Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MobileSuitGundamSEED

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's possible that the Federation uses mechanized factories for things like MS production and outfitting, so they could easily have programmed said factories to rapidly churn out new equipment, and quickly retrofitted older model suits, while rapidly beginning work on new models. Also, it's not like the Federation entirely had to worry about success rate. Even if a few suits failed, they had reserves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I always reasoned that they were that shape to reflect radar waves, similar to the nighthawk stealth plane in the real world. Although given the fact that neutron jammers are a thing in seed this probably would not work too well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A large amount of the confusion surrounding Kira's survival is the fault of the animators. Logically speaking, the self-destruction of the Aegis should be nowhere near as violent as portrayed in the actual show. The reason is simple; neither suit is actually powered by a reactor, but is instead fueled by an energy battery with a starkly limited operation time. When the self-destruct system for the Aegis is triggered, it has already expended so much energy that it has been left physically incapable of moving. The Strike on the other hand still has active PS Armor, indicating that it still has at least enough energy to power it's primary defensive system. If you disregard the hilariously over-the-top detonation depicted in the TV show, Kira's survival becomes far more believable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This one's AllThereInTheManual - in the ''GundamSEEDAstray'' side story, it's shown that Lowe witnesses the end of said battle and recovers the critically injured Kira from the Strike, bringing him to the Reverend.

to:

** This one's AllThereInTheManual - in the ''GundamSEEDAstray'' ''Manga/MobileSuitGundamSEEDAstray'' side story, it's shown that Lowe witnesses the end of said battle and recovers the critically injured Kira from the Strike, bringing him to the Reverend.



** Unfortunately, if you go all MoHS scale on Gundam, you'll find that very little actually works, especially when you start going at it with thermodynamics. Where are the radiators on the ships (in ''any'' Gundam show)? How come ''anybody's'' able to dodge particle beams? How on Earth does an [[MobileSuitGundam I-field]] repel mega particles, when it's ''specifically stated'' that mega particles are electrostatically neutral? If not electrostatic, then what force is repelling the mega particles? And for that matter, why is the most effective form of combat vehicle a 10X mechanical scale replica of a human being? What it comes down to is that in terms of the science of a Gundam show, [[MST3KMantra you should really just relax]].

to:

** Unfortunately, if you go all MoHS scale on Gundam, you'll find that very little actually works, especially when you start going at it with thermodynamics. Where are the radiators on the ships (in ''any'' Gundam show)? How come ''anybody's'' able to dodge particle beams? How on Earth does an [[MobileSuitGundam [[Anime/MobileSuitGundam I-field]] repel mega particles, when it's ''specifically stated'' that mega particles are electrostatically neutral? If not electrostatic, then what force is repelling the mega particles? And for that matter, why is the most effective form of combat vehicle a 10X mechanical scale replica of a human being? What it comes down to is that in terms of the science of a Gundam show, [[MST3KMantra you should really just relax]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The term was coined in-universe by the first Coordinator, George Glenn, who basically thought that genetically enhanced humans like himself could help push humanity into a new golden age, helping to "coordinate humanity's efforts". The name stuck. Out-of-universe, I always took it to be a reference to their generally enhanced ability to multitask when compared to a Natural human.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Coordinators are genetically enhanced humans. Fine. But why are they [=CALLED=] coordinators? What do they coordinate?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Changed: 179

Removed: 179

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Not really, since in Destiny we are told that both factions signed a treaty to restrict use of nuclear technology in military vehicles, specially the MS. It would be safe to assume that warships fall under that treaty too. So they kept using whatever technology they used before, or they started using hyper-deuterium reactors (which seem to not affected by said treaty, since noone made a fuss over the Destiny and the Legend using them).

This last theory tough seems a little shaky, since the hyper-deuterium reactors were in test phase at that point and only 4 MS had them : Destiny, Legend, S.Freedom and I.Justice.

to:

*** Not really, since in Destiny we are told that both factions signed a treaty to restrict use of nuclear technology in military vehicles, specially the MS. It would be safe to assume that warships fall under that treaty too. So they kept using whatever technology they used before, or they started using hyper-deuterium reactors (which seem to not affected by said treaty, since noone made a fuss over the Destiny and the Legend using them). \n\n This last theory tough seems a little shaky, since the hyper-deuterium reactors were in test phase at that point and only 4 MS had them : Destiny, Legend, S.Freedom and I.Justice.

