Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TombRaider2018

Go To

OR

Added: 838

Changed: 339

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She had ''not'' accepted that her father was dead. She thought he might still be alive somehow, and she went to the island in hopes of finding him. Of course that still leaves us with the question of why she didn't just sign the form declaring his death and then go look for him anyway, but I suppose that's just a point of pride for her. She won't sign the form if she doesn't believe it.



* Why wasn't Himiko simply cremated in the first place? In shinto cremation appeases the spirit of the dead, while in materialistic world it is the best way to get rid of any deadly plague. And since this version of Himiko was a vanilla mortal, there would be no real hindrances to that plan, even considering her TouchOfDeath.

to:

** Probably the same way that Lara's dad knew about it. They found some ancient texts or whatever.
* Why wasn't Himiko simply cremated in the first place? In shinto cremation appeases the spirit of the dead, while in materialistic world it is the best way to get rid of any deadly plague. And since this version of Himiko was a vanilla mortal, there would be no real hindrances to that plan, even considering her TouchOfDeath.TouchOfDeath.
** Maybe they were worried that cremation would simply spread her death-touch into the air, which would kill everybody.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The idea isn't that Lara made a fatal mistake by giving Ana control; Ana was ''already'' in control. That's how she was able to fund Trinity in the first place. The idea is simply that now Lara is ''aware'' of what Ana's been up to, because she happened to look over the books after she signed the death declaration. In theory she could fire Ana immediately, but I think the idea is that Ana has been at this for so long that she'd probably have some ace up her sleeve, some complicated legal claim that Lara wouldn't necessarily know how to handle. The writers were probably leaving it vague because they weren't sure exactly where this would go in the sequel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe Trinity wasn't sure whether the island actually had anything important on it, and they didn't want to waste resources on something that might not pay off. Plus it could be a punishment for Mathias. He was supposed to find the tomb within 6 months or whatever, and when he failed they just said "You don't get to leave till you finish the job."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But Wiki/TheOtherWiki has a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales section]] about it.

to:

** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But Wiki/TheOtherWiki Website/TheOtherWiki has a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales section]] about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Removing Ana as Lara's attorney (and presumably CEO and director of Croft Holdings and a bunch of key subsidiaries, and possibly a trustee of the Croft Family Trust(s)) would take time, which would in turn give Trinity time to arrange a fatal accident for Lara, or even merely one that leaves Lara incapacitated, and Ana in control.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How does Trinity know what's really on the island?

to:

* How does Trinity know what's really on the island?island?
* Why wasn't Himiko simply cremated in the first place? In shinto cremation appeases the spirit of the dead, while in materialistic world it is the best way to get rid of any deadly plague. And since this version of Himiko was a vanilla mortal, there would be no real hindrances to that plan, even considering her TouchOfDeath.

Added: 52

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Just because she'd written her father off at that point, doesn't mean she wanted to track in his footsteps. When he left her, she felt betrayed, and effectively wanted nothing to do with him any longer. The only reason she came back was because she was told what would happen if she didn't [note]namely the British Government would liquidate the company and its assets, including the house she grew up in [/note]. It was only after she was handed the puzzle box that she decided to look for her father.

to:

** Just because she'd written her father off at that point, doesn't mean she wanted to track in his footsteps. When he left her, she felt betrayed, and effectively wanted nothing to do with him any longer. The only reason she came back was because she was told what would happen if she didn't [note]namely [[note]]namely the British Government would liquidate the company and its assets, including the house she grew up in [/note]. in.[[/note]] It was only after she was handed the puzzle box that she decided to look for her father.father.
* How does Trinity know what's really on the island?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Firearms are exceptionally loud, and firing an AK47 or M4 at all would give her position away instantly. Also keep in mind that this Lara has not had ample time to train with firearms yet, but has plenty of practice with a bow. As for why this is the case, just remember that in the UK, there are very strict rules on firearms, and even for someone who's wealthy, getting a firearm without a clear need for one, is not an easy task.

to:

** Firearms are exceptionally loud, and firing an AK47 [=AK47=] or M4 at all would give her position away instantly. Also keep in mind that this Lara has not had ample time to train with firearms yet, but has plenty of practice with a bow. As for why this is the case, just remember that in the UK, there are very strict rules on firearms, and even for someone who's wealthy, getting a firearm without a clear need for one, is not an easy task.

Added: 738

Changed: 548

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't Lara sign the papers, getting access to the Croft fortune and resources, and then assemble a large and well equipped expedition to the island? At that point of the movie she already had accepted that her father was dead.

to:

** Firearms are exceptionally loud, and firing an AK47 or M4 at all would give her position away instantly. Also keep in mind that this Lara has not had ample time to train with firearms yet, but has plenty of practice with a bow. As for why this is the case, just remember that in the UK, there are very strict rules on firearms, and even for someone who's wealthy, getting a firearm without a clear need for one, is not an easy task.
* Why didn't Lara sign the papers, getting access to the Croft fortune and resources, and then assemble a large and well equipped expedition to the island? At that point of the movie she already had accepted that her father was dead.dead.
** Just because she'd written her father off at that point, doesn't mean she wanted to track in his footsteps. When he left her, she felt betrayed, and effectively wanted nothing to do with him any longer. The only reason she came back was because she was told what would happen if she didn't [note]namely the British Government would liquidate the company and its assets, including the house she grew up in [/note]. It was only after she was handed the puzzle box that she decided to look for her father.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't Lara go back and get the gun that guy who'd been tracking her had, instead of going off to the rescue with only the bow and arrow?

