Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TheHitchhikersGuideToTheGalaxy

Go To

OR

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


::But mostly the only thing that passes between them that could be construed as showing affection is that they spend time in each other's company even when they could avoid it. Did they get along better on Earth? Did Ford think exploring the galaxy would make Arthur more fun to be around? Did he not have any more agreeable friends? Is he just very reserved about his presumable friendliness toward Arthur? Or are they just stuck together by authorial fiat[[hottip:*:[[StealthPun dohohoho]] in order to have a StraightManAndWiseGuy? And what's the deal with the fact they seem to increasingly dislike each other throughout the series?

to:

::But mostly the only thing that passes between them that could be construed as showing affection is that they spend time in each other's company even when they could avoid it. Did they get along better on Earth? Did Ford think exploring the galaxy would make Arthur more fun to be around? Did he not have any more agreeable friends? Is he just very reserved about his presumable friendliness toward Arthur? Or are they just stuck together by authorial fiat[[hottip:*:[[StealthPun dohohoho]] fiat[[note]][[StealthPun dohohoho]][[/note]] in order to have a StraightManAndWiseGuy? And what's the deal with the fact they seem to increasingly dislike each other throughout the series?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Two possibilities: either she's saying that women can already understand others' perspectives, or s

to:

** Two possibilities: either she's saying that women can already understand others' perspectives, or ss
** Trillian was being comically sexist (that is, comically in the sense of the movie, not the character, and don't tell me it wasn't funny because I'd agree with you). She was saying that only TheUnfairSex ''needs'' to be hit by the gun to see someone else's point of view. It's like Bruce banner in ''Film/TheAvengers'': "That's my secret, Cap; I'm ''always angry''."

Changed: 439

Removed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** I've always liked to think that the implication of the mathematical error is that life, the universe and everything is just really, ''really'' bad at math.



** Two possibilities: either she's saying that women can already understand others' perspectives, or she's saying Zaphod is a big sissy girl. I think she said she's "already a woman", suggesting the latter. But aside from the fact he wears nail polish and was shouting from offscreen that he was wearing her underwear at some point, your guess is as good as mine why she'd say that.
----

to:

** Two possibilities: either she's saying that women can already understand others' perspectives, or she's saying Zaphod is a big sissy girl. I think she said she's "already a woman", suggesting the latter. But aside from the fact he wears nail polish and was shouting from offscreen that he was wearing her underwear at some point, your guess is as good as mine why she'd say that.
----
s
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Meet Douglas Adams. For all the jokes, he had a pretty depressing view of the universe in many ways.

Changed: 93

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** MAybe they mated with those humans and also evolution?

to:

** MAybe Maybe they mated with those humans and also evolution?
** I've always assumed they didn't survive and Arthur just jumped to the wrong conclusion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Two possibilities: either she's saying that women can already understand others' perspectives, or she's saying Zaphod is a big sissy girl. I think she said she's "already a woman", suggesting the latter. But aside from the fact he wears nail polish and was shouting from offscreen that he was wearing her underwear at some point, your guess is as good as mine why she'd say that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* So, when Zaphod attempts to use the Point-of-View gun on Trillian, she says something along the lines of "It won't work on me, I'm a woman." Um, what? Why exactly does that make her supposedly immune to it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's actually several instances across books of Arthur reading alien text just fine--"Do not press this button again", the novels on the depressing planet in ''MostlyHarmless'', etc--my personal theory is that for whatever reason the Babel fish just can't do cursive.

to:

** There's actually several instances across books of Arthur reading alien text just fine--"Do not press this button again", the novels on the depressing planet in ''MostlyHarmless'', ''Literature/MostlyHarmless'', etc--my personal theory is that for whatever reason the Babel fish just can't do cursive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Send Arthur ''et al'' to the Restaurant At The End Of The universe, where they discover that the Krikkitmen are plotting to destroy the universe early and disrupt causality. As the gang tries to stop the plot, toss them across time and space, the B Ark, Slartibartfast, etc.

to:

*** Send Arthur ''et al'' to the Restaurant At The at the End Of The of the universe, where they discover that the Krikkitmen are plotting to destroy the universe early and disrupt causality. As the gang tries to stop the plot, toss them across time and space, the B Ark, Slartibartfast, etc.



