Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / SoulSeries

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sadly, no. The artbook you're referring to is called ''New Legends of Project Soul'', which (puzzlingly/infuriatingly so) is currently [[NoExportForYou Japanese only]].

to:

* Sadly, no. The artbook you're referring to is called ''New Legends of Project Soul'', which (puzzlingly/infuriatingly so) is currently [[NoExportForYou Japanese only]].only]].
!A-CupAngst, what A-Cup Angst?
I've read somewhere in the Soul Calibur wiki that Seong-Mina has an inferiority complex due to Taki's 'assets," is there a source for this, because I doubt that's true?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***That was built ages ago and appears to be mostly abandoned. I don't see how that changes things.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Seong Mina also has a father who wants him to marry Hwang, but both seem to be worried about a Japanese invasion atleast during Soul Calibur 2. He seems to be somewhat allowing Mina to travel the world, or more darkly she, Hwang and Yun Sung are the only survivors of the many Korean agents sent to claim Soul Edge aka the Sword of Salvation.

to:

* Seong Mina also has a father who wants him her to marry Hwang, but both seem to be worried about a Japanese invasion atleast during Soul Calibur 2. He seems to be somewhat allowing Mina to travel the world, or more darkly she, Hwang and Yun Sung are the only survivors of the many Korean agents sent to claim Soul Edge aka the Sword of Salvation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** First, Cassandra ''doesn't'' worships them, and neither does any other member of Sophitia's family as a matter of fact. Dunno if what Sophitia (and Rothion) do can really be named "worshipping": visiting an ancient and ruined temple a few times to ask for blessing/help, or some personal/whispering prayers. And that's mostly given they know they are the real deal. No one else knows about that (except Cass), and she'd not be willing to reveal it, considering the last time Sophie spoke about her adventures she was ridiculized by even her close friends. PS: I wouldn't really count with those lazy greek gods to even move a finger if they even get pursued for that, considering their long-lasting lack of action, CF not-withstanding.

to:

** First, Cassandra ''doesn't'' worships worship them, and neither does any other member of Sophitia's family as a matter of fact. Dunno if what Sophitia (and Rothion) do can really be named "worshipping": visiting an ancient and ruined temple a few times to ask for blessing/help, or some personal/whispering prayers. And that's mostly given they know they are the real deal. No one else knows about that (except Cass), and she'd not be willing to reveal it, considering the last time Sophie spoke about her adventures she was ridiculized by even her close friends. PS: I wouldn't really count with those lazy greek gods to even move a finger if they even get pursued for that, considering their long-lasting lack of action, CF not-withstanding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** This is not necessarily true, there have been times even in the medival period where common women were given power or were largely independent on their husbands, see the Wife of Bath. Also there are few records written by the poor who lived by a different set of rules than the nobility who would be the ones in charge of the records. Besides that given the fighting ability of these women your hypothetical would end in the death of said guard.

to:

*** This is not necessarily true, there have been times even in the medival period where common women were given power or were largely independent on their husbands, see the Wife of Bath. Also Bath and more famously Joan of Arc (France) and Queen Boudicea (England) who lead entire ''armies'' at a time when the concept of a female warrior was almost unthinkable -- but it ''did'' happen. Also, there are few records written by the poor who lived by a different set of rules than the nobility who would be the ones in charge of the records. Besides that given the fighting ability of these women your hypothetical would end in the death of said guard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She's also a ManificentBitch because ''she'' was the mastermind for Team Soul Edge in IV, not Nightmare. Even as early as III, she chooses to join forces with Nightmare and afterwards spends a great deal of time manipulating dangerous or well-meaning people to do what she wants. She takes Astaroth and Cervantes, who should be huge threats to her master since they want the sword for themselves, and aims them at other people to make Nightmare too strong for either to defeat. She takes Sophitia, one of the most unambiguously good characters in the series, and tricks her into leaving her family unprotected so that she can take Pyrrha as a host for Soul Edge and then blackmail Sophie, one of the sword's most deadly enemies, into protecting it! Tira's crazy when she's in battle, but she earned the title by being able to manipulate many people a good deal more powerful than her to serve her own ends, nearly wins in both IV and V (and gets away scott-free both times when the good guys manage to avert her goal), and is generally a more dynamic and wily villain than Nightmare, even with Dumas starting to catch up. Add in that she's remarkably stylish while doing all this and manages to get around SanityHasAdvantages, and she fits the criteria better than a ''number'' of examples on the page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Which is ''Raphael's'' height. And that's not the only hint at their connection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Tira appears to have calmed down considerably by the time of ''SCV'', only snapping when Patroklos called her a 'pawn'. She was more unstable than usual in ''SCIV'' due to her mind only recently being spilt in two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* How is Tira considered a {{Magnificent Bastard}}? The only person she ever manipulates is a scared little girl and she ultimately fails at that. Also isn't Tira SUPPOSED to be crazy as hell? How does she hide that or does crazy now come with a switch?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Um, Sophitia worships in a fairly large TEMPLE.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not Understatement


** I honestly don't see any FoeYay between Inferno/Soul Edge and Elysium/Soul Calibur, if that's indeed who Elysium is. Looking back, I see now that Inferno used Siegfried's Nightmare armour as a proxy host after Soul Edge was taken by Siegfried in III as there was nothing else there to possess. Cervantes was very much obsessed with reclaiming Soul Edge prior to V, although his obsession doesn't really qualify as {{Yandere}}. I guess that narrows it down to Sigfried x Nightmare. Tira's still yandere, [[{{Understatement}} she's just not impressed]] with Nightmare [[TaughtByExperience learning from his mistakes]] and employing subterfuge, and has decided that a [[LesYay female Nightmare works just as well]].

to:

** I honestly don't see any FoeYay between Inferno/Soul Edge and Elysium/Soul Calibur, if that's indeed who Elysium is. Looking back, I see now that Inferno used Siegfried's Nightmare armour as a proxy host after Soul Edge was taken by Siegfried in III as there was nothing else there to possess. Cervantes was very much obsessed with reclaiming Soul Edge prior to V, although his obsession doesn't really qualify as {{Yandere}}. I guess that narrows it down to Sigfried x Nightmare. Tira's still yandere, [[{{Understatement}} she's just not impressed]] impressed with Nightmare [[TaughtByExperience learning from his mistakes]] and employing subterfuge, and has decided that a [[LesYay female Nightmare works just as well]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Hilde is justified, as by ''V'' she is leading her people to refuge while researching a way to purify the lands of Wolfkrone. In short, she's pretty much her nation's current leader.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** More WordOFGod: Voldo's backstory in Soul Calibur V states he has quite the keen sense of smell. He was able to track down and kill the thieves who ransacked the Money Pit while he was gone this way. And successfully retrieve every last piece of treasure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The timeline provided by Namco's Soul Archive site states that ''Edge'' takes place in 1584. ''Calibur'' is noted to take place three years after, and ''SCII'' four years after that. That's seven years. 1584 + 7 = 1591. Judging by certain bios in ''III'', a minimum of four months passed between ''II'' and ''III'' (it took Xianghua one month to carry Kilik back to Edge Master's place and Kilik spent another three training under Edge Master). Allegedly, approximately one full year passes between ''II'' and ''IV'', but I can't find any official sources for that, so the validity of such a statement sounds fishy. Unless that holds true, ''IV'' still ended in 1591. Seventeen years later, and it's 1608.



