Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / WelcomeToNightVale

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Or time could pass at different speeds in different parts of town, this would allow Cecil to leave during pre-recorded ads, public service announcements and The Weather and return in time to continue the program despite having been gone for much longer. Something like this had to have happened in episode 25 too, for him to travel to the bowling alley, spend some time sitting with Carlos then return to the radio station by the end of the song. Although broadcasting from a place where time travels at one speed and having people listening in other locations where time travels at other speeds couldn't possibly work, it makes about as much sense as a lot of things in this town.

to:

*** Or time could pass at different speeds in different parts of town, this would allow Cecil to leave during pre-recorded ads, public service announcements and The Weather and return in time to continue the program despite having been gone for much longer. Something like this had to have happened in episode 25 too, for him to travel to the bowling alley, Arby's parking lot, spend some time sitting with Carlos then return to the radio station by the end of the song. Although broadcasting from a place where time travels at one speed and having people listening in other locations where time travels at other speeds couldn't possibly work, it makes about as much sense as a lot of things in this town.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Or, if Cecil never went so far as to take and put a picture of Carlos on his desk, maybe it's a picture of someone else entirely - but ''who?'' Earl Harlan? A family member?

to:

*** Or, if Cecil never went so far as to take and put a picture of Carlos on his desk, desk before the events of "One Year Later", maybe it's a picture of someone else entirely - but ''who?'' Earl Harlan? A family member?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Or, if Cecil never went so far as to take and put a picture of Carlos on his desk, maybe it's a picture of someone else entirely - but ''who?'' Earl Harlan? A family member?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Citizens of Night Vale most likely practice DoubleThink like in 1984 or The City & The City: they need to know the actual truth for practical reasons, but must also deny and disbelieve on command. The impermanence of radio makes it perfect for disseminating things that must be forgotten.

to:

** Citizens of Night Vale most likely practice DoubleThink like in 1984 or The City & The City: they need to know the actual truth for practical reasons, but must also deny and disbelieve on command. The impermanence of radio makes it perfect for disseminating things that must be forgotten.forgotten.
** One fanon interpretation is that Cecil is the personification of Night Vale and so he knows all the things that are happening and tells them as he sees them. Any government corrections are mentioned as a sort of overwriting the town memory of the event.

Added: 501

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's possible that in Night Vale, the people of the town already know what Cecil look like. To them, he doesn't need to explain anything-- the out-of-universe reason is to preserve the loose descriptions in radio plays, so every listener can have their own Cecil.

to:

** It's possible that in Night Vale, the people of the town already know what Cecil look like. To them, he doesn't need to explain anything-- the out-of-universe reason is to preserve the loose descriptions in radio plays, so every listener can have their own Cecil. Cecil.
** Over at the WMG, there's a theory that – because people don't keep pictures of themselves on their own desks – the picture on Cecil's desk was a picture of Carlos, and the picture on Kevin's desk was of Kevin's love interest, some kind of DesertBluffs!Carlos. This would mean Cecil looks like DesertBluffs!Carlos, except for the eyes and smile, and Kevin looks like Carlos, except for the smile. And Cecil didn't meet Kevin in the portal, he met DesertBluffs!Carlos, while Kevin met Cecil's Carlos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's possible that in Night Vale, the people of the town already know what Cecil look like. To them, he doesn't need to explain anything-- the out-of-universe reason is to preserve the loose descriptions in radio plays, so every listener can have their own Cecil.


Added DiffLines:

** One fanon explanation of the fanon eye on Cecil's forehead is that he's [[PsychicPowers Clairvoyant]]-- there seems to be some ban on writing and reading certain things, it's possible this is one of the few ways he can even obtain the news at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There's been strong evidence in the "technical difficulties" section in the episode that happens after the "station managers" episode that may have been...either replaced, or that he's been changed from his initial form in some way.

to:

*** There's been strong evidence in the "technical difficulties" section in the episode that happens after the "station managers" episode that may have been...either replaced, or that he's been changed from his initial form in some way.way.
** Citizens of Night Vale most likely practice DoubleThink like in 1984 or The City & The City: they need to know the actual truth for practical reasons, but must also deny and disbelieve on command. The impermanence of radio makes it perfect for disseminating things that must be forgotten.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe they were just enjoying it. He mentions that they were laughing. Rolling down hills is fun and everything, especially with someone you ambiguously seem to ''like''-like. Or maybe there was some kind of {{Bizarrchitecture}} thing going on where you'd end up rolling downhill no matter what. Or since it may have been a hallucination, maybe they were just weirdly confused and incompetent the way people sometimes are in dreams.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It seems significant that he's much more afraid of the station management - although there's been no evidence that they're actually dangerous - than he is of all the things that are known to be deadly and horrible.

to:

*** It seems significant that he's much more afraid of the station management - although there's been no evidence that they're actually dangerous - than he is of all the things that are known to be deadly and horrible.horrible.
*** There's been strong evidence in the "technical difficulties" section in the episode that happens after the "station managers" episode that may have been...either replaced, or that he's been changed from his initial form in some way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Perhaps because the radio station management has been protecting him in some bizarre way.

to:

** Perhaps because the radio station management has been protecting him in some bizarre way.way.
*** It seems significant that he's much more afraid of the station management - although there's been no evidence that they're actually dangerous - than he is of all the things that are known to be deadly and horrible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Or time could pass at different speeds in different parts of town, this would allow Cecil to leave during pre-recorded ads, public service announcements and The Weather and return in time to continue the program despite having been gone for much longer. Something like this had to have happened in episode 25 too, for him to travel to the bowling alley, spend some time sitting with Carlos then return to the radio station by the end of the song.

to:

*** Or time could pass at different speeds in different parts of town, this would allow Cecil to leave during pre-recorded ads, public service announcements and The Weather and return in time to continue the program despite having been gone for much longer. Something like this had to have happened in episode 25 too, for him to travel to the bowling alley, spend some time sitting with Carlos then return to the radio station by the end of the song. Although broadcasting from a place where time travels at one speed and having people listening in other locations where time travels at other speeds couldn't possibly work, it makes about as much sense as a lot of things in this town.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Or time could pass at different speeds in different parts of town, this would allow Cecil to leave during pre-recorded ads, PSAs and The Weather and return in time to continue the program despite having been gone for much longer. Something like this had to have happened in episode 25 too, for him to travel to the bowling alley, spend some time sitting with Carlos then return to the radio station by the end of the song.

to:

*** Or time could pass at different speeds in different parts of town, this would allow Cecil to leave during pre-recorded ads, PSAs public service announcements and The Weather and return in time to continue the program despite having been gone for much longer. Something like this had to have happened in episode 25 too, for him to travel to the bowling alley, spend some time sitting with Carlos then return to the radio station by the end of the song.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Or time could pass at different speeds in different parts of town, this would allow Cecil to leave during pre-recorded ads, PSAs and The Weather and return in time to continue the program despite having been gone for much longer. Something like this had to have happened in episode 25 too, for him to travel to the bowling alley, spend some time sitting with Carlos then return to the radio station by the end of the song.

Added: 330

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Kevin may also be referring to the NUMBER of eyes that they have, as fanon often gives Cecil a third one on his forehead.

to:

** Kevin may also be referring to the NUMBER of eyes that they have, as fanon often gives Cecil a third one on his forehead.forehead.
** They might each be seeing slightly different things in the pictures and both telling the truth as far as they know. Or maybe Kevin is the one who's mistaken about his own appearance: it could be that Cecil has normal eyes and Kevin has black eyes but he doesn't notice them in the picture of himself or, presumably, in mirrors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Maybe they were actually having adventurous sex.

to:

*** ** Maybe they were actually having adventurous sex.sex sessions both in the inn and outside, and "rolling" is just a euphemism. He says he didn't know this partner or remember where he met him, so maybe the partner was a prostitute or one-night-stand he picked up while drunk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Maybe they were actually having adventurous sex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Kevin may also be referring to the NUMBER of eyes that they have, as fanon often gives Cecil a third one on his forehead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Cecil sure does seem to report a lot on things that the government don't want people to know about and actively deny happening. It's been established that they can make people disappear, though they don't do it often--how the hell has Cecil lasted this long?

