been seen up to that point indicate that he's just as much of a "good guy" as they are. To put an even finer point on it, [[spoiler:he joins the Rangers on one condition: that Ziggy be released from prison]].
** As much as [[TedBaxter Bulk and Skull]] from MightyMorphinPowerRangers are jerks and bullies, they do have a soft spot, spots, showcasing genuine care for a disgusting pig, trying to save a runaway stroller, and when stuck in a dreamscape, they dream of being heroes. They also ''[[BeyondTheImpossible saved the rangers Rangers' lives]]'' durring one episode where the MonsterOfTheWeek gave them LaserGuidedAmnesia. Maybe not full gold, but some lower value precious metal, made shinier as the show went on.



** One great example of this is how he gave up a partnership in a very high-profile law-firm despite promises of a private office and an attractive female boss who wanted him after he found out that he was being hired for his reputation as a good lover -- not because of his record as Assistant D.A. Of course Dan slept with the woman offering him the job first THEN quit, excitedly telling a confused janitor as he left her office "You can have your principles and STILL get lucky!"

to:

** One great example of this is how he gave up a partnership in a very high-profile law-firm law firm despite promises of a private office and an attractive female boss who wanted him after he found out that he was being hired for his reputation as a good lover -- not because of his record as Assistant D.A. Of course Dan slept with the woman offering him the job first THEN quit, excitedly telling a confused janitor as he left her office "You can have your principles and STILL get lucky!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[{{Firefly}} Jayne Cobb]] is on the borderline, and definitely leaning toward "Jerk" but shows some nicer moments, such as sending a chunk of his pay to his mom to help take care of his ailing brother, and wearing a truly hideous hat because his mother made it for him.

to:

* [[{{Firefly}} [Series/[{{Firefly}} Jayne Cobb]] is on the borderline, and definitely leaning toward "Jerk" but shows some nicer moments, such as sending a chunk of his pay to his mom to help take care of his ailing brother, and wearing a truly hideous hat because his mother made it for him.



* In the later seasons of ''{{Farscape}}'', Dominar Rygel XVI.

to:

* In the later seasons of ''{{Farscape}}'', ''Series/{{Farscape}}'', Dominar Rygel XVI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Arthur in ''{{Series/Merlin}}''. Arrogant and self-centered yes, but with a genuine sense of justice. In fact he might not be a jerk at all, or at if it wasn't for his sense of duty towards his father, who is a ''true'' {{Jerkass}}.

to:

* Arthur in ''{{Series/Merlin}}''. Arrogant and self-centered yes, but with a genuine sense of justice. justice and near unshakeable loyalty to his friends, his people and his king. In fact he might not be a jerk at all, or at if it wasn't for his this sense of duty towards his father, who is a ''true'' {{Jerkass}}.

Added: 683

Changed: 302

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Dr. {{Frasier}} Crane, likewise, is a pompous, self-righteous and snobby jackass who nevertheless genuinely loves and cares for his family and friends, is devoted to psychiatry and his patients, and is deep down ruled by an inner need to be liked. His brother [[TheNiles Niles]] is similar, in that he's even ''more'' of a pompous, arrogant jerk who nevertheless demonstrates genuinely decent redeeming qualities.

to:

* Dr. {{Frasier}} Crane, likewise, is a pompous, self-righteous and snobby jackass who nevertheless genuinely loves and cares for his family and friends, is devoted to psychiatry and his patients, and is deep down ruled by an inner need to be liked. His brother [[TheNiles Niles]] is similar, in that he's even ''more'' of a pompous, arrogant jerk who nevertheless demonstrates genuinely decent redeeming qualities.qualities, especially his determinedly concealed adoration of his older brother, and his love for Daphne, which always brings out his good side (part of the reason people complain that ''Frasier'' was less funny after Niles and Daphne got together was because it made Niles a whole lot nicer, i.e., more boring).