* The rundown of the universe's statistics in ''TheRestaurantAtTheEndOfTheUniverse'' is funny, but it has a very basic math mistake. It says that if the universe is infinitely large, it should contain an infinite number of planets, but that since not all planets are inhabited, there must be a finite number of inhabited planets, and thus a finite total population. Dividing a finite number by infinity gets you "as near to nothing as makes no odds," so the average population of each world in the universe is zero; therefore, "any people you may meet from time to time are merely the product of a deranged imagination." This would certainly explain a lot about the universe, but it's fundamentally flawed. It's true (as we here on Earth can easily see) that not all planets are inhabited, but that doesn't mean a finite population in an infinite universe. Consider the natural numbers (1, 2, 3, 4, and so on.) There are, of course, infinitely many of them. Not all of them are even, and yet there are still infinitely many even natural numbers. So a universe with infinitely many planets could have both infinitely many inhabited ones and infinitely many uninhabited ones, for an infinite total population.

to:

* The rundown of the universe's statistics in ''TheRestaurantAtTheEndOfTheUniverse'' ''Literature/TheRestaurantAtTheEndOfTheUniverse'' is funny, but it has a very basic math mistake. It says that if the universe is infinitely large, it should contain an infinite number of planets, but that since not all planets are inhabited, there must be a finite number of inhabited planets, and thus a finite total population. Dividing a finite number by infinity gets you "as near to nothing as makes no odds," so the average population of each world in the universe is zero; therefore, "any people you may meet from time to time are merely the product of a deranged imagination." This would certainly explain a lot about the universe, but it's fundamentally flawed. It's true (as we here on Earth can easily see) that not all planets are inhabited, but that doesn't mean a finite population in an infinite universe. Consider the natural numbers (1, 2, 3, 4, and so on.) There are, of course, infinitely many of them. Not all of them are even, and yet there are still infinitely many even natural numbers. So a universe with infinitely many planets could have both infinitely many inhabited ones and infinitely many uninhabited ones, for an infinite total population.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->"Hey, will you get this, Earthman," interrupted Zaphod. "You are a last generation product of that computer matrix, right, and you were there right up to the moment your planet got the finger, yeah?"
-->"Er ..."
-->"So your brain was an organic part of the penultimate configuration of the computer programme," said Ford, rather lucidly he thought.
:::Basically, to continue the computer thing, Arthur represents the last known good configuration of the Earth. Trillian might be missing some information since she's been out and about in the galaxy for the past six months. They're trying to be completionists about it, I guess. But I don't know why they didn't go for her brain before they knew Arthur's was an option. I'd have to assume that it's just that they like her. She takes care of them, and even Marvin apparently likes her, so maybe she's just very likable.

to:

-->"Hey, --->"Hey, will you get this, Earthman," interrupted Zaphod. "You are a last generation product of that computer matrix, right, and you were there right up to the moment your planet got the finger, yeah?"
-->"Er ...--->"Er ..."
-->"So --->"So your brain was an organic part of the penultimate configuration of the computer programme," said Ford, rather lucidly he thought.
:::Basically, ::Basically, to continue the computer thing, Arthur represents the last known good configuration of the Earth. Trillian might be missing some information since she's been out and about in the galaxy for the past six months. They're trying to be completionists about it, I guess. But I don't know why they didn't go for her brain before they knew Arthur's was an option. I'd have to assume that it's just that they like her. She takes care of them, and even Marvin apparently likes her, so maybe she's just very likable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


::Basically, to continue the computer thing, Arthur represents the last known good configuration of the Earth. Trillian might be missing some information since she's been out and about in the galaxy for the past six months. They're trying to be completionists about it, I guess. But I don't know why they didn't go for her brain before they knew Arthur's was an option. I'd have to assume that it's just that they like her. She takes care of them, and even Marvin apparently likes her, so maybe she's just very likable.

to:

::Basically, :::Basically, to continue the computer thing, Arthur represents the last known good configuration of the Earth. Trillian might be missing some information since she's been out and about in the galaxy for the past six months. They're trying to be completionists about it, I guess. But I don't know why they didn't go for her brain before they knew Arthur's was an option. I'd have to assume that it's just that they like her. She takes care of them, and even Marvin apparently likes her, so maybe she's just very likable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Ford and Zaphod attempt to relay the explanation:
-->"Hey, will you get this, Earthman," interrupted Zaphod. "You are a last generation product of that computer matrix, right, and you were there right up to the moment your planet got the finger, yeah?"
-->"Er ..."
-->"So your brain was an organic part of the penultimate configuration of the computer programme," said Ford, rather lucidly he thought.
::Basically, to continue the computer thing, Arthur represents the last known good configuration of the Earth. Trillian might be missing some information since she's been out and about in the galaxy for the past six months. They're trying to be completionists about it, I guess. But I don't know why they didn't go for her brain before they knew Arthur's was an option. I'd have to assume that it's just that they like her. She takes care of them, and even Marvin apparently likes her, so maybe she's just very likable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why do the mice need Arthur's brain specifically? If all they need is a human brain, why couldn't they just take Trillian's without having to go the effort of finding Arthur?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** VitriolicBestBuds, OppositesAttract, something along those lines. I can only presume that, back on Earth, Ford was okay with having a few quiet moments and Arthur was fine being dragged to the occasional party, and mostly meeting each other somewhere in the middle. Out in space, though, Ford has limitless and increasingly bizarre options he can act on after years stranded on dull old Earth, and Arthur doesn't have much in the way of chances to opt out. I can see how that could build some resentment--especially given that twice Arthur had a shot at peace and contentment and twice it got thoroughly wrecked when Ford showed up.
:: Given, though, that that's a load of WMG, the simple, Doylist explanation is that Adams didn't give characterization a whole lot of thought when writing this franchise.