Added: 182

Changed: 445

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----

to:

----***Not really, since in Destiny we are told that both factions signed a treaty to restrict use of nuclear technology in military vehicles, specially the MS. It would be safe to assume that warships fall under that treaty too. So they kept using whatever technology they used before, or they started using hyper-deuterium reactors (which seem to not affected by said treaty, since noone made a fuss over the Destiny and the Legend using them).

This last theory tough seems a little shaky, since the hyper-deuterium reactors were in test phase at that point and only 4 MS had them : Destiny, Legend, S.Freedom and I.Justice.
---
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The series never actually explains this, but I would guess some extremely large batteries charged via solar power. Of course, once N-Jammer Cancellers were distributed, they could resume nuclear power once again, so I imagine that Destiny-era warships would be nuclear-powered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* What is the power source for the spaceships? Is it nuclear? They must have a greater energy requirements than the MS and yet they aren't affected by N-jammers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* So, here's something that is confusing me about the Skygrasper. Specifically, its missiles. After managing to find an image of them that shows them from different angles, I have found out that they are triangular prisms compared to the cylindrical shape of normal missiles. I just have to ask, is there a point to having missiles shaped like that?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Most likely they can still catch common ailments. The human immune system isn't something that can be perfected through some genetic tinkering, though it might be possible to improve it a bit. Genetically-transmitted diseases on the other hand are likely near non-existent in Coordinators for obvious reasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


*Can Coordinators get sick? I mean like a commen cold or the flu. I've seen various fansites and fanfiction that say no,and while I recall Kira saying they don't get sick it seemed like he meant serious terminal illnesses like cancer. Not to mention Kira himself does get a fever in one episode(and Meyrin Hawke gets an infection at point in Destiny).Therefore is in fact possible for a Coordinator to catch a cold or say the Chicken Pox?

Added: 247

Changed: 263

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding my two bits


*** Lowe ''is'' there during Aegis and Strike's sword fight and quickly rush-in once th battle is over. Strike's PS went down ''after'' he already pull Kira out. You can assume that cockpit wasn't burned until the outside heat creep-in afterward.

to:

**** In the manga, it shows that the damage to the cockpit is caused by something blowing in it AFTER Kira abandons mech.
*** Lowe ''is'' there during Aegis and Strike's sword fight and quickly rush-in once th the battle is over. Strike's PS went down ''after'' he already pull Kira out. You can assume that cockpit wasn't burned until the outside heat creep-in afterward.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because they aren't genetically engineered. They're on a regimen of drugs that enhance their mental and physical abilities to the point where they can fight Coordinators. Not the same thing as genetic engineering, or at least not in Azrael's mind[[note]]see also religious people who convince themselves that various sexual acts aren't real sex[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Muruta Azrael

Added DiffLines:

* Supposedly, Muruta Azrael is against the Coordinators and anything revolving around genetic engineering. If so, then why did he have no qualms relying on the Biological CPUs starting from the battle with Orb and later?

Added: 428

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Er, no. A spherical blast at that distance from earth would have ABSOLUTELY no effect on the planet. The energy from a spherical blast is proportional to the square of the distance.

to:

**** *** Er, no. A spherical blast at that distance from earth would have ABSOLUTELY no effect on the planet. The energy from a spherical blast is proportional to the square of the distance.distance.
*** Point still stands: even if Earth is unaffected, both fleets of spaceships and the PLANTS would annihilated. Even if the EA higher-ups were willing to sacrifice their entire space fleet to end ZAFT, how many soldiers in the fleet would be willing to follow such an order? (Remember when the EA sacrificed a huge chunk of forces at Alaska, they did so with subterfuge: none of the soldiers there knew they were going to die.)
Willbyr MOD

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hottip cleanup; see thread for details.