to:

* Cecil sure does seem to report a lot on things that the government don't want people to know about and actively deny happening. It's been established that they can make people disappear, though they don't do it often--how the hell has Cecil lasted this long?long?
** Perhaps because the radio station management has been protecting him in some bizarre way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Carlos ''has'' recently discovered that time in Night Vale may not be real...

to:

*** Carlos ''has'' recently discovered that time in Night Vale may not be real...real...
* Cecil sure does seem to report a lot on things that the government don't want people to know about and actively deny happening. It's been established that they can make people disappear, though they don't do it often--how the hell has Cecil lasted this long?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It happens enough throughout the series that you can be pretty sure it's intentional. One interpretation is that the 20-minute podcast version is a cut-down version of a much longer radio show. Or you can take it to mean that Cecil is capable of some strange instant-travel type action. Given Night Vale, though, it's likely there ''is'' an answer, and it's weirder than anything fans would be likely to guess.

to:

** It happens enough throughout the series that you can be pretty sure it's intentional. One interpretation is that the 20-minute podcast version is a cut-down version of a much longer radio show. Or you can take it to mean that Cecil is capable of some strange instant-travel type action. Given Night Vale, though, it's likely there ''is'' an answer, and it's weirder than anything fans would be likely to guess.guess.
*** Carlos ''has'' recently discovered that time in Night Vale may not be real...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There are a few possibilities here. Cecil's eyes might be "black as obsidian" like Kevin's, and Cecil is just unaware of this for some reason- or, Cecil's eyes might be similar in some way(s) to Kevin's eyes EXCEPT for their color. For example, some fans have the headcanon that Cecil's eyes are just white, without a visible iris or pupil. If Kevin's eyes are completely black without a visible iris or pupil, then Cecil would be correct in saying that his eyes are different, and Kevin would be technically correct if what he's saying is that they have the same TYPE of eyes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* From time to time, Cecil seems to go out and do things without actually leaving the radio studio. For instance, in the first episode, he does a news segment and starts out confused about the mysterious scientists who've come to town. Then, during the same segment, Carlos arranges a town meeting, and Cecil then discusses the meeting in detail as if he attended it (or at least personally saw everything that happened), despite the fact he was hosting his program the entire time. How does he do that? (It's pretty easy to muster a [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Doylist]] explanation, which is that the writers got mixed up or [[BellisariosMaxim expected the listener not to question it]], but the [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Watsonian]] implications are kinda freaky.)

to:

* From time to time, Cecil seems to go out and do things without actually leaving the radio studio. For instance, in the first episode, he does a news segment and starts out confused about the mysterious scientists who've come to town. Then, during the same segment, Carlos arranges a town meeting, and Cecil then discusses the meeting in detail as if he attended it (or at least personally saw everything that happened), despite the fact he was hosting his program the entire time. How does he do that? (It's pretty easy to muster a [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Doylist]] explanation, which is that the writers got mixed up or [[BellisariosMaxim expected the listener not to question it]], but the [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Watsonian]] implications are kinda freaky.))
** It happens enough throughout the series that you can be pretty sure it's intentional. One interpretation is that the 20-minute podcast version is a cut-down version of a much longer radio show. Or you can take it to mean that Cecil is capable of some strange instant-travel type action. Given Night Vale, though, it's likely there ''is'' an answer, and it's weirder than anything fans would be likely to guess.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* From time to time, Cecil seems to go out and do things without actually leaving the radio studio. For instance, in the first episode, he does a news segment and starts out confused about the mysterious scientists who've come to town. Then, during the same segment, Carlos arranges a town meeting, and Cecil attends the meeting, eats a corn muffin, and falls in love with Carlos. Meanwhile, he's doing his radio show, which is clearly recorded and broadcast live. He then reports on the town meeting with Carlos as part of the same news segment which he was doing ''the entire time''. How does he do that? (It's pretty easy to muster a [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Doylist]] explanation, which is that the writers got mixed up or [[BellisariosMaxim expected the listener not to question it]], but the [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Watsonian]] implications are kinda freaky.)

to:

* From time to time, Cecil seems to go out and do things without actually leaving the radio studio. For instance, in the first episode, he does a news segment and starts out confused about the mysterious scientists who've come to town. Then, during the same segment, Carlos arranges a town meeting, and Cecil attends the meeting, eats a corn muffin, and falls in love with Carlos. Meanwhile, he's doing his radio show, which is clearly recorded and broadcast live. He then reports on discusses the town meeting with Carlos in detail as part of if he attended it (or at least personally saw everything that happened), despite the same news segment which fact he was doing ''the hosting his program the entire time''.time. How does he do that? (It's pretty easy to muster a [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Doylist]] explanation, which is that the writers got mixed up or [[BellisariosMaxim expected the listener not to question it]], but the [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Watsonian]] implications are kinda freaky.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


::Cecil's wording clearly implies that Kevin's eyes are different from his own. However, Kevin states that Cecil's eyes are the same as his. So which is it? Is one of them lying? If so, why?

to:

::Cecil's wording clearly implies that Kevin's eyes are different from his own. However, Kevin states that Cecil's eyes are the same as his. So which is it? Is one of them lying? If so, why?why?
* From time to time, Cecil seems to go out and do things without actually leaving the radio studio. For instance, in the first episode, he does a news segment and starts out confused about the mysterious scientists who've come to town. Then, during the same segment, Carlos arranges a town meeting, and Cecil attends the meeting, eats a corn muffin, and falls in love with Carlos. Meanwhile, he's doing his radio show, which is clearly recorded and broadcast live. He then reports on the town meeting with Carlos as part of the same news segment which he was doing ''the entire time''. How does he do that? (It's pretty easy to muster a [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Doylist]] explanation, which is that the writers got mixed up or [[BellisariosMaxim expected the listener not to question it]], but the [[WatsonianVersusDoylist Watsonian]] implications are kinda freaky.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is Night Vale. Normal logic really just doesn't apply to it or its denizens.

to:

** It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is Night Vale. Normal logic really just doesn't apply to it or its denizens.denizens.
*Kevin's description of Cecil and Cecil's description of Kevin don't match up. Here's Kevin describing Cecil:
-->There is a photo here on the desk. It is a man. He is wearing a tie. He is not tall or short, not thin or fat. He has eyes like mine and a nose like mine, and hair like mine, but I do not think he is me. Maybe it is the smile. Is that a smile? I can’t say.
::And here's Cecil describing Kevin[=:=]
-->There is a photo, a single photo of a man on the desk here. He is wearing a tie. He is not tall or short, not thin or fat. His hair and nose are like mine, but his eyes - his eyes are black as obsidian and his smile. Noooo. It is not a smile. He must be wicked, this man.
::Cecil's wording clearly implies that Kevin's eyes are different from his own. However, Kevin states that Cecil's eyes are the same as his. So which is it? Is one of them lying? If so, why?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is Night Vale. Normal logic really just doesn't apply there.

to:

** It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is Night Vale. Normal logic really just doesn't apply there.to it or its denizens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is [i]Night Vale.[/i] Normal logic really just doesn't apply there.

to:

** It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is [i]Night Vale.[/i] Night Vale. Normal logic really just doesn't apply there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is <i>Night Vale.</i> Normal logic really just doesn't apply there.

to:

** It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is <i>Night [i]Night Vale.</i> [/i] Normal logic really just doesn't apply there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What's up with that inn in Switz where Cecil and his travelling partner keep rolling out of all night long? Wouldn't they, at some point, come up with the idea of closing the door or just sleeping at right angles to the slope instead of parallel to it?

to:

* What's up with that inn in Switz where Cecil and his travelling partner keep rolling out of all night long? Wouldn't they, at some point, come up with the idea of closing the door or just sleeping at right angles to the slope instead of parallel to it?it?
**It's heavily implied that the hostel, the traveling partner, and indeed the entire country of Switz did not in fact exist, possibly some sort of hallucination. Also, this is <i>Night Vale.</i> Normal logic really just doesn't apply there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-----
* What's up with that inn in Switz where Cecil and his travelling partner keep rolling out of all night long? Wouldn't they, at some point, come up with the idea of closing the door or just sleeping at right angles to the slope instead of parallel to it?

Top