to:

* Why didn't Lara go back and get the gun that guy who'd been tracking her had, instead of going off to the rescue with only the bow and arrow?arrow?
* Why didn't Lara sign the papers, getting access to the Croft fortune and resources, and then assemble a large and well equipped expedition to the island? At that point of the movie she already had accepted that her father was dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But TheOtherWiki has a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales section]] about it.

to:

** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But TheOtherWiki Wiki/TheOtherWiki has a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales section]] about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't Trinity just send more people and resources to the island over the course of seven years so they can cover more grounds? The end of the film shows that at least air transport is still available even if the sea is dangerous. Putting Mathias in charge and basically marooned him and his men (and there's probably just a couple dozen of them at most, the rest are all slave labors from shipwrecked sailors) on the island until they get the job done isn't going to let them achieve their goals sooner if they don't know where to look. Surely a worldwide conspiracy organization like Trinity can spare a few men for the cause.

to:

* Why didn't Trinity just send more people and resources to the island over the course of seven years so they can cover more grounds? The end of the film shows that at least air transport is still available even if the sea is dangerous. Putting Mathias in charge and basically marooned him and his men (and there's probably just a couple dozen of them at most, the rest are all slave labors from shipwrecked sailors) on the island until they get the job done isn't going to let them achieve their goals sooner if they don't know where to look. Surely a worldwide conspiracy organization like Trinity can spare a few men for the cause.cause.
* Why didn't Lara go back and get the gun that guy who'd been tracking her had, instead of going off to the rescue with only the bow and arrow?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** I meant ''after'' the climax when [[spoiler:Lara does sign over only to later find out Croft Holdings owns the company that was behind the BigBad.]]

to:

*** I meant ''after'' the climax when [[spoiler:Lara does sign over only to later find out Croft Holdings owns the company that was behind the movie's BigBad.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** I meant ''after'' the climax when [[spoiler:Lara does sign over only to later find out Croft Holdings owns the company that was behind the BigBad.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't Trinity just send more people to the island over the course of seven years so they can cover more grounds? The end of the film shows that at least air transport is still available even if the sea is dangerous. Putting Mathias in charge and basically marooned him and his men (and there's probably just a couple dozen of them at most, the rest are all slave labors from shipwrecked sailors) on the island until they get the job done isn't going to let them achieve their goals sooner if they don't know where to look. Surely a worldwide conspiracy organization like Trinity can spare a few men for the cause.

to:

* Why didn't Trinity just send more people and resources to the island over the course of seven years so they can cover more grounds? The end of the film shows that at least air transport is still available even if the sea is dangerous. Putting Mathias in charge and basically marooned him and his men (and there's probably just a couple dozen of them at most, the rest are all slave labors from shipwrecked sailors) on the island until they get the job done isn't going to let them achieve their goals sooner if they don't know where to look. Surely a worldwide conspiracy organization like Trinity can spare a few men for the cause.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lara didn't want to acknowledge that her father was truly dead, and, in refusing to sign the papers, she can hold out hope that he will return. I think it's less about the legal ramifications, and more about her emotions and acknowledgement.

to:

** Lara didn't want to acknowledge that her father was truly dead, and, in refusing to sign the papers, she can hold out hope that he will return. I think it's less about the legal ramifications, and more about her emotions and acknowledgement.acknowledgement.
* Why didn't Trinity just send more people to the island over the course of seven years so they can cover more grounds? The end of the film shows that at least air transport is still available even if the sea is dangerous. Putting Mathias in charge and basically marooned him and his men (and there's probably just a couple dozen of them at most, the rest are all slave labors from shipwrecked sailors) on the island until they get the job done isn't going to let them achieve their goals sooner if they don't know where to look. Surely a worldwide conspiracy organization like Trinity can spare a few men for the cause.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But TheOtherWiki has a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales section]] about it.

to:

** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But TheOtherWiki has a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales section]] about it.it.
** Lara didn't want to acknowledge that her father was truly dead, and, in refusing to sign the papers, she can hold out hope that he will return. I think it's less about the legal ramifications, and more about her emotions and acknowledgement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But TheOtherWiki has a [[section https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales]] about it.

to:

** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But TheOtherWiki has a [[section https://en.[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales]] org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales section]] about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How exactly does the power-of-attorney work in the United Kingdom? [[spoiler:The movie treats it like Lara couldn't take it back once she gave it.]]

to:

* How exactly does the power-of-attorney work in the United Kingdom? [[spoiler:The movie treats it like Lara couldn't take it back once she gave it.]]]]
** Perhaps it was done for dramatic effect and sequel bait? But TheOtherWiki has a [[section https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_attorney#England_and_Wales]] about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How exactly does the power-of-attorney works in the United Kingdom? [[spoiler:The movie treats it like Lara couldn't take it back once she gave it.]]

to:

* How exactly does the power-of-attorney works work in the United Kingdom? [[spoiler:The movie treats it like Lara couldn't take it back once she gave it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* How exactly does the power-of-attorney works in the United Kingdom? [[spoiler:The movie treats it like Lara couldn't take it back once she gave it.]]

Top