Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / PapersPlease

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Yes. See China and other countries that have instituted gender-selective policies in the past.

to:

*** Yes. See China and other countries that have instituted gender-selective birth policies in the past.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Yes. See China and other countries that have instituted gender-selective policies in the past.

Added: 178

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Everyone is shown entering Arstotzka on foot. How do they get their vehicles to the other side? Do they have another inspector in another booth for cars?

to:

* Everyone is shown entering Arstotzka on foot. How do they get their vehicles to the other side? Do they have another inspector in another booth for cars?


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Impossibly-Thin Bomb]]
* How the hell did that terrorist on day 15 fit that bomb through the tiny slit on the booth? You can clearly see it's too thick to fit.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Road access?]]
Everyone is shown entering Arstotzka on foot. How do they get their vehicles to the other side? Do they have another inspector in another booth for cars?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Forged seals start appearing after it's reported that the MoA's sealing plates were stolen. But if they're using the same sealing plates, why are imperfections so common? The logical situation would be that the visibly-forged seals start showing up ''before'' the plates are stolen, and then after the theft, you'd start seeing them less often, since you can no longer tell from the seal that it's a fake.

to:

* Forged seals start appearing after it's reported that the MoA's [=MoA=]'s sealing plates were stolen. But if they're using the same sealing plates, why are imperfections so common? The logical situation would be that the visibly-forged seals start showing up ''before'' the plates are stolen, and then after the theft, you'd start seeing them less often, since you can no longer tell from the seal that it's a fake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Visibly-forged seals]]
* Forged seals start appearing after it's reported that the MoA's sealing plates were stolen. But if they're using the same sealing plates, why are imperfections so common? The logical situation would be that the visibly-forged seals start showing up ''before'' the plates are stolen, and then after the theft, you'd start seeing them less often, since you can no longer tell from the seal that it's a fake.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Not enough women? Is that really something that realistically happens to an entire country?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wouldn't a "real identity" just be an identity that someone consistently uses for themselves, regardless of what entities have it on record?


*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) and EZIC isn't overly concerned about leaving a paper trail, or that it's within their capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.

to:

*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real legally-recognized identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) and EZIC isn't overly concerned about leaving a paper trail, or that it's within their capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Probably rent is summing up things like electricity, water, etc. And according to the system it’s trying to emulate, it’s almost quite accurate. It was possible to move from one apartment to another, but it was paid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) and isn't EZIC overly concerned about leaving a paper trail, or that it's within EZIC's capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.

to:

*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) and EZIC isn't EZIC overly concerned about leaving a paper trail, or that it's within EZIC's their capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) and isn't overly concerned about leaving a paper trail, or that it's within EZIC's capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.

to:

*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) and isn't EZIC overly concerned about leaving a paper trail, or that it's within EZIC's capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) or that it's within EZIC's capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.

to:

*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) and isn't overly concerned about leaving a paper trail, or that it's within EZIC's capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.

Added: 553

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the Soviet Union, there existed a permit system called "Propiska" which kept track of people's movements and applications for residency. Supporters of Propiska said that it allowed them to track criminals and suspects more easily and prevented overcrowding of lower-class dwellings while opponents said that Propiska violated freedom of movement and promoted segregation by excluding people from certain areas. Perhaps the reason why [=EZIC=] agents don't bring Entry Permits is because they don't want to be identified and tracked down by the Ministry of Information.[[/folder]]

to:

** In the Soviet Union, there existed a permit system called "Propiska" which kept track of people's movements and applications for residency. Supporters of Propiska said that it allowed them to track criminals and suspects more easily and prevented overcrowding of lower-class dwellings while opponents said that Propiska violated freedom of movement and promoted segregation by excluding people from certain areas. Perhaps the reason why [=EZIC=] agents don't bring Entry Permits is because they don't want to be identified and tracked down by the Ministry of Information.Information.
*** That'd be a pretty persuasive argument if it weren't for the fact that Corman Drex has full documentation, including a state-issued ID card. This means either Drex is operating under their real identity (inadvisable to say the least, but not nearly as stupid as annoucing your ties to revolutionary organisation to a state agent) or that it's within EZIC's capabilities to have these documents faked. Unless there's a good reason Drex is a special case, either explanation would render the Inspector's cooperation completely unneccessary.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Apartments]]
* Why does inspector has to pay rent for government-provided apartment? He would need to pay for utilities, so, heat. Is "rent" just the word the game uses for electricity and water for some reason? And also, how can inspector move to another apartment by saving up and paying? In such system as Arstotzka is supposed to emulate, you would be given a place and that's it.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On Day 20, you can use the poison to kill anyone after the EZIC messenger who gives it to you. No one ever questions you about it. Wouldn't an investigation obviously trace back to you given that the victim bites it right after they leave your booth? Alternatively, wouldn't an investigator check the body, notice the suspicious powder on the passport that the victim was carrying, and then investigate your booth and the rubber stamp?