to:

** VitriolicBestBuds, OppositesAttract, something along those lines. I can only presume that, back on Earth, Ford was okay with having a few quiet moments and Arthur was fine being dragged to the occasional party, and mostly meeting each other somewhere in the middle. Out in space, though, Ford has limitless and increasingly bizarre options he can act on after years stranded on dull old Earth, and Arthur doesn't have much in the way of chances to opt out. I can see how that could build some resentment--especially given that twice Arthur had a shot at peace and contentment and twice it got thoroughly wrecked when Ford showed up. \n:: Given, \\
I disagree,
though, that that's a load of WMG, they don't have any friendship moments (my favorite's probably them watching ''Casablanca'' together in ''SLATFATF''), as well as the simple, Doylist explanation is idea that Adams didn't give characterization a whole lot they get ''increasingly'' less fond of thought one another. (Keep in mind that Arthur is already having a rough time of it in ''Mostly Harmless'' when writing this franchise. Ford shows up, and less inclined than usual to put up with his bullshit. After the scene in the woods they seem to get on alright.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


: Given, though, that that's a load of WMG, the simple, Doylist explanation is that Adams didn't give characterization a whole lot of thought when writing this franchise.

to:

: :: Given, though, that that's a load of WMG, the simple, Doylist explanation is that Adams didn't give characterization a whole lot of thought when writing this franchise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** VitriolicBestBuds, OppositesAttract, something along those lines. I can only presume that, back on Earth, Ford was okay with having a few quiet moments and Arthur was fine being dragged to the occasional party, and mostly meeting each other somewhere in the middle. Out in space, though, Ford has limitless and increasingly bizarre options he can act on after years stranded on dull old Earth, and Arthur doesn't have much in the way of chances to opt out. I can see how that could build some resentment--especially given that twice Arthur had a shot at peace and contentment and twice it got thoroughly wrecked when Ford showed up.
: Given, though, that that's a load of WMG, the simple, Doylist explanation is that Adams didn't give characterization a whole lot of thought when writing this franchise.

Added: 763

Changed: 149

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The one part of the series which really, genuinely makes me scratch my head the most is that Ford went to the bother of rescuing Arthur from the demise of the Earth, suggesting that Arthur was the best friend he had while on Earth, despite generally acting as though he really just doesn't like him very much. They seem like they ''should'' be HeterosexualLifePartners, but they aren't. Admittedly, they do have a few {{Friendship Moment}}s...

to:

* The one part of the series which really, genuinely makes me scratch my head the most is that Ford went to the bother of rescuing Arthur from the demise of the Earth, suggesting that Arthur was the best friend he had while on Earth, despite generally acting as though he really just doesn't like him very much. They The cracks are already beginning to show quite early on:
-->Ford rounded on Arthur with an angry flash in his eyes. Now he felt he was back on home ground he suddenly began to resent having lumbered himself with this ignorant primitive who knew as much about the affairs of the Galaxy as an Ilford-based gnat knew about life in Peking. (Ch. 13, ''The Hitch Hiker's Guide to the Galaxy'')
::Narrative convention makes it
seem like they ''should'' be HeterosexualLifePartners, based on how much time they spend together, through thick and thin and all that, but they aren't.really pretty much aren't. With HeterosexualLifePartners, there's usually some acknowledgement of how close they are, but since Ford and Arthur aren't really very close at all, there of course isn't. Admittedly, they do have a few {{Friendship Moment}}s...



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* The one part of the series which really, genuinely makes me scratch my head the most is that Ford went to the bother of rescuing Arthur from the demise of the Earth, suggesting that Arthur was the best friend he had while on Earth, despite generally acting as though he really just doesn't like him very much. They seem like they ''should'' be HeterosexualLifePartners, but they aren't. Admittedly, they do have a few {{Friendship Moment}}s...
-->"I'm very glad to see you again, Arthur," he added.