Added DiffLines:

** Daphne is kind of a double subversion as a BitchInSheepsClothing [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold With A Heart Of Gold]]. She's sweet, polite, and cheerful on the outside; manipulative, bitchy, hot-tempered, and slightly unbalanced on the inside; and deeply loyal and caring on the ''very'' inside.
** Even Roz is a bit of this as well. She's a swaggering, loud, snarky, ball-breaking office slut; but shows that deep down she does feel insecure and vulnerable about her life and relationships, is a romantic at heart, and is very, ''very'' protective towards her best friend Frasier. Yeah, this show had a big thing for taking comedy-fodder stereotypes and giving them depth and complexity.

Added: 1168

Changed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{House}}'': Dr. Gregory House threatens to get into this during his PetTheDog moments, particularly when he was diagnosed with cancer and still insisted on focusing on the patient. As always, it turned out he was just a [[JerkWithAHeartOfJerk Jerk With The Heart Of An Even Bigger Jerk]] Than We Had Assumed -- [[spoiler:he faked having cancer so he could get his hands on the perscription drugs, although to be fair, his team only "found out" he was sick by snooping around behind his back]].

to:

* ''{{House}}'': Dr. Gregory House threatens to get into this during his PetTheDog moments, particularly when he was diagnosed with cancer and still insisted on focusing on the patient. As always, it turned out he was just a [[JerkWithAHeartOfJerk Jerk With The Heart Of An Even Bigger Jerk]] Than We Had Assumed than we had assumed -- [[spoiler:he faked having cancer so he could get his hands on the perscription drugs, although to be fair, his team only "found out" he was sick by snooping around behind his back]].



** Martin is in someways like this as well, at times to the point of being an inversion; although a lot more down-to-Earth, practical and, on the surface at least, likable than his two sons, he's nevertheless in the early seasons a crabby, bitter and emotionally repressed and distant man whom, it's suggested, has rarely actually made much of an effort to connect to his sons in any meaningful way (although he remains proud of them nevertheless). Whilst Niles and Frasier tend to wear their jerkiness on their sleeves, especially towards Martin, it's frequently established that Martin also has his jerkass side and partial responsibility for his difficult relationship with his sons.

to:

** Martin is in someways some ways like this as well, at times to the point of being an inversion; although a lot more down-to-Earth, practical and, on the surface at least, likable than his two sons, he's nevertheless in the early seasons a crabby, bitter and emotionally repressed and distant man whom, it's suggested, has rarely actually made much of an effort to connect to his sons in any meaningful way (although he remains proud of them nevertheless). Whilst Niles and Frasier tend to wear their jerkiness on their sleeves, especially towards Martin, it's frequently established that Martin also has his jerkass side and partial responsibility for his difficult relationship with his sons.



** Malcolm Reynolds could be said to be leaning in the other direction of the trope, being less of a jerk, but still fitting
*** Besides we need him to hit Jayne with a wrench.

to:

** Malcolm Reynolds could be said to be leaning in the other direction of the trope, being less of a jerk, but still fitting
fitting.
*** Besides Besides, we need him to hit Jayne with a wrench.



* Adam Baldwin, the who played the above role, does this trope better as Casey in ''{{Chuck}}''. While Chuck's other handler quickly becomes a viable LoveInterest, Casey continues to emphasise how little he thinks of Chuck, generally insulting him, not caring about him, and always following orders above all else. But by the end of the second seasons, he has quite a large amount of hidden fondness for both of his partners, even if he would never admit it.
** (He does.He tells General Beckman that Sarah is the "Best partner I ever had". Mind you, he is saving her job at the time...)

to:

* Adam Baldwin, the who played the above role, does this trope better as Casey in ''{{Chuck}}''. While Chuck's other handler quickly becomes a viable LoveInterest, Casey continues to emphasise how little he thinks of Chuck, generally insulting him, not caring about him, and always following orders above all else. But by the end of the second seasons, he has quite a large amount of hidden fondness for both of his partners, even if he would never admit it.
** (He does. He tells General Beckman that Sarah is the "Best partner I ever had". Mind you, he is saving her job at the time...)