to:

* On Day 20, you can use the poison to kill anyone after the EZIC messenger who gives it to you. No one ever questions you about it. Wouldn't an investigation obviously trace back to you given that the victim bites it right after they leave your booth? Alternatively, wouldn't an investigator check the body, notice the suspicious powder on the stamp on the passport that the victim was carrying, and then investigate your booth and the rubber stamp?stamp that should also have some of the death powder?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On Day 20, you can use the poison to kill anyone after the EZIC messenger who gives it to you. No one ever questions you about it, not even M. Vonel, not even if you kill anyone besides Khaled to avoid ticking the EZIC checklist. Wouldn't an investigation obviously trace back to you given that the victim bites it right after they leave your booth? Alternatively, wouldn't an investigator check the body with a hazmat suit on, notice the suspicious powder on the passport, and then investigate your booth and the rubber stamp?

to:

* On Day 20, you can use the poison to kill anyone after the EZIC messenger who gives it to you. No one ever questions you about it, not even M. Vonel, not even if you kill anyone besides Khaled to avoid ticking the EZIC checklist. it. Wouldn't an investigation obviously trace back to you given that the victim bites it right after they leave your booth? Alternatively, wouldn't an investigator check the body with a hazmat suit on, body, notice the suspicious powder on the passport, passport that the victim was carrying, and then investigate your booth and the rubber stamp?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Suspicion-proof poison]]
* On Day 20, you can use the poison to kill anyone after the EZIC messenger who gives it to you. No one ever questions you about it, not even M. Vonel, not even if you kill anyone besides Khaled to avoid ticking the EZIC checklist. Wouldn't an investigation obviously trace back to you given that the victim bites it right after they leave your booth? Alternatively, wouldn't an investigator check the body with a hazmat suit on, notice the suspicious powder on the passport, and then investigate your booth and the rubber stamp?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Both journalists the inspector encounters are smug, entitled jerks who expect their press passes to give them universal access to anywhere. Unfortunately, these types of journalists [[TruthInTelevision are fairly common in real life]].

Added: 343

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* You'd think that the first time a terrorist jumps over the low wall that the Arstotzkan government would be sensible enough to raise it or at least add barbed wire to deter future attempts. But no. The corruption is so bad that they can't even afford to install barbed wire. Or maybe they're trying to present a better self-image of openness. (High Walls + Barbed Wire = Oppression)[[/folder]]

to:

* You'd think that the first time a terrorist jumps over the low wall that the Arstotzkan government would be sensible enough to raise it or at least add barbed wire to deter future attempts. But no. The corruption is so bad that they can't even afford to install barbed wire. Or maybe they're trying to present a better self-image of openness. (High Walls + Barbed Wire = Oppression)[[/folder]]Oppression)
** There's also the fact that the Arstotzkan government is plagued by bureaucratic inertia and plain old corruption. Very likely there were plans to upgrade the border wall but the resources kept getting "allocated" elsewhere. Plus, the inspector is considered expendable considering how easy he is to replace if killed or arrested.[[/folder]]

Added: 495

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because that stamp of denial tells Jorji this (or at least, this is what I like to think is the meaning): "You're wasting my time with this piece of shit fake passport, holding up the line, costing me time and money to deal with your bullshit. FUCK. OFF."[[/folder]]

to:

** Because that stamp of denial tells Jorji this (or at least, this is what I like to think is the meaning): "You're wasting my time with this piece of shit fake passport, holding up the line, costing me time and money to deal with your bullshit. FUCK. OFF."[[/folder]]"
*** That's subject to AlternateCharacterInterpretation; personally, [[RefugeInAudacity I would be impressed enough by the audacity of bringing in such a blatant fake]] that I'd stamp it real quick just to humor him. Plus, this early in the game, the inspector doesn't know him enough to know how he'd react; it might just be quicker to stamp it and send him on his way than take the passport and risk him kicking up a fuss. (He wouldn't, but the inspector has no way of knowing this.)[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And if they are denied, they still get a good story without actually leaving their homes for more than a few hours. They might prefer it that way.

