Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TheBigBangTheory

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Howard is quite capable of that. Look at the later episode where he continually brought up his sad, fatherless childhood to make Bernadette feel sorry and have sex with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** But how many costume-hire places would have those outfits available? They're fairly obscure and unlikely to be recognised by people who don't read comic books, but ''everybody'' knows Wonder Woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** There is a difference though. While those guys accidentally proved Super Asymmetry, they at least did it via an experiment they set up and ran independently. Look at it this way, if Sheldon and Amy had set up that experiment and then said to those guys "press the experiment start button" because they'd randomly turned up and expressed interest in what the experiment was for, would those two have been included in the Super Asymmetry Nobel? Almost certainly not. It's the same with what Leonard said, someone independently discovering something, even by accident, is one thing, only doing it because you pressed a button on something already setup by someone else, at the invitation of that other person and not of your own initiative, does not deserve any credit.

Added: 712

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** That might work if Penny independantly set up a way for her to "see it first". But she didnt, she looked through the telescope, set up by Raj, at Raj's invitation, didnt change anything, and only took the photo on Raj's instruction, she didnt even take the photo on her own initiative. She didnt do anything. Your examples dont work because a) someone else independantly set up the machines that someone else built and used them under their own power to find something and b) Penny's entire contribution to "seeing it" was to be told "look through this aperature" and then "take the picture". She had no independant contribution to it. If someone had dropped a sandwich on to the take photo button they would have got the same outcome, as Raj had already set it all up to do that.

to:

*** That might work if Penny independantly set up a way for her to "see it first". But she didnt, didn't, she looked through the telescope, set up by Raj, at Raj's invitation, didnt change anything, and only took the photo on Raj's instruction, she didnt even take the photo on her own initiative. She didnt do anything. Your examples dont work because a) someone else independantly set up the machines that someone else built and used them under their own power to find something and b) Penny's entire contribution to "seeing it" was to be told "look through this aperature" and then "take the picture". She had no independant contribution to it. If someone had dropped a sandwich on to the take photo button they would have got the same outcome, as Raj had already set it all up to do that.that.
*** While Penny only happened to look in at the right moment, at the right time, it is shown in the show that is all that is needed for the person to rceive scientific acclaim. Look at the final season arc for Sheldon and Amy's Nobel. They are like Raj. They set things up, they conceived the theory, but it was the two who proved the theory that were in hot contention for the Nobel over Amy and Sheldon. Likewise Leonard mentions it was the ones who discovered evidence of the Big Bang over the theorists in getting the Nobel. Penny is the practical part here. She saw it first. She took the photo. Raj was the backseat driving. Sharing credit for the discovery is the right thing to do in this case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* I always thought Sheldon had a bit of a point. It's his parking spot, given to him as part of his benefits package, so why should he just give it up? It's not like they offered him something in return (eg slightly more money). Logically, he should have just bought a cheap car and parked it there and left it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Part of the issue for this seems to be the impression that the guys ruined Sheldon's experiment. That isnt true. In the episode when they get back home Leonard says how they kept all the original data and that could be published, so the experiment itself, while not giving the results Sheldon hoped for, was still valid, so no one is getting fired over that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** No one went to Antarctica
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Sheldon for his condescending attitude to the others. It wasnt Sheldon's "OCD" which caused him to obsess, it was Sheldon thinking he's much smarter than Howard so he should obviously be able to figure of the trick too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Mary probably figured that this was something the boys had to fix themselves.

Added: 362

Changed: 337

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder: Georgie initial refusal to come to Sheldon's wedding]]
Certainly the fact that Sheldon and Georgie made up was heartwarming. However, I do have one minor question. Why didn't Mary contact MeeMaw to settle the dispute? As seen, MeeMaw is still a formidable women even in her nineties. Presumably she still has persuasive powers over Georgie.

to:

[[/folder: Georgie [[/folder]]

[[folder: Georgie's
initial refusal to come to Sheldon's wedding]]
wedding]]
Certainly the fact that Sheldon and Georgie made up was heartwarming. However, I do have one minor question. Why didn't Mary contact MeeMaw to settle the dispute? As seen, MeeMaw is still a formidable women even in her nineties. Presumably she still has persuasive powers over Georgie.Georgie.
[[/folder]]

Added: 285

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]][[/folder: Georgie initial refusal to come to Sheldon's wedding]]
Certainly the fact that Sheldon and Georgie made up was heartwarming. However, I do have one minor question. Why didn't Mary contact MeeMaw to settle the dispute? As seen, MeeMaw is still a formidable women even in her nineties. Presumably she still has persuasive powers over Georgie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In any case, Sheldon being a jerk is [[{{ButForMeItWasTuesday}} a Tuesday]] for the gang. It wouldn't exactly be surprising for Leonard and Penny to just roll their eyes, FacePalm, and move on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** First of all, he probably doesn't have that much self-confidence, especially because they're almost his only friends. Secondly, it seems that they do buy stuff once in a while, and given how poor business is for Stuart, he'll take people coming in and only once in a while buying stuff over them never coming.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And don't forgrt "Publish or Perish"!