Several of the articles talk about an art book for Soul Calibur V, which reveals secrets like [[spoiler: Lexia and Xiba being siblings]] and [[spoiler: Nightmare using Raphael's body as a host]]. Is this the same art book included in the collector's edition?

to:

Several of the articles talk about an art book for Soul Calibur V, which reveals secrets like [[spoiler: Lexia and Xiba being siblings]] and [[spoiler: Nightmare using Raphael's body as a host]]. Is this the same art book included in the collector's edition?edition?
* Sadly, no. The artbook you're referring to is called ''New Legends of Project Soul'', which (puzzlingly/infuriatingly so) is currently [[NoExportForYou Japanese only]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How so? He possessed Siegfried, whose height was 5'6" up until ''V''. And even when Nightmare was an AnimatedArmor in ''III'' and ''IV'', his body was still based off of his previous one (i.e. Siegfried's). If it's any consolation, his new host in ''V'' is 5'10".

to:

* How so? He possessed Siegfried, whose height was 5'6" up until ''V''. And even when Nightmare was an AnimatedArmor in ''III'' and ''IV'', his body was still based off of his previous one (i.e. Siegfried's). If it's any consolation, his new host in ''V'' is 5'10".5'10".
!Artbook
Several of the articles talk about an art book for Soul Calibur V, which reveals secrets like [[spoiler: Lexia and Xiba being siblings]] and [[spoiler: Nightmare using Raphael's body as a host]]. Is this the same art book included in the collector's edition?

Added: 1122

Changed: 1099

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** ''I think that you are all giving Namco too much credit and that they just did not bother do the research.'', except that most of what's said (specially about Sophitia assisting mass and being a big fan of ancient greek mythology) is directly stated in her original profile. Sophitia was the only one who ever had this interest too, as Cassandra only believes they exist because she knows Sophitia is not the type to lie.



*** No other people was ever sent for the sword by the Korean government, as Hwang's bio in 3 states he was selected the 2nd time because he was the only one with some experience traveling west. In Mina's bio in 2, Han-myeong is reluctant to let Mina go get Yun-seong, but he realizes she'd just escape home a third time if he said no, and accepting she was fit for the task, gave his blessing to her quest.




to:

*** Nope, the prologue for 2 is very clear "no one knew" and "most people were oblivious" about the final battle and Nightmare's fate; it even states "Four more years passed, and the horrors became a distant memory and people felt safe once again". Besides, it also states that there were no witness of the final battle, so outside of Kilik, Xianghua and (maybe) Edge Master, no one ever knew what happened in Osthreinsburg.




to:

** Pretty much no one really knows that Nightmare wields Soul Edge. Not even Ivy was aware while she ''stood next to him in his slaughters'', and she spent most of her life researching that sword. Also, there are very scarce survivors of Nightmare's massacres, so it's actually stated there are very few reports about his attacks, most of which happened during midnight (low visibility and all that stuff).



** Those birthdates aren't from any official source, they were just {{fanon}} assumptions based on the only official timeline ever released (which mostly listed historical events intertwined with Mitsurugi's career). 1607 has been the first official date ever given for any of these game.




to:

** Still, Mitsurugi and Arthur ''do'' suffer from langauge barriers, so that doesn't really cut it. All interactions outside those two, however, do happen without any communication problem, so it's really just a minor detail that hasn't really been taken into account.

Changed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I would assume they do. To the best of knowledge, Ezio is the first character to actually break out into his native tongue, and that's only during select quote. [[TranslationConvention It would seem that everyone knows English, even when they shouldn't.]] However, this didn't hold true for ''Soul Edge/Soul Blade'', [[BilingualDialogue where the Asian characters were left in Japanese]]. I don't quite have an answer for you, but there's a WMG here suggesting that since the soul swords are unnatural entities that warp the fabric of reality, they eventually broke down the language barriers on Earth once they grew powerful enough.

to:

** I would assume they do. To the best of my knowledge, Ezio is the first character to actually break out into his native tongue, tongue (although Talim can be heard saying "Sipa" in ''II'', which is Tagalog for kick), and that's only during select quote.quotes. [[TranslationConvention It would seem that everyone knows English, even when they shouldn't.]] However, this didn't hold true for ''Soul Edge/Soul Blade'', [[BilingualDialogue where the Asian characters were left in Japanese]]. I don't quite have an answer for you, but there's a WMG here suggesting that since the soul swords are unnatural entities that warp the fabric of reality, they eventually broke down the language barriers on Earth once they grew powerful enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Nightmare is 5'6''. This is very silly.

