Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSeason7

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing red link


** [[WomanAreWiser They're too smart or capable]] to want anything to do with [[MilitariesAreUseless the Guard]]?

to:

** [[WomanAreWiser [[WomenAreWiser They're too smart or capable]] to want anything to do with [[MilitariesAreUseless the Guard]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In relation to the above, what's with this mindset anyway. Tirek's backstory showed that he befriended Scorpan, someone who willingly assisted Tirek in his first attempt to steal pony magic, causing him to reform and help seal his brother into Tartaurus, something that couldn't have been possible if becoming a villain was permanent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope disambig


* The Tear Jerker page points out that Spike would have been devastated to see Rarity like this...except we see him cleaning up all the RapunzelHair after the third failed attempt to restore Rarity's mane. Rarity's in the same room in the same distraught state, yet he doesn't bat an eyelid. He doesn't even glance at her.

to:

* The Tear Jerker page points out that Spike would have been devastated to see Rarity like this...except we see him cleaning up all the RapunzelHair hair after the third failed attempt to restore Rarity's mane. Rarity's in the same room in the same distraught state, yet he doesn't bat an eyelid. He doesn't even glance at her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Throughout the series, it's suggested that the ponies have a decent handle on plastics (such as in "The Parent Map", where we're shown smoothies served in what appear to be disposable plastic cups). Depending on the precise state of their polymer science, artificial leather could be possible. Though that does raise the question of why they'd go to the trouble of developing artificial leather when they presumably never bothered with natural leather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** What we see Derpy is a sadly realistic depiction of [[https://aapos.org/glossary/strabismus strabismus]], a medical condition in which the eyes are unaligned. There isn't always a concrete reason for it in children, but it could be caused by trauma (perhaps while flying) or a genetic condition affecting the brain and/or tendons that control the eyes. It usually starts at an early age—around age three—and lack of treatment can cause it to worsen over time, often resulting in poor vision in one eye and severe loss of depth perception. It shouldn't be hard to see how those would lead to poor performance in flying competitions.

to:

** What we see in Derpy is a sadly realistic depiction of [[https://aapos.org/glossary/strabismus strabismus]], a medical condition in which the eyes are unaligned. There isn't always a concrete reason for it in children, but it could be caused by trauma (perhaps while flying) or a genetic condition affecting the brain and/or tendons that control the eyes. It usually starts at an early age—around age three—and lack of treatment can cause it to worsen over time, often resulting in poor vision in one eye and severe loss of depth perception. It shouldn't be hard to see how those would lead to poor performance in flying competitions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** What we see Derpy is a sadly realistic depiction of [[https://aapos.org/glossary/strabismus strabismus]]. There isn't always a concrete reason for it in children, but it could be caused by trauma (perhaps while flying) or a genetic condition affecting the brain and/or tendons that control the eyes. It usually starts at an early age—around age three—and lack of treatment can cause it to worsen over time, often resulting in poor vision in one eye and severe loss of depth perception. It shouldn't be hard to see how those would lead to poor performance in flying competitions.

to:

** What we see Derpy is a sadly realistic depiction of [[https://aapos.org/glossary/strabismus strabismus]].strabismus]], a medical condition in which the eyes are unaligned. There isn't always a concrete reason for it in children, but it could be caused by trauma (perhaps while flying) or a genetic condition affecting the brain and/or tendons that control the eyes. It usually starts at an early age—around age three—and lack of treatment can cause it to worsen over time, often resulting in poor vision in one eye and severe loss of depth perception. It shouldn't be hard to see how those would lead to poor performance in flying competitions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** What we see Derpy is a sadly realistic depiction of [[https://aapos.org/glossary/strabismus strabismus]]. There isn't always a concrete reason for it in children, but it could be caused by trauma (perhaps while flying) or a genetic condition affecting the brain and/or tendons that control the eyes. It usually starts at an early age—around age three—and lack of treatment can cause it to worsen over time, often resulting in poor vision in one eye and severe loss of depth perception. It shouldn't be hard to see how those would lead to poor performance in flying competitions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* During the flashback, Derpy is seen on the podium in first place at first. Then as time goes on, she goes down in the ranks as her eyes are seen shifting into the iconic derp look. What happened to Derpy?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because it was Star Swirl saying it. The point of the episode was everyone looked up to him so highly they followed him and were unwilling to speak against him even if they should have known he was wrong.