* Conner from ''PowerRangersDinoThunder'' is one of these, which was a very interesting example considering he was the Red Ranger. This made for some funky team dynamics during the time it took for the group to begin to actually trust each other, since his teammates were a [[HollywoodNerd male geek]] and a [[RebelliousSpirit female loner musician]].

to:

* Conner from ''PowerRangersDinoThunder'' is one of these, which was a very interesting example considering he was the Red Ranger. This It's actually a quick upgrade from the JerkJock that he is in the premiere. Still, this made for some funky team dynamics during the time it took for the group to begin to actually trust each other, since his teammates were a [[HollywoodNerd male geek]] and a [[RebelliousSpirit female loner musician]].


Added DiffLines:

** The ultimate in-series example is Eric, ''PowerRangersTimeForce'''s SixthRanger. Having grown up poor, he's [[TheResenter bitterly jealous]] of [[WhitePrince Wes's privileged upbringing]], and much of his motivation after becoming the Quantum Ranger is to finally have as much (if not more) power than [[TheHero Wes]] does, which he gets by becoming the leader of the Silver Guardians, a private security force created by Wes's father. (This is all [[FoeYay amplified]] by how much of a [[NiceGuy genuinely good guy]] Wes is.) Yet one of his best friends is a young girl who's a neighbor of his at the trailer park he lives in, and he also [[MoralityPet keeps birds as pets]]. As the series goes on, he begins to warm up to the Time Force team, even thwarting one of Wes's father's plans that would have inadvertently helped the BigBad. In the finale, he [[spoiler:agrees to become Wes's partner leading the Silver Guardians... at Wes's insistence.]]
*** Obligatory SuperSentai note: Eric was virtually a carbon copy of his [[MiraiSentaiTimeranger Sentai counterpart]] Naoto, birds and all. The only real difference between them is [[spoiler:Naoto dies at the end.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** You can forget that lovable rouge, Autolycus! He's proven time and time again that despite claiming that his main interest is himself... and riches, he's put his own life on the line to save his friends on multiple occasions. Gabrielle even says that he has a heart of gold after he defends her bad plan to Xena even though he himself had been criticizing her for it shortly before the warrior princess' arrival.

to:

** You can can't forget that lovable rouge, Autolycus! He's proven time and time again that despite claiming that his main interest is himself... and riches, he's put his own life on the line to save his friends on multiple occasions. Gabrielle even says that he has a heart of gold after he defends her bad plan to Xena even though he himself had been criticizing her for it shortly before the warrior princess' arrival.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** You can forget that lovable rouge, Autolycus! He's proven time and time again that despite claiming that his main interest is himself... and riches, he's put his own life on the line to save his friends on multiple occasions. Gabrielle even says that he has a heart of gold after he defends her bad plan to Xena even though he himself had been criticizing her for it shortly before the warrior princess' arrival.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Pablo Guerra from ''{{Carrusel}}''. He may be the class prankster, may get into trouble often, and may inadvertently cross the line at times. But he is not malicious or cruel. In fact, he was the first one to befriend Mario the new boy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The devastation on Jayne's face after one of the Mudders sacrifices himself to save him speaks more about his character than anything else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Drake from ''DrakeAndJosh'' has his moments, contrasting to the JerkWithAHeartOfJerk sister, Megan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* Most of the incarnations of The Doctor from ''DoctorWho'' would touch on this trope at some point, but in many ways the Sixth Doctor matches it most of all; for the most part he's a pompous, arrogant, blustering jackass filled with a monumental sense of his own self-importance... who, every so often, does something that reveals him to be more than capable of acts of astonishing compassion and generosity.

to:

* Most of the incarnations of The Doctor from ''DoctorWho'' ''Series/DoctorWho'' would touch on this trope at some point, but in many ways the Sixth Doctor matches it most of all; for the most part he's a pompous, arrogant, blustering jackass filled with a monumental sense of his own self-importance... who, every so often, does something that reveals him to be more than capable of acts of astonishing compassion and generosity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Anthony Bourdain from ''No Reservations''. On the outside he may seem like a jerkass, but really, he's all right and cares about his crew and the people he visits in his travels.

