Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / ResidentEvil0

Go To

OR

Added: 934

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Also, [[RuleOfCool it's freakin' awesome]].

to:

*** ** Also, [[RuleOfCool it's freakin' awesome]].



** For starters, zombifying the shark is presumably just a preliminary stage in the process. Step two would be finding some way to control the resultant monster. In which case you now have an army of giant zombie sharks at your beck and call, as opposed to real sharks, which can't be tamed. Plenty of ways to use that to terrorize enemy shipping and coastal communities.
*** To say nothing of the ''other'' projects that could be run using infected sharks as a basis. The shark equivalent to Hunters, for example.

to:

** For starters, zombifying the shark is presumably just a preliminary stage in the process. Step two would be finding some way to control the resultant monster. In which case you now have an army of giant zombie sharks at your beck and call, as opposed to real sharks, which can't be tamed. Plenty of ways to use that to terrorize terrorise enemy shipping and coastal communities.
*** ** To say nothing of the ''other'' projects that could be run using infected sharks as a basis. The shark equivalent to Hunters, for example.



** They could've theorized that animals were eating the corpses or something, at the very least.
** Too hard a sell. Admittedly, that would've been inductive reasoning, but this was before the rampaging outbreak and the mansion incident. What else could they have theorized?

to:

** They could've theorized theorised that animals were eating the corpses or something, at the very least.
** Too hard a sell. Admittedly, that would've been inductive reasoning, but this was before the rampaging outbreak and the mansion incident. What else could they have theorized?theorised?



** She's a S.W.A.T. Medic, not an Army medic. They don't abide by the Geneva Convention rules on unarmed medical personnel. Police medics can usually handle themselves (as indeed she does), but the whole LetsSplitUpGang part was pretty dumb, even by [=RE=] standards.

to:

** She's a S.W.A.T. Medic, medic, not an Army medic. They don't abide by the Geneva Convention rules on unarmed medical personnel. Police medics can usually handle themselves (as indeed she does), but the whole LetsSplitUpGang part was pretty dumb, even by [=RE=] standards.



*** Sending the medic alone is still stupid (especially considering how said medic is like 18 years old and has the physique of a stick). Trained or not, why would you keep her away from the rest of the team when it's her job to keep them alive?

to:

*** ** Sending the medic alone is still stupid (especially considering how said medic is like 18 years old and has the physique of a stick). Trained or not, why would you keep her away from the rest of the team when it's her job to keep them alive?alive?
** As Wesker had intended to get combat data on the [=BOW=]s, perhaps the "split up and do solo patrols even for medics" was instituted at a doctrinal training level by him, even though most other police departments would be stunned at this lack of overwatch.



** In the end, the rest of the platoon was likely feverish and delusional, as pointed out by Billy due to the severe heat. The unit essentially was venting their frustrations, and whether they were as delusional to think the village was still part of the guerrilla unit or they came to their senses after murdering everyone in blind rage only to implicate Billy as the instigator...who knows. In the end though, all that matters...they were a mess and not in their right minds.

to:

** In the end, the rest of the platoon was likely feverish and delusional, as pointed out by Billy due to the severe heat. The unit essentially was venting their frustrations, and whether they were as delusional to think the village was still part of the guerrilla unit or they came to their senses after murdering everyone in blind rage only to implicate Billy as the instigator... who knows. In the end though, all that matters... they were a mess and not in their right minds.



** The latter. They just happened to find a village that had no guerilla presence. Or, the guerillas had fled by the time they got there.

to:

** The latter. They just happened to find a village that had no guerilla guerrilla presence. Or, the guerillas guerrillas had fled by the time they got there.


Added DiffLines:

** Also, she may have mentioned the bioweapons she saw in 0, but it's just not relevant to show that conversation because they generally aren't the same ones that show up for Chris (and if you tell a gamer who's first game in the series is the original game that there are zombie baboons, giant centipedes and bats, and leech monsters and the like running around, they may be unduly worried about seeing them in that game, when they never show), and for those that are, he has likely already encountered them or at least read about them by that point in the game.


Added DiffLines:

** Also, perhaps Ashford himself had the torture dungeon installed and sold Marcus on the basis of those merits?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, it could be a test for future hybrid BOWs. Something with, say, the aquatic capabilities of a shark, but the terrestrial mobility of a Hunter or Licker, creating a multi-purpose BOW that could, say, ambush a ship or be deployed via waterways, then jump out and prey on victims.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Sending the medic alone is still stupid (especially considering how said medic is like 18 years old and has the physique of a stick). Trained or not, why would you keep her away from the rest of the team when it's her job to keep them alive?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Once he made a breakthrough with said leeches, he started infecting the students at the facility with them, then used all that medieval equipment to test what they can do. More specifically, it was to see what their threshold for pain was and how much damage they could take before expiring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Small one, this, but: in Zero, you can create Molotov cocktails with which to torch leech zombies. Not really a problem, except for the fact that you can do this while playing solo with Rebecca, and can do so ''before'' Billy finds fuel for his otherwise-useless lighter. How does it ignite? Does Rebecca have a tinderbox handy?
** Perhaps. Mercenaries Reunion hints that she's something of a pyro, as one of her special attacks is a flame spray.

to:

* Small one, this, but: in Zero, you can create Molotov cocktails with which to torch leech zombies. Not really a problem, except for the fact that you can do this while playing solo with Rebecca, and can do so ''before'' Billy finds fuel for his otherwise-useless lighter. How does it ignite? Does Rebecca have a tinderbox handy?
** Perhaps. [[Videogame/ResidentEvil5 Mercenaries Reunion Reunion]] hints that she's something of a pyro, as one of her special attacks is a flame spray.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Billy says he went in with his "unit", and that their leader was the one who ordered them to do the village. He also calls said leader "sir" in the flashback, so it was an officer who outranked him. I'm thinking the mission was undertaken by his whole company, led by a captain, with Billy leading one the company's platoons.

to:

** Billy says he went in with his "unit", and that their leader was the one who ordered them to do the village. He also calls said leader "sir" in the flashback, so it was an officer who outranked him. I'm thinking the mission was undertaken by his whole company, led by a captain, with Billy leading one of the company's platoons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rebecca survived the whole ordeal and made it to the spencer mansion. She knows a great deal about the evil Umbrella corporation, BOW's, etc. So why doesn't she provide any of this very relevant information to Chris when he finds her? She may even know of Wesker's treacherous nature based on the files she found and Marcus' flashbacks.

to:

* Rebecca survived the whole ordeal and made it to the spencer Spencer mansion. She knows a great deal about the evil Umbrella corporation, BOW's, etc. So why doesn't she provide any of this very relevant information to Chris when he finds her? She may even know of Wesker's treacherous nature based on the files she found and Marcus' flashbacks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's also pointed out in the book, and shown by how most of the time everyone is alone, that the STARS were pretty well trained to handle themselves without a partner and Rebecca was out on field training. It's still a bit of a flimsy excuse, but there it is.


Added DiffLines:

** In the end, the rest of the platoon was likely feverish and delusional, as pointed out by Billy due to the severe heat. The unit essentially was venting their frustrations, and whether they were as delusional to think the village was still part of the guerrilla unit or they came to their senses after murdering everyone in blind rage only to implicate Billy as the instigator...who knows. In the end though, all that matters...they were a mess and not in their right minds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
just putting this here for future editors

Added DiffLines:

'''As a Headscratchers subpage, all spoilers are unmarked [[Administrivia/SpoilersOff as per policy.]] Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned.'''
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Let's get medieval with the test subjects!]]
* Why does James Marcus have a full on torture-dedicated room in his basement? Which includes things like iron maidens? [[VideoGame/ResidentEvilCodeVeronica Alfred Ashford's]] torture room was explained by him just being a gratuitous sadist who took advantage of his position of power to kill prisoners, but Marcus just seems too singularly focused on his research and his leeches to take time out of his day for unproductive torture sessions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In fact, Rebecca doesn't have anything that would indicate Wesker is a traitor. The Queen Leech never names Birkin and Wesker as the people who assassinated James Marcus, only that "Umbrella" did it. Likewise, all of the files she and Billy finds only refer to the two by their first names - and those could be anyone. There's just no solid evidence connecting Wesker to Umbrella until the encounter in the Tyrant lab.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As TheDarkId mentions in his LetsPlay, zombie sharks. What possible use is there for a zombie shark that a regular shark couldn't do? ''Why'' would you deliberately make a zombie shark in the first place?