to:

** And don't forgrt forget "Publish or Perish"!

Added: 40

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sheldon has no room in his apartment for any kind of serious layout with O guage he insists on. Later he discvers that smaller gauges are even more fun an sets up an HO layout in his room. He invites his former mortal enemy Wil Wheaton in to watch him play and even lets him blow the gtrsain whistle

to:

** Sheldon has no room in his apartment for any kind of serious layout with O guage he insists on. Later he discvers that smaller gauges are even more fun an sets up an HO layout in his room. He invites his former mortal enemy Wil Wheaton in to watch him play and even lets him blow the gtrsain train whistle


Added DiffLines:

** And don't forgrt "Publish or Perish"!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Sheldon has no room in his apartment for any kind of serious layout with O guage he insists on. Later he discvers that smaller gauges are even more fun an sets up an HO layout in his room. He invites his former mortal enemy Wil Wheaton in to watch him play and even lets him blow the gtrsain whistle
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It should be noted that nothing was "ruined". A line from Leonard early in the episode says they kept all the original, accurate data and Sheldon could publish that.

to:

*** It should be noted that in terms of the experiment, nothing was "ruined". A line from Leonard early in the episode says they kept all the original, accurate data and Sheldon could publish that. It wouldnt prove what he wanted it to, but he could publish the proper results.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It should be noted that nothing was "ruined". A line from Leonard early in the episode says they kept all the original, accurate data and Sheldon could publish that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**There wasnt just one match, a line near the start from Gablehouser says its a "preliminary match". To win the trophy they had to go on and win more unseen matches. They celebrated like the did after that match because they had beaten Sheldon.

Added: 254

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** because a table would also let everyone put their food down and eat while also coming with extra chairs for everyone to sit on.

to:

** because Because a table would also let everyone put their food down and eat while also coming with extra chairs for everyone to sit on.


Added DiffLines:

** In the case of Sheldon, at least, it may be a case of BunnyEarsLawyer--he's legitimately smart enough that the university may have decided that, short of him doing something ''really'' bad, they'll just look the other way so they can keep him around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Penny was really forced to jump over the roof or anything though. When she came up to them in the stairs they weee already near the top of that set of stairs, so if she waits another minute or two then they'll be on that landing and she can slip by and not be appreciably any later than she already was. Futher it's very unfair of her to yell at them for blocking the stairs. The lift doesnt work and they have just as much right to take something up the stairs to their appartment as any other tenant does. Would Penny have been happy with someone yelling at her for causing the stairs to be blocked when her tv cabinet thing early in season one is being taken up the stairs? Of course not.

to:

*** Penny was wasnt really forced to jump over the roof or anything though. When she came up to them in the stairs they weee were already near the top of that set of stairs, so if she waits another minute or two then they'll be on that landing and she can slip by and not be appreciably any later than she already was. Futher it's very unfair of her to yell at them for blocking the stairs. The lift doesnt work and they have just as much right to take something up the stairs to their appartment as any other tenant does. Would Penny have been happy with someone yelling at her for causing the stairs to be blocked when her tv cabinet thing early in season one is being taken up the stairs? Of course not.

Added: 694

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It tanked because, while she is very sexy, she's a terrible actress and the one field that might have not been a hinderenabce too (porn), she turned down the audition for.

to:

** It tanked because, while she is very sexy, she's a terrible actress and the one field that might have not been a hinderenabce hinderance too (porn), she turned down the audition for.


Added DiffLines:

***Penny was really forced to jump over the roof or anything though. When she came up to them in the stairs they weee already near the top of that set of stairs, so if she waits another minute or two then they'll be on that landing and she can slip by and not be appreciably any later than she already was. Futher it's very unfair of her to yell at them for blocking the stairs. The lift doesnt work and they have just as much right to take something up the stairs to their appartment as any other tenant does. Would Penny have been happy with someone yelling at her for causing the stairs to be blocked when her tv cabinet thing early in season one is being taken up the stairs? Of course not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[TheSimpsons Thaht is da johke.]] Sheldon would rather get the question wrong than admit that anyone, especially a janitor, knew something he didn't. The only reason he teamed up with the janitor at all is that he wanted to answer all the questions himself... it was basically the whole point of the episode.

to:

** [[TheSimpsons [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Thaht is da johke.]] Sheldon would rather get the question wrong than admit that anyone, especially a janitor, knew something he didn't. The only reason he teamed up with the janitor at all is that he wanted to answer all the questions himself... it was basically the whole point of the episode.