* How did Kira possibly get in the Freedom Gundam, leave the PLANT, evade ZAFT forces ''and'' get to Alaska in time to save the Archangel? Even if we assume the PLANT was relatively close to Earth it should have taken the fastest possible vessel hours[[hottip:*: assuming applied phlebotinum sped him up, if it were realistic it would have been more like days at best]] to get there. By the time he was shown the Gundam the battle was already close to self-destruct time, they should have been long dead before he even reached Earth's atmosphere!

to:

* How did Kira possibly get in the Freedom Gundam, leave the PLANT, evade ZAFT forces ''and'' get to Alaska in time to save the Archangel? Even if we assume the PLANT was relatively close to Earth it should have taken the fastest possible vessel hours[[hottip:*: assuming hours[[note]]assuming applied phlebotinum sped him up, if it were realistic it would have been more like days at best]] best[[/note]] to get there. By the time he was shown the Gundam the battle was already close to self-destruct time, they should have been long dead before he even reached Earth's atmosphere!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Er, no. A spherical blast at that distance from earth would have ABSOLUTELY no effect on the planet. The energy from a spherical blast is proportional to the square of the distance.
* How the hell did the Calamity Gundam survive Mwu's suprise attack with Perfect Strike's Anti-Ship Sword in the Remaster besides plot armor. Yes, they needed him alive, but they could at least have avoided having him shrug off getting blindsided with the strongest melee weapon in the show, right?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** It's well known that Phase Shift offers Heat Resistance, hence why Gundams can survive atmospheric re-entry. So it's not so far-fetched.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The N-Jammer's function would require the manipulation of weak/strong nuclear forces. This is generally the answer to others of it's kin. Like above, its a very basic force of reality and physics. This brings the reason why they don't use antimatter induced fusion warheads... They do use antimatter like mad... Some lines of thought do indicate that the manipulation of wing/strong nuclear forces would cause disruptions to electronic wavelengths.

to:

*** The N-Jammer's function would require the manipulation of weak/strong nuclear forces. This is generally the answer to others of it's kin. Like above, its a very basic force of reality and physics. This brings the reason question why they don't use antimatter induced fusion warheads... They do use antimatter like mad... Some lines of thought do indicate that the manipulation of wing/strong nuclear forces would cause disruptions to electronic wavelengths.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The N-Jammer's function would require the manipulation of weak/strong nuclear forces. This is generally the answer to others of it's kin. Like above, its a very basic force of reality and physics. This brings the reason why they don't use antimatter induced fusion warheads... They do use antimatter like mad... Some lines of thought do indicate that the manipulation of wing/strong nuclear forces would cause disruptions to electronic wavelengths.


Added DiffLines:

*** Actually ANY laser hitting ANY material would cause a plume of plasma each hit in addition to radiation effects. Gamma radiation however would disrupt electronics horrifically. Its part of the reason nukes are so devastating in atmo. X-Rays and Gamma radiation gets absorbed by atmospheric gasses and causes intense ionization to create an EMP blast. This radiation is only shortrange in space unless focused. If focused however this would be deadly to anyone in it's path. You practically have to have a meter of lead to simply protect you from gamma radiation in space due to the fact you don't have the atmosphere and magnetosphere to protect you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Also, it was never actually stated that beam weapons ignore phase shift armor. Beam weapons are just generally powerful enough to overcome the defense provided. This is most obvious with the Freedom, which took a couple hits to the torso from such weapons on different occasions and still wasn't destroyed.

Added: 1110

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** First, how on earth did the Phase Shift Armour stop the Kusanagi's Lohengrin Positron Blaster Cannon? It's bad enough that they gave Phase Shift Armor the ability to block beam weapons if you feed in enough power when it was well established that beams ignored the stuff. But the Lohengrin is an antimatter weapon. It doesn't really matter what your armor is made of when half the energy of the blast comes from the electrons in the surface of the armor turning into gamma rays.

to:

** First, how on earth did the Phase Shift Armour stop the Kusanagi's Lohengrin Positron Blaster Cannon? It's bad enough that they gave Phase Shift Armor the ability to block beam weapons if you feed in enough power when it was well established that beams ignored the stuff. But the Lohengrin is an antimatter weapon. It doesn't really matter what your armor is made of when half the energy of the blast comes from the electrons in the surface of the armor turning into gamma rays. rays.
*** Phase Shift armor doesn't draw its strength from an alloy: it generates a force field just barely above the physical surface of the armor. The armor's strength is completely dependent on how much power you feed into it to strengthen the force field. It isn't that beam weapons ignore PS armor, it's that a Mobile Suit doesn't have the power output to up the field to the point it can effectively block beams. Genesis had nigh-unlimited power thanks to massive nuclear reactors, thus its PS armor is practically invincible. If the positrons are repelled before they get anywhere near electrons, the Lohengrin loses a lot of its destructive potential.


