Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / HowToTrainYourDragon2

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All this being said, it does seem that Hiccup wasn't taking to her story right away and is visibly uncomfortable interacting with her for a good majority of their initial conversation. When his mother goes on about some of the dragons there that were injured by the vikings--specifically Toothless' injury--notice how Hiccup feels the need to pad the story of Toothless' missing wing by jokingly calling attention to his own amputation, as if he believes that his mother may not accept him if she knew he hurt a dragon. Her actions--or lack there of--do not seem to make her one hundred percent endearing to Hiccup, and Valka does seem to realize that there is some faulty reasoning behind her willingness to stay away from her family. When Stoick and Gobber walk in, they don't get to hear her story, and Stoick is clearly mesmerized by the discovery of his wife being alive, but had their reunion not lasted only a couple of hours it's possible that Valka's leaving her family would have been discussed with the possible [[WhatTheHellHero calling out of Valka's decision to permanently remove herself from Berk]] [[CassandraTruth all because she has discovered that dragons are actually capable of coexisting peacefully with humans.]]

to:

* All this being said, it does seem that Hiccup wasn't taking to her story right away and is visibly uncomfortable interacting with her for a good majority of their initial conversation. When his mother goes on about some of the dragons there that were injured by the vikings--specifically Toothless' injury--notice how Hiccup feels the need to pad the story of Toothless' missing wing by jokingly calling attention to his own amputation, as if he believes that his mother may not accept him if she knew he hurt a dragon. Her actions--or lack there of--do thereof--do not seem to make her one hundred percent endearing to Hiccup, and Valka does seem to realize that there is some faulty reasoning behind her willingness to stay away from her family. When Stoick and Gobber walk in, they don't get to hear her story, and Stoick is clearly mesmerized by the discovery of his wife being alive, but had their reunion not lasted only a couple of hours it's possible that Valka's leaving her family would have been discussed with the possible [[WhatTheHellHero calling out of Valka's decision to permanently remove herself from Berk]] [[CassandraTruth all because she has discovered that dragons are actually capable of coexisting peacefully with humans.]]



* Valka is saved for me by the fact that neither she nor the movie consider her to be particularly heroic. She's a good person, like her son, but unlike her son she lacks the courage and strength of character to really challenge the way things are. She clearly understands this and constantly apologizes and offers weak rationalizations for her actions, and once the bad guy appears she is rather ineffectual.She's cool, knowledgeable and kind hearted, but she's not a hero like her son is. That is why she didn't go back (which in fairness Hiccup himself seriously considered in the first movie).

to:

* Valka is saved for me by the fact that neither she nor the movie consider her to be particularly heroic. She's a good person, like her son, but unlike her son she lacks the courage and strength of character to really challenge the way things are. She clearly understands this and constantly apologizes and offers weak rationalizations for her actions, and once the bad guy appears she is rather ineffectual.She's cool, knowledgeable and kind hearted, kindhearted, but she's not a hero like her son is. That is why she didn't go back (which in fairness Hiccup himself seriously considered in the first movie).



** Eret had failed to supply enough dragons before, he actually shows Hiccup a brand on his chest that Drago gave him as punishment for that. Drago basically just runs his army with [[IncrediblyLamePun draconian]] punishments it seems to keep order. Sort of like how the Romans had a very harsh discipline code. Basically, Eret had failed before, and this was just another failure since if Drago hadn't had sentries to ambush the Riders of Berk they might have been able to get away and warn Berk without him knowing he was revealed to an enemy who actually stood a chance against him.

to:

** Eret had failed to supply enough dragons before, he actually shows Hiccup a brand on his chest that Drago gave him as punishment for that. Drago basically just runs his army with [[IncrediblyLamePun [[{{Pun}} draconian]] punishments it seems to keep order. Sort of like how the Romans had a very harsh discipline code. Basically, Eret had failed before, and this was just another failure since if Drago hadn't had sentries to ambush the Riders of Berk they might have been able to get away and warn Berk without him knowing he was revealed to an enemy who actually stood a chance against him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Might HAVE, not might OF.


** Eret had failed to supply enough dragons before, he actually shows Hiccup a brand on his chest that Drago gave him as punishment for that. Drago basically just runs his army with [[IncrediblyLamePun draconian]] punishments it seems to keep order. Sort of like how the Romans had a very harsh discipline code. Basically, Eret had failed before, and this was just another failure since if Drago hadn't had sentries to ambush the Riders of Berk they might of been able to get away and warn Berk without him knowing he was revealed to an enemy who actually stood a chance against him.

to:

** Eret had failed to supply enough dragons before, he actually shows Hiccup a brand on his chest that Drago gave him as punishment for that. Drago basically just runs his army with [[IncrediblyLamePun draconian]] punishments it seems to keep order. Sort of like how the Romans had a very harsh discipline code. Basically, Eret had failed before, and this was just another failure since if Drago hadn't had sentries to ambush the Riders of Berk they might of have been able to get away and warn Berk without him knowing he was revealed to an enemy who actually stood a chance against him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Or it's possible that Valka convinced the white Bewilderbeast to not send its flock a-raiding anymore, and prior to that, Berk was attacked by both the Red Death and White Alpha's dragons. This is supported by the fact that the raid appears larger scale than the one that opened the first movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's pretty clear that his mother was never big, and yet his dad gives him a helmet and claims it's HALF of her breastplate? Or was she just big before Hiccup was born? This was HtTyD1 by the way, right after Hiccup's awesome flight test with Toothless.

to:

* It's pretty clear that his mother was never big, and yet his dad gives him a helmet and claims it's HALF of her breastplate? Or was she just big before Hiccup was born? This was HtTyD1 [=HTTYD1=] by the way, right after Hiccup's awesome flight test with Toothless.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** That is entirely inaccurate, it's like saying that everyone in the USA want's to rule the world. The kind of Viking you describe where only a small part of the whole. Many Vikings where peacefull traders, farmers, craftsmen and what not. Those where normal people as well. The 'typical' Vikings we know, the one plundering and destroying villages where often considered criminals or at least far from normal people back home.

to:

*** That is entirely inaccurate, it's like saying that everyone in the USA want's to rule the world. The kind of Viking you describe where only a small part of the whole. Many Vikings where peacefull peaceful traders, farmers, craftsmen and what not. Those where normal people as well. The 'typical' Vikings we know, the one plundering and destroying villages where often considered criminals or at least far from normal people back home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All this being said, it does seem that Hiccup wasn't taking to her story right away and is visibly uncomfortable interacting with her for a good majority of their initial conversation. When his mother goes on about some of the dragons there that were injured by the vikings--specifically Toothless' injury--notice how Hiccup feels the need to pad the story of Toothless' missing wing by jokingly calling attention to his own amputation, as if he believes that his mother may not accept him if she knew he hurt a dragon. Her actions--or lack there of--do not seem to make her one hundred percent endearing to Hiccup, and Valka does seem to realize that there is some faulty reasoning behind her willingness to stay away from her family. When Stiock and Gobber walk in, they don't get to hear her story, and Stiock is clearly mesmerized by the discovery of his wife being alive, but had their reunion not lasted only a couple of hours it's possible that Valka's leaving her family would have been discussed with the possible [[WhatTheHellHero calling out of Valka's decision to permanently remove herself from Berk]] [[CassandraTruth all because she has discovered that dragons are actually capable of coexisting peacefully with humans.]]

to:

* All this being said, it does seem that Hiccup wasn't taking to her story right away and is visibly uncomfortable interacting with her for a good majority of their initial conversation. When his mother goes on about some of the dragons there that were injured by the vikings--specifically Toothless' injury--notice how Hiccup feels the need to pad the story of Toothless' missing wing by jokingly calling attention to his own amputation, as if he believes that his mother may not accept him if she knew he hurt a dragon. Her actions--or lack there of--do not seem to make her one hundred percent endearing to Hiccup, and Valka does seem to realize that there is some faulty reasoning behind her willingness to stay away from her family. When Stiock Stoick and Gobber walk in, they don't get to hear her story, and Stiock Stoick is clearly mesmerized by the discovery of his wife being alive, but had their reunion not lasted only a couple of hours it's possible that Valka's leaving her family would have been discussed with the possible [[WhatTheHellHero calling out of Valka's decision to permanently remove herself from Berk]] [[CassandraTruth all because she has discovered that dragons are actually capable of coexisting peacefully with humans.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicking Not So Different as it is now a disambig.


** [[HornyVikings Why does nearly everyone forget that actual Vikings were like Drago? Real Vikings were power-hungry, cruel bastards.]] I praise HTTYD 2 for actually having a character like that. And Drago also serves as a reminder that had it not been for Hiccup, [[NotSoDifferent Berk could have possibly gone down that route]]. Honestly, the lack of [[HornyVikings crazy, immoral traits in the Viking characters]] irks me, because the [[Literature/HowtoTrainYourDragon Books]] handled those kinds of stuff better than HTTYD 1 did. The first movie just flicked away all those immoral traits of actual, historical Vikings. The second movie had those traits in the form of Drago and reminded us that Hiccup is the reason why Berk is so peaceful, just like the books. So yeah, Drago is like an actual viking, so I wouldn't call him a flat character. This is one of the reasons why [[EvenBetterSequel I view HTTYD 2 as the better film]].

to:

** [[HornyVikings Why does nearly everyone forget that actual Vikings were like Drago? Real Vikings were power-hungry, cruel bastards.]] I praise HTTYD 2 for actually having a character like that. And Drago also serves as a reminder that had it not been for Hiccup, [[NotSoDifferent Berk could have possibly gone down that route]].route. Honestly, the lack of [[HornyVikings crazy, immoral traits in the Viking characters]] irks me, because the [[Literature/HowtoTrainYourDragon Books]] handled those kinds of stuff better than HTTYD 1 did. The first movie just flicked away all those immoral traits of actual, historical Vikings. The second movie had those traits in the form of Drago and reminded us that Hiccup is the reason why Berk is so peaceful, just like the books. So yeah, Drago is like an actual viking, so I wouldn't call him a flat character. This is one of the reasons why [[EvenBetterSequel I view HTTYD 2 as the better film]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


I'd also like to point out she reminds me of another [[Disney/{{Frozen}} misfit of a young woman who ran away from home to find a place "where I can be who I am without hurting anybody"]], except no one followed her to drag her back and tell her she was wrong...

to:

I'd also like to point out she reminds me of another [[Disney/{{Frozen}} [[WesternAnimation/Frozen2013 misfit of a young woman who ran away from home to find a place "where I can be who I am without hurting anybody"]], except no one followed her to drag her back and tell her she was wrong...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wolves can't mind control other wolves, and that's not how wolf pack dynamics work anyway.


*** The Red Death and Bewildebeasts use a different form of mind control. The Red Death is basically a queen bee who enthralls other dragons to act as her drones(as pointed out by Astrid) while Bewildebeasts actively dominate and control the minds of their subordinates, much like an Alpha of a pack of wolves.

to:

*** The Red Death and Bewildebeasts use a different form of mind control. The Red Death is basically a queen bee who enthralls other dragons to act as her drones(as pointed out by Astrid) while Bewildebeasts actively dominate and control the minds of their subordinates, much like an Alpha of a pack of wolves. subordinates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''WARNING: Administrivia/SpoilersOff applies to this page. Proceed at your own risk.'''
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Watch the "For the dancing and the dreaming" segment, when she's not wearing her [[HiddenBuxom bulky dragon-armour]]. Her breasts are roughly the size of Stoick's brainpan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Made from her breastplate" doesn't mean they kept it the exact same size and dimensions, and that wouldn't make sense anyway because, you know, heads and boobs are different shapes. Stoick probably had it made when Hiccup was still small and he was hoping that he'd grow up to be enormous like the other vikings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Seconded. Listening to the way Hiccup says the line "There are ''other'' dragon riders?!" still makes sense if he's thinking, ''There are other dragon riders still around? Didn't we get rid of those guys a year ago?'' Plus, this other dragon rider is apparently ''fighting'' dragon trappers -- up to that point, any non-Berk dragon riders were bad guys harming dragons, not good guys protecting them from bad guys like the ones Hiccup and Astrid are meeting at that moment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Another one: Valka, being dragon-obsessed, spent some time tracking down information about Night Furies from books, documents, or other human experts that wasn't in any of the bestiaries or dragonfighter training-manuals available on Berk. We don't know how she spent all those years away from Berk, or if she and Cloudjumper necessarily went straight back to the White Alpha's nest after he found her; they might've wandered for years until her new dragon friend decided she was worthy of joining the Bewilderbeast's hidden haven.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That other young woman didn't leave ''her own baby'' or a loving husband behind.

to:

** That other young woman didn't leave ''her own baby'' or a loving husband behind. Nor did she allow the one family member whom she ''did'' abandon to believe she'd just seen Elsa carried off by a bloodthirsty monster that would devour her alive, and spend two decades grieving for and striving to avenge her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That other young woman didn't leave ''her own baby'' or a loving husband behind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe Stoic just wasn't being specific, and the breastplate Hiccup's helmet came from was one Valka inherited from ''her'' mother, whom it fitted much better. No law says a Viking can't have heirloom armor and her own as well.

Added: 329

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None








** Or it could be that Cloudjumper was never a part of the Red Death's nest in the first place. He wasn't raiding berk but just scouting for food and resources for the bewilderbeast like a worker ant. Most likely he just happened to be there where a dragon raid is happening and that's where he met valka and took her.

to:

** Or it could be that Cloudjumper was never a part of the Red Death's nest in the first place. He wasn't raiding berk Berk but just scouting for food and resources for the bewilderbeast like a worker ant. Most likely he just happened to be there where a dragon raid is happening and that's where he met valka Valka and took her.


Added DiffLines:

** It may be that the conflict with Viggo and other Dragon Hunters will end with the complete destruction of the current Dragon Hunters, with Hiccup's surprise thus being based more on the idea that dragon trappers still exist after what the Riders did to the pre-existing operation rather than that the profession exists itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** We also have to keep in mind that she left when Hiccup was too young to have really started growing into himself; she was probably afraid that she'd come back to find that her son had grown into a carbon copy of his father, a determined anti-dragon Viking and a fierce warrior who could have maybe torn a dragon's head off as a child (remember the reference to Stoick having killed a dragon as a baby according to local legend in the first film), and found it easier to stay away rather than face that fear of her husband AND her son being so vehemently opposed to everything she'd come to believe.

Top