History Headscratchers / MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicIDW

25th Sep '17 5:03:41 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: MLP:FiM #58]]
* According to this comic, Mage Meadowbrook never had foals, implying Cattail, repeatedly stated to be her dependent, is related through Mage Meadowbrook's sister, making her his distant aunt. I've never seen ancestry (which implies straight line of decent) work this way. Anything?
[[/folder]]
12th Jun '17 11:14:43 AM Philweasel
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** The elements weren't directly aimed at her, and this issue considers the elements as the embodiment of ''order''. As Starlight actually explains, she's not the most chaotic of ponies herself. They didn't work on her for the same reason they didn't work on Accord.
27th May '17 2:17:45 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** According to artist/writer Andy Price (LineToGod), the comics are only canon until the show says otherwise.

to:

** [[LineToGod According to artist/writer Andy Price (LineToGod), Price]], the comics are only canon until the show says otherwise.
27th May '17 2:15:00 PM FlamingSamurai
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[folder: MLP:FiM #1 - #4]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #1 - #4]]#4 (The Return of Queen Chrysalis)]]



[[folder: MLP:FiM #5 - #8]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #5 - #8]]#8 (Nightmare Rarity)]]



[[folder: MLP:FiM #11 - #12]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #11 - #12]]#12 (Neigh Anything)]]



[[folder: MLP:FiM #17 - #20]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #17 - #20]]#20 (Reflections)]]



[[folder: MLP:FiM #34 - #37]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #34 - #37]]#37 (Siege of the Crystal Empire)]]



[[folder: MLP:FiM #48 - #50]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #48 - #50]]#50 (Chaos Theory)]]
27th May '17 2:13:32 PM FlamingSamurai
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** According to artist/writer Andy Price, the comics are only canon until the show says otherwise.

to:

** According to artist/writer Andy Price, Price (LineToGod), the comics are only canon until the show says otherwise.
27th May '17 2:11:17 PM FlamingSamurai
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** The comics follow the shows continuity but the show does not.

to:

** The According to artist/writer Andy Price, the comics follow the shows continuity but are only canon until the show does not.says otherwise.
15th Mar '17 6:07:32 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message








* Why is Iron Will involved in the VillainTeamUp? AT ALL? He's ''never'' been a villain in any appearances or had a SINGLE villainous moment. And the reason for it makes ''zero'' sense. Iron Will was ''never'' about trying to scare anyone, nor did it play in ''at all'' period. He was about using your anger as a tool and motivator and to not take any crap. Fear had nothing to do with it, ''anger'' was his thing. It makes ''no sense'' and comes off more as the justification a bad fanfic would use to make him a RonTheDeathEater than something that should pop up in canon. If they wanted a Minotaur, use freaking Well-To-Do. He was an actual ''villain'' who would have reason to want payback on the mane six.
** Wasn't he EATEN at the end of his debut arc? Kinda hard to bring someone back when they've been digested. With Sombra, Hope at least had a horn and his consciousness to work with.
** He was still alive the last time we saw him.

to:

* Why is Iron Will involved in the VillainTeamUp? AT ALL? He's ''never'' been a villain in any appearances or had a SINGLE villainous moment. And the reason for it makes ''zero'' sense. Iron Will was ''never'' about trying to scare anyone, nor did it play in ''at all'' period. He was about using your anger as a tool and motivator and to not take any crap. Fear had nothing to do with it, ''anger'' was his thing. It makes ''no sense'' and comes off more as the justification a bad fanfic would use to make him a RonTheDeathEater than something that should pop up in canon. If they wanted a Minotaur, use freaking Well-To-Do. He was an actual ''villain'' who would have reason to want payback on the mane six.\n** Wasn't he EATEN at the end of his debut arc? Kinda hard to bring someone back when they've been digested. With Sombra, Hope at least had a horn and his consciousness to work with. \n** He was still alive the last time we saw him.


Added DiffLines:

** The series has always worked on the basis of StrongAsTheyNeedToBe, this is just the logical conclusion.
2nd Feb '17 7:56:21 AM Peridonyx
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[folder: MLP:FiM #48 - 50]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #48 - 50]]#50]]
2nd Feb '17 7:56:07 AM Peridonyx
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[folder: MLP:FiM #34-#37]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #34-#37]]#34 - #37]]



[[folder: MLP:FiM #48-50]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #48-50]]#48 - 50]]
2nd Feb '17 7:55:43 AM Peridonyx
Is there an issue? Send a Message




Added DiffLines:


[[folder: MLP:FiM #48-50]]
* So Starlight, already (somehow) powerful enough to match an Alicorn, can even [[spoiler:shield herself from the freaking '''''Elements of Harmony''''' -- i.e., the top dogs on the SuperWeight scale]]?
[[/folder]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 54. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicIDW