History Headscratchers / SonicGenerations

29th Apr '18 7:59:17 PM Dere
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Classic Sonic is not a younger version of Sonic. He is a literal interpretation of how the Genesis Sonic sprites would look in 3D. Since He does not speak in the Genesis trilogy, he does not speak here.

to:

* ** Classic Sonic is not a younger version of Sonic. He is a literal interpretation of how the Genesis Sonic sprites would look in 3D. Since He does not speak in the Genesis trilogy, he does not speak here.here.
*** So he's less the past version of the main timeline's Sonic, and more a new character introduced in Generations that is modeled after the Genesis-era Sonic? That does makes sense. That explains why he's seemingly mute when "main" Sonic isn't, the eye color change, and why it's stated in Sonic Forces states that he's actually from another dimension.
29th Apr '18 5:06:19 PM Emreld3000
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* He got sent to the Taxman port of Sonic 1.

to:

* ** He got sent to the Taxman port of Sonic 1.
29th Apr '18 5:06:05 PM Emreld3000
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** We may look to the Archie comics as an example of universe and timeline splitting and its effects in the Sonic world. Blaze's current backstory may be a consequence of the now-removed events of Sonic 06, even if Sonic 06 is non canon. The current, permanent state of the affairs was influenced by the transient state of affairs at the end of Sonic 06 - Blaze absorbed a fire god and transported herself into an alternate dimension. Then, when the universe reset at the end of 06, those transient events became permanent - Blaze suddenly had ''always'' been from that alternate dimension, and inherited some of the fire god's previous host's qualities. The Time Eater's white void brought back Crisis City, causing Blaze to regain memory of that event as long as it existed again in a timeline she was aware of.
29th Apr '18 4:57:40 PM Emreld3000
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Classic Sonic is not a younger version of Sonic. He is a literal interpretation of how the Genesis Sonic sprites would look in 3D. Since He does not speak in the Genesis trilogy, he does not speak here.



** Modern Tails doesn't remember Green Hill for the same reason he and Modern Sonic don't recall meeting their future selves when they were younger. It's regular time travel, not a stable time loop.

to:

** Modern Tails doesn't remember Green Hill for the same reason he and Modern Sonic don't recall meeting their future selves when they were younger. It's regular time travel, not a stable time loop.loop.
* He got sent to the Taxman port of Sonic 1.
3rd Mar '18 10:27:40 AM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** It's possible that it's the Silver from SonicRivals. He ''did'' appear in that game, too.

to:

*** It's possible that it's the Silver from SonicRivals.''VideoGame/SonicRivals''. He ''did'' appear in that game, too.
16th Feb '18 6:14:37 AM Dere
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** For the same reason Modern Sonic and Tails don't remember meeting their future selves when they were younger. It's standard time travel, not a stable time loop.

to:

** For Modern Tails doesn't remember Green Hill for the same reason he and Modern Sonic and Tails don't remember recall meeting their future selves when they were younger. It's standard regular time travel, not a stable time loop.
16th Feb '18 5:30:31 AM SeptimusHeap
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Considering that the game's story was written by the same people who did SonicColors, I don't think we should think too hard on serious levels.

to:

*** Considering that the game's story was written by the same people who did SonicColors, VideoGame/SonicColors, I don't think we should think too hard on serious levels.
5th Dec '17 12:03:05 PM Dere
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** The devs probably either didn't notice or didn't care, or it might just be representing the classic era, and Classic Sonic and Classic Tails weren't actually sent to Green Hill.

to:

** The devs probably either didn't notice or didn't care, or it might just be representing the classic era, and Classic Sonic and Classic Tails weren't actually sent to Green Hill.Hill.
** For the same reason Modern Sonic and Tails don't remember meeting their future selves when they were younger. It's standard time travel, not a stable time loop.
4th Dec '17 7:50:03 AM Anichibi
Is there an issue? Send a Message


***It's possible that it's the Silver from SonicRivals. He ''did'' appear in that game, too.



* Tails' line about not remembering Green Hill Zone makes sense at the beginning of the game but at the end Classic Tails clearly jumps through a portal leading to that exact location, so what the hell?

to:

* Tails' line about not remembering Green Hill Zone makes sense at the beginning of the game but at the end Classic Tails clearly jumps through a portal leading to that exact location, so what the hell?hell?
**The devs probably either didn't notice or didn't care, or it might just be representing the classic era, and Classic Sonic and Classic Tails weren't actually sent to Green Hill.
28th Aug '17 10:25:35 AM Ninjabot
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* What was the logic behind making it so that Classic Sonic never speaks? He was ''never'' a HeroicMime. The games he starred in just didn't have any dialogue, so he didn't get a chance to speak. Even then, he ''did'' speak when the hardware [[VideoGame/SonicCD his]] [[VideoGame/SegaSonicTheHedgehog games]] were on made it feasible, as well as in the story prologues from some of the classic games' Japanese manuals. He spoke far more than Classic Tails ever did prior to Generations, yet this one did get a speaking role here. That's pretty backwards.

to:

* What was the logic behind making it so that Classic Sonic never speaks? He was ''never'' a HeroicMime. The games he starred in just didn't have any dialogue, so he didn't get a chance to speak. Even then, he ''did'' speak when the hardware [[VideoGame/SonicCD his]] [[VideoGame/SegaSonicTheHedgehog games]] were on made it feasible, as well as in the story prologues from some of the classic games' Japanese manuals. He spoke far more than Classic Tails ever did prior to Generations, yet this one did get a speaking role here. That's pretty backwards.backwards.
* Tails' line about not remembering Green Hill Zone makes sense at the beginning of the game but at the end Classic Tails clearly jumps through a portal leading to that exact location, so what the hell?
This list shows the last 10 events of 91. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.SonicGenerations