Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TheBigBangTheory

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In Raj's case, Leonard rolls a die before announcing that Raj died. My guess is that Leonard is a dungeon master who prefers rolling saving throws for the players behind the DMing screen rather than having the players roll saving throws themselves, and Raj just failed a save-or-die vs. the cannon trap. In Sheldon's case, it's possible that the 'paralysis spell' was a homebrewed spell with no save, but it's more likely that the other players and the DM were just too shocked by his betrayal to insist on allowing saving throws.


Added DiffLines:

** Howard was the Dungeon Master for that game, and he once built a robot with six breasts. Running a setting where orcs have MultiBoobage is obviously AuthorAppeal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If Sheldon was hunting for a caretaker, he would have gone to Raj next. When he already called Howard seconds after Leonard bolted out of the room, Raj would have been next in line. The guys knew this and just skipped the next place to hide, and let some poor schmuck get roped into taking care of Sheldon (i.e. Penny).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** because a table would also let everyone put their food down and eat while also coming with extra chairs for everyone to sit on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** They most likely did - it just took ''that'' long for them to respond since there wasn't anyone with a disability around.
** RuleOfFunny - the writers probably lived with an indolent landlord.


Added DiffLines:

** More likely that Sheldon playing Bongos at 3 a.m caused their rent to start dropping. You get what you pay for.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Remember - apart from Penny and later on Bernadette and Amy (whose nerdy interests are treated as more "Acceptable"), the characters are ''nerds'' and social exiles. Social exiles and nerds generally grow up to be more inclusive of others... which is a good thing, but it also means that it's harder to evict genuinely toxic people like Sheldon from the group. Yeah, I get it, Sheldon became much much better as the series went on, but untile the last two or so seasons of the show, he had pretty much ''no'' positive traits whatsoever, which made me think he was like [[WesternAnimation/TheProudFamily Dijonay]] or [[WesternAnimation/AsToldByGinger Dodie]] - only friends due to inertia and proximity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Sheldon mentions the Pokemon anime via Ash, Pikachu, and Ash's catchphrase "I choose you!" and one episode has Penny mentioning Leonard having the cards. So that's at least one anime that has been referenced.


Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: The other apartment residents]]
* Why are the other people living in the apartment building and the landlord rarely, if at all, annoyed or even react to the things the main characters are doing? Like Sheldon playing bongos at 3 a.m. only Leonard and Penny show annoyance. Or when the guys are moving a time machine prop into Leonard and Sheldon's apartment, its only shown inconveniencing Penny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Also, Amy may not have minded dressing up in a Star Trek uniform in the privacy of Sheldon's apartment, but refused to be seen wearing it in public.

Added: 849

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Going back to the original point, instead of debating Sheldon's morality, never mind their reputations, how the hell did those three keep their jobs? I don't know how much an arctic expedition costs but I assume it is quite a lot, and they deliberately sabotage it. And if they, or anyone, tries the "Sheldon was an annoying A-hole" defense; They know him, Leonard has lived with him for several years, and Howard and Raj have speant much of their free time with them since he moved in, They know how difficult he can be, particularly when things don't go his way, and they know how much he annoys them, in the episode before the expedition they debate the possibility that they would struggle to deal with 3 months in isolation with Sheldon and ''decide'' to go with him anyway. Ultimately if they had refused Sheldon would've had to either pick a new team or decline, they weren't being forced into this and then they sabotaged the whole expedition. Frankly, for all the debatable morality of Sheldon as a character, the only way I can see that they weren't fired, is that Sheldon must've covered for them.

to:

** Going back to the original point, instead of debating Sheldon's morality, never mind their reputations, how the hell did those three keep their jobs? I don't know how much an arctic expedition costs but I assume it is quite a lot, and they deliberately sabotage it. And if they, or anyone, tries the "Sheldon was an annoying A-hole" defense; They know him, Leonard has lived with him for several years, and Howard and Raj have speant spent much of their free time with them since he moved in, They know how difficult he can be, particularly when things don't go his way, and they know how much he annoys them, in the episode before the expedition they debate the possibility that they would struggle to deal with 3 months in isolation with Sheldon and ''decide'' to go with him anyway. Ultimately if they had refused Sheldon would've had to either pick a new team or decline, they weren't being forced into this and then they sabotaged the whole expedition. Frankly, for all the debatable morality of Sheldon as a character, the only way I can see that they weren't fired, is that Sheldon must've covered for them.them.
*** Depends on how it was reported, really. The electric can opener which caused the interference was a standard piece of expedition equipment so Sheldon ought to have accounted for that. The other guys may just have recognised a pattern from when they were opening cans of food, one that Sheldon too ought to have noticed, and that doesn't really rise to malfeasance levels. It could be reported as unintended overlooked consequences of normal expedition life just as easily as being deliberately done to screw with Sheldon. So it all depends on how the incident is written up, and the University would probably much rather it be seen as a screw up rather than their scientists out to get each other. The latter is a far more embarrassing and damaging to the institution's reputation than a whoopsie screw up is. Also, RuleOfFunny as per page note.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Going back to the original point, instead of debating Sheldon's morality, never mind their reputations, how the hell did those three keep their jobs? I don't know how much an arctic expedition costs but I assume it is quite a lot, and they deliberately sabotage it. And if they, or anyone, tries the "Sheldon was an annoying A-hole" defense; They know him, Leonard has lived with him for several years, and Howard and Raj have speant much of their free time with them since he moved in, They know how difficult he can be, particularly when things don't go his way, and they know how much he annoys them, in the episode before the expedition they debate the possibility that they would struggle to deal with 3 months in isolation with Sheldon and ''decide'' to go with him anyway. Ultimately if they had refused Sheldon would've had to either pick a new team or decline, they weren't being forced into this and then they sabotaged the whole expedition. Frankly, for all the debatable morality of Sheldon as a character, the only way I can see that they weren't fired, is that Sheldon must've covered for them.


Added DiffLines:

** Simple, any fans that were pro Penny/Leonard and/or pro Sheldon disliked her, so when a plausible breakup reason came up they figured that was enough to just get rid of her.


Added DiffLines:

** I think that is either a plot hole or a statement on hospital funding issues, or possibly there really was some kind of outbreak going on that they didn't bring up and the hospital was out of secure rooms.


Added DiffLines:

** Plus wasn't it within the same day that he met up with her? He did have work and "My friend thinks she slept with me." isn't a good excuse for a day off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Presumably because if they had gone up to the actors and said "Okay, for realism's sake you guys are gonna need to put on weight over the course of the series" then they would all have turned down the show and it'd probably have been a stillborn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Why? Because it was free (important for Penny on her relatively low income) and it made Sheldon 1000 times happier than anything Penny could have chosen at a store. Penny might not be as bright as the rest of the gang but she’s smart enough to work that out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Yes, Sheldon's mother has a rural Texas accent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** My father who is now deceased was also a university professor in LA County working on a cure for colorectal cancer. He only made middle-income while working on machines that cost $500,000 each and his university's president only promised him money in the ''7 figures'' if he successfully materialized said cure.

to:

** My father who is now deceased was also a university professor in LA County working on a cure for colorectal cancer. He only made middle-income while working on machines that cost $500,000 each and his university's vice president only promised him money in the ''7 figures'' if he successfully materialized said cure.cure. After he died, the vice president donated to me a good amount of money.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** My father who is now deceased was also a university professor in LA County working on a cure for colorectal cancer. He only made middle-income while working on machines that cost $500,000 each and his university's president only promised him money if he successfully materialized said cure.

to:

** My father who is now deceased was also a university professor in LA County working on a cure for colorectal cancer. He only made middle-income while working on machines that cost $500,000 each and his university's president only promised him money in the ''7 figures'' if he successfully materialized said cure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** My father who is now deceased was also a university professor in LA County working on a cure for colorectal cancer. He only made middle-income while working on machines that cost $500,000 each and his university's president only promised him money if he successfully materialized said cure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Penny's borrowed money from both Leonard and Sheldon to pay rent. It wouldn't be shocking if it turns out that Penny has been borrowing money from other men with false, empty promises of ever paying them back. And we've been told that Penny likes to sleep with other men for money, which could explain why she keeps inviting a long list of men into her apartment.
** As Penny puts it, "I'm cute! I get by!" (Season 4's "The Cruciferous Vegetable Amplification")
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In another, he loans Penny a wad of cash that he keeps in a novelty can of snakes (not to mention "a couple of fifties in GreenLantern's ass" as Leonard puts it to Howard). He explains that he makes more money than he spends and just has extra thousands lying around that she's welcome to. That brought the question to mind of why he would want a roommate, since he seems to be so annoyed by people and doesn't need any help paying the rent, which seems more glaring than why there are occasionally money worries in the cast.

to:

** In another, he loans Penny a wad of cash that he keeps in a novelty can of snakes (not to mention "a couple of fifties in GreenLantern's ComicBook/GreenLantern's ass" as Leonard puts it to Howard). He explains that he makes more money than he spends and just has extra thousands lying around that she's welcome to. That brought the question to mind of why he would want a roommate, since he seems to be so annoyed by people and doesn't need any help paying the rent, which seems more glaring than why there are occasionally money worries in the cast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** 90% of '''sane''' Franchise/StarTrek fans hate Wesley the '''character''' and like or don't care about Wheaton the '''actor'''. Sheldon is the exact opposite for reasons set out in the [[MagicTheGathering Magic: The Gathering]] episode.

to:

** 90% of '''sane''' Franchise/StarTrek fans hate Wesley the '''character''' and like or don't care about Wheaton the '''actor'''. Sheldon is the exact opposite for reasons set out in the [[MagicTheGathering Magic: The Gathering]] TabletopGame/MagicTheGathering episode.



** It's just a riff on ultracommon/really weak cards in those sorts of card games. Basically crap cards they can stuff booster packs with to keep people buying them because "Oh crap not another enchanted bunny!" And like the troper above said it probably has a few combos where it's theoretically powerful. If Mystic Warlords of Ka'a is anything like the game it most obviously parodies ( MagicTheGathering ) I guarantee you someone out there has an Enchanted Bunny Deck that obliterates other decks just to prove it can be done.

to:

** It's just a riff on ultracommon/really weak cards in those sorts of card games. Basically crap cards they can stuff booster packs with to keep people buying them because "Oh crap not another enchanted bunny!" And like the troper above said it probably has a few combos where it's theoretically powerful. If Mystic Warlords of Ka'a is anything like the game it most obviously parodies ( MagicTheGathering TabletopGame/MagicTheGathering ) I guarantee you someone out there has an Enchanted Bunny Deck that obliterates other decks just to prove it can be done.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* We may find out later; I wouldn't be surprised if it ends up happening in Young Sheldon at some point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Universities often have indefinite-length visas that they can give to people they offer jobs to (as opposed to the individual applying for a visa to come and look for work in the US based on being skilled). So if the university was the one to offer him his position, they would be the sole determining factory of his residency, and if his employment there was terminated he would have had to apply for some other sort of visa, and immigration might want him to return to India until that application was processed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Star Trek movies are mainstream. Super, super mainstream. Tons of "normies" watch them without thinking they're nerdy in the slightest. (Especially the new ones, which were full of hot young actors and tons of action.) Lots of non-nerds even watch the show. Socially, you only turn into "one of those weird obsessed Trek nerds" if you can rattle off episode numbers (which some people can do even without realizing they're one of those weird obsessed Trek nerds), launch into random deep lore, or dress up and go to conventions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is actually one of the most accurate parts of the show. Wil Wheaton really is a washed-up has-been, recently admitting in a blog post that he quite literally can't remember the last time he got a role that wasn't preemptively offered to him. (While raging at and insulting all the casting directors that didn't hire him, which might help to explain it.) His career is actually worse off than it is in the show because he apparently couldn't even nail an audition for a bikini-wearing mutant orangutan even if he wanted to.

Added: 452

Changed: 463

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Roommate Agreement. He HAS to watch what Sheldon wants to watch.

to:

** Roommate Agreement. He HAS to watch what Sheldon wants to watch.
watch on the TV.
** Leonard perhaps secretly watches programs Sheldon doesn't approve of such as Babylon V on his laptop in his room.
** Sheldon and Leonard both enjoy some to many of the same sci-fi and action entertainment, such as Star Trek and Indiana Jones. In spite of their differences, they still see each other as friends and so they would agree it's more fun to watch something together than individually.
*** And if Leonard can't get Sheldon to watch it, he might just watch it with Penny instead as Penny usually doesn't object to the type of entertainment Leonard shows her.



* We see Leonard, Sheldon, Raj, Howard and Penny eating junk food all the time. They eat lots of unhealthy cuisine such as pizza, cheeseburgers, fries, Chicken Nuggets and Chinese take-out food. How are they not all obese?

to:

* We see Leonard, Sheldon, Raj, Howard and Penny eating junk food all the time. They eat lots of unhealthy cuisine such as pizza, cheeseburgers, fries, Chicken Nuggets and Chinese take-out food. How are Doesn't it seem odd that they not all obese? never gain any weight from eating foods that aren't good for you? Having pizza on a weekly basis is okay, but every time the TBBT cast are eating, their meals are rich in carbs and meat. Even Sheldon seems to lampshade in "The Tenant Disassociation" that the kinds of foods his friends like to eat isn't very healthy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Fast food loving cast always stay slim?]]
* We see Leonard, Sheldon, Raj, Howard and Penny eating junk food all the time. They eat lots of unhealthy cuisine such as pizza, cheeseburgers, fries, Chicken Nuggets and Chinese take-out food. How are they not all obese?