to:

Nightmare is 5'6''. This is very silly.silly.
* How so? He possessed Siegfried, whose height was 5'6" up until ''V''. And even when Nightmare was an AnimatedArmor in ''III'' and ''IV'', his body was still based off of his previous one (i.e. Siegfried's). If it's any consolation, his new host in ''V'' is 5'10".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Nightmare is 5'7''. This is very silly.

to:

Nightmare is 5'7''.5'6''. This is very silly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I would assume they do. To the best of knowledge, Ezio is the first character to actually break out into his native tongue, and that's only during select quote. [[TranslationConvention It would seem that everyone knows English, even when they shouldn't.]] However, this didn't hold true for ''Soul Edge/Soul Blade'', [[BilingualDialogue where the Asian characters were left in Japanese]]. I don't quite have an answer for you, but there's a WMG here suggesting that since the soul swords are unnatural entities that warp the fabric of reality, they eventually broke down the language barriers on Earth once they grew powerful enough.

to:

** I would assume they do. To the best of knowledge, Ezio is the first character to actually break out into his native tongue, and that's only during select quote. [[TranslationConvention It would seem that everyone knows English, even when they shouldn't.]] However, this didn't hold true for ''Soul Edge/Soul Blade'', [[BilingualDialogue where the Asian characters were left in Japanese]]. I don't quite have an answer for you, but there's a WMG here suggesting that since the soul swords are unnatural entities that warp the fabric of reality, they eventually broke down the language barriers on Earth once they grew powerful enough.enough.

!On the character heights...
Nightmare is 5'7''. This is very silly.

Added: 690

Changed: 375

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So how does everyone understand each other? Do they?

to:

** Maybe their math was a bit incorrect? Everything else in the series suggests that the last three games took place in 1591. I guess you could also chalk it up to the amount of time it'd take for the characters to travel back and forth (such as Pat going to locales like Hungary and Japan) as well as the lack of secondary narratives in the story (outside of Sophitia's kids).
* So how does everyone understand each other? Do they?they?
** I would assume they do. To the best of knowledge, Ezio is the first character to actually break out into his native tongue, and that's only during select quote. [[TranslationConvention It would seem that everyone knows English, even when they shouldn't.]] However, this didn't hold true for ''Soul Edge/Soul Blade'', [[BilingualDialogue where the Asian characters were left in Japanese]]. I don't quite have an answer for you, but there's a WMG here suggesting that since the soul swords are unnatural entities that warp the fabric of reality, they eventually broke down the language barriers on Earth once they grew powerful enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Soul Calibur V contradicts stuff. It says that SCIV takes place in 1590 and that SCV takes place in 1607, yet when you look at the characters' DOBs, they all suggest it's in 1591. Add 17 years to that, 1608. Even the new SCV characters' DOBs suggest 1608. Does the story mode start in 1607 and end in 1608, even if the whole thing is called 1607?
* So do language barriers exist? Some bios mention them, and yet cutscenes suggest they don't exist.

to:

* Soul Calibur V contradicts stuff. It says that SCIV takes place in 1590 and that SCV takes place in 1607, yet when you look at the characters' DOBs, they all suggest it's in 1591. Add 17 years to that, 1608. Even the new SCV characters' DOBs suggest 1608. Does the story mode start in 1607 and end in 1608, even if the whole thing is called 1607?
1607? Are the previous ones in 1590 or 1591?
* So do language barriers exist? Some bios mention them, and yet cutscenes suggest they don't exist.how does everyone understand each other? Do they?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just adding some of my own headscratchers...