Added: 187

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Crappy forgeries, of course. Whoever made it didn't think it through.[[/folder]]

to:

** Crappy forgeries, of course. Whoever made it didn't think it through.through.
** Or other checkpoints, with different rules. Border with Kolechia just opened, but there could be checkpoints on other borders, or even an international airport in Arstotzka.
[[/folder]]

Added: 205

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sergiu, at least, mentions that he fought in the war, and his aim is "not like before", suggesting he may be a ShellShockedVeteran. You don't get to talk to the other guards, but it may be the same case for them.[[/folder]]

to:

** Sergiu, at least, mentions that he fought in the war, and his aim is "not like before", suggesting he may be a ShellShockedVeteran. You don't get to talk to the other guards, but it may be the same case for them.them.
** Speaking of, we know nothing about what inspector was doing during the war — he could easily be an ex-soldier too, or even a sniper. His assignment as a border inspector is completely random.
[[/folder]]

Added: 105

Changed: 743

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It doesn't matter whether they get i or not, they get a good Story. So they probably just don't care.

to:

**** Lying about your purpose for entering a country (to report as a journalist) when you're a journalist is a bad idea. And having a forgery can get you arrested, which is a terrible fate for any journalist. No one will come to your aid and the government will be eager to punish you. It might even declare you a foreign spy instead of a journalist, which, since you've broken the law, you can't really defend against (you can't prove your own government didn't put you up to it, and helped you obtain false documents). The journalists likely couldn't get approved for real papers, did not want to risk being 'covert' with forgeries, and so just attempted to wave their press pass and bluster their way past the inspector.
** It doesn't matter whether they get i in or not, they get a good Story.story. So they probably just don't care.

Added: 15

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It doesnt matter wether they get i or not, they get a good Story. So they probably just dont care.[[/folder]]

to:

** It doesnt doesn't matter wether whether they get i or not, they get a good Story. So they probably just dont care.[[/folder]]don't care.
[[/folder]]
----

Added: 653

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Every member of the family has a different threshold of suffering they can take before getting sick and eventually dying. The son, for example, will get sick after only a single day of hunger, while the uncle can go for a full three days. It is possible that the inspector is simply the most resilient of his family.[[/folder]]

to:

** Every member of the family has a different threshold of suffering they can take before getting sick and eventually dying. The son, for example, will get sick after only a single day of hunger, while the uncle can go for a full three days. It is possible that the inspector is simply the most resilient of his family.[[/folder]]family.
** It is very likely that inspector's food share is provided by the goverment. They want employees to work properly and not be distracted by such things as hunger due to accidently skipping dinner. The time used to consume that food is skipped for the sake of gameplay, but it exists. This also explains policy "supply your family or get fired" - without it, workers could survive infinitely while doing really bad ad their work but having no formal reason to be replaced.
** As for heat, there should be some heat source at his workplace, so he don't have to suffer from cold whole day - and he is probably more cold-resilent than his family[[/folder]]

Changed: 11

Removed: 351

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Nevermind, I was mixing up Kolechia and Antegria


** Alternatively the immigrating Kolechians are either in extremely good standing with the Kolchian Government (and possibly spies, given what Arstotzka has been doing to them) or their permits are forgeries. Really really good forgeries (which is possible, given that Jorji will have one at some point).
** Even more alternatively, Elisa is in unusually bad standing with the Kolechian government. There are all sorts of reasons this could be the case in a place like Kolechia. Anything from having criminal family members, to going to the wrong university or having the wrong job (bartending at a place frequented by subversives, for example).[[/folder]]

to:

** Alternatively the immigrating Kolechians are either in extremely good standing with the Kolchian Government (and possibly spies, given what Arstotzka has been doing to them) or their permits are forgeries. Really really good forgeries (which is possible, given that Jorji will have one at some point).
** Even more alternatively, Elisa is in unusually bad standing with the Kolechian government. There are all sorts of reasons this could be the case in a place like Kolechia. Anything from having criminal family members, to going to the wrong university or having the wrong job (bartending at a place frequented by subversives, for example).
point).[[/folder]]

Added: 351

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively the immigrating Kolechians are either in extremely good standing with the Kolchian Government (and possibly spies, given what Arstotzka has been doing to them) or their permits are forgeries. Really really good forgeries (which is possible, given that Jorji will have one at some point).[[/folder]]

to:

** Alternatively the immigrating Kolechians are either in extremely good standing with the Kolchian Government (and possibly spies, given what Arstotzka has been doing to them) or their permits are forgeries. Really really good forgeries (which is possible, given that Jorji will have one at some point).point).
** Even more alternatively, Elisa is in unusually bad standing with the Kolechian government. There are all sorts of reasons this could be the case in a place like Kolechia. Anything from having criminal family members, to going to the wrong university or having the wrong job (bartending at a place frequented by subversives, for example).
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[foldercontrol]]

Top