to:

* As TheDarkId LetsPlay/TheDarkId mentions in his LetsPlay, zombie sharks. What possible use is there for a zombie shark that a regular shark couldn't do? ''Why'' would you deliberately make a zombie shark in the first place?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** For starters, zombifying the shark is presumably just a preliminary stage in the process. Step two would be finding some way to control the resultant monster. In which case you now have an army of giant zombie sharks at your beck and call, as opposed to real sharks, which can't be tamed. Plenty of ways to use that to terrorize enemy shipping and coastal communities.
*** To say nothing of the ''other'' projects that could be run using infected sharks as a basis. The shark equivalent to Hunters, for example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Perhaps their assumption was that Billy had broken free and started a scuffle that ''caused'' the crash?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** What's especially dumb is the position of the bodies suggests the van crashed and the [=MPs=] were flung through the windshield. Forget Billy. Forget the leeches. Why didn't S.T.A.R.S. [[TakeAThirdOption assume]] they died in the crash and ''then'' Billy escape?

to:

** What's especially dumb is the position of the bodies suggests the van crashed and the [=MPs=] were flung through the windshield. Forget Billy. Forget the leeches. Why didn't S.T.A.R.S. [[TakeAThirdOption assume]] they died in the crash and ''then'' Billy escape?escaped? I'll accept that they had no idea about the leeches, but for them to assume they were murdered as opposed to killed in a car crash when everything points to a violent wreck is strange.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** What's especially dumb is the position of the bodies suggests the van crashed and the [=MPs=] were flung through the windshield. Forget Billy. Forget the leeches. Why didn't S.T.A.R.S. [[TakeAThirdOption assume]] they died in the crash and ''then'' Billy escape?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Given the limited time they spend together and Chris not mentioning Wesker - he disappears for prolonged periods in Chris' campaign, after all, much like Barry for Jill - she might not have thought the information was pertinent, or maybe thought Marcus had a few screws loose, or was just too plain exhausted to tell Chris anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** An empty Zippo can still strike sparks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She does have a chemical mixing kit though, it could have some medicals that didn't show up due to gameplay reasons.

to:

** She does have a chemical mixing kit though, it could have some medicals medical items that didn't show up due to gameplay reasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Does Rebecca have amnesia?]]
* Rebecca survived the whole ordeal and made it to the spencer mansion. She knows a great deal about the evil Umbrella corporation, BOW's, etc. So why doesn't she provide any of this very relevant information to Chris when he finds her? She may even know of Wesker's treacherous nature based on the files she found and Marcus' flashbacks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She does have a chemical mixing kit though, it could have some medicals that didn't show up due to gameplay reasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They were probably created as research specimens to study the effects of the T-Virus on non-human creatures. I doubt they were intended as practical bioweapons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: Magical leeches, away!]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder: The Medic who Doesn't Have Anything Medical]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder: Jumping the (Zombie) Shark?]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder: Light my fire with... something...]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder: MPs killed by something non-human? Has to be the work of the escaped convict!]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder: Alright Rebecca, there are dangerous monsters and cannibals out here, so you go off by yourself and we'll stay together. Sound Good? Good!]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder: Our commanding officer tells us to stop killing innocents? Let's ignore him!]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder: Wrong turn?]]



** The latter. They just happened to find a village that had no guerilla presence. Or, the guerillas had fled by the time they got there.

to:

** The latter. They just happened to find a village that had no guerilla presence. Or, the guerillas had fled by the time they got there.there.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Billy says he went in with his "unit", and that their leader was the one who ordered them to do the village. He also calls said leader "sir" in the flashback, so it was an officer who outranked him. I'm thinking the mission was undertaken by his whole company, led by a captain, with Billy leading one the company's platoons.