to:

* Anthony Bourdain from ''No Reservations''. On the outside he may seem like a jerkass, {{Jerkass}}, but really, he's all right and cares about his crew and the people he visits in his travels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Anthony Bourdain from ''No Reservations''. On the outside he may seem like a jerkass, but really, he's all right and cares about his crew and the people he visits in his travels.

to:

** * Anthony Bourdain from ''No Reservations''. On the outside he may seem like a jerkass, but really, he's all right and cares about his crew and the people he visits in his travels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Anthony Bourdain from ''No Reservations''. On the outside he may seem like a jerkass, but really, he's all right and cares about his crew and the people he visits in his travels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Adric is sort of a lesser version of this, as he doesn't really [[CharacterDerailment develop jerk tendencies until season 19]], but he still shows he cares. For instance, at the beginning of "Kinda" when he and Nyssa are discussing her recent fainting spells and he calls her "hopeless in her present state of mind." But when she starts having another attack, he goes over and puts a comforting hand on her shoulder.

to:

** Adric is sort of a lesser version of this, as he doesn't really [[CharacterDerailment develop jerk tendencies until season 19]], 19, but he still shows he cares. For instance, at the beginning of "Kinda" when he and Nyssa are discussing her recent fainting spells and he calls her "hopeless in her present state of mind." But when she starts having another attack, he goes over and puts a comforting hand on her shoulder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Drifter also counts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''[[{{ptitleypuldya7}} 100 Deeds for Eddie [=McDowd=]]]'' has the titular character going from antagonizing Justin while he's a dog to helping him when he's in trouble.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sam in ''{{iCarly}}''. A lazy, gluttonous bully she is saved by her [[MoralityChain genuine feelings of friendship for Carly]] and (very rare) moments of decency towards Freddie.

to:

* Sam in ''{{iCarly}}''. A lazy, gluttonous bully she is saved by her [[MoralityChain [[MoralityPet genuine feelings of friendship for Carly]] and (very rare) moments of decency towards Freddie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Jeff Winger in ''{{Community}}'' is an unapologetic {{Jerkass}}, and yet -- although he'd loudly complain about it -- would do absolutely anything for the people he loves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Gabriel/[[spoiler:the Trickster]]. He enjoys tormenting people, puts the Winchesters through hell, 'teaches' people lessons, often killing them in the process, but also sides with humans when it matters and goes up against Lucifer [[spoiler: with saddening consequences.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jaye Tyler from ''{{Wonderfalls}}''. She's lazy, whiny and frequently mean-spirited, but she loves her family and is, in her own words "very susceptible to guilt".

to:

* Jaye Tyler from ''{{Wonderfalls}}''. She's lazy, whiny and frequently mean-spirited, but she loves her family and is, in her own words words, "very susceptible to guilt".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Jaye Tyler from ''{{Wonderfalls}}''. She's lazy, whiny and frequently mean-spirited, but she loves her family and is, in her own words "very susceptible to guilt".
ccoa MOD

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Arthur in ''{{Merlin}}''. Arrogant and self-centered yes, but with a genuine sense of justice. In fact he might not be a jerk at all, or at if it wasn't for his sense of duty towards his father, who is a ''true'' {{Jerkass}}.

to:

* Arthur in ''{{Merlin}}''.''{{Series/Merlin}}''. Arrogant and self-centered yes, but with a genuine sense of justice. In fact he might not be a jerk at all, or at if it wasn't for his sense of duty towards his father, who is a ''true'' {{Jerkass}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Jade West on ''{{Victorious}}''. While aggressive and abusive towards most (even her boyfriend), she does show signs of caring about others. The recent episode, ''Wok Star'', is a very good representation of how much she has changed compared to some of her earlier deeds.

Top