Added: 274

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This troper gets the explanation that Thorax and Pharynx are 'brood brothers', fine. That could easily be taken as changeling mother's having large clutches of eggs, or if the implication to take away from that is that Chrysalis is indeed the hive’s mother, fair enough. However, if it is the latter case, it still leaves one awkward question: Who is now reproducing the next generation of changelings? It can’t be Chrysalis, because she’s been toppled and fled the Hive. The only explanation I can come up with is that the great transformation has changed the species’ biology and they now reproduce more like mammals. But even then, that's gonna make things ''[[Franchise/TheLionKing levels of awkward for at least the current generation...]]''

to:

* This troper gets the explanation that Thorax and Pharynx are 'brood brothers', fine. That could easily be taken as changeling mother's having large clutches of eggs, or if the implication to take away from that is that Chrysalis is indeed the hive’s mother, fair enough. However, if it is the latter case, it still leaves one awkward question: Who is now reproducing the next generation of changelings? It can’t be Chrysalis, because she’s been toppled and fled the Hive. The only explanation I can come up with is that the great transformation has changed the species’ biology and they now reproduce more like mammals. But even then, that's gonna make things ''[[Franchise/TheLionKing levels of awkward for at least the current generation...]]''


Added DiffLines:

** Nothing in canon suggests Chrysalis was the biological parent of all the hive, she was only Queen as the political ruler. The implication was the changelings reproduced normally but simply raised them communally like hive insects which changed under their new leadership.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This troper gets the explanation that Thorax and Pharynx are 'brood brothers', fine. That could easily be taken as changeling mother's having large clutches of eggs, or if the implication to take away from that is that Chrysalis is indeed the hive’s mother, fair enough. However, if it is the latter case, it still leaves one awkward question: Who is now reproducing the next generation of changelings? It can’t be Chrysalis, because she’s been toppled and fled the Hive. The only explanation I can come up with is that the great transformation has changed the species’ biology and they now reproduce more like mammals. But even then, that's gonna make things ''[[Franchise/TheLionKing'' levels of awkward for at least the current generation...]]

to:

* This troper gets the explanation that Thorax and Pharynx are 'brood brothers', fine. That could easily be taken as changeling mother's having large clutches of eggs, or if the implication to take away from that is that Chrysalis is indeed the hive’s mother, fair enough. However, if it is the latter case, it still leaves one awkward question: Who is now reproducing the next generation of changelings? It can’t be Chrysalis, because she’s been toppled and fled the Hive. The only explanation I can come up with is that the great transformation has changed the species’ biology and they now reproduce more like mammals. But even then, that's gonna make things ''[[Franchise/TheLionKing'' ''[[Franchise/TheLionKing levels of awkward for at least the current generation...]]]]''

Changed: 14

Removed: 65

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut page.


--->[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicMeta Meta]]\\
[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSetting Setting]]\\

to:

--->[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicMeta Meta]]\\
[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSetting
--->[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSetting Setting]]\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's the same reason for why Rarity rejected all her friends' attempts to make wigs for her. They weren't real/authentic.

to:

** It's the same reason for why Rarity rejected all her friends' attempts to make wigs for her. They weren't real/authentic. Also, all the other wigs fell apart rather easily, and while Rarity did try putting some of the magicked hair on her head, it too fell apart. Chances are that all that hair was was too brittle and delicate to be made into a wig as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The Great and Powerful Trixie merely altered what was already there into a different state.


Added DiffLines:

*** Contacting Discord isn't the hard part, both Twilight and Spike know a spell that sends mail instantly to whomever they choose. The problem is that asking the Lord of Chaos to warp reality to fix Rarity's mane is more likely to insult Discord than anything. He really doesn't like being invoked to perform mundane tasks and is more likely to make things worse out of spite for the disrespect than anything else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's the same reason for why Rarity rejected all her friends' attempts to make wigs for her. They weren't real/authentic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe Rainbow Dash can stomach eating a single pie once in a blue moon if she has to, just not the sheer quantity Pinkie Pie was trying to foist on her. Heck, maybe that's how this mess got started; Rainbow choked down the first pie, told Pinkie she liked it, and realized only too late how many more times she'd be expected to eat them as a result, forcing her to come up with another plan to get rid of them all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The season 9 episode Daring Doubt reveals that [[spoiler: Caballeron actually never knew her secret.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This troper gets the explanation that Thorax and Pharynx are 'brood brothers', fine. That could easily be taken as changeling mother's having large clutches of eggs, or if the implication to take away from that is that Chrysalis is indeed the hive’s mother, fair enough. However, if it is the latter case, it still leaves one awkward question: Who is now reproducing the next generation of changelings? It can’t be Chrysalis, because she’s been toppled and fled the Hive. The only explanation I can come up with is that the great transformation has changed the species’ biology and they now reproduce more like mammals. But even then, that's gonna make things ''[[Franchise/TheLionKing'' levels of awkward for at least the current generation...

to:

* This troper gets the explanation that Thorax and Pharynx are 'brood brothers', fine. That could easily be taken as changeling mother's having large clutches of eggs, or if the implication to take away from that is that Chrysalis is indeed the hive’s mother, fair enough. However, if it is the latter case, it still leaves one awkward question: Who is now reproducing the next generation of changelings? It can’t be Chrysalis, because she’s been toppled and fled the Hive. The only explanation I can come up with is that the great transformation has changed the species’ biology and they now reproduce more like mammals. But even then, that's gonna make things ''[[Franchise/TheLionKing'' levels of awkward for at least the current generation...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* This troper gets the explanation that Thorax and Pharynx are 'brood brothers', fine. That could easily be taken as changeling mother's having large clutches of eggs, or if the implication to take away from that is that Chrysalis is indeed the hive’s mother, fair enough. However, if it is the latter case, it still leaves one awkward question: Who is now reproducing the next generation of changelings? It can’t be Chrysalis, because she’s been toppled and fled the Hive. The only explanation I can come up with is that the great transformation has changed the species’ biology and they now reproduce more like mammals. But even then, that's gonna make things ''[[Disney/TheLionKing Lion King]]'' levels of awkward for at least the current generation...

to:

* This troper gets the explanation that Thorax and Pharynx are 'brood brothers', fine. That could easily be taken as changeling mother's having large clutches of eggs, or if the implication to take away from that is that Chrysalis is indeed the hive’s mother, fair enough. However, if it is the latter case, it still leaves one awkward question: Who is now reproducing the next generation of changelings? It can’t be Chrysalis, because she’s been toppled and fled the Hive. The only explanation I can come up with is that the great transformation has changed the species’ biology and they now reproduce more like mammals. But even then, that's gonna make things ''[[Disney/TheLionKing Lion King]]'' ''[[Franchise/TheLionKing'' levels of awkward for at least the current generation...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Because Twilight WAS that anti-social. Twilight never returned the interest the other students had in her. They spoke to each other in class, that's inevitable, but she wasn't being social with them and didn't hang out with them outside school. The whole reason she forgot about them entirely is because she didn't care about them on a personal level. Twilight was guilty because she realised they wanted to be her friends and now that she understands what that means she understands how harsh her blowing them off was.

Added: 424

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They weren't close enough friends for Twilight to really see them as such (given she completely forgot about them being friends in "Amending Fences", and her brother and foalsitter were family, which is a different enough thing.

to:

** They weren't close enough friends for Twilight to really see them as such (given she completely forgot about them being friends in "Amending Fences", and her brother and foalsitter were family, which is a different enough thing.thing).
*** That doesn't explain why Celestia speaks as if Twilight was completely anti-social, which the series show us she clearly wasn't. Twilight had some kind of relationship with them and it seemed they were also students of Celestia's school. Why have Twilight foster those friendships instead of send her off to a completely new place. Or are we suggesting Celestia had no idea Twilight already had some budding friendships?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** What kind of secrets do you think the Mane Six even have? The worst they've done was Twilight accidently driving the town mad in Lesson Zero, which everyone already knows about since they were all there when it happened, and Rainbow Dash sabotaging the weather factory, where nopony was hurt and the damage has been long fixed. Need I remind you that one of the reigning Princesses of the land once tried to trap Equestria in eternal night and then transformed into an evil, cackling tyrant? Or the spirit of Chaos that plunged Ponyville into madness in recent memory that pops in and out of town all the time with no reaction from anypony? Or how the local pincesses' pupil is a former dictator who brainwashed and enslaved a town, including stealing their cutie marks, and then nearly destroyed all of Equestria out of spite. If the citizens are fine with those then nothing the Mane Six have done is going to shock anyone.


