Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / HardcoreHenry

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler:So why didn't Henry take Colonel Jimmy with him in one van and Jimmy used his Nerd clone to drive his body to safety, then assume direct control of Colonel once both were safe and sound? There was no reason for all four of them to take the same van and stay together when splitting up would actually be the safest thing to do for Jimmy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I have problems making sense of Jimmy's remote controlled clones. I mean, why would they have different personalities, even different speaking accents? They even seem a bit dismissive of the main Jimmy (calling him "the cripple"), which is odd considering they are supposed to be mere empty vesselss.

to:

* I have problems making sense of Jimmy's remote controlled clones. I mean, why would they have different personalities, even different speaking accents? They even seem a bit dismissive of the main Jimmy (calling him "the cripple"), which is odd considering they are supposed to be mere empty vesselss.vesselss.
** There's a couple of ways to look at it; Jimmy uses his clones to experience things that he otherwise can't because of his physical condition, so he plays different characters the same way you'd have one voice actor playing different roles in a video game. The other possibility is that each clone has its own brain, so each one has individual, unique experiences and memories, with the original being sort of a hub for all the others that contains all the actual information from all of them, but doesn't have the experiences. For instance, if Punk Jimmy hits a mosh pit, Original Jimmy is aware that it is happening, but being paralyzed, he doesn't have the muscle memory or the ability to feel the excitement or pain of moshing, so when he later switches to Hippie Jimmy, Hippie Jimmy knows Punk Jimmy hit the mosh pit, but because Original Jimmy can't transmit the feelings associated with it, Hippie Jimmy doesn't have the experience of hitting the mosh pit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Remember that the movie was inspired by FPS games, many of which give final bosses unexplained powers to make them boss material. This was a homage to that concept. The reason why he didn't get more down to earth powers like Henry is because that would make the point of Henry being a SuperPrototype completely pointless; if he's stronger than Henry, then Henry's creation would be pointless since Akan could do what Henry could but better. If he's weaker than Henry, then he has the danger of being killed by a soldier who is essentially a superior version of Akan. Either possibility would need to have extra time to explain to keep immersion, so that's probably went with a "completely different, unexplained power" route instead; it keeps the focus on Henry as Akan's powers are not related to Henry and thus aren't important to explain.

to:

** Remember that the movie was inspired by FPS games, many of which give final bosses unexplained powers to make them boss material. This was a homage to that concept. The reason why he didn't get more down to earth powers like Henry is because that would make the point of Henry being a SuperPrototype completely pointless; if he's stronger than Henry, then Henry's creation would be pointless since Akan could do what Henry could but better. If he's weaker than Henry, then he has the danger of being killed by a soldier who is essentially a superior version of Akan. Either possibility would need to have extra time to explain to keep immersion, so that's probably went with a "completely different, unexplained power" route instead; it keeps the focus on Henry as Akan's powers are not related to Henry and thus aren't important to explain.explain.
* I have problems making sense of Jimmy's remote controlled clones. I mean, why would they have different personalities, even different speaking accents? They even seem a bit dismissive of the main Jimmy (calling him "the cripple"), which is odd considering they are supposed to be mere empty vesselss.

Added: 436

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jimmy can only control one clone at a time anyway. In his wheelchair, he serves as a "transport vehicle" for either Plain!Jimmy or Colonel!Jimmy's body, depending on who's active at any given moment. If he stays in the van, he can only send both clones to back up Henry by constantly flipping between the two, leaving one of them immobile and very vulnerable. Plus, crippled or not, he probably wants to be in the front row when Akan goes down.

to:

** Jimmy [[spoiler:Jimmy can only control one clone at a time anyway. In his wheelchair, he serves as a "transport vehicle" for either Plain!Jimmy or Colonel!Jimmy's body, depending on who's active at any given moment. If he stays in the van, he can only send both clones to back up Henry by constantly flipping between the two, leaving one of them immobile and very vulnerable. Plus, crippled or not, he probably wants to be in the front row when Akan goes down.]]
** [[spoiler:More importantly Akan is still watching, if they just ditch Jimmy's crippled body somewhere there is a very real chance that Akan will watch the feed from Henry's eyes and have Jimmy killed as soon as they leave him unattended. And they can't just blindfold Henry because they need his combat skills to keep the mooks of him or drive the van, someone has to be doing both tasks or the mooks kill them both then and there.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why does Akan have telekinetic powers? This doesn't seem to be explained at any point in the movie. Given that he seems to be involved with several projects to create superhumans, it may be inferred that his powers are the result of one of them, but they are so unlike anything else seen in the movie, and absolutely no explanation is given as to how they work.

to:

* Why does Akan have telekinetic powers? This doesn't seem to be explained at any point in the movie. Given that he seems to be involved with several projects to create superhumans, it may be inferred that his powers are the result of one of them, but they are so unlike anything else seen in the movie, and absolutely no explanation is given as to how they work.work.
** Remember that the movie was inspired by FPS games, many of which give final bosses unexplained powers to make them boss material. This was a homage to that concept. The reason why he didn't get more down to earth powers like Henry is because that would make the point of Henry being a SuperPrototype completely pointless; if he's stronger than Henry, then Henry's creation would be pointless since Akan could do what Henry could but better. If he's weaker than Henry, then he has the danger of being killed by a soldier who is essentially a superior version of Akan. Either possibility would need to have extra time to explain to keep immersion, so that's probably went with a "completely different, unexplained power" route instead; it keeps the focus on Henry as Akan's powers are not related to Henry and thus aren't important to explain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** No. [[spoiler: Henry is the SuperPrototype, but he's ''not'' the first, he's only the first ''success''. Estelle said as much, and the footage of the different names from tests ''before'' Henry, because there wouldn't be any point (or possibility) in making new footage tailored to other cyborgs while the useable memories from Henry are still in progress. And your logic is messed up anyway, because those memories are coming ''from Henry'', the one thing those memories couldn't possibly contain is a third-person view of Henry kidnapping Estelle. If it were possible for Akan to just fabricate memories from scratch, none of the movie would be necessary.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What was up with Slick Dmitry when Henry finds him? Why was he all ragdoll-like?

to:

* What was up with Slick Dmitry when Henry finds him? Why was he all ragdoll-like?ragdoll-like?
** Maybe he was in the process of recharging his battery?
* Why does Akan have telekinetic powers? This doesn't seem to be explained at any point in the movie. Given that he seems to be involved with several projects to create superhumans, it may be inferred that his powers are the result of one of them, but they are so unlike anything else seen in the movie, and absolutely no explanation is given as to how they work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jimmy can only control one clone at a time anyway. In his wheelchair, he serves as a "transport vehicle" for either Plain!Jimmy or Colonel!Jimmy's body, depending on who's active at any given moment. If he stays in the van, he can only send both clones to back up Henry by constantly flipping between the two, leaving one of them immobile and very vulnerable. Plus, crippled or not, he probably wants to be in the front row when Akan goes down.

to:

** Jimmy can only control one clone at a time anyway. In his wheelchair, he serves as a "transport vehicle" for either Plain!Jimmy or Colonel!Jimmy's body, depending on who's active at any given moment. If he stays in the van, he can only send both clones to back up Henry by constantly flipping between the two, leaving one of them immobile and very vulnerable. Plus, crippled or not, he probably wants to be in the front row when Akan goes down.down.
* What was up with Slick Dmitry when Henry finds him? Why was he all ragdoll-like?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** You are mistaken, my friend. First, Henry is the SuperPrototype, he is the first of his kind, it is explicitely stated in the movie. Those memories of Estelle activating the cyborgs are custom made to each, because 1) Estelle couldn't have been there to the waking up of the army as she was playing victim for a good chunk of plot and 2) They were all made after Henry experienced hia waking. The purpose of the whole act is not just to stage the kidnapping and motivate the cyborgs, they are recording Henry's fighting experience to make the army more effective killers. So yes, Akan can implant whatever he wants on the Cyborgs once he blocks his real memories. Those Cyborgs probably saw Henry himself kidnapping Estelle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's the same actress, so it's presumably the same character. We don't have any indication of how much time passed between Henry getting knocked out and him getting rescued, so it isn't too much of a stretch to say she had time to change clothes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** She ''does'' kill the last merc trying to bury Henry, much to Hippie!Jimmy's dismay, which would be in character for the dominatrix, if it's her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:Leaving his real body unguarded in a van in a situation where Akan ''knew'' they were coming is just plain dumb. Better to keep it near people who could actually protect it.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Leaving his real body unguarded in a van in a situation where Akan ''knew'' they were coming is just plain dumb. Better to keep it near people who could actually protect it.]]]]
** Jimmy can only control one clone at a time anyway. In his wheelchair, he serves as a "transport vehicle" for either Plain!Jimmy or Colonel!Jimmy's body, depending on who's active at any given moment. If he stays in the van, he can only send both clones to back up Henry by constantly flipping between the two, leaving one of them immobile and very vulnerable. Plus, crippled or not, he probably wants to be in the front row when Akan goes down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** He can't, though. [[spoiler: He has to install a memory blocker into Henry, but a) it doesn't work completely, since Henry gets flashbacks of his own real life and it's only meant to block those, and b) that's what I mean by ''inextricably''. If Akan were capable of truly creating or editing memory on that level, he wouldn't need the stage show to begin with. He needs real, genuine memories and for someone to buy into the lie, that's the point. Every scene that involves Estelle being abducted or captured or abused has Akan in it, doing the kidnapping, giving him the sadistic choices, making himself the focus of the motivational drama (which is also why, despite having different names, they all still have the same wife). The footage with the individual names isn't made from Henry's memories, it's from all the failed attempts before him.]]

