History Headscratchers / PhineasAndFerb

31st Jan '16 10:36:09 AM dutchguy1986
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* Jenny was a GranolaGirl, but was she a vegetarian/vegan? They never made it clear.
to:
* Jenny was a GranolaGirl, but was she a vegetarian/vegan? They never made it clear.clear. ** She was, remember she refused the jello in "Day of the Living Gelatin" which as Ferb explained contains bovine byproduct.
31st Jan '16 10:10:53 AM dutchguy1986
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
*** And in "Act your age" the two of them are dating.
31st Jan '16 9:42:22 AM dutchguy1986
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
*** Also don't forget Sergei the Snail, though he would have the lack of limbs issue as well.
12th Jan '16 11:02:24 AM MikeRosoft
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* In "Bully Bromance Breakup", Phineas is finally given a character flaw: an almost OCD-like tenancy to panic if he can't invent anything when given the opportunity to. As entertaining as it was to see him ''finally'' be given a weakness in a normal-length episode, it imposes a ''serious'' ContinutiyError: The episode "The Best Lazy Day Ever". In that one, Phineas is ''repeatedly'' given ''purposefully'' obvious chances to build stuff, and he...doesn't. He declines it very calmly and doesn't break a sweat once. If it was any other show, it really wouldn't bug me, but since this show is so continuity heavy for a cartoon, it's almost as if they gave him that weird habit ''just'' for the sake of answering the fanbase's prayers for character development for him.
to:
* In "Bully Bromance Breakup", Phineas is finally given a character flaw: an almost OCD-like tenancy to panic if he can't invent anything when given the opportunity to. As entertaining as it was to see him ''finally'' be given a weakness in a normal-length episode, it imposes a ''serious'' ContinutiyError: ContinuityError: The episode "The Best Lazy Day Ever". In that one, Phineas is ''repeatedly'' given ''purposefully'' obvious chances to build stuff, and he...doesn't. He declines it very calmly and doesn't break a sweat once. If it was any other show, it really wouldn't bug me, but since this show is so continuity heavy for a cartoon, it's almost as if they gave him that weird habit ''just'' for the sake of answering the fanbase's prayers for character development for him.
10th Jan '16 8:56:16 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* In ''Run Candace Run'', why did they have an episode about Candace being triple-booked with having to do things for her mom, Jeremy and Stacy(though we never see Candace with Stacy however) with the unstable prototype shoes and just cop out by cutting to another thing with a long-lost Johnson family member named Annabelle, and never resolve the original thing? Couldn't everybody have just worked something out like in that SpongeBob episode ''Overbooked?'' My mom tells me that otherwise Candace could have just quickly read that Smorky book to the kids, then go on that play with Stacy and then spend the rest of the time with Jeremy at his family picnic. It's been almost two years since the airing of that episode and I still haven't gotten over that. I still don't find bad enough to even watch repeatedly, however.
to:
* In ''Run Candace Run'', why did they have an episode about Candace being triple-booked with having to do things for her mom, Jeremy and Stacy(though we never see Candace with Stacy however) with the unstable prototype shoes and just cop out by cutting to another thing with a long-lost Johnson family member named Annabelle, and never resolve the original thing? Couldn't everybody have just worked something out like in that SpongeBob ''WesternAnimation/{{SpongeBob|SquarePants}}'' episode ''Overbooked?'' "Overbooked?" My mom tells me that otherwise Candace could have just quickly read that Smorky book to the kids, then go on that play with Stacy and then spend the rest of the time with Jeremy at his family picnic. It's been almost two years since the airing of that episode and I still haven't gotten over that. I still don't find bad enough to even watch repeatedly, however.
27th Dec '15 10:22:34 PM Shadowwing09
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
** Let's hope not, as this show really thrives on being lighthearted. Considering Candace is more a rival than an outright villain, this would be Flanderization or even CharacterDerailment.
27th Dec '15 10:17:22 PM Shadowwing09
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
** Candace may not be a nice person, and how much she cares for her brothers is highly questionable, but there's a big difference in not liking someone / being indifferent to them, and actually wanting them dead. If she ever did that, even her defenders would agree she crossed the MoralEventHorizon.
26th Dec '15 8:31:48 PM FF32
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** It's more like this: When Phineas has a Big Idea, he does it, and enjoys it. Including "Best Lazy Day Ever", it was his Big Idea to do nothing for the day. "Bully Bromance Breakup" however, is the first time he's FORBIDDEN from doing a Big Idea, despite how much he wants to... hence the behavior is not a ContinuityError at all.
to:
** It's more like this: When Phineas has a Big Idea, he does it, and enjoys it. Including "Best Lazy Day Ever", it was his Big Idea to do nothing for the day. "Bully Bromance Breakup" however, is the first time he's FORBIDDEN from doing a Big Idea, despite how much he wants to... hence the behavior is not a ContinuityError SeriesContinuityError at all.
27th Nov '15 9:15:35 AM luiz4200
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
** The armor might have lost the "open" function, preventing him from leaving it.

Added DiffLines:
*** He couldn't lift it but he still could hold it? His first sign that something was wrong was when he threw the hammer and it fell down instead of striking the intended targets.
20th Nov '15 11:16:28 PM smalltime
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* Is Phineas even aware that Candace wants to get him and ferb in trouble most of the time? I mean, there are times when Candace flat out says that she is going to bust them for whatever it is that they have planned for the day.
to:
* Is Phineas even aware that Candace wants to get him and ferb in trouble most of the time? I mean, there are times when Candace flat out says that she is going to bust them for whatever it is that they have planned for the day.day. * Jenny was a GranolaGirl, but was she a vegetarian/vegan? They never made it clear.
This list shows the last 10 events of 700. Show all.