Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / SonictheHedgehog

Go To

OR

Changed: 3

Removed: 423

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I've noticed that the idea of [[TheLostLenore Maria]] being brought BackFromTheDead is rather popular among the Sonic fandom. Especially as an anthropomorphic hedgehog. Other than for someone to ship Shadow with, why is it? Given how her death was an integral part of his backstory, don't you think that reviving her would render Shadow's character arc meaningless?

to:

* I've noticed that the idea of [[TheLostLenore Maria]] being brought BackFromTheDead is rather popular among the Sonic fandom. Especially (Especially as an anthropomorphic hedgehog. hedgehog) Other than for someone to ship Shadow with, why is it? Given how her death was an integral part of his backstory, don't you think that reviving her would render Shadow's character arc meaningless?



*** People also said all of Shadow's appearances following [=SA2=] ruin his character arc so it's a moot point, I guess. Not to mention it would actually be interesting to see how Maria would play off of Sonic and the others and how she would react to the events that transpired in her absence. (Like her grandfather going mad with grief and trying to destroy the world and her cousin turning evil and trying to conquer it)

Added: 498

Removed: 72

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to the bottom and responding


* Why does Shadow have a problem with Sonic, even when working together?


Added DiffLines:

* Why does Shadow have a problem with Sonic, even when working together?
** Seems to depend on the game. In Shadow where he had amnesia, he was annoyed by Sonic's attitude, which he found too carefree and friendly. By Sonic 06, though, the two seemed to be somewhat bitter toward each other, likely due to their clashing personalities and methods. Kind of like Sonic and Knuckles circa the Adventure era, with the difference that unlike Knuckles, Shadow doesn't seem to be secretly envious of Sonic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why does Shadow have a problem with Sonic, even when working together?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** This troper once read a theory that Sonic's world likes things in "rings", which would explain the loops. Perhaps the rings being well, ring-shaped, is in response to this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Probably for the same reason why Sonic was perfectly fine after the characters stated that he has been tortured for months.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another possibility is that it's a combination of scientific interest (gems that can both output near-limotless power AND warp reality itself would be of IMMENSE interest to a scientist like him) and pragmatic (keeping a valuable tool in Sonic's arsenal away from him) reasons. He wants to study the Emeralds to unlock their secrets to fuel his conquests, and he REALLY wants to keep them adu from Sonic so that Sonic can't use hos signature trump card by going Super. Win-win if he's got his hands on them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** People also said all of Shadow's appearances following SA2 ruin his character arc so it's a moot point, I guess. Not to mention it would actually be interesting to see how Maria would play off of Sonic and the others and how she would react to the events that transpired in her absence. (Like her grandfather going mad with grief and trying to destroy the world and her cousin turning evil and trying to conquer it)

to:

*** People also said all of Shadow's appearances following SA2 [=SA2=] ruin his character arc so it's a moot point, I guess. Not to mention it would actually be interesting to see how Maria would play off of Sonic and the others and how she would react to the events that transpired in her absence. (Like her grandfather going mad with grief and trying to destroy the world and her cousin turning evil and trying to conquer it)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


When all seven are gathered together, they have tremendous power, but when they are all used up, the Chaos Emeralds scatter and fly away to other parts of the world. The Chaos Emeralds that have fallen into such secluded places slowly accumulate their power in the midst of nature."\\
This was shown in Sonic Adventure, with the emeralds scattering after Perfect Chaos absorbed their powers. They were also depleted early in Unleashed but they didn't scatter, likely because they were inside one of Eggman's space colonies at the time.

to:

When "When all seven are gathered together, they have tremendous power, but when they are all used up, the Chaos Emeralds scatter and fly away to other parts of the world. The Chaos Emeralds that have fallen into such secluded places slowly accumulate their power in the midst of nature."\\
This was shown in Sonic Adventure, ''Sonic Adventure'', with the emeralds scattering after Perfect Chaos absorbed their powers. They were also depleted early in Unleashed ''Unleashed'' but they didn't scatter, likely because they were inside one of Eggman's space colonies at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The above was confirmed by Sonic Channel. When the emeralds' powers are used up, they revert to their depowered grey form and scatter all over the planet only to slowly recharge again:\\
When all seven are gathered together, they have tremendous power, but when they are all used up, the Chaos Emeralds scatter and fly away to other parts of the world. The Chaos Emeralds that have fallen into such secluded places slowly accumulate their power in the midst of nature."\\
This was shown in Sonic Adventure, with the emeralds scattering after Perfect Chaos absorbed their powers. They were also depleted early in Unleashed but they didn't scatter, likely because they were inside one of Eggman's space colonies at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Iizuka explained that there are two worlds: the human and Sonic's world. [[PlotHole Not that it even makes sense at all, though...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
correcting wicks


** I guess Sonic has a {{Required Secondary Power}} like Super Endurance/Durability that allows him to run at Super Sonic speed without ripping apart; this would also explain how he is able to survive hits from super powerful blows from enemies and plow through robots and certain stationary objects without any major injury.
* How does Sonic have a reputation for being super-fast anyway? In the comics and cartoons yeah, but the video games (even the newer ones) constantly show that most consumer vehicles can keep pace with him or outrun him. Compare TheFlash, who can break the sound barrier on foot. Really, if Sonic has any superpower, its his insane durability (seriously try bodyslamming anything mechanical and see what condition you're in afterwards), but that seems to be something he shares with everyone... then again, so is the speed.

to:

** I guess Sonic has a {{Required Secondary Power}} RequiredSecondaryPower like Super Endurance/Durability that allows him to run at Super Sonic speed without ripping apart; this would also explain how he is able to survive hits from super powerful blows from enemies and plow through robots and certain stationary objects without any major injury.
* How does Sonic have a reputation for being super-fast anyway? In the comics and cartoons yeah, but the video games (even the newer ones) constantly show that most consumer vehicles can keep pace with him or outrun him. Compare TheFlash, Franchise/TheFlash, who can break the sound barrier on foot. Really, if Sonic has any superpower, its his insane durability (seriously try bodyslamming anything mechanical and see what condition you're in afterwards), but that seems to be something he shares with everyone... then again, so is the speed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** To be fair, Knuckles being able to knock Sonic out of Super form makes some sense, considering his connection to the Master Emerald, which is shown to be able to react to the Chaos Emeralds. It's possible that Knuckles can scramble Super modes if he hits them (we just don't see it in action, due to story contrivances).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Perhaps the gloves are the symbolic weapon/tool of the Echidna tribe, or of a particular caste therein (something like a badge of office that happens to be functional as well as symbolic), and Tikal doesn't have the spikes because she either didn't earn them (she's not shown to be much of a fighter), or because she's of a different caste (in this case, a priestly caste)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Because this just sounds like UrbanLegendOfZelda, a source would be great.

to:

*** Because this just sounds like UrbanLegendOfZelda, a source would be great. As far as I'm aware the rings may not even canonically be laying about at random and are just currency.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Because this just sounds like UrbanLegendOfZelda, a source would be great.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Unless you have ShippingGoggles on there's no confirmation of romantic feelings from Silver to Blaze.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of the only incarnations that portrays his sexuality is him having marry Sally as King Shadow in the comics.

to:

** One of the only incarnations that portrays his sexuality is him having marry been married to Sally as King Shadow in the comics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of the only incarnation that portrays his sexuality is him having marry Sally as King Shadow in the comics.

to:

** One of the only incarnation incarnations that portrays his sexuality is him having marry Sally as King Shadow in the comics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One of the only incarnation that portrays his sexuality is him having marry Sally as King Shadow in the comics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Hold on, cyberpsace?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I've noticed that the idea of [[PosthumousCharacter Maria Robotnik]] being brought BackFromTheDead is rather popular among the Sonic fandom. Especially as an anthropomorphic hedgehog. Other than for someone to ship Shadow with, why is it? Given how her death was an integral part of his backstory, don't you think that reviving her would render Shadow's character arc meaningless?

to:

* I've noticed that the idea of [[PosthumousCharacter Maria Robotnik]] [[TheLostLenore Maria]] being brought BackFromTheDead is rather popular among the Sonic fandom. Especially as an anthropomorphic hedgehog. Other than for someone to ship Shadow with, why is it? Given how her death was an integral part of his backstory, don't you think that reviving her would render Shadow's character arc meaningless?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They're too poor to afford a third member, and they assume that Epsio is close enough to a data specialist to work it out. To be fair, when you can just jump into cyberspace like a regular level, they're not wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* So, in the Sonic OVA, what's Sarah's deal? Why is she a CatGirl of all the things?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[ComicBook/SonicTheHedgehog Comics, too.]] Don't forget the comics. Anyway, in the early games, where plot wasn't a big issue anyway, I always assumed that the animals Sonic saves had a similar thing going on; the difference was a matter of, well, being a heavily-programmed main character. (The comics support this, as I recall.) The ''VideoGame/SonicAdventure'' series is a little hazier -- no one even seems to notice that Sonic or his friends are out of the ordinary apart from their special powers. Uh... honestly, I think a better question is where all the ''humans'' came from, but either way it's a poser.

to:

** [[ComicBook/SonicTheHedgehog [[ComicBook/SonicTheHedgehogArchieComics Comics, too.]] Don't forget the comics. Anyway, in the early games, where plot wasn't a big issue anyway, I always assumed that the animals Sonic saves had a similar thing going on; the difference was a matter of, well, being a heavily-programmed main character. (The comics support this, as I recall.) The ''VideoGame/SonicAdventure'' series is a little hazier -- no one even seems to notice that Sonic or his friends are out of the ordinary apart from their special powers. Uh... honestly, I think a better question is where all the ''humans'' came from, but either way it's a poser.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I've noticed that the idea of [[PosthumousCharacter Maria Robotnik]] being brought BackFromTheDead is rather popular among the Sonic fandom. Especially as an anthropomorphic hedgehog. Other than for someone to ship Shadow with, why is it? Don't you think that reviving her would render Shadow's character development meaningless?

to:

* I've noticed that the idea of [[PosthumousCharacter Maria Robotnik]] being brought BackFromTheDead is rather popular among the Sonic fandom. Especially as an anthropomorphic hedgehog. Other than for someone to ship Shadow with, why is it? Don't Given how her death was an integral part of his backstory, don't you think that reviving her would render Shadow's character development arc meaningless?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Well, I've heard people say that all of Shadow's appearances following SA2 ruin his character arc so it's a moot point, I guess. Not to mention it would actually be interesting to see how Maria would play off of characters like say, Sonic and his friends. Speaking of angst, imagine how Maria would react upon learning of the events that transpired during the past 50 years. (i.e. her grandfather going insane, her cousin turning evil)

to:

*** Well, I've heard people say that People also said all of Shadow's appearances following SA2 ruin his character arc so it's a moot point, I guess. Not to mention it would actually be interesting to see how Maria would play off of characters like say, Sonic and his friends. Speaking of angst, imagine the others and how Maria she would react upon learning of to the events that transpired during the past 50 years. (i.e. in her absence. (Like her grandfather going insane, mad with grief and trying to destroy the world and her cousin turning evil)evil and trying to conquer it)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Well, I've heard people say that all of Shadow's appearances following SA2 ruin his character arc so it's a moot point, I guess. Not to mention it would actually be interesting to see how Maria would play off of characters like say, Sonic and his friends.

to:

*** Well, I've heard people say that all of Shadow's appearances following SA2 ruin his character arc so it's a moot point, I guess. Not to mention it would actually be interesting to see how Maria would play off of characters like say, Sonic and his friends. Speaking of angst, imagine how Maria would react upon learning of the events that transpired during the past 50 years. (i.e. her grandfather going insane, her cousin turning evil)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Well, I've heard people say that all of Shadow's appearances following SA2 ruin his character arc so it's a moot point, I guess. Not to mention it would actually be interesting to see how Maria would play off of characters like say, Sonic and his friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** But the angst! Think of the angst that would arise form Shadow re-uniting with the dead person he cares so much about, [[SurferDude man!]]

Top