to:

*** He can't, though. [[spoiler: He has to install a memory blocker into Henry, but a) it doesn't work completely, since Henry gets flashbacks of his own real life and it's only meant to block those, and b) that's what I mean by ''inextricably''. If Akan were capable of truly creating or editing memory on that level, he wouldn't need the stage show to begin with. He needs real, genuine memories and for someone to buy into the lie, that's the point. Every scene that involves Estelle being abducted or captured or abused has Akan in it, doing the kidnapping, giving him the sadistic choices, making himself the focus of the motivational drama (which is also why, despite having different names, they all still have the same wife). The footage with the individual names isn't made from Henry's memories, it's from all the failed attempts before him. At best, it only means that the cyborgs' motivation will be "find the mystery man who has my wife", and that's still Akan at the end of the day.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** He can't, though. [[spoiler: He has to install a memory blocker into Henry, but a) it doesn't work completely, since Henry gets flashbacks of his own real life and it's only meant to block those, and b) that's what I mean by ''inextricably''. If Akan were capable of truly creating or editing memory on that level, he wouldn't need the stage show to begin with. He needs real, genuine memories and for someone to buy into the lie, that's the point. Every scene that involves Estelle being abducted or captured or abused has Akan in it, doing the kidnapping, giving him the sadistic choices, making himself the focus of the motivational drama (which is also why, despite having different names, they all still have the same wife). The footage with the individual names isn't made from Henry's memories, it's from all the failed attempts before him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Except he's shown that [[spoiler:he can modify the soldiers' memories, such as how when Estelle "wakes" them up, she always uses their own personal names substituted in for Henry's. With the power to control what memories the cyborgs retain, Akan can effectively manipulate them in to believing ''anybody'' kidnapped Estelle.]]



** [[spoiler:He might have been afraid of leaving his real self in plain sight, where anyone could have gotten to him. Better safe than sorry.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:He might have been afraid of leaving his real self in plain sight, where anyone could have gotten to him. Better safe than sorry.]]
** [[spoiler:Leaving his real body unguarded in a van in a situation where Akan ''knew'' they were coming is just plain dumb. Better to keep it near people who could actually protect it.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I took it to mean that they're associates of Jimmy's, but that they're not really connected to him beyond that. They pretty clearly have their own gig going.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Then Akan's an idiot to begin with. [[spoiler: The memories of Estelle's kidnapping are inextricably linked to Akan ''being the kidnapper''. He's building an army of super cyborgs who are emotionally motivated to seek out and destroy him. ''Specifically'' him. The whole point of making the super prototype is to stage events to create memories because their technology can only block pre-existing memories, they can't fabricate new ones.]]


Added DiffLines:

** It's implied that he's not. Fridge Brilliance, this.[[spoiler: He's just the only one who actually got anywhere with it. Estelle says she knew for sure that it worked because Henry brought her with him in the escape pod built for one; that scene is actually a SecretTestOfCharacter designed to confirm that the subject completely bought into the lie and was emotionally invested in his "wife". The ones that don't pass the test? ''They got into the escape pod alone and didn't know how to open the parachute''. The reason Henry is the only one to rebel is that he's the only one that didn't impact a parking lot at terminal velocity and scatter himself like a toaster full of meat.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Maybe she got really high with Hippie!Jimmy and as a result she was really mellow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:Why did Jimmy bring his body into the Akan Corp. building? He already had British Soldier!Jimmy and Avatar!Jimmy accompanying Henry into the building, and probably knew he would be putting himself at great risk by bringing his own body into a building full of armed soldiers. Why didn't he just leave himself in the van outside and let those two bodies go with Henry?]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Why did Jimmy bring his body into the Akan Corp. building? He already had British Soldier!Jimmy and Avatar!Jimmy accompanying Henry into the building, and probably knew he would be putting himself at great risk by bringing his own body into a building full of armed soldiers. Why didn't he just leave himself in the van outside and let those two bodies go with Henry?]]Henry?]]
** [[spoiler:He might have been afraid of leaving his real self in plain sight, where anyone could have gotten to him. Better safe than sorry.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Since Henry is apparently [[spoiler:the first successful cyborg, he's most likely a SuperPrototype. There is also the point where he takes down a great deal of the enemy cyborgs with stolen guns and explosives, and then dopes himself with adrenaline in the second half of the fight. Plus, it could be argued that since Henry himself actually experienced the memories rather than have them downloaded directly into his mind, he had much more HeroicResolve and emotional motivation than they did. ]]

to:

** Since Henry is apparently [[spoiler:the first successful cyborg, he's most likely a SuperPrototype. There is also the point where he takes down a great deal of the enemy cyborgs with stolen guns and explosives, and then dopes himself with adrenaline in the second half of the fight. Plus, it could be argued that since Henry himself actually experienced the memories rather than have them downloaded directly into his mind, he had much more HeroicResolve and emotional motivation than they did. ]]]]
* [[spoiler:Why did Jimmy bring his body into the Akan Corp. building? He already had British Soldier!Jimmy and Avatar!Jimmy accompanying Henry into the building, and probably knew he would be putting himself at great risk by bringing his own body into a building full of armed soldiers. Why didn't he just leave himself in the van outside and let those two bodies go with Henry?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Akan specifically spells out that [[spoiler:the kidnapping was to act as motivation for Henry and by proxy, the rest of the cyborg super soldiers to fight. Killing the other scientists was to act as further the act that he was the main villain.]]

to:

** Akan specifically spells out that [[spoiler:the kidnapping was to act as motivation for Henry and by proxy, the rest of the cyborg super soldiers to fight. Killing the other scientists was to act as further the act that he was the main villain.]]villain. Plus the scientists he killed were only ones that specialized in making voices. Why would Akan care about giving his expendable soldiers voices?]]

Added: 614

Changed: 235

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:How come Henry became the (as far as we know) only one of Akan's cyber-soldiers to turn against him?]]

to:

** Akan specifically spells out that [[spoiler:the kidnapping was to act as motivation for Henry and by proxy, the rest of the cyborg super soldiers to fight. Killing the other scientists was to act as further the act that he was the main villain.]]
* [[spoiler:How come Henry became the (as far as we know) only one of Akan's cyber-soldiers to turn against him?]]him?]]
** Since Henry is apparently [[spoiler:the first successful cyborg, he's most likely a SuperPrototype. There is also the point where he takes down a great deal of the enemy cyborgs with stolen guns and explosives, and then dopes himself with adrenaline in the second half of the fight. Plus, it could be argued that since Henry himself actually experienced the memories rather than have them downloaded directly into his mind, he had much more HeroicResolve and emotional motivation than they did. ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Akan is bleeding from the mouth a bit before Henry even gets his hands on the jerk, possibly indicating a limit to or cost of his powers.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Akan is bleeding from the mouth a bit before Henry even gets his hands on the jerk, possibly indicating a limit to or cost of his powers.]]]]
*[[spoiler:What's the purpose of "kidnapping" Estelle? To test Henry's loyalty? And why Akan kill that scientist then?]]
*[[spoiler:How come Henry became the (as far as we know) only one of Akan's cyber-soldiers to turn against him?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Akan through the entire movie is depicted as always being one step ahead of Henry- [[spoiler: seeing as everything had been setup and he always has had a personal live feed of Henry's vision. He can always predict Henry's actions and time his mentally draining psychic powers accordingly, but is in trouble if he can't see danger coming in time to react, as while he is Psychic, he's not a bullet-time Cyborg like Henry. He thought Henry was dead or completely destroyed, and due to letting Henry kill everyone who wasn't Estelle or his helicopter pilot, there was no one to tell him otherwise, so Henry getting back up in a rage with a new unexpected attack caught him off guard and he couldn't react in time. And once hurt, he couldn't focus past the incredible pain, allowing Henry to kill him. In some ways, it's riff on Plot Armor combined with a bit of Reality Ensues, once the "scripted" battles were over, he was just as vulnerable as everybody else.]]