** I honestly don't see any FoeYay between Inferno/Soul Edge and Elysium/Soul Calibur, if that's indeed who Elysium is. Looking back, I see now that Inferno used Siegfried's Nightmare armour as a proxy host after Soul Edge was taken by Siegfried in III as there was nothing else there to possess. Cervantes was very much obsessed with reclaiming Soul Edge prior to V, although his obsession doesn't really qualify as {{Yandere}}. I guess that narrows it down to Sigfried x Nightmare. Tira's still yandere, [[{{Understatement}} she's just not impressed]] with Nightmare [[TaughtByExperience learning from his mistakes]] and employing subterfuge, and has decided that a [[LesYay female Nightmare works just as well]].

to:

** I honestly don't see any FoeYay between Inferno/Soul Edge and Elysium/Soul Calibur, if that's indeed who Elysium is. Looking back, I see now that Inferno used Siegfried's Nightmare armour as a proxy host after Soul Edge was taken by Siegfried in III as there was nothing else there to possess. Cervantes was very much obsessed with reclaiming Soul Edge prior to V, although his obsession doesn't really qualify as {{Yandere}}. I guess that narrows it down to Sigfried x Nightmare. Tira's still yandere, [[{{Understatement}} she's just not impressed]] with Nightmare [[TaughtByExperience learning from his mistakes]] and employing subterfuge, and has decided that a [[LesYay female Nightmare works just as well]].well]].
* Soul Calibur V contradicts stuff. It says that SCIV takes place in 1590 and that SCV takes place in 1607, yet when you look at the characters' DOBs, they all suggest it's in 1591. Add 17 years to that, 1608. Even the new SCV characters' DOBs suggest 1608. Does the story mode start in 1607 and end in 1608, even if the whole thing is called 1607?
* So do language barriers exist? Some bios mention them, and yet cutscenes suggest they don't exist.

Changed: 904

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** What you see is what you get with the credits. It's possible that there are (like in ''III'' and ''IV'') uncredited [=VAs=] for English, but Pyrrha (LauraBailey) and Raphael (Charles Rubendall, who voiced him in ''III'' and ''IV'') would seem to still be correct. As for the issues of Viola and Nightmare, there are strong hints that what is on the characters page is correct (aside from [=VAs=], [[spoiler:Raphael remarks "Strange..." when biting Viola during his throw and Graf Dumas looks like Raphael, but with a mask--something that's made even more obvious in CAS]]), but nothing was ''officially'' disclosed in the story. Thus, it's just conjecture at this point. True? Most likely. Confirmed? No. [[Tropers/{{X2X}} I'm]] going to bring this post up on the discussion page for the characters page, but I might just go ahead and remove that information altogether since it's not explicitly true.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Which results in more dead guards. Assuming anyone actually saw the fight. Besides, they have a lot ore pressing matters to worry about, like Nightmare going around the countryside.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Okay, so I did not watch the whole story mode yet, but I did watch the end and the credits. Suddenly, so much gets confirmed based on what I assume is the the voice actor list in the credits. Viola is suddenly Amy based on sharing both English and Japanese VA's (which was known way before story mode was leaked) and Nightmare is using Raphael's body because they share the same seiyuu. This is where I get confused. Popular theory aside, does the trope, TalkingToYourself not apply? Not to mention that while they specified who played who in Japanese, but they only specified RogerCraigSmith as Ezio. Everyone else is just mentioned in alphabetical order. Nightmare in particular is going back and forth between PatrickSeitz and Charles Rubendall. Some VA's also seem to be outright ''missing'', like how the general consensus says that LauraBailey is Pyrrha. Is this all being assumed based on the VA list or do I have the wrong assumptions and missed something? Also, is there anywhere I can find a confirmed VA list?

to:

* Okay, so I did not watch the whole story mode yet, but I did watch the end and the credits. Suddenly, so much gets confirmed based on what I assume is the the voice actor list in the credits. Viola is suddenly Amy based on sharing the fact that they share both English and Japanese VA's (which was known way before story mode was leaked) and Nightmare is using Raphael's body because they share the same seiyuu. This is where I get confused. Popular theory aside, does the trope, TalkingToYourself not apply? Not to mention that while they specified who played who in Japanese, but they only specified RogerCraigSmith as Ezio. Everyone else is The other English VS's are just mentioned in alphabetical order.order without saying who they voiced. Nightmare in particular is going back and forth between PatrickSeitz and Charles Rubendall. Some VA's also seem to be outright ''missing'', like how the general consensus says that LauraBailey is Pyrrha. Pyrrha, but she appears to be either missing from the credits or played by someone else. Is this all being assumed based on the VA list or do am I have making the wrong assumptions and missed something? Also, is there anywhere I can find a confirmed VA list?
list? I apologize for this wall of text. I just don't TVTropes to be giving out {{fanon}} as fact.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Okay, so I did not watch the whole story mode yet, but I did watch the end and the credits. Suddenly, so much gets confirmed based on what I assume is the the voice actor list in the credits. Viola is suddenly Amy based on sharing both English and Japanese VA's (which was known way before story mode was leaked) and Nightmare is using Raphael's body because they share the same seiyuu. This is where I get confused. Popular theory aside, does the trope, TalkingToYourself not apply? Not to mention that while they specified who played who in Japanese, but they only specified RogerCraigSmith as Ezio. Everyone else is just mentioned in alphabetical order. Nightmare in particular is going back and forth between PatrickSeitz and Charles Rubendall. Some VA's also seem to be outright ''missing'', like how the general consensus says that LauraBailey is Pyrrha. Is this all being assumed based on the VA list or do I have the wrong assumptions and missed something? Also, is there anywhere I can find a confirmed VA list?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's also the Female part of Soul Edge- the sword itself is both male and female.

to:

** There's also the Female part of Soul Edge- the sword itself is both male and female.female.
** I honestly don't see any FoeYay between Inferno/Soul Edge and Elysium/Soul Calibur, if that's indeed who Elysium is. Looking back, I see now that Inferno used Siegfried's Nightmare armour as a proxy host after Soul Edge was taken by Siegfried in III as there was nothing else there to possess. Cervantes was very much obsessed with reclaiming Soul Edge prior to V, although his obsession doesn't really qualify as {{Yandere}}. I guess that narrows it down to Sigfried x Nightmare. Tira's still yandere, [[{{Understatement}} she's just not impressed]] with Nightmare [[TaughtByExperience learning from his mistakes]] and employing subterfuge, and has decided that a [[LesYay female Nightmare works just as well]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Cervantes and Xianghua are far from Yandere material. As for your question... dunno. I get the feeling that Siegfried as Nightmare was probably the most successful host Soul Edge has had to date (Siegfried ''did'' best Inferno in combat back in ''Soul Edge'', after all). Resuming the form of his most recent host was probably the best way to go for Inferno, considering how notorious and feared the Azure Knight was (to the point that stories of him stretched all the way from Western Europe to Japan). It could also very well be psychological warfare against the one who escaped his grasp. At any rate, it's no less weird than the FoeYay the two soul swords ''themselves'' have going on, which probably is the strangest implication of BrotherSisterIncest I've ever seen in fiction.

to:

* Cervantes and Xianghua are far from Yandere material. As for your question... dunno. I get the feeling that Siegfried as Nightmare was probably the most successful host Soul Edge has had to date (Siegfried ''did'' best Inferno in combat back in ''Soul Edge'', after all). Resuming the form of his most recent host was probably the best way to go for Inferno, considering how notorious and feared the Azure Knight was (to the point that stories of him stretched all the way from Western Europe to Japan). It could also very well be psychological warfare against the one who escaped his grasp. At any rate, it's no less weird than the FoeYay the two soul swords ''themselves'' have going on, which probably is the strangest implication of BrotherSisterIncest I've ever seen in fiction.fiction.
** There's also the Female part of Soul Edge- the sword itself is both male and female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Interestingly, Voldo was neiher blind or mute(another assumption) in Soul Edge, he just had very deteriorated sight. And he spoke according to the game story.

Top