Added DiffLines:

** Likewise, the changelings aren't really the backstabbing type. They're a Hive, they move and live as a whole, the idea of overthrowing Thorax likely wouldn't even occur to them. Heck, the only reason the former Queen was overthrown was because she absolutely refused to do what was best for the Hive and join them in their new way of life. Yes, there are those reluctant to change but there's never an indication they're a danger to the Hive or even to Thorax.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: [=7.03=] A Flurry of Emotions]]
* Princess Cadance and Shining Armor gave Sunburst the responsibility of being Flurry Heart's foalsitter and mentor when they made him Crystaller for the Crystal Empire. Was he simply unavailable or incapable of taking the job at the time? Or did Cadance and Shining forget about him when they turned to Twilight for help?
** The latter is certainly possible; considering how frazzled, hurried, and scatterbrained they are when they arrive it's not impossible for that alternate option to slip their minds in the heat of the moment.
** Given that Sunburst ''is'' Flurry Heart's mentor, whose to say he isn't just as frazzled as her parents? Unlike them, he isn't an alicorn or even moderately powerful as a unicorn. He would have more trouble than either Cadance, Shining ''or'' Twilight keeping up with Flurry.
** Since they were already going to Ponyville for an art gallery they might just have figured that Twilight would enjoy some quality time with her niece and Cadance and Sinning Armor were just frazzled enough to forget that Twilight is a very schedule oriented individual without much free time as of late.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
7.01 was there twice.

Added: 893

Removed: 929

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: [=7.01=] Celestial Advice]]
* In season 1, we're told Twilight has no friends. In season 2, we learn she grew up with a brother and a foalsitter she adores, giving her at least two friendships. In season 5, we learn she did have friends in Canterlot that she unintentionally left behind. Now, in season 7, we hear again Twilight didn't have friends, and Celestia was so desperate for her to socialize, she was willing to shut down the library to force her into it. Okay, writers, which is it? Because there's a difference between never having friends and having old friends that get left behind (which, ironically, was the fault of the pony trying to force her to make friends).
** They weren't close enough friends for Twilight to really see them as such (given she completely forgot about them being friends in "Amending Fences", and her brother and foalsitter were family, which is a different enough thing.
[[/folder]]


Added DiffLines:

[[folder: [=7.24=] Uncommon Bond]]
* It seems a bit too convenient for Sunburst, a recently introduced supporting character who has made three minor appearances and two appearances in the secondary role, to quickly bond with the mane six during this visit to Ponyville. Has Sunburst actually been studying friendship and making some friends in the Crystal Empire?
** It can actually be a bit of FridgeBrilliance if one thinks about it. Sunburst doesn't bond with the Mane 6 but with Twilight, Trixie and Maud, all ponies who have bonded with Starlight AND have had various troubles forming bonds with others in the past. His getting along with them so easily is actually something he has in common with Starlight!
* Did Starlight and Sunburst genuinely travel back in time, or was it all just an illusion?
** Likely the latter given [[OldShame Starlight's experience with time travel]].
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: [=7.17=] Daring Done?]]
* How is Daring Do even able to maintain her secret identity anymore? As it stands, there seems to be "mainstream" Equestrian society, where everyone thinks that Daring Do is a fictional character and A. K. Yearling is just a talented author, and that same nation's more adventure-prone outskirts and frontier, where everyone knows that Daring Do is real and nobody seems to know who A. K. Yearling is. Daring Do's secret identity seems to rely entirely on people from different areas of the country never interacting -- all it would take to blow her cover is someone taking an exotic vacation and taking a popular book along, or someone from the areas she adventures in going somewhere else in Equestria for whatever reason and happening to see or hear about one of her books, or a newspaper reporting on her adventures and their side effects (in other words, ''exactly like the ones in this episode did'', just with a slightly wider circulation). I mean, it's one thing to suspend disbelief for characters maintaining their secret identities despite some improbabilities, but this is ridiculous.
** While that is all true, it does seem that overall Equestria has a serious communication issue when it comes to how information is spread. Just look at how long it took for Twilight's princess status to start getting much attention outside of Canterlot and Ponyville, and she isn't trying to hide her identity. Then we have Starlight not knowing who the Wonderbolts are, Pharynx not knowing who Twilight is, etc. Even the Mane 6's accomplishments seem to only recently be getting widespread recognition, despite all the celebrations and events held in their honor in earlier seasons its like the knowledge didn't spread much beyond those present at the celebrations. Still, Daring Do has been active as an adventurer for longer than the Mane 6, so it still stretches disbelief. We know tourist/travelling ponies exist, so them not selling her books in a region shouldn't equal complete anonymity for years on end unless said tourists never go there.
** For that matter, Caballeron must be fully aware of her secret. Why doesn't he spill it?
** One possible reason Daring Do could maintain her secret is because her exploits considered fiction by northern ponies while being kind of [[TheGreatestStoryNeverTold greatest stories never told]] for southern. So even if someone tried to tell everyone that Daring Do's heroics are a real deal, they'd have a hard time actually proving it, since locals would only tell about destruction Do leaves behind, but not actual stories.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: [=7.15=] Triple Threat]]
* As the recently appointed and sole leaders of their respective species and kingdoms, it's potentially dangerous for Ember and Thorax to be away from their homelands for any amount of time as it runs the risk of allowing potential enemies to try and make their moves against them. One must wonder who they have that they can absolutely trust to manage local affairs in their absence during their visits to Equestria.
** No answer for Thorax but it's possible that Ember's father, as former Dragon Lord, is watching over her subjects in her absence. It's not like that's new for him.
** Also worth noting is that dragons seems to be loyal to the Dragon Lord, whoever that dragon might be. Garble became entirely loyal to Spike the moment he became the dragon lord for a few minutes, even though up to that point he was willing to kill Spike. So even if the dragons at home were screwing around, the moment Ember comes back it would all be back to regular affairs.
[[/folder]]

Added: 956

Changed: 1022

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: [=7.03=] A Flurry of Emotions]]
* Why couldn't they just take the sick foals to see Zecora?
** Even if Zecora did have a remedy for the horsey hives, she may not have had enough ingredients to heal an entire class. There's also the fact that she's not a licensed doctor; Some parents may not be willing to try something that hasn't been medically proven.

to:

[[folder: [=7.03=] A Flurry of Emotions]]
01=] Celestial Advice]]
* Why couldn't they just take the sick foals to see Zecora?
** Even if Zecora
In season 1, we're told Twilight has no friends. In season 2, we learn she grew up with a brother and a foalsitter she adores, giving her at least two friendships. In season 5, we learn she did have a remedy for the horsey hives, friends in Canterlot that she may not unintentionally left behind. Now, in season 7, we hear again Twilight didn't have had enough ingredients friends, and Celestia was so desperate for her to heal an entire class. There's also the fact that she's not a licensed doctor; Some parents may not be socialize, she was willing to try something shut down the library to force her into it. Okay, writers, which is it? Because there's a difference between never having friends and having old friends that hasn't been medically proven.get left behind (which, ironically, was the fault of the pony trying to force her to make friends).
** They weren't close enough friends for Twilight to really see them as such (given she completely forgot about them being friends in "Amending Fences", and her brother and foalsitter were family, which is a different enough thing.


Added DiffLines:

[[folder: [=7.02=] All Bottled Up]]
* Starlight points out that making things disappear isn't possible with Equestrian magic -- you have to teleport it. But how hard would it be to magically bend light around an object to make it invisible, thus "making it disappear"?
** We know an invisibility spell exists as Starlight used one on herself and Trixie in the previous season finale. Course using it on an object on stage runs the risk of accidentally bumping into it later in the act.
** Also, stage magicians typically wave a hand or wand through the empty space to establish to the audience that your eyes aren't fooling you! The object truly has disappeared from existence! Now imagine how that'd go if the object were just made invisible and Trixie [[DamnYouMuscleMemory forgot that and did the gesture out of habit.]]
** Starlight certainly means the technical definition, making something 'not exist' anymore. An invisible thing still exists.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSeason5 Season 6]]\\

to:

[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSeason5 [[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSeason6 Season 6]]\\

Added: 64

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSeason8 Season 8]]

to:

[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSeason8 Season 8]]8]]\\
[[Headscratchers/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSeason9 Season 9]]

Top