Added: 177

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Too hard a sell. Admittedly, that would've been inductive reasoning, but this was before the rampaging outbreak and the mansion incident. What else could they have theorized?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So if there was no guerrilla hideout for Billy's unit to find, just an ordinary peasant village, what killed his teammates other than the African heat, and where did all those traps come from? Or did they just simply take a wrong turn?

to:

* So if there was no guerrilla hideout for Billy's unit to find, just an ordinary peasant village, what killed his teammates other than the African heat, and where did all those traps come from? Or did they just simply take a wrong turn?turn?
**The latter. They just happened to find a village that had no guerilla presence. Or, the guerillas had fled by the time they got there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* So if there was no guerrilla hideout for Billy's unit to find, just an ordinary peasant village, what killed his teammates other than the African heat, and where did all those traps come from? Or did they just simply take a wrong turn?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A 2nd LT is a junior officer, a newly commissioned Marine. This would be one of his first actual outings with his platoon. The men would hardly know him, whereas they very much would know their platoon sergeant. All it would take is for the platoon sergeant to give the word and the rest of the platoon might very well be willing to blame the new CO for their crimes. Billy might also have been serving as a second-in-command to a 1st LT.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Leeches and leech zombies. Leeches have an anesthetic in their saliva when they bite, so the main characters and the people on the train shouldn't be in pain over them. Leeches are also not acidic, so the leech zombies shouldn't cause that sort of burning to the characters.
** These things are Marcus's pet project. They form human shapes, have a HiveMind, and have a mouth on their belly, as opposed to a real leech's mouth (which is at the front end of its body). ''[[CaptainObvious These ain't normal leeches.]]'' All bets are officially off.
* Rebecca is a medic, but she starts out with no healing items. This is semi-justified for gameplay purposes, though. But it's still kind of stupid seeing as she's {{the medic}} of S.T.A.R.S.
* As TheDarkId mentions in his LetsPlay, zombie sharks. What possible use is there for a zombie shark that a regular shark couldn't do? ''Why'' would you deliberately make a zombie shark in the first place?
** Just to see if it works.
*** Also, [[RuleOfCool it's freakin' awesome]].
* Small one, this, but: in Zero, you can create Molotov cocktails with which to torch leech zombies. Not really a problem, except for the fact that you can do this while playing solo with Rebecca, and can do so ''before'' Billy finds fuel for his otherwise-useless lighter. How does it ignite? Does Rebecca have a tinderbox handy?
** Perhaps. Mercenaries Reunion hints that she's something of a pyro, as one of her special attacks is a flame spray.
* Am I the only one bugged by the fact that Bravo Team thought Billy killed the [=MPs=], when the wounds don't look like anything a human could do?
** What sounds more plausible? The dangerous prisoner traveling with the [=MPs=] killed them, or they were killed by zombie viral leeches psychically controlled by an immortal madman?
** They could've theorized that animals were eating the corpses or something, at the very least.
* On that note, why is it that {the medic} is being sent off on her own, seeing as how, you know, ''she's supposed to be a non-combatant?'' Let alone, being sent off when there's what they believe to be a burly convicted murderer running around, who could probably overpower her without them knowing?
** She's a S.W.A.T. Medic, not an Army medic. They don't abide by the Geneva Convention rules on unarmed medical personnel. Police medics can usually handle themselves (as indeed she does), but the whole LetsSplitUpGang part was pretty dumb, even by [=RE=] standards.
** We can blame Rebecca on this. Bravo Team spreads out with sidearms looking for the killer. She's the one who decides to investigate the train with no backup.
* Okay, I was looking up about Billy's rank in the Marines. Apparently, a [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Lieutenant_(United_States)#United_States 2nd Lieutenant leads a group of 16-44 Marines in combat.]] So why did two of the platoon listen to the other Marine, rather than Billy? What, was that one who ordered the execution, let's call him Bob for now, a higher rank than Billy?
** Presumably he did outrank Billy. It may have been a small mission where Billy had a superior officer along and a smaller contingent of Marines than usual. Alternatively, Billy was a new officer and the ranking NCO and the soldiers beneath him were on someone's payroll. Just mutiny and blame the new officer.
** It's entirely possible that they went in with two lieutenants; the operation was high-risk, after all. When the Allies went into Normandy, for example, all paratrooper platoons had two lieutenants and double the usual number of senior [=NCOs=] assigned to them because of losses due to attrition.

Top