to:

** Akan through the entire movie is depicted as always being one step ahead of Henry- [[spoiler: seeing as everything had been setup and he always has had a personal live feed of Henry's vision. He can always predict Henry's actions and time his mentally draining psychic powers accordingly, but is in trouble if he can't see danger coming in time to react, as while he is Psychic, he's not a bullet-time Cyborg like Henry. He thought Henry was dead or completely destroyed, and due to letting Henry kill everyone who wasn't Estelle or his helicopter pilot, there was no one to tell him otherwise, so Henry getting back up in a rage with a new unexpected attack caught him off guard and he couldn't react in time. And once hurt, he couldn't focus past the incredible pain, allowing Henry to kill him. In some ways, it's riff on Plot Armor combined with a bit of Reality Ensues, once the "scripted" battles were over, he was just as vulnerable as everybody else.]]
** [[spoiler: Akan is bleeding from the mouth a bit before Henry even gets his hands on the jerk, possibly indicating a limit to or cost of his powers.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: pretty sure that wasn't the same girl with Hippie!Jimmy. Her clothing and attitude were completely different from only minutes before. The only hint that it might be her is the katana Henry ends up with.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:I don't know how/if it helped him get close, but it did help by breaking Akan's focus when Henry got his hands on him - The pain of the barbed wire digging into him gave Henry a bigger window in which to act.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:I don't know how/if it helped him get close, but it did help by breaking Akan's focus when Henry got his hands on him - The pain of the barbed wire digging into him gave Henry a bigger window in which to act.]]
** Akan through the entire movie is depicted as always being one step ahead of Henry- [[spoiler: seeing as everything had been setup and he always has had a personal live feed of Henry's vision. He can always predict Henry's actions and time his mentally draining psychic powers accordingly, but is in trouble if he can't see danger coming in time to react, as while he is Psychic, he's not a bullet-time Cyborg like Henry. He thought Henry was dead or completely destroyed, and due to letting Henry kill everyone who wasn't Estelle or his helicopter pilot, there was no one to tell him otherwise, so Henry getting back up in a rage with a new unexpected attack caught him off guard and he couldn't react in time. And once hurt, he couldn't focus past the incredible pain, allowing Henry to kill him. In some ways, it's riff on Plot Armor combined with a bit of Reality Ensues, once the "scripted" battles were over, he was just as vulnerable as everybody else.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:I don't know how/if it helped him get close, but it did help by breaking Akan's focus when Jimmy got his hands on him - The pain of the barbed wire digging into him gave Henry a bigger window in which to act.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:I don't know how/if it helped him get close, but it did help by breaking Akan's focus when Jimmy Henry got his hands on him - The pain of the barbed wire digging into him gave Henry a bigger window in which to act.]]

Added: 421

Changed: 518

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Also, how does Henry [[spoiler:wrapping barbed wire around his hand suddenly get him close enough to attack Akan when every other time, Akan is able to push him away with his telekinetic powers?]]

to:

** I'm pretty sure they both had their fates shown on screen. [[spoiler:They are with Henry and Jimmy when they catch up with Akan on the highway. Henry catches a ride on the back of one of their motorcycles, but she goes down (explodes, maybe? It helps Henry jump) right as they get to Akan's lab vehicle. I thought that the other one was the girl with Henry and Jimmy out in the woods, who gets killed by shrapnel when Hippy!Jimmy gets hit with the tank shell, but I *might* be wrong on that one.]]
* Also, how does Henry [[spoiler:wrapping barbed wire around his hand suddenly get him close enough to attack Akan when every other time, Akan is able to push him away with his telekinetic powers?]]powers?]]
** [[spoiler:I don't know how/if it helped him get close, but it did help by breaking Akan's focus when Jimmy got his hands on him - The pain of the barbed wire digging into him gave Henry a bigger window in which to act.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What was the point of the two dominatrix assassins? I understand they also had a bone to pick with Akan, but after the brothel scene, they just disappear and are never mentioned again.

to:

* What was the point of the two dominatrix assassins? I understand they also had a bone to pick with Akan, but after the brothel scene, they just disappear and are never mentioned again.again.
* Also, how does Henry [[spoiler:wrapping barbed wire around his hand suddenly get him close enough to attack Akan when every other time, Akan is able to push him away with his telekinetic powers?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* What was the point of the two dominatrix assassins? I understand they also had a bone to pick with Akan, but after the brothel scene, they just disappear and are never mentioned again.

Top