** [[TheSimpsons Thaht is da johke.]] Howard thinks he's a fashion plate and is wrong because he looks ridiculous. There's also probably something to the first reply since other people have pointed out that a lot of Howard's behaviors are out of lame "how to get girls" technique books (negging, faking subculture, magic tricks, etc.).

to:

** [[TheSimpsons [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Thaht is da johke.]] Howard thinks he's a fashion plate and is wrong because he looks ridiculous. There's also probably something to the first reply since other people have pointed out that a lot of Howard's behaviors are out of lame "how to get girls" technique books (negging, faking subculture, magic tricks, etc.).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***That might work if Penny independantly set up a way for her to "see it first". But she didnt, she looked through the telescope, set up by Raj, at Raj's invitation, didnt change anything, and only took the photo on Raj's instruction, she didnt even take the photo on her own initiative. She didnt do anything. Your examples dont work because a) someone else independantly set up the machines that someone else built and used them under their own power to find something and b) Penny's entire contribution to "seeing it" was to be told "look through this aperature" and then "take the picture". She had no independant contribution to it. If someone had dropped a sandwich on to the take photo button they would have got the same outcome, as Raj had already set it all up to do that.

Added: 907

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the Comet Polarization, why should we agree with Penny that she discovered the comet? Raj setup the telescope, invited Penny to look and told her how and when to take a picture. She looked through it, said she saw something, he said take a picture and she did.

She didnt move or refocus the telescope, she didnt even look through it or take the photo off her own initiative. She just pressed a button based on Raj's instructions with how Raj had set it up. Nothing about that is Penny discovering anything.

to:

In the "The Comet Polarization, Polarization", why should we agree with Penny that she discovered the comet? Raj setup the telescope, invited Penny to look and told her how and when to take a picture. She looked through it, said she saw something, he said take a picture and she did.

She didnt didn't move or refocus the telescope, she didnt even look through it or take the photo off her own initiative. She just pressed a button based on Raj's instructions with how Raj had set it up. Nothing about that is Penny discovering anything.anything.
* Because ''she saw it first.'' It doesn't matter who takes the photo or who pointed what where. If the astronemer doesn't recognize there is a comet in either their telescope or satellite imagery, then it doesn't mean they found it. The one who identifies the moving object gets the credit. According to this article from the early 2000s, [[https://www.wired.com/2002/05/now-anyone-can-discover-a-comet/ here]], hundreds of comets were discovered from people scouring public images from a satelite looking near the sun. It wasn't the scientists who built the machine or the ones who catalogued the photos, but the people who looked over the photos and noticed something in them that got the discovery. So, yes, Penny discovered it first. Raj verified it, likely checking it out the next night to confirm it was a moving object and not some other celestial body, but Penny is the first to ''see'' it.

Added: 245

Changed: 221

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the Comet Polarization, why do should we agree with Penny that she discovered it? Raj setup the telescope, invited Penny to look and told her how to take a picture. She looked, said she saw something, he said take a picture and she did. She didnt move or refocus the telescope,she didnt even take the photo of her own initiative. She pressed a button on how Raj had set it up. Nothing about that is Penny discovering anything.

to:

In the Comet Polarization, why do should we agree with Penny that she discovered it? the comet? Raj setup the telescope, invited Penny to look and told her how and when to take a picture. She looked, looked through it, said she saw something, he said take a picture and she did. did.

She didnt move or refocus the telescope,she telescope, she didnt even look through it or take the photo of off her own initiative. She just pressed a button based on Raj's instructions with how Raj had set it up. Nothing about that is Penny discovering anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the Comet Polarization, why do should we agree with Penny that she discovered it? Raj setup the telescope, invited Penny to look and told her how to take a picture. She looked, said she saw something, he said take a picture and she did. Nothing about that is Penny discovering anything.

to:

In the Comet Polarization, why do should we agree with Penny that she discovered it? Raj setup the telescope, invited Penny to look and told her how to take a picture. She looked, said she saw something, he said take a picture and she did. She didnt move or refocus the telescope,she didnt even take the photo of her own initiative. She pressed a button on how Raj had set it up. Nothing about that is Penny discovering anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Raj's telescope and Penny]]
In the Comet Polarization, why do should we agree with Penny that she discovered it? Raj setup the telescope, invited Penny to look and told her how to take a picture. She looked, said she saw something, he said take a picture and she did. Nothing about that is Penny discovering anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed a complaining entry, notifier sent.


[[/folder]]

[[folder: Amy's behaviour towards Sheldon]]
* If there was one thing that bugged me about the show, it's the fact that Amy kept trying to get more intimate with Sheldon and he wasn't interested - and we were supposed to laugh at it or sympathize with her. At one point, she even ''stores nightclothes IN HIS APARTMENT'' just in case Sheldon invited her to spend the night. How did this ''not'' raise any red flags that Amy is a ''stalker''?! Imagine if it were the other way around or Amy wasn't played by Mayim Bialik.

Top