-->Arthur shook his head in a sudden access of emotion and bewilderment. (Ch. 2, ''Life, the Universe, and Everything'')
::But mostly the only thing that passes between them that could be construed as showing affection is that they spend time in each other's company even when they could avoid it. Did they get along better on Earth? Did Ford think exploring the galaxy would make Arthur more fun to be around? Did he not have any more agreeable friends? Is he just very reserved about his presumable friendliness toward Arthur? Or are they just stuck together by authorial fiat[[hottip:*:[[StealthPun dohohoho]] in order to have a StraightManAndWiseGuy? And what's the deal with the fact they seem to increasingly dislike each other throughout the series?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* Whenever I try to figure out what the forfeit is for the Janx spirit drinking game, as described in Chapter 1 of the first book, anything I imagine seems either overly or insufficiently obscene. Does anyone whose mind has a correctly calibrated degree of dirtiness want to offer some suggestions for what fresh hell is being implied here?
-->As soon as a predetermined quantity had been consumed, the final loser would have to perform a forfeit, which was usually obscenely biological.

-->Ford Prefect usually played to lose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**Does the book specifically say that what is written appears to Arthur as English? I mean, if Earth was obliterated and you could never come back and were left to wander the universe, you'd probably pick up on a few other languages. Arthur never learns to speak any of these languages because of the Babelfish, but he can read them :) As for the buttons in Heart of Gold, maybe those were programable and were set to English because of Trillian?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** If black and white are the ''same'', though, it's just another black spot on black pavement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Yeah. Every try to imagine infinity? Most people have a concet of infinity that's really, really small compared to even the big numbers used in real mathematics. The TPV just makes your brain ''understand'' those numbers. And then you start screaming and never stop, because people aren't designed for that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**MAybe they mated with those humans and also evolution?

Added: 83

Changed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None














* It could simply be that non of this is Trillian's fault: The guide 2.0 explicitly has the power to abusively retcon reality. The Guide 2.0 needed a emotional cripple to work with so it ensured Random's life was pure crapsack. Whatever bad (or unforgivably horrible) decisions Trillian made were the result of every possible variable leading to those decisions being made. Or at least, that's how I'd handwave it.


to:

* ** It could simply be that non of this is Trillian's fault: The guide 2.0 explicitly has the power to abusively retcon reality. The Guide 2.0 needed a emotional cripple to work with so it ensured Random's life was pure crapsack. Whatever bad (or unforgivably horrible) decisions Trillian made were the result of every possible variable leading to those decisions being made. Or at least, that's how I'd handwave it.




* On a related note, how could deducing that Black = White result in anyone getting killed at a zebra crossing? A zebra crossing with its black and white bars inverted would ''still'' look like a zebra crossing, and still indicate where it's safe to cross the road.

to:

* ** On a related note, how could deducing that Black = White result in anyone getting killed at a zebra crossing? A zebra crossing with its black and white bars inverted would ''still'' look like a zebra crossing, and would still plainly indicate where it's safe to cross the road.





Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

** Animals may not provide the right psychic emanations for the Fish to pick up on.


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* On a related note, how could deducing that Black = White result in anyone getting killed at a zebra crossing? A zebra crossing with its black and white bars inverted would ''still'' look like a zebra crossing, and still indicate where it's safe to cross the road.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How did the Golgafrinchams manage to survive long enough to overtake pre-historic humans if they were as utterly incompetent as they seem to be, they have no survival skills, no technology, no leadership and Ford states that most of them died in the first winter.

to:

* How did the Golgafrinchams manage to survive long enough to overtake pre-historic humans if they were as utterly incompetent as they seem to be, they be? They have no survival skills, no technology, no leadership and Ford states that most of them died in the first winter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*How did the Golgafrinchams manage to survive long enough to overtake pre-historic humans if they were as utterly incompetent as they seem to be, they have no survival skills, no technology, no leadership and Ford states that most of them died in the first winter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Sounds to me like he enjoys the state of being depressed. The act of complaining about everything that happens is what keeps him going. And it obviously works well enough to keep him going for three times the lifetime of the universe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**** Friend, you're thinking of things in a three-dimensional context. The universe does not have an actual outer boundary. Even if it is finite, there would be no boundary. Instead, the universe would wrap around itself so that, if a traveler were chugging along in a straight line at impossible speeds, they'd eventually return to the place they left from. If you're familiar with the balloon analogy for universal expansion, we're basically just sitting on the surface of the balloon as it expands. Light would also only travel along the balloon's surface so that things that are far away would seem to be moving away from us very very quickly. But, in truth, both we and the observed object are actually traveling away from the centre of the balloon (which in our 11-dimensional universe would be in a direction that we can't point to). An infinite universe works in a similar fashion, but it's a lot more difficult to wrap one's head around it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* It could simply be that non of this is Trillian's fault: The guide 2.0 explicitly has the power to abusively retcon reality. The Guide 2.0 needed a emotional cripple to work with so it ensured Random's life was pure crapsack. Whatever bad (or unforgivably horrible) decisions Trillian made were the result of every possible variable leading to those decisions being made. Or at least, that's how I'd handwave it.

Top