Added DiffLines:

*** The mirror blocks merely focus the blast. Firing Genesis without the block would still result in the same huge amount of gamma radiation getting output, except rather than a coherent beam, it is just sprayed out in all directions. That would still cause quite a bit of damage to Earth, not to mention frying everything else in the surrounding battlefield, including the PLANTS. That outcome is hardly any better than allowing Genesis to fire unhindered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I repeated stuff


*** Actually this has been briefly explained in ''SEED'' and ''SEED X Astray''. The Reverend states that Kira had the SEED gene activated in that explosion so his mortal wounds were reduced to serious ones. It is needed to say that the SEED gene's function are unknown but basing it from the Character Theatre parodies it appears as it enhances the body physically. Lowe also states that the Strike served as a shield to Kira in ''Astray''. His wounds are actually the result of Strike suffering some damages and the mobile suit was later repaired without problems and they could even improve it.

to:

*** Actually this has been briefly explained in ''SEED'' and ''SEED X Astray''. The Reverend states that Kira had the SEED gene activated in that explosion so his mortal wounds were reduced to serious ones. It is needed to say that the SEED gene's function are unknown but basing it from the Character Theatre parodies it appears as it enhances the body physically. Lowe also states that the Strike served as a shield to Kira in ''Astray''. His wounds are actually the result of Strike suffering some damages and the mobile suit was later repaired without problems and they could even improve it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Actually this has been briefly explained in ''SEED'' and ''SEED X Astray''. The Reverend states that Kira had the SEED gene activated in that explosion so his mortal wounds were reduced to serious ones. It is needed to say that the SEED gene's function are unknown but basing it from the Character Theatre parodies it appears as it enhances the body physically. Lowe also states that the Strike served as a shield to Kira in ''Astray''. His wounds are actually the result of Strike suffering some damages and the mobile suit was later repaired without problems and they could even improve it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The entire sequence where the Kusanagi and Eternal attack Genesis makes no sense whatsoever.
** First, how on earth did the Phase Shift Armour stop the Kusanagi's Lohengrin Positron Blaster Cannon? It's bad enough that they gave Phase Shift Armor the ability to block beam weapons if you feed in enough power when it was well established that beams ignored the stuff. But the Lohengrin is an antimatter weapon. It doesn't really matter what your armor is made of when half the energy of the blast comes from the electrons in the surface of the armor turning into gamma rays.
** Second, why didn't they just target the mirror block if they couldn't destroy Genesis. It wasn't armored at least to the same degree and would have prevented the weapon from working until it was replaced if destroyed.

Added: 219

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Have you SEEN how long the Valiants are? By the time you got the barrel aimed anywhere NEAR the (fast-moving) enemy suits, the damn things would be dragging in the water. Not to mention how slow the Valiants are to rotate, and the fact the gunners apparently can't hit the broad side of a ''Naszca'' with them, let alone mobile suits.

to:

*** Have you SEEN how long the Valiants are? By the time you got the barrel aimed anywhere NEAR the (fast-moving) enemy suits, the damn things would be dragging in the water. Not to mention how slow the Valiants are to rotate, and the fact the gunners apparently can't hit the broad side of a ''Naszca'' ''Nazca'' with them, let alone mobile suits.suits.
**** In defense of the gunners, mobile suit combat may take place at close to melee range, but warship combat does not, and there's a powerful ECM in effect during battle, so hitting an enemy ship would be pretty tough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** This is fanon, but it's been pointed out that [=ZAFT's=] fleet couldn't have dropped on Alaska if they were already positioned to drop on Panama, so the fleet would either have needed to reposition itself into an inclined orbit or they would have had to approach the Earth very differently before reaching drop altitude. Therefore, they could have known that the target had been changed several hours before the attack began. And since it was a major battle, it would have lasted several hours as well.


Added DiffLines:

*** To expand on this, the reason it takes so long for real spacecraft to get to the moon is that they basically glide there. And in space it's not so much a matter of speed as acceleration. Since there's nothing to provide drag like there is in the atmosphere, an object can keep accelerating essentially forever (cosmic speed limit excepted). Now, the Freedom can fly, so its thrusters are capable of acceleration of at least 10 m/s^2. Assuming that minimum, it would take 2000 seconds, or about 33 minutes, to accelerate to 20 km/s. At that speed, it would have taken only about 5 and a half hours to get to Earth, and the Freedom is probably quite a bit faster than the assumption I've used here. So yeah, Kira could have made that flight in the time required.

Top