Added: 135

Changed: 334

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They're researchers, not professors. And researchers make crap money (unless you're Brian Greene or Stephen Hawking). The money that research gets in most universities goes into their projects, not their pockets. From my post-collegiate years (admittedly as a mathematician, not a physicist, but they're pretty much the same thing when it comes to product) I lived like a pauper. I'm shocked that they have as much disposable income as they do. The episodes where Raj gets mentioned in People, and the Korean kid pretty much epitomises how the academic research world works. It's bragging rights for the institute and they'll pay to keep you around.

to:

** They're researchers, not professors. And researchers make crap money (unless you're Brian Greene or Stephen Hawking). The money that research gets in most universities goes into their projects, not their pockets. From my post-collegiate years (admittedly as a mathematician, not a physicist, but they're pretty much the same thing when it comes to product) I lived like a pauper. I'm shocked that they have as much disposable income as they do. The episodes where Raj gets mentioned in People, and the Korean kid pretty much epitomises epitomizes how the academic research world works. It's bragging rights for the institute and they'll pay to keep you around.



** Bernadette claims that while as a microbiologist she makes plenty of money, her husband Howard does not as an aeronautics engineer.



** Sheldon has been shown a few times to have more money than he needs. He simply doesn't ''care'' about money.

to:

** Sheldon has been shown a few times to have more money than he needs. He simply doesn't didn't ''care'' about money.money until Season 11's "The Monetary Insufficiency".



** 52% of fast food workers in the United States gain social welfare benefits such as food stamps and subsidized housing. Maybe Stuart gets treated fairly by the government like a [=McDonalds=] crew person.

to:

** 52% of fast food workers in the United States gain social welfare benefits such as food stamps and subsidized housing. Maybe We've seen Stuart gets treated fairly leech off Howard's mother by living in her house and eating the government food she provided. It could be that Stuart is a freeloader much like a [=McDonalds=] crew person.Penny is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Perhaps his apartment was being decorated or there was some pest elimination in progress. Or more likely, the show did not have a set for Raj's apartment just yet.

to:

** Perhaps his apartment was being decorated painted or there was some pest elimination in progress. Or more likely, the show did not have a set for Raj's apartment just yet.


Added DiffLines:

** 52% of fast food workers in the United States gain social welfare benefits such as food stamps and subsidized housing. Maybe Stuart gets treated fairly by the government like a [=McDonalds=] crew person.

Added: 308

Changed: 256

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* They spend money on stupid things. Raj spends on fancy foods, self-care products, alcohol, and his dog. Howard...well, look at his room in his mom's house! Satin sheets, huge figurines, light-up lightsabers, models upon models ([[StealthPun though not the kind he'd like best of all]]), etc. Leonard splurges on things like time machines, probably has to pay extra for gas since he drives Sheldon everywhere, and has massive piles of collectible comics. The guys are often seen at the comic book store, so that just exacerbates their spending.

to:

* They spend money on stupid things. Raj spends on fancy foods, self-care products, alcohol, and his dog. Howard...well, look at his room in his mom's house! Satin sheets, huge figurines, light-up lightsabers, models upon models ([[StealthPun though not the kind he'd like best of all]]), etc. Leonard splurges on things like time machines, probably has to pay extra for gas since he drives Sheldon everywhere, and has massive piles of collectible comics. Sheldon is an avid video game consumer and he actually ''buys'' DVD boxsets for his favorite movies and TV shows that could definitely cost hundreds to thousands of dollars (but most likely that's [=CBS=] telling us the viewers not to do Internet piracy). The guys are often seen at the comic book store, so that just exacerbates their spending.spending.
** To be precise, they almost never buy something from the comic book store, they just read the comics there and put them back in the shelves when done. "Santa Stimulation" even proves that Leonard (and most likely so do the rest of the guys) does most of his shopping on Amazon instead of at Stuart's store.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Howard thinks his style ''is'' sexy and attractive. He does take a lot of care in dressing himself, and has flirted with other styles (like when he and Raj tried to go goth), but one of his blindspots is thinking that his turtlenecks and belt buckles are sexy and attractive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: How do the writer's justify Howard's wardrobe]]
* For someone as sexually obsessed as Howard and who didn't go after girls who were nerds, why did he put himself at a disadvantage by wearing such unattractive clothes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The point still stands. The landlord probably wouldn't be in any hurry to get it fixed if no one complained, and those that may have had problems with it probably moved out and he replaced them with people that didn't care about the elevator.

Top